Understanding Why Things Went Wrong in Pakistan | Why Pakistan Had Problems Explained| Miftah Ismail
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ม.ค. 2024
- Understanding Why Things Went Wrong in Pakistan | Why Pakistan Had Problems Explained| Miftah Ismail |Education Only for Elite Class? Hard Facts on Pakistan's Failing Economy by Miftah Ismail @raftartv Podcast
Exploring current educational landscape of Pakistan and recent news and developments in educational sector, including the problems with our education system, education policies and public of Pakistan. In our conversation with Miftah Ismail, former Minister of Finance and a prominent figure in PMLN. Delve into pertinent topics such as the challenges faced by Pakistani youth, education ka matlab kya hota hai? (What's the actual meaning of education?), and why our economy is suffering so badly?
#miftahismail #financeminister #podcast #urdupodcast #education #pakistani #pakistanipodcast #educationsystem #pmln #ishaqdar #economy #saylani #imf #imrankhan #shahmehmoodqureshi #pakarmy #pti #ppp #government #urdu #ministryoffinance #interview #shariffamily #lahore #untoldstory #literacy #ministryoffinance #ministryofeducation #illiteracy #health #nawazsharif #maryamnawaz #shahidkhaqanabbasi #elections2024 #electioncommission #election #supremecourtofpakistan #supremecourt
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
TH-cam
/ @raftartv
TH-cam
/ @raftarnewsofficial
TH-cam
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
Pakistan must have a independent finance minister and all political parties must agree on common economics reforms and carry forward without any interference for at least 10 years
Miftah is straight and honest
Pakistan need politicians like him
There should be seperate podcast on education system by mufta ismael .
Vote 👍
Whateva or doesnt matter how many Podcast you make, There is no Future of Pakistan as long as Army is holding on to everything!
A quote to remember: “Lato k Bhoot , Bato seh nahi Manate “
Similarly you keep talking but cannot put progress into work in this Practical World.
@@kushog1646 yahi Haqeeqat hai based on 75 years history.
His name is Miftah, have some respect.
@@syedabdullah3225 are you dumb
Random algorithm suggested video.I am quite impressed by his honest views.
The most effective statement: In the first 10 years of Independence India made 10 IITs and Pakistan changed 7 prime ministers...what an intelligent podcast
There was only 1 IIT established by 1957 in India. Intelligent people will not support his incorrect facts.
Khalistan Jindabad 🐷🇮🇳🐷
@@Babasasa111 ISI!
@@Babasasa111bet your parents are cousins!!!🤣🤣🤣
So? Just because it's taboo in your religion doesn't mean it's unacceptable. Just like in some religion it's common to marry to be bride with tree or dog so that any bad omen in her fate can be removed@@anjan67
I can't believe this kind of Mind blowing content and channel exist in Pakistan. We will keep supporting you. Carry on with this great content
بہت اچھے باتیں کیا شُکریہ
We must agree on strong PLANING COMMISSION... and polices fo next 20 years .......
India has closed the planning commission under Modi regime 10 years ago because it is useless.
Landreforms and smaller provinces are needed for progress of Pakistan.
Bhai total boycott of kafur India is enough
Pakistan be rich and prosperous
@@commonman7730 kuffar buffar duffar e azam ho gayi fufr bufr o zufr ki taumeem e faqradood uz khabeebat al falooda uz haleem daleem ki ho gayi kufr bufr o zufr e tabradeeb e paaaaaaaaaaaqqqqqqqqqqqqqsssssssssssstaaaaaaan
Please continue to invite such great minds so we learn and grow as a nation
All department.
1)military.
2)political person & his family.
3) bureaucrats & his family.
Already eaten pakistan.unless u change them and his power u wont lift urself....revolution hi answer hai naki reform.
Reform key liye late hochuka hai.
Being a islamic riyasat , Pakistan should implement Sharia as soon as possible to make it riyasat e madina.
Shariah is not joke dude it's very to implement because of western power never allow muslim to unite as well in muslims there are some sects they have to agree .. Upcoming generation is very educated most probably in future.
😁😁
Good analysis....... Mifta..
This is a brilliant discussion. Have always regarded Mifta as a "way forward" thinker. He needs the full backing of the nation. His concerns about lack of education or poor education is due to many factors. When a pupil rote learns something like this, we do not have a chance, no matter what:
"The Sun travels until it prostrates underneath the Throne and takes the permission to rise again and it is permitted and then when the time comes, it will be about to prostrate itself but its prostration will not be accepted, and it will ask permission to go on its course but it will not be permitted........"
Surely, we will not produce scientists, pupils with a balanced mind.
Set a debate between Miftah and Shabbar it would be a magnificent streams of knowledge
Miftah and Shabbar families migrated from India to Karachi.
Salute to sir Miftah Ismail
Wow! Wonderful channel for the first time i have seen from Pakistan. Amazing videos topics, story tellers etc superb work! Keep growing 👍
Pakistan Bhi Agay Barey Ga inshaALLAH
The only barrier you guys have is Allah!
Tum agay nahin baroge - Allah say chipke rahoge.
Pakistan pehlay he corruption me bohut aagay barh gaya hai MashaAllah
@@agrippa-theskeptic9346 have you ever made comparison of the strategies implemented in 75 years has how much to do with religion. You would get your answer religion was not the significant problem (it is the problem but the it only contributed ig, 1%. Major reasons are the selfishness, power dilemma etc.
Go and check with the politicians and their household stance on religion and how many strategies have they devised considering that. ALMOST REMOTE.
Be logical!!!
@@hamidmalik7754 Miyan, P’stan’s misery has nothing to do with my being logical or illogical.
It was formed in the name of Islam - Allah.
Its constitution is made after Islam, the word of Allah.
P‘stan‘s heroes are marauders, killers who devastated the Indian subcontinent in the name of Islam - Allah.
The asmani kitab asks the momin to kill or convert the kafir, loot and slavery is permitted, nay desired!
P‘Stan like the marauders it calls its heroes, chose its army to run the country.
The choice of Allah, Army & Amreeka has screwed your country beyond shape.
Allah hu Akbar!
Really he was at the level of Pakistan's finance minster that is why Pakistan is sinking.
Mifta is a good thinker
Good podcast, kindly invite Asad Umar so that we can gwt his perspective as well.
One of the best interview I had ever watched. Hope people like Mifta Ismael occupy the highest post of relevance and show the way forward to Pakistan.
Pakistan ki tabahi ka zimmadar siraf aur siraf pakistan Army haa.jab tak inko controll me nahi late.aghle 75 sal iss sa bi badtar hunghe.
Miftah makes so much sense he could be Pak's man mohan Singh. Govt should not be in business of running businesses. Period
Sheikh Chilli hai, sapne dekhta hai, beyond the capability of the system.
Zero deliverance!
Alhumdulillah - I am from middle-class background and luckily ended up in Canada aa a software engineer.
Growing up, the schooling (rata system) never appealed me. I was lucky to find a local academy nearby my home where focus was on conceptual learning.
I took admission in Govt M.A.O College Lahore and later on went to FAST-NUCES Lahore. I can attest what Miftah SB has said, that children of rich people have an unfair disadvantage over children of lower to middle class, due to the schooling system of Pakistan. In FAST one of the professor publicly ridiculed me by saying that now we have started taking students from Govt MAO college; while I was the second highest grader in engineering discipline of college.
Anyway, last year I wanted to settle back to Pakistan for the sake of my aging Maa. But Maa told me to go back and support family because Pakistan is a sinking ship. So I have come back to Canada. I feel so disappointed with Pakistan (as a country as well as nation) that I also ended up marrying a foreigner. The divorce rate is increasing in Pakistan and women have unrealistic expectations nowadays. It's just crazy back home.
So, I don't miss Maa anymore, but I do miss Nihari, Halwa Poori,.and Ramadan in Pakistan.
At this moment, I honestly believe that Pakistan is under divine punishment due to collective sins of Nation and I see Malaysia as a better place to settle down, raise my children and serve Islam. inshAllah!
The ex minister has identified every reason for Pakistan’s present situation and facing failures.
I watched till 25 minutes. After every two sentence this educated person was invoking “Insha Allah, Masha Allah, Subhan Allah, Alhumdulillah”…
This is the reason of Pakistan’s downfall.
When they depend on their God for everything, their children are sent to madrasas instead of secular schools, they spend 5 times a day praying disrupting their business, education, routine work, when they spend 30-40 days on fasting-feasting, how do you think they can progress and compete with others.
Send religion to homes as a personal belief and encourage scientific, secular, liberal and peaceful thoughts, Pakistan will progress
Just as ice cream cannot be made in an oven, impactful education centered on critical thinking cannot be affected without certified teacher training.
In the educational value chain, teacher training is the first stage of development which is desperately required for teachers of both public and private sector schools.
keep it up... intelligent minds like Miftah are rarity in Pakistan
I Am amazed by listening to MUFTA ISMAIL AT least he Acknowledged the truth
Mutfah and shabbar they are legends ❤
Miftah ismail 2022 k start may kehtha tha k imran petrol 150 per liter mehenga sale karaha hey, jab govt may aye tho kehtha k imran 150 per liter market rate say sastha sale karaha hey.
Good Work, most needed podcast.
Very good discussion and honest admittance on few areas - One may take so many good directional points from this !
🙏
Great man❤
Miftah ismail saheb to apna love hain.
Keep making such videos. Such an informative platform for this politically I'll informed youth
Assume every wish of this Sheikh Chilli comes true, it will still take Pis’stan more than one generation (25 yrs.) to stabilise!
But then ones gotta start some day.
Today is as good as any other day!
Great speech mifta sahab
Yup, plenty hot air Sheikh Chilli Sa’ab!
Zero deliverance!
The military used budget for political engineering, not to counter India.
I am very happy we are listening discussions on economic issues, problems of our economy, ways to improve economy.
Atif Mian, Miftah Ismail, Shabbar Zaidi, Qaiser Bengali all are giving their opinions. It enlighten public about the problems.
For a change we are listening things other than politics. Allah may bless our economists, anchors of economic podcast. Let's hope things will improve.
miftah is just another failed bureaucrat
Subko ilm muft main muhayya ho wo bhi aala.
Paisa hai khaney ka ...ilm kaha sey deyga😂...jao revolution Lao pehley...France ki tarah
5 million enjoyed renovated his house in Islamabad
There is a need of Foreign EDUCATION MINISTER. First and must solution for the education system of Pakistan.
Not at all. The problem in Pakistan is they copy foreign systems... They invest in buildings and resources.. Pakistan can never do this. Pak needs to follow methods in countries like Cuba where they did a mass campaign of education.
👍👍👍
Pakistan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs website is only in English. Even in Afghanistan's Taliban regime, the website is written in English, Dari, and Pashto. Pakistan is worse than Taliban's Afghanistan when it comes to not being able to properly create a website in own language.
The problem is scarcity of honesty in Pakistani generals, politicians, judges, and awaam as we know that Honesty is the best policy". The Taliban are honest and they really want to grow the nation not their own pockets
Miftah Bhai best man for the job
I have never seen a former finance minister make so many policies basis luck and Allah.
The number of ways one can cover his incompetence is beyond astounding.
Pakistan government is borrowing 4000 cores every day. With consumption of 85% bank money at 22% interest, who can start a business. Repatriation of money for foreign companies is a problem, this why so many foreign companies are leaving.
Pakistani Bhaiyo please ab change kro apnà total syllabus, Aap too tourism se hi bahut earning kar sakte ho agar pure Mandir aur Gurudware bana doo jitne 1947 mai thhe, Sabse fertile soil apke paas hai, Nadiya apke paas hai, Sirf Leaders hi chamge krne hai aapko aur fauj ko barracks mai rakhna hai ❤
Love from Amritsar Punjab, India
Impressive podcast. Please avoid the annoying sounds of requests for the channel subscription during the Podcast.
👍
❤❤❤
Before the Industrial Revolution, the governments did not involve themselves in commercial enterprises. During the IR, there was so much exploitation of the workers and the customers that governments started taking interest in the commercial enterprises, too. The principle was to provide essential services at a fair price. The resurrection of economies of European states after the two great wars was led by the state owned enterprises. There are many countries such as China, Iran, etc, where almost all enterprises, especially strategic enterprises like Railways, are state owned and work very efficiently. Even Indian Railways are state owned and still are one of the most efficient railways of the world. There are many state owned commercial enterprises in the USA and Western European countries, too. The most pertinent question in your vlog should have been why we can't run our SOEs efficiently.
Railways, for example, once operated pretty efficiently. Being a technical/commercial organisation, the strategic management and the technical management oversight requirements are different from those of the usual secretrait departments of the government. As the general bureaucracy did not have requisite expertise, Railways had a professional full-time executive Railway Board at the strategic management level. This board acted as the government for the railways. The arrangement was exactly on the same principles of the Indian Railway Board. The Chairman of the Board was always a railway professional who also acted as the ex-officio secretary for the federal government. In 1990. The professional Railway Board was abolished. The professional chairman was replaced by a CSS bureacrat. The Railway Board was also replaced by a board consisting of bureaucrats who had no knowledge of transport economics and even less of Railways. With the strategic management tier consisting of people from the general bureaucracy having no professional knowledge, the Railways started floundering like a rudderless ship. This has been the state of affairs since the last 24 years, grinding a once promising organisation to dust. Similar has been the case of PIA and Pakistan Steel Mills. Please study the staffing of their strategic management tier, and you will find proof of what I have stated above. Failure of every State organisation in Pakistan is a direct result of incompetence and a complete lack of appreciation of the job requirements by the policy making segment of our government.
Firstly you have pointed out correctly CCS CCS-qualified led board and political appointments have been the main cause of loss-making SOEs. To bring efficiency and limit political influence, I support the privatization of SOEs.
He seem to be good person
30:49 / 1:03:45 Why Private sector is performing well? The reason would be accountability, hand-on-hand punishment, and expulsion if someone is found guilty. Make the accountability & punishment in govt departments better, then we may not need privatization. If the same employee gives better output in private, then why not in public office? Something is missing in govt institutions; please remove that loophole. 1st, stop bureaucratic & political appointments in govt at any level. Otherwise also privatize Senate and parliaments.
If Pakistan is to progress, 1st it should distance itself from relegion and identity crisis.
پاکسان کا مسئلہ ھمیشہ سے فوجی جرل رھے ھیں اگر ملک آئین پر چلے تو ترقی کرسکتا ھے
I love Miftah Sahib a man with solutions
No, a man with ideas & suggestions. Basically a Sheikh Chilli with dreams.
Solutions hote to Pis’stan ki halat aaj wali nahin hoti!
Mr Ismail is a great orator. Pakistan with its current dispensation will not go anywhere. Think about it…mid day meals in schools is great way to attract out of school kids…
Our Balochistan is Bleeding. Help us.
Reduce ministries, give incentives to foreign investors, invest in human capital and education, and collect taxes from elites.
Ye pehla banda ha jiski ab ma izat karna laga hn kam az kam such to bol raha ha baki to sirf or sirf dalaal hain chaha siasat daan hoon ya uniform ma 😡
Mufti sb always talks so logical but unfortunately these people can't work in our system
If dishonesty, and flattery had a face it would exactly look like Miftah Ismail
Yes, he is a genius when it comes to economics but what to do with economic when he is not serious with the business of economics, he is an epitom of intellectual dishonesty, so what he says is just talking the talks and it will never be walked
You hit the nail on the head.
Sheikh Chilli hai!
Zero deliverance!
You are 💯 right
Raftar team done a great job ❤ invite the more honest Pakistani politicains . We need to understand the law and order and how run the country many people noting knows about the his rights ..best of luck for future one of best cheneal ❤
Every noteworthy country in the developing world has a national flagship airline owned by the state. The reason for this is that no country wants to put their airspace totally at the mercy of a few private profiteers. If you put air fares 100% in the control of private sector, they will exponentially increase them whenever it suits them, much to the detriment of the public. And there won't be anything the govt would be able to do to stop them. The only way to keep check on fares not becoming unreasonably high in 3rd world economies is to atleast keep 1 state owned airline in the aviation business.
Sensible person
Land owners agriculturest do not pay taxes - they should...agree Gold, Dimond and other luxery items should pay higher tax rate... lack of law & Order is the key issue in PK
No. 1 education subject is Islamiyaaat !
paxtan repeating the same mistake of bangladesh again with Balochi, Pashthun's, Sindhi's, minorities getting converted forcibly but but jump into matters of other nations thinking their opinions matters in world
Pakistan = Pakistan Punjabi Army #Fact
So doesn't increasing tax reduce the purchasing power of the taxed and doesn't the taxed entity would want to pass it on too? Case in point agriculture and service sector? Passing on taxes would again result in higher prices of potatoes, eggs, etc
Give up hatred with Hindu India, religious fanaticism, and terrorism, the Pak will be a best country in the world.
Can india do the same under BJP and modi?
👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Boht acha laga Miftah bhai apko sun kay. Magar afsos aap jis party men rahe un logo nay apki qadar nahi ki aur baat nahi mani. Damn them all -> PMLN, PPP, PTI
Good point.
Pakistan k schools main b achi education nhi. Teachers classes main b nhi jaty aur agar jatay hain to bs theorems yaad krny ya similar way main hi parhaty hain
Plus there r so many bad teachers principals jo students who physically abuse students. I have heard from credible sources how some students parents were so poor that they couldn't take these kids to hospitals afterwards and the other teachers pitched in. Principal still remained unscathed.
Sharia is solution for pakistan's problem. Allah ata farma.
Miftaf, you are very eloquent in identifying problems… however, i never hear you or any other pakistani politician propose a blue print for transformation… everyone only talks of tactical measures.. i have seen many talk of FDI’s in pakistan will solve everything but think for a moment, how it will happen ?? Even local or overseas pakistanis are unwilling to invest in industries in pakistan…
Basically a Sheikh Chilli.
Big dreams and ideas.
Zero deliverance!
سچ تو یہی ہے جب تک ہم امریکہ کے غلامی سے آزاد نہیں ہونگے ہم ترقی نہیں کر سکتے ہے
You are now free from American slavery now you are Chinese slave
46:00 onwards... wahan gareeb or ameer k liye equal oppertunity ha, yahan nahin or yahan koi honay bhe nahin deta q k ameeron k dumb bachon k liye competetion na ban jain.
Nihari wali baat sahi hai 💯 👍🏼😅
محترم پاکستان کا مسئلہ آبادی نہیں کرپشن ہے جس میں سبھی ذمہ دار ہے
Dear pakistani real problem is chusalam
Fauj ko budget india ke fauj ka nazar arha hai lekin india ke fauj ka constitutional role and civil obedience nazar nahe arhe .
💯
Sir Jagir daro per tex kio nahi lagatay
Pakistan need more states provinces immediately to solve problems
I listened to both episodes & I am actually a student of Mufta SB @ IBA during my MBA, really good & visionary thinking but my point is that why he didn't do all these plans as implemented during his tenures as he got enough opportunities in different govt setups....he is feeling a guilt I guess but better start paying off rather then doing talk shows.. Nation needs a lot of support....
So that he connt implements because he was undercomnd of Pmln... Chonron ky nichy
Implementation is important and provide technical education.
shabbar zaidi and miftah ismail combined podcast
Please dont put subscription bell ring in between very important discussion . Keep it soundless or pause the talk .Else ur content is fabulous
Lovely interview. Thank you so much, dear, Miftah Sahab for giving such a candid view even if a few of them may be politically incorrect & can hurt your political career. Pakistan needs brilliant, straight forward & committed rulers like you. You have demonstrated how you have used your position to understand the route problems of your nation & willing to travel an extra mile. But you have missed an important point that improving relationships with 3 critical neighbors India, Afghanistan & Iran must be the first priority. That enmity is not allowing you to focus on your problems & allocate adequate resources for the purpose of development & poverty alleviation. China has demonstrated that it could achieve economic prosperity despite the political model that is not acceptable to the democratic world but Pakistan is not successful in establishing the political coalition model where the military is either a dominant partner or ruler. Salute to you for the economic measures taken by you for your country. Our best wishes to our twin. May the great Allah help Pakistan & its people & also bring peace to India, Pakistan, Afghanistan & Iran. That is very important for the progress of all our nations. It is time to re-look at our assumptions & aspirations & forgive, if not forget, the mistakes committed by governments & militaries in the past. People of India & Pakistan, particularly the new generation want peace & an opportunity to progress rather than getting entangled in history & acts of revenge. Let the new Sun rise in the skies of India & Pakistan.
Aye si baat nahi india mein dukane 8 9 baje band khudi hojati hai mosam to ekjaise sa hai
Jinnah made a mistake to invaded Kashmir. Pakistan partition is not included with Kashmir 😂🎉🎉
Sir!
کراچی میں جو خون خرابہ ہوا، اور عوام نے جو قیمت ادا کی، اسکا شئیر بھی تو سیاستدان دیں نا۔
کریں جمع اب؟ ؟ ؟
کرتے جائیں
اے طائر لاہوتی اس رزق سے موت اچھی ۔ ۔ ۔
جس رزق سے آتی ہو پرواز میں کوتاہی ۔ ۔ ۔
Quide Azam ki wafat kese hui, uki ambulance q kharab hui wagera jasy untold secrets pa bhi video banaya
In issues par bohot videos ban chuki hain. It’s time Pakistanis stop doing randi Rona and get their act together to fix the economy. The only issue Pak has is economic , fix it and then no one will question why Pak wa created why ambulance broke down why this happened why that happened. Rather then fixing the country Pakistani public behaves like a looser and don’t play their part to do their bid
Pakistan faces economic challenges due to various factors including political instability, corruption, inadequate infrastructure, low tax revenue, reliance on foreign aid, terrorism, and insufficient investment in education and healthcare. These issues have hindered sustainable economic growth and development, contributing to its classification as a struggling economy.
I think he's good at highlighting ineffectiveness and inefficiencies and has a good train of strategic thought. However he also comes off as evasive and redirects to tangential topics without giving accountable answers and concrete way to get the hard things done.
If Pakistan fails. How candyland becomes billion rupees company in destroying Pakistan
Mifta, despite unearthing revelations, there is still a lot of "ME's" and "I's" giving a sense of bravado.