The Origins of Solar Bahamut & Truth behind Job Abilities in Dawntrail

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ย. 2024
  • I wanna thank 'Skijaramaz - Tone Shift' for helping me out with the intro of this video. He's done a lot of fun and interesting dubs over on his own TH-cam channel and I couldn't help but ask for his assistance. The link to his channel can be found here.
    Be sure to let me know your thoughts on Solar Bahamut as well as the use of job abilities in Dawntrail down in the comment section bellow. While the lore is quite clear on much of this, there's still plenty of room for healthy debate!
    Solar Bahamut Voice Actor, Skijaramaz - Tone Shift
    / @skijaramaz
    Follow me at: / scribesynodic
    Channel Art by Catti: ko-fi.com/catt...
    Join the Channel's Discord: / discord
    Support the Channel on Patreon: www.patreon.co...
    Disclaimer: The MMORPG known as FinalFantasy XIV Online as well as all its related publications and merchandise are owned by Square Enix. I have no claims to it.
    Primary Sources:
    Video Games-
    FinalFantasy XIV Online
    Publications-
    Encyclopedia Eorzea Volume I
    Encyclopedia Eorzea Volume II
    Encyclopedia Eorzea Volume III
    Alternative Sources:
    FinalFantasyXIV, The Lodestone/Sidestory
    FFXIV, Letter from the Producer
    Published FFXIV Brand Art Books
    #ffxiv #dawntrail #lore

ความคิดเห็น • 663

  • @Skijaramaz
    @Skijaramaz หลายเดือนก่อน +498

    Who knew voicing a sobbing dragon would be so much fun? "Twas a blast to be on board, even if only for a bit.

    • @SynodicScribe
      @SynodicScribe  หลายเดือนก่อน +21

      Amazing work as always my friend!

    • @AndrewsArtDen
      @AndrewsArtDen หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      You did an amazing job!

    • @jessicaguarneri8460
      @jessicaguarneri8460 หลายเดือนก่อน

      The sobbing dragon made ME sob. Great job!

    • @Taoryu
      @Taoryu หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      As I keep telling people...I cant enjoy this star dragon , because my CARBUNCLE is -still- braindead!

    • @shinyhero306
      @shinyhero306 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@SynodicScribeside note this video needs a spoiler warning because of hydaelyn talk

  • @Larryzaur
    @Larryzaur หลายเดือนก่อน +567

    They are all Bahamut to me ❤

    • @dafire9634
      @dafire9634 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

      Of course larry is on a summoner video, its a magnet

    • @EratoTiaTuatha
      @EratoTiaTuatha หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Kudos to u Larry you were the first person I saw point out that Solar Bahamut was using Hydaelyn's sygil

    • @dazzlemasseur
      @dazzlemasseur หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Fire bahamut, wind bahamut, Earth bahamut, normal bahamut, rebirth bahamut and finally solar bahamut.

    • @nirau
      @nirau หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I love my dragon boi ❤

    • @lanah_tyra
      @lanah_tyra 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I was scrolling down the comments to see if you have already shouted "WHOSAGOODBOY" or do I have to do it. Looks like I have to XD Bahamut is the best boy ❤WHOSAGOODBOY yes you are Bahamut, you are.

  • @AnnaBananya
    @AnnaBananya หลายเดือนก่อน +490

    Not having a summoner version of Ramuh/Leviathan/Shiva is a crime against Final Fantasy.

    • @FtanmoOfEtheirys
      @FtanmoOfEtheirys หลายเดือนก่อน +93

      it totally is and could be easily implemented by having ifrit, titan, and garuda action change to ramuh, levi, and shiva after summoning phoenix

    • @krexed6709
      @krexed6709 หลายเดือนก่อน +17

      ​@@FtanmoOfEtheirys This! Ive thought often that it would be a good place to add these summons. And if not even that ive thought at the very least they added the whole egiglamour command. Just let summoners pick which 3 egis they want summoned change the attack animations if you can and call it a day (though i would still much prefer the first method)

    • @BlaineKodos
      @BlaineKodos หลายเดือนก่อน +34

      I was super into Phoenix having the other three elemental Primals. Even if they didn't do anything different statistically (one fast one, one medium one, one slow one) having the illusion of eight total summons would have felt better than a bigger Bahamut. I don't hate Solar but he wasn't what I wanted either

    • @jrtime228
      @jrtime228 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      So is posting complaints here instead of on the official XIV threads where the devs can see them. Yes, this would be nice. But the devs aren't going to see your opinion HERE. (If you have already, then just ignore this post)

    • @NargiKyrad
      @NargiKyrad หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@BlaineKodos while you would've been okay with it. i wouldn't have. if they're not making them different then it's pointless to add them and i'm sure other people think alike, why add Shiva, Ramuh and Leviathan if they're just re-skinned Ifrit, Titan and Garuda

  • @Otacanthus
    @Otacanthus หลายเดือนก่อน +264

    "Inspired by someone"
    "Blue, slim lizard like face. Zoral Ja??"
    "Hydaelyn."
    "Oh yeah that works too"

    • @Scerttle
      @Scerttle หลายเดือนก่อน +7

      lmao ngl I was like "oh, maybe it's not hydaelyn and Zoraal Ja instead?!"

    • @sifferino
      @sifferino หลายเดือนก่อน +14

      I mean technically zoral ja is a 99 msq fight. It could definitely be influenced (the swords in that fight come to mind)

    • @pentagonofpeople
      @pentagonofpeople 28 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Personally I was on "Bunch of swords? Vaguely holy aesthetic? Gotta be knights of the round"

    • @AmberNeri-bs3es
      @AmberNeri-bs3es 20 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@pentagonofpeople i personally think that is the case. honoring hershy and venah both at once.by using the magic signature of venah and the swords as wings while boosting the dragon power

  • @bob-hf1kw
    @bob-hf1kw หลายเดือนก่อน +252

    "Who told you to start doing backflips with a ranged weapon?"
    Huh, I feel kinda called out here.

    • @leandroribeiro3626
      @leandroribeiro3626 หลายเดือนก่อน +19

      That part of the video made me ''Huh'' more than the whole Bahamuth bit. Like yeah if the MCH soulstone its empty and this job its unique to the WOL, every machinist gadget, robots and weapons are created either BY you or FOR for you. As is the whole *backflipping* thing. We are super extra!

    • @treesuschrist1782
      @treesuschrist1782 หลายเดือนก่อน +15

      "I dont backflip because the rock told me to, I do it because I WANT to. I AM that extra. I am HIM. Ive BEEN HIM. I will continue to BE HIM"- Machinist mains.

    • @Silvershadowfire
      @Silvershadowfire หลายเดือนก่อน +8

      Considering the WoL can hit the cracks in a suit of armor with a blowgun from fifty yalms, I personally think they started doing backflips just to add some challenge lol. And maybe to be harder to hit by the enemy. I mean, it's harder to hit a moving target.

    • @Puddingskin01
      @Puddingskin01 หลายเดือนก่อน +15

      "I'm making these moves the future stone users problem!" -Inner Azem

    • @Wolfdoggie
      @Wolfdoggie 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I still want to know the lore behind "Air Anchor." What is the science and reasoning behind that bizarre attack?

  • @VesperOfRoses
    @VesperOfRoses หลายเดือนก่อน +203

    Solar Bahamut has 14 swords, seven on each wing, representing the fourteen shards. His regular attacks (umbral impulse, etc) are light-aspected which we know corresponds with umbral ether. And to top it all off, his big attack is Exodus, the ability Hydaelyn used to split the world into 14

    • @itsmefirefox
      @itsmefirefox 28 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      So this is the hydalin primal?

    • @makisbizarreadventure4669
      @makisbizarreadventure4669 28 วันที่ผ่านมา +8

      @@itsmefirefox more or less yeah.

    • @VesperOfRoses
      @VesperOfRoses 28 วันที่ผ่านมา +10

      @@itsmefirefox It's like if the WoL used the aetheric signatures of both bahamut and Hydaelyn together

    • @Azdaja13
      @Azdaja13 27 วันที่ผ่านมา +8

      @@itsmefirefox It's a Hydaelyn-inspired Primal. It's more like the version of Ramuh we summoned on the First where it ended up getting Ixion elements, or Leviathan getting mixed with Thalaos and Perykos.

    • @thomasdziuk5893
      @thomasdziuk5893 24 วันที่ผ่านมา +7

      @@itsmefirefox It probably was originally just hydaelyn, but having summoners running around in low level areas with a hydaelyn egi was probably considered to lore breaking, so they had to reskin the egi and couldn't think of anything other than 'shiny bahamut'. And they may have even wanted to add a Zodiark egi as well, it would make sense for them to be a pair

  • @rengreeneyes
    @rengreeneyes หลายเดือนก่อน +170

    If this video has taught me anything, it's that:
    1) Solar Bahamut is a focused amalgamation of WoL's journey up to Dawntrail.
    2) Machinist proves that WoL is so FLIPPING EXTRA!

    • @warkiller
      @warkiller หลายเดือนก่อน +14

      WoL being rather extra kinda makes sense when...you remember WHO the WoL used to be before...And that someone apparently was very much into many hijinks...

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      That's somehow the most accurate summary of a video I've ever heard.

    • @dylanflynn1895
      @dylanflynn1895 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      charged into an erupting volcano to save grapes because the wine tastes good, the WoL has always been extra

    • @FinnFann
      @FinnFann 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@@warkillerThe embodiment of shenanigans.

  • @cordrac
    @cordrac หลายเดือนก่อน +162

    I remember the dragoon story where you're training a dragoon and, when you learn battle litany, it's canonized as the trainee going something like "what? doing this just made you think of a new ability?" *quest completion music*

    • @8BitCerberus
      @8BitCerberus หลายเดือนก่อน +56

      Also notice that most of the job quests end at level 70, and even the new jobs that start at 70 and 80 only get about 10 levels worth of job quests before your WoL is once again improvising and coming up with new abilities and techniques on their own.
      I would still like to see at least "capstone" job quests though, like we got at 80. Would be nice to have at 90 and 100 just catching up with everyone, help out with a new mission or something.

    • @elecrom_9757
      @elecrom_9757 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      @@8BitCerberus Arguably it cannot be ruled out that the abilities unlocked after 70 were still created by previous holders of the stones (when applicable, so MCH and BLU are out) and the new experiences in the expansion activated the memory.

    • @8BitCerberus
      @8BitCerberus 29 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@elecrom_9757 True, that is a possibility. And in that case it's also possible that the stone(s) was/were **always** ours, and hold the memories of our past selves.

  • @Lyn685
    @Lyn685 หลายเดือนก่อน +160

    The name "Solar" is also interesting in connection to the WoL, because the sun is Azem's symbol

    • @Zoeila
      @Zoeila หลายเดือนก่อน +21

      Yes and multiple jobs got new sun themed abilities. Sun sign, Flare star etc.

    • @CleopatraKing
      @CleopatraKing หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      It's more of a counterpart to Lunar bahumut from shb

    • @acgearsandarms1343
      @acgearsandarms1343 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      @@Lyn685 The Allagans did have plan to use Bahamut in Dalamud as a solar battery. He did show unique affinity with fire aether and the sun is a good source of it.

    • @klabence
      @klabence หลายเดือนก่อน +5

      @@Zoeila I mean, this is DAWNtrail.

    • @kiretan8599
      @kiretan8599 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      You can also find it in solar panels and solar systems. Really interesting

  • @orly4672
    @orly4672 หลายเดือนก่อน +108

    So Solar Bahamut is basically the song "Answers" in summon form. Fitting since the song is both associated with Bahamut and Hydaelyn.

    • @AlphaXXI
      @AlphaXXI หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      I would have loved it if there was a recerence to the song in its sound design. Like if when you cast Umbral Pulse it made the notes for "Witness" and Solar responded with the note for "Feel" when attacking after.

    • @crazy13alex
      @crazy13alex หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I feel it's more specifically "Your Answer", the Scions battle with Hydaelyn.

  • @BenHyuga
    @BenHyuga หลายเดือนก่อน +40

    "How did you make solar Bahamut"
    "It came to me in a dream"

    • @DantoriusD
      @DantoriusD หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      More like a Nightmare 😂

    • @PikachuBen
      @PikachuBen หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      "The source is I made it the fuck up"

  • @oriondezagrats4228
    @oriondezagrats4228 หลายเดือนก่อน +30

    There's also the fact that it is known that Midgardsormr and Hydaelyn had an accord, so there is some thematic link between the two, and therefore the First Brood, just to get in the WoL's headspace since some of their ideas have been pretty wacky before, Eden raids as an example.
    It might be that Solar Bahamut is, perhaps, an attempt to 'redeem' or do justice by Bahamut, pulling from the original's title of 'Dawnwyrm', which got corrupted to 'Dreadwyrm' and has parallels with the term used in-game, 'Lightwyrm'.
    It might be that WoL just thinks of Hydaelyn as the go-to idea of Light now, thus the theming.
    Alternatively, the WoL noticed they had the 'code' for Hydaelyn, but felt weird about just summoning a clone of her due to knowing her personally, and so warped the shape the code took by shunting it onto the Dawnwyrm.

    • @torashiki5646
      @torashiki5646 25 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      While I agree with the point, a big reminder is that despite the brain damage memes, Eden primals were intentionally modified by the slumbering Mitron. Thats why Shivadelyn is cartoonishly evil - Mitron is an ascian.

  • @Wanderingsage7
    @Wanderingsage7 หลายเดือนก่อน +53

    I like your explanation and it makes sense. Alternatively, I also like the idea of the WoL meditating and their minds wander to 'you know what would be neat? If Bahamut was blue like mom and had swords for wings.'

    • @AmberNeri-bs3es
      @AmberNeri-bs3es 20 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      my headcanon is still its honoring haurshefaunt with the wing swords. mentioning the 14 shards at the same time and using mom energy to redeeem the dragon father son all at once XD (tho didnt say the last part in the last comment)

  • @gianghuynh9570
    @gianghuynh9570 หลายเดือนก่อน +86

    If you collect the Apocryphal Bahamut, by having all of the extreme trial mounts from EW, the explanation is given to you straight up: yes you can form pretty much any Bahamut you like, even one holding a chair.
    The NPC and PC selectively chose to focus on primal Bahamut’s desire to be free to summon a version of him that only embodies hopes and dreams.
    If you as any job that can summon a dragon holding a chair, I can buy that you as summoner can summon a dragon with sword for wings.
    The sword wings also looks the same as the swords falling from Dalamud.

    • @bradleydevron
      @bradleydevron หลายเดือนก่อน +23

      The swords that form Solar Bahamut's wings also seem to add to the Hydaelyn connection. If you count them, each "wing" is made up of 7 swords, totaling 14, the same amount of shards Hydaelyn sundered Etheirys into in order to sunder Zodiark. Plus, on a bit more of a stretch, while she does use Chakram and a staff, Hydaelyn's go-to weapon seems to be a good old sword, both as Hydaelyn and as her original self of Venat. There's also Exodus being used by both, so...

    • @acgearsandarms1343
      @acgearsandarms1343 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      @@bradleydevron Don’t forget the brands imprisoning Zodiark. Those were swords as well, and by association, tied to Hydaelyn.

    • @bradleydevron
      @bradleydevron หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      @@acgearsandarms1343 Yeah, Solar Bahamut is no doubt the WoL's version of Hydaelyn, just in draconian form.

    • @valenten89
      @valenten89 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Look they cant just let summoners summon Hydaelyn in dawntrail the amount of people confused and spoiled would be insane. This is the work around for that imo. What I would like to see next is instead of just repeating ifrit, garuda, and titan between big summons we alternate based on what is the next big one. have like Shiva, Leviathan, and Ravana or w/e leading to pheonix or solar bahamut. then another 3 or even 2 leading to pheonix. Maybe theme them together leading to the big summon so it makes sense. Titan Garuda and Ifrit are tied to Bahamut, then tie another 3 to Pheonix and another batch to Solar Bamahut. Thats what people want imo. Least I think it would be cool.

    • @bradleydevron
      @bradleydevron หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@valenten89 I feel from a lore perspective, that is best achieved by making the Gem Primals (which are technically what you summon and which replace your Egis at that point, of course) technically their own thing, a WoL invention that is like Trance and bypasses the Egi Limit.

  • @nargazuba9682
    @nargazuba9682 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    With the mention of MCH creating there own style, the 80 Optional Quest just straight up tells you that the Warrior of Light made Automaton Queen themselves

  • @johndipietro9301
    @johndipietro9301 หลายเดือนก่อน +31

    From a Doylist perspective, I strongly suspect they wanted to make a Demi-Hydaelyn, but were afraid of it being too much of a spoiler. Also can't help but notice similarities to the concept of the Stranger in Paradise version of Bahamut (who also had blades floating behind him in lieu of wings, and was made of a silvery metal).
    As for both why and how the Warrior would make such a merger of Hydaelyn's essence and Bahamut's form, I think that it's in the limitations of the Trance. IIRC the reason why we got Phoenix is due to how those two essences were intermingled - essentially, Demi-Phoenix really is just Demi-Bahamut, but altered slightly by invoking a different aspect of the mingled aether (possibly due to our time in the First and the exposure to the Light somehow drawing out the Phoenix aspect). Since we haven't gone through the process (in game at least...) of repeating the ritual for any other primals, it's possible that the only way the WoL can improve their Demi is by developing another alteration - in this case, by merging a new essence onto the Bahamut template.

    • @TheZeratulsan
      @TheZeratulsan หลายเดือนก่อน +9

      One thing to point out with Phoenix in ShB is that the WoL was effectively resurrecting the first, like how Phoenix had the same result on the source.
      They definitely had a reason in leaving Phoenix as the lvl 80 skill after the EW rework

    • @hawk4558
      @hawk4558 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I like the way you think sir!

  • @PanMoriiCaelestis
    @PanMoriiCaelestis หลายเดือนก่อน +32

    To add to the theory of taking inspiration from past encounters for Dawntrail:
    Samurai's "Tendo Setsugekka" does seem very similar to a certain Garlean Prince.
    Bard's new jumping shot feels similar to a certain "Wanderer"
    And i'll be honest, when i saw Disesteem on Drk, i thought of Zodiark.
    Of course i may be grasping at air, but it's atleast something to think about.
    Edit: Also Red Mage's new finisher "Prefulgence" Feels similar to Venat's Finisher

    • @maallos334mi8
      @maallos334mi8 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

      No, you’re onto something. The idea of the WoL creating their own moves goes as far back as Dragoon’s lvl 62 quest, when they create the part-wide critical hit rate buff by watching another dragoon fight.
      There’s also a subtle moment for White Mages in Shadowbringers, where their earth 3 attack changes into Glare at 72, which for most played would have been after the lvl 71 dungeon…

    • @BrainCleanser0
      @BrainCleanser0 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Disteem actually brings to mind durante and his fate

    • @rfactor1502
      @rfactor1502 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Given the theme of legacy DT has, this all tracks.

    • @undvined
      @undvined 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@BrainCleanser0 True! Golbez's stance with Black Fang and the subsequent effects would very much explain Disesteem.

    • @kohlicoide2258
      @kohlicoide2258 13 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@@undvined In German Disesteem has also the Name "Antiheld" (Antihero) and the Buff for it is called "Lied des Antihelden" (Song of the Antihero) and Golbez was a Antihero in some way

  • @MrLilven
    @MrLilven หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    I like how wol suddenly decided to just henshin into fairy with scholar

    • @Poldovico
      @Poldovico หลายเดือนก่อน

      Scholar fairies are distinct beings. Creatures akin to the Pixies of the First whose souls have come to reside in the soul crystal, and to whom we merely grant Aether to fashion themselves a corporeal form.

  • @juanpablolozanotorres2437
    @juanpablolozanotorres2437 หลายเดือนก่อน +76

    honestly solar bahamuth shows how not adding more job quest can be detrimental to job fantasy and identity

    • @AlphaXXI
      @AlphaXXI หลายเดือนก่อน +16

      I understand why they wouldn't want to add job quests on the scale of what they keep adding for new jobs, it's a lot of work. But they could at least add a really short sidequest that gives some lore like they did for Fantasias.

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@AlphaXXI
      Hell, I wouldn't mind capstone quests that allow you to check in on the NPCs associated with each job and get their thoughts on your actions and developments and stuff.

    • @whodistoodis
      @whodistoodis 29 วันที่ผ่านมา +10

      @@AlphaXXI Or just do what Shadowbringers did and give a job a single job quest at max level, minimizing the total workload of quest design, still allowing role quests to do their thing, and still letting us actually explore classes and their lore. A level 100 quest explaining Solar Bahamut would have gone a long way. Alas, not everything can be as good as ShB.

    • @crypto66
      @crypto66 19 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      I get the desire to avoid having to implement five mechanically-diverse quests for more than a dozen jobs every expansion, but would a story/lore/exposition-heavy interaction with your former job trainers really be too much? Programming a quest where you just talk to a bunch of NPCs can't be _that_ much more work. Just one cutscene where they bob heads at each other.

    • @WalkerRileyMC
      @WalkerRileyMC 16 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Or they cut back on the two billion sidequests and set that a side for jobs quests.

  • @pll3827
    @pll3827 หลายเดือนก่อน +17

    Makes me think how it appears the Endwalker Paladin spells that summon swords appear to come out of nowhere since other in-game Paladins among the Sultansworn don't seem to use them, but they don't come out of nowhere. You see Venat using them.

    • @Krysta1Rose
      @Krysta1Rose หลายเดือนก่อน +12

      And post Endwalker, seeing Oschon using his arrows, Bard gets a very similar ability in Dawntrail...😊

    • @escahfaidhe755
      @escahfaidhe755 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      And Elidibus as the warrior of light too. Which was most likely influenced by the Seat of azem, not the person
      Thusly wol as Paladin is using the will and strength associated with their original self to fight.

  • @pitta3114
    @pitta3114 หลายเดือนก่อน +24

    Great evidence, especially at the end! really felt like everything that you talked about in the video came together all neatly at the end to prove your point - and that's tough to do, so great execution!

  • @Deesar_
    @Deesar_ หลายเดือนก่อน +18

    Kind of makes me think of how awesome summoner could be if they werent so intent on keeping the job simple. Imagine cycling through bahamut/solar, ifri/titan/garuda, phoenix/perhaps some zodiark inspired phoenix, then ramuh/leviathan/shiva. Also give summoners dots again.

    • @alexanderchipman9571
      @alexanderchipman9571 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      No. That thought will breathe Phoinix back into existence, and...far too many players have horrible memories of P3S. Love the idea, hate the ramifications. :D

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      I'd love it if Summoner severed all connections it had with WoW's Warlock for forever - so please no DoTs.

  • @MEAD3MAYNE
    @MEAD3MAYNE หลายเดือนก่อน +9

    Crazy how no one points out Solar Bahamut's ultimate is Exodus, which is Hydaelyn's attack that sundered the world.

  • @unknownfate1985
    @unknownfate1985 หลายเดือนก่อน +9

    Nice Video. I also noticed that Solar Bahamut has 14 swords, which might represent the Convocation of Fourteen. So Solar Bahamut might also be the memory of the conflict between Hydalean and the Ascians and quite literally fulfills our promise to Emet Selch: "remember us". And just by how random solar bahamut actually is, I would place my bets on the next expansion being Meracydia with Summoner being the first caster poster job

  • @VollkinSea
    @VollkinSea หลายเดือนก่อน +10

    One thing that I think you forgot to mention was the dreadwyrm trance phase of summoner. There was a lot of care into pointing out that the first three summons were, for all intents and purposes, as close as possible to a "tamed" primal. They had the exact same signature, and we were able to provide enough ether to sustain it for it's attack. Bahamut, on the other hand, was too grand, so we had to learn that there are other uses for a primal's ether: weaving it into other things, or in this specific case, ourselves. Endwalker also taught us about the intricacies of primal's, why they act the way they do, and how it's based off of creation magicks, changes and taught by ascians. I believe that solar bahamut is us taking our knowledge of summoner summoning, weaving ether into trances, and the idea of creation magicks in order to not just create an imitation of a primal, but use what ever combination of ethers to make new summons. It's practically exactly what you said, but I feel the detail of our character already knowing how to weave primal ether into something other than a practically identical copy is a pretty important detail.

    • @AmberNeri-bs3es
      @AmberNeri-bs3es 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

      i mean mom did give us the power to weave the fabric of reality tho lasted just a bit. tho i think our wol could have used that time to study how to weave eather in a similair fashon tho invinitely less than the ancients. add summoner power. yeah i can see how we could do it

  • @ProfessorHeavy1
    @ProfessorHeavy1 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    "Good work, WAR, you learned more abilities. What will you do with your newfound--"
    "AXE."
    "But you already--"
    "MORE AXE."

  • @LordoftheDice
    @LordoftheDice หลายเดือนก่อน +9

    This kinda adds on to something I heard someone say. That as of Shadowbringers, we basically learned everything that the soul crystals could teach us and everything beyond that is a new technique that we've developed through our mastery of the skills and magics available to us. It sortof explains why we no longer have job quests from a lore perspective. There's no longer anyone who can teach us anything. We've mastered our jobs and now all that remains is honing our abilities and creating new ones that will be etched onto our jobs stones.
    It's kinda interesting to think about how the jobs stones of the Warrior of Light will likely become powerful relics after we're gone and only the strongest of people will be able to wield the skills etched upon them.

    • @daizelp
      @daizelp 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Or. Hear me out. Role quest comes back in the future but as US teaching the job for future generations.

    • @LordoftheDice
      @LordoftheDice 28 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@daizelp I assume you mean job quests, since role quests still exist. I doubt it. Each expansion introduces 2 new jobs, which would mean the work load required to make a questline for each job would get larger and larger as time goes on. That's a lot of work that only a small portion of players will see all of, since most people only play/level a few jobs. They could do small little quests for each job after finishing the job quest like they did in Shadowbringers, but even that could eventually get out of hand.

  • @skibuski
    @skibuski หลายเดือนก่อน +15

    I don't have SMN 100 yet but as soon as I saw the incantation circle I knew it had something to do with Mother!
    Keep up the great lore insights! 👍

  • @alexisrios4991
    @alexisrios4991 25 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    WOL: I know exactly who you are?
    Solar Bahumat: Really? Who am I?
    WOL: My new Pal.

  • @LadyAsteria58
    @LadyAsteria58 หลายเดือนก่อน +40

    Synodic Therapist

  • @MissKashira
    @MissKashira หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I sat there for 16 minutes going "it's Hydaelyn." There is the color, the floor effect and the sword wings. I just assumed the summon was impacted by the WoL meeting Hydaelyn.

  • @aikireikinu
    @aikireikinu หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Considering that it's pretty typical for a Final Fantasy game to have multiple Bahamut versions (Bahamut, Neo-Bahamut, Bahamut Zero, etc.) it seems perfectly normal that SMN ends up with a pokedex full of Bahamuts.

  • @aurora3381
    @aurora3381 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    The therapy joke with Bahamut is clever job. Nice work lol

  • @ShielderCortolo
    @ShielderCortolo 24 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I appreciate your bringing up that the WoL's behavior when playing Machinist is completely their doing. It's been my theory since the job quests stopped being the source for abilities and spells that the WoL had reached a point surpassing any of their mentors and indeed what the soul stones had recorded, resulting in the WoL essentially having to 'improvise' skills and spells that would then be etched onto the stones.
    As for why Solar Bahamut was the result of this behavior, I think Occam's Razor would point to sheer familiarity. Not only did they encounter the primal Bahamut during the Battle at Carteneau Flats, but in their last outing to the ruins of Dalamud, as well as the strength of those tempered by it (Twintania, Nael, etc.), making Bahamut probably the second most familiar primal to the WoL after Hydaelyn.

  • @acgearsandarms1343
    @acgearsandarms1343 หลายเดือนก่อน +16

    Based on the Eden primals, my idea would have been to combine the primals we already have into a fusion. Like combining Ifrit, Titan and Garuda into a temporary super summon.
    Without the faith, the act of making a primal is like creation magic: super exacting. You can’t let your mind stray. We learned this in Amaurot. And in Eden, the end result of the Eden primals wildly differed from our recollection.

    • @jrtime228
      @jrtime228 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Summoning something by using aether IS creation magic in essence. You are creating something out of aether rather than it being teleported from one place to another using aether. Zodiark and Hydaelyn are prime examples of this in action. Despite them being lauded as gods, they did not already exist within the vastness of creation when they were summoned. And the unsundered taught this summoning to beast tribes, which was then studied and refined by Allag and weaponized as the Summoner Spell School. The "faith" spoken of is the conduit for which the summoning takes a form. It has nothing to do with the creation of the summon but it gives it an identifiable form (a body). An example of aether in a bodiless form are the common elemental sprites we see in the world (the furbles are an example of wind aether in an identifiable physical form)

    • @acgearsandarms1343
      @acgearsandarms1343 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      @@jrtime228 Not the point of me mentioning creation magic. It’s to point out how wildly the end results vary from your intention without the exact conceptual design or the faith to supplement the lack of said concept.
      As a separate point, summoning vs true creation magic has a visible divide despite one being derivative of the other. Not relevant to the original point, so I’m not going to go further into it.

    • @escahfaidhe755
      @escahfaidhe755 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Raktapaksa
      Give us raktapaksa with a car as a 4th demi

    • @girla9480
      @girla9480 หลายเดือนก่อน

      That sounds like it should summon Ultimate Weapon. Which would be baller, I'm all for it.

  • @DrakeWurrum
    @DrakeWurrum หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    @0:00 Solar Bahamut is just Hydaelyn.
    But they can't just GIVE players Hydaelyn... at least to avoid spoilers.
    *Even Larrysaur realized this* it's glaringly obvious.

    • @maallos334mi8
      @maallos334mi8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      It’s not if you haven’t leveled summoner to 100, because they haven’t seen the whole phase yet.

    • @DrakeWurrum
      @DrakeWurrum หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      @maallos334mi8 - Solar Bahamut's ability name is Exodus.
      This is the same name as the ability Hydaelyn casts during the trial where you need to destroy all 6 crystals to avoid a wipe.
      It even uses the same animation.

    • @maallos334mi8
      @maallos334mi8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@DrakeWurrum and I haven’t seen it, as I’ve not leveled summoner yet

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@maallos334mi8
      You know that other players can use summons out in the field, right?
      Imagine doing hunts, and a giant pretty woman appears and you can see its nametag is "Demi Hydaelyn".
      Meanwhile you're a sprout only know Hydaelyn as the Mothercrystal, a representation of the planet itself, and you just go "Huh?"

  • @ugxsan
    @ugxsan หลายเดือนก่อน +23

    If I had a nickel for every time a creator made me appreciate MCH while talking about Dawntrail SMN, I’d have two nickels, which isn’t a lot, but it’s weird that it happened twice in the same week!

    • @Nazuiko
      @Nazuiko หลายเดือนก่อน +7

      Hey machinist is fuckin awesome we cant help it.

    • @rfactor1502
      @rfactor1502 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      DT feels like a MCH Lore matters expansion.

  • @TorManiak
    @TorManiak หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I always understood that past a certain point there was no longer any knowledge to be gained from most Soul Crystals, so the Warrior of Light gets to "unlock" job actions by coming up with them on their own(and imprinting that in the Crystals).
    Of course, it's not truly this clear cut and the WoL may learn things from soul crystals late into their growth or boost their beginnings by creating moves that weren't in them.
    After all, if you remember the HW DRG job quests, your WoL actually invents the lvl 52 skill as the NPC Heustienne will ask them about, which they do comfirm that they did, or Esteem mentioning the "trick" the WoL had made in the lvl80 DRK quest, it's pretty clear that the skills you unlock aren't always learned but invented by the WoL, and that especially applies for jobs that were evolved from classes(Dragoon and Monk job quest explicitly talk about how the WoL's style of fighting is different from the normal practitioners of the same discipline as them).
    What I mean by this is that the Warrior of LIght coming up with new moves unheard of isn't really news to me, but I would *_INFINITELY_* prefer that you have a way to properly introduce them to the player so that it makes sense to everyone -and to also make the rotation of SMN less boring even if still easy pls pls pls-. Sure getting a new summon is nice, but it doesn't really make me WOW that much specifically _because_ it's not explained what it actually means to have it and what it represents, since to most people, it's just a blue skin of Bahamut. I'm guessing next expansion we'll get Lunar Phoenix with Zodiark's aetherial signature from what this video hints at, but it's not really gonna matter how cool as a concept it is if we don't get anything that gives context as to what it symbolizes.

  • @ryokophreak
    @ryokophreak หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Your videos started showing up in my feed. Subbed. Enjoying it.
    Also....as a summoner main, I actually like Solar Bahamut's look and spell sfx effects.

  • @Wanderingsage7
    @Wanderingsage7 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

    Wouldn't Tiamaht's summoning be the closest to the original since she actually knew Bahamut inside and out?

    • @zacross8504
      @zacross8504 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Yeah. Imo it’s most likely Primal Bahamut is what he looked like ages ago while the EE art is him around the time of his death.
      Similar to Midgardsomr minion, mount and corpse being very different in design.

  • @ianchristiansen6601
    @ianchristiansen6601 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    When I first saw Solar Bahamut, I thought it was supposed to be Azem's familiar

  • @warllockmasterasd9142
    @warllockmasterasd9142 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    So, what you are saying is that after the WoL came into contact with Eden, we stole its ability to make primals.
    and thus created our own very first original work.

    • @Rayhaku808
      @Rayhaku808 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Fake it til you make it

    • @maallos334mi8
      @maallos334mi8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      More like we’re copying Eden at a smaller scale

    • @NieroshaiTheSable
      @NieroshaiTheSable 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Eden facilitates creation magic as a factory. More like the WoL learned something in Elpis.

  • @Funami2006
    @Funami2006 หลายเดือนก่อน +19

    I like Solar Bahamut as a concept, but why can’t we have both Solar Bahamut and all six standard elements for egis/demi summons?
    Picto is the first job to actually implement all six of the standard elements and personally I feel like they should lean in more on these classical elements stuff.

    • @jrtime228
      @jrtime228 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Picto is also based on the imagination and aetheric paintings that serve an intended function, not complicated formulas to make aether take on the form of something semi-autonomous that can use aether as well. And the concept for a XIV summoner was already well established before the concept of lunar and solar primals was. Retconning that would take a lot of changes to ARR which would also result in changes needing to be made to further expansions (all for one class). That does not sound like a feasible thing to do in terms of time and resources that can be allocated to keeping the game going. It would be VERY nice to have more summons. And id be all for having a summon or two from stormblood. But realistically speaking, I see more downsides for the devs than upsides for us. Don't forget, this is a GAME, and it has its limitations.

    • @Funami2006
      @Funami2006 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      @@jrtime228 To clarify what I mean, I share the desire of many for Summoner to have Shiva Ramuh & Leviathan added to their repertoire of Egis. Doing so would complete the set of six major elements available to Summoner.

    • @Nazuiko
      @Nazuiko หลายเดือนก่อน

      Picto is also the first time Water magic has been an actual thing. We get no closer than Fluid Aura and Aquaveil, one of which has been deleted and neither actually offensive abilities.
      Likewise, Picto finally added Comet, in a way, to the WoL's spellbook .... Yet still, no Quake.
      At this point I wonder if they view Quake as too triggering to a Japanese audience due to the prevalence of tragedies from earthquakes irl, or some nature of it exclusive to enemies akin to Rogue turning to Ninja and not Thief (and of course, no Necromancer job)

    • @Funami2006
      @Funami2006 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@Nazuiko fun fact Fuild Aura used to do damage way back in the day. They removed that aspect at some point

    • @SavageReaperDemon
      @SavageReaperDemon หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@Nazuiko if you mean playable. Though I'm assuming it existed in 1.0 because Y'shtola had water magic and even used it back in Heavensward on, and used it officially in battle from shadowbringers on. She has Water IV as an aoe spell she uses occasionally similarly to how urianger casts death, Ryne uses the deleted ninja skill, ect. They should've let us have the water magic as whm is a parallel to blm but whm Is now a light magic user and blm still used fire, ice and lightning.
      Kinda want them to make blm a proper dark mage now by making it like "dark fire IV or something lol

  • @Alovon
    @Alovon หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I would say that an interesting idea would be that Solar Bahamut is the culmination of the WoL's learning about Summoning in general (As a Summoner and of learning about the Creation technique of the Ancients).
    Using the knowledge from the SMN Soul Crystal, the knowledge and techniques they themselves developed starting in Shadowbringers. And the knowledge of the truth behind creation magics and the "fixed" summoning technique used by the Tribes at EW's climax, the WoL used all of that to use creation magic to create a "Demi Primal"
    I use quotations there as, while it is in the shape of a demi-primal and has Hydealyn's ether signature woven into it. Solar Bahamut could very well be a Concept rather than a Demi-Primal (the WoL dispelling Solar Bahamut at the end of his duration to prevent him from supping up too much ether from the environment/themselves)
    To simplify, my thought is Solar Bahamut isn't a Demi-Primal. He's a concept akin to those made with Ancient-Creation Magic, fashioned in the form of Bahamut using Hydealyn's Ether-signature

  • @JeracotIII
    @JeracotIII 18 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    So a fun fact to go with this: We've had the "Primal code" for Hydaelyn since we got The Echo, thus a summoner could still technically form Solar Bahamut before her trial (which is mechanically also possible)

    • @lushdontu4015
      @lushdontu4015 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

      That's not how it works. You need to see the primals aether after it dies in order to summon it. The only reason we were able to summon bahamut was because his aether scattered all over eorzea.

  • @eji
    @eji หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    The Warrior of Light canonically has one hell of a wild imagination. 15:22 - I'm surprised you didn't mention the Eden raids, where the WoL's imagination makes the craziest versions of familiar primals. The Eden raids are basically foreshadowing the WoL SMN getting randomly inspired after the events of EW to start making their own thing, with... questionable results, lol. From a gameplay perspective though, I really wish it wasn't just another Bahamut because visually it's so goddamn boring to have another one.

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      The Eden raids explicitly mention that Eden is twisting the summons when being used as the focus for summoning.

  • @JynxdTea
    @JynxdTea หลายเดือนก่อน +9

    I personally wish, if this is accurate, that they had leaned more into it being Mom (Hydalean) and given summoner a dark counterpart to it to represent Zodiark.

  • @rei0
    @rei0 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    tbh I kind of wish summoner went in the direction picto has taken with the subtractive palette, with an astral summons rotation and an umbral one

    • @Poldovico
      @Poldovico หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      So Ifrit, Garuda, Ramuh then Titan, Leviathan, Shiva?

  • @tylerslittlecafe1288
    @tylerslittlecafe1288 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    Damn, that youtube recommend works quick

  • @CastorGaming
    @CastorGaming 24 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I love this idea because it lends itself so well to the established lore in very subtle ways. First, the "solar" part of the name makes perfect sense, not only as a counterpart to "Lunar Bahamut" but as the sun was the symbol of the Seat of Azem. The Warrior of Light is the current bearer of (the majority) of Azem's soul, and even Emet-Selch, Elidibus, and the shade of Hythlodeus mention recognizing your soul as Azem in Shadowbringers, before you even find out who you are.
    Additionally, the blue glow coming from Hydaelyn makes perfect sense as well. Not only because of how the Warrior of Light fought her, but because of how Hydaelyn relates to Azem. Hydaelyn was summoned by Venat, the previous occupant of the Seat of Azem. The wings being formed of fourteen blades, likely each representing the fourteen shards (possibly with the main body representing the source). There's the fact that Astral Impulse is changed to Umbral Impulse, and we know light (Hydaelyn's element) is umbrally aligned, thanks to Shadowbringers. And finally, Solar Bahamut's ultimate finisher is "Exodus", is the same name of Hydaelyn's big finisher move.
    Thank you for this video, and encouraging me to look into it a bit more. Before watching this, I was a bit indifferent to the idea of Solar Bahamut. But when put into the context of it being related to Hydaelyn, it makes far too much sense when you look into it. There's far TOO many tiny details that match up for it to not be.

  • @NobutakaFairclough
    @NobutakaFairclough 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wonderful video. The opening though? Peak. Very nicely done!

  • @basteala525
    @basteala525 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    I think that's a reasonable take. We already know summoners enter trance to invoke power of primals too powerful to create an egi of (this is what we do with Bahamut back in Heavensward). With the WoL's greater power from an 8th rejoining, it could be they can manifest a primal, in this case, Bahamut, but they're entering a Hydaelyn Trance while doing so. Swords were a part of her motif.

  • @NavaSDMB
    @NavaSDMB 29 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The knights definitely wanted a primal of shoulderpads.

  • @MrSpiderspider12
    @MrSpiderspider12 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Another example of WoL being their own person with defined thought and emotion is the Drk questline.
    We clearly see WoL's desires, fears, and traumas through Drk jo quests.

  • @torashiki5646
    @torashiki5646 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

    One thing is that Lunar Bahamut was not just astral/dark aspected, but also clearly Anima/Zodiark inspired, in-game.
    Solar Bahamut is, basically, a redemption of Bahamut. Its based on Hydaelyn, its based on the lore and feelings of the Apocryphal Bahamut quest, its based on the saving of Azdahja. Its basically an embodiment of the song of hope embodied by both the original Bahamut and the untainted Bahamut primal made by Tiamat's love.

  • @backslash4141
    @backslash4141 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The WoL, being from the source, has been "rejoined" with several shards of azem + one additional shard from the first making you very possibly the single most "complete" being outside of the unsundered ascians. Perhaps this means the WoL is beginning to gain access to the creation magics of the ancients, and that is how they were able to create solar bahamut?
    Solar bahamut is actually kinda cool now. Thanks for the explanation!
    On another note, this is a strong case for why it would be nice to see specific job quests again. Outside of the job itself and how/where you gain certain skills, they can add a lot of lore to the world and your own character.

  • @RockR277
    @RockR277 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    Okay but ya know who else is light aspected, flies, and uses glowing swords? Vauthry.
    Ain't blue, but the idea is funny to me so I'm rolling with it.

    • @dragonmangames2523
      @dragonmangames2523 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Fat Bahamut

    • @dumbsterdives
      @dumbsterdives หลายเดือนก่อน

      i mean, if solar bahamut was created using our understanding of hydaelyn and light as an element, sin eaters would likely come to mind in the process and potentially influence the form. so theres nothing saying our recollection of innocence couldnt be a factor!

    • @Nazuiko
      @Nazuiko หลายเดือนก่อน

      okay but you know else has wings, swords, and light aether theme? Even the ability to heal allies or shoot pulses of light?
      Paladin

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      Beautiful blue light > ugly piss "golden" light every day. (And that's why I prefer FF over other settings that always make light-elemental all gold-colored)
      No, this isn't a real response, just felt like bitching.

  • @-DeScruff
    @-DeScruff 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I like this! It makes perfect sense to me, that our summons would evolve based on our experience and thoughts on a the being we are attempting to create. That at some point you aren't limited to simply copying. Eventually you learn how to modify, and make something your own.

  • @LastMinWin
    @LastMinWin 13 วันที่ผ่านมา

    i like the juxtaposition of lunar bahamhut being born of twisted despair and solar bahamut being born of focused hope. I think you're spot on here.

  • @auraegis5286
    @auraegis5286 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I just did the mch quest where you get the first heated shot flip upgrade and they actually said it was developed by the other elf machinist during the fight with the dragons on the bridge like moments before its given to you. So at least the first flip was shown to you. You just really liked the ideal and improved on it from there.

  • @lanah_tyra
    @lanah_tyra 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Really love this explanation and as a summoner main, it all makes complete sense to me. Yes I would have loved to get new summons like a lot of us thought we would get, but I see Bahamut and I'm a happy girl. You know, like warrior mains are happy when they get to do another Fell Cleve. I think it was also influenced by our encounter with Tiamat. We learnt her grief and regret for calling forth the primal form of her beloved companion. In creating Solar Bahamut there might be a way for us to honour the noble dragon he was. Just like Hydaelin loved her people and the star, Bahamut loved his kin and was protecting them until the last. We get Lunar Bahamut on lvl100... and we all know what we are fighting for there in the MSQ.

  • @LoreSquid
    @LoreSquid หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    Machinist WoL: "I wanna do backflips and acrobatic jumps while going bang bang bang!"
    Me: "I'll fix that urge of yours with a mod or two, dear..."

  • @beatrixkaelin5120
    @beatrixkaelin5120 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    You're mostly right with where "Solar" Bahamut came from. Especially since we know Venat and of Azem. Azem's Celestrial Sign is the Sun. And while Venat does have that circle platform-like symbol related to her, it's also the defacto image we know of the "Blessing of Light." which has also been associated with the Warrior of light since before we knew who Venat was, and the symbol will most likely continue onwards with people still capable of worshipping Hydaelyn, which can still recreate the MotherCrystal in her place as it did the last time. Solar Bahamut is the embodiment of our desire to protect, which is why we also get Lux Solaris a massive healing spell, along with the stronger than Demi Bahamut's Enkindle, so my Supposition is that Solar Bahamut is totally our Concept, not inspired by anything else.
    And I do need to point out several things. Using the Encyclopedia Eorzea as reference has to come with the Caveat of the EEs being written in universe, with knowledge that may or may not be biased or flat out wrong. For instance, EE Vol1 still calls the Tribal Societies as Beastmen, even though it also recognizes them as Spoken just the same as other Races, which is something that has since changed in our external vernacular, but the book is still influenced by the in-world bias. Here's the proofs to disprove The Encyclopedia's account of Lunar Primals. First, Odin Has a *singular* Adherent, the Sundered, also known as the person who is holding the Zantetsuken (The actual Primal, the Man on the Horse isn't a Primal but the tempered who is changed into the Knight, it's the lore reason the Superboss changes each time he's killed). If there are no tempered, there's no one to summon a "Lunar Odin" but he surely existed, and was certainly killed on Carteneau. Secondly, the mind addled Arkasodara created Cinduruva Minduruva and Sanduruva, three primals who are not "Lunar" in any way shape or form, the same as 'the Anima of Garlemald' which while twisted in form, has no defined shape at all, and is the ensummoned butchered body of Varis. To me, this makes the case that the "Lunar" are actually molded from Fandaniel's own twisted desires, rather than those being controlled to summon them, allowing them to be created and moved to wherever Fandaniel wants, rather than simply protect the ones who summoned them. He certainly had a twisted mind, which could absolutely pollute and twist the image of those Primals for his own desires, even making a full on Odin, too.
    So where does this leave us now? Like you said, after a certain point, all jobstones have nothing left to give us, and I'd place that point at the last quest of their "Natural" Job questlines (All pre Shadowbringers quests for the jobs before Shadowbringers). No one else has ever shown Living Shadow as a DRK, Sidgurd flabbergasted that "Frey" could manifest in Stormblood even supports this. Every other Padjali White Mage uses Stone and aero spells (Even Kann-e in Endwalker uses Stone IV) while we bust out the Glares (We gained Glare in 72 in Shadowbringers). Monk Quests in Stormblood even point out how you've already diverged heavily from normal Monk moves. Not a single Samurai has the same large scale moves post 60 (Hien's limit break is Crush Weapon in Ghimlyt where as Lyse's Final Heaven and Yugiri uses Chimatsuri). I would go as far as saying for Summoner, since we have lore to back up the "Only 3 Egi" limit and Trance being the means to utilize power beyond our limit. But we can summon Demi-Bahamut (as of StormBlood), Demi-Phoenix (As of Shadowbringers), Ruby-Ifrit, Topaz-Titan, and Emerald-Garuda (as of Endwalker), which is 2 or 5 outside of the normal Summon limit. We're so far out of the standard that Solar Bahamut *has* to be our creation alone, no outside influence required.

    • @GayLPer
      @GayLPer หลายเดือนก่อน

      I would argue that we're still operating by normal Summoner limits.
      After all, it specifies three *Egis*. Egis not only contain some of the power of the primal it's spawned from, but its personality as well. A demi summon isn't an egi - it seems to be more like calling forth an echo of a primal, which makes it ephemeral in nature, and seem to be more extensions of our will. Though it still holds the usual caveat of us needing to be exposed to their aether.
      That being said, Solar Bahamut is probably *not* a demi summon - it is an all new creation of ours, drawn from the energies of Hydaelyn and formed by our experienced. And don't forget that our egis also evolve to contain the full power of the primals they were born from, coincidentally around the same time as in Endwalker where the Loporrits use creation magic to create uncorrupt primals from the faith of the tribes. I firmly believe that the implication is that being exposed to their aether again, in a much purer form, allowed us to evolve them in such a way. With that in mind, I'd propose that Solar Bahamut is, in fact, a full primal of our creation. Albeit... one that is pure of purpose, hungers not for power, and doesn't take more than it's given.

  • @mayfaynezzz
    @mayfaynezzz 29 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Oooooh, the idea of summoners using the Hydaelyns 'code' to create something new by combining it with a previous spell is so cool and also really emphasises the strength of WOL at this time of their journey.
    I had assumed it was the light exposure via hydaelyn that was involved, and as a bard player that was only reinforced with Radient Encore, which definitely also had Hydaelyn vibes. I am not sure if other classes have some light or hydaelyn flavoured touches, but it makes co plete aense to me considering how bog of an influence she is.
    I love when the story effects the attacks, or the attacks tell a story, like how during Shadowbringers, white mages spells immediately leaned more light based with glare and dia because of the available aether around them. It's super cool 😁

  • @Azdaja13
    @Azdaja13 27 วันที่ผ่านมา

    To add onto the mention of the Primals we summoned on The First, Solar Bahamut isn't too different from the Ramuh we summoned being merged with Ixion, or the Leviathan we summoned being merged with Thalaos and Perykos, just we created a Demi-Primal inspired by two different Primals. Not to mention the other example: Shinryu, which was directly inspired from Bahamut and Ilberd's trauma from the Calamity (and possibly from Midgardsormr himself). Also, from more of a series standpoint (not lore), Bahamut having lots of alternate forms is a bit of a Final Fantasy staple and it's also probably a little reference to Final Fantasy XVI's Bahamut being light-aspected.
    Also thank you for mentioning the lore book image since we've never truly seen the real Bahamut in-game. Real Bahamut would also have looked more like the other Great Wyrms (as in much longer and more slender) whereas the Primal version doesn't really resemble the other Great Wyrms much.

  • @Noah-gn2gu
    @Noah-gn2gu หลายเดือนก่อน

    There *is* one perfect primal: Esteem. Know yourself better than anyone.

  • @loofy530
    @loofy530 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The thought of passing the machinist discipline on new machinists and telling them that yes, the backflips are absolutely vital, is very funny to me.

  • @iamonthetube
    @iamonthetube หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    My god I love this video. You are so much more than a scribe. You have added to the lore better than the publisher. Thank you my friend.

  • @kooriicolada
    @kooriicolada 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

    After hearing the hydaelan theory before I came around to liking Solar Bahamut a lot more, and I think your explanation for how it exists is a good one.
    Whoever inherits the WoL Mch crystal is going to be in for a wild ride....

  • @vincentbeton
    @vincentbeton หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Thank you for making playing Level 100 Summoner more exciting with this Theory.
    I would guess that with Venat having been a former Azem, those similarities in personality traits might be another reason why the WoL could shape something related to her

  • @wakkaseta8351
    @wakkaseta8351 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Machinist jumping around and doing flips makes sense when you remember that the job was invented in the city of people who jump around and do flips. It also sets the job apart from Limsa's Musketeers.

  • @AlphaXXI
    @AlphaXXI หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I honestly think their biggest mistake was making it "a bahamut" when it comes to the reception. If you really didn't want to make Hydaelyn herself because of spoilers, I think making up a new summon that acts as a reinterpretation of her, with a different shape and name but the same references Solar Bahamut has, would have been a lot more appreciated, because there'd be less confusion. Plus now you have "two bahamuts + phoenix" as your demi trio, it makes Phoenix the odd one out of the bunch thematically, having the third, stronger demi something unique would have avoided that. Hopefully the next addition balances things out, I wouldn't mind a Lunar Phoenix, even if it wouldn't make sense with your lore reasoning. And I'm saying all this as someone who doesn't actively dislike Solar, it's a pretty cool design.

  • @icykuikinu6757
    @icykuikinu6757 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I absolutely love this perspective. A grievance I've had with summoner is how we don't have access to the last 3 elements (water, ice, lightning) and should be able to summon the primal energies of those 3 elements considering where we are now with our strength and discipline. Our storage of Aether has even bolstered substantially because of Ardbert as well, so thematically it would've made sense to have us summon the primals like Levi, Shiva, and Ramuh
    However, i love the idea that Solar Bahamut is that of our own willpower. This one being a testament to our own capability. Gameplay wise I personally wanted something a bit more involved than essentially being Bahamut with a heal, but thematically i think Solar is perfect (esp also Solar = Sun, sun emits light, we're the Warrior of Light, BOOM)

  • @supergamer1388
    @supergamer1388 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

    At a minimum, Solar Bahamut shows more innovation than most other Jobs' "same skill you already have, but bigger."

  • @Ludipolo
    @Ludipolo 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I feel like part of Solar Bahamut is mixture of Hydealyn as you mention but also a bit of us having a clearer understanding of who Bahamut was through our time with the other members of the first brood. We see Bahamut less as this villain or natural disaster and more as a tragic character who we wish we could have saved.

  • @DJ_Bonebraker
    @DJ_Bonebraker 23 วันที่ผ่านมา

    That whole thing about primals being shaped by the summoner's thoughts & feelings & such is how I came up with my personal theory about why the Eden primals summoned by the WoL were so different from their original forms: My pet theory is that, due to merging with Ardbert & becoming that much closer to their original Ancient self, the WoL was starting to subconsciously reconnect with some of Azem's original power, which resulted in them accidentally putting a bit to much pizazz on their summonings, as it were. One thing in-game that actually somewhat supports this theory is that the two Eden primals created after the player receives Azem's memory stone are much more true to their original forms, suggesting that the player has better control over Azem's powers as a result of the events of the 5.3 MSQ.
    This also ties into your own theories as to the origins of Solar Bahamut, especially with the knowledge gained about the Ancients & the events of Endwalker, which, IMO would result in even further mastery of their inherited Ancient powers (as evidenced by the increasing ease with which they wield Azem's power to summon allies to their side for certain battles).

  • @Kayem237
    @Kayem237 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I'm going to note that Bahamut is often considered to be a light-aspected summon or entity and you can see this especially in 16, which Yoshi-P brought a lot of the ideas of 14 into. So it's likely that the reason that Solar Bahamut is influenced by Hydaelyn is just because she's a more powerful source of light ether.
    Also, not every Warrior of Light actually has been to the first one. Anyone that was made in 2.0 is never really considered to be the same character as the one from the initial cutscene. However, summoners do deal with getting attuned to Bahamut's aether in the early job quests when Dreadwyrm Trance was introduced.

  • @UltimegaSeven
    @UltimegaSeven 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Another reason why we need job quests of some kind at max level. Even if it doesnt progress the story, something to tie in the skills or update old friends about our progress.

  • @NiraSader
    @NiraSader หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I like this especially for WoLs who have not been there for Dalamud’s fall, so mine’s just going off what she saw at the coils and bringing in a little individual flair.

  • @8BitCerberus
    @8BitCerberus หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Another piece to support the theory, there are 14 swords making up the wings. Could just be a coincidence, but given the sigil and aetherial resemblance, it seems pretty intentional to me.

    • @Nazuiko
      @Nazuiko หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Honestly looking at Hydaelyn's own wings up close, they do look rather like swords. And of course, Venat herself loved conjuring up weapons of all kinds.

  • @MrBloodriver
    @MrBloodriver หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    "Did you heard story about a boy and dragon Gay?"

  • @AshP210
    @AshP210 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Not gotten Solar Bahamut myself, but my thought on it was that in going to the Alexandrian reflection our connection to Bahamut's recognised Aether managed to pick up a similar creature from their world.
    And taking your belief into account, I would say that the "bahamut" we picked up there was light-aspected and so it essentially merged in concept with the only light-based primal we've met to create Solar Bahamut, thus why it has heavy Hydaelin influence in its design.

  • @EdumBot
    @EdumBot หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    It's funny you mention Solar's magic circles but not Exodus. Literally Exodus. It's an olive branch towards Divine Light Trance, no question.
    There's some thoughts I wanna throw in haphazardly about SMN in general. And I hope I'm not misremembering stuff here.
    - At the end of 6.0, I was completely convinced the next trance would be Eternal Darkness Trance, as all conditions for it have been met resoundingly. The Source is still actively being showered with His Darkness, as... the FSH questline in Sharlayan mentions, of all things. Less so for Hydaelyn, but we can say using the Mothercrystal sufficed to spread Her aether.
    - Don't quote me on this, but I'm pretty sure a Demi is summoned by infusing any Egi with the drawn-in aether of a trance, for a short period of time. I don't have an encyclopedia to check that, nor do we have supplementary quests for Demi summons. We can blatantly ignore spoiler reasons and just say Hydaelyn and Zodiark are too powerful to summon Demis of and/or no Egi could withstand being infused with their aether.
    - The conditions for a trance differ from that for binding an Egi. For a trance, you "only" need to draw from a primal's residual aether. You don't have to fight the primal, hence why Urianger can use Firebird Trance. For an Egi, the SMN has to have participated in its slaying, then go to a place that matches the primal's aether, summon it and subdue the Egi in combat. That needs to happen for all Egis, no ifs or buts.
    - Any given SMN is limited by their aether in how many Egis can be bound. For the WoL, that limit happens to be three. A longstanding misconception is that people think everyone is limited to three Egis. Trances were conceived to go around this aetheric limit and still harness primal power(s).
    - Based on Enkindle II, we can surmise the WoL decided to further enhance/refine Ifrit-, Titan- and Garuda-Egi, instead of binding another one. Alternatively, the WoL is still not capable of binding a 4th and that's the next best thing.
    - I understand people want Sapphire Leviathan, Diamond Shiva and Amethyst Ramuh. But as I mentioned before, this isn't so easily done for lore reasons and you can spit venom and grating insults at me as much as you want. It doesn't change. HOWEVER, there is a super simple and even better workaround for this debacle - Egi glamour.
    All we need is one more quest, either from the Arcanist Guild Master or Y'mithra, to glamour the refined Enkindle II summons to literally anything else. That way, we could go further than just the ARR primals. The writers wouldn't have to be burdened with rewriting, the quest people wouldn't have to work on solo instance quests and... well the artists and devs will have to supply icons, vfx, sfx and animations, but that's the least problematic thing.

    • @SAI-Max_D
      @SAI-Max_D หลายเดือนก่อน

      Perhaps I'm overlooking and/or misunderstanding something both here and from the Eden raids-given my lack off knowledge in the aetheric arts-but would it be possible for an experienced summoner to place their egis under a trance?
      (e.g. having Titan Egi undergo a Leviathan Trance to trigger a mudslide for the purpose of drawing-in a group of enemies, or infusing Ramuh's lightning into Ifrit's Crimson Strike to create a superheated bolt of plasma)

  • @Kaelin_Stereo
    @Kaelin_Stereo 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Another example of the WoL's creativity coming into class quests: pictomancer.
    You learn about the Moogle because of Relm. Everything after that is your own interpretation of what you can do with the power. Iterating on the basics to create something new, like the Madeen or the Starry Landscape.

  • @Adicon_
    @Adicon_ หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Beginning: lol sure man
    Middle: ehhh maybe I guess
    End: WTF ITS THE CRYSTAL THING???? I AM A TRUE BELIEVER!!

  • @gammenday
    @gammenday หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Great vid, especially the beginning bit lmao. After playing as SMN at max level, it made me think that the devs missed an opportunity to bring in new egis by implementing alternate egis in the transition phases between Solar Bahamut, Regular Bahamut and Phoenix. It could have been for ex. Solar Bahamut -> Egi1, Egi2, Egi3; Reg Bahamut -> Titan, Ifrit, Garuda; Phoenix -> Leviathan, Shiva, Ramuh. Each new egi could still act similarly as the 3 egis we already have, just with different graphics to give uniqueness to that egi, like Garuda's range being the template for Ramuh dealing lightning strikes and leaving a levin field dot. Anything could've been possible, like introducing egis for Ravana, Bismark or even the Triple Triad. If these egis would come in out of nowhere by the devs, they would eventually obtain reason of being from the playerbase that enjoy it.

  • @Guran.M
    @Guran.M 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Soooo in short..
    CONGRATS SUMMOMERS ON YOUR NEW CHILD, Your own sweat and tears birthed by your own aether.

  • @Spyrit2011
    @Spyrit2011 หลายเดือนก่อน +22

    I just want Shiva, Ranuh, and Leviathan.

    • @Nazuiko
      @Nazuiko หลายเดือนก่อน

      Shiva and Alex are common asks, but I dont think theyd really work due to the nature of them within XIV's lore. Sure it COULD, the developers can do whatever they please, but it seems distinctly unlikely.
      Ramuh or perhaps some other entity are long overdue, that I will agree. And I was certain in the Benchmark it would be Ramuh, given the apparently lightning ability, which would also fit well with the theme of Dawntrail

    • @Zoeila
      @Zoeila หลายเดือนก่อน

      Sorry you can't it's a lore break established back in HW

    • @Zoeila
      @Zoeila หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@Nazuiko we tried to summon ramuh egi in HW and it failed because there's a limit to how many primal elements you can attune too

    • @deadzedwalking1346
      @deadzedwalking1346 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@Zoeila Well lore for smn doesn't matter now that solar bahamut is just a lore asspull in the game so they can easily disregard the lore for that :P

    • @DantoriusD
      @DantoriusD หลายเดือนก่อน

      Wait for 8.0 and the 123th smn Rework 😂

  • @Torterror1
    @Torterror1 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Adding on to that, its heavily implied that everything after lvl 70/the job quests is the WoL developing their own techniques/abilities. White Mage's offensive magics going from earth and wind to unaspected umbral magic being probably the most obvious example but also phoenix and the demi-primal evolutions of the egi summons are already well outside the scope of what the summoner job quests were.

  • @Bayleaf6399
    @Bayleaf6399 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Ive always imagined that Solar Bahamut is the result of our exposure to Hydaelyn. It stands to reason that our WoL as a Summoner would be skilled enough to creat this summon using Hydaelyn's essence

  • @ChaosDX1
    @ChaosDX1 24 วันที่ผ่านมา

    As much as I respect the decision to switch to role quests instead of job quests, what I wouldn't give for a 10-second cutscene of our WoL going over dusty tomes and suddenly having an epiphany, sketching out blueprints for the Automaton Queen, or twirling your weapon experimentally as a thought begins to form.

  • @meggerrsss
    @meggerrsss หลายเดือนก่อน

    i've always felt that Azem is solar-aspected, and it shows with azeyma being a fire based / sun-like goddess, so it stands that Venat and therefore Hydaelyn would as well. ties in well too with Zodiark being yknow, trapped on the moon

  • @pixiesnakes4293
    @pixiesnakes4293 29 วันที่ผ่านมา

    My canon is that WoL did indeed tried to summon Hydaelyn but with creation magics and it's successor the summoning being so incredibly difficult to achieve exactly your desired outcome, it mingled with Bahamut's image and the WoL was like "meh. close enough"

  • @dazzlemasseur
    @dazzlemasseur หลายเดือนก่อน

    I wish you voiced solar bahamut going "hmm i guess this is okay then"

  • @aSmolGoth
    @aSmolGoth หลายเดือนก่อน

    Solar Bahamut is in the name: solar is generally referred to as a source of light. We are the Warrior of Light. Solar Bahamut's abilities, on top of that, are lux (a measurement of luminance) and umbral (which we know light belongs to) and sunflare (again, a source of light). The only thing that is weird is exodus, but given how we liberate the universe of Endsinger's song of destruction, this could be a reference to leading the people from darkness/the end. All of this to say, Solar Bahamut is most definitely the WoL's being shining through. As for Venat's magic circles, we ARE a shard of the one who bore the seat of Azem (which if I remember correctly, is a sun symbol). We technically have access to this as well, given we have the aether for it. I won't rule out that maybe Venat has some influence, but I'm saying it could also just be us being ... the warrior of LIGHT. It's hard to tell where her influence ends and where we begin because we exist because of her (literally; she created us beings as well as we are her chosen champion, granting us the Warden's Blessing).
    EDIT: Since I was going through some other lore videos: "Strong art thou mortal. Stronger than any other of thy kind. Having looked upon thy deeds, I am convinced. Thou art worthy to bear Her light." -Midgardsormr, Heavensward 3.0, Fetters of Lament, Cutscene #5

  • @Apollad2
    @Apollad2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I mean... Summon Hydaelyn would be a pretty massive spoiler in the spellbook to a newbie playing Arcanist and Summoner, if they pay attention to the lore. 'Why the !@#$ do we get to summon the planet?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!'

  • @DracoSuave
    @DracoSuave 29 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Regarding the Heated shots and their moves, it is confirmed during the Stormblood quest chain (when those abilities were introduced) that the WoL has been making up their own techniques and is teaching it to the new generation of machinists including Joy and Hilda.
    It's true of -every- job ability you don't learn from a Crystal, and even a few that have that animation. Dragoon invented all its abilities since Heavensward for example.
    As for it being connected to Hydaelyn... yeah, obviously.
    Luxwave is just a rename for Lightwave and SB's ult is Exodus, which is Hydaelyn's ult. Guy's got Hydy moves.

  • @celestial_illusions
    @celestial_illusions หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    it makes perfect sense for the WoL to be insanely extra, if all the rumors in elpis about azem are anything to go by.

  • @yrsa7637
    @yrsa7637 23 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    They need to give us more variety of summons... one day maybe teehee :(

  • @jonesdaevilone
    @jonesdaevilone หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Well this is my new head cannon.. so freaking cool, just wish there was a quick jobquest to go along with it