Sorry I had no choice in putting photos along side of video, if I didn't the upload would be blocked by youtube, the only way to get it on for you to enjoy
I just want to pass along my thanks to you for doing this. Inasmuch as certain people blocking what I consider to be free speech in favor of money I hope that they rot in hell! I mean what type of uneducated jackass would try and deprive people from seeing one of the best ever (Roger Waters) perform. Certainly I would be more than happy to see him if he came to Austin , Tx......but he does not come here so much. So I keep my eyes and ears on youtube in the hope I can see something great.
Thanks very much, HDPinkFloyd, for posting this. Saw this show/tour in Dallas TX in 2000. Was incredible. Stellar performances by the band. And the sound and mix is great. I have a band playing the Animals album at a local show in November, (on a much smaller scale!) and this clip is very insightful. Thanks again!
You got that right brother. It might be why David Gilmore has left this song out of his live songs. Both David Gilmour and Roger Waters have utmost respect for Jon Carin. Jon is lights out on this one!
Agree that David wisely left this song to Roger. To me David’s rendition of Echoes on Live In Gdańsk (with Richard Wright, Jon Carin, Guy Pratt and some other marvellous musicians) is on par with this wonder, as well as Nick Mason’s version of A Saucerful of Secrets almost two decades later.
My favorite Floyd song...came out my senior year in HS.......it speaks to me of the cruelty of the corporate world.....I left with knives in my back.....started my own business....now over 20 years of success.....I play this song as a reminder of breaking away from those bastards......
That's his name? I have not encountered him before. He's playing Dick Dale tuning, guitar upside down stringwise , but the body up the right way (as in Dick Dale's guitar "Beauty") but the neck on the wrong way (as in Dick Dale's guitar "The Beast") Clearly this man is one of those Uber Talents who sings flawlessly and just knows what every fret will give him whatever the setup with total confidence. And hence, people build him unorthadox guitars just to see what he'll do with them. Who am I kidding....he builds them himself right? I bet he does.
I read this song aloud in class one day and got an applause. I also got an A for it. My teacher Miss Young said it was VERY good! That was back in 1985.
That's the best thing I've seen Roger do since Pros and Cons. Best band he's had - Roger himself on bass, not too splashy on the drums and *RED ALERT RED ALERT* fantastic guitar solos for once - Doyle Bramhall II makes an absolutey standout contribution.
"Who was born in a house full of pain Who was trained not to spit in the fan Who was told what to do by the man Who was broken by trained personnel Who was fitted with collar and chain Who was given a pat on the back Who was breaking away from the pack Who was only a stranger at home Who was ground down in the end Who was found dead on the phone Who was dragged down by the stone."
The double track on this verse (the background vocal you can hear as he sings it) is the lip sync playback track on his 2017-18 US and Them tour, 16 years after this was recorded.
if you look closely Doyle is a lefty playing a righty guutar like off the rack, apparently he learned to play guitar like this... crazy.. i saw this shownon tour; his band is alway a trained kill squad of assasin musicians. fuck up on stage, Roger hands you a knife amd says you know what to do (hes taking 1st joint if your pinky, fuck uo again its your thumb!!!)
Doyle is obviously playing the solo in the lines of Gilmour but he’s not trying to be him for a second and still creating the perfect vibe. Absolutely genius!
Upside down and backwards Doyle on red strat. Very few of us play this way. I do. Doyle gives me a run for my money. Great lead and he is Clapton's rhythm player not to shabby of a gig. I am greenwithenvydoyle
P s. Chris let me write this reply I am guitar Steve from Detroit upside down and backwards kinda like Doyle just not famous yet I was John fives bassist in 83 84 85
Jon Carin simply nailed it! Nailed IT! That is one very hard song to sing just right, and he did it. Perfectly. Man, props for that big time. Then we can get to the absolutely superb job Doyle and Snowy did on the guitars. Jeez, what an outstanding rendition of the song. You could not have asked for a better job. I was transfixed.
I remember when this album came out I was 14 and listened to it on headphones at night, and was mesmerized and lost in the awesome music. It's still my favorite Pink Floyd album of all time.
I remember being 15 in the Christmas of 2010 and my uncle’s gift to me was the Animals CD. Just like you I was so immersed in the music and this song was my absolute favorite to dream to.
I found this clip tonight several hours ago and I can't stop playing it. This must be the song I listen to of all my favorites. Was a great concert in Dallas. Fantastic job. The lead guitars were amazing also.
Amazing version of one of the best songs ever. Doyle plays incredibly well and Jon, what a talent! Vocals, Acoustic guitar and synth solo, everything is top notch!
Well... I don't really think this is a "version" of Dogs. Doyle is playing his parts following the original Gilmour's solos... Which is unfortunate, there's very little room for him to show what a hell of a player he is. I guess Waters learnt his lesson back in the day, when he hired Clapton to play on his tour -and you don't tell Clapton to reproduce Gilmour's solos! So, this time around, he hired Doyle to do just that. After all, he's a pro. As for Snowy, I'm sure he didn't mind playing just like he did with Gilmour and the Floyd, back in '77.
one of my favorite songs from Pink, and the best live performance a ever heard, Doyle Abraham II what a fucking good guitar man, just look at it while he do it
My favourite Pink Floyd song of all time, so dark and mesmerizing ...I always though with Roger Waters shows and the rest of Pink Floyd shows you get the best of both worlds two almost completely different Pink Floyd shows. I have this DVD awesome stuff
Truly a really nice version, the studio version for me is the second after this one cuz has (or had? I talk spanish only, such a bad english xD) that magic from 77' and is the version that everyone surely listen first, is kinda special expierence, how usually people says "The first time will never be forget".
well I fell in love with Dogs then I discovered the Gotta be Crazy demo version xD about Waters and Gilmour I believe it's just dumb to say one it's better than Another. they both have such pure and peculiar talent in they're own particular away. plus they together build the classic Pink Floyd and should not be evaluated in this way. this is why Pink Floyd is so beautiful. it varies. It has mAterial for everyone and every feeling or necessity. so we should be thankful for it's diversity and accept the brilliance of both this members, a brilliance that's brilliant in they're unique way
Man...did that bring me back to when I was younger, hanging with my buddies, having fun, and taking life by the horns. Animals by far is one of my favorite PF albums.
I've listened to this many times. It's one of my favorites. I took me many times over to realize Doyle was playing left handed. Thank You for sharing this video and many others!
Doyle Abraham II should never left this band, he is such a great guitarrist. Get a Richie Kotzen feeling from him, with a little SRV, Hendrix, all that good stuff packed in one player. Just awesome.
I must say that I cried when Roger left Pink Floyd, but after that most of his concerts were The Wall. Yet Pink Floyd continued on. Touring the world over and over. I saw them with Roger, starting Wish You Were Here. Went to all their live shows even after Roger left. The special affects kept getting better. I consider myself lucky to have been a fan of Pink Floyd since their Meddle album.
My Favorite Double Lead of all time and I feel Doyle captures DG's feel beautifully in his solo's (hard for me to say that as DG is one of my absolute favorites) .
All I can say is that this lineup is fantastic. John Carin is amazing. The guitar lineup of Andy Fairweather Low, Snowy White, and Doyle Bramhall is otherworldly.
This is Roger's best tour in my opinion. His best band and this makes me wish Doyle Bramhall II was still with him. A true rock and blues guitarist God.
Jon Carin is amazing, has done great work with Roger AND David for a long time. Obvious throughout this piece is that David Gilmour is irreplaceable. Doyle, Snowy, Joe Doaks, Johnny Q. Public...nobody plays with same soul and mastery as David.
That schtick never sat well with me. It seemed like an obvious disrespectful jab at what the Floyd did-“everything in between the lyrics is filler, the audience is bored just waiting for these tedious musical bits to end,” right, Rog?-and a little disrespectful to what Jon was doing *literally right frakking then*. This show was best enjoyed on CD. Having liked that, when I subsequently bought the DVD, I found it highly offputting.
Me and My pop would watch this over and over when it first came out. He could play the lead just like this. He passed away lil over a year ago... Makes me remember him well. ❤
what a fantastic version of dogs, played and sung so professionaly and respectfully, Roger and Dave have put together some amazing bands over the years
i think this is the best version of this song ever....even bether than original studio version and John Carin did amazing job... Bramhals left handed playing guitar with strings up side down is amazing and sound is massive
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
Sorry I had no choice in putting photos along side
of video, if I didn't the upload would be blocked
by youtube, the only way to get it on for you to enjoy
+ HDPinkFloyd sensational, I have this full show in my notebook
I just want to pass along my thanks to you for doing this. Inasmuch as certain people blocking what I consider to be free speech in favor of money I hope that they rot in hell! I mean what type of uneducated jackass would try and deprive people from seeing one of the best ever (Roger Waters) perform. Certainly I would be more than happy to see him if he came to Austin , Tx......but he does not come here so much. So I keep my eyes and ears on youtube in the hope I can see something great.
Totally
Fair enough, I was wondering about that.
Thanks very much, HDPinkFloyd, for posting this. Saw this show/tour in Dallas TX in 2000. Was incredible. Stellar performances by the band. And the sound and mix is great. I have a band playing the Animals album at a local show in November, (on a much smaller scale!) and this clip is very insightful. Thanks again!
Dogs is a masterpiece. Jon Carin sang David’s party flawlessly. Good stuff. Doyle Brahmhall did an amazing job on guitar as well Loved this.
Is Doyle the lefty?
@@anthonybrockamp9461 yep
Jon Carin: Sings Roger's parts when he plays with David
Jon Carin: Sings David's parts when he plays with Roger
He is really talented.
Of course! 😂
and does keyboard fills for Richard Wright
Roger did a lot of lypsyncig last time I saw him.He appeared as if he were being inconvenienced , lifelessly hunched over on a stool.
@@72timhall He pooped his pants?
Without a doubt, the best rendition of Dogs I have ever heard. There is not even a close second.
You got that right brother. It might be why David Gilmore has left this song out of his live songs. Both David Gilmour and Roger Waters have utmost respect for Jon Carin. Jon is lights out on this one!
Oakland...this isnt even close
@@JacksonPM23 Do you have a link so I can see and hear it for myself?
Agree that David wisely left this song to Roger. To me David’s rendition of Echoes on Live In Gdańsk (with Richard Wright, Jon Carin, Guy Pratt and some other marvellous musicians) is on par with this wonder, as well as Nick Mason’s version of A Saucerful of Secrets almost two decades later.
The best one for me has to the one on the original album with Gilmour singing. Still, this version is amazing.
My favorite Floyd song...came out my senior year in HS.......it speaks to me of the cruelty of the corporate world.....I left with knives in my back.....started my own business....now over 20 years of success.....I play this song as a reminder of breaking away from those bastards......
Favorite song of all time. Favorite album of all time.
In my opinion Animals is PF's best work. And the last one with all the member's real presence.
best lyrics , best gilmour , best floyd !!
Agreed.
what? The Wall was released after and all were there.
That's correct, but The Wall's almost completely created by Roger, and performed by many other musicians.
For me, Dark side of the moon is the best. It's a matter of opinions.
Thanx for sharing, I came all the way from Karachi to Dubai to watch "Roger Waters - In the Flesh - Live". And boy the memory is still fresh
Jon Carin doesn't get the credit he deserves.. He is definitely multi-talented!
Summer Geiser yes he does!!!!
I love Jon. And he does a fantastic job here!
The truly great don{t need to show off
He should go make his own music then
He is a genius in his job
every second , from start to finish ... pure high quality
Doyle Bramhall's playing is nothing short of amazing here. Perfect tone, insane control of the instrument.
Agreed.... A lefty , OF COURSE ! Haaa...just like Hendrix. Jimi couldnt read music...because ? HE DIDNT HAVE TO !
Not just lefty, but it is strung backwards.
He’s amazing wot he can do with a guitar aw wow he plays a string upside down too lol. and he can sing too I love him ❤️
That's his name? I have not encountered him before. He's playing Dick Dale tuning, guitar upside down stringwise , but the body up the right way (as in Dick Dale's guitar "Beauty") but the neck on the wrong way (as in Dick Dale's guitar "The Beast") Clearly this man is one of those Uber Talents who sings flawlessly and just knows what every fret will give him whatever the setup with total confidence. And hence, people build him unorthadox guitars just to see what he'll do with them.
Who am I kidding....he builds them himself right? I bet he does.
I'd only ever seen him play with Clapton. I never knew he could play like that. Amazing.
I'm the biggest David Gilmour fan on the fucking planet but even I have to admit this is really great
coldplayplayer15 yep, Doyle is a great guitarrist, the best that played for Roger in my opinion.
Same opinion here. Awesome guitar work
Hear ya bud
couldn't agree more. guitarist killed it. is he playing with his strings upside down?? high e on top and low e on bottom???
Yea, he is playing a right handed guitar upside down. Unbelievable!
Jon Carin kills it here, one of my favorite versions of Dogs
My favourite too
He sounds just like the record
Meraviglioso Roger...😊😍😘🎶🎸🎶💘💓💋💯💯💯
I read this song aloud in class one day and got an applause. I also got an A for it. My teacher Miss Young said it was VERY good! That was back in 1985.
Met both Waters and Carin... Most intellectual people I've ever met.What a great video. Rodger at his best.
Just turned 50, and this is STILL mesmerizing to me!!!!
Great job all across the board! Doyle Bramhall is a phenomenal guitarist and Jon Carin is an incredible musician.
Jon Carin absolutely crushing this song. Such a joy to watch him play!
Dogs has been stuck in my head for the past week. Ever since I watched Roger live in Mexico I can't get enough of it.
Same here man! I hum it going to and from work!
i was humming it walking downtown the other day, throwing in the odd words....crazy
That keyboard that fullfil the entire stadium and the dog sounds coming out from every corner... FANTASTIC!!!
Jon Carin is incredible. Brilliant guitarist, a keyboard genius and his voice is like honey. No wonder Roger wants him on tour.
That's the best thing I've seen Roger do since Pros and Cons. Best band he's had - Roger himself on bass, not too splashy on the drums and *RED ALERT RED ALERT* fantastic guitar solos for once - Doyle Bramhall II makes an absolutey standout contribution.
Rogers band did a great job on this concert. This was the first time I'd ever heard of Andy Fairweatherlow. Another excellent musician.
+Lee Ross Agree, the best Waters concert he has ever done
"Who was born in a house full of pain
Who was trained not to spit in the fan
Who was told what to do by the man
Who was broken by trained personnel
Who was fitted with collar and chain
Who was given a pat on the back
Who was breaking away from the pack
Who was only a stranger at home
Who was ground down in the end
Who was found dead on the phone
Who was dragged down by the stone."
Beqa Kochauri 👍
Roger Waters is a genius
Am I the only one who thinks this may be about me? Surely not!
holboroman definitely not my friend...it kinda describes my ex as well :/ lol
The double track on this verse (the background vocal you can hear as he sings it) is the lip sync playback track on his 2017-18 US and Them tour, 16 years after this was recorded.
Doyle is such an unbelievably good guitarist. This performance is insane.
what brand is his guitar?
Fender Stratocaster
So effortless
if you look closely Doyle is a lefty playing a righty guutar like off the rack, apparently he learned to play guitar like this... crazy.. i saw this shownon tour; his band is alway a trained kill squad of assasin musicians. fuck up on stage, Roger hands you a knife amd says you know what to do (hes taking 1st joint if your pinky, fuck uo again its your thumb!!!)
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
What a f'n masterpiece. We'll never witness or hear rock music written to the level of this genius again. What a gift to music fans
Doyle is obviously playing the solo in the lines of Gilmour but he’s not trying to be him for a second and still creating the perfect vibe. Absolutely genius!
Upside down and backwards Doyle on red strat. Very few of us play this way. I do. Doyle gives me a run for my money. Great lead and he is Clapton's rhythm player not to shabby of a gig. I am greenwithenvydoyle
P s. Chris let me write this reply I am guitar Steve from Detroit upside down and backwards kinda like Doyle just not famous yet I was John fives bassist in 83 84 85
I am listening to this retired at age 62 in the US. This album blew me away in 1977 when I was a sophomore(10th grade) in High School.
Jon Carin simply nailed it! Nailed IT! That is one very hard song to sing just right, and he did it. Perfectly. Man, props for that big time. Then we can get to the absolutely superb job Doyle and Snowy did on the guitars. Jeez, what an outstanding rendition of the song. You could not have asked for a better job. I was transfixed.
I was there, 2007, incredible concert, Roger pointed at us because we sang this like mad and our neighbours didn't, plus that we were at the fence.
I could never imagine anyone pulling off Dogs without David Gilmour playing. Mind blowing
I remember when this album came out I was 14 and listened to it on headphones at night, and was mesmerized and lost in the awesome music. It's still my favorite Pink Floyd album of all time.
I remember being 15 in the Christmas of 2010 and my uncle’s gift to me was the Animals CD. Just like you I was so immersed in the music and this song was my absolute favorite to dream to.
The guitar solos performance is out of this world!
He has a snowie and the other guy, both plays so good.
Good yes but know one can match Gilmour
@@Kenandlizabeehaven why do Gilmour fans can't spell? Always wondered.
name ?
@@moyjuz6015
Doyle Bramhall 2 solo is unreal
My son and I saw Roger Waters play Pigs and Dogs back to back in Quebec City. Life defining moment.
I found this clip tonight several hours ago and I can't stop playing it. This must be the song I listen to of all my favorites. Was a great concert in Dallas. Fantastic job. The lead guitars were amazing also.
Utterly fantastic! Best version I've seen or heard since the original 1977 tour!
John Carin remarcable. I remember his “state of the Nation”. He was already immense.
Music, words, stage-concepts, al created by Genius Roger. Without Him, there would have been never a Pink Floyd.
Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Black Sabbath, Deep Purple.. we can just be grateful about the existence of these bands...
Great choice
Nazareth
Yes, Emerson, Lake and Palmer
60’s and 70’s bands were the greatest. Just don’t make em like that anymore. Will we ever have great musicians like that again in our lifetime? 😩
@@EnvyBlu we probably have. But the crowd don't like songs like that these days.
My personal favorite live performance of Jon Carin. Great job really.... The man is a machine... A machine which emits progressive melody...
Amazing version of one of the best songs ever. Doyle plays incredibly well and Jon, what a talent! Vocals, Acoustic guitar and synth solo, everything is top notch!
Well... I don't really think this is a "version" of Dogs. Doyle is playing his parts following the original Gilmour's solos... Which is unfortunate, there's very little room for him to show what a hell of a player he is. I guess Waters learnt his lesson back in the day, when he hired Clapton to play on his tour -and you don't tell Clapton to reproduce Gilmour's solos! So, this time around, he hired Doyle to do just that. After all, he's a pro. As for Snowy, I'm sure he didn't mind playing just like he did with Gilmour and the Floyd, back in '77.
what a version of dogs ! wow , John Carin was brilhant in the vocals and also Doyle Branhall on guitar ! amazing job
one of my favorite songs from Pink, and the best live performance a ever heard, Doyle Abraham II what a fucking good guitar man, just look at it while he do it
My favourite Pink Floyd song of all time, so dark and mesmerizing ...I always though with Roger Waters shows and the rest of Pink Floyd shows you get the best of both worlds two almost completely different Pink Floyd shows. I have this DVD awesome stuff
Snowy White and Doyle Bramhall II playing Pink Floyd together. What a piece of music history!
Can't get bored of these songs. I don't think I ever will...
"Sheep" has always been my favorite from "Animals", but this "Dogs" was terrific. Great to see it performed by such a talented array of musicians.
Silent Queue Check Anubis Gate Sheep cover. It blew me away
Minha favorita sempre foi Dogs
This is the best Dogs since the original live in 1977 Big thanks HDPinkFloyd
I think this is far the best version i have heard. Rogers has protected the integrity and this is the result.
Truly a really nice version, the studio version for me is the second after this one cuz has (or had? I talk spanish only, such a bad english xD) that magic from 77' and is the version that everyone surely listen first, is kinda special expierence, how usually people says "The first time will never be forget".
Not always, I love the Pulse version of DOTM as well as the songs that followed except Run like Hell, plus Roger sucks in Wish you were here.
you know little
well I fell in love with Dogs then I discovered the Gotta be Crazy demo version xD about Waters and Gilmour I believe it's just dumb to say one it's better than Another. they both have such pure and peculiar talent in they're own particular away. plus they together build the classic Pink Floyd and should not be evaluated in this way. this is why Pink Floyd is so beautiful. it varies. It has mAterial for everyone and every feeling or necessity. so we should be thankful for it's diversity and accept the brilliance of both this members, a brilliance that's brilliant in they're unique way
The bass guitar at 6:27 ... goosebumps... literally the legend ..Roger water
En mi opinión Dogs es la mejor de Animals y una de las mejores canciones de la historia de la música. Muy infravalorada.
Estoy de acuerdo!
Yo pongo pigs al mismo nivel
La larga duración lo hace desapercibida
Amazing tour !! Love it !! Jon Carim, left hand guitar Doyle Bramhall, Snowy White, Andy Fairweather Low, Graham Broad and the genius.. Roger Waters ♥
totally
Doyle is BADASS !!
perfection Anamgify// i'm grateful i can listen to roger at his best//
I agree Clive Weiner !!!
Clive Weiner I agree !!
Pink Floyd es la mejor banda de toda la historia tengo 63 años a un la sigo escuchando siempre son famosos no pasan de moda
Man...did that bring me back to when I was younger, hanging with my buddies, having fun, and taking life by the horns. Animals by far is one of my favorite PF albums.
Wow. Jon Carin really did a solid job signing Glamour's part Overall a tremendous rendition of these songs. I really enjoyed the hell out of it.
Seen the Animals tour in Cleveland Stadium in 77. One hell of a show..opend up.with a jet just missing the stadium. Very Cool
thanks, the best live version of Dogs, and I love the musicians he had
The best version! Thank you!
John Carin. The unofficial Pink Floyd member.
I think you have to write your own parts to be a member.
ThomasWilliamsMusic he’s credited as having helped write “Learning to Fly”
@ThomasWilliamsMusic Polly Samson wrote High Hopes, but she isn't part of the band.
No, and John Carin would agree. Floyd is set in stone untouched since the early 70s after Syd left and remains so.
2021. Its been a hell of a ride. Thank you Roger.
I've listened to this many times. It's one of my favorites. I took me many times over to realize Doyle was playing left handed. Thank You for sharing this video and many others!
Doyle Abraham II should never left this band, he is such a great guitarrist. Get a Richie Kotzen feeling from him, with a little SRV, Hendrix, all that good stuff packed in one player. Just awesome.
You mean Doyle Bramhall II.
I must say that I cried when Roger left Pink Floyd, but after that most of his concerts were The Wall. Yet Pink Floyd continued on. Touring the world over and over. I saw them with Roger, starting Wish You Were Here. Went to all their live shows even after Roger left. The special affects kept getting better. I consider myself lucky to have been a fan of Pink Floyd since their Meddle album.
Nice! 💟I LOVE RODGER WATER .. 💟LOVE ..The final Cut.. i know every lyric..it was my fav. since high school
I really love Richard Gere's playing on the bass here.
That's Roger Gere... Richard's brother ;)
Tomás Cullen lol, funny.
Around the same time, Roger Waters starred in The Mothman Prophecies...
separated at birth
Richard Gere "Wishes He Were Here".
My Favorite Double Lead of all time and I feel Doyle captures DG's feel beautifully in his solo's (hard for me to say that as DG is one of my absolute favorites) .
Dogs is one of their best for sure.Awesome song.Great performance and vid!
All I can say is that this lineup is fantastic. John Carin is amazing. The guitar lineup of Andy Fairweather Low, Snowy White, and Doyle Bramhall is otherworldly.
OK.......just watched it again.....One last "WOW" for the road. Damn this was good. Thanks for putting it up here!
The most incredible thing I’ve ever seen. And he’s playing the solos upside down!!!!
Sir Roger waters , what a great joy , hats 🎩 off 🌹❤️
Must be one of the most world class performances ever played live in history
damn that singer nailed it.
He also nails all the keyboard sounds.
My First Roger Waters concert. In the Flesh Tour, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 2000. This is by far the best live version of Dogs I ever seen.
Roger knows how to put a band together!
This was a very good video. Awesome As a matter of fact.. Some very talented performers on stage.. Thanks for posting.. GOD BLESS..
Dogs....the greatest rock song of all time. Pure genius.
Dogs is such an appropriate song for the era we live in. What a performance !
Loving the Jon Carin lead vocals. Very effective with this particular track.
That is an outrageously great version of Dogs. Thanks for posting, really applies to these crazy times.
I’m actually very impressed by Doyle Bramhall II. He nailed it!
His blues background is the key
This is Roger's best tour in my opinion. His best band and this makes me wish Doyle Bramhall II was still with him. A true rock and blues guitarist God.
Serious respect to Jon Carin, that's some effort!
Jon Carin smashing this on vocals / guitar AND Synth! Brilliant job.
I love how left handed Doyle Bramhall and right handed Snowy White playing guitar solo together 🙏
Absolutely stunning performance, in my opinion the very best of all!!! Wooooohooo what a journey!
Jon Carin is amazing, has done great work with Roger AND David for a long time. Obvious throughout this piece is that David Gilmour is irreplaceable. Doyle, Snowy, Joe Doaks, Johnny Q. Public...nobody plays with same soul and mastery as David.
David Gilmour FOREVER !! ❤
A card game and a drink during the interlude. I heart Roger waters.
That schtick never sat well with me. It seemed like an obvious disrespectful jab at what the Floyd did-“everything in between the lyrics is filler, the audience is bored just waiting for these tedious musical bits to end,” right, Rog?-and a little disrespectful to what Jon was doing *literally right frakking then*. This show was best enjoyed on CD. Having liked that, when I subsequently bought the DVD, I found it highly offputting.
@@simondodd918 You make a good point.
@@simondodd918 pra você, então, naõ deveria existir opera-rock? The Wall é uma piada? hahahah
What a beautiful live, emotional solo….thanks roger🙏🙏
I love davids solo but apart from comfortably numb and a few more this has to be one of the best solo of all time so much emotion
Superbe morceau d'anthologie de l'album ''Animals''...! Merci beaucoup pour cette version ! 💖👏👏👍👍💐💐
That must be as close to a flawless performance as one could get!! Thanks for the upload
gave me goose bumps...Animals is in my top 3 albums of all time.
Well done performance! Doyle Bramhall II killed that solo at @6:30!
Me and My pop would watch this over and over when it first came out. He could play the lead just like this. He passed away lil over a year ago... Makes me remember him well. ❤
Gilmour's vocals and guitar are unmatched
Yes, for sure. But we still bring Bach and Shakespeare on stages, because we must change...
Ya I’m wishing he was actually singing his parts
A talented bunch of men that make beautiful music together x
No doubts!!!! Best version since the original!!!! Thanks for upload....;-)
what a fantastic version of dogs, played and sung so professionaly and respectfully, Roger and Dave have put together some amazing bands over the years
i think this is the best version of this song ever....even bether than original studio version and John Carin did amazing job... Bramhals left handed playing guitar with strings up side down is amazing and sound is massive
Right there with ya, amazing performance and energy!
Agreed 100%
Amazing !!
Best version IMO! Carin vocals are spot on!