4:54 "You ARE foolish, all of you...even my own son." Love that delivery. One of Ed Blaylock's finest performances (of which there were many in my opinion).
@Makhi Makharadze father custom made the bodies of the homunculi. Their souls are basically formed from the vices of the population of xerxes. Envy is different. His body itself is formed from people.
Amazing how they had such good writing despite swaying so far from the source material. I really loved this show. Shame modern viewers disregard it entirely.
@@corinneolivier1871 Yes, they did sway. It is not the same story. I know the manga wasn't finished when they made it. The point of my comment was that the anime had excellent writers, which is very rarely the case.
100% I will always take the WInecellar death because just the view of him Choking his HUMAN SON was so much more brutal for the tone. I love Wrath bradley but I can't ever unsee the absolute badassery of Mustang Torching the fucker after he hurt his own kid :). I always hated Pride in FMAB like he wasn't inherently bad but the view on bradley having SOME semblance of humanity from the outside is what made me love his character so much. But fuck watching Bradley wreak havoc on everyone as wrath is a sight to see haha
@@tempestindustries9446 i enjoyed Bradley's death in fmab a lot more than in fma. Generally i prefered fma deaths but i enjoyed bradely's last words in bortherhood i think the instance where the homunculi are more human or insightful i enjoy. in brotherhood his death is triumphant, he dies on his terms, here its the end of a man whos motive is confusing as well as his relationship with his son
@@medalgear654 Nah. As cool as the tank scene was it was way over the top. This scene feels grounded and more intimate. It just comes down to personal preference.
Pride was just toying with Mustang he probably is every bit as powerful as Wrath but his personality was completely different. He was more indulgent and expressive less focused on the task at hand unlike Wrath. To wrath fighting was definitely his outlet and relished the chance to do so.
Yeah, here’s always smiling while fighting, showing his pride, while Wrath barley ever smiled while fighting, showing his wrath and how seriously he took it
I will always stand by how the concept of the homunculi, how they were made and how to kill them, was just so much more impactful in FMA over brotherhood
What I love about the original anime. There wasn’t really a happy ending the characters had to make the best of the consequences. They had to keep moving foward. How that ed and al crossed over to our world. While I love how brother hood gave us that closure. That the hard work wasn’t for nothing. They were able to find a way even someone like scar was able to move foward put his wrath behind him. Fma kept that tone that alchemy isn’t the short cut the people were expecting. There was a much higher price to pay. Good intentions can led down to hfil.
I just love this I understand why FMA wasn’t as good as FMAB as a whole, but one thing I seriously wanted to see stay in FMAB is a fight between Bradley and Mustang A man with much alchemical power vs a man with much political power Seriously, an actual fight between Mustang and Bradley would’ve been badass And nobody bring up the “fight” they had in brotherhood where Wrath just rushes and stabs Mustang while avoiding the flame alchemy, because that wasn’t even a fight, it ended in less than 5 seconds
I love how the original anime handled the homunculus, being the outcome of human transmutation and their only weakness is the remains of the person they once were. It just hits a lot deeper than them being Fathers emotions given life through a stone, an all you have to do is burn out their stone to beat them.
@@алексейпугачев-л9й but that was exactly what happened in bortherhood. Mustang flame blasted two of them over and over and thats it. Even Sloth basically just got punched to deth
@@asa_6110 Mustang's alchemy is OP: Gluttony and Greed are the only homunculuses who can negate it's effect and Sloth was beaten to death time and time again he was also not taking the fight seriously most of the time whitch was the factor of his defeat....
I think the messege that truth imposed on the world in brotherhood is much more impactful. The dead do not come back to life and even if you tried what you create isn't even your loved one.
Well this homunculi would also eventually die if you keep killing them over and over but I do think they concept of these ones being failed human transmutations is better than
I disagree Brotherhood is not better both versions are amazing 2003 had a stronger start and developed the main cast more especially some of the homunculus and yes the tone is also an amazing Factor so is the messages of the series
I agree there are parts of it I wanna watxh again but I don't know about all the way through since there are parts that I didn't like. Things I did like were, seeing ed take the exam, seeing abit more adventures of edward and al, learning about the concept if the homunculi( I liked that they were sort of like clones but also there own people, wish we got more back story for some of the others like gluttony though and greed, My other complaint is that its ending felt to rushed, and the final confrontation of edward and envy is cut short to my disliking. I liked that the story starts showing when edward met mustang for the firat time, seeing him go from being a nervous 14 year old boy around mustang to the sassy short rival we all know and love was a treat.
As amazing as this fight was, I just noticed something that’s bugging me.. Mustang sealed the door shut with his alchemy, as if to say “even if I fall here, I will not let this monster escape” right? Or at least, that’s what it looked like to me. But then right as Bradley is about to kill Mustang, Selim walks in without so much as a struggle. He’s not a homunculus in this version, he’s no alchemist, he’s merely a 10 year old boy. How did he nonchalantly get in? As much as I got satisfaction from Roy taking down Bradley for good, he realistically should’ve been killed there if I’m right.
Salim came through a different door. That leads to the kitchen The fight had moved from the wine cellar to the kitchen. Mustang had blasted the fight into the kitchen. So mustang had unfortunately provided a way for Bradley to escape but that was irrelevant as pride Bradley can cut his way out. But it did present the opportunity for salim to hand his father his one weakness. Fma was in a time anime never stuck directly to the original manga and only based off. So fit an original storyline. It’s pretty good.
@@brawl8 I agree, 2003 FMA is a masterpiece and I find myself going back to it more than brotherhood. And thanks for the clarification, I somehow didn’t notice they moved to a different location. Guess I was too captivated by the fight itself.
Most of the fight occurred off-screen. The fight actually left the wine cellar and entered the kitchen, likely due to Mustang blowing holes in the wall. So Selim entered through a different door.
What was really interesting to me is the quiteness of FMA's climax as supposed to Brotherhood. In Brotherhood, the entire world ends, and there's an all out-war. But here... it feels a lot more hidden-down. I think both are really nice and sell different vibes
Bradley as Pride is nowhere near as scary as FMA:B's Wrath. Yes, his abilities are mostly the same, but even with the additional bonus of regeneration as Pride, he doesn't have the same menace. He's just another homunculus like the others and feels more like a proper pawn, he just kinda sneers at Mustang and exchanges a few blows, but it's clear he's just posturing and wasting energy on being scornful. On the other hand, Wrath went for the throat every single time, yes he was given to indulge in philosophical debate mid-fight, but it never made him lose focus for even a moment, and the fact that he didn't need the regen ability of his fellow homunculi made him all the more intimidating. FMA:B's Pride and Father may have been more powerful and the BBEGs, but in my opinion, Bradley was the true threat.
You say the other version is better, yet you came back to watch this one. I can't even remember a single fight in FMAB. It was not nearly as well composed as this first version was.
You are absolutely right. The fact that Wrath, the only homunculus who couldn't regenerate, was stronger than 90% of the cast when he was *well past his prime* is just so frickin cool. Also in Fmab wrath is mostly calm but there's this underlying sense of extreme anger in his voice
The way they were done and the way the shows were done the two characters are entirely separate characters all together so can't really compare them anyway tbh, it would be like comparing every different version of Batman or Spiderman, alot of it depends on the how that writer wrote them at the time, not every Batman is the same just because it's Batman if that makes sense
Brotherhood comment section: Man, this thing sure is cool/sad/thought provoking. 2003 comment section: Brotherhoodbrotherhoodbrotherhoodbrotherhood- You guys DO realize it's not the 2010s anymore, right?
Hot take: I like this series a _lot_ more than Brotherhood. I _get_ why people prefer Brotherhood, but authenticity for its own sake is a lost cause. TV is just a different format altogether, and requires different pacing, different devices, etc. The original series _HAD_ to diverge somehow. The comic was great, (and Brotherhood, by extension) but the original broadcast stood on its own two feet after the first two seasons or so. It had its own identity. They're both great for their own reasons, and it breaks my heart to see the original run being put through the ringer as often as it is.
I believe lots of people prefer Brotherhood overall because it has a much more in depth story, the Elric Brothers actually get their bodies back, it also has alot more action scenes
@@PatSpeedruns Lots of people in every 2003 FMA video/review prefer it over Brotherhood. I’m sorry not everyone thinks so highly of your precious Final Fantasy/Disney-esque storytelling, you Brotherhood fan boy or fan girl.
@@makerboy1074 oh boy it took me longer than i expected 😂 about 45min but here it is it s called conquest ✌️❤️ th-cam.com/video/WYPc_CcN0Zo/w-d-xo.html
@Rgoid in FMAB he was degraded as Wrath, and Saleem: the son he choked was upgraded to Pride, the first Sin that “Father” wanted to get rid off, the second was Wrath, so I guess that being an homunculi is a family tradition for the Bradley family’s, or whatever they are called, because they are technically all brothers. The “Dwarf in the Flasks” the not yet developed form of Father, when got the human form became the father/producer of all the homunculi, so they are by the book brothers, even if Wrath is the official father of Pride they are in reality both sons of Father, same for all the others homunculi. Pride and Wrath are the most powerful and evolved from theirs original form to fit in with humans, my personal opinion: the most powerful and the most evolved from its original form of Sin is Greed.
The English voice of Mustang in 2003 is so much better than Brotherhood imo, even if it's done by the same guy. The 2003 performance matches his colder personality more, in Brotherhood Mustang's voice sounded.. err... kinda forced and a little dramatic even in normal scenes. He sounds more natural here.
I think of myself as one of God's Guardian angels... "There's no such thing as God..." We can't know that for sure... however devils do exist, they're the alchemists who DARE TO GET IN MY WAY. That line goes hard
Yeah Pride was just toying with mustang and severely underestimated him we he could have just cut his head off with his first strike he wanted to humiliate Mustang first. Wrath didn’t give Mustang the chance to even fight back.
hmm, was fma bradleys son not pride? I feel like i should have watched fma which is different from the story to fmab Also fr mustang got that homunculus killer blood in him.
The 2003 series progressed too quickly for the manga. Instead of doing a long filler arc, it told its own story. The 2003 series finished in October 2004. At that point the manga had only reached the point of Greed being captured by Father and Ling being introduced. Pride and Sloth had not appeared in any real capacity at that point. In fact the revelation that Bradley was Wraith occurred 2 weeks before 2003 episode revealed him as Pride.
The 03 anime and the 09 anime differ off from each other for the simple fact the manga was caught up to in the original show but the station running the anime version was rushing for its completion so it ended up having its own story that wasn’t tied to the manga. In the 03 anime and 09 anime, 3 homunculus are swapped around. Those homunculus are pride sloth and wrath. In 03 FMA it’s Sloth- Trisha Elric Bradley- Pride Wrath- Teacher’s dead son In brotherhood it’s Sloth- the big sleepy giant Pride- Selim Bradley Wrath- Fuhur Bradley
I love him for that. He was prideful because his son was no like other humans and totally ruin this and brandley in his pride tries to kill him is amazing really fits to his character
As amazing as FMA Brotherhood fights with Bradley were I prefer this one over all of them. This scene is personal, intimate and instead of a bombastic and over the top fight scene it is a gruesome encounter in a wine cellar of all places. Overall this scene feels much more real and plausible, like how a real coup could or an attempt on a leader's life might happen... And that is impressive from a scene where immortal swordsman fights against a guy in a suit who can throw fireballs. Well, overall I prefer FMA 2003 over Brotherhood (which is excellent in some aspects).
Totally agree. I still think Brotherhood did Bradley better overall however, since he has more screen time. But yeah, this fight here in 2003 felt very thematic and not just all around action orientated like Brotherhood typically does. 2003 overall is superior to Brotherhood, which only handled Bradley better.
It hits completely different in the early 2000s when you got to watch the anime for the first time though. Brotherhood anime had the manga predate its episodes while the 2003 version had none for the most part... I remember getting anxious as hell if they were gonna kill off Mustang.
Trust me it goes both ways haha. Lust being an incredibly generic bad guy and Izumi getting her organs back in Brotherhood are both so cursed to me, the latter especially because how seriously equivalent exchange is taken in 03 beyond just being a mechanical law
@@trueblue6201 sorry it’s been awhile, but my point is she no longer had her punishment from performing human transmutation. In Brotherhood, Izumi’s condition is treated as more of a gag or a way to keep her from fighting strong opponents, and when Hoheniem performs alchemy on her, it’s main purpose was likely because the author wanted Izumi to participate in the final battles. In 03, Izumi’s condition is treated as a much harsher punishment for performing human transmutation, and is a serious indicator of her shortened lifespan. It still would make sense on a conceptual level if Izumi either got new organs or they got rearranged due to the philosopher stone obtained towards the end of the show, but the point is 03 wouldn’t do that unless something greater was taken away, because equivalent exchange is more than a battle shounen mechanic; equivalent exchange in 03 also encompasses, and even critiques, the idea of “if I put in work into something, I will get what I want in return”. Equivalent exchange might be “equivalent” but it’s not necessarily fair. At the end of 03, Ed and Al are not truly rewarded for their hard work and suffering, but they did grow throughout it, and that was what they got in exchange. It’s not necessarily a bad decision that this isn’t a theme discussed at length in Brotherhood, but I will never forget how weird I felt when Izumi was essentially “cured” of her punishment from human transmutation. TLDR Izumi’s condition being pretty much cured goes against the main theme from 03 and will just always be weird to me.
I just watched Brotherhood and yesterday I was looking over the wiki description of the 2003 anime. For what I read, it can even be called an alternative timeline, or at least thats what I see. It even seems to have interesting concepts (I don't really have the ability to say if they are good or not, but if I watch it fot sure.) Although, this comment section really seems like a warzone, at least the super vs gt debates can co-exist nicely with each other; brotherhood vs 2003 anime tho...I have the face that Bradley has on Brotherhood when Ling comesback within the many souls inside greed to tell Bradley to not understimate humans.
I highly recommend watching FMA 2003. Both 2003 and Brotherhood are different, but both are excellent. FMA 2003 is more intimate and character focused story while Brotherhood is more action / story driven story.
That was Pride/King Bradley human skull. In this iteration, humunculi are failed human alchemy resurrection. And when confronted with a part of their human parts the become really weak. That's why Mustang could kill him and why he killed his son for bring it.
Que luta fantástica teria sido o King Bradley ou ORGULHO vs o Selim Bradley o ORGULHO do Brotherhood hein!? Eu VEJO uma mudança drástica, pois o Bradley dessa versão PODIA se regenerar dos ferimentos graves bem fácil, pois o Bradley do Brotherhood nem de longe PODIA fazer isso!
One thing I never understood, why was Mustang sent to deal with Bradley if they didn't have his remains? Didn't they know he couldn't kill him without the parts of the original body? Like if Bradley's kid didn't come down with the skull Mustang would've died and Bradley would've escaped.
So in this version of fma you can still technically kill a homunculus, its just really fucking hard to much like it is in brotherhood. Parts of the original body just make the homunculus much weaker.
@@shocktrooperstudios659 Mustang thought he could easily subdue Bradley with his flame alchemy despite knowing the homunculi’s true weakness. Plus, the whole build up was perfect. It fits both characters since Mustang always trusted Bradley up till he learn about his true identity.
@@JacksonSimile In Brotherhood, if you kill them enough times, they eventually die. 💀☠️ The only difference is that Bradley is a human-based homunculus whereas here, he’s a full blown homunculus who can regenerate and make it look like he ages like a human.
Funfact this Bradley is more OP than brotherhood imagine his eye give him counterattacks to enything he see even transmutation of Mustang brotherhood breadly didn t have such overpowered ability ✌️he saw everything but.....he wans t able counter transmutations
In Brotherhood, Bradley was weakened by... 1. Being hampered by old age. 2. Surviving a train accident. 3. Fighting off multiple characters at once and being wounded for it. He did struggle to defeat Scar, who was unarmed - but he forced scar to use alchemy to reconstruct matter instead of merely deconstructing it. Bradley in Brotherhood was made much more powerful. Had he been in his prime, he would have anhialated everyone with relative ease.
@@isauldron4337 Yea and he still lost in a battle of attrition. Cope more. FMA Bradly had all of that, PLUS neigh immortality via regeneration. He just liked to toy with his food.
@@NoNameNoWhere He was only weakened by old age and getting wounded. The train didnt hurt him he just jumped over the cars as they went over the side. Bradly in brotherhood wasnt more powerful he was just given more dramatic feats. He struggled to beat Scar because due to his wounds they were on equal footing. Brotherhood Bradley sucks in a battle of attrition. That is literally how he lost. FMA Bradley has all of that speed/strength, yet also has full regen and can continuously regen so long as his human remains are not found. It is a Portrait of Dorian Grey kind of situation. So long as Neo Bradley doesnt find the Skull, OG Bradley beats the shit out of him. Cry about it. Notifs are off, btw, good luck replying generic Brotherhood glazer
@trollking6315 Generic Brotherhood Gazer? What are you, 12? Have you not grown out of fanboyism yet? Bradley in Brotherhood, as you admitted, was in a weakened state due to numerous factors. The fact he fought as well as he did is a testament to how powerful he was in his prime. That's all I'm saying. I'm sorry you felt like this was a personal attack. You're really making the 03 fans look quite immature. If you do read this, just know that my notifications are turned on. I don't cower from criticism. I'd be delighted to read more of your bad takes. I'm sure they're amusing.
Actually at the time they were making this episode the manga was at the point where it was revealed King Bradley was Wrath, but since the 2003 anime already made its own Wrath they had to make him Pride.
@c.a.whodat The episode where Bradley is revealed as a homonculus and kills Martel came out 4 days before the manga had him fight Greed and be revealed as Wrath. That chapter, which also included the introduction of Father, Ling, and May, would be the last chapter published before the 2003 series ended.
Brotherhood Feels like essentially rebooted fan fiction (yeah i said it to piss you off and you know who you are) where they decided that having character driven story, developments and a darker tone was too much for "the slow Brain” (which they seem to think is huge) of most anime watchers and decided to just refill the series with hardcore anime action cliche Brotherhood focusses more on delivering you scenes where your brain only has to register that something cool occurred, instead of having to understand the implication of something they show. cause that could make the neurons fire and short circuit For example, Alchemists’ best example of writing is seen here, Bradley vs Mustang in Alchemist is a real fight and more importantly contains a lot of character driven elements that show the fault in Bradley that leads to his downfall; 1. Having Mustang as the one to face Bradley, always felt right, it’s the person who represents the corruption, arrogance and threat of governmental power vs. the person who represents the dedication, duty, and nobility of the government, 2. Furthermore having the skull, made more sense, it showed that Bradley was seemingly supernatural but still grounded to earth by the last piece of his original body, the only weakness he has 3. The fact he was so prideful or wrathful (cause that could have worked too) that he kills his own son instead of finishing off Roy, out of pride or wrath, because his son showed and brought out his weakness, the thing that he fears and covets most, is what allows Mustang the time to grab the skull and destroy them both This is truly brilliant writing, having his own sin be what does him in. A far more superior form of character writing to brotherhoods scene.
Couldn't agree more sadly alot of anime fans are mindless consumerists thats why people like hellsing ultimate over the original 2001 gonzo hellsing despite one being just style over substance and the other a noir masterpiece.
@@doubleflores8350 I will say that Brotherhood is very cool, and has a better pace and more flow in terms of episodes and plot then Alchemist Alchemist could sometimes get bogged down by story and character, it wasn’t as flashy or as tantalizing as some action anime can be, and i do think it came off as boring. but the darker tone i will say fit better with that format, and i think the darker tone for the nature of the series and content was essential.
@@kingpiye7060 I’m not against action based ANIME series, but the are what they are this is a remake version of a name that was more character written and oriented To claim that Brotherhood was the better which is implied because of dropping all writing and character driven elements that were well done and or mastered in Alchemist is what bothers me
Less so than the manga, which had a lot of deus ex machina. Bradley was also killed by deus ex machina in the manga (the sunlight blinding him) as was Pride (Kimblee somehow being able to exist as a dominant soul in Pride and Edward being able to turn himself into a Philosopher's Stone to transmute Pride into a child), and the defeat of Father powered by God through Von Hoenheim's almost unmentioned counter transmutation circle.
@@trueblue6201 I agree about the Kimblee thing, but I disagree with the counter transmutation circle, it was constantly hinted at. It's not a deus ex if you have multiple scenes of hoenheim traveling and spilling his own parts of the philosopher stone into random locations, something being referenced and then explained later doesn't count as a deus ex machina
@@efazchowdhury3866 To be honest Fuhrer, king, etc Bradley as either Pride or Wrath works either way actually, it doesn’t matter as Pride is the sin from which most others especially wrath follow and stem from...but this scene, in terms of character and story is far superior to anything brotherhood came up with Brotherhood feels like someone said “let’s reboot the series but drop all the emotional, character driven story and Development and just go full anime action” and that shows Again Bradley vs Mustang in Alchemist is a real fight and more importantly contains a lot of character driven elements that show the fault in Bradley that leads to his downfall the fact he was so prideful or wrathful (cause that could have worked too) that he kills his son instead of finishing off Roy, out of pride or wrath, because his son showed and brought out his weakness, the thing that he fears and covets most allowing Mustang the time to grab the skull and destroy them both Is truly brilliant writing, having his own sin be what does him in. A far more superior form of character writing to brotherhoods scene.
@@mckenzie.latham91 brotherhood isn’t a reboot though. Brotherhood is a by the book’s adaptation of the Manga. But that doesn’t make 2003 any less than brotherhood. If anything, 2003 felt more of a story about brothers then brotherhood did.
@@martanek1082 I checked online about that and it says Bradley snapped his sons neck and Mustang carried his lifeless body outside. That was a pretty dark scene
![FMA (2003) Roy Mustang vs Orgullo/King Bradley Español Latino [FANDOBLAJE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2Ri9XaYLaKk/mqdefault.jpg)
4:54 "You ARE foolish, all of you...even my own son."
Love that delivery. One of Ed Blaylock's finest performances (of which there were many in my opinion).
RIP Ed Baylock.
Pretending to love his son got him killed, the irony.
For what it’s worth it’s damn impressive that Mustang managed to dodge some of Bradley’s attacks
Bradley says its the first he use his regeneration ability so i guess he dont fight that much
More like he doesn't get hit very much.
Pretty sure bradley was just toying around with him
he was full of pride to think that his opponent wouldn't stand a chance, so he wanted to humor himself
Bradley would be completely OP if he could regenerate in FMAB.
yeah. thank gawd he couldnt.
He is already op without it
There was literally no reason he shouldnt have had it, couldnt ling regenerate?
@Makhi Makharadze ye cuz he was made from a human unlike the other homunculi.
@Makhi Makharadze father custom made the bodies of the homunculi. Their souls are basically formed from the vices of the population of xerxes. Envy is different. His body itself is formed from people.
3:07 this was the most creepiest part I've ever seen in anime history
“I didn’t do this for politics! It was for TINY MINISKIRTS!”
That's a pretty good reason tbh
Mustang: "There's no such thing as God."
Bradley: "We don't know that for sure. However, devils do exist."
Bradley's statement is so true
I think a lot about the triumphant musical cue when Mustang pulls the skull out, and how well it bleeds into Al's triumphant moment against Dante.
In case you’re wondering it named “Sin” in the FMA ost. I’m telling this because I’ve been looking for its name for a long time
@@dayzdove Thank you so much, I was also looking for this
Masterpiece
Its full epic!
Bro seeing Bradley regenerate scares me
Always found the animation of that scene really unsettling yet amazing.
@@joer8954That’s usual Yutaka Nakamura for you :)
@@Fatema3006that was Nakamura?! Oh that’s so cool
@@Phasmania He even animated some other sequences of the series like Edward vs Greed or Wrath and Al vs Glutonny in Conqueror Of Shamballa :)
Pride was low-key op as hell in this. His ability coupled with his regeneration is insane.
Amazing how they had such good writing despite swaying so far from the source material. I really loved this show. Shame modern viewers disregard it entirely.
They didn’t sway The series wasn’t finished think of it as another interpretation.
@@corinneolivier1871 Yes, they did sway. It is not the same story. I know the manga wasn't finished when they made it. The point of my comment was that the anime had excellent writers, which is very rarely the case.
This will always be my favorite version because we got way more Hughes.
If someone's first introduction to the series was this scene, they would be convinced that mustang is the main character.
He is essentially the third main character.
@@trueblue6201yep, man always got maimed each version. Same location.
One of the finest English dubs out there
3:09 was badass
FmaB fans: OMG Bradley just 1v1’d a tank!
FMA Enjoyers: a final stand inside a cramped wine cellar
100% I will always take the WInecellar death because just the view of him Choking his HUMAN SON was so much more brutal for the tone. I love Wrath bradley but I can't ever unsee the absolute badassery of Mustang Torching the fucker after he hurt his own kid :). I always hated Pride in FMAB like he wasn't inherently bad but the view on bradley having SOME semblance of humanity from the outside is what made me love his character so much. But fuck watching Bradley wreak havoc on everyone as wrath is a sight to see haha
@@tempestindustries9446 i enjoyed Bradley's death in fmab a lot more than in fma. Generally i prefered fma deaths but i enjoyed bradely's last words in bortherhood i think the instance where the homunculi are more human or insightful i enjoy. in brotherhood his death is triumphant, he dies on his terms, here its the end of a man whos motive is confusing as well as his relationship with his son
It’s not the other way around,
FMA enjoyers: oh my God, Bradley took out the tank
@@medalgear654 Nah. As cool as the tank scene was it was way over the top. This scene feels grounded and more intimate. It just comes down to personal preference.
@@jam8539Because Bradley was more developed in manga/Brotherhood than in the 2003 anime.
Pride was just toying with Mustang he probably is every bit as powerful as Wrath but his personality was completely different. He was more indulgent and expressive less focused on the task at hand unlike Wrath. To wrath fighting was definitely his outlet and relished the chance to do so.
Yeah, here’s always smiling while fighting, showing his pride, while Wrath barley ever smiled while fighting, showing his wrath and how seriously he took it
4:51 this is we call gentleman and badass for Bradley.. That why I love him
I will always stand by how the concept of the homunculi, how they were made and how to kill them, was just so much more impactful in FMA over brotherhood
What I love about the original anime. There wasn’t really a happy ending the characters had to make the best of the consequences. They had to keep moving foward. How that ed and al crossed over to our world. While I love how brother hood gave us that closure. That the hard work wasn’t for nothing. They were able to find a way even someone like scar was able to move foward put his wrath behind him.
Fma kept that tone that alchemy isn’t the short cut the people were expecting. There was a much higher price to pay. Good intentions can led down to hfil.
This comment isn’t getting the love it deserves for having HFIL at the end
Well said. Such bittersweet character endings remind me of Final Fantasy Tactics.
I just love this
I understand why FMA wasn’t as good as FMAB as a whole, but one thing I seriously wanted to see stay in FMAB is a fight between Bradley and Mustang
A man with much alchemical power vs a man with much political power
Seriously, an actual fight between Mustang and Bradley would’ve been badass
And nobody bring up the “fight” they had in brotherhood where Wrath just rushes and stabs Mustang while avoiding the flame alchemy, because that wasn’t even a fight, it ended in less than 5 seconds
They did very briefly fight. But Wrath defeated him near instantly, and without the use of his ultimate eye.
@@jenothemississippianofmand5202 If Bradley had regeneration in Brotherhood he'd probably be the strongest character in the series.
@@JuggoJuggo Absolutely
@@BlackangelKatakuri still think Pride could deal with him. Prides versitility with those Shadows could overwhelm him even with the Ultimate Eye..
Bruh 03 is great up there with fmab what u saying there💀
The God talk is a bit out of left field, considering where Bradley stands in FMAB xD
This scene scared me as a kid not knowing if mustang would come on top.
This fight is so underrated. It's right up there with Ed's last battles against Greed and Envy.
Can't say I agree
And more Scar vs Kimblee
Selim looks like a smaller version of Shinji from Evangelion. Now I imagine Wrath choking Shinji
Good
The happy alternate ending of evangelion lol
Imagine if this were selim pride that bradley was trying to strangle.
FMAB Pride would destroy 2003 Pride.
The camera movement at 2:34 is something I've never seen in any other anime. Wish more studios did this kinda thing
I love how the original anime handled the homunculus, being the outcome of human transmutation and their only weakness is the remains of the person they once were. It just hits a lot deeper than them being Fathers emotions given life through a stone, an all you have to do is burn out their stone to beat them.
"all you have to do is burn out their stone to beat them." you make it sound so easy....................
@@алексейпугачев-л9й but that was exactly what happened in bortherhood. Mustang flame blasted two of them over and over and thats it. Even Sloth basically just got punched to deth
@@asa_6110 Mustang's alchemy is OP: Gluttony and Greed are the only homunculuses who can negate it's effect and Sloth was beaten to death time and time again he was also not taking the fight seriously most of the time whitch was the factor of his defeat....
I think the messege that truth imposed on the world in brotherhood is much more impactful. The dead do not come back to life and even if you tried what you create isn't even your loved one.
Well this homunculi would also eventually die if you keep killing them over and over but I do think they concept of these ones being failed human transmutations is better than
Powerscaling:
2003 King Bradley = Brotherhood Envy
2003 Envy = Brotherhood Bradley
True, bradly in brotherhood would dog on 03 Bradley, plus we already seen Bradley scared of envy in 03
Bradley was the only thing better in Brotherhood.
@@manofwisdom000alongside every other Homunculus, the main antagonist, the plot, the main characters, the side characters and the ending
@@somersaultinggiraffe1901 Another Brotherhood fan boy or fan girl. 2003 is superior to your baby show.
Did Bradley just fucking regenerate 😯
In the original anime, he was a true homunculus. He was Pride in FMA, and the human/homunculus Wrath in Brotherhood.
Yes he was op with his eye and to all of that he can regenerate ✌️
Imagine you have the opps in the palm of your hand, and then your son walks in holding your ultimate weakness.
I always prefer the tone in the first series, Brotherhood is mostly better but boy did the first go really hard on the serious tone.
I disagree Brotherhood is not better both versions are amazing 2003 had a stronger start and developed the main cast more especially some of the homunculus and yes the tone is also an amazing Factor so is the messages of the series
I think its the music
the music and scene here in the original of Mustang finishing off Wrath/The Fuhrer was never duplicated or matched in Brotherhood
I agree there are parts of it I wanna watxh again but I don't know about all the way through since there are parts that I didn't like. Things I did like were, seeing ed take the exam, seeing abit more adventures of edward and al, learning about the concept if the homunculi( I liked that they were sort of like clones but also there own people, wish we got more back story for some of the others like gluttony though and greed, My other complaint is that its ending felt to rushed, and the final confrontation of edward and envy is cut short to my disliking. I liked that the story starts showing when edward met mustang for the firat time, seeing him go from being a nervous 14 year old boy around mustang to the sassy short rival we all know and love was a treat.
I like the music in 2003 better.
"For being blind so long" -Mustang
As amazing as this fight was, I just noticed something that’s bugging me..
Mustang sealed the door shut with his alchemy, as if to say “even if I fall here, I will not let this monster escape” right? Or at least, that’s what it looked like to me. But then right as Bradley is about to kill Mustang, Selim walks in without so much as a struggle. He’s not a homunculus in this version, he’s no alchemist, he’s merely a 10 year old boy. How did he nonchalantly get in? As much as I got satisfaction from Roy taking down Bradley for good, he realistically should’ve been killed there if I’m right.
Salim came through a different door. That leads to the kitchen The fight had moved from the wine cellar to the kitchen. Mustang had blasted the fight into the kitchen. So mustang had unfortunately provided a way for Bradley to escape but that was irrelevant as pride Bradley can cut his way out. But it did present the opportunity for salim to hand his father his one weakness.
Fma was in a time anime never stuck directly to the original manga and only based off. So fit an original storyline. It’s pretty good.
@@brawl8 I agree, 2003 FMA is a masterpiece and I find myself going back to it more than brotherhood. And thanks for the clarification, I somehow didn’t notice they moved to a different location. Guess I was too captivated by the fight itself.
@@lewisstrongofficial the whole house was in fire so yeah they move to another room
Most of the fight occurred off-screen. The fight actually left the wine cellar and entered the kitchen, likely due to Mustang blowing holes in the wall. So Selim entered through a different door.
What was really interesting to me is the quiteness of FMA's climax as supposed to Brotherhood. In Brotherhood, the entire world ends, and there's an all out-war. But here... it feels a lot more hidden-down. I think both are really nice and sell different vibes
Bradley is so handsome. No matter what version
i mean..
Really?
I overall liked Pride (FMA) especially as a villain, but man I just love Wrath (FMAB).
"I couldnt forgive myself for being blind all this long"
😳
Bradley as Pride is nowhere near as scary as FMA:B's Wrath. Yes, his abilities are mostly the same, but even with the additional bonus of regeneration as Pride, he doesn't have the same menace. He's just another homunculus like the others and feels more like a proper pawn, he just kinda sneers at Mustang and exchanges a few blows, but it's clear he's just posturing and wasting energy on being scornful. On the other hand, Wrath went for the throat every single time, yes he was given to indulge in philosophical debate mid-fight, but it never made him lose focus for even a moment, and the fact that he didn't need the regen ability of his fellow homunculi made him all the more intimidating. FMA:B's Pride and Father may have been more powerful and the BBEGs, but in my opinion, Bradley was the true threat.
Agreed. It also helps wrath DIDNT KEEP A WAY TO KILL HIM
You say the other version is better, yet you came back to watch this one.
I can't even remember a single fight in FMAB. It was not nearly as well composed as this first version was.
@@MaximilianonMars its possible to enjoy something without saying its better than something else
You are absolutely right. The fact that Wrath, the only homunculus who couldn't regenerate, was stronger than 90% of the cast when he was *well past his prime* is just so frickin cool.
Also in Fmab wrath is mostly calm but there's this underlying sense of extreme anger in his voice
The way they were done and the way the shows were done the two characters are entirely separate characters all together so can't really compare them anyway tbh, it would be like comparing every different version of Batman or Spiderman, alot of it depends on the how that writer wrote them at the time, not every Batman is the same just because it's Batman if that makes sense
Wonder why he couldn't regrnerate in FMAB
Brotherhood comment section: Man, this thing sure is cool/sad/thought provoking.
2003 comment section: Brotherhoodbrotherhoodbrotherhoodbrotherhood-
You guys DO realize it's not the 2010s anymore, right?
Karens these days. FMA03 will be 20 years old later this year. Arguing is part of the human nature. Deal with it and get over it.
@@manofwisdom000"Karen."
Insert Princess Bride clip here.
"Get over it."
Yeah, that's what I'm telling you.
@@laststrike4411 What you gonna do about it?
@@manofwisdom000Laugh at you, mostly. How about you?
@@laststrike4411 Same here, Karen.
Hot take:
I like this series a _lot_ more than Brotherhood.
I _get_ why people prefer Brotherhood, but authenticity for its own sake is a lost cause. TV is just a different format altogether, and requires different pacing, different devices, etc. The original series _HAD_ to diverge somehow.
The comic was great, (and Brotherhood, by extension) but the original broadcast stood on its own two feet after the first two seasons or so. It had its own identity.
They're both great for their own reasons, and it breaks my heart to see the original run being put through the ringer as often as it is.
I believe lots of people prefer Brotherhood overall because it has a much more in depth story, the Elric Brothers actually get their bodies back, it also has alot more action scenes
@@PatSpeedruns Brotherhood only handled King Bradley and to some extent Kimblee better. Otherwise, 2003 is objectively better.
@Man of Wisdom uhh that is your opinion, which is wrong
@@PatSpeedruns Lots of people in every 2003 FMA video/review prefer it over Brotherhood. I’m sorry not everyone thinks so highly of your precious Final Fantasy/Disney-esque storytelling, you Brotherhood fan boy or fan girl.
@@manofwisdom000 you apparently don't look at anime sites and their rankings. You lack knowledge and are acting childish calling me names
I missed their conflict in FMA-B. Begun with struggle for power and competition and ended up here.
I feel bad for the little boy
When in the manga canon...
@@archangeruriseofthewizards8649who cares. In 2003 canon he's a little boy.
@@dragonwarriorz1 I mean that the horrible monster had to survive, because he looked like him
@@dragonwarriorz1 Selim was less important than his evil self
I totally forgot Bradley choked and snapped selim’s neck in the original and tossed his body like a nerf football😂
Mustang is a boss in every iteration
This fight was way better here then in brotherhood
Mustang and Bradley never fought in fmab (wait was that a joke?).
@@ivoschuster6363 yes the joke is that they never fought in brother hood so of course it’s better
@@dangray6438 what episode is this on? Because maybe I skipped an episode or something idk pls tell meh
@@dangray6438 ok nvm I went on Netflix and found it (turns out I skipped it) whoops
@@ivoschuster6363 yeah they did. It was over real quick- Mustang got stuck to the floor in five seconds by Wrath.
So this was like the last episode?
It's on episode 50 and 51 of FMA
1:58 this dialog is amazing
Why
@kaan_tuna because it is theological and gothic af
What’s the music title when Mustang talks to Bradley in the room?
It s year later but can you give me time in the video? I ll find it for you
@@martanek1082 0:50
@@makerboy1074 wait a moment ✌️😇
@@makerboy1074 oh boy it took me longer than i expected 😂 about 45min but here it is it s called conquest ✌️❤️
th-cam.com/video/WYPc_CcN0Zo/w-d-xo.html
@@makerboy1074 are you here? 😁❓
Fritz Lang from Metropolis went full blown supervillain… intriguing 🤔🤔
Roy Mustang appearance is reference of Kurei Mori from Flame of Recca
In this one Roy chooses revenge.
King Bradley aka Pride.
@Rgoid in FMAB he was degraded as Wrath, and Saleem: the son he choked was upgraded to Pride, the first Sin that “Father” wanted to get rid off, the second was Wrath, so I guess that being an homunculi is a family tradition for the Bradley family’s, or whatever they are called, because they are technically all brothers. The “Dwarf in the Flasks” the not yet developed form of Father, when got the human form became the father/producer of all the homunculi, so they are by the book brothers, even if Wrath is the official father of Pride they are in reality both sons of Father, same for all the others homunculi. Pride and Wrath are the most powerful and evolved from theirs original form to fit in with humans, my personal opinion: the most powerful and the most evolved from its original form of Sin is Greed.
The English voice of Mustang in 2003 is so much better than Brotherhood imo, even if it's done by the same guy. The 2003 performance matches his colder personality more, in Brotherhood Mustang's voice sounded.. err... kinda forced and a little dramatic even in normal scenes. He sounds more natural here.
3:10 Nightmare Bradley.
this is the fight that redeems the whole of fma03s immersion breaking nonsense for me
Is it voice Itachi from Naruto original series 2002, isnt it
Thank God that King Bradley could not regenerate in the original manga and Brotherhood. He wound have been damn-near unstoppable. 😅
original Bradley is an atheist this one is agnostic
I think he was being facetious here.
I think of myself as one of God's Guardian angels...
"There's no such thing as God..."
We can't know that for sure... however devils do exist, they're the alchemists who DARE TO GET IN MY WAY.
That line goes hard
didn't want it to get hurt in the fire, then proceeds to bring it into a room full of flames.
This fight was so underwhelming. Mustang would never had the time to draw the circle if it was in brotherhood.
Actually Bradley was quite fast here too. It was just that he was stunned and scared looking at mustang holding the skull
He was weakened by the skull
1. It’s not brotherhood. It’s its own show, get over it.
2. Mustang was holding Pride’s one weakness.
Yeah Pride was just toying with mustang and severely underestimated him we he could have just cut his head off with his first strike he wanted to humiliate Mustang first. Wrath didn’t give Mustang the chance to even fight back.
The skull paralyzes the Fuhrer. Shut the fuck up. There's more to the 2003 anime than Shonen fights for your juvenile brain to be giddy about.
as someone whos only seen brotherhood. wtf is actually happening?
hmm, was fma bradleys son not pride? I feel like i should have watched fma which is different from the story to fmab
Also fr mustang got that homunculus killer blood in him.
The 2003 series progressed too quickly for the manga. Instead of doing a long filler arc, it told its own story. The 2003 series finished in October 2004. At that point the manga had only reached the point of Greed being captured by Father and Ling being introduced. Pride and Sloth had not appeared in any real capacity at that point. In fact the revelation that Bradley was Wraith occurred 2 weeks before 2003 episode revealed him as Pride.
The 03 anime and the 09 anime differ off from each other for the simple fact the manga was caught up to in the original show but the station running the anime version was rushing for its completion so it ended up having its own story that wasn’t tied to the manga. In the 03 anime and 09 anime, 3 homunculus are swapped around.
Those homunculus are pride sloth and wrath.
In 03 FMA it’s
Sloth- Trisha Elric
Bradley- Pride
Wrath- Teacher’s dead son
In brotherhood it’s
Sloth- the big sleepy giant
Pride- Selim Bradley
Wrath- Fuhur Bradley
@@crackysnacky7235 oh shoot didn't know that at all thanks
@@trueblue6201 thanks for the info
I hate this version of Bradley for what he did to Selim
I love him for that. He was prideful because his son was no like other humans and totally ruin this and brandley in his pride tries to kill him is amazing really fits to his character
@@martanek1082I love to hate him. He's a great villain
@@MrMisterman1 You say that but in Brotherhood, he’s killed millions of people on-screen wise, one after the other. Lol.
@@manofwisdom000 At least that version of him cared about his family
@@MrMisterman1 He cared only for Mrs. Bradley. Lol.
As amazing as FMA Brotherhood fights with Bradley were I prefer this one over all of them. This scene is personal, intimate and instead of a bombastic and over the top fight scene it is a gruesome encounter in a wine cellar of all places. Overall this scene feels much more real and plausible, like how a real coup could or an attempt on a leader's life might happen... And that is impressive from a scene where immortal swordsman fights against a guy in a suit who can throw fireballs.
Well, overall I prefer FMA 2003 over Brotherhood (which is excellent in some aspects).
Totally agree. I still think Brotherhood did Bradley better overall however, since he has more screen time. But yeah, this fight here in 2003 felt very thematic and not just all around action orientated like Brotherhood typically does. 2003 overall is superior to Brotherhood, which only handled Bradley better.
This feels like a fanmade when the first version you've watched was the brotherhood. LOLS. Sooo weird seeing Seim Bradley being choked like that.
It hits completely different in the early 2000s when you got to watch the anime for the first time though. Brotherhood anime had the manga predate its episodes while the 2003 version had none for the most part... I remember getting anxious as hell if they were gonna kill off Mustang.
Trust me it goes both ways haha. Lust being an incredibly generic bad guy and Izumi getting her organs back in Brotherhood are both so cursed to me, the latter especially because how seriously equivalent exchange is taken in 03 beyond just being a mechanical law
@shanemiller1182 Izumi did not get her organs back. Hoenheim just rearranged her organs to allow her to breath better and reduce the bleeding.
@@trueblue6201 sorry it’s been awhile, but my point is she no longer had her punishment from performing human transmutation. In Brotherhood, Izumi’s condition is treated as more of a gag or a way to keep her from fighting strong opponents, and when Hoheniem performs alchemy on her, it’s main purpose was likely because the author wanted Izumi to participate in the final battles. In 03, Izumi’s condition is treated as a much harsher punishment for performing human transmutation, and is a serious indicator of her shortened lifespan. It still would make sense on a conceptual level if Izumi either got new organs or they got rearranged due to the philosopher stone obtained towards the end of the show, but the point is 03 wouldn’t do that unless something greater was taken away, because equivalent exchange is more than a battle shounen mechanic; equivalent exchange in 03 also encompasses, and even critiques, the idea of “if I put in work into something, I will get what I want in return”. Equivalent exchange might be “equivalent” but it’s not necessarily fair. At the end of 03, Ed and Al are not truly rewarded for their hard work and suffering, but they did grow throughout it, and that was what they got in exchange. It’s not necessarily a bad decision that this isn’t a theme discussed at length in Brotherhood, but I will never forget how weird I felt when Izumi was essentially “cured” of her punishment from human transmutation.
TLDR Izumi’s condition being pretty much cured goes against the main theme from 03 and will just always be weird to me.
@shanemiller1182 I don't disagree with you. I felt the same way with how they just nonchalantly gave Mustang his sight back.
I just watched Brotherhood and yesterday I was looking over the wiki description of the 2003 anime.
For what I read, it can even be called an alternative timeline, or at least thats what I see. It even seems to have interesting concepts (I don't really have the ability to say if they are good or not, but if I watch it fot sure.)
Although, this comment section really seems like a warzone, at least the super vs gt debates can co-exist nicely with each other; brotherhood vs 2003 anime tho...I have the face that Bradley has on Brotherhood when Ling comesback within the many souls inside greed to tell Bradley to not understimate humans.
I highly recommend watching FMA 2003.
Both 2003 and Brotherhood are different, but both are excellent. FMA 2003 is more intimate and character focused story while Brotherhood is more action / story driven story.
Bom Anime
What was that skull supposed to be?
Pride’s human remains (in other words his homunculus kryptonite).
That was Pride/King Bradley human skull. In this iteration, humunculi are failed human alchemy resurrection. And when confronted with a part of their human parts the become really weak. That's why Mustang could kill him and why he killed his son for bring it.
So, in FMA Bradley's son was in fact his son?
Selim is still adopted, just not a homunculus
Que luta fantástica teria sido o King Bradley ou ORGULHO vs o Selim Bradley o ORGULHO do Brotherhood hein!?
Eu VEJO uma mudança drástica, pois o Bradley dessa versão PODIA se regenerar dos ferimentos graves bem fácil, pois o Bradley do Brotherhood nem de longe PODIA fazer isso!
I never knew Bradley my all time favorite in FMAB was this weak in the 1st anime series. His only advantage here is his regeneration.
He fight the powerfull caractere of the show ? If selim wasnt came mustang will be killed ezly
@@mouadchaglalchimistefullme6116 also selim brought bradley weakness to the room
He's not weak, he's not Wrath but Pride, he was toying with mustang cause he had a large upperhand
Weak? I'm pretty sure he's just as strong as the wrath counterpart the difference is he's more arrogant here and sadistic.
Did you even watch the entirety of the 2003 series to know why Bradley ended up losing to Mustang? No?
One thing I never understood, why was Mustang sent to deal with Bradley if they didn't have his remains? Didn't they know he couldn't kill him without the parts of the original body? Like if Bradley's kid didn't come down with the skull Mustang would've died and Bradley would've escaped.
So in this version of fma you can still technically kill a homunculus, its just really fucking hard to much like it is in brotherhood. Parts of the original body just make the homunculus much weaker.
@@shocktrooperstudios659 Mustang thought he could easily subdue Bradley with his flame alchemy despite knowing the homunculi’s true weakness. Plus, the whole build up was perfect. It fits both characters since Mustang always trusted Bradley up till he learn about his true identity.
@@JacksonSimile In Brotherhood, if you kill them enough times, they eventually die. 💀☠️ The only difference is that Bradley is a human-based homunculus whereas here, he’s a full blown homunculus who can regenerate and make it look like he ages like a human.
@@manofwisdom000 Exactly XD
This Bradley way weaker than his brotherhood counterpart.
Foi uma PENA que tanto o Mustang assim como o Bradley TIVERAM poucas participações nas lutas do ANIME de 2003!?
I liked the orgin of homunculis in the first series better
fmab is the original origin of them. in this one was made up by anime writers since the manga wasn't finished after they did episode 14.
I regret reading these comments lol
OST name?
Give me time and i ll give you name
Okay here it is if you mean this one during fight
It s called conquest
th-cam.com/video/WYPc_CcN0Zo/w-d-xo.html
@@martanek1082 thanks so much, you must be a huge fma fan
@@danielyeager6666 i am ❤️😇✌️ i love both series but fma2003 has special place in my heart ❤️
2:03
Funfact this Bradley is more OP than brotherhood imagine his eye give him counterattacks to enything he see even transmutation of Mustang brotherhood breadly didn t have such overpowered ability ✌️he saw everything but.....he wans t able counter transmutations
Bradley in the manga compensates lack of healing by being a god
In Brotherhood, Bradley was weakened by...
1. Being hampered by old age.
2. Surviving a train accident.
3. Fighting off multiple characters at once and being wounded for it.
He did struggle to defeat Scar, who was unarmed - but he forced scar to use alchemy to reconstruct matter instead of merely deconstructing it.
Bradley in Brotherhood was made much more powerful. Had he been in his prime, he would have anhialated everyone with relative ease.
@@isauldron4337 Yea and he still lost in a battle of attrition. Cope more. FMA Bradly had all of that, PLUS neigh immortality via regeneration. He just liked to toy with his food.
@@NoNameNoWhere He was only weakened by old age and getting wounded. The train didnt hurt him he just jumped over the cars as they went over the side.
Bradly in brotherhood wasnt more powerful he was just given more dramatic feats. He struggled to beat Scar because due to his wounds they were on equal footing. Brotherhood Bradley sucks in a battle of attrition. That is literally how he lost.
FMA Bradley has all of that speed/strength, yet also has full regen and can continuously regen so long as his human remains are not found. It is a Portrait of Dorian Grey kind of situation. So long as Neo Bradley doesnt find the Skull, OG Bradley beats the shit out of him. Cry about it.
Notifs are off, btw, good luck replying generic Brotherhood glazer
@trollking6315 Generic Brotherhood Gazer? What are you, 12? Have you not grown out of fanboyism yet?
Bradley in Brotherhood, as you admitted, was in a weakened state due to numerous factors. The fact he fought as well as he did is a testament to how powerful he was in his prime. That's all I'm saying.
I'm sorry you felt like this was a personal attack. You're really making the 03 fans look quite immature.
If you do read this, just know that my notifications are turned on. I don't cower from criticism. I'd be delighted to read more of your bad takes. I'm sure they're amusing.
Is he really dead?
Unfortunately yes. Bradley snapped his neck completely
So was Bradley’s son not a homonculus in this series?
No, just watch it it has a really interesting take on homonculus i don't want to spoil
@@Volyan7 thank you
Rock’s Upsetting
I still can't believe the writers were able to correctly predict that Bradley was a Homunculus.
They did it when Bradley was already revealed to be a homunculus
If i remember correctly
Actually at the time they were making this episode the manga was at the point where it was revealed King Bradley was Wrath, but since the 2003 anime already made its own Wrath they had to make him Pride.
@c.a.whodat The episode where Bradley is revealed as a homonculus and kills Martel came out 4 days before the manga had him fight Greed and be revealed as Wrath. That chapter, which also included the introduction of Father, Ling, and May, would be the last chapter published before the 2003 series ended.
If only this part of the story had a little more time.
5:03 song ?
Sin (tsumi).
Brotherhood Feels like essentially rebooted fan fiction (yeah i said it to piss you off and you know who you are)
where they decided that having character driven story, developments and a darker tone was too much for "the slow Brain” (which they seem to think is huge) of most anime watchers and decided to just refill the series with hardcore anime action cliche
Brotherhood focusses more on delivering you scenes where your brain only has to register that something cool occurred, instead of having to understand the implication of something they show.
cause that could make the neurons fire and short circuit
For example, Alchemists’ best example of writing is seen here, Bradley vs Mustang in Alchemist is a real fight and more importantly contains a lot of character driven elements that show the fault in Bradley that leads to his downfall;
1. Having Mustang as the one to face Bradley, always felt right, it’s the person who represents the corruption, arrogance and threat of governmental power vs. the person who represents the dedication, duty, and nobility of the government,
2. Furthermore having the skull, made more sense, it showed that Bradley was seemingly supernatural but still grounded to earth by the last piece of his original body, the only weakness he has
3. The fact he was so prideful or wrathful (cause that could have worked too) that he kills his own son instead of finishing off Roy, out of pride or wrath, because his son showed and brought out his weakness, the thing that he fears and covets most, is what allows Mustang the time to grab the skull and destroy them both
This is truly brilliant writing, having his own sin be what does him in.
A far more superior form of character writing to brotherhoods scene.
Hey brotherhood was pretty good. Granted the original is superior but that doesn’t mean you have to put brotherhood down like that b
Couldn't agree more sadly alot of anime fans are mindless consumerists thats why people like hellsing ultimate over the original 2001 gonzo hellsing despite one being just style over substance and the other a noir masterpiece.
@@doubleflores8350 I will say that Brotherhood is very cool, and has a better pace and more flow in terms of episodes and plot then Alchemist
Alchemist could sometimes get bogged down by story and character, it wasn’t as flashy or as tantalizing as some action anime can be, and i do think it came off as boring.
but the darker tone i will say fit better with that format, and i think the darker tone for the nature of the series and content was essential.
@@kingpiye7060 I’m not against action based ANIME series, but the are what they are
this is a remake version of a name that was more character written and oriented
To claim that Brotherhood was the better which is implied because of dropping all writing and character driven elements that were well done and or mastered in Alchemist is what bothers me
@@mckenzie.latham91 But story and character is what makes it great. It did not came off as boring. But everything else you said is 100% on point.
Badass
Who gave bro regen 💀
Ironically “air flux” would just feed mustangs flames
Alchemy is a lot of math on the fly so it would mess with it.
It's a bit of a dues ex machina that his son showed up with his skull...
Earlier in series Bradley give him key as symbol of his trust and his pride ✌️ and selim said i ll protect your treasure with my life.
Less so than the manga, which had a lot of deus ex machina. Bradley was also killed by deus ex machina in the manga (the sunlight blinding him) as was Pride (Kimblee somehow being able to exist as a dominant soul in Pride and Edward being able to turn himself into a Philosopher's Stone to transmute Pride into a child), and the defeat of Father powered by God through Von Hoenheim's almost unmentioned counter transmutation circle.
You guys can only find the flaws of 2003, meanwhile brotherhood is filled plot conveniences and contrivances
@@trueblue6201 I agree about the Kimblee thing, but I disagree with the counter transmutation circle, it was constantly hinted at. It's not a deus ex if you have multiple scenes of hoenheim traveling and spilling his own parts of the philosopher stone into random locations, something being referenced and then explained later doesn't count as a deus ex machina
@@beyondthegravebrandon Right. They can't accept the fact that not everyone thinks so highly of their precious baby show.
King Bradley will always be Pride just as Sloth is the transmutation of Trisha Elric and Wrath that of Izumi Curtis’ baby.
Too bad FMA is trash and the studio was making up total garbage as they went along, and it painfully shows.
@@Sprikers can't someone like both for different reasons.
Nope he works better as Wrath
@@efazchowdhury3866 To be honest Fuhrer, king, etc Bradley as either Pride or Wrath works either way actually, it doesn’t matter as Pride is the sin from which most others especially wrath follow and stem from...but this scene, in terms of character and story is far superior to anything brotherhood came up with
Brotherhood feels like someone said “let’s reboot the series but drop all the emotional, character driven story and Development and just go full anime action”
and that shows
Again Bradley vs Mustang in Alchemist is a real fight and more importantly contains a lot of character driven elements that show the fault in Bradley that leads to his downfall
the fact he was so prideful or wrathful (cause that could have worked too) that he kills his son instead of finishing off Roy, out of pride or wrath, because his son showed and brought out his weakness, the thing that he fears and covets most
allowing Mustang the time to grab the skull and destroy them both
Is truly brilliant writing, having his own sin be what does him in.
A far more superior form of character writing to brotherhoods scene.
@@mckenzie.latham91 brotherhood isn’t a reboot though. Brotherhood is a by the book’s adaptation of the Manga. But that doesn’t make 2003 any less than brotherhood. If anything, 2003 felt more of a story about brothers then brotherhood did.
I don't understand who actually kilns him Mustang or Scar??
Mustang in 2003 and scar in 2009
@@mouadchaglalchimistefullme6116 The funny thing is regardless of which series you watch, the man who killed Winry's parents fights Furher Bradley.
Is something wrong with the voices or i need to get my ears checked.
Other than quality it's the same pitch.
@@Uhhhhhyeahuhhhh nice pfp
the remake was super necessary.
FMA 2003 is great, though.
I disagree because you have the manga. Brotherhood only existed to cash in on the success of the 2003 original anime series.
@@manofwisdom000ya fma is for retrd like u.
@@PanaDekefuck you for making me delete all comments and cause a argument.
Mustang should be a king of the blue navy than bradley. Bradley should never be a king of blue navy
Dude really killed his son...
Like bro it's anime
I'm sorry always works
You can't just kill him after he apologized lmao
If i remember currently selim survived.....mustang carried him out and then archer shooted mistang to head
@@martanek1082 I checked online about that and it says Bradley snapped his sons neck and Mustang carried his lifeless body outside. That was a pretty dark scene
@@joseph5103 i think i love this scene after this even more ❤️
I liked this version of Bradley far more than his 2009 version, to be honest.
Out of curiosity, why is that?
Ini difma nya gak ada loh
Beda versikah?