I love how Agent Stone has become such a fan favorite. He could've been the standard henchman that no one really cares for, but Lee really made the character so lovable and charming
Thank you for giving love to Tom and Maddie I genuinely love their dynamic with each other and the Sonic cast. So many ppl forget them and only praise Stone and Eggman. Which I find sad because they are so central to these movies. They also easily have some of the funniest jokes in the movies next to Eggman. Especially in movie 1. Also wanna mention that they are a birracial couple and it’s not made into a big deal or anything. They just love each other. Because that is a normal thing and certain people and kids should learn that it is normal.
I can't wait to see our GOAT: Wade Whipple return in Sonic 4 and team up with Shadow to become Super Wade and Super Shadow and destroy Metal Sonic once and for all.
Before you start of the list, let’s all agree the WADE is the undisputed goat of the movie franchise and that he deserves his own tier, the FLAMES OF DISASTER tier. Who’s with me?
I actually feel bad for Agent Stone. In all three Sonic movies, he "lost" Robotnik in a plethora of ways (Sent to the Mushroom Planet, seemingly perishes within the Death Egg Robot wreckage and sacrifices himself to destroy the Ark after he gives his speech to Stone specifically).
Movie Shadow is the obvious contender for number one. He’s done absolutely perfectly well it’s amazing. Movie Knuckles tho, has been one of my favs. He restored Knuckles’ integrity and not make him a dummy.
Gotta give love to Kid Cudi too, from making a song for Sonic 2 and to play one of the funniest but awesome character in Knuckles. Hopefully to see him return as Agent Mason soon.
If Agent Stone ever gets his own show, you know I'm flipping the On switch for Paramount+ just to watch it. I can actually imagine the main villain of the show being another one of Eggman lackeys/henchmen from other games and media.
Wade Whipple should be in the S Rank lists. He's the true GOAT of the Sonic movies. We are getting the Year of Wade, The Year of Flames of Disaster! The iconic scene where he turns into Super Wade was total peak!!!
7:42 Technically, Patrick still has SpongeBob in his show. 10:23 Stone kinda had that moment in the 2nd movie's prequel comic where he slowly took out the coffee shop's employees.
something i never understood about the movie sonic "hate" is that... why are people acting like sonic isnt already goofy like he is in the movies? the only difference is instead of pop culture references, game sonic says goofy one liners. Thats literally half his character! Shadows over here reflecting on how fucked up his past was, and in walks sonic and goes *"AW YEAH, TIME TO ROCK AND ROLL! You coming Shadow?"* AND THEN JUST FUCKING LEAVES
I pretty much agree with this list beside Geralds placement. I would put him in S tier. I think he was better as a character who had a more clear nuanced motivation than Eggman. I also just love the costume and voice, just peak Jim Carrey right there. I also think Maria still might be sick but are just saving it for hopefully a Shadow movie to make that more impactful.
Fadel Gamescage, The GALL, the pure NERVE you have to place THE Wade Whipple, Guardian of the Master Emerald and eternal ally to Knuckles the Echidna in C Tier, is not only shocking, but appalling, be prepared Mr. Gamescage, as you have incurred the wrath of not only me, but all the dedicated Whipple Heads out there
My favorite movie sonic movie characters of all time has to be a tie between sonic and shadow cuz they both have simular backstorys that they have lost a very special someone and i really like that paralel and ik movie sonics personality fells nothing like game sonics but i feel movie sonic is almost my favorite version of the character but over all i like most of the movie characters and shadow is just RAW!!!!!!!!!!!
My S tier eggman shadow knuckles sonic agent stone I generally love all of them and Tom Maddie and Maria tails are all great to A tier Tom at the top of A
Shadow is actually perfect in this movie. Also the villain at the end of the Knuckles show is called “The Buyer” and we only know that because one of the Knuckles show posters calls him that. He never gets name dropped in the show. Actual waste of a character.
I agree with what you said about Sonic in the post credit scene. His dialogue felt more like his game counterpart. Also, I'm happy my guy knuckles is in the S tier, love him💪
I'm still mixed on movie Sonic. I understand he's a different interpretation and they want him to have more development than his game counterpart, but he's definitely the X factor that makes me feel like these movies are less for families and more for kids specifically. He's a tik-tok zoomer, basically. The Patrick Star comparison is super fitting. Comic relief characters work best when they're bouncing off of the more serious characters, but rarely as the star. Unless your names are Timon and Pumbaa, you're not carrying a show alone. For me I would actually rank Robotnik in different spots between movies 1 and 2-3. He feels like a completely different person in movie 1 compared to the latter two. It's like the difference between Heath Ledger Joker and Mark Hamill Joker.
Id honestly put Agent Stone S tier cuz for who he is, hes really great for a companion character, tho if they rlly want to give him a proper character I wouldn't mind if they made a Shadow TV show and have Stone be the equivalent of Wade cuz I think them 2 would really work well together and maybe even highlight Stone in a way we haven't seen cuz he's always tied to Eggman and they always make him a joke which isn't necessarily bad but hes not like Wade where he'd work outside of being a comic relief character.
Hey Fadel, what do you think of how Sonic the Hedgehog 3 (2024) adapted Sonic Adventure 2? Was it better? Was it worse? Was it what you expected? Or was it better than what you expected? For me, it was honestly a great rewrite and while it had a lot of comedy and humor, the main message and themes shined through. In the original Adventure 2, Sonic was not vengeful and I felt like that inclusion in the movie made Live and Learn make even more sense. Overall, it was a great movie and I saw it twice! Maria's death was not as graphic as it was in Shadow Generations, but I thought the emotional depth they gave to both Shadow and Maria made it work out perfectly.
@GamesCage I'm sorry if editing my comment removed your heart. I always hate having to edit my own comments because it automatically removes the heart which is so dumb that TH-cam hasn't done anything to change this.
MOVIE SONIC IS BEST SONIC he's cool funny adorable and sassy he's an adhd teenager who will be the first to fight you if your causing trouble and he'll be the first to help you change for the better i love his voice his design everything about him i might have a problem 😅
wades mom has a great dynamic with wade and feels like a genuine caring mom especially in the last episode with that heart to heart genuinely what are you on
tbh i think commander walter should be lower than b cuz i still don't forgive him and GUN for what they did to shadow but everything else i agree with. Good tier rank list
You made the right choice putting Wanda at the very bottom. Like, she adds basically NOTHING of substance to the story and does essentially NOTHING! FBI training, MY ASS, YOU COWARD! Like, if the mom brought the gloves on her own, it would have changed literally *nothing* in the story, like how if, in Frozen, if you take out Hans and his plan and replace him with basically anyone else, essentially nothing changes! Oh, she got a hit in? He was already down and out!
Gerald for me is an unfortunate D rank. Turning such a tragic character into a mustache twirling comic relief villain with like a little bit of a sinister side (ruins any kind of menace he briefly had when he popped a jetpack), is such an unnecessary change that clearly just came from the movie team wanting 2 Jim Carreys. Something they still could've had, if they still let Jim play a more game accurate Gerald, which would've also allowed him to flex more of his acting abilities, cause it seems some people watching these movies only know him for comedic roles.
Nah, movie sonic was really pushing it in movie 3. Not a single line got me to laugh or get goosebumps. It just didn’t work for me. I’d say B tier maybe Doesn’t help I’m just used to Ben Schwartz at this point and how he handles his characters. No disrespect or shade to the guy, but he feels p type cast wit how most of his characters are the same guy lol.
Maddie is top tier for the simple reason that we can predict what character will appear in the post-credits scene based on her clothes. Also Wade is S rank.
I love how Agent Stone has become such a fan favorite. He could've been the standard henchman that no one really cares for, but Lee really made the character so lovable and charming
HES SUCH A STANDOUT
It’s so cool to see people making fanart of Stone in the games
How could you forget the most important character, "Priest with a gun in the Bible"?
FUCK
I didn’t know I’d really appreciate Tom as a character. He’s a great Mentor Figure to Sonic and Sonic calling him “Dad” always gets me in the feels
HES FIRE
Agent Stone deserves his own tier at the top
YEAAAHH
*amy hasn’t even said a word yet we already putting her on sonics level*
THATS THE POWER OF AMY
YESSSIIIIRRR
THIS LIST DIDNT HAVE PACHAMAC I JUST REALIZED, BUT I’D PUT THAT MFER IN D. WHAT THEY DO TO MY MANS.
you also forgot longclaw........ rip owl mommy
Thank you for giving love to Tom and Maddie
I genuinely love their dynamic with each other and the Sonic cast.
So many ppl forget them and only praise Stone and Eggman. Which I find sad because they are so central to these movies.
They also easily have some of the funniest jokes in the movies next to Eggman. Especially in movie 1.
Also wanna mention that they are a birracial couple and it’s not made into a big deal or anything. They just love each other.
Because that is a normal thing and certain people and kids should learn that it is normal.
TOM AND MADDIE >>>
I can't wait to see our GOAT: Wade Whipple return in Sonic 4 and team up with Shadow to become Super Wade and Super Shadow and destroy Metal Sonic once and for all.
YES.
HECK YEAAAAAAH
I think we can all agree that shadow is "perfection"
MHM
2:22 “Beatle character poses
Ah yes, my favorite fictional characters, the Beatles.
LMAOOOO
No matter how people feel about these films, they crew did Knuckles and Shadow justice and probably their best interpretation in the franchise
@@dylanvo6394 absolutely. These movies have great depictions of Knuckles and Shadow
YEP
“Revenge Guac”🦔🥑
revenge guac
Revenge Guack!
Before you start of the list, let’s all agree the WADE is the undisputed goat of the movie franchise and that he deserves his own tier, the FLAMES OF DISASTER tier. Who’s with me?
SO TRUE
YES!! THE FLAMES OF DISASTER SUPREMACY!!!
Imagine Wade and Big together, the most unstoppable duo.
@@kevinkong64 Better, they team up and become Super Wade and Super Big
The little girl is the one who beat wade in the bowling match then teamed up with him
LMAOOOOO SUCH A NOTHING CHARACTER
@@GamesCageHop. Off. Susie.
I actually feel bad for Agent Stone. In all three Sonic movies, he "lost" Robotnik in a plethora of ways (Sent to the Mushroom Planet, seemingly perishes within the Death Egg Robot wreckage and sacrifices himself to destroy the Ark after he gives his speech to Stone specifically).
HE DOESNT DESERVE ALL THIS SADNESSS
Movie Shadow is the obvious contender for number one. He’s done absolutely perfectly well it’s amazing. Movie Knuckles tho, has been one of my favs. He restored Knuckles’ integrity and not make him a dummy.
Gotta give love to Kid Cudi too, from making a song for Sonic 2 and to play one of the funniest but awesome character in Knuckles. Hopefully to see him return as Agent Mason soon.
HES TOOO GOOOD
If Agent Stone ever gets his own show, you know I'm flipping the On switch for Paramount+ just to watch it.
I can actually imagine the main villain of the show being another one of Eggman lackeys/henchmen from other games and media.
YESSSIR
That little girl you put in F was the girl who beat Wade in bowling at the start of the Knuckles show LMAOOO idk why she's on the list
That’s so funny LMAAOOOOO
Knuckles and Shadow in top tier
1. Agent Stone
2. Agent Stone
3. Agent Stone
4. Agent Stone
5. Agent Stone
Not sure but it I think you really like Wade
@@Winder_Storm You mean Agent Stone
Wade Whipple should be in the S Rank lists. He's the true GOAT of the Sonic movies. We are getting the Year of Wade, The Year of Flames of Disaster! The iconic scene where he turns into Super Wade was total peak!!!
THATS TRUE
I think my S tiers are Shadow and Knuckles ❤️🖤
YEP
24:54 😭 this got me dying don’t
SKSKSSKSKS
Wade below S tier absolutely hurt me on another level
LMAO
KNUCKLES MY BOY IN S RANK, HECK-YEAH🎉🎉🎉 ily❤
HELL YES
The fact that Director Rockwell (Krysten Ritter) isn't on this list speaks VOLUMES on how much of a nothing burger and forgettable her character is.
LMAAOOOOOOO
Time for another wholesome friendly discussion in the comments 😊
7:42 Technically, Patrick still has SpongeBob in his show.
10:23 Stone kinda had that moment in the 2nd movie's prequel comic where he slowly took out the coffee shop's employees.
I'm glad you put my goat Knuckles in S
PEAK
shoutout to jojo who gave sonic his shoes
Fadel, you gotta make a video on how Wade Whipple become famous in the Sonic franchise after the iconic Flames of Disaster!!!
LMAOOOOO
Tom Alone: A Rank
Maddie Alone: A Rank
Tom & Maddie Together: SSS Rank 12/10 Best Power Couple
something i never understood about the movie sonic "hate" is that... why are people acting like sonic isnt already goofy like he is in the movies? the only difference is instead of pop culture references, game sonic says goofy one liners. Thats literally half his character!
Shadows over here reflecting on how fucked up his past was, and in walks sonic and goes *"AW YEAH, TIME TO ROCK AND ROLL! You coming Shadow?"* AND THEN JUST FUCKING LEAVES
Agreed LMAOOOO
I pretty much agree with this list beside Geralds placement. I would put him in S tier. I think he was better as a character who had a more clear nuanced motivation than Eggman. I also just love the costume and voice, just peak Jim Carrey right there. I also think Maria still might be sick but are just saving it for hopefully a Shadow movie to make that more impactful.
Fadel Gamescage, The GALL, the pure NERVE you have to place THE Wade Whipple, Guardian of the Master Emerald and eternal ally to Knuckles the Echidna in C Tier, is not only shocking, but appalling, be prepared Mr. Gamescage, as you have incurred the wrath of not only me, but all the dedicated Whipple Heads out there
My favorite movie sonic movie characters of all time has to be a tie between sonic and shadow cuz they both have simular backstorys that they have lost a very special someone and i really like that paralel and ik movie sonics personality fells nothing like game sonics but i feel movie sonic is almost my favorite version of the character but over all i like most of the movie characters and shadow is just RAW!!!!!!!!!!!
My S tier eggman shadow knuckles sonic agent stone I generally love all of them and Tom Maddie and Maria tails are all great to A tier Tom at the top of A
GOOD TASTE
@@GamesCage Thank you
Agent Stone is the goat! Really hope he gets his moment in the fourth movie
Rachel ended up being a great character and very useful
SHES COOL
Shadow and Sonic are obviously S tier.
TOP
Agent Stone is the GOAT!
Tom and Maddie are awesome!
Wade is a cool funny guy!
I wonder if Eggman counts or if we’re counting Jim Carrey on his own.
If Knuckles is in the top tier it’s a good list
:D
Shadow is actually perfect in this movie. Also the villain at the end of the Knuckles show is called “The Buyer” and we only know that because one of the Knuckles show posters calls him that. He never gets name dropped in the show. Actual waste of a character.
METAL SONIC even tho he ain’t there is instantly an S just on his looks alone
LMAO AGREE
I agree with what you said about Sonic in the post credit scene. His dialogue felt more like his game counterpart. Also, I'm happy my guy knuckles is in the S tier, love him💪
yessssirr!!!!
Long Claw doesn’t exist, guys 😢
FUCK
Knuckles is definitely my favourite character in the movies. Can't wait to see more of shadow
EZ
I'm still mixed on movie Sonic. I understand he's a different interpretation and they want him to have more development than his game counterpart, but he's definitely the X factor that makes me feel like these movies are less for families and more for kids specifically. He's a tik-tok zoomer, basically.
The Patrick Star comparison is super fitting. Comic relief characters work best when they're bouncing off of the more serious characters, but rarely as the star. Unless your names are Timon and Pumbaa, you're not carrying a show alone.
For me I would actually rank Robotnik in different spots between movies 1 and 2-3. He feels like a completely different person in movie 1 compared to the latter two. It's like the difference between Heath Ledger Joker and Mark Hamill Joker.
Yessir. Knuckles, Shadow and Eggman are S tier 🔥
YEP
That thumbnail is wild
Not gonna lie, you got me with that thumbnail. But you came through. I agree with your rankings. All hail Shadow!
Id honestly put Agent Stone S tier cuz for who he is, hes really great for a companion character, tho if they rlly want to give him a proper character I wouldn't mind if they made a Shadow TV show and have Stone be the equivalent of Wade cuz I think them 2 would really work well together and maybe even highlight Stone in a way we haven't seen cuz he's always tied to Eggman and they always make him a joke which isn't necessarily bad but hes not like Wade where he'd work outside of being a comic relief character.
I lowkey like wade tbh I’d put him in B, didn’t expect him to show up the way he did in movie 3 that was hilarious
NMMMMMMMM
Yeah this is a neat list I would pretty much do the same.
Btw on 24:54 That's the girl who played with Wade in the Bowling championship LOL
Hey Fadel, what do you think of how Sonic the Hedgehog 3 (2024) adapted Sonic Adventure 2? Was it better? Was it worse? Was it what you expected? Or was it better than what you expected?
For me, it was honestly a great rewrite and while it had a lot of comedy and humor, the main message and themes shined through. In the original Adventure 2, Sonic was not vengeful and I felt like that inclusion in the movie made Live and Learn make even more sense. Overall, it was a great movie and I saw it twice!
Maria's death was not as graphic as it was in Shadow Generations, but I thought the emotional depth they gave to both Shadow and Maria made it work out perfectly.
I talked about it in my reviews you can watch! But I loved it. I think that is AS good as a live action adaption of SA2 can be
@GamesCage I'm sorry if editing my comment removed your heart. I always hate having to edit my own comments because it automatically removes the heart which is so dumb that TH-cam hasn't done anything to change this.
I'm going to say it for real this time, Movie Sonic is absolutely the goat!!!🔥🔥🔥
Sonic, Knuckles, Shadow, Eggman and Stone are my favorites!
Honorable Mentions: Tails, Tom, Maddie, Maria and Gerald
MOVIE SONIC IS BEST SONIC he's cool funny adorable and sassy he's an adhd teenager who will be the first to fight you if your causing trouble and he'll be the first to help you change for the better i love his voice his design everything about him i might have a problem 😅
HES SVERY COOLL
@@GamesCage I'll take it lol
Jojo the one to give sonic shoes
You forgot Pachacamac
FUCK
Where would he be?
Hey fadel can we just get a Agent Stone tier at the top?
ALMOST
wades mom has a great dynamic with wade and feels like a genuine caring mom especially in the last episode with that heart to heart genuinely what are you on
tbh i think commander walter should be lower than b cuz i still don't forgive him and GUN for what they did to shadow but everything else i agree with. Good tier rank list
YEAAAA
He forgot to rank Metal Sonic😭
NO I DIDNT WATCH TILL THE END COWARD
Amazing tiert list
ITS BEEN 4 MINUTES
😂
hey dad
Hello son
You made the right choice putting Wanda at the very bottom. Like, she adds basically NOTHING of substance to the story and does essentially NOTHING! FBI training, MY ASS, YOU COWARD! Like, if the mom brought the gloves on her own, it would have changed literally *nothing* in the story, like how if, in Frozen, if you take out Hans and his plan and replace him with basically anyone else, essentially nothing changes! Oh, she got a hit in? He was already down and out!
ASS CHARACTER
Movie shadow was the goat
YEP
10:39 “unique” you mean GAY🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈
SKIPPED TO THE END TBH STONE IS S RANK UNSUB+SENDING GUN
LMAAOAOAOOAOA
Gerald for me is an unfortunate D rank. Turning such a tragic character into a mustache twirling comic relief villain with like a little bit of a sinister side (ruins any kind of menace he briefly had when he popped a jetpack), is such an unnecessary change that clearly just came from the movie team wanting 2 Jim Carreys. Something they still could've had, if they still let Jim play a more game accurate Gerald, which would've also allowed him to flex more of his acting abilities, cause it seems some people watching these movies only know him for comedic roles.
you did not watch sonic 3 if thats your takeaway
No Rockwell 👎
FUCK
In my point of view, can we all agree Wade should be bottom tier of the list?
Hell no. Ya don’t diss the goat Wade.
NOPE NOPE NOPE
I put him in C LMAOO
@@GamesCage LMFAOOOOOOOOO
Nah, movie sonic was really pushing it in movie 3. Not a single line got me to laugh or get goosebumps. It just didn’t work for me. I’d say B tier maybe
Doesn’t help I’m just used to Ben Schwartz at this point and how he handles his characters. No disrespect or shade to the guy, but he feels p type cast wit how most of his characters are the same guy lol.
😔
Maddie is top tier for the simple reason that we can predict what character will appear in the post-credits scene based on her clothes.
Also Wade is S rank.