@@herom123 tbh, i would've expected only 2 screenshots - full open and full close. Maybe 16 more to set up dynamic grid for definition of pixel taking in account field of view. Then just use software to cut result out for every frame based on black/white pixel grid. Yeah, i know, that's basically cheating. But it would've worked.
@@ftblaze6175 Someone recreated Minecraft in Minecraft So I doubt this is anywhere more difficult than that Some mods would prolly be required Like carpet mod just to speed up the game
This made me realize how many possibilities there are to play Bad Apple just in Minecraft alone. If there's a way to show black and white, you damn well know there's a way to display Bad Apple on it
It doesn’t even have to be black and white. You could play it with water and lava or something, there just has to be two contrasting colors. Rule 86 of the internet, if it exists, you can play bad apple on it
@@anotherwofartist5895 It doesn’t even have to be contrasting colors, it just have to be two identifiable things and people will be able to play bad apple on it (someone did it with two slightly different looking static)
@@difrractsliver1031 I’ve seen that one. It was just a different frame of static I’m pretty sure, since the color wasn’t too different and all you needed to trace was the outline
More abstractly, so long as you have a notion of a space X on which you can define functions f: X -> {0, 1}, then you have representations of Bad Apple.
This is my favorite "Bad Apple but..." So far. Something about the transitions feels more satisfying than most, likely because there's less motion blur and a nice texture on the black areas.
Everyone is talking about how talented this person is and how detailed the animation looks and meanwhile I’m wondering how their computer hasn’t become a french fry
@@tommyhetrick im assuming this is due to their being a two tick delay with redstone etc, but isnt there a new method with the copper bulb were it can give out one tick pulses? would this be viable to make it without needing frames removed?
I think this is a first time for me where the meme version actually looks better than the original, the gradient and slight pixelization makes it look so cool; and, somehow, a tad nostalgic
Most likely recorded visuals slower to be able to match Minecraft ticks and preserve framerate for the final product and then video re-aligned to the default playback speed of the song via two points to assure that it matches correctly. That's how I would have done it. Otherwise, this person's computer is just fucking insane (or a French fry).
nothing. they are being setblock. I think it would have been far too laggy to be opening or closing sometimes 40,000 trapdoors at the same time. it would have been cooler, but also would have taken like 24 hours to render
it is also not in realtime. it took about 120x longer than realtime. It is made up of a bunch of screenshots, so there is no sound at all. (also I forget to record sound anyway as you can tell in the beginning when I was doing an actual screen recording)
@@WOKEchair yeah, I don’t doubt it’s possible. You’ve got those redstone wizards that make functioning computers, I bet this would be a challenge but definitely not impossible
The devil works hard, but Touhou fans work harder! I love seeing all the ways people recreate the Bad Apple!! animation in Minecraft, and this is no exception.
I'm Japanese and I love this song and Minecraft. I've been doing Minecraft for many years, and I'm surprised that Minecraft can do this, and it's very reproducible, and I respect it. Please continue to do your best.
you gotta be dumb, this is fake buddy, to do pixle by pixle u have to spend months to to years to animate that by goig up and down and replaying the doors, use ya brains.
@@microvive30 Definition of Hypothetical: hy·po·thet·i·cal /ˌhīpəˈTHedəkəl/ adjective of, based on, or serving as a hypothesis "that option is merely hypothetical at this juncture" noun a hypothetical proposition or statement "Finn talked in hypotheticals, tossing what-if scenarios to Rosen"
thing is, most of the methods people use to display bad apple are too low resolution to get that smile properly and plus it'd defeat the point to just like add it in half the time
If there was revealed to be a secret society running the world at any point, I would not doubt for a second if it was composed of touhou fans trying to play Bad Apple with all the lights on earth and record it for some yt video.
Interestingly, I like this more than the original. The way iron trapdoors opening create a 'wave'/'texture' for the black makes the animations and figures stand out with way more depth.
@@tomikun8057 if I remember tnt dupers had some issues in an area with ridiculous updates such as areas with lag machines, to be specific pistons lossing the ability to push as the top part wouldn't spawn or update, I believe it also applies to entity being spawned or latency issues that this absolute unit could do when nearby. Might work on lan though, who knows I might be wrong but please explain to me where, I feel like I might have a misunderstanding.
@@DummyDumDumb Minecraft updates by the tick, it's why it's single threaded. Unless it's using forge which has multithreading or something else, there shouldn't be any problems
@@tomikun8057 ah thanks for clearing up that part, that means it is possible as long as there is no drastic change in tick speed, I appreciate your help.
@@StopDropDash The creator said this is played 120x faster than the original. Video looks 60fps so original must be 0.5fps. Also he pointed out this is a bunch of screenshots stitched together.
I’ve started to see Bad Apple everywhere nowadays. It’s beginning to become the, “doom can be played on everything” of the Touhou Project and I’m all for it
To be honest, I thought that this was going to be a cover of the song. But what you did was much more impressive than any Minecraft mods that I have ever known of. Really, I’m just trying to congratulate you on getting everything perfect for this video. I just want to say… you’re truly amazing.
Would be fun to be a bunch of players ON the display & playing Tag with each other, and the trap-doors "randomly" flapping about & disrupting them when they run :D
Every time I think I’ve seen the most insane “Bad Apple played on ____ “I am always proven wrong when another pops up into my feed. It’s crazy how many versions can be made
Debería decir que a estas alturas ya nada me sorprende pero está versión de *Bad Apple!* es simplemente fascinante y muy divertida. Gracias por crear tal obra y a pesar de que no es la primera de su tipo, es la *mejor* de la misma. PD: Apenas estamos en *febrero* y ya estoy loco con tantas versiones de esta fabulosa así como magnífica animación XD
The technological and mechanical progress of Humanity is tracked by 2 things in specific: The amount of ridiculous/strange ways of playing doom and recreating the bad apple video
O ciclo não pode parar nunca, edit de bad Apple são um patrimônio pra história da internet, a mais de 9 anos esse estilo invade meus sugeridos e sempre é uma versão incrível 🙏
THANK YOU for 1 Million views! th-cam.com/video/5idyTkp-FG0/w-d-xo.html
Watch the behind the scenes: th-cam.com/video/CvajAPbe0xk/w-d-xo.html
I'm interested too !
I need to know how
Yes
pls
Please
I can’t imagine the ear splitting sounds of thousands of trapdoors opening and closing trying to keep up with the apple lmao
I would want that
Sorry for ruining it but probably he opens-closes them with command so no sound :s
@@herom123 tbh, i would've expected only 2 screenshots - full open and full close.
Maybe 16 more to set up dynamic grid for definition of pixel taking in account field of view.
Then just use software to cut result out for every frame based on black/white pixel grid.
Yeah, i know, that's basically cheating. But it would've worked.
@@DimkaTsv but imagine someone repeats this entire process but in redstone., No commands 💀
@@ftblaze6175
Someone recreated Minecraft in Minecraft
So I doubt this is anywhere more difficult than that
Some mods would prolly be required
Like carpet mod just to speed up the game
This made me realize how many possibilities there are to play Bad Apple just in Minecraft alone. If there's a way to show black and white, you damn well know there's a way to display Bad Apple on it
It doesn’t even have to be black and white. You could play it with water and lava or something, there just has to be two contrasting colors. Rule 86 of the internet, if it exists, you can play bad apple on it
@@anotherwofartist5895 It doesn’t even have to be contrasting colors, it just have to be two identifiable things and people will be able to play bad apple on it (someone did it with two slightly different looking static)
@@difrractsliver1031 I’ve seen that one. It was just a different frame of static I’m pretty sure, since the color wasn’t too different and all you needed to trace was the outline
More abstractly, so long as you have a notion of a space X on which you can define functions f: X -> {0, 1}, then you have representations of Bad Apple.
Sheep
We went from running doom to displaying bad apple.
We're doing both now
@@slimestaff1 Playing Bad Apple within Doom
@@CrustyFox87 hell yeah
Evolution
This is my favorite "Bad Apple but..." So far. Something about the transitions feels more satisfying than most, likely because there's less motion blur and a nice texture on the black areas.
Thank you so much! That is very nice
frfr
When something exists there are 2 questions:
Can it run doom?
Can it play bad apple?
@@theultimateamazingsleepyko6687 and also the third: can it run crysis
this song is the doom of music videos, you can run it everywhere
Everyone is talking about how talented this person is and how detailed the animation looks and meanwhile I’m wondering how their computer hasn’t become a french fry
There is delay between each frame that was removed
This looks like this would be the actual version of bad apple
It’s possible that each frame took like a minute, and he just edited out the dead time
Never mind, just saw the actual reply
@@tommyhetrick im assuming this is due to their being a two tick delay with redstone etc, but isnt there a new method with the copper bulb were it can give out one tick pulses? would this be viable to make it without needing frames removed?
First step to preventing your computer from turning into a french fry is to not have a potato pc
Imagine the noise and chaos thats going on down there with the trapdoors while bad apple is playing.
The trapdoors are arguing..
turns out theyre just being setblocked and not actually opening and closing, so it’d be fairly calm rip
Beat me to it lol
@@layalsaleh4103 So they are just disappearing?
@@Midorix_ they are getting replaced every frame
i don't get it, why are touhou fans all so talented?
They eat healthy fruits, such as apples
Have you seen touhou gameplay
@@jakkakasunset5485 Don't they usually like eating them spoiled? Usually bad apples
@@jakkakasunset5485 specifically spoiled apples
not all are fans
The resolution made by trapdoors alone is so crisp and ridiculous I LOVE IT
I think this is a first time for me where the meme version actually looks better than the original, the gradient and slight pixelization makes it look so cool; and, somehow, a tad nostalgic
It reminds me of the flipnote hatena version
Most likely recorded visuals slower to be able to match Minecraft ticks and preserve framerate for the final product and then video re-aligned to the default playback speed of the song via two points to assure that it matches correctly. That's how I would have done it. Otherwise, this person's computer is just fucking insane (or a French fry).
The fire surely looks better in the trapdoor version
It's also impressive that the black part has a pretty unique shading of white
it looks like when a skybox fails to render so everything gets smeared across the screen and it never cleara
I'm really curious on what this sounds like up close 😭
This is really cool tho!
nothing. they are being setblock. I think it would have been far too laggy to be opening or closing sometimes 40,000 trapdoors at the same time. it would have been cooler, but also would have taken like 24 hours to render
it is also not in realtime. it took about 120x longer than realtime. It is made up of a bunch of screenshots, so there is no sound at all. (also I forget to record sound anyway as you can tell in the beginning when I was doing an actual screen recording)
@@tommyhetrick new challenge: do it with only redstone (probably impossible unless every trapdoor is spread out a ton)
@@WOKEchair Oh it's definitely possible even without spreading them out at all, but it would probably be very laggy
@@WOKEchair yeah, I don’t doubt it’s possible. You’ve got those redstone wizards that make functioning computers, I bet this would be a challenge but definitely not impossible
I wanna see a version where you could hear sounds of the trapdoors opening and closing
I can't with the way I did it... I cam't think of a way that would practically be possible
SAME
@@tommyhetrick you can make simple programm that imitates sounds, like when pixel changing color -> play trapdoor sound
@@L1te that'd be so painful to hear
I love it
I wanna hear the song made with trapdoor sounds
Rule 86.5: if you can see Flan's smile, then bad apple can be played perfectly.
Flan's smile is at 1:11
Why is it .5?
@@fujiwaranonekobiodrando1257 because it’s a subsection
Rule of what?
@Kanna Rule Ratio?
@evilneuro_IITPP_quittingrule 86 is "if it exists, you can play bad apple on it"
This is a subset of that rule
No way i watched iron trapdoors for 3min+
😂
If theres 2 distinct properties, it can be bad apple
If theres a screen, theres doom
If it exists, theres R34 of it
The 3 horsemen of the internet
Amazing, just as good as the original, and the gradient thing going on makes it even nicer
500th like, hehe
If the trapdoors had an actual rotation animation, I wonder what that would look like with this.
I think the transitions between frames would look blurred.
It was done using set block commands and screenshots, so even with such an animation it wouldn't show here.
My best guess would be like an lcd screen with really bad pixel response times
The devil works hard, but Touhou fans work harder! I love seeing all the ways people recreate the Bad Apple!! animation in Minecraft, and this is no exception.
its usally not touhou fans who do it its mainly tech people getting bored with putting doom on shit so might as well put this on a heartrate moniter
I'm Japanese and I love this song and Minecraft.
I've been doing Minecraft for many years, and I'm surprised that Minecraft can do this, and it's very reproducible, and I respect it.
Please continue to do your best.
you gotta be dumb, this is fake buddy, to do pixle by pixle u have to spend months to to years to animate that by goig up and down and replaying the doors, use ya brains.
Why do Japanese comments always start with a self-introduction? 😆
@@hlp3324context!! yummy context and also because why not its the internet
Wow! That's so sick!!! I love it so much.❣️❤️❣️
Thank you so much!
Imagine being on the ground with the absurd amount of trapdoor open and close sounds playing at the same time.
Lag machine too probably
I cant hear anything
but this thing called "blood" Is coming out of head, is that normal?
Bruh he already said that he used setblock command to do that and it doesnt make any sound
@@microvive30
Definition of Hypothetical:
hy·po·thet·i·cal
/ˌhīpəˈTHedəkəl/
adjective
of, based on, or serving as a hypothesis
"that option is merely hypothetical at this juncture"
noun
a hypothetical proposition or statement
"Finn talked in hypotheticals, tossing what-if scenarios to Rosen"
i love he included the little smerk
epic thing no one gets
thing is, most of the methods people use to display bad apple are too low resolution to get that smile properly
and plus it'd defeat the point to just like add it in half the time
This masterpiece is too underrated 🤩
Thanks
this is the most high quality bad apple version i ever saw, holy cow this is so good
Thanks!
If there was revealed to be a secret society running the world at any point, I would not doubt for a second if it was composed of touhou fans trying to play Bad Apple with all the lights on earth and record it for some yt video.
1:44 THAT FIRE IS SICK BRO
Interestingly, I like this more than the original. The way iron trapdoors opening create a 'wave'/'texture' for the black makes the animations and figures stand out with way more depth.
The texture isn't from trapdoors opening and closing, it's just the Moire pattern from the black tiles
Here before someone says “what is the moire effect”
"whats a moire effect?"
@@sarikabonavate.3360 "who's moo?"
Good luck finding the entrance now, griefers.
Yknow they'd just run a tnt duper right?
@@tomikun8057 if I remember tnt dupers had some issues in an area with ridiculous updates such as areas with lag machines, to be specific pistons lossing the ability to push as the top part wouldn't spawn or update, I believe it also applies to entity being spawned or latency issues that this absolute unit could do when nearby.
Might work on lan though, who knows I might be wrong but please explain to me where, I feel like I might have a misunderstanding.
@@DummyDumDumb Minecraft updates by the tick, it's why it's single threaded. Unless it's using forge which has multithreading or something else, there shouldn't be any problems
@@tomikun8057 ah thanks for clearing up that part, that means it is possible as long as there is no drastic change in tick speed, I appreciate your help.
@@DummyDumDumb Even if there is a tick rate change, theoretically there could only be graphical errors. I have not tested this.
Meanwhile, on the ground: *Iron trapdoors being instruments playing Bad Apple*
スッゴい綺麗だしなめらか～
これで再現しようとした発想もすごすぎ
The animation is so clean! I haven't seen anything so smooth coming from trap doors.
this feels easier to watch than the original because the colors are easier on the eyes
The Touhou community never ceases to amaze me with how many things they can put Bad Apple on.
-Okay, so we have minecraft and so much free time.
-Sound like a plan!
Idk how did your device able to withstand with so much triggers of trap doors, but all i could say is "this is amazing".
something about bad apple heavily aliased at this exact resolution with these exact colors looks really appealing to me
The fact that you can see the square pixels means this is not just edited in
you could edit in square pixels....
@@petfroggydbm1327 that would be one of the most grueling tasks
@@Guythatrember no you could literally add a filter
@@Guythatrember and doing it in minecraft isnt?
@bruh seem too complex. I’d assume it’s a data pack, no?
The detail in this one is insane and it's so smooth good job dude
This is actually the video that introduced me to this genre of the internet I never knew, thank you!
This is great detail, must've been an insane amount of trapdoors.
captain obvious
Imagine what this sounds like from up close XD just an onslaught of trapdoor noises
The frame rate is much better than most versions I have seen, congrats
It's actually a bunch of screenshots knit together.
No is not lol it’s a video
@@StopDropDash The creator said this is played 120x faster than the original. Video looks 60fps so original must be 0.5fps. Also he pointed out this is a bunch of screenshots stitched together.
@@StopDropDashsurprise surprise, that's how a video works
This is so good! The details are almost identical somehow. Thanks for making this so perfect and your hard work is amazing.
Thank you
I want to hear all those trap doors opening up close
Most high quality Minecraft Bad apple video so far
Thanks
2:50 this is the perfect opportunity for a transforming meme
I’ve started to see Bad Apple everywhere nowadays. It’s beginning to become the, “doom can be played on everything” of the Touhou Project and I’m all for it
I want to hear the unedited version with all the trap door noises
I think touhoh fans reached a point where coding feels like a bullet hell, once they have mastered it, nothing can get through them
To be honest, I thought that this was going to be a cover of the song. But what you did was much more impressive than any Minecraft mods that I have ever known of. Really, I’m just trying to congratulate you on getting everything perfect for this video. I just want to say… you’re truly amazing.
Thank you! That is so nice
感動しました！素敵な動画をありがとう！
The amount of detail on the close ups alone shows just how big this build is.
Dude you're insane this is amazing I tell people I have patience this blows it out of the water
Thank you
This gives a really cool effect to the animation. The black sections look really cool
Thank you
@@tommyhetrick By the way just out of curiosity, how many screenshots did this take?
@@reinbew62 just over 6,500
_I want to appreciate this masterpiece, but part of me refuses to believe this... _*_*sobs*_*
すご！
こんな綺麗に輪郭はっきりするもんなんだ
どーやってやってるのか気になる…
I like that some parts look 3d because of the effect the trapdoors give, like Marisa going a the castle
Another addition to my ever growing collection..
This is the first time I’ve watched the entirety of bad apple.
Would be fun to be a bunch of players ON the display & playing Tag with each other, and the trap-doors "randomly" flapping about & disrupting them when they run :D
This needs more views!
Thank you!
I can only imagine how annoying it can be to hear the sound of all the trapdoor that open in close in same time
Another fine addition to my collection
Glad you made a behind the scenes ffideo, I gotta see how this one works 🤔
Thanks
[Deafening sound of 1.2 million iron trapdoors rapidly clicking up and down]
They're being setblocked. There's no opening or closing.
If you can see the smile, the Bad Apple is perfect.
Every time I think I’ve seen the most insane “Bad Apple played on ____ “I am always proven wrong when another pops up into my feed. It’s crazy how many versions can be made
😀
I am stunned by the commitment…. You have done a very cool thing good sir.
Thank you!
I can't even imagine the trapdoor-noise if you were down there
Debería decir que a estas alturas ya nada me sorprende pero está versión de *Bad Apple!* es simplemente fascinante y muy divertida.
Gracias por crear tal obra y a pesar de que no es la primera de su tipo, es la *mejor* de la misma.
PD: Apenas estamos en *febrero* y ya estoy loco con tantas versiones de esta fabulosa así como magnífica animación XD
At this point Bad Apple has become Doom bruv
Imagine hearing all trap doors sound while recording this.
the way that the guy did it uses a lot of screenshots so there would be no sound in the first place
This is probably the best version I have seen. The level of detail is mind blowing.
@@ColdMystery thank you!
The technological and mechanical progress of Humanity is tracked by 2 things in specific: The amount of ridiculous/strange ways of playing doom and recreating the bad apple video
Marvel has Best transition... Bad Apple 1:00
At this point videos like this aren't even memes, they're *_MASTERPIECES_*
Cant imagine the sound of hundreds of iron trapdoors opening and closing alot of times
holy shité dude, this shit is frickin' amazing. this is so much effort you did to acomplish this, wow.
I can smell the flames from my computer already.
O ciclo não pode parar nunca, edit de bad Apple são um patrimônio pra história da internet, a mais de 9 anos esse estilo invade meus sugeridos e sempre é uma versão incrível 🙏
Brasileiro jumpscare!!!! Nem fudendo!!!
vdd
Criminal
Criminally underrated
thx
I cannot imagine how much trapdoor opening and closing that would actually make
Thank God u didn't add the trapdoor sound, it would R.I.P my ear💀
My freind when he pranks me with hidden trapdoors: "Like that sound?" *anoying noise instencifys*
I can not even begin to imagine how loud that would be in game.
At this point I'm waiting for someone to make a "Bad Apple but it's on an apple"
th-cam.com/video/rSiOhsGwcII/w-d-xo.html
12 years ago
That already happened lol
@@melissacastillo5562 Link?
@@junebox.9882 th-cam.com/video/rSiOhsGwcII/w-d-xo.html
@@junebox.9882 th-cam.com/video/rSiOhsGwcII/w-d-xo.html
HOW IN THE ACTUAL HECK DO YOU HAVE 16K VIEWS BUT ONLY 123 SUBSCRIBERS? Do people not recognize true talent anymore?
*You've earned a subscriber!*
Awww, that is so nice. Thank you.
@@tommyhetrick You're welcome! :D
you got my sub and got me impressed. You deserve a big W
Thank you
Bad apple is literally the Doom of the musics, is playable on everything
now think what was the sound of trapdoors opening.
Now I just want to hear the original audio of the trapdoors lol
Imagine the noise
Bad Apple is just like Doom, you can play it everywhere at this point.
the scale to it is so much bigger, making it so much smoother than a lot of others, and it really makes you wonder how their pc hasnt melted yet.
Would love to see this with the actual trapdoor sounds making the music
Imagine the noise of all the trapdoors moving 💀✋
So no one's gonna talk how the gray gradient made the Bad Apple way, way more cooler?.
no way i just watched iron trapdoors open and close for 4 minutes (love this sm)
bro gave it such a high resolution holy shit