Richard Dawkins interviews Saudi Arabian atheist author Rana Ahmad
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- Richard Dawkins speaks with young Saudi Arabian atheist Rana Ahmad, author of the new book Frauen dürfen hier nicht träumen (Women Aren’t Allowed to Dream Here).
They discuss the plight of atheists in Saudi Arabia and how she and her fellow freethinkers found new hope and new ideas from an unofficial translation of The God Delusion in Arabic.
In coordination with the Center for Inquiry, the Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason & Science has launched the Translations Project, giving folks like Rana free access to the books of Richard Dawkins professionally translated into languages such as Arabic, Urdu, Indonesian, and Farsi. Visit to learn more - translations.r...
We also have our Secular Rescue program which provides emergency assistance to atheist writers, bloggers, publishers, and activists who face threats due to their beliefs or expressions regarding religion - secular-rescue...
Special thanks to Atheist Refugee Relief (ARR), which assists atheists in Germany, such as Rana, who have escaped persecution in Islamic countries. Learn more at atheist-refuge....
Arab atheists are the bravest people you can find in the Middle East
'Ex-muslim atheists' to be precise
No doubt
I'm so proud of them, but they need a lot of help. Cuz they are losing everything, so difficult. Are there organizations to help people that are leaving those coercive religions?
false, they are cowards this braveness is only behind the screens, but in a real debate? It will become clear to you how stupid and misguided they are
She is not arab Arabs are people of Arabian peninsula with j1 dna speaking Arabic don’t make you arab
This is why atheist activism is needed. Thank you for inspiring multiple generations to speak out against religious tyranny, Richard, Rana, and RDF.
Seconds that.
Genetically Modified Skeptic must be tough being outperformed by your religious counterparts for centuries.
Wassup keep making the videos
People have the right to be atheists or Christian and all women should have the same freedom as a man in all countries. I have Christian friends and atheist friends they would all agree what happened to this woman was wrong and needs to stop.
I love you channel!
Given she isn't from an English speaking country and she moved to another country where English isn't their first language; she speaks English very well. She is evidently a very smart person.
@Mohamed Mo
TO ALL MUSLIMS: These are questions to you from the non-islamic world.
======================
EXPLAIN: ((Islamist test))
1) Freedom of speech is punishable by death.. literally.. (Charlie Hebdo)
2) Islam claims governance in its core, no matter how inadequate it is.. There is no such thing in Islamic culture nor texts as "Give back to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God what is God's." (Hence, Sharia Law)
======================
ANSWER:
((moderate muslim apologist test))
What's the punishment of (in Quran and Hadith):
- Apostasy / Infidels
- Adultery
- Sex before marriage
- Thievery
- Homosexuality
- Inheritance and Testimony of a woman = half of a man
- Wife inobedience (beating)
======================
How about you describe how you feel, and your family about those "sins"?! and their punishments?!
How about you describe your country laws against them?!
How about you describe your sharia laws against them?!
How about you describe what will happen if someone confessed in public to these sins?!
STOP sugarcoating and misleading others....
th-cam.com/video/LV7eVvph69Y/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/LVR_WxWWLek/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/2BrueU4xd2w/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/hI0UvILD59U/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/MlAw7qYLk5w/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/B-vvoRwJSPc/w-d-xo.html
@Mohamed Mo You are either lying or wrong. Ayaan did not flee the Netherlands, nor did she lose her Dutch nationality. So filled in the wrong day of birth and her grandfathers name on her assylum request. The Netherlands did not really care about the day of birth, but at first did not accept the wrong name. But since it is legal in Somalia to use our grandfathers name instead of your, it was ultimately decided that here assylum request was legal.
She did not flee from the Netherlands! At least, not from the state, as you are trying to suggest. The Dutch Government continued to protect her while she was in the US. Protect her from muslims by the way.
@Mohamed Mo I don't know anything about what she did after she left the Netherlands, but ultimately it was decided that she did not do anything unforgivably wrong.
The Dutch minister was a friend of hers. She nevertheless tried to revoke her nationality because she wanted a reputation as 'tough' politician as she was in a race to take her party leadership. It ultimately backfired on her, on costed her her political career.
You make it look like the Dutch strongly dislike her or something, but that is just not the case.
@John Myers what you say, death for apostasy
its not just radical Muslims that believe in this, even moderate Muslims believe in this
you could find a Muslim that drink alcohol, have sex, go to clubs, wear western clothes and so on
but he believes in apostasy law
@ms wpwm everyone in Europe knows that ayaan hirsi is a fraud, but apparently the news hasn't reached America yet.
She's making money out of it as is the so called the first lady of Isis is doing also.
You Americans can be very gullible sometimes.
Hirsi was exposed and her party expelled her for lying in so many occasions.
Why would she move to America then?
Well I cried.. what a brave and intelligent woman
Why did you cry?
@@incumbentvinyl9291 because of her brightness and bravery, I cried because of happiness , for her and for humanity
@@maximilyen
I also cried 😭 and you know what. I am a Muslim. I don't support this brutality. Freedom of thought and belief is fundamental right of everyone.
@ 4 Feb 2024
Very proud of her she sacrificed a lot for her freedom. Our community as arab atheists is rapidly growing. for female atheists it takes a considerable amount of courage to come out.
It’s such an honor to meet you Dr. Richard Dawkins. I hope one day I could meet you.
She was seeking freedom, I guess.
Agnaye Ochani thank you! I was the first to leave Islam from my friends. With time more of them started leaving islam as well for different reasons. Now almost half of my friends are irreligious and most of my muslim friends are very tolerant and accepting. Of course they don’t represent the whole society maybe I tend to befriend more open minded and liberal people.
GOD BLESS YOU OOPS SORRY
Iranian Atheist here! I've so much respect for you guys.
S Al Ameri. I respect your courage and wish you well in your life in reality 😊
I got emotional when she said that one of her Dreams was to meet him.. So glad she did it!
I will always be sorry that I never got to meet Christopher Hitchens, but I hope to meet Dr. Dawkins one day. And I hope my son is with me!
Sean Jones me too people like Richard Dawkins And Christopher Hitchins (RIP Hitch) inspire me and my son too
@@seanjones2456 I send my son links to many of Richard's interviews. It's my way of trying to be a good dad.
I don't have a son but if i had one i'd like him to be like mr Hitchens and mr Dawkins.
Neither do i have a daughter but if i had one i'd still would like her to be as them!
That's one of my dreams too. I hope he came to US soon.
Atheist from Pakistan, started believing in atheism when I was 15 still surprised how many people are brainwashed by Islam in my country.
EDIT: started being an atheist.
Atheism is growing in the Islamic world thanks to the Internet. It is shocking that for thousands of years most Muslims could not even understand the Quran, Just recite it like parrots.
alex ojideagu yeah most of them still do owing to the fact that they do not know Arabic
Yes. The same when Christianity was only preached Latin, Greek Hebrew to keep people ignorant, before it was converted. That is when Christians started questioning it. Islam is going though that NOW slowly.
@@noneimportant5951 Atheist from Pakistan too 🇵🇰
bravo
I.m from India Kerala
My faith lost. 10 year ago
And this talking deep touching my Heart
Atheist from Tamil Nadu, India
Same too here…
OCI Mallu here. I hope he will also translate his books in Hindi and also other Indian languages since I believe it is, especially lately, also needed in India.
Atheist from Odisha, India❤️
I am an ex muslim from Indonesia, I used to hate Richard Dawkins and I saw him as an evil person, but now I am an atheist and I am in the process of getting rid of the holier-than-thou attitude and now I know that Prof. Dawkins is just trying to help us free ourselves from man-made religions and the delusion of "God", which is only a human concept
"Allah has set a seal upon their hearts and upon their hearing, and over their vision is a veil. And for them is a great punishment"
I need help for escape in county respect me become agnostic ,im from Algeria and my age is 32 plz and my life in danger , someone help me to escape to my freedom.plzzz...
Hhhh you guys are smart and unique. You guys are funny. I wonder do atheists have brain ot something else rather than brain. And that's it, you said just to be free and to worship your desires. Ignorants people.
@@zaynabazam4948 may Allah bless you and protect you from all that which is bad and evil in this world
@@REDLINE94306 rana kifkif dans la merde wila l9it kach idéé 3awena t3ich kreht reb hyati depression shithole islamic countries
It's really good to see Richard Dawkins good and healthy .
Long life to him
@@panuntukan I nearly run Richard over in Oxford once, he was on his bike.
He looks like he's in his mid 80's already. Yuck, i think he has aged bad.
@@xenomorphexidious9102 he is 77, so not far off
@@xenomorphexidious9102 77yrs
I am an Egyptian man at 55 who denounced religion 8 years ago.. I wish I had half her courage 😱
Anoymous Arab Agnostic at age of 55 you become a bit smarter.. otherwise you were a donkey,, that is what you are trying to tell us 😂
Whatever!
It must be hard to be an atheist in Egypt so fully understand the fear you feel. Best of luck to you
@@jimlewis4389 Egypt is 99.9999999% religious.
ياطعمية هاذي وافدة سوريا في السعودية راحت الى المانيا وتتكلم كانه سعودية هههههههه زي اصحابك مايفتخرون بجنسيتهم اكتب رانا احمد في اليوتيوب شوف المقابلة في العربي
ex-Hindu here, proud to be an atheist
Nothing to be proud of being atheist or a person from a certain religion
@@erenyaeger9407 For what purpose. Anywase, Athiesim isn't a religion either. get your facts straight
We consider atheist also a Hindu. We are okay with atheists in Hinduism. I'm an agnostic but I say I'm Hindu as an agnostic is allowed to ask questions and follow or not certain things in Hinduism. You can't be a ex- Hindu actually.
LOL. You bought the liberal propaganda!
@@erenyaeger9407 yes there is sometimes it can be really challenging or even life threatening to announce atheism.
I am an atheist from Kuwait 🇰🇼, it is very hard to express your opinions and ideas even a criticism of religion is prohibited.. i feel so alone yet am surrounded by a lot of people . My country provides the right to believe in what ever you want to believe, but the problem is with blinded stupid religious citizens that might kill me if tried to criticize their religion even peacefully. Sorry for my bad english just needed to express my feelings.
How many of your friends are Atheist too?
The important thing is that you know who you are. And you are not alone. There are millions out there just like yourself. Stay safe and happy. No one can take away your wisdom now. And never try to convince anyone else. 😃👍
Your English is excellent, I wouldn't be worried about that. I hope you have a few good friends with which you can safely share your thoughts and concerns. I also hope you can one day live without that fear, whether by Kuwait improving or by you moving to a safer country. Take care, many of us stand with you in solidarity.
You are not alone, man. Secularists around the world are with you and we will do wathever we can for the freedom of thought. Someday islam will become just like christianity in the West.
optimus Transformer only one 🙁
I’m an atheist from India. Congratulations for your courage. Keep your voice heard. Be safe. You have my best wishes.
@ابو ليث الخطيب watched and added a dislike.
Nah... You probably just drooling on her skirt...and hoping to get lucky some how. Your name suggest you don't only believe in God but many thousand's of gods.
Fellow atheist🤘
Still you are hindu
Me too! From the Northeast part of India, Mizoram.
Religion is indoctrination. This woman is wonderful and strong. Respect.
@@boxingexpert9065 Muhammad is a pedophile.
@@entoythedragon8463 *was ;) cuz y'know, he dead and there's no afterlife
"religion was created when the first conman met the first fool ' Mark twain ? not sure.
@@zerototalenergy150 Yep. Mark Twain ;-)
@@boxingexpert9065 Very eloquent. I see you are a true expert on the art of debate.
I’m ex Muslim I’m so happy in my live now thx 🙏🏻
Do you eat bacon?
Guess when I'm dead I'll be ex-alive lmao
@Davy Anthonissen because it's my choice peopel define themselves by what they are in the present not by what they were in the past lmao and btw I'm a Muslim
@Davy Anthonissen like for example if I break up from a relationship with my gf and someone asks if I'm single or taken am I ex-taken?🤣😂🤣
@Davy Anthonissen and better than being ex-smart like you applying you're logic that is 🤣🤣
Her brother wanted to kill her because she is not religious! That's very sad.
This is what religion does to a human being.
Not necessarily because she turned her back on religion. Rather because what she did to his cheap pride.
@@aupti Well because they stopped doing it, and buddhist are actually killing atheists as well :
www.abc.net.au/religion/buddhist-extremism-and-the-hypocrisy-of-religious-violence/10098240
As for jews, they killed in times before (antiquity) and early dark ages, but their religion was forced to evolve when propagating to the west.
Religion kills, not just islam even if they are indeed the most dangerous ideology right now.
Gross overgeneralization. Did religion do this to Martin Luther King or were his laudable beliefs and actions perhaps informed and enhanced by his religion?
Not religion .. people that dont follow religion
no, this is what islam does to a human being.
The refugees who threaten her should be thrown out of Germany, UK, France, Spain, everywhere in the West.
im moroccan and i have alot of things against islam but i cant tell anyone i once discussed it with my parents they threathened to kill in front of the neighboors to watch .like i would get killed if i come out as a freethinker to arabs the people here are fkn violent and ignorant thats why my only way is school im studying really hard to graduate and live in the west
Those violent people generally who force their religions on everyone else should be thrown out (muslim,christian,jewish...) if theyre so ungrateful and violent in it
@Feiner Fug since i was a kid the only thing i did was watching movies especially english i could even imitate an american british irish and australian accent i speak french too cus thats the sysytem in morocco but in my country people are more into french but to me i prefer english
They are not refugees. They are invaders.
To be honest I support trump because he was trying to clean up United States from random immigrants who come here just for money but they hate America and Americans people same in Europe they run to go this countries then they hate them in their hearts so stupid extremist people, get them out of here fuck mmmm
@@emerald_kiwi4046 hello my dude I am from morocco to, can we communicate ? I'd love to meet a freethinker just like I am, and I'd suppose u too would like that.
I will never, never take my freedom for granted after listening to this brave woman's experience.
@@badawe87 nope..
She is in Germany. Doing well. Studying physics.
Couldnt agree more.
@@badawe87 fake freedom? Whats fake freedom? She is not even in usa lol
@@badawe87 its not the same person you idiot! She is living in Germany not usa
Freedoms means to be Partly Naked.
Freedom means to take care of Responsibility of Humans.
Freedom for a Thief is to steel and bit to get caught. It is low for lower interligenct people.
Both these Athiests are STUPIDS in a Low level Freedom knowledge.
Ex-muslim here🧠🧠🧠 from India,KERALA.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I'm glad to come across an Indian atheist. Hope the light of rationality spreads across South Asia soon.
Pity on you. More people are realizing the truth (i.e. becoming Muslims) than leaving it. Pity you are of the ones God chose to leave astray.
@hashem elhwary Ex-muslims are just a bunch of people uneducated or misinformed about Islam.
@hashem elhwary What a load of rubbish, expected nevertheless. Cherry picking on a book of questionable origins that fails in the face of evidence provided by modern science. No place for such a medieval cult in this century.
@@anonymousperson1189 Islam and education are opposites of each other. It is meant for those who have failed to evolve beyond the belief in a desert cult fiction. Its followers time and again prove that they are devoid of any intellect.
Richard Dawkins, thank you so much for everything you've done for the atheist and scientific community
I'm Indonesian and I feel trapped living like a rat. This woman showed how bad a religion handle free-thinking.
Well, Islam. Try free thinking in North Korea. But no problem in most countries with deep christian roots.
@@markaurelius61 ...now.
@@markaurelius61 it used to be a problem in those countries too. It's just that many chiristians nowadays do not practice it Christianity in such a strict manner as Muslims. When they do, they end up doing shit too.
Some do. But in fact that extremists are often not the most devout, despite the public assumption. It is not a one-dimensional thing.
@@markaurelius61 it doesn't matter if they're the most devout or not, the fact is those people carry out those crimes when they see nothing but religion. I agree that RIGHT NOW Islam is, indeed, one of the most dangerous ideologies due to it being initially born from a conquerors era, and political issues of the preceding centuries. However, it does not mean that countries with christian roots have "no problem", just look at history, how much blood was shed to achieve this.
As an atheist Iranian woman im really touched and i wish freedom for all my sisters all around the world❤
I really feel bad for Iran , the real Airyans and their religion and way of life , all gone. Now they follow rules of desert people
@@mokujin29 Islam destroys everything it touches - this is why the free world should actively fight this pagan man-made cult and ban its spreading in the West.
@@mokujin29you're delusional
Does God exist?
th-cam.com/video/hQPuvIQlbxU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=mxAV92h-8kp2sO9e
I really feel bad for Iranians leaving the truth..
How can you deny your creation and call it just an accident??
DNA is information and information cannot come without intelligence and intelligence cannot come without consciousness and consciousness cannot come without a' BEING'..
Nobody is an atheist in a sinking ship..
As an Indian Muslim, we feel grateful and proud that we are muslims...
I'm also an Athiest from Saudi Arabia and She's absolutely right and on point about the reality of life for women in Saudi Arabia and of the cruel treatment of Apostates. She's very brave and I hope her book is published in English, I'd love to read her work.
Glad to know other atheist ex muslim..what is your age? are u married?
Where in Saudi are you from?
I congratulate you in leaving the religion of hate and religion of evil. However, when it comes to is there a God or not, it does not mean you left allah the moon god that you are an atheist. knowing the true God is a personal experience is not just an idea or you are born as a muslim or Jew that is not true. All children are born the same without religion as islam declare all are born muslims that is not true but I am sure all muslim children are taught from day one of their life that they are muslim. Being an atheist is faith as well. Atheist has no proof there is no God it is faith. What I want you to know leaving islam does not make you an atheist, you left the religion of islam . there are 4000 gods one is true and the rest are false or satanic like the god of islam. My opinion if there is a true God which I believe there is , He must manifest himself to you in a convincing way. It is personal relationship not as nation. I do not believe coincident made the universe. 1st matter dos not spontaneously exist or invented or vanish.My 1st question to my self How, when, the universe come to existence? That is before any evolution or any thing like that. Then how life in human animal plants and all other living being come to existence? Then the evolution does not show us any specie changed from another specie? Do you know we cannot make in the lab a biological cell one biological cell we cannot make one biological cell inspite we know how its structure and the material and we can make the suitable environment? We can make a living cell that does not reproduce other cells so it would die. So think logically but not believing in islam would not make you an atheist and not believing in the moon god allah will not make you an atheist. I can be agnostic but I would search for the truth. As n MD I cannot believe in both the evolution that has missing links since there are a huge gap between human and the most intelligent animal and we and apes are cousins, I refuse to be from the same family as an ape. If you have any answers to my questions, please provide me with them. Those scientists not all some of them thins the are the true gods.
You do not know whom Mohmed called them the Apostles did exist and if they did his stories about them are disgusting An example Mosses and Al kheder the most evil story about the apostles. They are not called apostles by the Jewish people but prophets because the Jewish faith know they told prophecies about the Messiah
@@T-19- Dhahan
What a courageous lady! She's just being honest to herself. She deserves the highest respect.
The fact that a book is illegal to have pretty much says it all.
Believers in religion are pretty much flat earthers. Denounce something they wouldn’t think is actual and are proved wrong in the future.
yes it's illegal to sell fecal matter to public, shit should be illegal :)
mein kamp is illegal in Germany,no?
f
Why is the Protocols of the Elders of Zion illegal in "free" countries, though?
Happy women's days to this beautiful strong lady and all brave women's out
There
What's the price of the ducati in your dp?
@@majinvegeta3284 out of the door
27,000 in California
*MINDBLOWING*
Science, The Universe & The Universal Truth
th-cam.com/video/nIbnUMqLQ78/w-d-xo.html
PART 1 th-cam.com/video/mtCgzM5v6MU/w-d-xo.html
PART 2 th-cam.com/video/UELGDF2jNhU/w-d-xo.html
ex-muslim from Bangladesh and leaving islam is the best decision i have ever made
Jesus is the Prince of peace my friend, and persecution is coming from this wicked world
misguided life choices, you will regret it in the hereafter
@@tahrir76 Jesus is King, and is coming to destroy satan
@@isaiahbakombo8603 Yes, I agree with that, but he does not recognize Christianity, he will ask: who are you? Who told me to worship me, get away from me
@@tahrir76 No He said NOT EVERYONE who call Me Lord Lord, I will deny because they haven't done my works but were lukewarm Revelation 3:16. If Jesus said EVERYONE who calls Me Lord, than He is denying He is God, but Jesus said He will judge. Daniel 7:9 the prophet describes Jesus on judgment day. When the Father wants to make Himself visible, that is Jesus, Bible calls Him Son because He appears as Son of Man and came into the World to accomplish the mission promised to Ibrahim John 8:56
An atheist and ex muslim from Malaysia. We have a little secret group for atheist here. Few years back our government try to track us down and its on national news. Hopefully all good and be strong and safe to ex muslim all around the world!
@ameroffsky Hi. Yes, definitely. I think most people will read in English or Bahasa Melayu but Indonesian books are always huge thing here in Malaysia especially literature. We need to follow and learn how success book scene in Indonesia are. Me myself a huge fan of Pak Pram and Chairil Anwar. :)
@@firstgear6751 Well, good for you then. Do not kill/imprison other people if they don’t believe in your little god.
@@firstgear6751 there’s a lot sources from Hadith or Quran. You claim you’re better muslim in term of understanding Islamic’s core. But how could you don’t even know? Have you heard herd mentality? Ah you believe in slavery. Funny.
Crimes (Qisas or Retaliation)
Ibn 'Abbas (RAA) narrated that The Messenger of Allah said, “He who changes his religion (i.e. apostates) kill him.” Related by Al-Bukhari.
وَعَنْ اِبْنِ عَبَّاسٍ رَضِيَ اَللَّهُ عَنْهُمَا قَالَ: قَالَ رَسُولُ اَللَّهِ - صلى الله عليه وسلم -{ مَنْ بَدَّلَ دِينَهُ فَاقْتُلُوهُ } رَوَاهُ اَلْبُخَارِيُّ
English translation : Book 9, Hadith 1242
Arabic reference : Book 9, Hadith 1214
Mu’adh bin Jabal (RAA) narrated - concerning a man who embraced Islam and then turned to Judaism (i.e. apostated), ‘I shall not sit down until he is killed. That is the Command of Allah and His Messenger, and he gave an order that he must be killed and so he was.’ Agreed upon. In a version by Abu Dawud, ‘He was given a chance to repent and return to Islam but he refused.’
وَعَنْ مُعَاذِ بْنِ جَبَلٍ - رضى الله عنه - -فِي رَجُلٍ أَسْلَمَ ثُمَّ تَهَوَّدَ-: { لَا أَجْلِسُ حَتَّى يُقْتَلَ, قَضَاءُ اَللَّهِ وَرَسُولِهِ, فَأُمِرَ بِهِ, فَقُتِلَ. مُتَّفَقٌ عَلَيْهِ } . 1 . وَفِي رِوَايَةٍ لِأَبِي دَاوُدَ: { وَكَانَ قَدْ اُسْتُتِيبَ قَبْلَ ذَلِكَ } . 2 .
1 - صحيح. رواه البخاري (6923)، ومسلم (3456 - 1457/رقم 15)، وهو بتمامه من طريق أبي بردة قال: قال أبو موسى: أقبلت إلى النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ومعي رجلان من الأشعريين، أحدهما عن يميني، والآخر عن يساري، فكلاهما سأل العمل. والنبي صلى الله عليه وسلم يستاك. فقال: "ما تقول يا أبا موسى! أو يا عبد الله بن قيس"؟ قال: فقلت: والذي بعثك بالحق! ما أطلعاني على ما في أنفسهما. وما شعرت أنهما يطلبان العمل. قال: وكأني أنظر إلى سواكه تحت شفته، وقد قلصت. فقال: "لن. أو لا نستعمل على عملنا من أراده. ولكن اذهب أنت يا أبا موسى. أو يا عبد الله بن قيس" فبعثه على اليمن. ثم أتبعه معاذ بن جبل، فلما قدم عليه قال: انزل. وألقى له وسادة. وإذا رجل عنده موثق. قال: ما هذا؟ قال: هذا كان يهوديا فأسلم، ثم راجع دينه؛ دين السوء. فتهود. قال: لا أجلس حتى يقتل. قضاء الله ورسوله. فقال: اجلس. نعم. قال: لا أجلس حتى يقتل. قضاء الله ورسوله (ثلاث مرات) فأمر به. فقتل. ثم تذاكرا القيام من الليل. قال أحدهما؛ معاذ: أما أنا فأنام وأقوم، وأرجو في نومتي ما أرجو في قومتي.
2 - صحيح. رواه أبو داود (4355).
English translation : Book 9, Hadith 1241
Arabic reference : Book 9, Hadith 1213
Narrated Zaid:
that he heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) saying: "Whoever is killed over his wealth then he is a martyr, and whoever is killed over his religion, then he is a martyr, and whoever is killed over his blood, then he is martyr, and whoever is killed over his family, then he is martyr."
حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ بْنُ حُمَيْدٍ، قَالَ أَخْبَرَنِي يَعْقُوبُ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ بْنِ سَعْدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا أَبِي، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنْ أَبِي عُبَيْدَةَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَمَّارِ بْنِ يَاسِرٍ، عَنْ طَلْحَةَ بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَوْفٍ، عَنْ سَعِيدِ بْنِ زَيْدٍ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَقُولُ " مَنْ قُتِلَ دُونَ مَالِهِ فَهُوَ شَهِيدٌ وَمَنْ قُتِلَ دُونَ دِينِهِ فَهُوَ شَهِيدٌ وَمَنْ قُتِلَ دُونَ دَمِهِ فَهُوَ شَهِيدٌ وَمَنْ قُتِلَ دُونَ أَهْلِهِ فَهُوَ شَهِيدٌ " . قَالَ هَذَا حَدِيثٌ حَسَنٌ . وَهَكَذَا رَوَى غَيْرُ وَاحِدٍ عَنْ إِبْرَاهِيمَ بْنِ سَعْدٍ نَحْوَ هَذَا . وَيَعْقُوبُ هُوَ ابْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ بْنِ سَعْدِ بْنِ إِبْرَاهِيمَ بْنِ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ بْنِ عَوْفٍ الزُّهْرِيُّ .
Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)
Reference : Jami` at-Tirmidhi 1421
In-book reference : Book 16, Hadith 38
English translation : Vol. 3, Book 14, Hadith 1421
@@firstgear6751 😖🥵
Sahih al-Bukhari 5158
Narrated 'Urwa:
The Prophet (ﷺ) wrote the (marriage contract) with `Aisha while she was six years old and consummated his marriage with her while she was nine years old and she remained with him for nine years (i.e. till his death).
حَدَّثَنَا قَبِيصَةُ بْنُ عُقْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا سُفْيَانُ، عَنْ هِشَامِ بْنِ عُرْوَةَ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ، تَزَوَّجَ النَّبِيُّ صلى الله عليه وسلم عَائِشَةَ وَهْىَ ابْنَةُ سِتٍّ وَبَنَى بِهَا وَهْىَ ابْنَةُ تِسْعٍ وَمَكَثَتْ عِنْدَهُ تِسْعًا.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 5158
In-book reference : Book 67, Hadith 93
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 7, Book 62, Hadith 88
@@firstgear6751 are you still there? Want more?
What a privilege to be interviewed by Dawkins.
Yeah I'm sure atheism made Hitler and Stalin much nicer people
HZ GP pretty sure hitler was christian but anyway what about all the wars fought in the name of God?
@@wildmoonchild8210, If i could i would have rise thumb (likes) for your to HZ GP more than once!!!
@@user-lj7md8sv7d i'll help u.
@@theguidancecounsellor2948 stalin and hitler is not atheisr but another kind of religious prophet，they replace old religion with their own personal cult，claming their new ideology is superior than any others and promote hatred as priority just like all three Abrahamic religions
my english is not good, i will be very happy to read your books in arabic , thank you very much mr dawkinz for your enlightment
thank you very much for the links👍
Pretty sure she said something about having to use a hidden VPN
@@tafdiz lol, there are millions atheist and seculair people in arab world, but not enough!!! may be 15% of the population.. and muslims can be violent, so people hide
Here is the top atheist youtube channels in the arab world, millions of views
th-cam.com/channels/_CKL5F9i7e9sPnZcxXP3HQ.html
th-cam.com/channels/nTJcc901wCa5vZQQot8fCw.html
I m optimistic :)
@@JM-ti2ii thanks for the links. I don't understand arabic but the top one had english subtitles. I admire people who leave religion in fanatically religious countries. My whole family and all my friends are atheist, so for me it was easy. Can't even imagine how hard it most be when all around you are religious.
@@KevinUchihaOG yeah, for me it was not very hard, in age of 16, and im 36 now, i start asking questions, reading books, i become agnostic.. The problem of atheist people in muslim country is to speek out, internet facilite this, but we still live in a big open psychiatrie hospital, people who lives with imiginary angry dangerous friend on the sky!! i can't even tell my parents about that, and i m realy very sorry for them that their parent abuse their brain when they was kids... For now, we need your help to get alot of views so muslims cant not shutdown our youtube and facebook channels and pages. thank you for your coments, and hope that all of that mess will change soon!
Syrian/Jordanian atheist 🇯🇴🇸🇾 living in America 🇺🇸
You are revolutionary dear. Life is a lot easier this way.
There is no coercion in Muslim religion, but your choice of life, out of Islam is astray, you will regret in the hereafter
@hashem elhwary oi,will she get 72 virgins to abuse too? So ur fictional heaven is a hell for virgins.
ازاي رحت هناك ؟
Welcome.
I love how Richard dawkins really want to empower people bcoz he is providing his book to several countries for absolutely free ....30million downloads man...that would be great deal of money if that was paid yet he gave them ...love u Richard but seeing u getting old is horrifying me 🤐
I buy his books, not just to read... but also support him
Indeed! Bravo to him!
I believe he is more interested in providing good information to as many people as possible. Money is secondary. Also, providing it for free online will reach far more people than a physical book that costs money. I'm sure a paper copy wouldn't have sold 30 million copies, at least not in the same amount of time. Bravo, Mr. Dawkins!
Drastic Gamers TV . I feel exactly the same way. I remember how gorgeous looking he was up until his stroke.
Fortunately his mind is as sharp as ever and he retains his wonderful personality. He’ll always be a beautiful soul.
Louise Haley That’s probably the funniest thing I’ve read in ages.
I wish Professor Dawkins lived 100 years more , humanity needs people like him a lot.
There will be new Dawkins and even better, study to be one of them
@@LaZanzaraAlbopictus as much as i like to believe that but the more I'm watching the world the more I'm becoming convinced that the teachings of Professor Dawkins will go to waste.
Religion are just part of human evolution to understanding the unknown. With our present understanding and knowledge towards the world, its fair to assume and predict that the more advanced and civilized humanity become, the chance that people become irrelegious are more high. Greeting from indonesia 🇲🇨
@@obesewan6632 Of course!
I wish the same. Such a fine Brilliant man
Iranian here, I concur.
Same story here.
Many us have seen the ugliness of organized religion, especially when it becomes a political tool.
Thanks for the interview. Ms. Ahmad is indeed very brave.
Religion does more good for society than bad though. Provided its not forced and doesnt take the route of extremism.
@@bobsvagene3021 True indeed. But the problem is, that even the less extremist route has often been forced upon nations either via invasions, wars or propaganda.
Zoroastrian is not organized political crime
It's all about the family and the kind of upbringing. I had an Islamic upbringing, was taught prayers, Quran, celebrations etc in early age. One great thing though is that my family while insisting I pray in time etc, theytrusted me to do it without checking on me or forcing me, they always said don't fear us, fear your Creator. I always was free to ask questions about our existence and asked all sorts of paradoxical questions. And they took it with open heart, and when they didn't know the answer they would admit it. What is going on here with this woman is that she wasn't convinced and needed to be let go. I'm not certsin her story checks out though, that she didn't kniw about Atheism before finding Dawkins book, and that her brother hired someone from the darknet to track his sister to kill her. Sounds like something from what a typical Atheist script. But I as a Muslim totally agrees that she is free to believe what she wants. Her family did an effort to convince her, but they cant make faith into a cultural issue and force her to cover up. But they also can't ship her to other countries just because she wants to wear minidkirt.
@@snake1mi
If it is all about the family ,why are muslims taught to love allah and mohamed more than their own parents and children?
God is love? ..... love him above all humans?
If you can convince people the glorious leader is more important than your own parents and children..... you are in a cult, no doubt about it.
When you are willing to kill or even stand by and turn a blind eye when others kill in the name of allah/mohamed or any other made up god you are in a cult.
When you deny a scientific field of study because it contradicts a fairytale in your holy book. You are in a cult.
I admire her courage to stand up for the real truth. Hope we will get the English version of her book very soon.
I'm Indian atheist. But still my family don't know I'm atheist, I keep it secret bcz if they know they may throw me away from my family . I need family support too.
My father Islamic preacher, and my brother Islamic teacher in a mosque.
Ngyahoo Prophet focus on becoming financially independent and move out and get your own place. Then tell them.
Congratulations Ngyahoo, you're the most intelligent in your family. I wish you all the best.
My family do, am from Pakistan
In which city do u live bro ?
Indian atheist here, belonging to the same religious background. I would suggest, don't reveal any of what you believe as of now. Get a good education, get a job and then move out(probably to a different city). Once done, you may reveal then. If they accept you then(I don't think they would) good for you, else leave it. Don't change yourself. You need to fight for what you believe. Start a new life. And lastly don't be sad, tough life makes a tough person and a great story to remember!
May the forces(of Physics) be with you.
I'm an atheist from Lebanon and I wish I could meet Mr Dawkins
He can't meet everyone..and why do you need to meet him
No way! Me too!
You can find out where he is, his conferences on his website and prepare your travel :) Need to hurry maybe :(
I'm also a Lebanese atheist there are many atheists here u r not alone
@@warrencotterill4864 well wouldn't you want to meet him? Ofcourse he can't met everyone. He didn't demand it. He just said he "wish". I also wish i could meet Dawkins and i'm an atheist in one of the (if not the) most atheistic countries in the world (sweden).
I'm an atheist from West Bengal India.
West Bengal
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Bengal
Atheist from India, and thankfully I am surrounded by Hindus, Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs and hence I have nothing to worry about.
@BHAGWAN atheist Especially practices like expensive dowry, honor killings and untouchability.
Atheist from india here, im surrounded by muslims 💀💀
@@abelsoo5465 After buddhism , hinduism has relaunched So there are many Practises which are not consistent with vedas/puran
@@navneetkumar5268 Yes thanks to these assholes who call themselves bhakts
I was born in a Sikh family, quite pious but they were fine with me being atheist. Growing up we used to have healthy debates about religion and faith. I guess India is better in terms of tolerance for atheism.
Athiest from Kuwait 🇰🇼
Azizataurus Taurus me too😍
Where in Kuwait !?
🇮🇶 بارك دوكينز بك
So you don't belive on God?
الله يهديك
I'M Egyptian EX-muslim , i left islam 2 years ago but no one in my family knows about that
Egyptian Ex-Muslim well wht to say.. you are one of the unlucky ones man.
I suggest think again and study quran again.
Take care
Rethink again
Indonesian ex muslim agnostic atheist here, i haven't told my family, they're generally awesome people doing their best for me and i don't want to break their hearts
EX Christian Egyptian here bro
@Beelzebub 666 please don't say that is offensive to me and some other people
Respect from your Tunisian brother! Personally, your courage to sacrificing the relationship with your family in favour of freedom is undeniably strong and it takes a lot to overcome. In this respect, I admire your special will and strength. It is special in your case since you come from one of the most theocratical countries in the world.
Its so sad that such a loving brother would then try to kill her later just for leaving her faith. Religion really corrupts people
Any brother who would do such a thing is NOT loving; he fooled her all those years; now she sees him for what he is.
@@fearlessleader1477
No mahn... This can happen...
Even Some parents behave very wildly.
Only those who are morally good will love you for your diverse decisions.
….. it only takes religion for a good person to do bad”
It's so disgusting she gets threatened in Germany by other immigrants. This country values religious freedom and they should be sent back to where they came from immediately.
if Europe doesn't take care of this disease called Islam it will be even worse than Corona virus.
@hashem elhwary what is your point?
@hashem elhwary it's muslims who can't respect freedom of religion so they have to go.
sorry but not sorry.
Crazy mad stupid people who fled from İslam and still support islam😃
@@gbtusa1325 its not just islam its all religions
I admire u. Greetings from an ex muslim from Albania. I wish u all the best
Back off, before it is too late
You don't know
The sun may rise from its set tomorrow
@@ahmedsherif8341 What?
@@ahmedsherif8341 wth
Ex muslim from Bangladesh..❤
I in turn admire you, and Shwaj and any Muslim who's brave enough to admit that they no longer believe in Islam ❤
Today I am atheist only because of Mr Dawkins.
Thankyou sir your work have liberated many shackled conscious.
Lots of respect for you
"Thankyou sir your work have liberated many shackled conscious.
Lots of respect for you"
Yes, Richard liberated you. You now believe the universe came about by "literally nothing" like that dumbass does. How liberating.
The extreme order we have, it all happened by mere chance. It's dumb, but you feel liberated so who cares.
Life forming on its own. Can't happen, but you feel liberated.
Life evolving from soup to man, no science to back that but you feel liberated.
Congrats, you feel liberated as a dumbass. You must be proud.
@@2fast2block Well you guys believe that the god creature came out of nothing, nobody has created this thing, it just exists. Yet you call other people dumbass for believing the universe came out of nothing?
@imu70 dah obviously there was something before but it sure is not god.
@imu70 you must be another theist shit for brain.i don't wanna waste my time trying to make you realise how stupid,cruel and dumb theistic beliefs are.
Can anyone demonstrate which scripture states that allah/god/yahweh/zeus et all claims to have patience beyond any belief to start life millions and millions of years ago, watch 99+% of all species go extinct, gradually form human kind BUT only reveal himself to an individual (generally in a desert in the Middle East) in the last few millennia, create a universe so huge it is incomprehensible to humans and all the time have stars forming, dying, galaxies colliding billions of light years away for what purpose?
We don’t know how it all started but methinks it has fuck all supernatural about it.
Dawkins, I salute you.
The world isn’t flat, the universe is billions of years old, not 6000 so why isn’t this stated in your scriptures? Adam, Eve my arse.
Ex-muslim from Morocco here! You are not alone.
@btmana mana yes I know, when you can khroj men temma
Love to see Richard Dawkins active again.
Please leave out your coarse and obscene language next time.
It is unnecessary.
Жалко, че го изпуснах, като беше в София преди няколко години...
It's a terribly sad and inconceivable tragedy to even hear of, I'm 15 years old and I'm proud to say that I'm an atheist .. I am from Egypt but now my location is within the country of devil Saudi Arabia .. I really wish that I could read Rana's book. One day only the truth will be revealed.
One day, maybe, you would end up like *Anthony Few, the *famous atheist* who opted to be a déist* (ni musulman ni chretien). He wrote 30 books.
See the video: eveilphilosophie.canalblog.com/archives/2013/11/07/28379219.html
You are a citizen of the world, it's good that you have overthrown the controlling ideas of religion; as an atheist who has a much easier time of it(I live in a country in which it is much easier to say that I am an atheist) I want very much to support your freedom of choice (and Rana's); don't forget that you are not alone.
@Ibrahim Mohamed Finding out that religion isn't true isn't about 'betrayal'. You don't 'betray Father Christmas just because you no longer believe in him.
اخواتي اخواتي
You are too young for these things. I am looking for the truth. Look at the woman. She is sad
I love you, Richard Dawkins!!! You are HOPE for the future of mankind.
Rana, you are the most brave woman I know. You are also HOPE. It gives hope to see it is possible that somebody can open his mind and his heart in such deeply religious environment, somebody can be brave enough to fight with this monster called religion, with the whole world, defending his true beliefs and his freedom. You are a true hero. I love you too!
Å
I’m SOOOOOOOO proud of all the ex Muslims in the comment section. ♥️
@AWB R again, fuck your Allah up the ass
@AWB R lol k go away now
@AWB R yet appostates are to be put to death .yet there is compultion in islam
@AWB R how dare you ask us to have our anger under control ,how dare you !
Tell that to ur brethern in muslim states like pakistan and saudia
How dare u call us ignorant when ur willing to kill over an imaginary god u cant even prove
How dare u strip our rights and freedom away yet demand to be not sad
How dare u call us hateful when ppl are thrown off roof tops,thrown out of their houses ,hated and humiliated by u ppl in ur states on the basies of petty faith !
We dont need ur petty sympathy . Get out ! May common sense guide u
@AWB R sorry but I'm not misinformed at all .i live what u deny
Here in Libya the atheist movement is uprising as well.
Nice 👍👍👍
Very good ❤️
All the very best to our enlightened Libyan Atheist and Agnostic brothers and sisters. Be brave, strong and free in your mind.
@Lucid Dreams🌈
ملحد ≠ لا ديني
Congratulations!
That women is a true feminist.
I would say free thinking. Feminism and free thought are two different things.
@ken Why not just say 'humanism' and get rid of all problems related to feminism?
Feminism means advocating for equal rights between sexes. Misandry means discrimination against men. They aren't the same thing.
Both religion and feminism stem from mental disorder and a want of power.
@ken I see your point. But I still am against the usage of 'femisism'. It is a very loaded term, and I might be willing to use it to describe 'towards women's human right' if contemporary feminists didn't exist. Given they do exist, what I am afraid is that they will hijack any attempt towards women's human rights named 'feminism'. And I am really not going to take such a risk.
She seems to be a very intelligent and especially very brave young woman!
I wish we had more refugees like her. REAL refugees that actually need our help because they risk their life if they stay in their country.
And i'm with you on this 100% 👍😃
Actually,that is what happens many times. Most of the refugees are fleeing violence and authoritarian regimes. Or they are looking for a place where they can give a better life to their kids
Your image man..You really should go to the gym and stop doing what your doing in the basement
muslims were so happy that many muslims refugees in Europe in order to dominate Europe
She was rich enough. Most atheists like us will remain buried because of the depressed lives we've lived that hardly makes a good case for us when it comes to in demand jobs abroad. Well fuck it anyway
I remember being at shock a few years ago when i first saw this video. As a Saudi it was so hard for me to believe that there are atheists among us.
And here i am coming back to this video after leaving islam and looking back at it all. Ugh i wish i left this religion sooner.
I truly feel sorry for u. Well, when u die u will know
Nice
Dear Richard i'm from iran and i'm atheist.i've read your great book "God Delusion".I can easily say that almost half of Iran's people are atheists.I'm glad to see you healthy.❤😍😍😍
really half? I doubt so. Half is a really high number even in secular countries. Only 23% in USA are out of a religion. So 50% for iran seems high. Anyway i hope that is true.
Kevin Uchiha in Scandinavia i think less than 1 % believe in god.. Personally i don’t know a single person from there believing the stories from the bible or Quran are real.
@@KevinUchihaOG You are correct. 50% sound too high. I am confident it is not correct. However, the trend of Iranians leaving religion is very significant. It has been pointed out as a threatening social phenomenon by some religious or state news networks. It is worthy to mention that criticism of religion and clergy is an old trend in Persian culture and literature. I think Spiegel published a report about the atheism trend in Iran several years ago.
@@Natorz111 i live in Sweden and i personally don't know any people who believe the bible or quran. But i have met people who do. And 1% is way to low. Just google the stats. For example in Sweden 45% of people say they adhere to a religion. Sure that doesn't mean they live their life by the books or so. But that most mean they atleast believe in God, why else would they be part of a religion? Only 17% self identify as an atheist, sure more people probably don't believe in a God but still don't identify with atheism. But still your 1% figure is waaaay off. Google it.
Kevin Uchiha i was talking about believing the stories of the bible or Quran to be fact... like people could be 1000 years old in the past there was a global flood, the earth is 6000 years old, women are made from the rib of a man and evolution to be false...i would be shocked if more than 1% of Scandinavians believe in that stuff (not including immigrants in this)
What a beautiful and powerful woman
Osh She looks like Elizabeth Taylor in cleopatra which is pretty fitting.
Extreme power
I would too. Agreed. Though I would like to dress her in a black sack for my enjoyment only:)
My point exactly. It's criminal to keep such beauty and intelligence from the world.
Agreed
It's sad to see Richard Dawkins getting older
Consider the alternative
It's called"old age"!!!After all,the man is 77.......it's going to happen to all of us if we live long enough etc.
He is fuckn dead 💀 within 2019 😂
Make thousands of equal human beings..Old age , you can't stop it. Idea will not die
He is closer to meeting God.
I hope they keep her safe in Germany. What a brave, intelligent and passionate person!
She deserves a wonderful future, free from persecution.
I hope she continues to write!
I'm not going to lie, I burst into tears hearing this. I hope her book gets translated into English asap.
Typical Anglophone who won't bother learning another language
@@pithitammegatherium7208 you have alot of time in your hands brother...
👇
I'm so happy to live in Germany. Sometimes I forget what a great privilege that is.
Open gates to more Islamic refugees, and in 50-100 years it will be like any other Islamic country.
I'm a Brit and I've nothing but admiration for Germany. Out of the chaotic terror of the Nazi regime comes arguably the greatest democratic country in Europe. I just hope the refugees understand that they're entered a country that birthed Goethe, Hegel, Kant, Beethoven, Nietschze, Liebniz, Bach and far too many other cultural giants to mention
@@wiseonwords Maybe it's the fact they would have the freedom to read Goethe
@flannel sykes,
wonderfull answer
i wish i had born in liberal countries like Germany, Canada etc
Religion was invented when the first conman met the first fool - Mark Twain
hahaha. awesome.
And where is mark twain? Gone, dead, and religion is still standing soo ..
@@borisrovchenko7747 fool
@@benukumari4524 loooool why u deleted my comment, are u afraid to debate? Like ur old man richard?
@ً ً look if u wanna discuss something just bring it, dont throw empty bad words to me, u slacker
I am an Egyptian ex Muslim and I wish you safety, happiness and above all freedom! Despite of what I passed by, but it nothing compared to a Saudi Arabian declaring this. Much respect to you
Four things to be clarified:
1- This woman is Syrian, not Saudi.
2- The interview is so old.
3- Today's Saudi Arabia is much different from what it was prior to 2015.
4- While you are watching this interview now, other Arabic-speaking fanatic media are simultaneously
attacking Saudi Arabia for what they call "A shun away from religious/conservative identity) which is quite the opposite of this interview.
@@aquapisces24 I am aware of and happy with current changes in Saudi Arabia but Islam remains the same
@@MichaelFaraday9 good for you but I hope everyone else is aware and not misled
It pains me to see how Richard Dawkins is getting at the edge of his life now...i admired him for soo long...i hope he lives long.
Truth never dies
Hopefully he starts to believe before he returns to his creator.
No doubt personally and will change in thrity years, mark my words.
@AT Complete SS yes I will, you too
@AT Complete SS okay keyboard warrior👏
She is incredibly brave
And an inspiration to all people (especially women) who live under the same circumstances as her..
I am from India and I am very happy that I am an atheist now. Humanity is only the thing that can bring peace in this beautiful planet. All religions demands peace yet rage war through out history. How wonderful?
Atheism does not guarantee peace on this planet. Some of the biggest tyrants in the history of humanity were atheists
my heart breaks for her and people in the same situation! she is so brave
my heart breaks for her These (English translation available)
Guided Through the Quran
th-cam.com/video/K9Yo43w62FA/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/EvcpjwVTfYQ/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/Y-7bmSQ90uA/w-d-xo.html
"religion poisons everything"
-Christopher Hitchens
"Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction." - Blaise Pascal
An interesting perspective from a Biblical Christian.
Then again, it wasn't too many decades earlier was The French Civil War, but still 300 years before Jo Stalin gave us an example of unbridled atheist extremism.
What you refer to as "unbridled atheist extremism" was nothing but religious extremism. Communism was the de facto religion. The fact that Communism is incompatible with religious faith had nothing to do with it.
Since you're into 'whataboutism', what about the hundreds of thousands innocents that were butchered in Bush's Irak war? Bush: "God told me to invade Iraq"
@@Io1564 It wasn't really even communism, you won't find Gulags, strong nationalism, militarism, strong leaders in Marx writings. Not to mention Lysenkoism.
@@Hirnlego999 I know. However, the poorly educated, holier than thou, right wing nutcases like 1969cmp do not.
@Nathan El m(
Thank you Mr Dawkins. You are doing a great service to humanity by exposing the lies and flaws of religions
Have you ever read a religious book especially Quran?
@@jwanrojwanro6856 I read Bible and Quoran also ;-)
Yes .The Quran. It is a book that contains nice poetry and Sharia law but it is full of scientific mistakes, and "Harry Potter like stories" Therefore cannot be from a creator @@jwanrojwanro6856
Salem Ahmad لايوجد اي خطأ علمي بالقرآن الكريم
there is no scientific errors in quran , if you speak arabic I can explain to you better
@@therealityforyou665 اتركهم يا سبحان الله يقول الله تعالئ ويمدهم في طغيانهم يعمهون هو قرأ القرأن بالكامل ولم يؤثر به كيف تريد انت أن تؤثر به هو فقط مثل دمية للشيطان أفكاره وشكوكه وكل شي قاده الئ هذا فقط كن مع الحق ويمكنك رؤية النور بشكل واضح والسلام عليكم
Ex muslim from india🇮🇳
I am ex hindu
@hashem elhwary who are you
which PRoblem bro
,,ywgjg
Islamism is against humanity
@hashem elhwary you just read Surat thauwa 9:4,5,6of Quran then after contact me
*Proud Ex- Muslim women from India 🇮🇳, I am lucky to born here, I can openly do whatever I want*
Why did you leave islam what your reason?
except eat beef
Nice to hear. Fellow Atheist from 🇮🇳🇮🇳
👏👏🤘🤘
Just shut the fuck up !
If you are identified fanatics may not kill you but there is possiblity that they will harm you .
I really hope you will live a free and happy life here in Germany.
Also your book sounds so interesting that I immediately ordered it.
TheSpinTensor just another member of the brown horde replacing white Europeans in their own homeland. There will be a war soon, you can hear the hounds of battle barking. No one wages war like Europeans. No one. It’s not going to be pretty.
Yeah, she will live free and happy here - while our arms manufacturers sell weapons to Saudi Arabia. Strange new world.
@@BikingVikingHH I think that was wishful thinking on your part. I'm a Brit, there have been Muslims in Britain for centuries. Many of the doctors and nurses in Britain are Muslims. I don't care what colour or religion someone is when they're saving my daughter's life.
@@TonyEnglandUK Same from here in Austria. I live in a district with many Muslims. The overwhelming majority, just like the overwhelming majority of Christians and atheists, are interested in living a good life and not bothering others.
cheers from cloudy Vienna, Scott
@@user-ng7ri8qj9k Yep, I agree with you wholeheartedly. Fundamentalist Islam is a real danger for human rights and democracy.
The most horrible thing is that she has to hide from her family just because she doesn’t believe in “God/Allah”!??
I would definitely buy the book if/when it arrives in English!
You do not really understand it. For her family it is not the disbelief that really matters! It is a matter of family honour for them and no it does not correlate with religion. They would be equally dismissive for here had they been pagan, or nonreligious in any sense.
I know, still hide it for over 6 years.
@@nahidhkurdi6740 -- You're being dishonest if you minimise the role of religion in this. As someone who has rejected Islam to become an atheist, Rana would be considered an apostate. For that, the punishment is death in many Muslim countries.
@@wiseonwords After reviewing the clip for another time I could point you to 5:50. She said it all herself in amongst the hype. Now tell me about dishonesty.
@ATHEIST BHAGWAN
No, it is not. There were complete tribes that lived in the desert for millennia and has nothing to care about but basic survival. Yet, they care much about their honour before encountering any systematic religion.
Shout out to this lady for showing tremendous courage.
I'm an atheist from Sudan. Hearing what she's gone through, I'm convinced she's the most courageous atheist to have ever come out from an Islamic nation.
The truth she chose !
She will die bcz of natural selection though (killed by other people is natural too)
@@ahmadieb In a way maybe, but that doesnt mean that would be good, it would be horrible if she were killed. Do you think it would be OK if she was killed, is that what you mean?
Technology, science saved this woman from a life of oppression and misery. BRING on knowledge, bring on information to everyone. If you let light in the world is a brighter, happier place!
Wait for that sweet dino juice to exhaust and lose its value. Then those arabs who believe in flat earth would open themselves to science and open society or become a poor and bankrupt nation like pakistan.
codyjones109 me too
I mean, you are more likely to have the strength of the universe and suggest the presence of strength
And God is all I mentioned
And then the Messenger of Islam was the one who was informed about the emergence of new diseases due to adultery, such as AIDS, after a period of time
He is the one who said that if you choose from the ground, I feel a tightness in his chest, and this is now known as the lack of oxygen in the heights as in Surat Al-Anaam A125
He said he would be a war in Iraq and Syria
He is the one who said that the Arabs will be weak among the nations
He is the one who said that songs and singers will spread and now everyone has become a singer because of Snap and Tectok
He said that the commercial markets will be many
He said that religion will be weak
He is the one who said that unethical things will happen on the road like adultery
He is the one who said that time and time will be short
It was he who said that Jerusalem would be taken by the Muslims, then the Jews would take it, and at the end of time the Muslims would take it
He is the one who said that sedition will follow like what has happened in this time
He was the one who advised turning the sleeping body for a long time so as not to eat and it is a norm now, as in Surat Al-Kahf.
He is the one who said that the sun runs by modern science
Whoever searches fairly in Google will find many clues. And what is mentioned in some of the false hadiths is not a measure or some
Wrong applications are not a measure either, with a wealth of evidence
As for his evil dilemma, it is necessary, and the dilemma of imperfection is necessary. Inequality is needed
Because perfection, justice, beauty and goodness ... are in paradise only
Satan's torment and punishment for expulsion and cursing him
As for seeing God Almighty, it is the greatest blessing that a Muslim will receive in Paradise
And noticing Satan, he made himself bad for him. After seeing the kingdom of God
The situation is upon you, no matter how you see evidence, to satisfy yourself, commanding you of evil, which is unilateral and unbelief
So, rightly, you are the one with you and above before it is too late
Sss Sss says the human with no evidence.
Atheists paint with a wide brush ,one religion bad ,,they 're all bad ,real bright! I truly pity the Atheist ,why do you guy's even get out of bed?
I cried watching this. I think i felt the same pain as Mr. Dawkins. What a world we live in.
This is why, NEVER ever let a devoted Muslims enter your country for what ever reasons.
Yeah, because his faith will light up your dark life
@@Faizan_H lmao
@@Faizan_H so according to you more than half of the world is living in dark except for the people believing in nonsense.
@@user-hr7wq7wt7q No no, not half, It's even more than that
@@Faizan_H nice joke 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
atheist from iraq 🇮🇶
Proud of you bro
From Iraq or in Iraq?
... if actually in Iraq ... take care! And congrats to this, too.
kafir
Welcome my brother in the kufr and the fujor ❤️🙏
abbasi 111 who doesn't love the kafers ☺️
Thank you for bringing theses realities to light
@Abdul Raheem my poor man, I prescribe yet another Richard Dawkins vid, or hitchens or many others that are very 'reality' based. *Godless* is a super slogan today, didn't you know ? Very TRENDY :))
Am looking forward to reading this in English, thanks for sharing your story Rana.
Rana is doing it for money why you're doing it.
Zero Hour There’s much easier ways to make money
If you can explain a god without a creator, you can explain a universe without a creator. Thank you Richard. Congratulations to Rana.
Watch hamza tzortiz he have done great work
I am an atheist and is wonderful to see this
Moises Sandoval damn I didn’t know that
METALLICCA you didn’t know what bro?
I applaud her! She's really courageous. I know she never exaggerates because I live in the Arab world and I know the suffering. I really wanna read her book I wish it will be translated into English soon.
Her choice but why in half dress before an elderly intellect like prof,Dawkins ,the great !
Typical Anglophone who won't bother learning another language.
@@lovehumanity6468 Because it is indeed her choice and Richard will be absolutely fine with that.
@@pithitammegatherium7208 Yur, 'cos Arabic is SOOOOO useful in technologically advanced and modern thinking cultures.
@@valvlog4665 That language should be banned in America and Canada.
She's come a long way since that vice documentary. Very much applaud her numerous achievements.
This should be aired on every news channel.
The first time I have seen Richard as an interviewer, he has a lovely way about him.
This woman is an inspiration. I wish there was more coverage of moderate or secular persecution in the middle east. It's a blatant lie that there is no pushback from the people being persecuted by Sharia law. There is. They need help.
Edit: I'm sad to hear her book is not published in English. I would love to read it.
The best thing I ever lost was my belief in a god. Good riddance.
AllSeeingEye ofGod 😂😂😂😂
@AllSeeingEye ofGod -Go fish...
@AllSeeingEye ofGod 14 year old proud Trans Humanist Atheist :D
@AllSeeingEye ofGod A religious book is not truth. Far from it.
@AllSeeingEye ofGod The concept of deity is absurd.
Moroccan ateist from denmark🧢
Atheism is natural development of humans - all gods are false and man-made.
yakma kayhaddouk hta nta
@TH-camnet Best Vedeo ستكبر وتعقل
@Allahu fuckbar Jihadmaster69 fuck off
@Abdel-Ilah BENAHMED هو بس يمزح. ثانياً انت ملحد بكل الاله ما عدا اله الاسلام طب لو طلع واحد منهم وصح ايش ايكون موقفك اذا كان زيوس او فيشنو او اهورا مزدا او مثل يسوع انت تقول وما صلبوه وماقتلوه وهو يقلك بلا قتلوني وصلبوني ههههههههه.
I am an Atheist from India and I like you so much Mr. Dawkins. Hats off to this lady.
th-cam.com/video/17rXZa8IUFo/w-d-xo.html
@hashem elhwary not interested in pseudoscience.
@hashem elhwary Then stop comparing science and religion.
@hashem elhwary very funny.. stop lying to yourself and others. don't lie for the sake of your religion. If your religion seeks truth and supports science, first abolish apostasy law .
@hashem elhwary and don't do things because it was ordered by your religion, do it if you like it and do things which wont hurt others, then there will be true peace in this world.
In 15 years Dawkins has helped me so much.. I love this video with an aching heart. I hope this woman's courage succeeds..
I wish Richard Dawkins didn't get older.
Same
Yes brother...wishes remain wishes...Reality wins🥀
But that would disprove e evolution
fuck him .. i am glad he did get
older ..
@@laserbeam3836 uneducated religious person spotted
Richard Dawkins is big man And big idea👏👏👏👏👏.I am from Turkey 🇹🇷
I am from India
@@ansaribanda2444 r u an atheist
@@harjolijatt02narsan81 yes
Turkey muslim country ☪️☪️☪️
@@musti8659 secular country I think
Beautiful, smart, courageous, atheist. My kind of woman.
Arshad Bhat as an atheist with moral values, I can confidently say that your assertion is false. Free your mind from your narrow theistic views, man.
@@arshadbhat6840
We have more moral values than you and then your religion
The Koran calls for stoning and killing all who is not Muslim and selling slaves and rape non-Muslim women married ... Where is the morality in the fucking Koran
Believe me she is not !
Banished From The Dwarf Planet you stupid idiot, so what if she was ugly like an old boot, what would you type
Fools like you piss me off
haha, smart? you should say dumb.... to prove: science says Universe came into existence from NOTHING, ILLOGICAL. while you accept from science that there has to be external cause for a body/material, atom, etc to act.....
Dawkins still on the move
Brave arabian girl, I hope they publish the book in English and Portuguese.
Lots of love from 🇧🇩
Having worked in Saudi I can assure you it is a hell hole. And yes Islam is forced upon people in many countries. It is a punishable offense in many countries to leave Islam whether by becoming an athiest or converting to another religion. Freedom of religion must also include freedom from religion. I applaud this woman and her bravery.
@Alixon Xulkarov People only go to saudi if they can't find anywhere else to go. Wages are about 1/2 what other countries pay for worse conditions. I was in engineering. Harder now to get jobs cause there is a big push to put locals in the positions
It's a horrible country!