Addition to the Video After reading some comments I realized that I have totally missed out on a number of tolls plazas we have Vs other countries have. If I talk about Western countries they have way fewer toll roads in comparison to India, almost every plain surfaced road in India is a toll road which is not the case in countries like the USA, hence, many of their commuters don't even take toll roads as their free roads are already quite decent also, In Europe even though there are countries where you have to pay tolls. but again even European countries have far fewer toll roads than India, For example, in Switzerland the only toll their computers pay is for a couple of tunnel roads..
Very good information. But just a small correction. USA also has the automatic toll deduction mechanism where you don't need to wait in the line. But it also has gate based system in areas like airport. Those are also automatic.
The Indian taxation system is a Joke on middle class tax payers. Whether it's Income Tax or Purchasing a new car. No matter which government is in power. Everyone will talk about the poor or rich. The middle class exists only for paying Taxes in 100 different ways for both the classes.
No, pay up your taxes, and then vote. Wonder how countries are still Third Word, or become Third World like the US (shocked?). They don't pay their taxes! So, pay up and hold the government to account at the elections. Did you bother to vote? 1/3 of voters in Bharat did not.
Not a sparkle toll tax. The roads are still not good & full of pits & jerky repair. But it's a very good cartal of Ministers. NHAI, & Road & toll companies
Greedy people always want things for free, even in rich countries like the UK, so the greedy desperate people of Bharat are no different. Pay up or enjoy the pot-hole rat infested dirt roads for free, for a while, before the rains wash them away.
@@VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhu already Indians pay a king's ransom of taxes and still there's not a single strip of road that's not broken. Usually guys who give lectures on paying taxes are the biggest freeloaders and burden.
Middle class waale india me bass cheated feel karte hain . Desh ka poora bojh hum par , aur humko milta hai thenga . We give tax not for our benefit but for the charity .
हम जितना अपने आप को साफ समझते हैं उतने साफ नहीं है हममें से ही कोई सरकारी अधिकारी बनता है ओर फिर भ्रष्टाचार करता है हममें एकता भी नहीं है किसी अपराधी के विरोध खड़े होने कि
Asli muddo ke bajay jati dharm ki rajniti krne ka theka bhi to middle class ne hi le rkha hai bhai...gareeb ko revdi mil hi jati hai or Ameer ko upr ki malai...
कृपया,इस टोल टैक्स सिस्टम को विदेशों से तुलना करते समय प्रति व्यक्ति आय और जीडीपी का भी ध्यान रखना होगा और भारतीय परिस्थितियों के अनुरूप ही , व्यावहारिक रूप से टोल टैक्स का निर्धारण भी होना चाहिए,,,31 किलोमीटर की यात्रा का 115/- टोल भुगतान क्या औचित्यपूर्ण है? सरकार का उद्देश्य केवल जनता का खून चूसना ही होता है,,,चाहे वित्त मंत्री, परिवहन मंत्री, और चाहे प्रधानमंत्री ही क्यों न हों,,,,
Bro I’m living in Australia & Here, you don’t need to pay the toll for long motorways. Like Melbourne to Syney is approx 1000km stretch & there is no toll. You need to pay toll in local city only just to avoid traffic. Second, there is toll rebate schemes, if you cross the particular limit than you can apply for toll rebate at the end of year. Moreover, there is not toll barriers.
That's why I am going to shift there in few months.....even though they have higher taxes but the facilities they are providing is top notch and worthy to pay
Bikes 28% + Registration Cement 31% AC 28% Tolls: Hadd se jyada aur an-ginat taxes + Income tax as well Consumer products costly hote hai but accordingly income tax slabs mai changes nahi hote.
@@surajtomar4870 Wow hai lekin billionaires itne smart hai ki woh apna net money bohot Kam rakhte hai. Aur unko har tax avoidance ka tarika jante hai. Apple ke CEO Tim Cook ki salary toh normal hai but woh stock billions ke hold karte hai. They're not rich cuz they know how to become, They're rich cuz they know how to stay rich.
@@prateekpanwar646 Right and that's why we hear about things like "CEOs taking 1 ruppe salary" . That's a money laundering pro max in a legal way. But only available to billionaires.
Per capita income of France is ₹ 39 lakhs while in India per capita income is just ₹ 2 lakhs. So we can not compare France toll tax with Indian Toll tax.
@thecomment9489 Also consider the average highway speeds, 120kmph vs 47kmph. Also, this PPP logic is bullshit because for Westerners the cost of a car is very low, whereas Indians spend years of savings on it.
Ghatkari ko hata do sab theek ho jai ga besharamo ki tar ha bolta hai road chahiye to tol dena pade ga phir RTO tax 2000, 3000 lo ya lo hi mat they fucking people fucking hole country and we fuckedup
Middle-class and Rich Middle-class pay taxes like hell in India, but 90% amount goes into the pockets of MPs, MLAs, Government bodies and Government employees also most tax rules are not followed by government employees. Also, remember the high fuel cost.
90% aapne jyada bol diya 20%- 30% k around tax ka corruption mei jata hai paisa .uske alava rishwat ka paisa lete hai yeh direct logo se. uska bada kaaran yeh hai kyunki mla,mp ko ticket k liye mota Paisa Dena padta hai. And party is paise ko election campaign mei bahut bade level par kharch karti hai. Jis din yeh election par Paisa lagna band ho jayega . Us din se shayad corruption kam ho jaye.
Toll tax to theek hai par itna toll tax dene par bhi roads acche nahi hote h mostly roads par aur koi b acchi service provide nahi karte h NHAI wale Travellers ko.
Bhai toll tax bus National Highway pr hota hai . Our Highways are very good . Local roads aapki state ke mla or cm ke under aati hai . Unpar ni lagta toll tabhi wo gandi hoti hai
Ribbon Development ना हो Planned Development हो इसके लिए सरकार Expressway के आसपास Planned Development करने कि कोशिश कर रही है - उत्तर प्रदेश ओर Local Municipality से प्रशन पुंछे तो चीजें ज्यादा जल्दी बेहतर होगी
@@Vab462Kabhi mauka mile to NH130 me chal kar dekhe.....! कार उछलती हुई चलती है , कभी अचानक उछलने से सिर अगर कार की छत से ना टकरा जाय , तो कहना ।।।। 370 k.m. के हाईवे में 100 k.m. 6 लेन है , बाकी 2 लेन हाईवे है ।।। 7 बार toll tax भी भरने पड़ते हैं ।।। कार उछालने के ।।।।
I think 1 more point should be, the amount of vehicle in India is also very high as I just googled and found: French-40mil~ whereas India-350mil~ approx.. so India's tolls should get more money so they should charge less.
Any proof for your statement? IRCC is the official maker of roads for NHAI. Not any specific lobby, regardless, we only pay an average of Rs.3 per km. Think again.
@@brockrumlow debt of nhai % increase kitna hai any idea? Gadgari ji ke driver ke naam jo company thi uska shayad kuch pata nahi chala right. Dost daal kaali hai grey bhi nahi hai
Corruption ek bohot hi important role play karta hai roads ke mamle main. Kyun ki agar road pehli baar main hi acchi quality ki banayi jaye to kam se kam 10-15 saal tak usko kuch nhi hoga. Lekin humare idhar to corruption ki vajah se bohot hi ghatiya quality ki roads banayi jati hai. Jisko ye log har saal banate hai. Kayi baar pipeline ya cable beechane ke naam pe unko khoda jata hai. Aur ye baar baar road banane ki vajah se unginat paise ki barbadi hoti hai jo paisa kisi aur cheez ke liye istemal kiya ja sakta hai. Aur ye paisa jata to public ki jeb se hi hai to log aur ghussa hote hai kyunki ye sab charo or khule aam ho rha hai. Agar pehli baar main hi ye sheher ya gaon ke roads acchese banaye jaye to bacha hua paisa highways ke maintenance ke liye istemal ho sakta hai jisse toll kam kiya ja sakta hai.
Bhai sahi Keh rahe hoon Kuch bhi kaho lekin toll bahut zyada agar aap delhi se haridwar bhi jau tab bhi 450 rupay toll Dena padta hai aur km sirf 193 hao
@@No_one_is_above_time tumhe shayad pata nahi ki food grains tumhare ghar tak kaise pahuch te hai. Aapke kitchen me jo ingredients hain, kam se kam 10 states se aaye huae hai. Bina ache roads ke, ya toh woh mahenge padenge, ya phir khareedne ko hi nahi milega.
Govt for last 5 years have installed toll plazas in roads that were built almost 15 to 20 years ago. And no maintenance is being done on this road and now there are 3 toll plazas in 150 km stretch of road built almost 15 years ago before there was only one toll plaza. Does govt wants toll revenue from road built 15 years ago
If the govt was run by the three champion commenters here, they would have built 30k kms of free expressways, paid salaries of 17k workers till retirement and filled a million potholes with the 16,700/- vehicle tax you paid in 2011. And yet you choose Mudi ze rejin pls over them😢
One of the issue is the lack of transparency how these funds are used , many of the times they keep charging the toll tax even after they have made profits. 2. You need to factor in the amount of vehicles passing beach day. Yes the amount is less than other countries but the amount or number of cars passing by is much higher. 3. No accountability, if there's a fault no one fixes it immediately. The crux of the problem is people do not mind paying money but it should be at par with level of services being delivered , rather than making contractors rich
Not under the Chinese governance model. In China their citizens enjoy first world living standards in third world prices. That's why approval ratings for their government is 95%. Inflation rate in China hovers around 1%.
You forgot one point, we have more population, more vehicles. number of people paying per km rs is 20, 30 times more than these countries. We pay more taxes on other things.. so these comparisons will not work
One injustice in India is that, Alto and Mercedes pays same toll tax even though the impact of both the cars on road is vastly different, the toll tax should be based on the engine capacity or weight of the vehicle
Good video sir..... I ride my car daily 40-50 kms....going on highway is rare for me....like 1 time in 3 months so i don't feel burden of toll taxes ....
दूसरे देशों में गाड़ी भी सस्ती है और तेल भी। उसे भी equation डालना चाहिए। गाड़ी पर ज्यादा टैक्स लगाना ठीक है अगर public transport पे सरकार ध्यान देती हो जोकि भारत सरकार नहीं कर रही।
You forgot Consider to compare per capita income , the income of truck drivers in US vs india, the price. One packet chips price in india - 20 rupee, in us - 500 rupee. Chepest car in india- 4lac, in Us - 14lac.
Point from my side. if the quality of roads improves drastically. Complaints shall come down significantly. There are certain new roads. That are not good in quality. That makes us the users questioning why do we pay so much when the service is not nearly as good.
Pay Direct Taxes & Get rid from Indirect Taxes But it should be done by all or atleast almost - Citizens Less than 10 % pay Direct Tax then it's obvious Government has to find indirect ways to Collect How can Government Run Corruption is because of both Government & People People are No Saint
@@Priyaykanth2 people are corrupt by nature what political system should do is to set an Example like lal bahadur shastri. When government can put hindu muslim agenda as the core instinct of vast majority of people why not honesty?
The guy earning 5 to 20 lakh in this country bears the most burnt.... doesn't get good government schools and healthcare even after paying direct tax, let alone other indirect ones...
Cattle on roads is a very unique Indian phenomenon and must be declared a UNESCO cultural heritage of India. LOL. Well any there is hardly any difference between the cattle on Indian roads and the rabble.
Also compare their neat - clean and jam free roads with public facilities to our bad bad roads. Toll tax amount is really high and toll staff also very irresponsible
I completely agree with you regarding this matter, makes a good road takes strong action on stray animals and removes the road tax while buying new vehicle.
Your videos are automobile related but you talk about every segment of automobile ...very versatile and informative, Thanx for made such type of videos....
tbh man, what I loved about this video is the approach, the way you supported the govt. for the right things and also mentioned the how govt taking tax through other medium for the same very thing, and you were completely unbiased, maybe now a days its kinda rare thing
I lived in Dallas for 6 years. We drive at 120kmph and the toll gets deducted from the toll tag without stopping. Also, there's no need for GPS in your vehicles. Entry and exit gates can calculate distances and deduct toll accordingly (that's also at 100kmph). In India, why does the govt want to put trackers in our cars? Huge violation of citizens privacy.
I am travelling from delhi to Kolkata since 2012 i have seen many things changing and some of the things not. First the toll tax distance is not uniform sometimes we have pay on 2 different toll booths in 80km or sometimes for 200 km And then the prices. The price for worst road was around 120 for 40km And for best road around 100 for 50 km Another thing for me is why you dont penalized for overloaded trucks because of them roads got damaged. Also we should start taking toll tax from 2 wheelers also as seen of yamuna expressway agra Lucknow expressway because of them also we get disturbed and couldn't maintain speeds But yeah previously our travel time was more than nowadays thanks to better road qualities. But there should be uniformity on toll distance and should be taken from all types of vehicles
Your selection of topics are becoming interesting day by day, keep up the good work buddy. I would like to add one more point though, that is the average speed in Indian highways and the US. For a distance of around 1,500 km (Delhi to Mumbai) it takes 24 hours but on the flipside the same distance in US (Los Angeles to Portland) can be covered within 16 hours which is way less. From my POV if I'm saving 50 percent of the time in an expressway on the route that I'm travelling, I'll not have any issue paying the current toll rates but it doesn't feel beneficial to pay tolls on normal highways which are full of local traffic, barricades, stray animals. Hopefully the travel time will reduce drastically in about 5-10 years when most tier one, two cities will be connected through expressways.
Very good informative video. I am not against road toll tax but I want : 1. Flawless toll roads ( most of them have very bad patches which damage low profile tyres). 2. Waiting time at toll gates should be reduced considerably (which is possible but maybe expensive) 3. Reduce road tax on new vehicles.
If you are paying 30% income tax, don't call yourself middle class. You will have to earn 7-8 lakh per month to pay 30% income tax. Someone earning 3 lakh per month pays ~20% income tax under new tax regime.
@@tusharaggarwal9956 aye Bhai, you'll only need to make 15 lakhs annually to qualify for the 30% tax bracket under the new regime and 10 lakhs per annum under the old regime. Thoda padh likh lo yaar
@@MozaffarMansoor My monthly salary is 1.72 lakh and I am in new tax regime, yes I am in 30% tax bracket but that isn't imposed on complete income, 30% applies on income above 15 lakh annually. So, overall my tax liability is 14.5%
@@tusharaggarwal9956 yaar using your logic, nobody truly will give exactly 30% tax. Even a 7 lakh a month making fellow will only start paying 30% after 15 lakhs. He'll fall close to 30% but never exactly 30. But I digress and on a factual level you're even right but mudda ye hai ki ek normal life jeene ke liye with a family you'll need about 2 to 2.5 lakhs a month salary jiski tax new dhajji uda Deni hai. A significant chunk of this salary will be taxed at 30% and any and all bonuses over this will fall in the 30% tax bracket itself. Let's work with an example You live in Mumbai and make 2 lakhs a month in a family of 4. Your rent goes to about 40k for a 2bhk, and other expenditures (electricity, food, travel, school, fuel) make up 50k a month, you've purchased a house on a loan and are paying 30k a month as installments - this will come out to about 14.5 lakhs annually that you need to exist in a decent condition. Any saving you do will only be after this amount. But all of that amount is being taxed at 30%, essentially all your savings. And then everything that you are purchasing is also being taxed at different rates. Any profit you make on your savings will also be taxed at 30%, any increment, bonus, lottery, or profit from sale of property will also be taxed further. You're right when you say that tax liability isn't 30%, but there's nuance to the idea of what is being taxed and how much. I hope you appreciate the intricacies of it
India is the most affordable and least taxed country on an overall basis in the entire world. From insurances to mobile tariffs to food, human labour, electricity, medicines almost everything is fairly affordable. It’s just that more hands depend on your money right now. Over the time that generation goes away and every person in the family will be independent. Wait for it.
Amazing analysis. Your PPP analysis was spot-on to conclude that Indians pay equal to developing nations. Road Tax, on the other hand, is a HUGE burden on Car owners. This can be reduced significantly if not eliminated. The third, and MOST important aspect, is the PATHETIC Road Construction, Corruption, and Negligence. India has some of the HIGHEST Road accidents for developing nations. Here RTO is partly responsible for HUGE Corruption. The Potholes alone, claim thousands of lives each year. Financial Audits reveal local Municipalities spend THOUSANDS PER POTHOLE, but the conditions keep deteriorating. Here overloading and rash driving are the primary causes, which points finger to Corrupt Traffic Police officials.
I think road tax should be slashed in India. Considering that you are paying good price for toll tax and if the roads are not in good shape you are paying afterwards for maintenance.
4:55 - one thing you failed to mention, public transport is so good in Japan that you don't need cars, while travel without car is impossible in india.
@@MrXperx By that logic unless you are doing manual labour you aren't doing something productive. Learn what productive means before throwing in words you know little about and learn how modern economy works. You should have foresight to see how many jobs are replaceable by AI and robots.
Bro, people are already paying many taxes. Some might disagree but this is the case. For those, who are gonna reply me, hear me first You are already paying income tax, that is 20-30% ( if you are middle class it's mostly around 30), the goods you are gonna buy have gst included ( by the way the seller is also paying some tax depending on the sales too), petrol price which is ₹100/l (it's actual base price is only half of that), toll tax, road tax, if you selling your house (on which you already have paid your tax) you need to pay tax again etc etc etc. (Sorry comments have word limits, can't use it all) For those who are gonna say, where the government is gonna get money from, Government has it's own companies set up which actually do generate profits, it even has shares in the companies and many more, but even if they do need to collect, this many? I mean we are getting facilities for that like education ( lowest education standard in government school, lack of medical colleges etc), hospitals ( covid has already shown enough- oxygen tanks), roads ( what's that? Forget local roads, I have seen dangerous potholes on a highway, a fucking highway which is supposed to have high speed vehicles on it), Security that is police (Do I need to say this?). For those who are thinking ki more tax= more development, that is true but in a competent system. Yaha agar koi ek baar pradhan ban jaae toh uski next 2 generation ko kaam karne ki jarurat nhi padti, think about MLAs, CMs etc. So whats the point of giving more money to a govt which is a bottomless pit of greed 😂😂😂
28 to 200% non creditable gst on new car purchase, high road tax, 300% non creditable GST and excise on petrol and diesel, highest car insurance ... And then salt ( tolltax) on wounds.
I recently did a road trip from Pune - Kodiakanal - Ooty - Pune. In total we paid ₹3500 in tolls for a journey of roughly 3100kms. So it cost us around ₹0.88/km.
Cost of everything is more in developed countries. Right from milk, groceries to dental and medical treatment. A root canal treatment in India costs around 2-7k on an average whereas it can cost around 1lakh in developed countries. Same with salaries paid to multinational corporate employees in India as compared to west. That is Purchasing power parity.
Absolutely Yes to the Title of the Video..! I factor in the toll cost when claiming my travels for work... when driving within 500 kms radius of Hyderabad... and it's no joke... hyderabad to Vijayawada, Nagpur, Bangalore they all cost a lot... Yes the roads are good...
Also... you are missing the point when discussing cost... you need to consider the cost of ownership as opposed to cost of acquisition... because we are a democracy and most consumer have choices...
You don't understand PPP, stop peloing gyan. PPP is extremely unreliable because it is only useful when you have something completely sourced locally. Involvement of tech and automation reduces difference in PPP massively because machines costs same everywhere.
28℅ GST bhi du, high toll tax bhi du , kya milta hai is sarkar se! Sirf bhashan? Bahar desh se compare karte ho, france, japan k jaisa hume social security, world class healthcare milta hai?
Congress ka time me desh ko luta gaya he uska varpai kon karega.... Amm janta ke dwara varpai ho rahahe na or Government tumko free ka medical, Rashen de rahahe wo kiu lete ho
@@patelraj3335 bhai gujrat ka healthcare WB k samne kuch bhi nehi hai. Idhar top to bottom pura free hai from tests to chemo for cancer patients. Waise bhi tera state mein toh mostly neet ka leak karwake doctors bante hai , really feel sad for Gujarati peoples.
@@navigatorprashant buddy its not free, a gst of 28℅ is not free, people are paying direct and indirect taxes whereas in terms of benifits of govt people are getting peanuts.
Like you approach of being neutral and calling a spade a spade.. Have been a sub for quite some time and I always leave a like.. today i decided to leave a comment also to please youtube mama
Indians don't want to pay taxes in India but same Indian happily pays taxes in Germany and Singapore. It's all about return of investment thing. If they are paying taxes there they are actually getting benefitted from that. But here we get almost no or very less out of the taxes we pay at each step of our lives. Hn India mei log direct tax kam bharte h. Pr hn log India mei indirect tax bhut jyada bharte h... Even on education, healthcare, and salt. Hn wahi salt jiske liye dandi March Tak hogya tha ki is pr se taxes hatao..aaj wo taxed h.
@@akhripasta2670 bro we are still paying a lots of taxes. Get your economics more stronger, we have one of the highest taxes in indirect ways. You can check anywhere from education, road tax, petrol or etc.
That's exactly what happens when for 60years half the population don't had access to toilet, no sewage treatment plant, no roads, no railway electrification NOTHING!!!. Kashmr valley & some North East got their first railway in last 3 years. We are paying high taxes because we are catching up.
How much toll has nitinji paid for toll? He says for good roads you need to pay then how much are these babus and netas paying. I want all these freeloaders to pay tax from their income, only then i will be okay to pay toll.
Till we have at least 10% of our population (like in China) in the tax bracket this is going to be the case, unfortunately - right now its about 2%. So we need to collectively think as to how we can collectively increase the income prospect of our countrymen. Be it startups, MSME, Services etc. Just govt jobs are not going to help. And blaming the govt for such huge taxes is unproductive - we all know that and the govt also knows. Our ask of lower taxes and higher quality of living when only 2% of the people is paying tax is criminal. Can we, collectively, come up with creative solutions?
2:27 per capita income भी देख लो फ्रांस का औसत आदमी भारत से 6.8 गुना कमाता है, अगर उनके टोल टैक्स को 6.8 से भाग दें तो ये संख्या 1.4 आती है मतलब वो हमसे आधा टैक्स देते हैं। और वहां पेट्रोल, गाडी पर अंधा टैक्स नहीं लगता, भारत की तरह..
I travel 200kms one side to Delhi, diesel costs somewhere around ₹800-1000 but the toll tax is 500/-. We pay almost 85% in taxes on day to day basis. Plus developed countries have a great public transportation system.
Indian per capita income - USD 3300 India has direct + indirect taxes. Indua has 42% tax on cars. Europe has per capita - USD 50,000 No indirect taxes. Full free education and health facility. What Gadkari talking about paying is to private contractors. NHAI gets peanuts from toll tax. Most of it is extortion for private accounts.
not sure about other countries, In the USA, Toll roads are not compulsory, You always have a way to get to the same destination with the same road quality, only a time difference. Please check it once.
Toll employees will not follow the 3min rule but they will obey 1 rule "Fasttag me recharge nahi hai ab apko cash me 2 times more toll dena padega" Also, I am glad the right profile is getting noticed. Hope every Indian & every official can see your videos which perfectly pinpoint the pain of every commuter.
I am taking a car delivery tomorrow. Here is some break-up of cost: Dealer price : 13L Showroom price: 19L On-road price : 22.8L Actual Cost of ownership: 30.5L (22.8L + 30% income tax + 4% cess) Total Tax: 6L(CGST+SGST+CESS) + 2.3L RTO = 8.3L Already paid income tax: 7.7L(on on-road price) Total Tax: 16L(Not considering GST on insurance, accessories, consumables etc.) I still need to pay toll. Funny, isn't it? By the way Bharat's PPP is 22, that means actual value of $1 is not 80-85 INR but 22 INR. So 2.2 INR per KM is same as 10 cents.
Taxes are each & every where specially in Maharashtra , w bengal. Government doesn't give damn i know infra needs money but charging 30rs on each liter of petrol seriously
But except a few newly developed toll highways. Most of the toll roads are in pathetic condition. I commute regularly on NH-8 Delhi-Jaipur highway. You'll never find this highway in good condition, most of the time it is full of potholes and after rain it becomes a mess. With potholes and most of the highway submerged under water. There are illegal intersections everywhere. You can never go at full speed as someone cam emerge from any point of the road. There is constant congestion, cameras are only limited to only Gurgaon areas in the immediate vicinity of Delhi. Even the street lights are missing on most of the highway. Everytime I pay toll tax here, I curse these toll operators. But I once had the chance of traveling on Delhi-Mumbai expressway. It is something that feels like spending toll on.
Not just ppp but also population plays a major role, for example in America if 100 cars/day drive on a certain highway and the toll tax for that highway is around 10rs/km the total tax collected would be around 1000rs, on other hand if we look at India as it is more populated than us or any other country the toll tax is 2.25rs and more than 1000 cars use that highway, so if we look at the figures developed nations earn about 1000rs a day on toll tax where as for India the money collected is more than 3x to that of those nations. P.S numbers are just for examples/illustrations
Addition to the Video
After reading some comments I realized that I have totally missed out on a number of tolls plazas we have Vs other countries have.
If I talk about Western countries they have way fewer toll roads in comparison to India,
almost every plain surfaced road in India is a toll road which is not the case in countries like the USA, hence, many of their commuters don't even take toll roads as their free roads are already quite decent
also, In Europe even though there are countries where you have to pay tolls. but again even European countries have far fewer toll roads than India, For example, in Switzerland the only toll their computers pay is for a couple of tunnel roads..
True... I didn't see much of the tolls plazas when I went there
Very good information. But just a small correction. USA also has the automatic toll deduction mechanism where you don't need to wait in the line. But it also has gate based system in areas like airport. Those are also automatic.
You are comparing America and Europe with India... Nice!
Petro $ left the Chat
Other countries have good toll free roads also which we don't have.
The Indian taxation system is a Joke on middle class tax payers. Whether it's Income Tax or Purchasing a new car. No matter which government is in power. Everyone will talk about the poor or rich. The middle class exists only for paying Taxes in 100 different ways for both the classes.
Agreed. The worst of socialism. Minus any benefits.
Nirmala taaiii
Modi 3.0
No, pay up your taxes, and then vote. Wonder how countries are still Third Word, or become Third World like the US (shocked?). They don't pay their taxes! So, pay up and hold the government to account at the elections. Did you bother to vote? 1/3 of voters in Bharat did not.
Not a sparkle toll tax.
The roads are still not good & full of pits & jerky repair.
But it's a very good cartal of Ministers. NHAI, & Road & toll companies
Illiterate Nirmla tai 😅😅
The most irritating fact is, in toll plaza of 5 gates usually only 2 are open, thus increasing the waiting time. Never understood the reason for it
Maintenance
To save labour costs lol
@@devahlwtto waste our time too
@@devahlwt
What labour cost??
Nowadays it's all digital
We Indians are paying a hell lot of every tax...not just toll tax.
Greedy people always want things for free, even in rich countries like the UK, so the greedy desperate people of Bharat are no different. Pay up or enjoy the pot-hole rat infested dirt roads for free, for a while, before the rains wash them away.
@@VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhu already Indians pay a king's ransom of taxes and still there's not a single strip of road that's not broken. Usually guys who give lectures on paying taxes are the biggest freeloaders and burden.
@@VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhupaying all taxes and I'm still enjoying the glorious pothole infested roads of India 🥰
not all indians mostly the middle class
All developing countries in the world, taxes are high .. you can't blame govt if u want development to happen.
Itna sab kuch tax Dene ke baad NH main speed limit 80km/ hour 🤡
Chalani toh phir bhi 120 ke upper hai 😂😂😊
@@manavsharma1754Ha to overspeeding ka challan tum ni bharte humare lie wo b humko hi bharna padta hai
Expressway per 120-130 limit h 2/km toll Tax
National Highway 80-100 speed limit 1.3/km
@@aniketkaithwas1247 free main cow . Bakri kutta sab raste ke uper wait karke Bethe rehte hai
Middle class waale india me bass cheated feel karte hain . Desh ka poora bojh hum par , aur humko milta hai thenga . We give tax not for our benefit but for the charity .
हम जितना अपने आप को साफ समझते हैं
उतने साफ नहीं है
हममें से ही कोई सरकारी अधिकारी बनता है
ओर फिर भ्रष्टाचार करता है
हममें एकता भी नहीं है
किसी अपराधी के विरोध खड़े होने कि
Asli muddo ke bajay jati dharm ki rajniti krne ka theka bhi to middle class ne hi le rkha hai bhai...gareeb ko revdi mil hi jati hai or Ameer ko upr ki malai...
Pakistan will welcome you with open arms. FO.
Tu hi chala ja modi ke bete@@SameerPatra-ld1iu
कृपया,इस टोल टैक्स सिस्टम को विदेशों से तुलना करते समय प्रति व्यक्ति आय और जीडीपी का भी ध्यान रखना होगा और भारतीय परिस्थितियों के अनुरूप ही , व्यावहारिक रूप से टोल टैक्स का निर्धारण भी होना चाहिए,,,31 किलोमीटर की यात्रा का 115/- टोल भुगतान क्या औचित्यपूर्ण है? सरकार का उद्देश्य केवल जनता का खून चूसना ही होता है,,,चाहे वित्त मंत्री, परिवहन मंत्री, और चाहे प्रधानमंत्री ही क्यों न हों,,,,
After running my car for one year, I have paid 56 % to govt and 9% to bank interest. only 35% is what I consumed😢
🙏Please stop purchasing vehicle.
@@mohinderaastropal1240 So want to travel in Bullock carts?
@@Alpha-cf8fh travel in public transport
@@v-rex3206 We can clearly see How Good 1st World Public Transport System India has.
@@Alpha-cf8fh South Indian states have it
Bro I’m living in Australia & Here, you don’t need to pay the toll for long motorways. Like Melbourne to Syney is approx 1000km stretch & there is no toll. You need to pay toll in local city only just to avoid traffic. Second, there is toll rebate schemes, if you cross the particular limit than you can apply for toll rebate at the end of year. Moreover, there is not toll barriers.
That's why I am going to shift there in few months.....even though they have higher taxes but the facilities they are providing is top notch and worthy to pay
Bikes 28% + Registration
Cement 31%
AC 28%
Tolls: Hadd se jyada
aur an-ginat taxes + Income tax as well
Consumer products costly hote hai but accordingly income tax slabs mai changes nahi hote.
Middle class pe tax hona hi nahi chahiye. Billionaires pe badhao, middle class pe ghatao.
@@surajtomar4870 Wow hai lekin billionaires itne smart hai ki woh apna net money bohot Kam rakhte hai.
Aur unko har tax avoidance ka tarika jante hai. Apple ke CEO Tim Cook ki salary toh normal hai but woh stock billions ke hold karte hai.
They're not rich cuz they know how to become, They're rich cuz they know how to stay rich.
@@prateekpanwar646 Right and that's why we hear about things like "CEOs taking 1 ruppe salary" . That's a money laundering pro max in a legal way. But only available to billionaires.
@@surajtomar4870middle class kon hai jiske pass 4 car hai,
@@surajtomar4870toh garreb kon hai
Per capita income of France is ₹ 39 lakhs while in India per capita income is just ₹ 2 lakhs.
So we can not compare France toll tax with Indian Toll tax.
And in France and all other developed countries their normal roads are also of top-notch quality.
@thecomment9489 Also consider the average highway speeds, 120kmph vs 47kmph. Also, this PPP logic is bullshit because for Westerners the cost of a car is very low, whereas Indians spend years of savings on it.
@@shenanigans4177
Correct
@@shenanigans4177
Yes
Now compare the car prices of France and in India.
why tf we have toll tax what the fuck is THE FRICKING 1.5LAKH RTO FOR PUTTING A STUPID METAL PLATE!!!???
Legitimate scam is what it is.
Gadkari is the most corrupt person in power
Ghatkari ko hata do sab theek ho jai ga besharamo ki tar ha bolta hai road chahiye to tol dena pade ga phir RTO tax 2000, 3000 lo ya lo hi mat they fucking people fucking hole country and we fuckedup
RTO money goes for the state roads. Not to the centre. And centre builds the highways.
@@pranaysinha8300 nonsense
Middle-class and Rich Middle-class pay taxes like hell in India, but 90% amount goes into the pockets of MPs, MLAs, Government bodies and Government employees also most tax rules are not followed by government employees.
Also, remember the high fuel cost.
90% aapne jyada bol diya 20%- 30% k around tax ka corruption mei jata hai paisa .uske alava rishwat ka paisa lete hai yeh direct logo se. uska bada kaaran yeh hai kyunki mla,mp ko ticket k liye mota Paisa Dena padta hai. And party is paise ko election campaign mei bahut bade level par kharch karti hai. Jis din yeh election par Paisa lagna band ho jayega . Us din se shayad corruption kam ho jaye.
Toll tax to theek hai par itna toll tax dene par bhi roads acche nahi hote h mostly roads par aur koi b acchi service provide nahi karte h NHAI wale Travellers ko.
Bhai toll tax bus National Highway pr hota hai . Our Highways are very good . Local roads aapki state ke mla or cm ke under aati hai . Unpar ni lagta toll tabhi wo gandi hoti hai
Ribbon Development ना हो
Planned Development हो इसके लिए सरकार Expressway के आसपास Planned Development करने कि कोशिश कर रही है - उत्तर प्रदेश
ओर Local Municipality से प्रशन पुंछे तो चीजें ज्यादा जल्दी बेहतर होगी
UP se toh jaatiwaad bas karva lo 😂😂
@@Vab462 🤣🤣 bhai nahi h har jagah aisa kayi jagah abhi bhi even highways i am in panipat (GT road) road quality is not upto the mark
@@Vab462Kabhi mauka mile to NH130 me chal kar dekhe.....! कार उछलती हुई चलती है , कभी अचानक उछलने से सिर अगर कार की छत से ना टकरा जाय , तो कहना ।।।। 370 k.m. के हाईवे में 100 k.m. 6 लेन है , बाकी 2 लेन हाईवे है ।।। 7 बार toll tax भी भरने पड़ते हैं ।।। कार उछालने के ।।।।
I think 1 more point should be, the amount of vehicle in India is also very high as I just googled and found: French-40mil~ whereas India-350mil~ approx.. so India's tolls should get more money so they should charge less.
"If you want good roads, our friends and family from the contractor's lobby deserve to make thousands of crores"
The real story
True
Any proof for your statement? IRCC is the official maker of roads for NHAI. Not any specific lobby, regardless, we only pay an average of Rs.3 per km. Think again.
@@brockrumlow debt of nhai % increase kitna hai any idea? Gadgari ji ke driver ke naam jo company thi uska shayad kuch pata nahi chala right. Dost daal kaali hai grey bhi nahi hai
@@brockrumlow LOL, go and search who is the developing Ganga Expressway in UP, Its Adani not IRCC.
Corruption ek bohot hi important role play karta hai roads ke mamle main. Kyun ki agar road pehli baar main hi acchi quality ki banayi jaye to kam se kam 10-15 saal tak usko kuch nhi hoga. Lekin humare idhar to corruption ki vajah se bohot hi ghatiya quality ki roads banayi jati hai. Jisko ye log har saal banate hai. Kayi baar pipeline ya cable beechane ke naam pe unko khoda jata hai. Aur ye baar baar road banane ki vajah se unginat paise ki barbadi hoti hai jo paisa kisi aur cheez ke liye istemal kiya ja sakta hai. Aur ye paisa jata to public ki jeb se hi hai to log aur ghussa hote hai kyunki ye sab charo or khule aam ho rha hai. Agar pehli baar main hi ye sheher ya gaon ke roads acchese banaye jaye to bacha hua paisa highways ke maintenance ke liye istemal ho sakta hai jisse toll kam kiya ja sakta hai.
Bakabas tumko dikat he to
Village ki road se jao koi toll nhi lagega
@@ComptetiveApproachNehi ja raha ham konsa highway me ja rahe hai par jis company ka truck chal raha hai o products ka price increase kar raha hai
@@pankajsamanta1602 dekh. Bhai. Sarkar. Loan leke road banati he
Usako return bhi karna hota he.
@@pankajsamanta1602 land free. Main koi nhi deta he.
Bo free de diya karo.
@@pankajsamanta1602 tumhare liye. Congress hi sahi. New road hi. Mat. Banao. Toll tex bo bhi legi
Are we playing too much toll tax in India ?
Answer is absolutely YES !
Bhai sahi Keh rahe hoon Kuch bhi kaho lekin toll bahut zyada agar aap delhi se haridwar bhi jau tab bhi 450 rupay toll Dena padta hai aur km sirf 193 hao
Stop paying tax and also stop asking for development
@@srinidhikarthikbs981 development kar ke govt ehsaan karti h kya janta pe?
@@No_one_is_above_time tumhe shayad pata nahi ki food grains tumhare ghar tak kaise pahuch te hai. Aapke kitchen me jo ingredients hain, kam se kam 10 states se aaye huae hai. Bina ache roads ke, ya toh woh mahenge padenge, ya phir khareedne ko hi nahi milega.
@@srinidhikarthikbs981baat toh yesa kar raha hay ki government aapni salary say aapna ghar bech kar highway bana raha hay
Very underated channel. You got loads of knowledge and your research is amazing. Folks better watch this content rather than wasting time on reels
Govt for last 5 years have installed toll plazas in roads that were built almost 15 to 20 years ago. And no maintenance is being done on this road and now there are 3 toll plazas in 150 km stretch of road built almost 15 years ago before there was only one toll plaza. Does govt wants toll revenue from road built 15 years ago
They want to scam people by saying 60 years no development and people are voting on religion
Chup desh 2014 ke baad hi vikaas hua h
@@freefireshorts134 before 2014 we were in Stone Age
If the govt was run by the three champion commenters here, they would have built 30k kms of free expressways, paid salaries of 17k workers till retirement and filled a million potholes with the 16,700/- vehicle tax you paid in 2011. And yet you choose Mudi ze rejin pls over them😢
Bhai public transport use Kiya kar.
1-2 per km ki Vara hai.
Tera toll tax Bach jayega khatakhat khatakhat😂😂
Meanwhile me watching these video while traveling and my father is driving car and just now we have crossed toll tax😂
@-vp4hu jab puri baat patha nahi toh bhokna nahi chahiya
From my City to Mumbai we pay 2000/-Rs toll and train tickets just cost 140/-
Train is best
Kuch bhi 😂 kaha hai ghar batana zara
@@Rah647 Solapur
Don't use national highways then go through random villages there are no tolls but there are lots of speed breaker so it consumes lots of fuel
Its a way to create inconvenience purposefully to avoid those roads. @vren777
Great unbiased opinions and research👍🏼
One thing you forget to mention is the fuel prices
My god. Please don't say the government controls it.
Respect++ for considering the PPP. People always ignore this concept while comparing India to other countries.
Bhai toll tax lene k baad bhi majority of expressways par street lights missing hai..
One of the issue is the lack of transparency how these funds are used , many of the times they keep charging the toll tax even after they have made profits.
2. You need to factor in the amount of vehicles passing beach day. Yes the amount is less than other countries but the amount or number of cars passing by is much higher.
3. No accountability, if there's a fault no one fixes it immediately.
The crux of the problem is people do not mind paying money but it should be at par with level of services being delivered , rather than making contractors rich
"The paradox of development is that while it lifts incomes and living standards, it also raises the cost of living."
So essentially, we are still in the same spot.
@@arealist8913I am afraid it's just you.
Not under the Chinese governance model. In China their citizens enjoy first world living standards in third world prices. That's why approval ratings for their government is 95%. Inflation rate in China hovers around 1%.
@@thecomment9489 aur freedom?
@@thecomment9489they paid the costly price of their freedom for that
You forgot one point, we have more population, more vehicles. number of people paying per km rs is 20, 30 times more than these countries. We pay more taxes on other things.. so these comparisons will not work
One injustice in India is that, Alto and Mercedes pays same toll tax even though the impact of both the cars on road is vastly different, the toll tax should be based on the engine capacity or weight of the vehicle
Bro dont give them ideas💀💀💀🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@JOD_YT lol
That is absurd
Bhai , tu toh lutwayega.
Good video sir..... I ride my car daily 40-50 kms....going on highway is rare for me....like 1 time in 3 months so i don't feel burden of toll taxes ....
दूसरे देशों में गाड़ी भी सस्ती है और तेल भी। उसे भी equation डालना चाहिए। गाड़ी पर ज्यादा टैक्स लगाना ठीक है अगर public transport पे सरकार ध्यान देती हो जोकि भारत सरकार नहीं कर रही।
You forgot Consider to compare per capita income , the income of truck drivers in US vs india, the price. One packet chips price in india - 20 rupee, in us - 500 rupee.
Chepest car in india- 4lac, in Us - 14lac.
You also need to consider the number of vehicles running on the road and total amount of tax collected.
Point from my side. if the quality of roads improves drastically. Complaints shall come down significantly. There are certain new roads. That are not good in quality. That makes us the users questioning why do we pay so much when the service is not nearly as good.
why road tax and tax for same facility we have to pay tax multiple times
So the corrupted sarkari babus can eat more money
Because you are servicing the debt that was taken to build it and salaries and upkeep cost to maintain it. Please don't be a ghonchu.
Pay Direct Taxes
& Get rid from Indirect Taxes
But it should be done by all or atleast almost - Citizens
Less than 10 % pay Direct Tax then it's obvious Government has to find indirect ways to Collect
How can Government Run
Corruption is because of both Government & People
People are No Saint
@@Priyaykanth2 people are corrupt by nature what political system should do is to set an Example like lal bahadur shastri. When government can put hindu muslim agenda as the core instinct of vast majority of people why not honesty?
The guy earning 5 to 20 lakh in this country bears the most burnt.... doesn't get good government schools and healthcare even after paying direct tax, let alone other indirect ones...
Govt. Should also focus on cattles on highways. Highways in MP are full of cattles.
Highly agreed 👍
Pr waha ki road to America se bhi achi h
it is also full of idiotic drivers with zero civic sense or even a small inclination to follow road driving rules
Sagar-jhansi
Cattle on roads is a very unique Indian phenomenon and must be declared a UNESCO cultural heritage of India. LOL. Well any there is hardly any difference between the cattle on Indian roads and the rabble.
Also compare their neat - clean and jam free roads with public facilities to our bad bad roads. Toll tax amount is really high and toll staff also very irresponsible
I completely agree with you regarding this matter, makes a good road takes strong action on stray animals and removes the road tax while buying new vehicle.
Your videos are automobile related but you talk about every segment of automobile ...very versatile and informative,
Thanx for made such type of videos....
Here we forgot heavy tax on petrol, life tax on 4 wheelers, insurance etc etc.
tbh man, what I loved about this video is the approach, the way you supported the govt. for the right things and also mentioned the how govt taking tax through other medium for the same very thing, and you were completely unbiased, maybe now a days its kinda rare thing
Wonderful Video Done by the Wonderful Person and team. Hats off to you.
Please Heart me I am your big fan please
I lived in Dallas for 6 years. We drive at 120kmph and the toll gets deducted from the toll tag without stopping.
Also, there's no need for GPS in your vehicles. Entry and exit gates can calculate distances and deduct toll accordingly (that's also at 100kmph).
In India, why does the govt want to put trackers in our cars? Huge violation of citizens privacy.
Bhai popular hone ke baad aap bhi 3 mahiney baad video dalna maat shuru krna. Coz Bhai maza aata hai dekhne mai🕺🕺
Sahi baat he😂
Itna nahi kar sakta Bhai channel ka rpm crash ho jayega iska😂😂😂
Amazing video, very informative ❤
I am travelling from delhi to Kolkata since 2012 i have seen many things changing and some of the things not.
First the toll tax distance is not uniform sometimes we have pay on 2 different toll booths in 80km or sometimes for 200 km
And then the prices. The price for worst road was around 120 for 40km
And for best road around 100 for 50 km
Another thing for me is why you dont penalized for overloaded trucks because of them roads got damaged.
Also we should start taking toll tax from 2 wheelers also as seen of yamuna expressway agra Lucknow expressway because of them also we get disturbed and couldn't maintain speeds
But yeah previously our travel time was more than nowadays thanks to better road qualities.
But there should be uniformity on toll distance and should be taken from all types of vehicles
Your selection of topics are becoming interesting day by day, keep up the good work buddy.
I would like to add one more point though, that is the average speed in Indian highways and the US. For a distance of around 1,500 km (Delhi to Mumbai) it takes 24 hours but on the flipside the same distance in US (Los Angeles to Portland) can be covered within 16 hours which is way less.
From my POV if I'm saving 50 percent of the time in an expressway on the route that I'm travelling, I'll not have any issue paying the current toll rates but it doesn't feel beneficial to pay tolls on normal highways which are full of local traffic, barricades, stray animals.
Hopefully the travel time will reduce drastically in about 5-10 years when most tier one, two cities will be connected through expressways.
Govt taking much more money as road tax on purchase of vehicles
Very good informative video. I am not against road toll tax but I want :
1. Flawless toll roads ( most of them have very bad patches which damage low profile tyres).
2. Waiting time at toll gates should be reduced considerably (which is possible but maybe expensive)
3. Reduce road tax on new vehicles.
India for middle class income tax is around 30%, if we include indirect taxes it will go above 45%.
If you are paying 30% income tax, don't call yourself middle class. You will have to earn 7-8 lakh per month to pay 30% income tax. Someone earning 3 lakh per month pays ~20% income tax under new tax regime.
@@tusharaggarwal9956 he is saying income tax(direct tax) isn't 2% but 30% and indirect tax is 45% to the government, overall
@@tusharaggarwal9956 aye Bhai, you'll only need to make 15 lakhs annually to qualify for the 30% tax bracket under the new regime and 10 lakhs per annum under the old regime. Thoda padh likh lo yaar
@@MozaffarMansoor My monthly salary is 1.72 lakh and I am in new tax regime, yes I am in 30% tax bracket but that isn't imposed on complete income, 30% applies on income above 15 lakh annually. So, overall my tax liability is 14.5%
@@tusharaggarwal9956 yaar using your logic, nobody truly will give exactly 30% tax. Even a 7 lakh a month making fellow will only start paying 30% after 15 lakhs. He'll fall close to 30% but never exactly 30. But I digress and on a factual level you're even right but mudda ye hai ki ek normal life jeene ke liye with a family you'll need about 2 to 2.5 lakhs a month salary jiski tax new dhajji uda Deni hai. A significant chunk of this salary will be taxed at 30% and any and all bonuses over this will fall in the 30% tax bracket itself.
Let's work with an example
You live in Mumbai and make 2 lakhs a month in a family of 4. Your rent goes to about 40k for a 2bhk, and other expenditures (electricity, food, travel, school, fuel) make up 50k a month, you've purchased a house on a loan and are paying 30k a month as installments - this will come out to about 14.5 lakhs annually that you need to exist in a decent condition. Any saving you do will only be after this amount. But all of that amount is being taxed at 30%, essentially all your savings. And then everything that you are purchasing is also being taxed at different rates. Any profit you make on your savings will also be taxed at 30%, any increment, bonus, lottery, or profit from sale of property will also be taxed further. You're right when you say that tax liability isn't 30%, but there's nuance to the idea of what is being taxed and how much. I hope you appreciate the intricacies of it
India is the most affordable and least taxed country on an overall basis in the entire world. From insurances to mobile tariffs to food, human labour, electricity, medicines almost everything is fairly affordable. It’s just that more hands depend on your money right now. Over the time that generation goes away and every person in the family will be independent. Wait for it.
Amazing analysis. Your PPP analysis was spot-on to conclude that Indians pay equal to developing nations.
Road Tax, on the other hand, is a HUGE burden on Car owners. This can be reduced significantly if not eliminated.
The third, and MOST important aspect, is the PATHETIC Road Construction, Corruption, and Negligence. India has some of the HIGHEST Road accidents for developing nations. Here RTO is partly responsible for HUGE Corruption.
The Potholes alone, claim thousands of lives each year. Financial Audits reveal local Municipalities spend THOUSANDS PER POTHOLE, but the conditions keep deteriorating.
Here overloading and rash driving are the primary causes, which points finger to Corrupt Traffic Police officials.
Very good presentation bhai sahab, will send some ideas for future videos as well. :)
Kal h WB se UP gya aur minimum 1200rs jaisa toll tax diya... this is a joke.
Train
By car
Chup reh....BJP ko vote karo.😊
thanks for making this good video raising awareness.
we really need good content creators .
Restrict voting rights to direct taxpayers, and the country will become developed within 2 decades.
@@BigMoose0901cry about it
Great video Man keep it up.
I think road tax should be slashed in India. Considering that you are paying good price for toll tax and if the roads are not in good shape you are paying afterwards for maintenance.
4:55 - one thing you failed to mention, public transport is so good in Japan that you don't need cars, while travel without car is impossible in india.
very informative video...salute you sir for being common man's voice
I was fed up from paying tolls so was searching about this on internet and you came up with a video ❤
GPS based toll sounds like dystopia. Corporate will save more money by not hiring a single human on Tolls.
BS
Why do you want to hire people as toll collectors? Let them do something productive rather than sit in one place all day doing nothing.
@@MrXperx By that logic unless you are doing manual labour you aren't doing something productive. Learn what productive means before throwing in words you know little about and learn how modern economy works. You should have foresight to see how many jobs are replaceable by AI and robots.
Bro, people are already paying many taxes. Some might disagree but this is the case. For those, who are gonna reply me, hear me first
You are already paying income tax, that is 20-30% ( if you are middle class it's mostly around 30), the goods you are gonna buy have gst included ( by the way the seller is also paying some tax depending on the sales too), petrol price which is ₹100/l (it's actual base price is only half of that), toll tax, road tax, if you selling your house (on which you already have paid your tax) you need to pay tax again etc etc etc. (Sorry comments have word limits, can't use it all)
For those who are gonna say, where the government is gonna get money from,
Government has it's own companies set up which actually do generate profits, it even has shares in the companies and many more, but even if they do need to collect, this many?
I mean we are getting facilities for that like education ( lowest education standard in government school, lack of medical colleges etc), hospitals ( covid has already shown enough- oxygen tanks), roads ( what's that? Forget local roads, I have seen dangerous potholes on a highway, a fucking highway which is supposed to have high speed vehicles on it), Security that is police (Do I need to say this?).
For those who are thinking ki more tax= more development, that is true but in a competent system. Yaha agar koi ek baar pradhan ban jaae toh uski next 2 generation ko kaam karne ki jarurat nhi padti, think about MLAs, CMs etc. So whats the point of giving more money to a govt which is a bottomless pit of greed 😂😂😂
28 to 200% non creditable gst on new car purchase, high road tax, 300% non creditable GST and excise on petrol and diesel, highest car insurance ... And then salt ( tolltax) on wounds.
What about city roads, even mumbai city has the worst roads till now. Goverment just wants tax money but no real benefits for people
1st View 🔥🔥
Your video very information
I recently did a road trip from Pune - Kodiakanal - Ooty - Pune. In total we paid ₹3500 in tolls for a journey of roughly 3100kms. So it cost us around ₹0.88/km.
Bjp is crushing middle class through exorbitant toll and other taxes
Don't expect it to be better in any government
@@IndiHeads-mn4kqDon't need excuses from people who voted for the non biological
Good update keep it up the good work 👍👍👍
3 minute rule should be implemented strictly.
I live in Houston Texas I pay $200 each month for toll tax.
Cost of everything is more in developed countries. Right from milk, groceries to dental and medical treatment. A root canal treatment in India costs around 2-7k on an average whereas it can cost around 1lakh in developed countries. Same with salaries paid to multinational corporate employees in India as compared to west. That is Purchasing power parity.
Yeah this guy just put the toll tax of different developed countries to justify the tax in India lol
Good & updated content brother👍👍
Everything is possible under modi supremacy not only toll everything is kinda expensive in India compared to other countries
Are you stupid?
inflation 5% hai india mai
argentina , turkey ka dekh le pata chal jayega
india baki countries se sabse cheap hai
Fool see inflation data and come out of ur tukde tukde university mindset speek in data
Chup Modiji Bhagwan hai....😊
@@तरबुज_खाने_वाला_राक्षसmujhe too laga tha tera bhagwaan bar dancer hai
Absolutely Yes to the Title of the Video..! I factor in the toll cost when claiming my travels for work... when driving within 500 kms radius of Hyderabad... and it's no joke... hyderabad to Vijayawada, Nagpur, Bangalore they all cost a lot... Yes the roads are good...
Also... you are missing the point when discussing cost... you need to consider the cost of ownership as opposed to cost of acquisition... because we are a democracy and most consumer have choices...
You don't understand PPP, stop peloing gyan. PPP is extremely unreliable because it is only useful when you have something completely sourced locally. Involvement of tech and automation reduces difference in PPP massively because machines costs same everywhere.
if he peloing gyan acc to u, then stop watching his channel
Thanks Bro for your Valuable Research and Information. I truly appreciate 🙏
28℅ GST bhi du, high toll tax bhi du , kya milta hai is sarkar se! Sirf bhashan? Bahar desh se compare karte ho, france, japan k jaisa hume social security, world class healthcare milta hai?
Congress ka time me desh ko luta gaya he uska varpai kon karega.... Amm janta ke dwara varpai ho rahahe na or Government tumko free ka medical, Rashen de rahahe wo kiu lete ho
@@patelraj3335 bhai gujrat ka healthcare WB k samne kuch bhi nehi hai. Idhar top to bottom pura free hai from tests to chemo for cancer patients. Waise bhi tera state mein toh mostly neet ka leak karwake doctors bante hai , really feel sad for Gujarati peoples.
@@unplannedmoody1430 free medical services de raha hai na, 70 years hoga uske baad woh bhi 5 lakh ka.
People in India want all things free. How do you expect to become Europe.
@@navigatorprashant buddy its not free, a gst of 28℅ is not free, people are paying direct and indirect taxes whereas in terms of benifits of govt people are getting peanuts.
Like you approach of being neutral and calling a spade a spade.. Have been a sub for quite some time and I always leave a like.. today i decided to leave a comment also to please youtube mama
Indians don't want to pay taxes in India but same Indian happily pays taxes in Germany and Singapore.
It's all about return of investment thing. If they are paying taxes there they are actually getting benefitted from that. But here we get almost no or very less out of the taxes we pay at each step of our lives.
Hn India mei log direct tax kam bharte h. Pr hn log India mei indirect tax bhut jyada bharte h... Even on education, healthcare, and salt.
Hn wahi salt jiske liye dandi March Tak hogya tha ki is pr se taxes hatao..aaj wo taxed h.
Because India is developing
Singapore citizens paid taxes during hard times, that's why they have the developed Singapore, we know.
@@akhripasta2670 bro we are still paying a lots of taxes. Get your economics more stronger, we have one of the highest taxes in indirect ways. You can check anywhere from education, road tax, petrol or etc.
That's exactly what happens when for 60years half the population don't had access to toilet, no sewage treatment plant, no roads, no railway electrification NOTHING!!!. Kashmr valley & some North East got their first railway in last 3 years.
We are paying high taxes because we are catching up.
Bhai apne upsc 2020 ke mains ke question ka perfect answer dediya. Hm aspirants is structure se hi answe likhte h. Respect for your research
How much toll has nitinji paid for toll? He says for good roads you need to pay then how much are these babus and netas paying. I want all these freeloaders to pay tax from their income, only then i will be okay to pay toll.
Exempted hai babus
Till we have at least 10% of our population (like in China) in the tax bracket this is going to be the case, unfortunately - right now its about 2%. So we need to collectively think as to how we can collectively increase the income prospect of our countrymen. Be it startups, MSME, Services etc. Just govt jobs are not going to help. And blaming the govt for such huge taxes is unproductive - we all know that and the govt also knows. Our ask of lower taxes and higher quality of living when only 2% of the people is paying tax is criminal. Can we, collectively, come up with creative solutions?
Ye to sirf toll tax hai, Gareebo ko khata khat khata khat ₹8500 dege tab middle class ka kya hoga? 😅😂
2:27 per capita income भी देख लो फ्रांस का औसत आदमी भारत से 6.8 गुना कमाता है, अगर उनके टोल टैक्स को 6.8 से भाग दें तो ये संख्या 1.4 आती है मतलब वो हमसे आधा टैक्स देते हैं।
और वहां पेट्रोल, गाडी पर अंधा टैक्स नहीं लगता, भारत की तरह..
Very informative video as always ..Maharashtra main to bahut hai bhai....am sure lot of ppl will agree to it
In Punjab chalang and ladowal toll plazas are have 92 km diff. and both have toll tax 170 and 355 rupees.
I travel 200kms one side to Delhi, diesel costs somewhere around ₹800-1000 but the toll tax is 500/-. We pay almost 85% in taxes on day to day basis. Plus developed countries have a great public transportation system.
Only an Indian Economist can tell us better about this topic.
Indian per capita income - USD 3300
India has direct + indirect taxes. Indua has 42% tax on cars.
Europe has per capita - USD 50,000
No indirect taxes. Full free education and health facility.
What Gadkari talking about paying is to private contractors. NHAI gets peanuts from toll tax. Most of it is extortion for private accounts.
not sure about other countries, In the USA, Toll roads are not compulsory, You always have a way to get to the same destination with the same road quality, only a time difference. Please check it once.
Toll employees will not follow the 3min rule but they will obey 1 rule "Fasttag me recharge nahi hai ab apko cash me 2 times more toll dena padega"
Also, I am glad the right profile is getting noticed. Hope every Indian & every official can see your videos which perfectly pinpoint the pain of every commuter.
The biggest complaint. Fastaq aane ke itne saal baad bhi koi fast lane nhi h.🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
I am taking a car delivery tomorrow. Here is some break-up of cost:
Dealer price : 13L
Showroom price: 19L
On-road price : 22.8L
Actual Cost of ownership: 30.5L (22.8L + 30% income tax + 4% cess)
Total Tax: 6L(CGST+SGST+CESS) + 2.3L RTO = 8.3L
Already paid income tax: 7.7L(on on-road price)
Total Tax: 16L(Not considering GST on insurance, accessories, consumables etc.)
I still need to pay toll. Funny, isn't it?
By the way Bharat's PPP is 22, that means actual value of $1 is not 80-85 INR but 22 INR. So 2.2 INR per KM is same as 10 cents.
Taxes are each & every where specially in Maharashtra , w bengal. Government doesn't give damn i know infra needs money but charging 30rs on each liter of petrol seriously
nice informative content sir , keep going !
Future video suggestions-
1) Overall car ownership cost comparision adjusted for PPP..
2) Overall running cost considering PPP..
But except a few newly developed toll highways. Most of the toll roads are in pathetic condition. I commute regularly on NH-8 Delhi-Jaipur highway. You'll never find this highway in good condition, most of the time it is full of potholes and after rain it becomes a mess. With potholes and most of the highway submerged under water. There are illegal intersections everywhere. You can never go at full speed as someone cam emerge from any point of the road. There is constant congestion, cameras are only limited to only Gurgaon areas in the immediate vicinity of Delhi. Even the street lights are missing on most of the highway. Everytime I pay toll tax here, I curse these toll operators.
But I once had the chance of traveling on Delhi-Mumbai expressway. It is something that feels like spending toll on.
Not just ppp but also population plays a major role, for example in America if 100 cars/day drive on a certain highway and the toll tax for that highway is around 10rs/km the total tax collected would be around 1000rs, on other hand if we look at India as it is more populated than us or any other country the toll tax is 2.25rs and more than 1000 cars use that highway, so if we look at the figures developed nations earn about 1000rs a day on toll tax where as for India the money collected is more than 3x to that of those nations.
P.S numbers are just for examples/illustrations