ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- After a week in which Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito's open political bias was cast in stark relief and literally run up a flag pole, followed by revelations of massive gifts accepted by Justice Clarence Thomas, frustration with the justices' arrogant impunity has a growing number of Americans demanding that something be done. Nikole Hannah Jones, civil rights reporter for the New York Times, and Dahlia Lithwick, senior editor at Slate, discuss with Alex Wagner.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#SCOTUS #SupremeCourt #ClarenceThomas
Come on people "A job for life, great pay,No Accountability and you get paid by big corps for helping them out with Favourable Decisions." ,,,,, What could go WRONG?????
So 4 million can buy you a Supreme Court Justice for decade(s).
And Thomas didn't even pay taxes on that 4 million! Dude should be prosecuted and given a federal cell for retirement.
I'm beginning to think the US needs to build a prison just for political and judicial convicts. It would need to be a pretty big one, but at least it would only need one security detail.
Probably could be bought for a lot less.
To be fair its a gift...
Four million isn't even very much, considering.
The N word applies to Thomas and his nasty insurrectionist sympathizing wife as well.
"inadvertently omitted" what a croc, then there is a bridge for sale in NYC. Impeach and prosecute all these corrupt judges. NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW, NOT EVEN A JUDGE.
How can a jury member go to jail for accepting a bribe but a supreme Court Justice can't?
becuase most jury members are not rich.
SCOTUS is above the law because it sets all laws.
Congress says so. Only Congress can impeach and remove a Supreme Court Justice. And right now it's the Congress that put them on the bench, deciding they can do whatever they want with impunity. Which is why so many Republican congressional representative have resigned and are not running again. They don't agree with or respect what their own party is allowing.
THIS!!!
How can a man tell so many lies as Biden has done and still have people like you believe in him ? It makes no sense to me 😂
I understand completely. I always forget about 4 million dollars in gifts. I'm so busy it just slips my mind.
So busy tooling around on yachts and in my beautiful custom RV.
Me too. I often forget about these little trifles. No biggee.
We need to drain the swamp paid for by our hard earned dollars!!
Discontent with the Supreme Court? More like outright disgust!
Q: What do Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and Biden all have in common?
A: They all arrested their political enemies!
@@herballycorrect Q: What do Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and Trump all have in common?
A: Dreadful cults of personality.
We love the SCOTUS
@@herballycorrect😂😂😂😂 bull 💩
Congress need to hold these corrupted MAGA judges accountable and responsible but will the corrupted MAGA RepubliCONS in Congress willing to impeach one of their own⁉️
Time to clean the court out................................
Just how do you suggest that? Do the liberal judges need to go also?
Are you talking out your butt?
Yep
Lifetime means Lifetime.
Trump ✊✊✊✊
@@nunyabusiness3666 which liberal judge has been caught taking bribes goober
FAFO lib. 😁
If I inadvertently fail to disclose stuff on my tax return, I'm prosecuted.
If I inadvertently fail to follow terms in my employment contract, I am fired
Nobody is above the law
In America it appears that many are.
Do you file on taxes that you went on a vacation and your friend paid for a rv and hotel rental?
Wrong. This proves that we are most definitely NOT equal under the law.
I'm from Germany, corruption like this would and could never happen here, and if by some chance it did, the justice would be immediately removed and indicted for corruption. And here they have a 12-year term limit.
BUT LER.!!!!
We need to take lessons and learn from our European cousins now!
Umm... i hate to be the bearer of bad news, but a long time ago, there was this guy named adolf who was elected leader of germany...
Umm, things changed since then!!@enigmacrk200
@@enigmacrk200yes and you would think the world, especially the US would learn from that. Ivana said in her book, that her husband had Mein Kampf by his bedside…
Ignorance isn’t an excuse especially for a Supreme Court judge, is it? Work hard to remove these outrageous MAGA judges. Money controls elections, supreme court decisions, and the explanation are so weak: my wife did it or inadvertently omitted
Ignorance is not a defense. Did he even go to law school!?
So what's your excuse for Biden plagiarizing Ronald Reagan?
Who could possibly believe that he just forgot a $500,000 vacation?
Joe Biden a lifelong politician who's a multi-millionaire it's amazing how Democrats standards don't apply to themselves
Can't blame it on his wife!! LOL
It's amazing how Joe Biden became a multi-millionaire as a lifelong politician.
@@Upper-cr1kh How is moscow?
@@michaelspring3915 can't come up with the counter argument so you asked how Moscow is 🤣
We the American people must do something about this illegitimate court.
Find and Vote for candidates that will fight this in the Senate.
What do you suggest?
MSNBC is feeding you Dog Turds telling you it's Escargot! 😂😂😂😂😂
It's all a crock of 💩!
Thomas knew his responsibilities in reporting. This obvious lack of transparency makes him unfit to serve on the highest court in the county. In what world does he just get to say “oops, left that out” and keep on. He needs to be removed because he is the kind of parasite who will not do the taxpayers he serves the favor of leaving.
FAFO lib. 😁
The best way to determine the integrity of someone's character is to give them absolute power and see what they do with it. Do they use it to help others or merely to enrich themselves? I think we know all we need to know about the SCOTUS, and it's not good.
Anyone on the Supreme Court is smart enough to know they omitted the "gifts." Things must change for SCOTUS.
In my job, if I was to accept a gift, and did not declare it, I'd be fired or at the very least receive some serious discipline. Its estimated Thomas has received over 4 million in the last 20 years.
Yeah. When I had a real job, we had to declare gifts over $30. I just gave them away, to avoid paperwork. (I'm lazy.)
Wonder if Thomas paid taxs on that $4 million?
Same. I worked a low-level job in municipal government. All City employees were open to discipline or termination if we accepted any gift from a private citizen or party. We were instructed to say an appreciative "thank you" but then nicely explain that City policy prohibits us from taking it. Even if it was something as simple and relatively inexpensive as a can of Pepsi on a hot day, for example.
Racist!!
They know better
28 U.S.C. Sec. 455 deals with the disqualification of district court judges and it states in part: Any justice, judge, or magistrate, of the United States shall disqualify himself/herself in any proceeding in which his/her impartiality might reasonably be questioned.
It ‘looks like corruption’, it is corruption.
The arrogance of this court is appalling and reprehensible... Thomas and Alito should be impeached at the very LEAST...
Democrats are trying, republicans are blocking. Vote in more democrat senators.
Sotomeyer too.
They don't care!!! So disgusting
Liberal justices have the same issue,stay informed. Ol Sotomeyer has plenty written about her.
@@RickMcGuire-bl2vs< liar. Troll. Spreads misinformation. Promotes terrorism.
From Australia I am watching and thinking, how can they have a job for life with no accountability? Is this the American royal family?
i am also an Oz. The basic problem is that all US supreme court appointments are at least in part a political act, and also seen as the final arbitrator of justice in the US. Most of the problems that have happened are because the politicians are afraid to act. The people should decide about abortion, execution, schooling and so on.
whichever way the election goes it is difficult to see what things will be like in 2 years!
Gane if Thrones,, live on our tv
That's what I have been thinking.. And I reason that I watch.. Why watch fiction when the real drama is happening before us.. but perhaps without the nudity and dragons
The media needs to stop calling it "gifts" and start calling it "bribes". Every single time.
The key to a Democrat propaganda is swaying the opinions of the ignorant sheep like yourself, without outright opening themselves up to defamation suits. This wasn't a bribe by any legal or moral basis. There was nothing given in return. No quid pro quo. It was a gift and completely legal. And you will continue to cope and seethe
Thomas wanted the best of it... and sold his soul to get it... the man is the worst kind of slave... the willing slave...
House slave
How can you say "looks like corruption"? This is a corruption period!
Their OWNED by GE....
Cool opinion.
It's a legal distinction & not as bad as you think. Most ethical declarations include not just corruption but the appearance of corruption. SCOTUS Justices are currently flouting ethical bans that in ordinary judges includes both corruption + the appearance of corruption. So they aren't softening it, more like it's twice as bad bc they don't even care about hiding it.
lies lies lies resign resign resign
28 U.S.C. Sec. 455 deals with the disqualification of district court judges and it states in part: Any justice, judge, or magistrate, of the United States shall disqualify himself/herself in any proceeding in which his/her impartiality might reasonably be questioned.
They lied about Hunter’s laptop for years.
@@herballycorrectTrump continues to lie everyday about everything.
@@herballycorrect who’s what?
Impeach, impeach, impeach!
How shameful. The level of corruption is so disturbing. 🇺🇸💙
yep all the way up to the FJB
Really, nothing about the big guy getting 10% from foreign nations? You guys really do you live in a bubble
Thank you for the reporting.... I didn't realize that the Supreme Court was doing this awesome and on track. 😊
Supreme Court needs to be accountable for their actions. Thomas and Alito need to be reprimanded/impeached for their disrespect of their own code of ethics.... they need to start by being TRUTHFUL with the American people and congress needs to hold hearings...
They need to be “”” charged with BREAKING THE LAW “”” like every other citizen would be!!!
What we need is someone to OVERSEE the Not-So-Supreme Court!
Not while Trump is running for office, and highly likely manage to cheat his way in to the White House
What truly needs to be done is to get a majority in the House and Senate enough so these Judges who think they are immune get impeached and removed from office Since Congress can do so. They need to also look at the Trump appointees who seemingly lied in their Senate confirmation hearings.
If they remove all five of those Justices then when they confirm the replacements some of those replacements should be on the moderate side.
Congress should also do something about Cannon as well since she is risking our national security over the Trump documents case.
They need to also impose an ethics standard on the Supreme Court as well and consider setting up term limits concerning all federal Judges.
Reprimanded ? They’re not toddlers they need to be impeached and charged for taking bribes and failure to pay taxes
SENATE JUDICIARY....PLEASE....BEGIN the IMPEACHMENT process against Justice Thomas.
LET'S DO THAT....!.
And Alito!
Wait to until and if the Dems get both houses and the presidency - otherwise it’s a waste of time
With the amount of support that Trump has from the Senate, do you really think that is going to happen?
Bahaha. Good luck with that.
Hello just to make things clear, the Senate cannot repeat cannot impeach anyone. The constitution puts the impeachment power in the House. The Senate can only vote on impeachment once the House has brought charges. You think MAGA Mike is going to do anything to wound his Lord and Master Trump???? Trump now owns our House of Representatives....reprehensible!
It is too late for recusal. Now, it's time for prison.
If he can't understand how to fill out a simple form for disclosures of massive gifts he accepted then how can he understand and rule on constitutional law? We need to hold the justices responsible for their actions. There should also be term limits and accountability for their actions, no one is above the law!
Corruption that they can not be held accountable for. That is horrendous.
Alito and Thomas Must Recuse or be Removed!
Same with Aileen Cannon.
Whaaaa whaaaa whaaaa, Democrats always crying about the Supreme Court, if it was 6-3 liberal you wouldn't hear a peep from them 😅😅😅
You say that but I wonder what your opinion of judge merchan is
Ole Clarence has got his and there aint nothin any body can do about it.
They won't be because the problem is fundamental.
The smell of corruption is strong in this one
Alito and Thomas need to voluntarily resign. But being corrupt and power hungry they’ll burn it down on the way out. 💛💙🇺🇸🇺🇦
We love the SCOTUS
The Ukraine flag huh, it's replaced the mask as the sign of a crazy person.
@@brucecampbell4528 🇺🇦
Do you really think that they will volunteer to leave the gravy train? Not gonna happen.
@@brucecampbell4528 I ❤️ 🇺🇦
Alito and Thomas have brought disgrace to their office and need to step down. We must restore integrity and impartiality to the highest court in the land.
*DOJ - DO YOUR JOB - INDICT ALITO & THOMAS FOR THEIR TAX CRIMES*
they can't if they did they'd have to go after FJB
Do not forget about liberal justices
Don’t let Donald get more Supreme Court picks. They will last for decades. vote!
He wont need Supreme Court picks once he is dictator...
Q: What do Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and Biden all have in common?
A: They all arrested their political enemies!
@@herballycorrect funny you didn't say Putin. Aaaaaannnyway, Biden didn't do anything about arresting Trump. Georgia arrested Trump for trying to coerce state officials to "find votes". NY state brought the indictment and he was NOT arrested. He might go to jail but that's on him for committing felonies that 12 jurors unanimously agreed upon.
@@herballycorrect keep taking your meds 🤡
@@herballycorrect What do Stalin, Hitler, Mao, Jong Un, Putin, Xi & Trump have in common! Yep you guessed it....all were or are a wannabe Dictator!!!
THEY DON'T CARE!! END OF STORY!! The Senate has the power to end this!
How exactly? Please explain
They can't end it but they can and should hold hearings. Doing nothing is insane!
Exactly!
“… The power to end this”
That would be 2A
The Senate can proceed with an investigation. VOTE BLUE
It's so easy to inadvertantly omit $4 millions of gifts over a nondescript career.
Hope he paid taxes on them.
Its none of anyones business, especially noisy leftys 😅😅😅😅
Racist!!
Our top court in our land should set a GOOD example and set a GOOD standard not embarrass us with their member's corrupt behavior. No shame! No character!
Impeach and remove Thomas and Alito.
What about Jackson’s?
“Maga Evil has stained the Soul of America 🇺🇸 “
- Buddha
Seriously? The Buddha said that?
@@linnetcooke5967 It was Chris Christie! 😂😂😂
@@linnetcooke5967 Sure did!!
Make America great again is evil ?
Can't blame this one on his wife or on a neighbors !!!
He can always blame Trump.
Just like the jailed insurrectionists.
Nobody cares 😅😅😅😅
He will blame the boogie man
@@b.t.2795 Thomas has been accepting bribes for over 20 years. So he was corrupt even before Trump.
I love the frank comparison of death penalty litigants losing a final right of appeal for paperwork errors, while Clarence gets an "oopsie". Thank you.
If the litigants on death row were SCOTUS justices, they wouldn't be on death row. Not a good comparison at all, and not even a comparable crime. Not that it shouldn't be, but under the way the court is governed, it's apparently not a crime at all. That's what you get when you have a self-policing government body.
How are these people completely immune to the law??
So, uncle Clarence didn’t realize he had to report gifts? Dumb as a rock, completely corrupt, or both.
Time to go after these judges that are clearly corrupt
They only have the obligation to report the gifts. There's is no check on whether it was done correctly. Or what consequences to face when they don't abide by it.
We should also thank Senator Sheldon Whitehouse for exposing the corruption in our SCOTUS.
thank you, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse
What about his corruption?
thank you, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse
thank you for your service
Some of these judges are not law abiding citizens. Something needs to be done quickly & don't sit on your hands like Merrick Garland.
"inadvertently omitted"
sure you did clarence
People should be out on the streets protesting against the Supreme Court.
That'll come when they grant presidential immunity to trump**.
Unfair. The Supreme Court is the best that money can buy.
Worst
Jesus is the Majestic of the Heavenly Supreme Court & he only recognize money in silver & gold and no other kind he will accept😅😅😊.
Al Capone and Clarence Thomas … both tax evaders.
😂😂😂 good one 🤟👌
Donald Trump too
its one thing to inadvertently forget to disclose dinner at Red lobster but forgetting $500,000 vecation is something else. who forgets a 500K Vecay.
If they get away with it this time, there is no stopping them
Why are Judges allowed to accept any gifts of monetary value? Regardless of disclosures. If a lawyer goes the path of judgeship, they are effectively forfeiting a higher salary they could make in the private sector. That is an active choice, no one is being forced to be a judge. You can’t compensate a “lower” salary by accepting hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of favors and experiences. You can’t possibly receive “gifts” with “no strings attached”.
When you have no accountability supreme power corrupts. Absolutly.
Justice Thomas and Justice Alito, a concerned citizen, ask you kindly to have some honor and dignity and resign.
No We love the SCOTUS
Come on now… Justice Uncle Ruckus and Justice Toadstool have no honor nor dignity, so there’ll be no resignation much less recusal.
Don’t hold your breath. Not gonna happen with these guys.
Those are qualities that all sociopaths lack.
Why just those 2? All of them are corrupt.
No one should have lifetime appointments.
As a scotus member, he SHOULD have been honest from the start and REFUSED ALL gifts, bribes, etc. in his position. His wife also knew better, so what's her excuse? Those two are corrupt + they both provided us with the ABSOLUTE TRUTH.
The monarchy in the UK doesn't even get to behave like your supreme court.
Even the Democrats are scared of uttering the 'I' word. Alito and Thomas must be impeached.
Register for vote. Help others to register. Go and vote all democrats. GOP want to ban contraception, IVF, abortion. Vote all democrats for womens rights and health care 💙🌊😎.
No one should be okay with this.
I agree continuously attacking a black judge because you don't have control is racist by democrats. Let's not forget Democrats history who put black people in slaves founded the KKK and implemented the Jim Crow laws
@@Upper-cr1kh So, you are okay with the corruption then? How unAmerican of you.
@@wtfisthishandIebuIlshit what corruption you act like Democratic politicians don't go on vacations with rich people. Hypocrisy is a form of desperation
@@Upper-cr1khmost people understand that the Democratic Party was conservative at one point. So stop the gaslighting.
@@L3L3L3 another person who doesn't know the Democrat history. News flash Democrats were never Republicans they were Dixiecrats. Imagine supporting a party with that kind of History
Inadvertently!!!!!!!!!!!!
That must now be every criminals defence. 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
You cannot be a Trump supporter AND a moral human being.
Fact checked true.
Definitely a conflict of interest.
Whaaaa whaaaa whaaaa, Democrats always crying about the Supreme Court, if it was 6-3 liberal you wouldn't hear a peep from them 😊
Yes!!!!👍
Explain please
Our government needs to take action against the Supreme Court judges
Yes, but only the Congress can make it happen. Today, the Congressional divide is extreme, as we can see. At the voting boxes this fall, we CAN fix that problem . . . . . . . perhaps.
@@billbernhard3582 while we may not be able to remove him but we can do something about him accepting gifts?
Whaaaaat? People don't like corrupt judges.... Especially supreme court judges?! Who'd have ever thought!?!
Inadvertently Omitted ON PURPOSE!
Can we sue these Judges?
Justice from corrupt judges....yeh, right.
Total corruption will lead to total ruin.
Thomas has clearly been bribed. Blackmailed TOO ???
More like whitemailed.
That kind of money always includes a collar and leash. As absolutely awful as that sounds, it is true.
TERM LIMIT SCOTUS- and then convict them for corruption when pay to play schemes like this emerge.
An "inadvertent" lack of disclosure of gifts is still subject to the irs. The irs should be investigating.
Justice Marshall is DEFINITELY rolling in his grave
See the problem is. Less talking about it and debating about it. And more actually doing something about it.
That's the thing with false accusations you can never do nothing about it
@@Upper-cr1khhush troll
@@byzantium8851 having a hard time making a counter argument I see. Keep showing that intelligence of yours
@@Upper-cr1kh Well here's the paddle. Did you bring lunch? We're going to be stuck going in circles.
@@SusenFreemyers1374 so your counter argument is asking me if I brought a lunch? 🤣 You act like Democrats don't go on vacations with rich people. Hypocrisy is a form of desperation
So in corporate world take gifts from outside entities is a sackable offence but at the pinnacle, the very top of the law, the creators of law, if ok to take gifts? And fail to declare them? No shame. He doesn’t even resign.
Finally caught!
This has to end. Vote blue.
Any politician or Judge whom receives any gift or favour should lose their job and be prohibited from holding any office that represents the people
The Senate needs to begin Impeachment hearings for Justices Thomas, Alito and Kavanaugh now.
The Senate cannot initiate impeachments. That lies with the House.
Don’t forget i lean right. Cannon! !!
Trump first!!!!
Exactly, we have the numbers in Congress no matter how slim, it’s time to take that chance and not let these corrupt “Justices” keep up with the arrogance that nobody is above them! 🇺🇸🇺🇸
LOL don't hold your breath.
Inadvertently my a**. Why isn’t he being investigated for accepting bribes?
they think they are untouchable. we need to show them otherwise
Disbarred the Supreme judge! Immediately following the other judges involved.
How?
Fascist.
"Gifts" "gift" ... I'm pretty sure that the word you are searching for is "bribe".
They appear to have been effective bribes as well.
Uncle Thomas sure has done his job good.
Inadvertently? You mean chose not to till caught. 🤦
Judge should be held countable along with all others who is guilty of accepting luxury gifts and being bought off
Justice well not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are period 🌻😊
Can I sue the Supreme Court? If not, what about each of the hypocritical members of it? I've been affected by their actions, so has every American. Can we all sue them?
This is disgusting! Corruption has entered the highest level in our courts.
Trump admires communist leaders that’s how they run their countries and he’s done the same good luck cleaning this lot up
INEXCUSABLE, period.
What voting rights did the Supreme Court remove?
i'm furious... and i'm not even american 😤😡
I understand you 😔
Come from Germany 🇩🇪
ITS so terrible what happened in the USA.
WE can't belive it.
How dare can this be.
@@Giantly Bwahahaha yeah a German saying that.
Why is no one talking about impeaching Alito and Thomas? They can be impeached!
Would like to know what else he 'forgot' to disclose. How about putting him under oath?
Like he wouldn't lie under oath
Literal definition of “THE SWAMP “. Look no further.
Resign! Thomas has lost all credibility!
He never had any.
Thank goodness. What a great video and report. Yes, finally someone is pointing out America is training these people to flout the law by inaction.
The modern-day SCOTUS has become yet another example of how absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Trump is no longer in Office.