It's going to be fun to come back to this video after the season's over and see which ones you got right and which ones you got wrong. I swear things change every year.
You didn't even have to wait until the end of the year. It's only week six and everyone was wrong about Russell and Geno. Also Rodgers,Brady,and Stafford are all having below average seasons whole the Eagles are 6-0 probably going to be the 1 seed in the NFC if things don't change
One statistic to remember about how good Herbert is: the Chargers are one of a few teams in the modern era to have a bottom 5 defense and have a positive record last year.
I liked your analysis of matt stafford, sure he's on a great team with a great coach. but the fact remains, he had his best season in a decade, rose to the occasion in the playoffs to beat the bucs and won the SB with that clutch last drive. So he did exactly what he was supposed to do
@@steamedclams5689 to be fair, his best season with the lions came in 2011, where like half the league’s QBs had 5,000+ passing yards, and his team was crushed in the wildcard round. His next best seasons, statistically, were arguably 2013 and 2015, where he went 7-9 both years. His two best seasons in Detroit, imo, were 2016 and 2017, as those were his best years without Megatron catching the ball. While he was really good, and went 9-7 both years, he was outperformed greatly by his QB competition TL;DR context matters
Bets response I’ve ever seen. Not to mention his 2016 season was historic. Dude broke the record for most comebacks in a season. 8 comebacks! Bro was the champion of the comeback.
People are sleeping on Baker. He’s a gently decent QB, even when injured. He’s just incredibly inconsistent. I think Mayfield will do decently on a shitty team.
I'm not a Mitch Tribusiky fan, but it was nice to see a fair analysis of him. Lots of people like to blame him for all the Bears problems over the last few years despite the fact that he was thrown under about 6000 buses and was never really helped out much.
If the rest of their division wasn't loaded with talent and good quarterbacks, I might have actually picked the Steelers to win their division this year
@Fries Yeah I think he had a lot of very high expectations put on him, the Bears just thought he was perfectly NFL ready and didn't try and help him at all.
everyone sleeps on Carr, he's the most consistent thing the Raiders have had for years, he's finally got a good offense and defense so I'm hoping it goes well from here
He was underrated for a few years because people were saying that he's not a starter when he is. But he's never been a good starter and has been average or lower his whole career so he's suddenly overrated now tbh
@@JSauer21 are you sure? Only 2 seasons 2017, 2014. Where he didn't have 4k+ passing. At least within 100 yards. Averages 10 or less ints his career. For having a garbage franchise backing you, that's more than good
The thing with kyler is I do agree that he's a good QB but he's getting paid like he's an elite cornerstone of the franchise. And sure, he could be that in a couple years but he's far from that at this point. So I feel like the cardinals are blowing a lot of their cap on a QB that's still developing
@@lampini yeah I think the two QBs that are stuck in that mold are Kyler and Dak (probably Lamar when he gets paid). By fans, they’re all hated way too much, and no none of them (frankly no one outside of the top 4ish) deserves 40 mil or more. Market is gonna market though, as much as it sucks. I think Kyler and Dak are overPAID but underRATED due to the amount of criticism both guys get from fans.
You forgot the fact that Joe Burrow was playing against a defense that had Aaron Donald, Von Miller and Jalen Ramsey on it. It wasn't just some NFC team they lost to, it was a literal bankrolled super team -- one that basically shutout Brady for almost 3 quarters; not to mention him being in the super bowl during his first full season as a starter anyway -- by leading a team that had like 3 wins the previous season to a division title -- while playing behind an awful offensive line. Burrow is definitely not overrated, he's properly rated at the very least. There are *very very* few 2nd year quarterbacks that have ever reached where Burrow is in terms of both development and accomplishments.
Yeah, but (like with Brady) reaching the Super Bowl is not an indicator of individual greatness. And yes the o line sucked, but he had Jamarr Chase, Tee Higgins and Joe Mixon on the team with him.
@@matthewskinner6626 Nobody thought Jamar was gonna be that good this past season. You could argue Jamar wouldn't have done nearly as well without Burrow or some other really good QB.
@@matthewskinner6626 an offensive line is way more important dude. It’s not even close. receivers are overrated, they help, yes , but not nearly as much as they are given credited for. Burrow couldn’t have played any better than he did in that super bowl. That offensive line literally lost like every snap. I mean literally every snap.
If we somehow kept kirk cousins completely blind to the context of the game, like keep him from knowing anything about the opponent or the stakes somehow, then kirk would have a 5000 yard 40 td season. I'd be like bolt where we have to keep cousins perpetually blind to reality before and after every single game.
Give Cousins a contract extension with an addendum to not watch and study tape, or be able to look at league standings, scores or anything related to football. Bonus cash to play video games under a contract with Faze Clan.
Something that I think could be a fun video idea would be doing a “Would you Rather” series. The Kirk Cousins analysis got me thinking mainly about the idea and how sad it is to be a Vikings fan. But just the question of to be a “Good” player that no one is afraid of or to be a “Bad” player that teams are afraid of. Love the content!
You are the funniest NFL commentator out there, glad this youtube makes you some cash, however limited it might be. Hope we get the week in review podcasts back... I also don't pay attention to the NBA and just listen to your commentary.
Would you ever do another quarterback retrospective? I know they take a lot of time but I think they are your best work. Would like to see one on Brett Favre or Warren Moon.
2:55 that's why Amari Cooper called Dak Prescott "the black Kirk Cousins." The reason it pissed Prescott off so much because currently it's pretty accurate. I think Dak can get over the hump to at least one superbowl if the cowboys put at least one fully elite defense and a decent enough offense (ie: a dynamic duo of receivers and Zeke returning to elite status or Tony Pollard stepping up)
honestly give him a better coach who can actually manage games properly and i think he’ll at least make the nfc chip. the problem with dallas for so long is they’ve never had a great coach since johnson
As a Colts fan, Julio to Tampa nearly made me inject some marijuana. I swear I thought he would join Matt in Indy. We just need a damn WR and we're a Super Bowl contender. Ryan never had an o-line, now he does. JT took a fat, slimy shit on the entire league (no offense to Lamar Jackson and Paul Pierce), and we have a top 5 defense behind a top 10 Bucker, top 5 Leonard, and criminally underrated Kenny Moore.
i generally hate the obsession with “overrated/underrated” players since they can completely flip flop solely based on public opinion, BUT. You do a terrific job with it and rarely find myself disagreeing
i feel like its harsh to say the 2nd year qbs have no excuses, you dont give up on a 1st overall pick in 2 seasons (this case he had 1 year under urban meyer)
Yeah I definitely feel like herbert is low key one of the more polarizing qbs in the league where many analysts and fans have him pegged as elite (I'm in this category as a chargers fan) while a significant minority of people don't even think he's top 10 because losing record and qb winzzzz "he's gotta prove himself" etc. I dunno though cuz I really feel like even if you just watch his highlights and even just momentarily glance at his counting stats I've no clue how you can come to the conclusion that he isn't elite and at least top 10 imo, even without diving deeper into his other stats and his film which would also tell you he's elite.
Anyone that thinks the losing record of the Chargers is on Herbert's head hasn't been watching. You can have the best QB in the country but if your defense can't make a stop and your idiot head coach can't manage a clock it's just pissing in the wind. Shit, if it wasn't for that asinine timeout they would've been in the playoffs last year regardless.
How are you still a chargers fan man? After they left San Diego I have literally forced myself to cut off any connections I have, even though their future is brighter than ever.
People have already forgotten that Pat Mahomes got absolutely crushed in the Super Bowl with a bunch of backups on the offensive line. Burrow’s team was also closer to winning it than Mahomes in 2021. I don’t think Burrow’s anywhere near as good as Mahomes, but the fact that he took *the Bengals* - by nearly all accounts, the most ineptly-ran franchise in the NFL - to the Super Bowl has to be properly accounted for. It’d be like 2nd-year Stafford taking the Lions to the Super Bowl in 2010 - completely and totally blowing past everyone’s expectations. He’s very clearly done enough to warrant the praise, IMO. Burrow has already won more playoff games than Lamar Jackson and is tied with Josh Allen - both of whom have played over twice as long as Burrow.
You completely miss the point of what he said. Everyone thinks Burrow carried the Bengals on his back through the playoffs which wasn’t the case. Burrow actually did very little getting his team through the playoffs. Their defense deserves the majority of the credit. They were also incredibly lucky to win against the Titans, and the Chiefs. Those are games they lose 9/10 times. Burrow is getting too much praise for the playoff run where he played average at best for the most part
I say this every year. The last Ohio State quarterback that was a star in the NFL was Tom Matte - as a HB for the 1960s Baltimore Colts. (Joe Burrow doesn't count) Yet every year, the Ohio State groupies squeal like little girls over the next Ohio State QB. From Pryor to Haskins (RIP) to Fields (RIP with Da Bears) to C.J. Stroud. When the Buckeyes produce a great QB, I'll stop repeating this but it's been over a decade now and nobody makes the cut.
I find it especially pathetic when Ohio State fans try to claim Burrow despite most of them agreeing that Haskins was the number one back in 2015. I get that their NFL careers went significantly different ways, but Burrow was made by LSU. Nothing Ohio can do to take that away, but they must have it all lol
The only school that has put a good number of decent QBs in the NFL is NC State. They actually have staying power as backups. Everywhere else is as inconsistent as OSU but yeah you're right we are annoying. Go Bucks!
Schlichter and Haskins are the bookend first-round picks, and both struggled with those high expectations. Tupa played punter for most of his career. Krenzel and Jones won national championships, and Smith won the Heisman Trophy, but they combined for 13 starts in the NFL. Tomczak, who was an undrafted free agent, had the most success. Graham is the only other quarterback with more than 20 starts at the NFL level. Sporting News said it all. Schlichter was a beast in the Arena league though 😂
The Joe Burrow slander is always tough :/ yes stats not amazing in postseason but he brings the confidence to an organization that has been historical losers. It’s like when the nerd gets the hot cheerleader in your favorite teen movies.
Next time you do an Overrated, underrated, properly rated: Big Mac. Me personally think that it is overrated. If you bite it it has all the insides get pushed out, and it makes a giant mess and the meat doesn’t taste as good as the flame broiled Burger King meat. I bought both and ate them after each other, and I came up with Burger King whoppers better. Seth Curry: I feel like he’s always overshadowed by his brother. Pre-marital sex: I wanna know if how you think about it and if you think it’s overrated, underrated, and properly rated. Donovan Mitchell vs Jamal Murray *rivalry*: I wanna know if you think it’s overrated, underrated, or properly rated. I know there playoff matchup in the bubble was really good, but does it really deserve all that hype? (I would say yes, but you’re the expert.)
Not sure if these kinds of shows/fandoms are your thing, but I’d LOVE to hear what you think of The Owl House-most people I know who’ve seen it think it’s either groundbreaking and brilliant (I’m in the former camp) or meh and overhyped for what it is & wants to do, so I’d like to know where you fall on the matter.
Hey from a Raiders fan, about Carr. You got it mixed up there, Barry. You said he does great against bad teams but shits his pants against good teams. Just go look back the last two seasons. The Raiders have won mainly against decent teams and lost to sucky teams.
@@peytonmanning5404 first off no he’s not lol he makes like 10 mil less. Anyways, that’s irrelevant, not only because he’s the 8th highest paid QB (which is around where he ranks btw lol), but also because he’s clearly basing his say on how FANS view the player, not the team paying him.
@@massivematt3113 in no order, russ, mahomes, herbert,allen,rodgers, stafford, burrow,lamar, watson and brady, and is in same tier as kyler, carr and cousins, and ryan
Yeah, this year vs San Francisco was the first playoff game of Rodgers career where you could make the argument that the loss was actually his fault. In 2020 he outplayed Brady by a lot, but the defense shat the bed in the first half and Jones's fumble inside their own red zone basically sealed the game, and Rodgers still nearly won it. The previous years against San Francisco (3x), Atlanta, and Arizona, the Packers were seriously outgunned and had no business even being in those games in the first place. They only even made it that far to those games because Rodgers did something absolutely heroic in the games prior to get them there. The Seattle game was blown by special teams, coaching, and the OT coin flip. The defense let up like 50 points to Eli Manning in that divisional round game against the Giants.
Titans fan here so of course going to be biased but sooo many people including an overwhelming majority of Tits fans are screaming for Tannehill to get out after last season. Personally I would say he's underrated because everyone wants to blame him without taking note of the fact he had average/below average pass protection and a bag of peanuts to throw to. I'm excited for him to hopefully ball out this season with a chip on his shoulder but we'll have to see. Keep up the great vids Barry!
Tbf to both, they’ve had some TERRIBLE coaching to deal with (many times that has cost them games even when Dak/Kirk put them in a position to win). I’m not saying they’re both elite at all, but definitely not bad QBs as some would love to tout. I do think they’re very similar, and are top 15 QBs, which is a good thing in this league. We’ll see what Kirk can do with a coach who actually likes him, and (maybe) Dallas could get Sean Payton to help Dak. Cheers
Bru burrow made plays happen when he had no time and no pocket anything the offense amounted was all because of burrow buying time sliding up sliding out of the pocket. And the last 4th down for the Bengals he was instantly grabbed by Donald and still managed to get the ball within range if perine who in my opinion didn't put much effort into catching that. Bet Mixon does
How do you feel about Tony Romo? He may be the least clutch player in all of sports but looking at the numbers he was a great QB. I’d love to hear your thoughts
4:00 out of all the known 100% legitimately real unedited images that have ever existed, this one is by far the most 100% legitimately real and unedited.
I actually agree about Mac Jones. He was in the best possible situation last year with McDaniels, Belichick, a good defense, a great run game, and a solid Oline. He didn't have great weapons, but he had enough to make do. People talk about him like he's already Brady though, and that's absurd. I saw the flashes of what he *could* be last year, but let's not pretend like he was incredible. He was just pretty good.
I disagree with the Carr assessment, I think it’s the opposite because he always plays up to good teams but then he ends up playing down to bad teams, think the Giants last year or the Falcons 2 years ago
The joe burrow hype has been real but tbf he clutched in the playoffs when he needed to outside the end of the Super Bowl where von miller crushed his leg immobilizing him. He came up huge in every game at various moments and I think that’s more of the hype than him throwing for say 400 yards and 5 tds in a game which he didn’t etc…
Ok but Russell Westbrook averaged a triple double
By rim camping and forcing passes and assist
This made me chuckle
W
He plays so hard, and he has a family
Ong he will forever be the best triple double guy
It's going to be fun to come back to this video after the season's over and see which ones you got right and which ones you got wrong. I swear things change every year.
Lol, funny seeing you here
@@atleeshanaberger5530 This guy is one of my favorite TH-camrs haha
@@talesfromthetrip hell yeah dude. You’ve got a great channel yourself too, rly enjoy listening to your vids before goin to sleep lol
@@atleeshanaberger5530 thanks bro 🙏 I appreciate it
You didn't even have to wait until the end of the year. It's only week six and everyone was wrong about Russell and Geno. Also Rodgers,Brady,and Stafford are all having below average seasons whole the Eagles are 6-0 probably going to be the 1 seed in the NFC if things don't change
One statistic to remember about how good Herbert is: the Chargers are one of a few teams in the modern era to have a bottom 5 defense and have a positive record last year.
Reminds me of another QB who plays in the same division
I liked your analysis of matt stafford, sure he's on a great team with a great coach. but the fact remains, he had his best season in a decade, rose to the occasion in the playoffs to beat the bucs and won the SB with that clutch last drive. So he did exactly what he was supposed to do
Yeah and I feel like he could be top 5 this season. All he has to do is cut down on turnovers. His advanced stats have him in the top 5 already
@@kiryukazuma8229 he put up the same stats in Detroit and he wasn’t top 5 then.
@@steamedclams5689 to be fair, his best season with the lions came in 2011, where like half the league’s QBs had 5,000+ passing yards, and his team was crushed in the wildcard round. His next best seasons, statistically, were arguably 2013 and 2015, where he went 7-9 both years. His two best seasons in Detroit, imo, were 2016 and 2017, as those were his best years without Megatron catching the ball. While he was really good, and went 9-7 both years, he was outperformed greatly by his QB competition
TL;DR context matters
Fuck it kupp is down there somewhere 😂
Bets response I’ve ever seen. Not to mention his 2016 season was historic. Dude broke the record for most comebacks in a season. 8 comebacks! Bro was the champion of the comeback.
People are sleeping on Baker. He’s a gently decent QB, even when injured. He’s just incredibly inconsistent. I think Mayfield will do decently on a shitty team.
I dont think hes gentle at all I think hes actually aggressively decent
@@neomarioism perhaps even atrociously decent
Baker is a top 15 qb and was before injury- if he hadn’t played injured everyone would still think so
Still sleeping
youre wrong haha
I'm not a Mitch Tribusiky fan, but it was nice to see a fair analysis of him. Lots of people like to blame him for all the Bears problems over the last few years despite the fact that he was thrown under about 6000 buses and was never really helped out much.
If the rest of their division wasn't loaded with talent and good quarterbacks, I might have actually picked the Steelers to win their division this year
@Fries Yeah I think he had a lot of very high expectations put on him, the Bears just thought he was perfectly NFL ready and didn't try and help him at all.
I was going to have pre-marital sex but Barry heroically saved me from committing this huge sin by apploading this video. Thank you Barry #hero
69 likes as of writing this comment. Nice
I’m surprised Barry was able to make this video through the tears he was shedding over Jimmy G not being a starting quarterback.
😆
But he still may
Ruh roh ..your wish is granted
@@pauljimerson8218 unfortunately not *my* wish...
everyone sleeps on Carr, he's the most consistent thing the Raiders have had for years, he's finally got a good offense and defense so I'm hoping it goes well from here
And constant coaching and front office personnel changes too
He was underrated for a few years because people were saying that he's not a starter when he is. But he's never been a good starter and has been average or lower his whole career so he's suddenly overrated now tbh
@@JSauer21 are you sure? Only 2 seasons 2017, 2014. Where he didn't have 4k+ passing. At least within 100 yards. Averages 10 or less ints his career. For having a garbage franchise backing you, that's more than good
@@Revy_1995 I have a challenge for you. Find me one single stat that he excels in that isn't based off pure volume
@@JSauer21 if I have to pick one, lack of interceptions, man has streaks longer than most fans ages. Highest ever in a season was 14.
The thing with kyler is I do agree that he's a good QB but he's getting paid like he's an elite cornerstone of the franchise. And sure, he could be that in a couple years but he's far from that at this point. So I feel like the cardinals are blowing a lot of their cap on a QB that's still developing
There’s a difference between overPAID and overRATED.
@@massivematt3113 very true
@@lampini yeah I think the two QBs that are stuck in that mold are Kyler and Dak (probably Lamar when he gets paid). By fans, they’re all hated way too much, and no none of them (frankly no one outside of the top 4ish) deserves 40 mil or more. Market is gonna market though, as much as it sucks. I think Kyler and Dak are overPAID but underRATED due to the amount of criticism both guys get from fans.
He would be that already if he was about a foot taller…
@@VandalSavage72 💀
Overrated Properly Rated and Underrated is lowkey my new favorite game. I know Barry didn’t create the game, but still, it’s fun to play
You forgot the fact that Joe Burrow was playing against a defense that had Aaron Donald, Von Miller and Jalen Ramsey on it. It wasn't just some NFC team they lost to, it was a literal bankrolled super team -- one that basically shutout Brady for almost 3 quarters; not to mention him being in the super bowl during his first full season as a starter anyway -- by leading a team that had like 3 wins the previous season to a division title -- while playing behind an awful offensive line. Burrow is definitely not overrated, he's properly rated at the very least. There are *very very* few 2nd year quarterbacks that have ever reached where Burrow is in terms of both development and accomplishments.
two words: overrated…wait that’s one word
Yeah, but (like with Brady) reaching the Super Bowl is not an indicator of individual greatness. And yes the o line sucked, but he had Jamarr Chase, Tee Higgins and Joe Mixon on the team with him.
@@matthewskinner6626 Nobody thought Jamar was gonna be that good this past season. You could argue Jamar wouldn't have done nearly as well without Burrow or some other really good QB.
@@matthewskinner6626 an offensive line is way more important dude. It’s not even close. receivers are overrated, they help, yes , but not nearly as much as they are given credited for. Burrow couldn’t have played any better than he did in that super bowl. That offensive line literally lost like every snap. I mean literally every snap.
Damn it's almost like he had a good team around him
everyone in cincinnati knows the d were the ones who carried us to the sb.
Especially Eli Apple. He is a god tier defenseman
“If he reaches his full potential, he could one day be as good as Andy Dalton” lol
such a funny burn
Andy dalton is the goat tho so tua will be just fine.
If we somehow kept kirk cousins completely blind to the context of the game, like keep him from knowing anything about the opponent or the stakes somehow, then kirk would have a 5000 yard 40 td season. I'd be like bolt where we have to keep cousins perpetually blind to reality before and after every single game.
This would work too
Give Cousins a contract extension with an addendum to not watch and study tape, or be able to look at league standings, scores or anything related to football. Bonus cash to play video games under a contract with Faze Clan.
was not expecting to see a reference to Bolt (2008) in the comments of a McCockiner video about NFL QBs
Man that's a good breakdown! SKOL VIKES
Something that I think could be a fun video idea would be doing a “Would you Rather” series. The Kirk Cousins analysis got me thinking mainly about the idea and how sad it is to be a Vikings fan. But just the question of to be a “Good” player that no one is afraid of or to be a “Bad” player that teams are afraid of. Love the content!
I’m trying to think of a “bad” QB that teams are scared of, ever. Thoughts?
I needed this, I had just watched the entire -rated series this morning
Look at Barry. Blessing us with content on a Sunday. ❤️
I feel like I get told Mariota is a former 2nd overall pick every week and I still get surprised hearing it every time
I’m literally laughing my ass off out of the zoom in on Mattress Firm 😂
Barry McCockiner is the only person that I have bell notifications on for.
The zoom-in on the mattress firm logo was the best part
I never would of thought wentz would have the career he’s had after watching his 2017 season
It’s honestly really sad, especially as an Eagles fan. He isnt bad either, just keeps getting hurt.
The zoom in on the mattress firm patch got me 😂
You are the funniest NFL commentator out there, glad this youtube makes you some cash, however limited it might be. Hope we get the week in review podcasts back... I also don't pay attention to the NBA and just listen to your commentary.
Would you ever do another quarterback retrospective? I know they take a lot of time but I think they are your best work. Would like to see one on Brett Favre or Warren Moon.
"Kirk Cousins with eyeliner". The perfect sentence.
Can you rate Will Clark in the next rated video? I love him as a player but i can see his career wasn’t long enough to make him a hall of famer
barry im proud to see your opinion of matt stafford has changed from the days of statpadford
I would like for you to do this with every nba teams best player currently
I get so har I mean happy every time I see you uploaded a new video
2:55 that's why Amari Cooper called Dak Prescott "the black Kirk Cousins." The reason it pissed Prescott off so much because currently it's pretty accurate. I think Dak can get over the hump to at least one superbowl if the cowboys put at least one fully elite defense and a decent enough offense (ie: a dynamic duo of receivers and Zeke returning to elite status or Tony Pollard stepping up)
honestly give him a better coach who can actually manage games properly and i think he’ll at least make the nfc chip. the problem with dallas for so long is they’ve never had a great coach since johnson
@@collinwaltz5877 you won’t get a better coach until Jerry passes away
@@colonless7512 soon likely look at the man he is like the physic embodiment of cancer
As a Colts fan, Julio to Tampa nearly made me inject some marijuana. I swear I thought he would join Matt in Indy. We just need a damn WR and we're a Super Bowl contender. Ryan never had an o-line, now he does. JT took a fat, slimy shit on the entire league (no offense to Lamar Jackson and Paul Pierce), and we have a top 5 defense behind a top 10 Bucker, top 5 Leonard, and criminally underrated Kenny Moore.
i generally hate the obsession with “overrated/underrated” players since they can completely flip flop solely based on public opinion, BUT. You do a terrific job with it and rarely find myself disagreeing
This gonna be a banger video
Barry. Are you going to do a breakdown of the 2022 NBA playoffs?
I predict that Marcus Mariota is gonna do good on the falcons especially if yo watched his one game with the raiders he knows how to use elite TEs
For your next Overrated,Underrated,Properly Rated: What are your thoughts on Kerry Collins? (love you and your content btw)
i feel like its harsh to say the 2nd year qbs have no excuses, you dont give up on a 1st overall pick in 2 seasons (this case he had 1 year under urban meyer)
Barry Mccockiner’s TH-cam Content is Underrated🐐
Yeah I definitely feel like herbert is low key one of the more polarizing qbs in the league where many analysts and fans have him pegged as elite (I'm in this category as a chargers fan) while a significant minority of people don't even think he's top 10 because losing record and qb winzzzz "he's gotta prove himself" etc. I dunno though cuz I really feel like even if you just watch his highlights and even just momentarily glance at his counting stats I've no clue how you can come to the conclusion that he isn't elite and at least top 10 imo, even without diving deeper into his other stats and his film which would also tell you he's elite.
Anyone that thinks the losing record of the Chargers is on Herbert's head hasn't been watching. You can have the best QB in the country but if your defense can't make a stop and your idiot head coach can't manage a clock it's just pissing in the wind. Shit, if it wasn't for that asinine timeout they would've been in the playoffs last year regardless.
@@jeremygilbert7989 100% agree with you because we’ve had experience in similar scenarios
How are you still a chargers fan man? After they left San Diego I have literally forced myself to cut off any connections I have, even though their future is brighter than ever.
Can you do a video over the 1976 QB starters please
Lol Kyler called mr October off the bat. This will be good
this video had me dying!!!!!, instant sub!!!
Thoughts on Jay Cutler? He had some statistically good seasons with the Bears in the early 2010s but was known for having a horrible work ethic
As a Bears fan, I despise Cutler. He was wildly inconsistent, threw tons of interceptions, and had an abysmal attitude. I'm glad he's gone.
People have already forgotten that Pat Mahomes got absolutely crushed in the Super Bowl with a bunch of backups on the offensive line. Burrow’s team was also closer to winning it than Mahomes in 2021.
I don’t think Burrow’s anywhere near as good as Mahomes, but the fact that he took *the Bengals* - by nearly all accounts, the most ineptly-ran franchise in the NFL - to the Super Bowl has to be properly accounted for. It’d be like 2nd-year Stafford taking the Lions to the Super Bowl in 2010 - completely and totally blowing past everyone’s expectations.
He’s very clearly done enough to warrant the praise, IMO. Burrow has already won more playoff games than Lamar Jackson and is tied with Josh Allen - both of whom have played over twice as long as Burrow.
You completely miss the point of what he said. Everyone thinks Burrow carried the Bengals on his back through the playoffs which wasn’t the case. Burrow actually did very little getting his team through the playoffs. Their defense deserves the majority of the credit. They were also incredibly lucky to win against the Titans, and the Chiefs. Those are games they lose 9/10 times. Burrow is getting too much praise for the playoff run where he played average at best for the most part
i see a berry post: i click no hesitation
I say this every year. The last Ohio State quarterback that was a star in the NFL was Tom Matte - as a HB for the 1960s Baltimore Colts. (Joe Burrow doesn't count) Yet every year, the Ohio State groupies squeal like little girls over the next Ohio State QB. From Pryor to Haskins (RIP) to Fields (RIP with Da Bears) to C.J. Stroud. When the Buckeyes produce a great QB, I'll stop repeating this but it's been over a decade now and nobody makes the cut.
And that's why Ohio State sucks.
I find it especially pathetic when Ohio State fans try to claim Burrow despite most of them agreeing that Haskins was the number one back in 2015.
I get that their NFL careers went significantly different ways, but Burrow was made by LSU. Nothing Ohio can do to take that away, but they must have it all lol
The only school that has put a good number of decent QBs in the NFL is NC State. They actually have staying power as backups. Everywhere else is as inconsistent as OSU but yeah you're right we are annoying. Go Bucks!
Schlichter and Haskins are the bookend first-round picks, and both struggled with those high expectations. Tupa played punter for most of his career. Krenzel and Jones won national championships, and Smith won the Heisman Trophy, but they combined for 13 starts in the NFL.
Tomczak, who was an undrafted free agent, had the most success. Graham is the only other quarterback with more than 20 starts at the NFL level.
Sporting News said it all. Schlichter was a beast in the Arena league though 😂
You forgot Troy Smith. So actually, well over decade.
Matt Ryan is UNDERRATED
Perfect vid to watch while eating a bowl of cereal
"If his first read isn't there he panics." That says it all about Hurts. You know damn well what you're getting. Have fun this year.
He can improve. Last year was his first full season and now he has weapons
I’d say throughout the season he got better at not being a one read all the time. This year should be way better than last year though
I love all the funny nicknames
My favorite part of watching these videos is not finishing the rest of the video after my team comes up
The 6:20 pronunciation of Tua’s name actually sent me
@3:45 "Hippie with the Golden Arm" sounds like a 60's or 70's B Movie cult classic...
Hey barry what are your thoughts on Jalen ramsey I see him make some amazing plays but he also sucked in the superbowl
The Joe Burrow slander is always tough :/ yes stats not amazing in postseason but he brings the confidence to an organization that has been historical losers. It’s like when the nerd gets the hot cheerleader in your favorite teen movies.
Hi Barry love your content and gosh you’re handsome can you please do this video format for nba also? (Example: Point Guard, Shooting Guard….etc)
It's amusing to see the QBs where the most offensive nicknames Barry could come up with...were their actual names.
Lamar for me deserves the label as a top 12-8 QB that he usually gets, although I do have faith that he could bounce back this year.
I put him at least top 7.
He’s around 9-5 to most people
I will say, I like the lack of fluff in these videos, you can get through the entire league in 10 mins.
Matt Ryan so underrated he’s hardly ever injured and never brought up his stats every year
Barry. you are so funny. what can i do to be as funny as you?
Much Love,
-Steve
hey man at least you finally stopped the stafford slander
geno smith really didn’t write back
Next time you do an Overrated, underrated, properly rated:
Big Mac. Me personally think that it is overrated. If you bite it it has all the insides get pushed out, and it makes a giant mess and the meat doesn’t taste as good as the flame broiled Burger King meat. I bought both and ate them after each other, and I came up with Burger King whoppers better.
Seth Curry: I feel like he’s always overshadowed by his brother.
Pre-marital sex: I wanna know if how you think about it and if you think it’s overrated, underrated, and properly rated.
Donovan Mitchell vs Jamal Murray *rivalry*: I wanna know if you think it’s overrated, underrated, or properly rated. I know there playoff matchup in the bubble was really good, but does it really deserve all that hype? (I would say yes, but you’re the expert.)
Not sure if these kinds of shows/fandoms are your thing, but I’d LOVE to hear what you think of The Owl House-most people I know who’ve seen it think it’s either groundbreaking and brilliant (I’m in the former camp) or meh and overhyped for what it is & wants to do, so I’d like to know where you fall on the matter.
Hey from a Raiders fan, about Carr. You got it mixed up there, Barry. You said he does great against bad teams but shits his pants against good teams. Just go look back the last two seasons. The Raiders have won mainly against decent teams and lost to sucky teams.
You’re a raiders fan. Of course you think this 😂
The bengals game is all you really need to see
@@jacobw5914 literally go look back at this past season
@@Luke_boy_77 he lost to bengals. I know
this is a certified hood classic
0:15 seconds in and I’m dying at Mr. October
Deshaun Watson's R Kelly comparision had me DEAD
Was the sam darnold and baker being underrated "properly rated" a joke?
BARRY IS BACK LESGO
Barry you should rank every super bowl!
Konnichiwa Barry, what are your thoughts on Ahman green? All time leader in rushing yards for the packers o and he also a famous child Respecter.
Laughing my ass off at the pronouncing of Tua’s last name Barry lmaooo
I’m dying from the mills neck 😂
Oh golly man, these are ice fucking cold bro ❄️❄️❄️
Bro literally no one (even some Dallas fans) don’t like Dak lol, the dude is underrated
but hes paid like mahomes, but he is only good
@@peytonmanning5404 first off no he’s not lol he makes like 10 mil less. Anyways, that’s irrelevant, not only because he’s the 8th highest paid QB (which is around where he ranks btw lol), but also because he’s clearly basing his say on how FANS view the player, not the team paying him.
@@massivematt3113 nah hes not top 10
@@peytonmanning5404 tell me 10 QBs better than him right now
@@massivematt3113 in no order, russ, mahomes, herbert,allen,rodgers, stafford, burrow,lamar, watson and brady, and is in same tier as kyler, carr and cousins, and ryan
As a giants fan I believe that DJ can become a mid tier QB (14th-17th best) like Jimmy G, Tannehill or Baker
Rodgers only played bad in the playoff THIS year was literally the first game in playoff history he has scored under 20 pts
Yeah, this year vs San Francisco was the first playoff game of Rodgers career where you could make the argument that the loss was actually his fault. In 2020 he outplayed Brady by a lot, but the defense shat the bed in the first half and Jones's fumble inside their own red zone basically sealed the game, and Rodgers still nearly won it. The previous years against San Francisco (3x), Atlanta, and Arizona, the Packers were seriously outgunned and had no business even being in those games in the first place. They only even made it that far to those games because Rodgers did something absolutely heroic in the games prior to get them there. The Seattle game was blown by special teams, coaching, and the OT coin flip. The defense let up like 50 points to Eli Manning in that divisional round game against the Giants.
Titans fan here so of course going to be biased but sooo many people including an overwhelming majority of Tits fans are screaming for Tannehill to get out after last season. Personally I would say he's underrated because everyone wants to blame him without taking note of the fact he had average/below average pass protection and a bag of peanuts to throw to. I'm excited for him to hopefully ball out this season with a chip on his shoulder but we'll have to see. Keep up the great vids Barry!
Serious Question. Are Dak and Cousins similar? Both overpaid both pretty good but can't seem to win the big ones.
Tbf to both, they’ve had some TERRIBLE coaching to deal with (many times that has cost them games even when Dak/Kirk put them in a position to win). I’m not saying they’re both elite at all, but definitely not bad QBs as some would love to tout. I do think they’re very similar, and are top 15 QBs, which is a good thing in this league. We’ll see what Kirk can do with a coach who actually likes him, and (maybe) Dallas could get Sean Payton to help Dak. Cheers
yes. Amari cooper quite literally called him the ‘black kirk cousins’
Bru burrow made plays happen when he had no time and no pocket anything the offense amounted was all because of burrow buying time sliding up sliding out of the pocket. And the last 4th down for the Bengals he was instantly grabbed by Donald and still managed to get the ball within range if perine who in my opinion didn't put much effort into catching that. Bet Mixon does
How do you feel about Tony Romo? He may be the least clutch player in all of sports but looking at the numbers he was a great QB. I’d love to hear your thoughts
He made a 24-minute video on Romo already.
GENO SMITH PROVED EVERYONE WRONG 🎉
Idk why I laughed so hard at the Brady picture
Trevor Lawrence apparently doesn't even need to use the laces on the football.
4:00 out of all the known 100% legitimately real unedited images that have ever existed, this one is by far the most 100% legitimately real and unedited.
Fucked up on that Russell Wilson one. I loved him in Seattle but he left his HOF jacket in the pacific northwest
I actually agree about Mac Jones. He was in the best possible situation last year with McDaniels, Belichick, a good defense, a great run game, and a solid Oline. He didn't have great weapons, but he had enough to make do.
People talk about him like he's already Brady though, and that's absurd. I saw the flashes of what he *could* be last year, but let's not pretend like he was incredible. He was just pretty good.
I miss Barry and am happy that it’s almost nfl time
I want Jameis to succeed so much. He works so hard. I wish him nothing but the best. I fear other results
Me too, God. I hope he, along with the rest of the Saints players, do great
nah I really want him to drop another 30/30 season
@@schwany6703 apparently hes been living at the training facility in every single meeting
Barry you are my role model
“Tua Tacmfmcjfjfnfh” 😂😂
1:25 made me crack up😂😂
Verdict on the Breitbart Starr joke: Properly Rated but probably two ARod Press conferences away from being underrated
“Less handsome than jimmy garapalo” love it
I disagree with the Carr assessment, I think it’s the opposite because he always plays up to good teams but then he ends up playing down to bad teams, think the Giants last year or the Falcons 2 years ago
The joe burrow hype has been real but tbf he clutched in the playoffs when he needed to outside the end of the Super Bowl where von miller crushed his leg immobilizing him. He came up huge in every game at various moments and I think that’s more of the hype than him throwing for say 400 yards and 5 tds in a game which he didn’t etc…