Pakistan's Citizen Portal The Untold Stories of Tax Fraud in Pakistani Restaurant Industry
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 เม.ย. 2024
- Pakistan's Citizen Portal The Untold Stories of Tax Fraud in Pakistani Restaurant Industry @raftartv Podcast with Zubair Ahmed Khan
In this eye-opening podcast, we delve into the world of tax compliance and enforcement in Pakistan. Our guest, Zubair Ahmed Khan, a chartered accountant, reveals the challenges and solutions surrounding tax evasion, particularly within the restaurant industry and multinational chains like KFC and McDonald's.
Discover how technology, such as the Pakistan Citizen Portal, is empowering citizens to report tax fraud and hold businesses accountable. Learn about real-time invoice monitoring systems implemented by the government to track sales tax payments, ensuring fiscal transparency.
Explore the impact of COVID-19 on tax reporting and the crucial role of social media in raising awareness about tax compliance issues. From government initiatives to public engagement, this podcast sheds light on Pakistan's journey towards fiscal responsibility.
#taxevasion #foodindustry #portal #tax #untoldstory #fbr #sindhgoverment #audit #pakistanirestaurant #franchise #kfc #mcdonalds #salestax #pakistan #statebankofpakistan #moneylaundring #vat #private #public #hotels #streetfood #karachi #ministryoffinance #podcast #accountancy #finance #economics #prepayment #receipt #filer #revenue
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
TH-cam
/ @raftartv
TH-cam
/ @raftarnewsofficial
TH-cam
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Playoffs Grand Final // GEN vs DRX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Su6gA_UPs9s/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Playoffs Lower Bracket Final // PRX vs DRX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5HwO1bQyAx4/mqdefault.jpg)
This man deserves Sitara-e-imtiaz. People like him are true face of Pakistan.
This man should leave Pakistan as soon as possible
o bhai ye sirf 2+2 math parh ker apnay aap ko aqalmand samjh raha hai... FBR knows all this already.
keep this sitara with yourself. meaningless things.
ya nafsiyati hay bhai. kabhi ya nahi pochay ga kay sindh ka tex kaha laga.
He isn't corrupt/compromised enough to deserve any presidential award 😜.
Wow! That's what i call the social work he just made me realsie that when law enforcing agencies are corrupt, every business concern gets corrupted in turn, and That's how nations fail.
Not corrupt infact weak than general public and mafias
They have less resources to enforce law
If seaside restaurant does not want to register, AND if the authorities also do not reply, then hey common people, just boycott them. Do the same to others like that as well
Private doctors & hospitals earn crores but they take cash and do not pay any tax. They must be forced to issue FBR invoice.
True.. I believe there's more cash and transactions in a day in a big private hospital compared to a bank
Lovely podcast. Zubair deserves the Chairman FBR post !! Young , talented, motivated and concerned citizen. Super effort. Thanks Raftar for inviting him on your show.
Triple likes & Red salute to this HERO ❤. Deserves Sitara e Imtiaz.
Do bring more such people on the channel they are true heros and inspiration for Pakistani Youth.
This is an indirect tax and burden will be borne by Customer not restaurant
We need more sensitive and talented people like him in Public as well as in FBR to report such tex frauds. His words are simple and arguments are sound that ought to be considered in policy making of tax implementation and collection. Long live SIR :)
this is not tax fraud. FBR is aware of it
Lets viral the shorts of this video on every platform to increase awareness among general public
Proud of you Zubair👏👍 keep it up👍👍 Allah aap ko kamiyaab kare🤲 aap jese no jawano pe hi khan ko bharosa he k aap is tarha k issues ko hi light kare ge aur saari awaam ko bhi awareness mile gi👍👍💪💪👏👏
God bless you Allah aap ko apni amaan me rakhe🤲❤🇵🇰
Excellent video to educate the masses. More content like this should be created. Hats off to this Karachite for his work and dedication. Income tax evasion and sales tax evasion should be a crime punishable by life time.
ZubairKhanPK is a 💎 & thanks raftaar for bringing him on podcast
Gem lol 😂😂😂
I saw the first "Real existing" Philanthropist of Pakistani economy... Marvelous job Zubair Ahmed Khan Sahab, May Allah give you courage, Aameen
Zabardast finance economics accounting tax par mazaeed video banayen jari rakhen thanks
فوجی فاونڈیشن کے ادارے ، اور فوجی فرٹیلائزر کے یونٹ بھی ٹیکسز جمع نہیں کراتے ہیں اور fertilizer یونٹ تو گیس بھی انتہائی کم نرخوں پہ لیتے ہیں ۔
Good question۔
Galatfehmi hai aap k koi b business including Army business tax pay kertay hain mager UN ka Audit nahi hota hai, Army personnels per tax exemption hai.
Bus ek Nafrat hai usey pora kernay k lehay Mulk k her galat Kam ka sath do awam aur Mulk jahey bhar main bus Mera leader zindabad
😂yeh log tax khate hain hum hee unn ko palte hain
Army ka audit na hona kon c achi or qanooni bat hay? Is ke kya logic hay?
@@junaids3046 ku exemption hai?
This guy Deserved right recognition. Thanks raftar team for showing gems ❤
Wow, this video hits hard! Exposing how much corruption is in the tax department is eye-opening. If all that money wasn't stolen, Pakistan could be so much better off! It's like everyone who pays their taxes is getting cheated. Thanks to such activists and platforms like Raftar for bringing awareness.
Very Informative
Amazing work.
Government should award 5,000-10,000 for each valid entry.
You can get employed many in the country for doing this alone.
eye opener discussion, great talk
Unsung hero of Pakistan. These people deserve highest civilian awards instead of TV anchors.
excellent work, we need more heros like him to come forward. Hatsoff to Raftar for highlighting him.
Excellent.. informative... commendable effort by Zubair sb
Lol 😂😂😂
پورا بوہری بازار ، بولٹن مارکیٹ، جوڑیا بازار، لیاری مین مارکیٹ ، اور کراچی کی دیگر مارکٹیں ریونیو ڈیپارٹمنٹ کو نظر نہیں آتی ہیں ۔بس ایک تنخواہ دار طبقہ سے اگے کچھ نظر نہیں آتا ہے ۔
Shinwari aur dosray Pathano ke restaurant bhe nazar nahi aatay jo arab pati hain aur tax chori kartay hain.
Informative podcast
I myself is a Chartered Accountant, why this idea did not came in my mind.
Fasinating work and story sharing by Raftar. ❤❤
How to contact this guy?
Glad you liked it!
@@raftartv How to contact this guy
He’s a real life hero.
So proud of you my boy if you are reading this comment thank you so much.
Pakistan really needs heroes like you🤎
This young man is face of the slight glimmer of hope for Pakistan.
He's fraud he has taken bribe from many Marts and restaurants
So happy to see zubair here.following him for past several years.proud to be isafian
unbelievable , brother keep on doing great work
Very Informative podcast, May ALLAH pak grant you both a great success and give you protection from the ones who does tax theft. Ameen
May Allah bless Zubair Ahmed Khan and also thumbs up for Faisal Waheed.
Very informative podcast
زبیر صاحب کے لئے ایک مشورہ ہے کہ وہ لوگوں کی رہنمائی کریں کہ ٹیکس چوروں کو کیسے سامنے لایا جائے
آپ ذبیر کو ٹوئیٹر پر فالو کریں
اس کا ٹوئیٹر ہینڈلر @ZubairKhanPK ہے
Isko email karo iske pages follow karo
I think fbr kee app k opper reciept upload karo joo bhi reciept hoo us saay points bhi milltay hain. Imran k tenure mein prizes bhi thay draw k baad joo loog jitne bhi reciept upload karay gaa us koo points millain gaain. My cousin won 25 thousand ruppee.
@@SBS-22 you're winning prizes for what is the default
Goes to show the pathetic situation
Is citizen portal still active. It was very good application in PTI government.
I complained in 2022 but the issue was responded very late.
When fbr tries to expand taxnet by imposing tax on retailers they got very very angry and starts blackmailing of shutdowns. Govt has to take serious actions to document these economies.
Shabbar Zaidi Saheb was beaten ( yes he was beaten during the meeting federal officers watching ) by the President of retailers association.
What else is new. Goonda raj in Pakistan.
@@nizamuddinahmadaali3244anyone who is slightly well off in Pakistan benefit from the corrupt regime and goonda culture
Really Appreciated. Good effort dear
ہم دنیا میں اخلاق باختگی ، مس مینیجمینٹ اور لا قانونیت کی عمدہ مثال بن چکے ہیں ۔۔
Very informative and inspirational
Keep it up 👍
Great guy...following him on twitter since he started this tax policing role...Well done...Agr FBR walo se yeh kaam bhi nahi hota to FBR ko bhi privatize karde
I am also an ACCA. And this man gave a big answer to those people who don't count acca as Chartered accountants. he deserve to be in FBR.
Kudos to Zubair for his exceptional courage and determination
Excellent...
True representation of Pakistani youth, passionate, enthusiastic, dedicated, determined
Allah salamat rakhein aap ko bhai. Mashallah boht aala tarbiyyat ke aap k parents ne jo aap haq baat kerne se nai ghabraey. Allah aap ko hamesha apne hifz o aman mei rakhein. Ameen
Zabardast
very informative video thanks to raftaar
India gst collection is INR 250000 cr. a year (1cr= 100 lakh)
Very nice example given for Saudi Arabia. I live here for last 15 years with family, he is right.
it's on record chairman FBR was physically mandled by traders/ retailers in provincial gov office which he likes to impose minimum tax on.this sector.
Hats off to you man & shame to those responsible. Lets introduce the channel to report so everyone can put his/her effort to strengthen our homeland. Why do we bear all this tax and debt burden? Those who pay religiously should be awarded and compensated and acknowledged publicly.... We want to see Sitar e Izzat for all the top contributors. May Allah bless us with the good leadership. Ameen
Bravo🎉🎉
Excellent work and look how it was noticed and appreciated by the then PM Imran Khan!
This channel rise real issue
Also Savour Foods included.
Wo apna tax BHI awam sy ly rahy taky khud na dyna pary.🙆🏽♂️
Brilliant initiative, may Allah bless him
Revenue authority he corrupt hai to tax denay k baad bhe koi frq nhe parayga
Salute Zubair Bhai ❤
Zubair Bhai good work keep it up I am with you always
I traveled in 2019 to Pakistan and filed a complaint on the portal, and it worked. I got the confirmation .
Excellent content 👍
Great man
He is actually right . I have proofs kfc has two books
This is good way to serve country
Zubair bhai should make a TH-cam channel
He has one
TaxChoriBandKaru
Nice podcast 🎉
Keep it up bro
Good
Govt is all set to squeeze the blood of salaried class, and SRB don’t want to move their ass out of office! But the irony is if govt tax collection is enhanced than, will the government spend more on masses or on public services?
Brilliant.
BraVo
Last week on Thursday, I had lunch with my family at a well-known restaurant in Lahore called "The Online Pizza." They have clearly mentioned on the entrance door of the restaurant that they do not accept cards.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@ Zubair Ahmed Khan, a better way to deal with this theft is that the whole service sector should be asked to inform customer via receipt or ntn for sales tax they owe to the relevant authorities rather then collecting it on their behalf. Atleast this will motivate the relevant authorities to track amounts due from citizens rather then powerful/notorious business owners etc.
Good job Zubair and Raftar team. Please share his social media profile so we can also spread his work.
فوج اپنے بجٹ کا آڈٹ تک نہیں کراتی، اور ملک کا اتنا بجٹ کھا جاتی ہے، کچھ نہیں پتہ وہ پیسے کہاں خرچ کرتے ہیں۔
Please Hamen aap Logon ki Kaun series wali documentary bahut acchi Lagti Hai
I have also been reporting such invoices since 2020 after POS activation... I do report every POS invoice and verify on FBR tax asaan app ...
Wherever I find a suspicious invoice I always report it.
👍 Zubair Ahmed, zaburdast 👍🫡
How about doctors and pharmaceutical companies?
Need more podcasts on Tax Collections.
Thek hai, thek hai, thek hai 😀
Bhai Ap k video buhut ache hote hen mein regular dekhta rehta hun
Regard Zahid Hussain From Sukkur
Brilliant Man on Nobel Cause. He needs highest civilian award for his services.
I slaute your hard work Young Man but the problem is our concern department official who are pocketing the cash from these restaurants and basially guide these restaurants owners to hide the sale and how not to pay the taxes.
Tax officers ko paisay jaa rahay hotay hain isi liye wo restaurants ki complain nahi krta. 😅
Shahdi lawn ko ku integrate ni kr rahe.?
Sir balochistan me koi system hai to btaein hm b kuch jaalsaazo ko tax net me le kr ayain
Excellent and nationalist approach...
Bhai. Mene khud suna hai 1 business owner se k unho ne apna fbr ko kuch paisy de k tax maaf krwaya. Aur unho ne kisi aur business ko ye krty dekha tha. Kai business ko to fbr/sbr officers rishwat le k chor dete hongy
Jaisi qoum waisy hukmran...
I was checking the authenticity of the Halal Zabiha in McDonalds hamburgers sold in Karachi. I contacted their headquarters in Oak Brook , Chicago. Their response was ( contact local corporate representatives in Pakistan.). There ( Karachi ) response was to contact Dubai office, which is a game of circles. email response was also zero.
I was told by food industry representative that meat comes from Argentina and Australia which is ot slaughtered according to Islamic way ( zabiha ). Ownerships of franchisees are also non Muslims from India.
Let PM and budget makers must watch and listen.
How come that person riding on a luxury vehicle, owning and making money out of tax networks... a simple method to check and enlist tax payer. Why FBR is running after small shop keepers to squeeze their bread earnings, etc. A clear cut indications of vested interest, corruptions, lack of honesty.
A lot of this bad behavior is enabled by so called chartered accountants and tax consultants - catching them and taking away their license should also be part of the plan.
Bakery items to food category main atay hain, us per sales tax ni hona chahie
Sir Zubair Khan is using the PM Citizen Portal at his best!!!
May ALLAH bless him
Last tax amnesty bhi RAFTAR KE ABBU NIAZI NE DI THI 😂😂😂
بدقسمتی سے سندھ میں صوبایی لیول کے اداروں میں جو سندھی ہیں وہ بڑا بھائی چارہ کا خیال رکھتے ہیں، اور اسی بھائی چارے میں خیال کرکے دوستی یار سنگت نبھاتے ہیں،
5000 hazar ka note band kar dy sub theek ho jay ga
36:34 Because this is the main difference between service and goods. When you are eating food it’s a service so charged in Srb whereas if you’re purchasing packaged food or bakery item then they are providing goods so charged under Fbr.