Great Video. Thanks for making this, always good to see how others get my putting app to work. Just two remarks. Initially when you tried to get the putt to show shorter you should have increased the radius by 1, that is why you needed to go back to it. Smaller radius of the ball will lead to the distance travelled calculated as bigger thus making the putt faster/travel further in GSPRO. Also if you want to close out the settings windows just hit "a" and "d" again. Closing the window on the d - debug settings window will close out the whole app, it is a bug.
Should the app toggle the radius by itself whenever the putt is short/long instead of playing with the radius? Dynamic settings would be a good addition! I'm trying to figure out the best camera setup now because we have left/right handed players. I have setup an IP camera and it works great but I need to figure out why it's not putting in gspro now 😅
@@bv.hd883 The radius should be set/fixed once and then work with shorter and longer putts once "calibrated". It is dynamic also for initial calibration if you have good detection and should only be fixed if you see any changes or it does not fit your expected speed in the room.
As usual great video. I’m excited to give this a shot. One of my knocks on the R10 is the lack spin. I’m never super confident in the shot shape. I’d love some info on your Roxor version to add more spin if available. Thanks for your help!
I have a question. I have a FiberBuilt mat and need to know how far the read happens? Will it read from the distance of my mat or need more space, Thanks Spike on the new Golf Channel
Awesome video, definitely helped me get the putting tuned in. Question for you on running multiple cameras. If I have a second camera connected the putting app doesn’t ID the correct camera, says webcam not found. Help! Trying to set up a second cam to play with remote folks, and it’s not working!
Thank you for the video. I got the putting working and my camera works well only when the Exposure is set to AUTO. However, the setting resets on every hole so I have to open Advanced setting in each hole to click AUTO for the Exposure. Any tips on making this a default setting?
Excellent video and instruction. I have a Logitech Streamcam. Id like to know how you was able to shrink down the size of the putting window when it opens on the green. Thanks in advance for your reply
For your increased sidespin scale factors, I noticed that in the json you have a 1.3x multiplier for both spin axis and side spin. However, the gsp-r10 adapter source code shows that both sidespin and backspin are dependent on spin axis. Does this mean you are multiplying by 1.3x on both spin axis and sidespin, or are they independent? Otherwise this 1.3 operation would be applied twice since SpinAxis is a variable in the SideSpin equation, and the total spin being the sum of backspin and sidespin would be too high if backspin was left unaffected. In another way of asking it, wouldn't setting spinAxis to 1.3 also modify the sidespin (and backspin) value so you wouldn't have to change the scale factor also on SideSpin? Your executable doesn't have the source, so I thought I would ask before I spun my wheels trying to guess how you got these factors to multiply into the ball data. Thanks again, I appreciate your setup video for the putting webcam and all of the work you have put into getting the most out of the r10.
I had my putting working great, thanks to your great video. However, I tried to make some adjustments in the setting to improve the accuracy and now the webcam is seeing my putting, but not GSPro? Any suggestions
I'm just making the switch to GS pro and am wanting to get it right the first time. wonding what camera would be good. I want to mount it to ceiling or wall. I was hoping to NOT have it on a stand or so close.
How do I save the camera properties? I hit the apply button and it’s fine but when I close the program it goes back to its original settings. Thanks works great other then that
@@billakins3543did you guys figure out how to save the settings? I'm just going through the process now and I see I'm having the same problem with the settings not saving.
Great video. Got everything working but when the putting pop up shows up it covers the name of the person putting everytime. Any way to move this permanently?
I am struggling to find or get the settings.json file that looks like yours with the putting section that looks like this }, “putting”: { “enabled”: true, “port”: 8888, “launchBallTracker”: true, // if true, program will launch ball tracking software. If false”onlylaunchwhen Putting”: true, // if true, program ..... Where can I download that version? Can you prove a link please so i can try this too as I am stuck now... Thanks in advance.
I haven't been able to get the putting add-on to show up in GSPro. I've gotten it to work by opening ball-tracker.exe, but I can't get it to open when using GSPro. I have all of the files in what I think are the correct places and I have the settings file setup correctly. There's obviously something I'm missing though. Thanks for any help.
Great video. But I have an issue when I’m setting up things. After running the ball tacking application, I get a message in the command window at the end (replay cam not activated). Also, I’m able to go through the setup for the golf ball for putting. The weird thing is that no numbers showing up for the X, Y and Radius. Not sure what I’m doing wrong. Any help would be great!
I was able to get around the ‘Replay Cam not activated’ but updating the config file for the cam settings from 0 to 1. Now the ball tracking app starts stating the Replay Cam activated at 1’. But right after that the ‘Trackback’ fails to execute script ‘ball_tracking’ due to unhandled exception! Not sure what to do to fix this issue. The webcam I’m using is on the list of approved camera (Logitech c270). Does anyone have any suggestions?
Hi When I open the Putting view screen I only get an option on the top bar to press Q to exit. It doesn't give me an option to press A and open advanced settings. Any help would be appreciated
I watched your video about putting with R10 and you seem to be very computer savvy, I’m not! I want to purchase and affordable pc for gspro, doesn’t need to be new.can you make some recommendations?
Excellent video. I'll setup putting for GSPro next week so this is good. what is this spin axis fix. Is it a patch of code you have made that I can run when using GSPro or something else? I am curious.
best r10 putting video on you tube but i still need a little help. Camera working and putting calculations are being made but data not getting to gspro. Changed config json putting from false to true and putter selected in gsp. Last line on ball tracking screen says new connection error, target machine actively refused it. am i using the wrong bluetooth r10 connect ?? thanks
How much light do you need on the ball? When I play I turn most of the lights off, but leave a small spot light on the putting ball. It doesn’t work when most lights are off. Please help. Thanks
Picture showed up for a few minutes, could not save any settings. After a few more minutes could not access advanced settings by pushing A, now can’t get webcam to work in any slot (works perfect in system camera) got everything set up until GsPro was connected, didn’t work then returned to no settings no picture nothing.
Man you got me hooked up with the garmin and gspro with the putting, awesome videos. I only have one issue is the putting flakes out sometimes ? Could it be my AMR 5 it's running at 99% on GPU. Thanks again for all your help
Can I mount the webcam on the ceiling or behind (like the R10) for both right and left handed people? How close to the ball does the webcam need to be? Thanks!
Any update for this? Couple of things I've noticed. 1. long putts are impossible. It never reads the hit 2. I can't use my blue mizuno putter (not a problem though) 3. I get a lot of non-reads unless it's a short putt. Maybe I'm missing something?
Hi there. Quick question. I’m just setting up my garmin r10. Do u have to get fsx play to get gs pro ?? I’ve heard there is an interface I can run through ?? Any ideas. Thx
Quick question? how did you get the Putting window to open on the top right side of your screen? and also would be interrested in yhe GS Pro connector you built to give more spin axis with R10. Great Video btw! Thank you
Hi there Thank you for the video unfortunately i haven't used a pc in 30+years so I'm a bit lost 😂. Where do i get the ball tracking exe? Got no clue where to start from... By the way you got a heck of a swing, watched another video of yours the other day and was pretty impressed.
I've managed to make it work. The only thing is that if eg on gspro gspro chooses a wedge and I press U i get a putting view window with an error written in red. Everything still works but i get this darn window. The other putting view window is also still on there. Thanks for the video. Wanted to give us a call but not too sure where you're in the states. But time difference with Australia. @@roxorgolf
i got a problem, iam using WEBCAM THRONMAX STREAM GO 1080P with 30 fps. But if the radius = 2 is too fast, radius = 0 is too slow. My PC almost does not recognize the putting if radius = 1, sometime it does but still very fast. I have adjust the stimp from 8 to 13 with radius = 0 but it is very slow. Can u please help me, thank you so much.
I noticed that in the json you have a 1.3x multiplier for both spin axis and side spin. However, the gsp-r10 adapter source code shows that both sidespin and backspin are dependent on spin axis. Does this mean you are multiplying by 1.3x on both spin axis and sidespin, or are they independent? Otherwise this operation would be doubled, and the total spin between backspin and sidespin would be too high if backspin was left unaffected. Thanks
I was excited and tried, but I could not switch from my laptop camera to a new webcam. I could not aim the ball properly using my laptop camera. Could you guide me on how to switch to the webcam, so that I can move to the next steps?
I was able to connect by changing the camera index and turning off my laptop camera. However, it cannot find the camera again after restaring my laptop. I tried to change the camera index, but did not work at all. I can open my camera from other tools, but not from the putting API.
When i hit ‘d’ from the putting window, the entire putting UI crashes and the mask frame does not pop up. This is where I’m stuck. Anyone have any suggestions?
@@roxorgolf thanks for your answer, it was a windows problem. windows update solved the problem. but now i have another problem. the balltracking software recognizes everything perfectly and i also see that my putts are recognized. but as soon as i want to putt with gspro on the green i get an error that the webcam index 0 is not correct. i have tried all webcam indexes up to 8. always the same error only the number in the index changes. i use a pc with a usb webcam. Many thanks in advance Andi
I'm just now trying to setup my webcam to link to GS Pro and my GArmin R10. I have GS Pro running great, but the added link to connect the webcam only picks up the laptop's camera not the webcam with a usb cable. Do you have a link to the software to accomplish this or is there a setting that needs to be change. Thanks
Great Video. Thanks for making this, always good to see how others get my putting app to work. Just two remarks. Initially when you tried to get the putt to show shorter you should have increased the radius by 1, that is why you needed to go back to it. Smaller radius of the ball will lead to the distance travelled calculated as bigger thus making the putt faster/travel further in GSPRO. Also if you want to close out the settings windows just hit "a" and "d" again. Closing the window on the d - debug settings window will close out the whole app, it is a bug.
Yeah works great once I figured it out. You did a great job. Can you email me at Roxor Golf so I have your contact info?
Should the app toggle the radius by itself whenever the putt is short/long instead of playing with the radius? Dynamic settings would be a good addition!
I'm trying to figure out the best camera setup now because we have left/right handed players. I have setup an IP camera and it works great but I need to figure out why it's not putting in gspro now 😅
@@bv.hd883 The radius should be set/fixed once and then work with shorter and longer putts once "calibrated". It is dynamic also for initial calibration if you have good detection and should only be fixed if you see any changes or it does not fit your expected speed in the room.
seems like when I hit a hard putt for a long distance, it doesn’t pick it up. Using 60 fps. Any ideas?
same thing happens for me@@jeffcegalis2486
Can you post the adapter you made for more spin? Great video by the way!! Got mine working!! Thanks
Amazing job with the video! Everything works as it should. Could not have done it without your help. Thank you sir !
Glad it helped
thanks for this vid bro. playing gspro with putting now, way cool !!
As usual great video. I’m excited to give this a shot. One of my knocks on the R10 is the lack spin. I’m never super confident in the shot shape. I’d love some info on your Roxor version to add more spin if available. Thanks for your help!
I have a question. I have a FiberBuilt mat and need to know how far the read happens? Will it read from the distance of my mat or need more space, Thanks Spike on the new Golf Channel
Love your video about putting with garmin. Have a couple questions, how long of green do I need? Does the R10 have to align with ball and stroke?
Awesome video, definitely helped me get the putting tuned in. Question for you on running multiple cameras. If I have a second camera connected the putting app doesn’t ID the correct camera, says webcam not found. Help! Trying to set up a second cam to play with remote folks, and it’s not working!
Thank you for the video. I got the putting working and my camera works well only when the Exposure is set to AUTO. However, the setting resets on every hole so I have to open Advanced setting in each hole to click AUTO for the Exposure. Any tips on making this a default setting?
Hello, how can we change to left handed putting? Thank you
Excellent video and instruction.
I have a Logitech Streamcam. Id like to know how you was able to shrink down the size of the putting window when it opens on the green.
Thanks in advance for your reply
In the settings.json file, there are 2 lines for width and height. Modify it and save.
Do you have a step by step video of where to go and how to execute the files for the putting feature? Thx!
@roxorgolf
I would love to have your version of the garmin adapter
www.roxorgolf.com/post/gspro-garmin-r10-interface-with-increase-side-spin
Can I get the updated version of gspro connect please and thank you. Great video by the way.
www.roxorgolf.com/post/gspro-garmin-r10-interface-with-increase-side-spin
For your increased sidespin scale factors, I noticed that in the json you have a 1.3x multiplier for both spin axis and side spin. However, the gsp-r10 adapter source code shows that both sidespin and backspin are dependent on spin axis. Does this mean you are multiplying by 1.3x on both spin axis and sidespin, or are they independent? Otherwise this 1.3 operation would be applied twice since SpinAxis is a variable in the SideSpin equation, and the total spin being the sum of backspin and sidespin would be too high if backspin was left unaffected. In another way of asking it, wouldn't setting spinAxis to 1.3 also modify the sidespin (and backspin) value so you wouldn't have to change the scale factor also on SideSpin? Your executable doesn't have the source, so I thought I would ask before I spun my wheels trying to guess how you got these factors to multiply into the ball data.
Thanks again, I appreciate your setup video for the putting webcam and all of the work you have put into getting the most out of the r10.
Do you have any advice on the webcam to buy?
Especially considering that at night there's lots visibility? Let me know if you got a moment
I had my putting working great, thanks to your great video. However, I tried to make some adjustments in the setting to improve the accuracy and now the webcam is seeing my putting, but not GSPro? Any suggestions
I'm just making the switch to GS pro and am wanting to get it right the first time. wonding what camera would be good. I want to mount it to ceiling or wall. I was hoping to NOT have it on a stand or so close.
How do I save the camera properties? I hit the apply button and it’s fine but when I close the program it goes back to its original settings. Thanks works great other then that
Same here. And if I start it in GSPro, it's set to calibrate, and i have to pick ball color first every time.
@@billakins3543did you guys figure out how to save the settings? I'm just going through the process now and I see I'm having the same problem with the settings not saving.
Hi ! Good video 👌. You talked about running the Roxor version of Garmin R10 interface. What how does it work?
Is this different now with the new GS Pro connector for R10?
Great video. Got everything working but when the putting pop up shows up it covers the name of the person putting everytime. Any way to move this permanently?
I am struggling to find or get the settings.json file that looks like yours with the putting section that looks like this },
“putting”: {
“enabled”: true,
“port”: 8888,
“launchBallTracker”: true, // if true, program will launch ball tracking software. If false”onlylaunchwhen Putting”: true, // if true, program .....
Where can I download that version? Can you prove a link please so i can try this too as I am stuck now...
Thanks in advance.
Same. Would be great if someone could help out on this issue.
Hi My this was a great video. MY HLA is way off to the left. Is there any adjustment I need to make ?
Give me a call today and I can take a look
Mate, I found what I was looking for. Sorry about that.
How do I change the webcam on the ball tracking app?! Pls help trying to play tonight
I haven't been able to get the putting add-on to show up in GSPro. I've gotten it to work by opening ball-tracker.exe, but I can't get it to open when using GSPro. I have all of the files in what I think are the correct places and I have the settings file setup correctly. There's obviously something I'm missing though. Thanks for any help.
Call me on Monday. I'll fix it for you
I'm having the exact same issue! How did you fix it????
Great video. But I have an issue when I’m setting up things. After running the ball tacking application, I get a message in the command window at the end (replay cam not activated). Also, I’m able to go through the setup for the golf ball for putting. The weird thing is that no numbers showing up for the X, Y and Radius. Not sure what I’m doing wrong. Any help would be great!
I was able to get around the ‘Replay Cam not activated’ but updating the config file for the cam settings from 0 to 1. Now the ball tracking app starts stating the Replay Cam activated at 1’. But right after that the ‘Trackback’ fails to execute script ‘ball_tracking’ due to unhandled exception!
Not sure what to do to fix this issue. The webcam I’m using is on the list of approved camera (Logitech c270). Does anyone have any suggestions?
What camera is good for that? What the specification need it?
What camera do you use ? Regards Tommy
Hi When I open the Putting view screen I only get an option on the top bar to press Q to exit. It doesn't give me an option to press A and open advanced settings. Any help would be appreciated
Well done mine is working now, D key, game changer!
I’m not real computer savvy. Can you tell me step by step what to install one the file is downloaded?
I watched your video about putting with R10 and you seem to be very computer savvy, I’m not!
I want to purchase and affordable pc for gspro, doesn’t need to be new.can you make some recommendations?
Excellent video. I'll setup putting for GSPro next week so this is good. what is this spin axis fix. Is it a patch of code you have made that I can run when using GSPro or something else? I am curious.
The software I made increases the side spin axis is all. To give more curvature.
My thoughts exactly. I have been thinking that it would be rather easy to fix curvature to tinker a code a bit. Is this fix something you can share?
Oukkidoukki
Does ambient room lighting have any effect? Should I adjust settings in roughly the same “darkness” that I would normally be playing in?
Yes. Calibrate in the lighting you will be using during play.
best r10 putting video on you tube but i still need a little help. Camera working and putting calculations are being made but data not getting to gspro. Changed config json putting from false to true and putter selected in gsp. Last line on ball tracking screen says new connection error, target machine actively refused it. am i using the wrong bluetooth r10 connect ?? thanks
Text me
How much light do you need on the ball?
When I play I turn most of the lights off, but leave a small spot light on the putting ball. It doesn’t work when most lights are off. Please help. Thanks
You're going to want enough light to track the ball for at least 4 to 6 feet.
Great Video - where can I get the GS Pro connector you built to give more spin axis with R10?
Just sent it to you
@@roxorgolf to my email? Not sure where it is at?
would love to test your r10 connector as well please. THANK YOU...I had given up on this as well
Have you made the enhanced spin connector available in general somewhere? If not could I get it as well ?
Picture showed up for a few minutes, could not save any settings. After a few more minutes could not access advanced settings by pushing A, now can’t get webcam to work in any slot (works perfect in system camera) got everything set up until GsPro was connected, didn’t work then returned to no settings no picture nothing.
Why does my putting simulator view keep playing a loop rather than live view?
Man you got me hooked up with the garmin and gspro with the putting, awesome videos. I only have one issue is the putting flakes out sometimes ? Could it be my AMR 5 it's running at 99% on GPU. Thanks again for all your help
What resolution and what quality are you running at?
I'm running at 1920x1080 and on low or medium
I'm running at 1080 and on low could it be my FPS and radius it's my cam that is working and stops.@@roxorgolf
Can I mount the webcam on the ceiling or behind (like the R10) for both right and left handed people? How close to the ball does the webcam need to be? Thanks!
It's going to depend on the camera and lighting. I've had best luck at about 5 ft but it could be higher if the lighting is good
@@roxorgolf Thank you!
No matter how hard I hit the ball, it only moves a few inches on GSPro. Tried adjusting the radius and no change. Any suggestions?
Has to be the radius. Most people have it between 5 and 12 from what I've seen. Are you around there?
@@roxorgolf tried that. Even maxed it out and no change.
Great job man. thanks
Glad it helped
Any update for this? Couple of things I've noticed. 1. long putts are impossible. It never reads the hit 2. I can't use my blue mizuno putter (not a problem though) 3. I get a lot of non-reads unless it's a short putt. Maybe I'm missing something?
I think you are. Call me. My number is on my Roxor Golf
Hi there. Quick question. I’m just setting up my garmin r10. Do u have to get fsx play to get gs pro ?? I’ve heard there is an interface I can run through ?? Any ideas. Thx
Fsx play has nothing to do with gspro. You need an r10, gspro, and the interface call me on Monday and ill do it for you.
Quick question? how did you get the Putting window to open on the top right side of your screen? and also would be interrested in yhe GS Pro connector you built to give more spin axis with R10. Great Video btw! Thank you
I'm making another video today
@@roxorgolf cant wait ;) thanks again!
@@henrikgagne9079hit the U key when on the green, that will bring it up.
Hi there
Thank you for the video unfortunately i haven't used a pc in 30+years so I'm a bit lost 😂.
Where do i get the ball tracking exe?
Got no clue where to start from...
By the way you got a heck of a swing, watched another video of yours the other day and was pretty impressed.
Call me and I'll set it all up for you
@@roxorgolf hey there, thank you so much I will add soon as i have everything necessary to set it up.
I've managed to make it work.
The only thing is that if eg on gspro gspro chooses a wedge and I press U i get a putting view window with an error written in red. Everything still works but i get this darn window. The other putting view window is also still on there.
Thanks for the video.
Wanted to give us a call but not too sure where you're in the states. But time difference with Australia.
@@roxorgolf
which button you hit to show the putting window when you put in gspro?
If everything is in the correct location it will automatically open when putter is selected
i got a problem, iam using WEBCAM THRONMAX STREAM GO 1080P with 30 fps. But if the radius = 2 is too fast, radius = 0 is too slow. My PC almost does not recognize the putting if radius = 1, sometime it does but still very fast. I have adjust the stimp from 8 to 13 with radius = 0 but it is very slow. Can u please help me, thank you so much.
can you ultraview or teamviewer to help me?
Is your modified connector avail? Looks like you made a huge improvement in slices and hooks.
www.roxorgolf.com/post/gspro-garmin-r10-interface-with-increase-side-spin
I noticed that in the json you have a 1.3x multiplier for both spin axis and side spin. However, the gsp-r10 adapter source code shows that both sidespin and backspin are dependent on spin axis. Does this mean you are multiplying by 1.3x on both spin axis and sidespin, or are they independent? Otherwise this operation would be doubled, and the total spin between backspin and sidespin would be too high if backspin was left unaffected. Thanks
i'm getting an error on the download link for the modified connector, does anyone else have the same issue
my ball tracking file blinks a window that disappears right after it executes. what am i doing wrong?
I am having the same problem. It actually working one time.
i can't get my iphone connected via camo to appear as a webcam option. are there any support materials on this?
Not sure if it's the same on iphone but in the settings file I had to change webcamIndex to 1, and after additionalExeArgs put -w 1 in the quotes.
I was excited and tried, but I could not switch from my laptop camera to a new webcam. I could not aim the ball properly using my laptop camera. Could you guide me on how to switch to the webcam, so that I can move to the next steps?
Disable your webcam or change webcam index to 1 in the settings file
Thank you. There are multiple parameters in the configuration file, but I cannot figure which one is the Webcam index number.
I was able to connect by changing the camera index and turning off my laptop camera. However, it cannot find the camera again after restaring my laptop. I tried to change the camera index, but did not work at all. I can open my camera from other tools, but not from the putting API.
Did you get things working? Having similar issues.
How high of a frame rate camera do I need for the putting?
30nis fine
Which settings file are you referring to?
The config file that's in the main folder
What webcam are you using ? I tried doing this with a cheap webcam and it didn’t work I was wondering if I need something a little better
I think any webcam would work. Call me and ill take a look it for you.
@@roxorgolf thanks but I switched to an orange ball today and it worked !
When i hit ‘d’ from the putting window, the entire putting UI crashes and the mask frame does not pop up. This is where I’m stuck. Anyone have any suggestions?
Start over with a new extracted file.
Hi! When i try top Run the balltracking.exe nothing happens. Any ideas? Thx Andi
Did you extract it first?
@@roxorgolf thanks for your answer, it was a windows problem. windows update solved the problem.
but now i have another problem. the balltracking software recognizes everything perfectly and i also see that my putts are recognized. but as soon as i want to putt with gspro on the green i get an error that the webcam index 0 is not correct. i have tried all webcam indexes up to 8. always the same error only the number in the index changes. i use a pc with a usb webcam.
Many thanks in advance
Andi
Are you a software engineer?
I'm just now trying to setup my webcam to link to GS Pro and my GArmin R10. I have GS Pro running great, but the added link to connect the webcam only picks up the laptop's camera not the webcam with a usb cable. Do you have a link to the software to accomplish this or is there a setting that needs to be change. Thanks
Settings file. Change index to 1 and if that doesn't work text me
@@roxorgolf I'm not the best at computers. Where is the setting file located.
Im stuck it registers data but no matter how hard i hit it it goes only a few inches
Change the radius
@@roxorgolf to what? Some guy said to put in on 12
I think I have it on 20
Can this work with TGC2019 ? Nice job
No. Sorry
You are awesome.
I am unable to find the ball tracking.exe file.
Call me if you get stuck
Love it…..
Meanwhile I still can't chip with this god damn thing
👍👍👍👍👍