FMAB - Edward's Mercy
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ค. 2012
- I really love this part so I decided to upload this
please sub to this person
/ immafmabrotherhood
Japan International Inc., Square Enix, Aniplex, UGA, Bandai, Adult Swim, TBS, MangaUK, OR ANY OTHER COMPANIES ASSOCIATED WITH FULL METAL ALCHEMIST BROTHERHOOD. THIS IS A COMPILATION VIDEO AND NOTHING MORE. PLEASE SUPPORT THE OFFICIAL RELEASE. - บันเทิง
me trying to pull a band-aid off my arm
Crying it's so true
little late but your picture fits quite perfectly XD
eh?
Look at his profile pic and imagine that with him pulling a bandaid off ^^
Try a Band-Aid that covers your entire skin.
"I'll just have to use my own life force, the same way I would a philosopher's stone."
*after life shortening transmutation
"Hey look, a philosopher's stone!"
So true
Ed wouldn't have used it anyway. They swore not to use the stones for personal gain
+LucifertheGir that stupid because if you thinks about it these people are dead for nothing :(
That's like trying to do something that's hard then learning the easy way after the fact
+PermaFr0st He vowed to never use a Philosopher's stone since it's the devil's research.
FMAB lessons:
Showing mercy: you may get impaled but youre still a good person.
nrj6490 But when you think about it, it actually paid off later. If Edward had killed Kimblee, Pride wouldn't have absorbed Kimblee's soul, resulting in Ed having his body taken over by Pride in episode 60. Yes, showing mercy can get you into trouble and may even cost you your life. Still, it's better than the alternative.
BlueTeller Do you mean "Equivalent exchange"? Maybe that is the point.
Ed didn't kill Kimblee, so Kimblee saves Ed :3
420Praiseit Git gud no they just would have sent someone else to free him
@420Praiseit Gitgudneosucksasstoo they would have sent someone else
@420Praiseit Gitgudneosucksasstoo envy
It's ironic since Kimblee stated that Ed's mercy was going to get him in a lot of trouble (which brought him in such a bad situation), but his mercy to the two villains is what got him out of the trouble after his fight with Kimblee.
crazyconan28 sad part his it also got him 2 very useful allies one of which leads to Kimblee's demise
This whole anime is full of irony if you think about it lol
It's also why Kimblee respects Edward's convictions. When Pride cries: "He'll kill me!" at the end, Kimblee responds "If you think that, then you still do not understand Edward Elric".
@@Pfisiar22
That's the interesting thing about Kimblee. No matter what kind of values they are, he'll respect you if you hold true to them. It's the hypocrites, people who abandon their convictions at the drop of a hat, that he can't stand.
@@VGamingJunkie If I had to assign Kimblee an alignment I would say he's Lawful Evil.
Oh look at that. I've been impaled.
Don't do that please.
I'M SORRY
The feels are hitting me like a train right now...
Same omg
***** Yep, that's what I was referring to.
The worst part is that Edward had to drain years off of his lifespan when the Philosopher’s Stone was sitting a few feet away
He wouldn't have used even if he knew.... He swore to never use a philosopher stone because it is made up of human lives
Is it just me who found that a bit cheesy? Like since when could he heal himself? It was somewhat justified with the "taking years out of his lifespan", but since it comes out of nowhere it feels like plot armour.
@@manolgeorgiev9664 Yeah but I think it's kinda justified since the philosopher's stone is made of souls and he used his own soul to disregard the law of equivalent exchange
@@manolgeorgiev9664 Something that only people like Edward who went to the other side of the door, which is the truth, can do
@@hydratedgraph2486 he didn't disregard the law of equivalent exchange, he applied it when he paid several years of his life
Well I'm glad they didn't leave him lion around.
Just,no.
Haha i see what you did there
*inhales
BOI
Pearl, is that you?
Damn it, Barbara.
Okay, guys, let's be honest; most of us, in that situation, would be bawling ourselves to dehydration from the pain. Four for you, Ed.
Actually, most of us probably would have passed out from the pain
It I had the balls to go through that.. im sure it would have killed me.
I would have passed out definantly and I probably would've broken some guys ear drum first doh... XD
and seriously, GET THIS GUY SOME PAINKILLERS XD
He's probably in shock, which helped at least a little. That kind of trauma would definitely put you into shock.
how did ed sacrifice some of his life span ? can anyone explain?
Awww poor Edward, HOW MUCH PAIN DOES EVERY ANIME CHILD HAVE TO GO THROUGH?!?!?
I read a fan fiction where all the characters see the future in a room by watching the fmab episodes. The catch is that there's pain for every injury you gain, but worse than before. So everyone like Mustang and Hughes had to watch this happen. Its called "Truth Revealed"
DisillusionStarFruit
name of that FANFICTION
Its "Truth Revealed" :D
Thankyou verry much
He's not that young for most of the series, at least not for the time period anyway.
i tried to search this vid with: "edward elric pole scene"
sounded so wrong but i found it .-.
oml lmao
I searched "Edward gets impaled."
Tia Aaron hot metal asf blonde gets penetrated while two wild men watches
IMustTurd Has this gone too far?
omg XD
My thoughts through this whole scene were "yeouch"
Ive had needles drug through my skull but i still couldn't imagine how painful that was
Well ed is half philosopher stone
@@Katarinarabbit he still feels pian like normal
I actually gagged a few times, came close to puking, which is surprising because I can usually handle blood.
and to think he was scarred of needles not to long ago
Thats not a needle tho
Paragon Trayn logic man a sword is more scary that a needle
or whatever that was
being impaled is more scary then a flu shot
i aint though. seriously!!
Vic Mignogna take a FUCKIN BOW SIR! That voice acting was damn incredible!
Derek Collins ikr 😭
Derek Collins for real I could listen to his Ed voice all fucking day
I completely Agree!
This is the first anime show I've ever watched, and man, I picked a f*cking amazing place to start!
By far one of the most painful scenes in FMAB, Ed sacrificing his own years in order to heal himself so he can help everyone else, such determination from this character, this deserves to be a masterpiece anime.
Thanks for uploading, peace✌🏻️
I'll be honest it had my hairs coming off my entire body while I kinda got this odd feeling of sickness.
Duron this is exactly the kind of thing that makes this anime so great. Eds character is amazing
Nope ... don't forget he didn't scream during the entire operating of getting his arm and leg... he was conscious and without taking any kinds of painkillers ... getting a giant pillar out of him is nothing compared to what he's been through so far
Nigga, he was dying regardless
Jay Duron bb
The shit Edward goes through, man
I know right. I just finished this show the other day, and of my gosh... Those Poor kids went through so freaking much!
or goes through him in that case
He came out on top, I’d say
@@marcopohl4875 I just physically choked
I love how this show forgets pretty muc *No One* neena had such a meaningful death. Even though she was there for one episode, the mention her a lot and show flashbacks and everything.
I love the fact that it's Edward's mercy that gets him into this precarious situation, refusing to kill Kimblee - but it's the very same mercy that allowed both the Chimera to live, and save him.
Not to mention, all the good they end up doing down the line too.
That has to do with FMA’s biggest lesson. That a person’s greatest power is their potential for unity alongside their fellow man, that nothing is more powerful or important than human connection
'Remember that feeling, how it felt to use souls, TO HARNESS... LIFE!!!!'
'Oh wait, here's a stone.'
XD
Yeah, I'll never understand why either Darius or Heinkel didn't bother looking for the philosopher stone nearby. Ehhh, must have been a plot inconvenience.
summerguy03 ikr
He wouldn't have used it anyway.
Ed knew it was down there but he refuses to use the stone because to him its using up other human lives and he refuses to do that.
@@TChops-hi7hr The two Chimera's didnt know ot was down there. Ed did but Ed refuses to use the stone. He only used it ince and that was to get out of Gluttony.
I really loved how Darius and Heinkle became good guys here. They ended up being pretty damn vital later on and they were never really evil to begin with.
Just soldiers following orders they couldn’t have known were evil
@@RobertsonIslandwell…Good Soldiers Follow Orders. Glad Darius, Heinkle, Zampano and Jerso teamed up with Ed & Al
I love how his hair just stands up like "Yeah I'm alive suck an egg"
Reminds me of red vs blue when they thought Church died and he comes back and says and I quote "miss ne assholes" it made my entire week
oh a philosophers stone! that would have been helpful.
No it wouldn't, Edward and Alphonse has sworn not to use the philosphers stone to regain thier bodies. (stones being what they are).
***** Twas a joke. We all know this.
Hahaha I know right XD.
@@coldfusionstormgaming1808 they do the only reason they don't use it to get there bodies back is that they made that mistake and they won't use the souls of the philosophers stone to pay for their sins
@@coldfusionstormgaming1808 using the stone to save your own life and getting your body back are two different things
It's really amazing how after this scene Ed suddenly grown a lot and seemed much more mature. I was always wondering why did he suddenly changed so much within a year but rewatching it I realized that this scene is the reason. The years that he sacrificed basically caught up to him. It's fucking amazing how much detail did the manga's author put into this work.
I dont think that is the reason, i presume if you lose Llifetime your healthy ages will be shorter and then you die a couple of years sooner but it doesnt modifies your growing up process. Puberty just hitted Ed like a truck in a good moment xD
Actually, he seems to grow older because they to two years later
HIROMU ARAKAWA BITCHES!!
He grows at the end of the seires because al isnt fused to his soul anymore, al's body was taking half of every nutrient he had, which is explained why he eats so much and why hes short, and why als body didnt die well it was in the gate
@@blackstar_onjugthat's right. He's a big eater yet he's still short when he's still in his growing period
this scene is why i like the american dub over the original japanese. vic mignogna fucking nails every single line perfectly
I know right
And I love his voice acting in his role
But Seriously how can he not have felt it when he gets stabbed in the chest but it might be because he was unconscious when it happened
But it's really cool how he never gave up
StarmenRock doesn't Vic mignogna voice tamaki?
I still prefer the original Japanese since not all Eng dub is as great as the Eng dub in FMAB :/
Amen to that😎💜💜💜
When I first saw this I cringed and nearly cried. I love Ed to death and this almost killed me inside!
ME TOO
YOUR inside? just imagine how his must have felt 0_0
binarystar300 Wow thanks that made me feel even better about it! :P
That's strange it almost killed him tooo... lol XD
blinkyoureyes1400 Hahahaha! Wow, great joke there bud! You think you are just so witty don't you?! But no. :P
To the people who say why he couldn't just transmuted the bar is because his organs are crushed and he'll die anyways....so he needed alchemy to rearrange those organs, but its not exactly the best fix. Wow, fmab, this is why I love you.
Karamanga Plus, he would've bled to death anyway if it was just removed. Anyone who is medically trained knows being impaled with any object (arrow, sharp poles, etc.) you need to carefully trim down the object first and then be ready to stop the bleeding immediately. Lol also he would have to transmute it into something else, it wouldn't just disappear.
@@joosoo he could've transmuted the pole into the air
@@myneneedssomequalitytimein8908 Let's suppose it's a steel bar, and probably carbon steel considering it is the most common. That means an alloy of 90% iron and 10% carbon roughly. The atmosphere we breathe has about 20% oxygen (O2) and 80% nitrogen, along with additional trace elements such as argon, CO2, and methane. So no, he cannot transmute a steel bar into air.
@@joosoo what I went is the could transmute the pole into particles so small there floating around in the air
@@myneneedssomequalitytimein8908 They still have to go somewhere, yes you can break them down into dust, but iron and carbon are both elements and can't be broken down any further. So he would just have a pile of iron and carbon dust in his wound.
I know this scene is suppose to be gruesome and gut wrenching, but I found it adorable when Ed's little hair thing moved xD
His ahoegae
Yo
Like him or not, Vic deserved an award for this scene because it was very powerful and an emotional moment for anybody who loves Ed.
Tf why on gods green earth would anyone dislike him?
@@IkesPimpHandbogus allegations which pretty much ruined his career
I remember seeing this in the manga and my eyes started throwing up tears... my poor baby Ed D': Vic Mignogna did great in this scene. But Edward >< wahhhhhh
***** 69
As much as I hate this scene, I also love this scene.
Hate it because my anime crush is getting hurt here
Love it 'cuz he's such a badass
same
Ahahaha he's my anime crush too.
hes too cute :3
He's my anime crush too! He is so cool. He is my hero.
Edward is my anime crush too! He's so cooool!!!
One of the emotionally powerful scenes in the anime for Ed. Great moment
Oh. My. God. Seriously, great job by Vic. One of my all time favorite performances in anime. Such a powerful scene.
To bad they fired him
They made a grave mistake. And cause of their little freak show/ public stunts, they also lost a lot of respect
I can't imagine vic mignogna screaming from pain in the recording booth so perfectly omg!!!!
when you PURPOSEFULLY stub your toe to get the best scream you can.
Same guy nearly blew his vocal cords out when he voiced Broly
it was just a splinter. lol
Hakeem Elamin lmao it's just a flesh wound 😂
tis but a scratch
No it was a touch of leaves
It's nothing he can't walk off
Heneesommilk
The funny thing is, even though Edward payed the price of being impaled due to his mercy, he gained two allies in Heinkel and Darius who were both allies on The Promised Day. Arguably, Al wouldn't have survived the fight with Kimblee and Pride if it weren't for Heinkel, so this one act of Mercy could've saved the world.
I would've just let myself die. But not Ed! He's got a mission to complete and no stupid come-outta-nowhere mineshaft pole is gonna change that!
Same.
And that's why this is my Favorite Anime of all time.
Who had chills down their spine after watching this? Vic Micnonga put a lot of character to even SCREAM in pain as if he was in pain. Making this by far the best I've seen in the franchise.
You can almost feel the Metal being ripped out of YOUR OWN BODY when watching this. Also, that ending where it fades into the ending song is so smooth! Song's awesome too, and the song while Ed transmuted his wound was cool too. Brotherhood had a killer anime soundtrack!
Legit, I could never explain this moment any better
yet he nearly died from getting stabbed by a small knife in the third fullmetal alchemist game
Being stabbed in the stomach in the same spot for the second time tends to do that to you.
***** fma 03, the fma games, and brotherhood are all their own canons. Alother thing - it's not the same spot. The stab wound in the game was more centered.
+X51 A gut wound is a very dangerous one. A hole in your gut will cause you to die a slow and painful death, and can be incapacitating.
Evnyofdeath depends on the details. If it hit your intestines or ribs/kidneys rather than your liver or stomach, you'll tend to survive those far easier.
.midival_Minstrel Yeah ...Wait!!
When the ending starts playing at 3:30... chillz of nostalgia!
Facts
Man that is the catchiest ending i have ever heard of.
In my opnion, It's even better than the openings.
@@herivelton1973 Eh. I always thought it was generic as fuck
@@DefeatLust how come?
@@arai6147 It just sounds generic. Nothing special. Just a tune rapping up the show. Meh
This is honestly one of the best dubs of all anime. I usually watch sub, but fma has really put in the work and effort into making this an amazing and truly talented dub.
This scene always makes my stomach turn. Imagine the pain he's going through. Then you realize that Ed is practically still a Kid. Man, why must these Anime characters go through so much.
i love vic. He's a great actor and he also sings. He's an awesome person. I love FMAB and FMA.
Erin Phoenix same
Oh damn he *sings*?! 😍
nobodyNothing Anonymous user he sang the Dragon ball z Kai opening
nobodyNothing Anonymous user yeah, he led worship services at his church. He's an evangelical Christian.
That moment when you almost throw up due to sympathy pain... I won't be moving from this spot until I can convince myself I'm not almost dying.
Vic is such a great voice actor, his vocal range is incredible talking in a soft tone and screaming like Broly it's amazing XD
yea i love him and his voice so much!
Those monsters were more human than the people that run the military (except Bradley)
Bradley WAS human. And he was the most inhuman human in the military.
If you were referring to Bradly because he's a homunculus, remember, he's a homunculus-controlled human, just like Ling/Greed. Human Body, Homunculus controlled.
If you were referring to Bradly cause he SEEMED okay.....remember, he was the most evil of the bunch. When Hughes died, he wasn't trembling with grief at the funeral. He was trembling with rage cause Hughes daughter was crying, and it annoyed the piss out of him. He staged the war with Ishval, and then armed his men with fake philosopher stones to make sure their slaughter was as great as possible. He was TRAINED to be this way, as we see with the failed "King Bradley's" near the end of the show. The men is PURE EVIL, and Bradley was the best of the worst.
It's so sad that even after all that, when he finally got his and Al's body back Ed will have such a short life ;-; ....he deserves to life longer!
*Shorter, not short. "It'd probably take a few years from my lifespan though". A few years can be just that, a few years. So he'd die at 76 instead of 80. Who'd care?
4 Years are a long time he surely would've wanted to spend with his family..
Binova Art Time is relative. Yeah 4 years is a long time for me and you. But trust me for most people it matters little if they die at 76 or 80.
I know.....still it's sad
I would assume he lived alot longer in the original anime
If I remember correctly the last we saw him in that one he was like 100 or something :)
This scene is fucking amazing. Very powerful and the voice actor did a great job. Edward is such an amazing character / alchemist to be able to do this
Ah... This scene brings back a fondness that I have for FMAB especially when I watched it the first time the person who wrote FMA is a genius.
2:56 WOW that would help about 10 seconds ago
carlos salazar Ed wouldn't have used it though
Poor Edward :c Hearing him scream in pain like that made me cry :'(
Oh man... Every time that music wells up, so do I...
The pole being slowly pulled out of his stomach is the most visceral and disturbing scene in the entire show.
Darius: Your guts have got to be all messed up, you're going to need to use a philosopher stone to make this work.
Edward: I'm going to have to use my own life force like a philosopher stone. Not like I have a choice.
Later on; Heinkel: Hey, look a philosopher stone.
Edward: FUCK.
Eds yell always gives me goosebumps and it makes me sad 😔
Vic Mignogna... such a great job portraying Ed's pain and will to power through.
Me from 0:00-2:08: *crying*
2:09-2:43: Whew...
2:45-2:54: AAAHHH!!!
2:55-onward: *flips table in frustration*
This scene made me very emotional, in case that wasn't clear.
You should drink some tea Madeline.
FMAB does a good job at that
Top notch voice acting, Vic. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
The most painful scene in anime ever. Now that I think of it I think ed is the only character in the history of anime to go through as much pain as he has throughout his life.
So glad this happened within the context of the story. I almost can’t put into words how vital a scene like this is. 👍 Vic Did such an superb job.
"It is worse to commit an injustice than to suffer one" - Plato
I could write an essay about all the reasons why I love this scene.
The music here is so beautiful and hit at every moment it needed to hit.
I just remember finding this to be such an intense episode, especially because of this scene. I felt so bad for Edward here, but he's such a trooper.
The first time I saw this episode and saw the pole through Ed’s stomach I was like
“Oh crap. This sucks”
The way he used himself without knowing he’s actually a philosopher Stone is awesome
When I saw that I simply thought that he was for to stubborn to die even if he had to transmute the pole and his wound just to have to deal with blood poisoning after dragging himself to Briggs HQ
I love how his hair just stuck up aftet
When Ed says "I'm a philosophers stone powered by a single soul," I start crying. Just from the pain and determination in his voice. Whoever says Ed's English voice actor isn't good is crazy
fun fact: Hiromu Arakawa wrote this scene in the manga to represent the pain she went through when giving birth to her first child
Women really do be this dramatic
Grognak The Destroyer+ No, I think this is a fair comparison.
@@rikiishitoru8885 do you, not know how painful child birth is?
@@rikiishitoru8885 I'm pretty sure childbirth can be pretty painful, though I'm not a female, I would imagine having constant contractions for hours on end pushing the baby out I think can be really painful.
I'm not saying it isn't painful, I just don't think it's comparable to being impaled through the gut by a giant metal rod
I love how people said that he could have just used the stone. But, even if they had it, he wouldn't have used other souls but his own
Some of this voice actors best work.
I just realized that during this whole process ed didn't shed a single tear...
Edward elric such a goated protagonist one of the best of all time
Truth must've spotted him a bit for this one, according to some after series drawings, he makes it to 88.
This show was so fucking well written.
This is so touching. I love these scenes. The whole anime is awesome the creators did a very good job.
*gets impaled by steel*
Ed: Oh no
Also Ed: anyway
I remember this scene in the manga being so emotional... they nailed it in the anime too! Supurb job!
This is why Edward elric deserves a harem
Absolutly one of my favorite scenes. It really showcases Ed's fortitude and perseverance to remain a good person no matter what he suffered. Its just amazing.
I love this beautiful show and its amazing quality
This Show is so good, a simple Idea like a Metalpiece stuck inside your Body and you have to heal it whitout Dying. Its such a big Deal and so painfull, and thats great, its one of the most intense Scenes in the Story.
And Storywhise, it repressented the Toll Ed had to pay for the Decition to not kill. He does not get rewarded, he imideatly gets tested, and despite the Result he does not changes his Mind.
Thats why he gains Kimbleys Respect later.
Everyones talking about how there was a stone just a few feet away, but you know that even if he knew it was there, Ed wouldn't have used it.
The first time I seen this I was in shock. The pain he must have been going through after realizing what happened is like wow. At first you have that adrenaline and then when it wears out you feel the pain. It must have been hard not to pass out or die from that cause he had to stay awake to heal himself. Good job voice actor for that voice. You nailed it that sounded....so awfully good.
al’s recruitment method: be the most pure human alive
ed’s recruitment method: be a chad
This show has so much angst, it’s great for us writers 😌
That’s just crushing to watch. The determination, the sacrifice, and then the utter pointlessness of it . You can’t help what you don’t know, but having a stone that close and not knowing about it almost seems like a cosmic insult
Ed wouldn't have used it anyway. He swore not to.
God damn it Vic.
0:15 OW when i saw that my side hurt 🤕😨
I saw the sub version of this and it's honestly not the same. With the dub you can hear how much in pain Edward is suffering from the pole being pulled out. Dub wins this for me.
I could not and will not picture anyone else playing ed but Vic.
I love the comrardery of this version of FMA like literally everyone who helps Ed has taken some form of kindness from him and gives it back to him twofold
this is the most saddest part fullmetal alchemist brotherhood
2:58 Ed is like my will to live and the chimeras are me watching it slowly die
The lines of
"Remember what it felt like at that moment. REMEMBER HOW IT FELT TO USE SOULS TO HARNESS LIFE" fucking gets me everytime and Idk why
Okay, I've seen this scene a million times already. I can handle it. *watches video* DANG IT FMAB!!! WHAT HAVE YOU DONE?!?!
It's like the death of Hughes no matter how many times you see no matter how much you mentally prepare it still hits you like a semi-truck
People, please. Edward would never have used the Stone for his own benefit so it didn't matter if the two Chimera men found it earlier.
The brothers have only used the Stone once and it was for the benefit for others.
True.
Did anyone notice that Ed still had that sharp thing on his auto mail what if he stabbed himself just saying shit like that could happen in fmab
Jelani Johnson he probably was more concerned about the giant pole stabbed through him and bleeding to death
I guess this is just gonna show up on my feed 9 years later at 5 AM before a test, huh
I watched this for the first time when i was a kid about 10 years old maybe. And today, i still remember this scne, i cam feel how hurt it was, now i'm 18y.o now.
"Ive gotta picture myself as a single mass of ener-AGHHHHH!!!!!!"
_You Died._
1:22 these are the dialogues our mothers used while giving birth 😔👏🏼
Fun fact, that's actually why this scene was put into the manga. The author recently gave birth and wanted to put something nodding to that in the story
Edwards voice acting was top tier
Love how this was in recommendations, it's been years since I've watched FMAB❤