Arrau n'a plus les doigts de ses 20 ans, mais a plus que gagné en intensité et surtout émotionnellemet , j'adore cet immense pianiste depuis que je l'ai découvert à 13 ans , c'est à dire depuis plus de 40 ans
This is a truly unbelievable interpretation! Arrau, as always, lets audiences forget that the pieces are etudes. The power is hidden underneath the surface, just as the third movement of the C-major Fantasy op.17. The variation staring at 23:07 seems to have the tranquility in Waldszenen, Op.82, and the warmth in Kinderszenen Op.15. Not a single note, a phrase, a passage is neglected or taken for granted. Together these basic elements burst turbulence rarely heard of anywhere else.
Que se puede decir de las interpretaciones del Maestro Arrau , solo escuchar y aprender , 80 años interpretando de esa forma que en la actualidad no encuentro , ese grado de compromiso emocional , dominio técnico , musicalidad , calidad sonora, profundidad expresiva , parece venir desde muy dentro de su ser, en los comentarios solo se hace referencia a las notas falsas , gran falta de percepción musical.( triste )
@@pilarlopez2634 Sin dudas , siempre cala muy hondo , con cualquier compositor , despues evaluarás si estas o no de acuerdo con la interpretación y el estilo.
I'm not sure if I ever seen an interpretation of Etude 11 as beautiful as this one. Does anyone know why Etude 12 has passages completely different from the "usual" editions. Did he improvise something or is another version?
There are many arguments both for and against including the posthumous etudes. Ultimately it is up to the pianist to include them or not and in what order. Posthumous etude # 5 is surely one of the most beautiful piano pieces ever written!
Arrau n'a plus les doigts de ses 20 ans, mais a plus que gagné en intensité et surtout émotionnellemet , j'adore cet immense pianiste depuis que je l'ai découvert à 13 ans , c'est à dire depuis plus de 40 ans
Merveilleuse interprétation
Incredibly powerful recording. This piece is perfect for the heavy/dark playing of Arrau.
Merveilleuse interprétation des études de Schumann
This is a truly unbelievable interpretation! Arrau, as always, lets audiences forget that the pieces are etudes. The power is hidden underneath the surface, just as the third movement of the C-major Fantasy op.17. The variation staring at 23:07 seems to have the tranquility in Waldszenen, Op.82, and the warmth in Kinderszenen Op.15. Not a single note, a phrase, a passage is neglected or taken for granted. Together these basic elements burst turbulence rarely heard of anywhere else.
Nobody thinks of this piece as etudes.
J'adore Arrau depuis plus de 40 ans
Arrau is my favorite interpret for Schumann in general and this piece in particular.
J'adore Arrau dans quasiment tout
¡GRANDIOSA!....tanto la obra como la intepretación.
Entièrement d'accord
Magnificent.
Восхитительно!!!
Sublime! Both the piece, and the pianist. Grazie mille!
Entièrement d'accord
Arrau, The true Master !!!!
Entièrement d'accord, unique Arrau
Maravilloso !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Muchas gracias
Sublime version
Poetry. At the age of 80.
Quel leçon pour les gamins de pianistes ,une merveille
VERY symphonic!
Very nice to hear Arrau play those additional variations! THX
Masterful ❤🎶🎶🎶🎶👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Sublime version
Que se puede decir de las interpretaciones del Maestro Arrau , solo escuchar y aprender , 80 años interpretando de esa forma que en la actualidad no encuentro , ese grado de compromiso emocional , dominio técnico , musicalidad , calidad sonora, profundidad expresiva , parece venir desde muy dentro de su ser, en los comentarios solo se hace referencia a las notas falsas , gran falta de percepción musical.( triste )
Me encanta tu comentario!!!
Para mí, lo principal es que llegue al alma, y Arrau llega y la traspasa...
@@pilarlopez2634 Sin dudas , siempre cala muy hondo , con cualquier compositor , despues evaluarás si estas o no de acuerdo con la interpretación y el estilo.
Excellente analyse, j'adore Arrau tout comme vous, cette trempe de pianistes est hélas révolu à jamais
Arrau , la placidez , S.Richter el apasionado! , ambos sublimes y enormes talentos. Inolvidables!!
Immense pianiste que Claudio Arrau
I greatly admire Arrau's performance of this marvelous work as much as I admire Earl Wild's.
J'adore Arrau également, superbe
I'm not sure if I ever seen an interpretation of Etude 11 as beautiful as this one. Does anyone know why Etude 12 has passages completely different from the "usual" editions. Did he improvise something or is another version?
Si tratta della prima edizione composta da Schumann.
21:15 28:03
4:39, 21:50
Why can't anybody play these Etudes exactly as written by Schumann??? That is, without inserting the posthumous variations ad libitum?
There are many arguments both for and against including the posthumous etudes. Ultimately it is up to the pianist to include them or not and in what order. Posthumous etude # 5 is surely one of the most beautiful piano pieces ever written!
200 years later, why do you care? Just enjoy.
Kempff, Andras Schiff, Pogo, and so on...