What I found to be heartbreaking. Imagine being a 14 year old girl (or boy). You're not sick with cancer or any other deadly illness or sickness. Yet you know, you are going to die. She wrote that before hiding her diary. I can't imagine being 14 and knowing, not thinking, but knowing, I was going to die.
Christine Fougere I agree. Some of these documentaries would be better served without the background music. I want to hear what is being said and not struggle to hear because of the music.
"If only I could say, it's over, you die only once. But I can't, because despite all these atrocities, I want to live, and wait for the following day." ~Rut "Rutka" Laskier (12 June 1929 - 5 August 1943) My heart breaks for you, sweet child. I'm so sorry. RIP
Alice Rabbit Have you considered seeing a psychiatrist, or do you laugh it off when people close to you suggest it? Take your miserable lies and anger somewhere where they’re wanted.
Such a well done documentary, but unfortunately the music was so loud that whenever she was reading her diary it was nearly impossible to understand her words, which was the most important part of the story 😢
My first language is Spanish and I'm struggling to understand the English translation UNDER the voice of the girl reading in Polish. I'm missing a lot, and have to keep adjusting the volume because sometimes it's too loud, and then it decreases dramatically, and back again to loud.
The fact that you can’t hear the English narration it’s very frustrating that the person speaking whether it’s a child from the school or whatever is annoying because their shrilly loud. But the voice of Rutka In the near ration is really too soft. The music is utterly irrelevant. For that reason I nearly turn this off for or five times
I would love to actually be able to hear the words this beautiful young lady wrote. I didn't sit down to watch this only to hear the very loud music. So disappointing.
Thank you Rutka for hiding your diary and to your friend for keeping it so safe. She was so smart and determined. It shows in what person how much the world lost!!! What would she have done with her life??? What would her future generations??? So much taken by hate!!! I am so glad she named her daughter after her sister to keep her memory alive. I live in a small town in Vermont, USA nd we have a survivor that lived here and she set up teaching and spoke when she was alive at school. I had taught my daughter but when she heard it in person it is so much more powerful
It is a Jewish tradition to name children for beloved deceased family members. A friend named her daughter Ingrid, after a male member named Irving, in memory of him.
What a gifted writer....murdered at the hands of demons...what stories she could've written...but she was published...she reached out from the grave and lives on ... RIP Rutka
Yes, there is an issue with the sound, but I persevered and still found this documentary a powerful thought provoking account of a hideous period in European history.
@ImNotMad ButUR It doesn't feel like a troll to me. just someone who was triggered by the music being too loud just like everyone else. Honestly, I just have a hard time imagining a person using youtube while ignoring every single video they click. Only to write random disparaging comments on those videos.
What a touching documentary! What a privilege to know about the diary of that remarkable girl. She was surely one of a kind! I am so glad her diary was found, preserved, and her words spread out the way she surely would have wanted. Thank you to all of you who made that possible. What a privilege her sister had of visiting all the places that were part of the other sister's life! Thank you so very much for sharing the journey. So meaningful, so profoundly felt. The audio was really a problem, but still, the documentary was so worthy of watching. Thanks a lot! I will never forget this story!
I just bought the journal/diary and read it in a day. I love history and it amazed me how I couldn’t put it down. I don’t believe most kids her age have no idea what emotions she had. She dreamed about after the war and about life and how happy she would be. It was really sad how she was losing faith. So intelligent, yet so vulnerable with the short life she had. She loved reading and there were so few books to be found. Just so sad.
I can't hear the narrative above the music!! Do you guys play it back for yourselves before you release this in the public forums? At least add subtitles!! It's frustrating to say the least
@Lost Soul Thankyou. Yes. It is important for people to understand that most people were perpetrators of cruelty or bystanders. It certainly did not happen because of one man. Thankfully there is education happening in many places including Poland. Love from New Zealand.
I really would have liked to hear Rutka speaking; however, the music was way too loud. Who makes a video or movie with music so loud that it makes the thing impossible to hear?
Thank you for sharing this sad but inspiring story. Rutka left behind a very important account of herself and her life experience at a time when young people were witness to terrible things and had hope for nothing but to live through the day and see another tomorrow. That her father survived Auschwiz and went on to remarry and bring more life into the world is a true miracle. For Rutka's diary to have been kept, lovingly protected, and then shared with future generations is so important. The most touching aspect of this documentary is that the sister Rutka never knew, and who would never have a chance to meet her, has had the opportunity to acquaint herself with Rutka and the homeland in which she grew up. Rutka hid her diary to keep it safe but always wanted it to be found. She wanted people to know her story. Yet she would never have dreamed that her words would eventually find their way home to family again... to be read by a sister who would have the life that she herself would never get to live.
I have such a deep passionate respect for anyone who was in the holocaust. It has such a deep place in my heart. I was just a teen ager when i first read The Diary of Anne Frank .Since then i have absorbed everything about the holocaust . Thank you for this presentation.
@@dianestafford6968 you're welcome. I'm really glad that people share all the experiences of what happened during the holocaust . I hope that as time goes on that all generations will know and understand those years .
Me too. And my Jewish great grandmother fled Russia to escape right before the holocaust. Her son, my grandfather, married a Christian woman and their kids were raised Christian and so on. But his sister married another jew and that side of the family is all Jewish but live overseas. I know nothing about my Jewish heritage first hand and it makes me sad. I only know what I read in books. My great grandmother died 15 years before I came along and my grandfather didn’t talk about his Jewish past. It embarrassed him 😞
My heart feels broken for the tragic story of this innocent child. How can humans behave in this way? Is it any wonder the Jewish people fight to keep their country and home.
joan baczek, iIm certainly not diminishing the suffering of all those affected by this atrocity. I’m merely pointing out that they had no country. The 6000000 Jews had no where to turn to, no home and no loyalty from the country they were living in and calling home. The polish have Poland and were amongst their people in their home. I know this because my grandfather was a Polish Jew turned away by the people he thought were his friends and country.
ImNotMad ButUR so true. It’s up to people like you and myself to teach our kids, siblings, friends and any one else who is willing to learn, that we are all people, regardless of religion, color, sex and nationality. Bless you for your obvious kind heart 💓
Unbelievable story ! I think I grew a few wrinkles from my face being crunched the whole time. This little girl lost so much of her life to only be brought back to life many years later. Such a tragic Story. I think I’m traumatized when she said she seen a nazi solider take a baby from it’s mother and smash its head on a pole and the guts where everywhere. What kind of demon monster does something like that. The nazis party was nothing but an army straight from the pits of hell.
@Jen Green I really know this goes on today. I'm not going to give many details but I come from a country where food is scarce and thieves often steal food, oil is also scarce, as a result transportation is a luxury, power outages are part of one daily live. I didn't say it stopped but I said that people who caused the whole situation were evil. History often repeats itself and the weak ones suffer the most. Out of nowhere a tyrant might be the next in power... If what we live here now is tough enough, because it is I can't imagine how it was/it is for other people in much rougher circumstances. Sorry if I made any grammar mistake.
I can't hear what is being Said. the music is to loud. and the girls reading and at the same time they are talking the dialogue in English is impossible to hear both at the same time
Many of these kids had to grow up fast due to their situation, it’s sad too see how they suffered and they were very aware of what was to come and were preparing for it.
I am only 4 minutes in, but this has already pulled at my heart. I am so sorry for anyone who suffers loss like this. However, I am happy she has found her sister. Incredible.
Don't let future generations forget what these poor people went through because we as a society can't allow this to happen again!!! As hard as it is to let people know how horrible things were they need to never forget!!!
@Topjunkie in Russia’s case vs Ukraine. I think you mean lost. I’m bet Putin ends up like sadam Hussein. Neck in rope dangling from a tree. It’s a typical ending for dictators.
This is a very remarkable, sad and powerful story and the best testimony about a young Polish girl, whose only 'crime' was having been born Jewish. The saddest part of it is the state of people's mind, who get worked up about too loud background music, failing to engage with the message of this story. The words that matter are always uttered quietly amid background noise. Learning to listen and to hear is an important and valuable skill.
This is an important story and it needs to be told, with that said it needs to be redone because the music drowns out the voices. I am very disappointed in the editing. So get out your machine and redo this. I look forward to seeing a new copy and I believe more people will want to watch it once they can hear the story. Like I said it's a very important story and it needs to be told over and over again, but it's hard to retell a story when you can't hear it. Sometimes the words are so low it's unintelligible. Please fix this!
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan if you care so much to write such a long heated comment about it
I pray that one day this is re-edited so we can all hear and understand her story! I believe it is very very important for the world to hear and know her story!
I persevered through the video because my great-grandfather was a rabbi from Warsaw who came to the US prior to the war and none of his relatives survived. Unfortunately, music overplaying the speaker and the translator made it impossible to hear some passages and immensely detracted from the story. It would be nice if the sound was re-engineered so that all the English words were audible. I find it amazing how astute this child was at 13, much more so than I was at that age and how she and the other children were able to face the negative changes in their world with such strength. What a wonderful legacy for her half-sister and family.
I really wanted to watch this important documentary but had to stop because the music was too loud making voices unclear in so many places. Such a scheme, wish it could be sound edited.
As I get older, I realize that many factors impact hearing. Younger people think it just means everything is softer or quiet. Now, I realize that it can be difficult to distinguish sounds from one another. That may be why the blending of two voices and music makes it difficult for some to hear Rutka's message.
Why are all of your channels videos edited with such horrible background music??? Can't hear the narrator or any of the people speaking. It's horrible. Honestly, in relation to a subject of this magnitude, the music shouldn't even be included. Only the subject matter being discussed by these people should be heard.
I never NEVER comment on videos.. but please re upload this video! The narration is barely audible due to the background music. This is an important piece of history and it’s a shame that you can’t properly hear it.
Yes, the music was too loud sometimes but it was still worth watching. Very beautifully made even though it was very sad. May they all RIP. Thank you for the upload.
marykatherine73 l could not hear the translation from polish to English. As the two languages were muddled together . Then the music was louder than the speaking.. So I put it on BOSE speaker , that was better, but still background noice was very annoying . I loved the story .
I was very interested in listening to this video, especially as there seems to be an increase in anti semitism. However I couldn't hear it with the horrendous music playing, I had to stop watching it. I've noticed that a loT of the historical and informative videos are doing this. Please either stop the music or provide a way to st.op it without losing normal sound
I wish that I could hear the when in the background her "words" are being read or the commentator, but the background music is too loud and the voice to low. Watched a couple of times to try and get the full story. Very important.
I am grateful for the account of another diary of a young girl. It never ceases to amaze me how much more educated children were than they are today. I would love to read this young girls account. Unfortunately in this documentary the music being played while she is speaking in her native language and then translated into English all at the same time is disturbing. Her thoughts, and feelings, as well as her story has been drowned out by all of the background noise. If the music had been toned down or just silent during the reading would have made this far better. This diary about her life is just as important today along with Anne Frank's. As we are living in a time when all of our freedoms may disappear.
If I may be so bold. I really don’t know how to communicate this well. But as I began to listen to this piece, the audio mix was less than desirable. The music overwhelmed the narrative. Other TH-cam videos come across well. I am disappointed in not being able to learn from this piece. FYI
How can you allow such terrible sound editing on a documentary about such an important subject? It is a disgrace to the memory of the murdered people this is about.
An Incredible life journey of a young talented girl. It must've taken immense courage to write and hide her diary for posterity. Please edit the background music/sounds for clear audibility. RIP Rutka.
The sound was poorly managed. Could not hear the words in the diary because the girls voices were much too loud. Very, very poor sound management. Hope that sound engineer didn’t get more work because the story was lost.
I find it kind of sad that she doesn’t talk as much about having a brother too, as much as she does about having a sister. We may not have his thoughts on paper, but he was just as real.
I really can't hear what is being said ,the music is loud and the girls reading over the voice is way too long ,it's such a shame ,I'd love to hear what this young lady said in her diary !!!
The innocence of the children and their compassion with how similar they were had me shedding tears as they realizing the horror of what this child had to confront from neighbors and friends made her my hero because she never was consumed with hate.🙏🙏🙏
So upset because of the loud music, you can not understand what the people and children are reading! Such a shame. I want to hear Rutkas story! Not sure I spelled her name right.
Great story makes me happy this girl was able to journal her experiences during such a horrific time in history. Her memories will live on. Her journal bears wittiness to an awful time in world history.
I just ordered Rutka’s diary in English from Amazon. I will return after reading it; I’m sure that I’ll want to watch this video again after reading. Oh! Rutka was so beautiful. That much I see right away. I’m eager to read what she has to tell us all. Like others, it found it hard to hear the voice through the music. Please remaster this!
Yes the music overcomes the dialogue. This is a very important part of human history please re-edit. As a non Jew my sincere condolences for your loss.
I wish the editor had mixed the audio better. It is a wonderful and very sad documentary. Rutka deserves her voice to be heard properly. I think what these types of stories have taught me it is so important to document your life. I used to write a journal but stopped a very long time ago. I think this is inspiring me to begin again. I think everyone should begin a journal. Maybe one day our words will mean something to someone in the future.
It's so hurting to heard that she's been rename after Anne Franks, but she was Rudka, and that's her, she wrote her own stories and she was unique too, just like each one of us. very admiring courage she'd.
The background music drowns out the dialogue and I ended up not watching it all as I couldn't hear what was being said. Such a shame as it is an important piece of history.
Please upload this again please make the music not so loud so we can actually hear this very important story disappointed. There is enough drama in the history of this horrible display of atrocities without the grinding pounding sound. YOU cheapen it. Don't play Hollywood.
I also hope this is reedited. This needs to be appreciated. I quit after 12 minutes, to difficult to hear the soft narration over the music. Every piece of information must be embraced, and I've already missed to much.
I literally weeped through the whole thing. I also have relatives who suffered in the holocaust. I don't think it's so easy for non Jews to connect to the real horror.
You don't need to be Jewish to understand the horror. We are all human beings. Human beings with families, and friends. We can all understand how precious and fragile life is.
Thank you for the compliments, but I am infatuated with children and women, who were victims and live to tell the their story. I want to put this i writing; I love you and admire you. I am a WW11 veteran's daughter with my dad and papa.
This made me cry so badly, my hubby is a Polish, he told me everything what he know from his grandparent... Those innocent and defenseless souls, all of them... RIP
Such a tragic, heartbreaking story. The one ray of happiness is the ending, where we see Zahava's beautiful family (who are also Rutka's beautiful family). Am chai Yisroel (the people of Israel live)! My only criticism of this video is that the music was too loud, making it very hard to hear the dialogue.
@@mspancake0561 - Nobody is saying the music isn’t beautiful. People are complaining about the music overwhelming what is being said. Music, if any, should be on the background and never drowning the message that’s being conveyed.
It feels like we got to see Rutka all grown up, with the family and future she deserved. I'd like to imagine this is the ending of her journal and her story. She fought so hard to live.
I had the honor to live in Germany as a young adult, met and became friends with some survivors of this era. My landlords were Czech who were lucky enough to escape when the Nazis occupied Poland. They were children and young adults at the time of the escape. Hearing their stories first hand, I will never forget.
![⭐ฮิตในTikTok!! ( หมูเด้ง MooDeng ) Ver. แดนซ์โจ๊ะๆ ReMix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3krsyfWUeHU/mqdefault.jpg)
The friend that retrieved and held onto the diary for decades is the friend in life we all want. She was so sweet, it made me cry.
What I found to be heartbreaking. Imagine being a 14 year old girl (or boy). You're not sick with cancer or any other deadly illness or sickness. Yet you know, you are going to die. She wrote that before hiding her diary. I can't imagine being 14 and knowing, not thinking, but knowing, I was going to die.
Very important story and you are ruining it with the background music drowning out the dialogue
Yes. I so agree!
Christine Fougere I agree. Some of these documentaries would be better served without the background music. I want to hear what is being said and not struggle to hear because of the music.
Alice Rabbit ? Please explain?
I agree! I also couldn't hear the English translation because the guy was reading the Polish portions too loud.
@@bananapeaches6370 Please don't encourage the trolls.
"If only I could say, it's over, you die only once. But I can't, because despite all these atrocities, I want to live, and wait for the following day." ~Rut "Rutka" Laskier (12 June 1929 - 5 August 1943)
My heart breaks for you, sweet child. I'm so sorry. RIP
Alice Rabbit Have you considered seeing a psychiatrist, or do you laugh it off when people close to you suggest it? Take your miserable lies and anger somewhere where they’re wanted.
@Alice Rabbit you need serious help.
Wow Anne Frank was born on the same day
@@juliohuizar4226 Oh, wow. You're right. That's a crazy coincidence.
@@juliohuizar4226 Yeah what a coincidence
I truly wish the background music wasn't so loud.
Same, loved the documentary and the story but couldn't really hear a lot of it 😭
I agree!
Agreed
Yes , so much I couldn't hear .
0000
Such a well done documentary, but unfortunately the music was so loud that whenever she was reading her diary it was nearly impossible to understand her words, which was the most important part of the story 😢
sad no closed captioning
RIGHT ON!
Right
@@user-xg3uy6hq9gI'm watching this at this very moment with closed captioning. So what are you talking about??
The background music is so loud CANT HEAR most important dialogue! TERRIBLE EDITING
I agree! I can barely hear their voices! So frustrating!!
@tom kat no its never !!
I was just going to comment on that also, when I saw your post. :((
Earphones or headphones make a world of a difference. Yeah, there are too many uploads with poor sound quality.
@Alice Rabbit Fuck off, arsehole.
The little girl that wrote the diary had beautiful handwriting! Amazing how well preserved it is!
WHY is the irrelevant music more important to this video editor to be heard, than this very important story?!
It’s called copyright
Because the editor is a total idiot!
Side Eyed & Bushy Tailed I agree. Couldn’t make out the narrative at all.
My first language is Spanish and I'm struggling to understand the English translation UNDER the voice of the girl reading in Polish. I'm missing a lot, and have to keep adjusting the volume because sometimes it's too loud, and then it decreases dramatically, and back again to loud.
The fact that you can’t hear the English narration it’s very frustrating that the person speaking whether it’s a child from the school or whatever is annoying because their shrilly loud. But the voice of Rutka In the near ration is really too soft. The music is utterly irrelevant. For that reason I nearly turn this off for or five times
I would love to actually be able to hear the words this beautiful young lady wrote. I didn't sit down to watch this only to hear the very loud music. So disappointing.
That's today's world all over. 'The music was too loud'. If only Rutka's concerns had been so pathetically trivial.
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
@@flederfox Because music 🎶 should not be overshadowing such important information. It is a horrible distraction and just disrespectful.
@@peterbenton2897 ?Otto Frank wrote Ruthka Lasker's diary?
Thank you Rutka for hiding your diary and to your friend for keeping it so safe. She was so smart and determined. It shows in what person how much the world lost!!! What would she have done with her life??? What would her future generations??? So much taken by hate!!! I am so glad she named her daughter after her sister to keep her memory alive. I live in a small town in Vermont, USA nd we have a survivor that lived here and she set up teaching and spoke when she was alive at school. I had taught my daughter but when she heard it in person it is so much more powerful
It is a Jewish tradition to name children for beloved deceased family members. A friend named her daughter Ingrid, after a male member named Irving, in memory of him.
What you did with teaching your daughter about this is inspiring.
Distracting
Yeah turn thT music down
The poignancy of Rutka‘a diary is matched by her sister’s eloquence and sensitivity in sharing this with us. Thank you.
What a gifted writer....murdered at the hands of demons...what stories she could've written...but she was published...she reached out from the grave and lives on ... RIP Rutka
I’m
Yes, there is an issue with the sound, but I persevered and still found this documentary a powerful thought provoking account of a hideous period in European history.
@tom kat What?
Derek Emson -- I felt the same way. mind over matter. it wasn't extremely awful where it warrants one to walk away from the entire documentary.
I agree very powerful I didnt notice the music
@ImNotMad ButUR It doesn't feel like a troll to me. just someone who was triggered by the music being too loud just like everyone else. Honestly, I just have a hard time imagining a person using youtube while ignoring every single video they click. Only to write random disparaging comments on those videos.
Mankind's history.
What a touching documentary! What a privilege to know about the diary of that remarkable girl. She was surely one of a kind! I am so glad her diary was found, preserved, and her words spread out the way she surely would have wanted. Thank you to all of you who made that possible. What a privilege her sister had of visiting all the places that were part of the other sister's life! Thank you so very much for sharing the journey. So meaningful, so profoundly felt. The audio was really a problem, but still, the documentary was so worthy of watching. Thanks a lot! I will never forget this story!
I just bought the journal/diary and read it in a day. I love history and it amazed me how I couldn’t put it down. I don’t believe most kids her age have no idea what emotions she had. She dreamed about after the war and about life and how happy she would be. It was really sad how she was losing faith. So intelligent, yet so vulnerable with the short life she had. She loved reading and there were so few books to be found. Just so sad.
Rutka could be anyone's child. It's horrendous what happened to the Jews because one man hated them.
I can't hear the narrative above the music!! Do you guys play it back for yourselves before you release this in the public forums? At least add subtitles!! It's frustrating to say the least
See Canon not just Jews my family was catholic polish and met the same fate
@Lost Soul Thankyou.
Yes. It is important for people to understand that most people were perpetrators of cruelty or bystanders. It certainly did not happen because of one man. Thankfully there is education happening in many places including Poland.
Love from New Zealand.
@@alishadawn6636 hmmmm what children???? Certainly he prejudice about which ones.
The German woman didnt fair well either. The whole thing was a tragedy.
I really would have liked to hear Rutka speaking; however, the music was way too loud. Who makes a video or movie with music so loud that it makes the thing impossible to hear?
Thank you for sharing this sad but inspiring story. Rutka left behind a very important account of herself and her life experience at a time when young people were witness to terrible things and had hope for nothing but to live through the day and see another tomorrow. That her father survived Auschwiz and went on to remarry and bring more life into the world is a true miracle. For Rutka's diary to have been kept, lovingly protected, and then shared with future generations is so important. The most touching aspect of this documentary is that the sister Rutka never knew, and who would never have a chance to meet her, has had the opportunity to acquaint herself with Rutka and the homeland in which she grew up. Rutka hid her diary to keep it safe but always wanted it to be found. She wanted people to know her story. Yet she would never have dreamed that her words would eventually find their way home to family again... to be read by a sister who would have the life that she herself would never get to live.
Does anyone know how the friend got away?
Well put!
I have such a deep passionate respect for anyone who was in the holocaust. It has such a deep place in my heart. I was just a teen ager when i first read The Diary of Anne Frank .Since then i have absorbed everything about the holocaust . Thank you for this presentation.
@@dianestafford6968 you're welcome. I'm really glad that people share all the experiences of what happened during the holocaust . I hope that as time goes on that all generations will know and understand those years .
Me too. And my Jewish great grandmother fled Russia to escape right before the holocaust. Her son, my grandfather, married a Christian woman and their kids were raised Christian and so on. But his sister married another jew and that side of the family is all Jewish but live overseas. I know nothing about my Jewish heritage first hand and it makes me sad. I only know what I read in books. My great grandmother died 15 years before I came along and my grandfather didn’t talk about his Jewish past. It embarrassed him 😞
Fun fact Rutka and Anne were born on the same day and year
I was 9 when I first read the diary.
me too!
Beautiful story.. wished the background music weren't so loud so I could hear the words of this brave woman!!
My heart feels broken for the tragic story of this innocent child. How can humans behave in this way? Is it any wonder the Jewish people fight to keep their country and home.
Iris Pect all polish no matter religion
joan baczek, iIm certainly not diminishing the suffering of all those affected by this atrocity. I’m merely pointing out that they had no country. The 6000000 Jews had no where to turn to, no home and no loyalty from the country they were living in and calling home. The polish have Poland and were amongst their people in their home. I know this because my grandfather was a Polish Jew turned away by the people he thought were his friends and country.
ImNotMad ButUR so true. It’s up to people like you and myself to teach our kids, siblings, friends and any one else who is willing to learn, that we are all people, regardless of religion, color, sex and nationality. Bless you for your obvious kind heart 💓
Iris Pect
No, it’s perfectly understandable but what they do to the Palestinians is a shame nevertheless.
Lock Down
I appreciate your friendly comment and fully agree with you!
Unbelievable story !
I think I grew a few wrinkles from my face being crunched the whole time.
This little girl lost so much of her life to only be brought back to life many years later.
Such a tragic Story.
I think I’m traumatized when she said she seen a nazi solider take a baby from it’s mother and smash its head on a pole and the guts where everywhere. What kind of demon monster does something like that.
The nazis party was nothing but an army straight from the pits of hell.
Well said
There are no words to describe how evil those people were. Just pure evil.😢😢😢
@Jen Green I really know this goes on today. I'm not going to give many details but I come from a country where food is scarce and thieves often steal food, oil is also scarce, as a result transportation is a luxury, power outages are part of one daily live. I didn't say it stopped but I said that people who caused the whole situation were evil. History often repeats itself and the weak ones suffer the most. Out of nowhere a tyrant might be the next in power... If what we live here now is tough enough, because it is I can't imagine how it was/it is for other people in much rougher circumstances. Sorry if I made any grammar mistake.
har du har
har du har
Very important story and you are ruining it with the background music drowning out the dialogue with the music
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
@@flederfox is Susan the police manager of Karen?
I can't hear what is being Said. the music is to loud. and the girls reading and at the same time they are talking the dialogue in English is impossible to hear both at the same time
Such a gifted and talented girl. People are so cruel sometimes. I can never understand it.
I had never even heard of her until today. What a powerful and sad story.
Many of these kids had to grow up fast due to their situation, it’s sad too see how they suffered and they were very aware of what was to come and were preparing for it.
The background music is so unnecessarily loud.
Catherine Concina Barrientos just in joy it
@@mspancake0561 *enjoy** and no the music ruins it.
Yeah
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter
@@flederfox No.....it's not.
I am only 4 minutes in, but this has already pulled at my heart. I am so sorry for anyone who suffers loss like this. However, I am happy she has found her sister. Incredible.
Exactly Alice.
Don't let future generations forget what these poor people went through because we as a society can't allow this to happen again!!! As hard as it is to let people know how horrible things were they need to never forget!!!
@Topjunkie in Russia’s case vs Ukraine. I think you mean lost. I’m bet Putin ends up like sadam Hussein. Neck in rope dangling from a tree. It’s a typical ending for dictators.
This is a very remarkable, sad and powerful story and the best testimony about a young Polish girl, whose only 'crime' was having been born Jewish. The saddest part of it is the state of people's mind, who get worked up about too loud background music, failing to engage with the message of this story. The words that matter are always uttered quietly amid background noise. Learning to listen and to hear is an important and valuable skill.
I thought this was Anne Frank until I saw the name . I'm glad I watch it .
This person keep telling me it's not true and laughing. Something is wrong with people.
yep the loud music made it more difficult to engage with the story.
Ughhhh the stupid background sound is so loud I can't hear what she is saying...... I need to find this book
This is an important story and it needs to be told, with that said it needs to be redone because the music drowns out the voices. I am very disappointed in the editing.
So get out your machine and redo this. I look forward to seeing a new copy and I believe more people will want to watch it once they can hear the story. Like I said it's a very important story and it needs to be told over and over again, but it's hard to retell a story when you can't hear it. Sometimes the words are so low it's unintelligible.
Please fix this!
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan if you care so much to write such a long heated comment about it
100% behind you! The reading of the diary was drowned out by music and the translator😥
Like Anne Frsnks
I pray that one day this is re-edited so we can all hear and understand her story! I believe it is very very important for the world to hear and know her story!
Music is to much...
Damn it ! Every time the girl talks the music over takes the voice...
It's a shame that the music is louder (too loud) than the girls/women's voices. I couldn't understand more than half of what was said.
I persevered through the video because my great-grandfather was a rabbi from Warsaw who came to the US prior to the war and none of his relatives survived. Unfortunately, music overplaying the speaker and the translator made it impossible to hear some passages and immensely detracted from the story. It would be nice if the sound was re-engineered so that all the English words were audible. I find it amazing how astute this child was at 13, much more so than I was at that age and how she and the other children were able to face the negative changes in their world with such strength. What a wonderful legacy for her half-sister and family.
Alice Rabbit Your family is garbage and you’re a piece of trash they gave birth to
I really wanted to watch this important documentary but had to stop because the music was too loud making voices unclear in so many places. Such a scheme, wish it could be sound edited.
You wrote out my thoughts exactly! I turned it off. Disappointed.
That was a problem only in the beginning. As the video continues, you can hear the voices much better.
@@victoria653 Rutka clearly wanted her voice to be heard, too.
As I get older, I realize that many factors impact hearing. Younger people think it just means everything is softer or quiet. Now, I realize that it can be difficult to distinguish sounds from one another. That may be why the blending of two voices and music makes it difficult for some to hear Rutka's message.
A group of five Jewish women are eating lunch in a busy cafe. Nervously, their waiter approaches the table. “Ladies,” he says. “Is anything okay?”
Why are all of your channels videos edited with such horrible background music??? Can't hear the narrator or any of the people speaking. It's horrible. Honestly, in relation to a subject of this magnitude, the music shouldn't even be included. Only the subject matter being discussed by these people should be heard.
Totally agree!
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
The music is too loud, can't hear the words of the diary
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
I never NEVER comment on videos.. but please re upload this video! The narration is barely audible due to the background music. This is an important piece of history and it’s a shame that you can’t properly hear it.
Please stick to never commenting on videos. Thanks!
I agree with the comments about the loud music. I feel sad I couldn't finish it. It a shame those beautiful words can't be heard
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
My heart just sank💔😢 Rest in Peace Rutka
she might had been reborn again
She remind me of Anna Frank's who also wrote her diary during a Holocaust
Yes, the music was too loud sometimes but it was still worth watching. Very beautifully made even though it was very sad. May they all RIP. Thank you for the upload.
When the young girls read. It's hard to hear the translation in the background
marykatherine73 l could not hear the translation from polish to English. As the two languages were muddled together . Then the music was louder than the speaking.. So I put it on BOSE speaker , that was better, but still background noice was very annoying . I loved the story .
I was very interested in listening to this video, especially as there seems to be an increase in anti semitism. However I couldn't hear it with the horrendous music playing, I had to stop watching it. I've noticed that a loT of the historical and informative videos are doing this. Please either stop the music or provide a way to st.op it without losing normal sound
I wish that I could hear the when in the background her "words" are being read or the commentator, but the background music is too loud and the voice to low. Watched a couple of times to try and get the full story. Very important.
I am grateful for the account of another diary of a young girl. It never ceases to amaze me how much more educated children were than they are today. I would love to read this young girls account. Unfortunately in this documentary the music being played while she is speaking in her native language and then translated into English all at the same time is disturbing. Her thoughts, and feelings, as well as her story has been drowned out by all of the background noise. If the music had been toned down or just silent during the reading would have made this far better. This diary about her life is just as important today along with Anne Frank's. As we are living in a time when all of our freedoms may disappear.
I agree on the last line
If I may be so bold. I really don’t know how to communicate this well. But as I began to listen to this piece, the audio mix was less than desirable. The music overwhelmed the narrative. Other TH-cam videos come across well. I am disappointed in not being able to learn from this piece. FYI
Thank you for writing and let the world knows the truth. Rest in Peace, Rutka 🙏🙏❤
Most of the time I cannot hear the dialogue because the music is so loud.
Put the captions on
How can you allow such terrible sound editing on a documentary about such an important subject? It is a disgrace to the memory of the murdered people this is about.
I’m positive the actual tv documentary wasn’t this bad just for copyright reasons. Perhaps
An Incredible life journey of a young talented girl. It must've taken immense courage to write and hide her diary for posterity. Please edit the background music/sounds for clear audibility. RIP Rutka.
Blah, blah! Focus on the message and stop whining!
@@vivians9392 HER message is getting drowned by the loud music. That’s the problem.
I watch these, even though they are incredibly hard to watch, because as difficult as they are, they are so important.
Please remake this awesome without the background music. I missed quite a bit of what was being said. Thank you.
This is so depressing. I'm listening to it and I just feel like crying. It's very sad. I don't even want to imagine the pain they went through.😢😢
The sound was poorly managed. Could not hear the words in the diary because the girls voices were much too loud. Very, very poor sound management. Hope that sound engineer didn’t get more work because the story was lost.
FACTS IN 2021 🙏✌️🇺🇸
Truly so thankful to have watched rhis. The sound has issue here and there but could still follow a lot of what happened. Thank you for sharing.
This is so moving!!! Thank you for posting!!
I find it kind of sad that she doesn’t talk as much about having a brother too, as much as she does about having a sister. We may not have his thoughts on paper, but he was just as real.
Rutka’s mother isn’t mentioned even once either, as if she hadn’t existed. Sad.
I really can't hear what is being said ,the music is loud and the girls reading over the voice is way too long ,it's such a shame ,I'd love to hear what this young lady said in her diary !!!
The music is so loud that I could not hear a thing 😔😔
Wendy González Hagelsieb you couldn’t hear a thing? You must be deaf
I cannot hear the important parts...music is TOO LOUD...
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
The music is so loud that I can't hear the story.
The innocence of the children and their compassion with how similar they were had me shedding tears as they realizing the horror of what this child had to confront from neighbors and friends made her my hero because she never was consumed with hate.🙏🙏🙏
So upset because of the loud music, you can not understand what the people and children are reading! Such a shame. I want to hear Rutkas story! Not sure I spelled her name right.
Great story makes me happy this girl was able to journal her experiences during such a horrific time in history. Her memories will live on. Her journal bears wittiness to an awful time in world history.
can you not edit the music to be more quiet so that we can hear the words??
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
Is it just me or is the background music way too loud?? Did they watch this before producing?
Yes it was way too high, I had to stop watching because it was getting to me
@@kerriefearby9542 me too
I just ordered Rutka’s diary in English from Amazon.
I will return after reading it; I’m sure that I’ll want to watch this video again after reading.
Oh! Rutka was so beautiful. That much I see right away. I’m eager to read what she has to tell us all.
Like others, it found it hard to hear the voice through the music. Please remaster this!
Why would you return it after reading it???? Just go to the library instead of ruining brand new books for others.......
@@0hMyLife she means she will return to watch the video after reading the book😊
@@amandaturner8928 Oooooohhhhh!!!! Jeez do I feel like a dunce!!! 🤦🏼♀️😖 Not gonna delete though, just gonna say "SORRY @B. H.!!!!!!!! My bad!!"
She would have been such a wonderful Author, her diary was so descriptive. Such a beautiful soul
Yes the music overcomes the dialogue. This is a very important part of human history please re-edit. As a non Jew my sincere condolences for your loss.
I wish the editor had mixed the audio better. It is a wonderful and very sad documentary. Rutka deserves her voice to be heard properly.
I think what these types of stories have taught me it is so important to document your life. I used to write a journal but stopped a very long time ago. I think this is inspiring me to begin again. I think everyone should begin a journal. Maybe one day our words will mean something to someone in the future.
The background music is so loud I could not her the dialogue. Touching story....But very sad.
It's so hurting to heard that she's been rename after Anne Franks, but she was Rudka, and that's her, she wrote her own stories and she was unique too, just like each one of us. very admiring courage she'd.
??????
what do u mean? is she is ann frank too
is there an English book version? I would like to buy. Love history and this one is very interesting.
Yeah you can find it on Amazon! I'm going to order it, too.
I have it. I guess you have found it by now
I cannot hear what is being said; the music is terrible loud.
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
I dont why but i cant stop my tears. From 🇮🇳
Well maybe because its so bad and evil that a young special girl like her was murdered for no reason and in a brutal way . She and millions others
❤
The evocative music is much too LOUD!
The background music drowns out the dialogue and I ended up not watching it all as I couldn't hear what was being said. Such a shame as it is an important piece of history.
Please upload this again please make the music not so loud so we can actually hear this very important story disappointed. There is enough drama in the history of this horrible display of atrocities without the grinding pounding sound. YOU cheapen it. Don't play Hollywood.
I also hope this is reedited. This needs to be appreciated. I quit after 12 minutes, to difficult to hear the soft narration over the music. Every piece of information must be embraced, and I've already missed to much.
Just wear headphones, you'll hear the narrative better😊
Still with headphones it is sometimes hard to understand when they speak about the diary.
I literally weeped through the whole thing.
I also have relatives who suffered in the holocaust.
I don't think it's so easy for non Jews to connect to the real horror.
You don't need to be Jewish to understand the horror. We are all human beings. Human beings with families, and friends. We can all understand how precious and fragile life is.
Oh yes it is, I have friends that went through this.
@@arthurwebber-g4lFriends? How old are you? Did you live through this period?
I’m glad I was able to hear the dialogue over the “background” music..
Ok watching
Background music is too loud!! I can hardly understand what’s being said. Other than that it was very interesting & sad.
Background music was WAY to loud could hear what was being said very disappointed
Seriously please fix the sound. The story is amazing and should be heard
Does the music have to be so loud cant hear a lot of it
Is there a movie on Rutka Laskier? If so can anyone let me know. Thank you from Canada!
Thank you for the compliments, but I am infatuated with children and women, who were victims and live to tell the their story. I want to put this i writing; I love you and admire you. I am a WW11 veteran's daughter with my dad and papa.
I really want to watch this documentary, but the background music is so loud, it goes on my nerves!!! Learn to edit!!
it's not the editing it's YTbs terrible audio converter why do people always need to complain about this it's so obvious go and complain to susan
This made me cry so badly, my hubby is a Polish, he told me everything what he know from his grandparent... Those innocent and defenseless souls, all of them... RIP
Such a tragic, heartbreaking story. The one ray of happiness is the ending, where we see Zahava's beautiful family (who are also Rutka's beautiful family). Am chai Yisroel (the people of Israel live)! My only criticism of this video is that the music was too loud, making it very hard to hear the dialogue.
Hi Tim.
Shalom. Kiaora from New Zealand. I really enjoyed your reply.
She was almost the same age as Anne Frank. I like how descriptive they were when writing about their stories.
Not almost. She was the same age as Annelies Marie "Anne" Frank (who was also born on 12 June 1929).
Turn off the music.
marta parsons yeah it is so load !
But the music is Beautiful
@@mspancake0561 - Nobody is saying the music isn’t beautiful. People are complaining about the music overwhelming what is being said. Music, if any, should be on the background and never drowning the message that’s being conveyed.
Thankyou for sharing this very moving video. Unfortunately the music makes it very difficult to hear the narrative.
The lady is just as beautiful as her half-sister...!
Thats it you could see the outside beauty!
amen
@@mrsebastian2you
P
It feels like we got to see Rutka all grown up, with the family and future she deserved. I'd like to imagine this is the ending of her journal and her story. She fought so hard to live.
Was the baby a brother or sister to her
Alot of complaints about audio but it must depend on the speakers your listening to because it sounds fine to me!
Yes I agree. The music is beautiful but overtakes the words. Makes it difficult to catch everything.
I had the honor to live in Germany as a young adult, met and became friends with some survivors of this era. My landlords were Czech who were lucky enough to escape when the Nazis occupied Poland. They were children and young adults at the time of the escape. Hearing their stories first hand, I will never forget.