I thought the 1912-D nickel would have surely gotten CAC. And the 1894 should definitely have gotten it. Oh, well. Live and learn. Thanks for posting this video. Very helpful! Cheers!
Beautiful coins 🤩 Your MS66 Morgans are stunning! San Francisco early years are some of the most gorgeous Morgans in the series, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, great eye candy.
Nice group of coins. I’ve only ever sent 5 coins to CAC for sticker evaluation, but have an 80% positive sticker rate. But that was before CACG became a thing, and I feel they’ve gone even more conservative of late. I’ve got a few more I think are worthy of the green bean, but I’m going to wait a while before deciding whether to send them in. Gave you a like and sub. 👍
Thanks for watching. Yeah that’s a good success rate, I thought I spent enough time picking out coins to send, but I probably could’ve gotten 1 or 2 more stickers. To be fair I learned more about CAC in the time it took to get these back
You've got some really nice coins. The 82 S Morgan had lovely toning. I wasn't at all surprised that your 16 D didn't sticker, as I thought it looked very much a 2 instead of an AG 3. I thought the Barber should have got a green bean.
Nice coins, and much better results than my first sub. It’s possible they thought the 1912-D nickel was cleaned and retoned. They don’t seem to like that kind of color on XF nickels, I’ve observed. I think you’re right about an old cleaning on the 16-D, and the circ Morgan looks like it may have been cleaned too. In those grades Cac likes coin that have a “dusty” grey look, anything that looks a bit glossy or shiny is unlikely to pass IME. Not sure what they didn’t like about the barber but you might be right about them wanting a bit more flash for a 66. The S mint Morgan could’ve failed for eye appeal or perhaps environmental damage.
3 out of 8 isn't terrible. I just went 1 for 4 on my first sticker submission. You should get some PlastX for those holders. Polish those scratches right out.
It’s such a high grade with gorgeous color but there’s something that looks like a scratch on the neck, maybe it’s toning, I agree with you if that wasn’t the issue I’m not sure what they didn’t like
I think some folks are missing the point here. The CAC sticker is a second opinion on the grade represented on the holder. CAC is verifying the grade given, or not. They look at the grade only, not how beautiful or ugly the coin is, not at all. If they award your coin with a Gold sticker, you just hit a mini jackpot. The CAC Gold sticker says that the coin was undergraded by at least 1 grade point, fyi.
Sorry, but that would be a no go. The absolute newest coin that they will sticker is a 1964 MS Quarter. However they do recognize newer 1C Double Dies; 1955, 1969-S, 1970-S, 1971-S, 1972, 1983, 1984 and 1995. In other words, they like the old stuff.
@@michaelangelobergeron5980 Yes they will "grade" anything new or old. Since PCGS has already graded you coins there's no point in CAC doing so. We're talking about "Stickering" right now. CAC stickering is an approval of the grade stated on the slab. If the numerical grade is accurate but on the lower end of the grade = no sticker.
Why does everyone think their coins are better than the grade reflects? Anyone have one that believes strongly that their coins is a lower grade? Ever crack it out to get the real 'lower' grade? Humanity is an evil life.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 79 | คู่เอก "ก้องชัย vs อาเมียร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WfPSA1A0NHc/mqdefault.jpg)
![HIWWHEE | OHM [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OJJLtTLqLag/mqdefault.jpg)
All nice 🪙's, but i agree.... that 1894 barber dime... 😍 gorgeous 🪙.
Yeah thank you! no regrets buying that one
@@upnorthcoins I guess you can say it was worth every dime 😬
I thought the 1912-D nickel would have surely gotten CAC. And the 1894 should definitely have gotten it. Oh, well. Live and learn. Thanks for posting this video. Very helpful! Cheers!
Glad I could help, there will be more
Beautiful coins 🤩 Your MS66 Morgans are stunning!
San Francisco early years are some of the most gorgeous Morgans in the series, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, great eye candy.
Nice group of coins. I’ve only ever sent 5 coins to CAC for sticker evaluation, but have an 80% positive sticker rate. But that was before CACG became a thing, and I feel they’ve gone even more conservative of late. I’ve got a few more I think are worthy of the green bean, but I’m going to wait a while before deciding whether to send them in. Gave you a like and sub. 👍
Thanks for watching. Yeah that’s a good success rate, I thought I spent enough time picking out coins to send, but I probably could’ve gotten 1 or 2 more stickers. To be fair I learned more about CAC in the time it took to get these back
Excellent 🎉🎉
You've got some really nice coins. The 82 S Morgan had lovely toning. I wasn't at all surprised that your 16 D didn't sticker, as I thought it looked very much a 2 instead of an AG 3. I thought the Barber should have got a green bean.
Nice coins, and much better results than my first sub. It’s possible they thought the 1912-D nickel was cleaned and retoned. They don’t seem to like that kind of color on XF nickels, I’ve observed.
I think you’re right about an old cleaning on the 16-D, and the circ Morgan looks like it may have been cleaned too. In those grades Cac likes coin that have a “dusty” grey look, anything that looks a bit glossy or shiny is unlikely to pass IME.
Not sure what they didn’t like about the barber but you might be right about them wanting a bit more flash for a 66.
The S mint Morgan could’ve failed for eye appeal or perhaps environmental damage.
Thanks for your thoughts and for watching😀
Nice coins! Love pre 33!
3 out of 8 isn't terrible. I just went 1 for 4 on my first sticker submission. You should get some PlastX for those holders. Polish those scratches right out.
Thanks, I did get PlastX, it works well. I guess being able to see the coin better can’t hurt your chances lol
The fact that Barber dime didnt sticker makes me afraid to send anything to CAC
It’s such a high grade with gorgeous color but there’s something that looks like a scratch on the neck, maybe it’s toning, I agree with you if that wasn’t the issue I’m not sure what they didn’t like
I think some folks are missing the point here. The CAC sticker is a second opinion on the grade represented on the holder. CAC is verifying the grade given, or not. They look at the grade only, not how beautiful or ugly the coin is, not at all. If they award your coin with a Gold sticker, you just hit a mini jackpot. The CAC Gold sticker says that the coin was undergraded by at least 1 grade point, fyi.
A B C coins they sticker A and B coins for the grade, a coin could still be a C, passing for the grade but not nice enough for a sticker
Did pretty good on that sub 🎉
@@Numizzmaticaddict thank you, 3/8 isn’t bad. I just uploaded the next cac results video
Nice.
I have 16-D in Fair 2 with the exact same degree of die rotation on the reverse. A sister coin, I suppose.
@@swilliams937 cool!
Also, I've seen AG3s with CAC stickers with less detail and eye appeal than ours.
@@swilliams937 yeah I sold this one last month
I don’t think I’ll ever find a nicer fair2
I’m highly considering this for my 2020 V75 silver Eagle PR70 and my gold Mercury dime SP70 just to see what CAC thinks, they’re both graded by PCGS
Sorry, but that would be a no go. The absolute newest coin that they will sticker is a 1964 MS Quarter. However they do recognize newer 1C Double Dies; 1955, 1969-S, 1970-S, 1971-S, 1972, 1983, 1984 and 1995. In other words, they like the old stuff.
@@rc9660 so CAC wouldn’t even grade anything new?
@@michaelangelobergeron5980 Yes they will "grade" anything new or old. Since PCGS has already graded you coins there's no point in CAC doing so.
We're talking about "Stickering" right now. CAC stickering is an approval of the grade stated on the slab. If the numerical grade is accurate but on the lower end of the grade = no sticker.
Why does everyone think their coins are better than the grade reflects? Anyone have one that believes strongly that their coins is a lower grade? Ever crack it out to get the real 'lower' grade? Humanity is an evil life.
Yes, a draped bust dollar graded xf in an old ANACS that’s probably VF. You’re right, collection bias is real
I have a VG10 Walker in an NGC holder that I know is truly VG8.