@Mausi X because it takes longer to master and great dedication people tend to think it is superior to what it is a contrast to "4 chord songs". But who are we to judge, right?
This work, especially the last 2 minutes outlining those chord shifts and changes to make it easier for the listener to understand, is truly one of Geru's greatest achievements I think.
This is one of my favourite violin concertos by Vivaldi! I've only heard one recording (the one by Il Giardino Armonico) that actually incorporated Bach's solos into their performance of this piece.
@@usuarioanonimo5215 Violin concerto in D, RV 208 (Grosso Mogul) You can watch the Il Giardino Armonico version here: th-cam.com/video/VDdHsK5y_Fo/w-d-xo.html
UTMOST RESPECT FOR GERUBACH 🎉🎉🎉 this is genuine real fair effective MUSICAL EDUCATION 😮😮 to fully inform the Listeners on the Genesis of a Masterpiece : the original Concerto by Vivaldi , and the wonderful Arrangement/Transcription by Bach ❤❤ GREAT WORK as always , dear GERUBACH 💎💥💎
Bach seems to have changed the rhythm slightly, but I’m not sure why. I suspect he wanted to make it slightly easier to play-Vivaldi’s version is extremely virtuosic and has the tempo marking of “Grave recitativo”, so there’s a lot of rubato implied. I really like Enrico Onofri’s interpretation on the violin.
I am not musically trained and seeing seeing how the organist runs throuh 3 seperate complex lines simultaneously seems absolutely super human.
@Mausi X because it takes longer to master and great dedication people tend to think it is superior to what it is a contrast to "4 chord songs". But who are we to judge, right?
@Mausi X You're so right. Everyone has a different taste in music. People like what they like.
@Mausi X Music is not merely "different" it is inferior, or it is superior.
@@fernwehn5925 ikr
It feels superhuman when you're doing it...Playing the organ makes you feel powerful...
It just takes years of work...
Truly one of the best of Bach’s Vivaldi transcriptions imo!
Vivaldi foi tão genial que até Bach se viu na necessidade de traduzir para órgão as obras do mestre italiano
The conclusion to that solo, my god! Such intense speed! Your presentation of the outlined chords below the score was incredibly helpful, Gerubach.
This work, especially the last 2 minutes outlining those chord shifts and changes to make it easier for the listener to understand, is truly one of Geru's greatest achievements I think.
I understand why Bach chose it! Got a chance to show his skill.
Awesome. Makes me really want to take up organ lessons.
+Utstein Productions: You and me both, dude.....
This is one of my favourite violin concertos by Vivaldi!
I've only heard one recording (the one by Il Giardino Armonico) that actually incorporated Bach's solos into their performance of this piece.
which violin concert by vivaldi is this
@@usuarioanonimo5215 Violin concerto in D, RV 208 (Grosso Mogul)
You can watch the Il Giardino Armonico version here: th-cam.com/video/VDdHsK5y_Fo/w-d-xo.html
Wonderful upload ! Really makes you understand the technicity of the piece ! I was glued to the video from start to end !
Wow that's a fantastic recording, the freedom and musicality really helped it make more sense to me than others.
Complimenti per l'ottimo lavoro. Bellissimi gli accordi esplicitati nel terzo movimento. Grazie
Probably one of my favorites so far.
One of your best uploads!
BWV 594 - Organ Concerto in C major
0:24 1st moviment.
6:54 2nd moviment.
9:22 3th moviment.
UTMOST RESPECT FOR GERUBACH 🎉🎉🎉 this is genuine real fair effective MUSICAL EDUCATION 😮😮 to fully inform the Listeners on the Genesis of a Masterpiece : the original Concerto by Vivaldi , and the wonderful Arrangement/Transcription by Bach ❤❤ GREAT WORK as always , dear GERUBACH 💎💥💎
I really Love the Part at 3:35 - 3:46 :)
The solo would sound interesting on one of those old North German and Dutch organs of the late 1600 - early 1700s
Wonderful!
Super! The best I've ever heard! ❤❤❤
Dos grandes genios del barroco, juntos!
That transition around 2:00 was super buttery
increible
Und noch ein WUNDER !!! Tepper Michael.
Bravo bravo bravo
I fvcking love the organ
The solo is so insane
wow...
Never seen so many demisemiquavers in an adagio before.
@@ultrad-rex1389 uhh, demisemiquaver = 32nd note
I invite you to look at Bach's violin sonatas from his set of 3 sonatas and partitas, if you think that was a lot.
Bach seems to have changed the rhythm slightly, but I’m not sure why. I suspect he wanted to make it slightly easier to play-Vivaldi’s version is extremely virtuosic and has the tempo marking of “Grave recitativo”, so there’s a lot of rubato implied. I really like Enrico Onofri’s interpretation on the violin.
@Ultra D-Rex demisemiquaver = 32nd note
I bet Hilary Hahn could play the entire organ part. On the violin!
Wow!
Gerubach I wait on " Acht Kleine Präludien und Fugen ".
Zbyt proste!
Is it Vivaldi season on this channel or something? Not that I'm complaining, there's just been a lot of Vivaldi arrangements of late.
nvm
He's doing Bach's Concertos right now.
would u upload bwv974 plz
I'd love to hear it played on a Doppio Borgato Pedal Piano
Why does the title page say Violin Concerto in D?
Because is a transcription of il grosso mogul by Vivaldi
Sheets?
.. so so , make me know , Vivaldi is the real engine behind them all ? ? ? :D D :D thank you sir .
It’s like grosso mogul
Dio mio com'e complicato - ma bello
jesus christ the third movement
Shazam lied to me, yet again. Thank you for nothing Shazam.
Explain
Shazam is a song identification app, so I'm pretty sure that it didn't recognize the song well or something
I can't quite put my finger into it but there's something non-Bachlike in this piece.
That's because it was written by Vivaldi and rearranged by Bach
Both wonderful composers
probably the constant repetition - very Vivaldi, not very Bach
I though the opening was very Händellian. 0:35 reminds me of Hallelujah a little bit.
It is right-in-your-face non-Bachlike!
I feel like this comment was a joke
The organ concerti are not among my favorites. Thanks for sharing.
... not a fan of unrestrained rubato in quick baroque mvts, especially at the beginning of a measure.
The only thing not sublime about this is the bass at 5:26
These concerti are probably my least favorite of his organ music.