In spite of his technical misses, I love his interpretation. He plays more passionately than other artitists, especially in the parts where I think it should be.
such a criminally underrated piece of chopin's, and this interpretation is by far my favourite. played with such passion and such a high level of understanding of the piece. an absolutely beautiful and brilliant interpretation of one of chopin's most underrated yet (in my opinion) one of his greatest achievements
My god, what a performance. Spectacular. Its easy to see why this piece by Chopin isn't commonly played. This young man shows what true virtuosity is all about.
It's supposed to be easier than both the 2nd and 3rd piano sonata and the 4th Ballade. An 8 out of 9 in difficulty according to G.Henle, while the Sonatas and the last Ballade are a 9 out of 9. And you do not have to be a super virtuoso to play this. There's a very decent recording by Brazilian amateur pianist Tiago Mondini de Souza on TH-cam - who actually takes more risky tempo choices than this pianist.
@@classicallpvault Are you a pianist? If you are a pianist, you should know that tempo choices are not for tecnique possibilities but for interpretation, keyboard, room acoustics…
Not one of Chopin’s better known works but beautifully conceived and executed; every interpretation of it I have heard is unique as if it really belongs to whatever pianist is playing it. The ending of course is somehow striking and yet unexpected, as if the conclusion was a work of its own. I did read that Chopin himself was quite pleased with it.
It was Chopin's desire to play Op. 46 on his return to his beloved Poland finally free from the invaders. His wish did not come true as he died young, and this masterpiece is one of the least performed pieces by the Polish genius. Absurd, a mystery.
Definitely has great power and control. But he has lots of effects which sometimes don't make musical sense. He knows how to play, but doesn't yet understand what's going on in the piece, so the effects have a superficial excitement which sometimes goes against what the music is saying. Also, maybe the miking is off, or maybe he's left-handed, but too often the left hand overpowers the right.
I'd say he was fine till 8:22 - and then the performance lost interpretative cohesion. Until that point, I was very impressed by his playing. At that juncture, just a little restraint and control would have brought out the underlying pathos and heroic undercurrent of the piece in a deeper way, and what followed would have been so much more meaningful. Perhaps one simply needs more life experience to understand such nuances...
you sound like a wise and intelligent person. im hungry for such a friendship :$ can we start chatting or mailing somewhere about classical music? i do also compose classical music, but i dont even have much listening experience. i would be very happy with a response. thank you
Brian Ganz does a very nice performance of this piece. This guy is obviously very talented, and who am I to judge, but the last few minutes sound like the pianist is frustrated.
I think he actually has musical potential, but that banging and metallic out of control chord tones just don’t work Chopin, Liszt perhaps but not Chopin..
Listened a lot more recordings of this, and now I kind of agree. Going back to this performance, and it's really not very great. But still not terrible.
Bold choice to play the Allegro de Concert!
Instablaster
Interessante ritrovarti qui, per casualità, ed a distanza mia di tempo, Emiliano....Chopiniano nascosto!
One of my favourite Chopin works played with a lovely sense of phrasing.
I was looking for some rare Chopin I'd never heard, and look what I stumbled on to. Wow!
cool, good found.
Have you listened to op 14?
In spite of his technical misses, I love his interpretation. He plays more passionately than other artitists, especially in the parts where I think it should be.
such a criminally underrated piece of chopin's, and this interpretation is by far my favourite. played with such passion and such a high level of understanding of the piece. an absolutely beautiful and brilliant interpretation of one of chopin's most underrated yet (in my opinion) one of his greatest achievements
The most underrrated Chopin's work...
My god, what a performance. Spectacular. Its easy to see why this piece by Chopin isn't commonly played. This young man shows what true virtuosity is all about.
who do you think you are bushitting
It's supposed to be easier than both the 2nd and 3rd piano sonata and the 4th Ballade. An 8 out of 9 in difficulty according to G.Henle, while the Sonatas and the last Ballade are a 9 out of 9. And you do not have to be a super virtuoso to play this. There's a very decent recording by Brazilian amateur pianist Tiago Mondini de Souza on TH-cam - who actually takes more risky tempo choices than this pianist.
@@classicallpvault I have spoke to a few professional pianists, they say op. 46 is the most difficult piece from Chopin
@@classicallpvault Are you a pianist? If you are a pianist, you should know that tempo choices are not for tecnique possibilities but for interpretation, keyboard, room acoustics…
Very brilliant!!!
You should play this one someday ;)
Not one of Chopin’s better known works but beautifully conceived and executed; every interpretation of it I have heard is unique as if it really belongs to whatever pianist is playing it. The ending of course is somehow striking and yet unexpected, as if the conclusion was a work of its own. I did read that Chopin himself was quite pleased with it.
It was Chopin's desire to play Op. 46 on his return to his beloved Poland finally free from the invaders. His wish did not come true as he died young, and this masterpiece is one of the least performed pieces by the Polish genius. Absurd, a mystery.
To see someone so young, and so gifted, playing a 'rare' Chopin composition is a true joy. This is truly a breathtakingly beautiful performance!!
29 years old at the time
@@most_sane_piano_enthusiast still young lmao
@@Matt-hw2lo he could be considered an old man by 19th century coal miner standards
@@most_sane_piano_enthusiast thats cuz they die at like 15
@@Matt-hw2lo yea
11:26 love this part
What a beautiful interpretation! Full of poetry, passion, wonderful sound and technical perfection as a natural base
Wonderful performance! This young man is one of the finest pianists out there right now.
9/14/2020: First time hearing this piece. Of course it’s amazing. Especially the ending.
nice performance, just pitty that at 8:20 he realized that his flight is one hour sooner than he taught
Imagine Chopin completed the whole concerto
we need a time machine
Great. GREAT GREAT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Maybe the most beatiful thing i heard, only maybe.
It´s a great performance!!
Wspaniale, brawo! 😀
Masterful and courageous.
I hope this guy won.
He got t o the third stage, but he didn’t make it to the finals.
why would u think that he would've won
glasses:
6:51
8:43
10:06
Also, 5:57
**fixes his glasses mid piece like a badass**
10:08
The theme that occurs at 4:02 though
素晴らしい
Definitely has great power and control. But he has lots of effects which sometimes don't make musical sense. He knows how to play, but doesn't yet understand what's going on in the piece, so the effects have a superficial excitement which sometimes goes against what the music is saying. Also, maybe the miking is off, or maybe he's left-handed, but too often the left hand overpowers the right.
I'd say he was fine till 8:22 - and then the performance lost interpretative cohesion. Until that point, I was very impressed by his playing.
At that juncture, just a little restraint and control would have brought out the underlying pathos and heroic undercurrent of the piece in a deeper way, and what followed would have been so much more meaningful.
Perhaps one simply needs more life experience to understand such nuances...
you sound like a wise and intelligent person. im hungry for such a friendship :$ can we start chatting or mailing somewhere about classical music? i do also compose classical music, but i dont even have much listening experience. i would be very happy with a response. thank you
This Description Fits also perfectly the way of Pogorelich at playing....
是真的强！但会不会有些赶？
If you play the right hand pianissimo but the left hand forte it sort of defeats the purpose
11:36 whats that ??????
that's called failure
@@user-sv4ep5hx9rwhy?
Brian Ganz does a very nice performance of this piece. This guy is obviously very talented, and who am I to judge, but the last few minutes sound like the pianist is frustrated.
is his name really Mating Soon
lmao
Epic performance! You make this piece a lot better than it really is, if that makes any sense.
能很明显听出交响乐与独奏的区别
12:23
11:11
层次分明
I think he actually has musical potential, but that banging and metallic out of control chord tones just don’t work Chopin, Liszt perhaps but not Chopin..
too powerful for Chopin
I think it’s the Yamaha that has too harsh of a tone for my taste.
I love Yamaha, but not in this case.
I can understand. Maybe it was just the recording technique.
There are a few things here that are just wrong. I get the feeling that he learned the piece by ear.
Tojazzer yeah, he doesn’t really follow the written piece... dynamics etc. are sometimes off
hm... dont really like how he plays really fast and then slows down quickly... but you gotta respect the dudes playing, so i’ll just leave it as okay.
He got a few notes wrong too
imho he destroyed it a little. Yes, it is original and uncommon to play it like this but it's... nah
you're out of your mind
PieInTheSky no, he really isn’t.
Listened a lot more recordings of this, and now I kind of agree. Going back to this performance, and it's really not very great. But still not terrible.
Playing Op. 46 is uncommon in general lol
What an uninspired piece by Chopin. Guess he was very bored or not well when he composed it. (Sorry i guess it is just me).