Rekkai’s Deep Dive for Episode 10 (Vincent and the Doctor) is available - th-cam.com/video/BSFQok4Dmv8/w-d-xo.html Rekkai’s Episode 9 (Cold Blood) Deep Dive available now - th-cam.com/video/h7343dACnRc/w-d-xo.html Make sure you join the Discord: discord.gg/QRmDp6G2
My son has suffered mental health issues all his life. He loved this episode. It helped him discover art. We ended up travelling to Paris to see Vincent’s works displayed at the Musée d’Orsay!
@@gurulimbo Getting it right as a parent is never easy. A mixture of hits and misses. I saw how much this episode spoke to him and then sought to maximise the educational effect!
There were a lot of DW watch alongs going on during lockdown with some of the writers and actors chipping in with behind the scenes stuff and for this one Richard Curtis (the writer) revealed he decided to do this story in memory of his sister who loved Van Gogh but sadly ended up taking her own life due to similar circumstances, I think that adds another beautiful heartfelt layer to this wonderfully constructed story
I liked the line about the Doctor choosing his name because he's always "making people better". If you skip the obvious Dr. / Health metaphor, the Doctor generally tries to make people, including Villains, Better.
As someone who’s struggled with major depression this is the most accurate depiction/commentary. No cliches, no crap about how ‘strong’ we are. Just simply that yes it sucks and we can’t always fix it but we can add to someone’s pile of ‘good’ things and that’s enough.
The painting that Vincent erased is an Easter egg or historical clue- Van Gogh reused his canvases a lot because they were expensive so some of his works have 2-3 paintings hidden under the final product, including the one you saw the actor cover up in the episode- a fact which has only been discovered in the last few decades after X-ray and infrared examination of the canvases.
@@Jameson_Visual_Arts_Studios OMG! That’s so fantastic- it just goes to show how much of an artist he was because in truth, we have only really seen a fraction of what Van Gogh accomplished in terms of body of work. While we can still examine and try to recreate his covered works without damaging the masterpiece above, I think it’s important to understand that Van Gogh didn’t paint over some works while not others for a reason. That’s what makes him such a great artist because he wasn’t doing it to be revered or famous, but for himself to cope with the challenges of life and the deep depression that plagued his mind. He saw beauty in the mundane, music in the inferior, light and movement in bleak darkness and encapsulated his human experience and personal sight with breathtaking vulnerability and creativity, but beautiful austerity.
i cry every time i see them taking Vincent into the future. this is one of my favourites episode. this is what i love about the 11th doctor, he is so... human.
The scene where The Doctor, Amy and Vincent lay in the field and we see Starry Night come to life through Vincent showing The Doctor and Amy through his eyes is one of the most beautiful things I have seen on the show
I loved that scene and sold my heart to Vincent. In 1999 i went to Paris with some friends to see an exibition of portraits of VVG. They were all people portraits and I didn't like the experience nor the paintings. Then this episode aired. Since then i went to 3 other exibitions of Vincent and i loved everything.
That scene at the end where the Doctor comforts Amy and tells her life is a collection of good and bad moments is the best Doctor moment in the entire show.
When this originally aired on BBC One they had an advisory at the end linking people to UK services if you were in need of help. I.e. a suicide helpline. This episode is largely credited not only by its writing and its acting, but by the impetus it caused for Britons to reach out to mental health services if they were struggling. Peace and love x
One of the best episodes of the entire show. The idea of depression as a monster only you can see is spot on. I’ve seen it so many times and it still makes me sob every time.
I'm so glad they didn’t "fix" him. I've struggled with mental illness my entire life, and I've been with my husband for 20 years. Nothing can magically make me 100% better all of a sudden, but we still have a good life.
Even after repeated viewing, this episode still gives me the eye sweats. Its an extremely powerful episode hidden in a "historic person" and monster of the week style. Great response and commentary. The one line that always strikes me is while the doctor is comforting Amy, he says "The good things don't always soften the bad things, but vice-versa, the bad things don't necessarily spoil the good things and make them unimportant.". I always felt it was less about her response to Vincent, but more that he was speaking to her about her unknown loss of Rory.
"The way I see it, every life is a pile of good things and bad things. The good things don’t always soften the bad things, but vice versa, the bad things don’t always spoil the good things and make them unimportant." This gets me EVERY time.
This episode gets me in the feels every single time. Also to know that even with the knowledge that his art is recognized he still ends up ending his life. That his depression couldn't just be solved by that one thing. It's really powerful.
This is THE episode of DW that changed my life on a foundational level. It totally rocked me to the core! I have struggled with lifelong anxiety and depression and always deeply loved Van Gogh, and this episode gave me such a different perspective on everything! It's so beautifully done ❤
When people ask me for a stand-alone episode to introduce them to Doctor Who I always recommend this one. There’s a little bit of Whovian sci-fi, but it is deeply rooted in compassion and the human experience. If you’ve ever felt unappreciated, disregarded, ridiculed, or hopeless, this episode shows how what one person calls madness others will call greatness and that what you do in this life matters.
@@dees3179 that’s the other one, depends on who I’m talking to. If they’re more emotionally vulnerable it’s this one. If they seem like they would enjoy more of a thriller who-done-it then it’s definitely Blink!
I've seen some people say they thought Bill Nighy was wasted in this episode. However, that monologue at the end required a thespian of his skill to pour all that emotion into every word, every syllable. Bill Nighy was the perfect actor.
That is certainly the best episode of Who. The subtle way it smacks you in the face and makes sure you knows its all about people and mental health. Chefs kiss👌
Dr Who can unexpectedly bring up long suppressed emotions and sensitive issues and make us speak about things we find difficult. Vincent was such a genius artist but was plagued with enormous mental anguish. His beautiful art is revered, his legacy remembered and the tragedy of his passing a great sadness. Thank you for sharing your own story. Sending everyone suffering in silence love and hugs ❤
Gosh so amazing I weep every time I rewatch. I very much enjoy the symbolism of an invisible beast that wrecks things around you that can make others blame you for the problems in life.
Really appreciated your guys honest emotions and willingness to show that and your words about your opinions and your experiences. Thanks. This episode had a huge impact on me. I'm grateful to still be here. Love to you if you're going through bad times. Don't unalive yourself- life can change, you can change, things could get better, and I hope you keep fighting to get there, as I have, and still am. Hugs ❤
This will forever be my favourite doctor who episode to date. I’ve always been a huge Van Gogh fan and this episode was beautiful, the way Tony Curran portrayed him was stunning
That museum scene always chokes me up a little bit. Anyone who has ever felt unappreciated, which is most people, can empathize and relate to that. And for somebody as tortured and brilliant as Vincent van Gough, it would be monumental.
Amazing episode and amazing reactions and discussion. Thank you guys! This episode had top notch writing and three wonderful performances from Matt, Amy and Matt Smith. Makes me tear up every time. I am so glad that they did not have Vincent's depression "solved" by his time with the Doctor, which would just not be true. The Doctor's speech about life being a pile of good things and bad things is perfect. BTW - the guy who wrote it is mainly known for writing romantic comedies - Fourth Weddings and a Funeral and Love Actually - also Blackadder, which is another great British (comedy) show you should think about reacting to.
By far the best doctor, in one of the best episodes they’ve ever made. Matt smith got the character so right, because he just seemed like someone who was trying their best to come over as human, but could never quite get it right.
I don't know if there will ever be an episode that tops this one for me. The good things/bad things speech gets me every single time. As someone who also struggles with mental health, this episode cuts deep and I appreciate the conversation here. Will be looking out for that deep dive
One of my favorite episodes. I am sorry I missed the discord on this day. Some of the words they put in Vincent’s mouth are actual quotes. Such a beautiful soul.
“The way I see it, every life is a pile of good things and bad things. The good things don’t always soften the bad things but vice versa the bad things don’t necessarily spoil the good things or make them unimportant… and we definitely added to his pile of good things”
Seeing people react to and tear up at that ending scene is what i live for, lol. Such an amazing impactful scene, i appreciate everything about it. That they gave vincent such an amazing experience, and that the episode acknowledged that depression and mental illness in general isnt a quick fix. And, of course, that giving him that experience DID make a difference, even if the ultimate outcome was the same.
Truly some of the most powerful Whoniverse stories are the ones centred around the things and situations that The Doctor simply can't fight, stop or save someone from.
I cannot tell you how many times I’ve seen this episode and I cry through it every time. But the last 10 minutes just breaks me. 😢 This episode is definitely a fan favorite and definitely in the top 3 of the most emotional episodes of the entire series ever. If not the most.
This is my favourite Matt Smith episode. Wonderful writing and the performances are top notch including the guest stars Tony Curran (Vincent) and Bill Nighy (Dr Black, the curator in the gallery).
Easily in my top 10, cry every time. I listened to the piece of music from the gallery scene whilst looking at the sunflower portrait in London. Actually wept
The scene where the Doctor scans his face in the TARDIS the photo of the two men coming from the typewriter where the First two Doctors William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton from Classic Who.
It's noteworthy that mental health has only really been destigmatised for a little while. It's only really this century where people have been able to be open about mental health without being perceived as dangerous. It's interesting to consider who in history dealt with these problems. I'm pretty convinced that being more informed is why more people are developing problems. Ignorance is bliss exists as an idiom for a reason, but clearly there were thoughtful people throughout history that were upset by the problems they perceived.
I loved this for the story telling. Brilliant and wrenching. Van Gogh has always been one of my favorite artists, so I loved how the sets recreated his paintings, like the one in the bedroom. I didn't see the full reaction and haven't watched this in a while, but his brother supported and loved him, and also died tragically. _Dear Theo: The Autobiography of Vincent Van Gogh_ is worth a read. There is some speculation that he may have had synesthesia, which would have seemed like utter madness to his contemporaries. On top of depression his improvised life growing up and appalling family life (other than his brother)...he endured so much and enriched the world so extraordinarily. As someone who's struggled with depression and thoughts of ending my life for more than 50 years I appreciate the discussion about depression.
Just realized, he was bullied horribly, by family and supposed friends and peers. Give people flowers, sure, but also have zero tolerance for bullying. Don't do it, and don't let it stand when it happens within your hearing. Please.
I originally came to this channel for IWTV but love that you are doing Doctor Who.. this episode is so nostalgic for me. It's one of my all time faves and one I came back to often because it's so touching. it was such heartfelt tribute to a troubled man that was such a genius and a talent, but so shunned during his hard life :( it's also so heartbreaking to think how people with any kind of mental issues suffered in the past and how misunderstood and mistreated they were
I agree with you. I recently had a cancer scare, and I decided I wanted a “live memorial” instead of one after I died. I wanted to hear how others thought of me and the memories they’ll keep of me. ❤️
Oooh boy I’ve been waiting for this one! Also fun fact the museum in this episode is surprise surprise, in Cardiff! Well worth a visit if you’re in the city
😭The ending of this one always gets me. 😭 Supreme acts of kindness like that always hit me hard, especially the older I get, and my emotional maturity and understanding of the world deepens. It's like the weight of all aspects just grabs you by the feels and pulls super hard, until you have option but to weep in empathy. I saw you Syntell, the onions were cut too close to you this time, and I see that you are a man not dissimilar from me, and I salute you sir! There is no shame in being moved by a triumph of writing and acting and directing such as this! And Rekkai, you never lied. You cannot find happiness in other people alone. You can rent temporary joy with external love or money, or success, but you cannot own true 💯happiness unless it comes from within. I love what the Doctor said at the end of this one about good moments and bad moments, and how the bad things do not make the good meaningless or unimportant. That's a line that sticks with you. I stuck with me certainly. I'm happy now but I wasn't always.
One of the best episodes of Doctor Who. Tony Curran's performance and Richard Curtis' writing were amazing and deserves so much praise. This episode gave me a new appreciation of Van Gogh's work and a small understanding of the kind of pain this man went through. I'm still bummed Richard hasn't written another episode for this show.
Hm, there was some speculation several years back (Vanity Fair has an article about it on their site from 2014), that van Gogh might not have actually killed themselves, and that they were actually shot by one of those kids who used to throw stones at him (either by accident while playing with a gun or intentionally because children are terrible). Allegedly the poor reputation Vincent had led local people not to bother probing too deeply into his death, and when he became famous it just became another part of his tragic backstory.
Wish I could give you a hug. I hope you know we appreciate you and we are giving you your flowers. Your videos make my days as I’m sure they do for others. Thank you! 🤗
It's considered easily as one of the top 10 episodes in Dr. Who fandom. The one bit they neglected to mention in this episode quite understandably being too dark as Dr. Who is a kid's show. It goes abit deeper than depression Vincent Van Gogh cut off his left ear when tempers flared with Paul Gauguin, the artist with whom he had been working for a while in Arles. Van Gogh's illness revealed itself: he began to hallucinate and suffered attacks in which he lost consciousness. There is no unaminous agreement on Van Gogh's incapacitating illness. Historians and researchers have variously felt that he might had suffered from elpilespy, bipolar disorder, sunstroke, acute intermittent porphyria, lead poisoning, absinthe intoxication, Meniere's disease, and digitalis toxcity.
The grafayiss is a good metaphor for many types of mental illness. It is an invisible thing that disrupts a person's life, and the actions a person takes when trying to fight against it or work around it (especially without support) are rational from the perspective of the person dealing with it. But to others those actions may appear strange, irrational, unreasonable, unsettling etc. Other people who have some knowledge or experience with mental illness of their own can provide support and help, but even they can only perceive reflected glimpses of the individual's problem, because it is different for everyone.
This episode makes me cry every time! Before I started watching these reactions it’d been like 10 years since I watched the show and I forgot a lot but what I always remember is the scene of Vincent in the museum
it took me a couple days to watch this reaction, because just recalling my memories of this ep brought up tears and shuddering breaths. i remember the first time i saw it distinctly... and it wrecked me HARD for the rest of the day. the hyperbole and oscillating heart of an artist and their crushing self doubt yet "we" still persist. "Tenacity" is the new "Hero Mode", but it can be exhausting for a wounded heart!
I am not a big 11th Doctor fan, but I love this episode. It is a shame Richard Curtis did not write more episodes. He said he wrote this as a tribute to his sister who had suffered severe depression and took her own life.
Another wonderful part of this episode is seeing Vincent Van Gogh’s most famous paintings come alive… starry night, terrace at night, his bedroom, self portrait, the fields of Provence. Just magical.
Wise wise words 'Guv'nor' and ( to connect another Doctor Who theme) was it Winston Churchill who called depression the 'Black Dog' that always follows you around.
January 5th 2010, my mother's birthday. Me, my sister and her went to Cardiff Bay because there was an IMAX down there (the first James Cameron Avatar film in 3D). Little did we know they were filming the "taking van gogh to the museum" scene outside the Millennium Centre. (Not far from where they parked the TARDIS "over the rift")
![British Doctors React To HOUSE MD [Medical Scenes]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EFBNBLiZ7So/mqdefault.jpg)
Rekkai’s Deep Dive for Episode 10 (Vincent and the Doctor) is available - th-cam.com/video/BSFQok4Dmv8/w-d-xo.html
Rekkai’s Episode 9 (Cold Blood) Deep Dive available now - th-cam.com/video/h7343dACnRc/w-d-xo.html
Make sure you join the Discord: discord.gg/QRmDp6G2
"He transformed the pain of his tormented life into ecstatic beauty" is such a gorgeous line.
My son has suffered mental health issues all his life. He loved this episode. It helped him discover art. We ended up travelling to Paris to see Vincent’s works displayed at the Musée d’Orsay!
That is absolutely beautiful! Good luck to you both on your journey and good luck to your son on his artwork!
Thats great i love hearing positive stories
I love this so much!!!!!🥰I know art helps me to work through things and feel at peace! I hope it helps him too!
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Parenting done right.
🤛😎👍
@@gurulimbo Getting it right as a parent is never easy. A mixture of hits and misses. I saw how much this episode spoke to him and then sought to maximise the educational effect!
There were a lot of DW watch alongs going on during lockdown with some of the writers and actors chipping in with behind the scenes stuff and for this one Richard Curtis (the writer) revealed he decided to do this story in memory of his sister who loved Van Gogh but sadly ended up taking her own life due to similar circumstances, I think that adds another beautiful heartfelt layer to this wonderfully constructed story
The Doctor's description of 'adding to the pile of good things...' that stabbed me in the heart and has stayed there ever since.
Me too. I want to get that on as a wall print. It's a beautiful quote and is oh so true.
One of my favorite quotes ever. 😭❤
I liked the line about the Doctor choosing his name because he's always "making people better".
If you skip the obvious Dr. / Health metaphor, the Doctor generally tries to make people, including Villains, Better.
As someone who’s struggled with major depression this is the most accurate depiction/commentary. No cliches, no crap about how ‘strong’ we are. Just simply that yes it sucks and we can’t always fix it but we can add to someone’s pile of ‘good’ things and that’s enough.
26:11 a sad fact is that for many men, the first time they receive flowers is at their funeral.
Send your masc folk flowers.
The painting that Vincent erased is an Easter egg or historical clue- Van Gogh reused his canvases a lot because they were expensive so some of his works have 2-3 paintings hidden under the final product, including the one you saw the actor cover up in the episode- a fact which has only been discovered in the last few decades after X-ray and infrared examination of the canvases.
@@Jameson_Visual_Arts_Studios OMG! That’s so fantastic- it just goes to show how much of an artist he was because in truth, we have only really seen a fraction of what Van Gogh accomplished in terms of body of work.
While we can still examine and try to recreate his covered works without damaging the masterpiece above, I think it’s important to understand that Van Gogh didn’t paint over some works while not others for a reason. That’s what makes him such a great artist because he wasn’t doing it to be revered or famous, but for himself to cope with the challenges of life and the deep depression that plagued his mind.
He saw beauty in the mundane, music in the inferior, light and movement in bleak darkness and encapsulated his human experience and personal sight with breathtaking vulnerability and creativity, but beautiful austerity.
i cry every time i see them taking Vincent into the future. this is one of my favourites episode. this is what i love about the 11th doctor, he is so... human.
@@CarmenMunteanu Just hearing the saxophone melody begin has me in tears every time I hear it. Such a great episode.
"Humany-wumany"
The scene where The Doctor, Amy and Vincent lay in the field and we see Starry Night come to life through Vincent showing The Doctor and Amy through his eyes is one of the most beautiful things I have seen on the show
I loved that scene and sold my heart to Vincent.
In 1999 i went to Paris with some friends to see an exibition of portraits of VVG.
They were all people portraits and I didn't like the experience nor the paintings.
Then this episode aired.
Since then i went to 3 other exibitions of Vincent and i loved everything.
That scene at the end where the Doctor comforts Amy and tells her life is a collection of good and bad moments is the best Doctor moment in the entire show.
I've seen this many times and I still cry every time. The writing is exquisite.
When this originally aired on BBC One they had an advisory at the end linking people to UK services if you were in need of help. I.e. a suicide helpline.
This episode is largely credited not only by its writing and its acting, but by the impetus it caused for Britons to reach out to mental health services if they were struggling. Peace and love x
One of the best episodes of the entire show. The idea of depression as a monster only you can see is spot on. I’ve seen it so many times and it still makes me sob every time.
I'm so glad they didn’t "fix" him. I've struggled with mental illness my entire life, and I've been with my husband for 20 years. Nothing can magically make me 100% better all of a sudden, but we still have a good life.
Even after repeated viewing, this episode still gives me the eye sweats. Its an extremely powerful episode hidden in a "historic person" and monster of the week style. Great response and commentary. The one line that always strikes me is while the doctor is comforting Amy, he says "The good things don't always soften the bad things, but vice-versa, the bad things don't necessarily spoil the good things and make them unimportant.". I always felt it was less about her response to Vincent, but more that he was speaking to her about her unknown loss of Rory.
19:17 and I'm already crying over an episode I've seen probably a dozen times. The onion slicing gets earlier and earlier.
"The way I see it, every life is a pile of good things and bad things. The good things don’t always soften the bad things, but vice versa, the bad things don’t always spoil the good things and make them unimportant."
This gets me EVERY time.
This episode gets me in the feels every single time. Also to know that even with the knowledge that his art is recognized he still ends up ending his life. That his depression couldn't just be solved by that one thing. It's really powerful.
This is THE episode of DW that changed my life on a foundational level. It totally rocked me to the core! I have struggled with lifelong anxiety and depression and always deeply loved Van Gogh, and this episode gave me such a different perspective on everything! It's so beautifully done ❤
When people ask me for a stand-alone episode to introduce them to Doctor Who I always recommend this one. There’s a little bit of Whovian sci-fi, but it is deeply rooted in compassion and the human experience. If you’ve ever felt unappreciated, disregarded, ridiculed, or hopeless, this episode shows how what one person calls madness others will call greatness and that what you do in this life matters.
I say this one or blink.
@@dees3179 that’s the other one, depends on who I’m talking to. If they’re more emotionally vulnerable it’s this one. If they seem like they would enjoy more of a thriller who-done-it then it’s definitely Blink!
Easily in my top 5 favorite episodes of Dr Who ever. I absolutely love Bill Nighy. This episode never fails to make me tear up.
Disney "Doctor" can't even dream of touching this kind of stuff. It can only remind us of what was taken away from us.
@@miller-joelThey still have time if they get off their agenda-pushing and concentrate on telling beautiful stories again.
@@cryptozoomauler5505 Good luck with that. It may take a generation or more.
If you haven't seen it, I recommend "About Time" with Bill Nighy, with a time travel theme.
Also written by Richard Curtis!
I've seen some people say they thought Bill Nighy was wasted in this episode. However, that monologue at the end required a thespian of his skill to pour all that emotion into every word, every syllable. Bill Nighy was the perfect actor.
We added to the his pile of good bits. And you have added to my pile of good bits today.
That is certainly the best episode of Who. The subtle way it smacks you in the face and makes sure you knows its all about people and mental health. Chefs kiss👌
This episode will never, ever fail to break me. As much as I love Blink, like everyone else, this episode is Doctor Who at its peak, for me.
Dr Who can unexpectedly bring up long suppressed emotions and sensitive issues and make us speak about things we find difficult. Vincent was such a genius artist but was plagued with enormous mental anguish. His beautiful art is revered, his legacy remembered and the tragedy of his passing a great sadness. Thank you for sharing your own story. Sending everyone suffering in silence love and hugs ❤
Gosh so amazing I weep every time I rewatch. I very much enjoy the symbolism of an invisible beast that wrecks things around you that can make others blame you for the problems in life.
Don't feel bad -- I cry every time I see that scene. It's so beautiful. I love a lot of Doctor Who, but this is definitely my favorite episode.
It's a profoundly moving episode of a kind very few shows get to make because Who has a boundless tapestry on which it can paint.
Thank you Rekkai (sp?) for sharing. You are not alone brother. Struggle with the same thing for most of my life. Always keep fighting. ❤
Really appreciated your guys honest emotions and willingness to show that and your words about your opinions and your experiences. Thanks. This episode had a huge impact on me. I'm grateful to still be here. Love to you if you're going through bad times. Don't unalive yourself- life can change, you can change, things could get better, and I hope you keep fighting to get there, as I have, and still am. Hugs ❤
Synesthesia, Vincent? Hearing colors? What wonderful works this wiring created for you. (not mad - not for that, anyway)
Tony Curran…wow 👏👏👏 He’s unbelievable. Stellar performance.
This will forever be my favourite doctor who episode to date. I’ve always been a huge Van Gogh fan and this episode was beautiful, the way Tony Curran portrayed him was stunning
That museum scene always chokes me up a little bit. Anyone who has ever felt unappreciated, which is most people, can empathize and relate to that. And for somebody as tortured and brilliant as Vincent van Gough, it would be monumental.
Amazing episode and amazing reactions and discussion. Thank you guys! This episode had top notch writing and three wonderful performances from Matt, Amy and Matt Smith. Makes me tear up every time. I am so glad that they did not have Vincent's depression "solved" by his time with the Doctor, which would just not be true. The Doctor's speech about life being a pile of good things and bad things is perfect. BTW - the guy who wrote it is mainly known for writing romantic comedies - Fourth Weddings and a Funeral and Love Actually - also Blackadder, which is another great British (comedy) show you should think about reacting to.
By far the best doctor, in one of the best episodes they’ve ever made. Matt smith got the character so right, because he just seemed like someone who was trying their best to come over as human, but could never quite get it right.
This one absolutely broke my heart the first time I saw it and still now I'm in tears.. 😭
I don't know if there will ever be an episode that tops this one for me. The good things/bad things speech gets me every single time. As someone who also struggles with mental health, this episode cuts deep and I appreciate the conversation here. Will be looking out for that deep dive
One of my favorite episodes. I am sorry I missed the discord on this day. Some of the words they put in Vincent’s mouth are actual quotes. Such a beautiful soul.
Live Deep dive coming today at noon on my channel
th-cam.com/users/liveOSai6g6ATuo?si=dNTNhxMuMmW5YpNS
“The way I see it, every life is a pile of good things and bad things. The good things don’t always soften the bad things but vice versa the bad things don’t necessarily spoil the good things or make them unimportant… and we definitely added to his pile of good things”
Seeing people react to and tear up at that ending scene is what i live for, lol. Such an amazing impactful scene, i appreciate everything about it. That they gave vincent such an amazing experience, and that the episode acknowledged that depression and mental illness in general isnt a quick fix. And, of course, that giving him that experience DID make a difference, even if the ultimate outcome was the same.
Truly some of the most powerful Whoniverse stories are the ones centred around the things and situations that The Doctor simply can't fight, stop or save someone from.
I cannot tell you how many times I’ve seen this episode and I cry through it every time. But the last 10 minutes just breaks me. 😢 This episode is definitely a fan favorite and definitely in the top 3 of the most emotional episodes of the entire series ever. If not the most.
This episode has me crying every time 🥺 such a beautiful story and one of my favourite Doctor Who episodes.
yupp, every time
This and When a Good Man Goes to War are my faves. One of the highlights in my life was seeing an exhibit of Vincent's.😥
This is my favourite Matt Smith episode. Wonderful writing and the performances are top notch including the guest stars Tony Curran (Vincent) and Bill Nighy (Dr Black, the curator in the gallery).
One of the BEST speeches EVER. It's so much. Always makes me feel...
Easily in my top 10, cry every time. I listened to the piece of music from the gallery scene whilst looking at the sunflower portrait in London. Actually wept
" . . . Brighter than sunflowers."
The scene where the Doctor scans his face in the TARDIS the photo of the two men coming from the typewriter where the First two Doctors William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton from Classic Who.
My favourite episode. Always make me cry.
I’ve suffered with depression and mental health issues since I was 14 (now 27) and I pretty much grew up with this episode and it always hits hard.
It's noteworthy that mental health has only really been destigmatised for a little while. It's only really this century where people have been able to be open about mental health without being perceived as dangerous.
It's interesting to consider who in history dealt with these problems. I'm pretty convinced that being more informed is why more people are developing problems. Ignorance is bliss exists as an idiom for a reason, but clearly there were thoughtful people throughout history that were upset by the problems they perceived.
I loved this for the story telling. Brilliant and wrenching. Van Gogh has always been one of my favorite artists, so I loved how the sets recreated his paintings, like the one in the bedroom. I didn't see the full reaction and haven't watched this in a while, but his brother supported and loved him, and also died tragically. _Dear Theo: The Autobiography of Vincent Van Gogh_ is worth a read. There is some speculation that he may have had synesthesia, which would have seemed like utter madness to his contemporaries. On top of depression his improvised life growing up and appalling family life (other than his brother)...he endured so much and enriched the world so extraordinarily. As someone who's struggled with depression and thoughts of ending my life for more than 50 years I appreciate the discussion about depression.
Just realized, he was bullied horribly, by family and supposed friends and peers. Give people flowers, sure, but also have zero tolerance for bullying. Don't do it, and don't let it stand when it happens within your hearing. Please.
I also think he was near sighted because I am and the night sky without glasses on explodes into swirling and glowing instead of pinpoints of stars.
I originally came to this channel for IWTV but love that you are doing Doctor Who.. this episode is so nostalgic for me. It's one of my all time faves and one I came back to often because it's so touching. it was such heartfelt tribute to a troubled man that was such a genius and a talent, but so shunned during his hard life :( it's also so heartbreaking to think how people with any kind of mental issues suffered in the past and how misunderstood and mistreated they were
also recreation of some of the famous paintings in shots and scenes themselves was fantastic :)
You are both my favourite reactors currently. Best reaction to this episode that I have seen across TH-cam. Keep up the reactions boys 💪🏼
I agree with you. I recently had a cancer scare, and I decided I wanted a “live memorial” instead of one after I died. I wanted to hear how others thought of me and the memories they’ll keep of me. ❤️
It's ok Syntell, I can’t tell you how many times I have cried at that scene 😢 🩵
this episode is very VERY beloved. It pretty much gets everyone!
Oooh boy I’ve been waiting for this one! Also fun fact the museum in this episode is surprise surprise, in Cardiff! Well worth a visit if you’re in the city
it's one of those locations that shows up quite a few times in NuWho, much like the Temple of Peace
😭The ending of this one always gets me. 😭
Supreme acts of kindness like that always hit me hard, especially the older I get, and my emotional maturity and understanding of the world deepens. It's like the weight of all aspects just grabs you by the feels and pulls super hard, until you have option but to weep in empathy. I saw you Syntell, the onions were cut too close to you this time, and I see that you are a man not dissimilar from me, and I salute you sir! There is no shame in being moved by a triumph of writing and acting and directing such as this!
And Rekkai, you never lied. You cannot find happiness in other people alone. You can rent temporary joy with external love or money, or success, but you cannot own true 💯happiness unless it comes from within. I love what the Doctor said at the end of this one about good moments and bad moments, and how the bad things do not make the good meaningless or unimportant. That's a line that sticks with you. I stuck with me certainly. I'm happy now but I wasn't always.
One of the best episodes of Doctor Who. Tony Curran's performance and Richard Curtis' writing were amazing and deserves so much praise. This episode gave me a new appreciation of Van Gogh's work and a small understanding of the kind of pain this man went through. I'm still bummed Richard hasn't written another episode for this show.
I have watched this episode dozens of times and I cry uncontrollably at that museum scene every freaking time!
Hm, there was some speculation several years back (Vanity Fair has an article about it on their site from 2014), that van Gogh might not have actually killed themselves, and that they were actually shot by one of those kids who used to throw stones at him (either by accident while playing with a gun or intentionally because children are terrible). Allegedly the poor reputation Vincent had led local people not to bother probing too deeply into his death, and when he became famous it just became another part of his tragic backstory.
Beautiful episode and one that hits close to home. I send you both positive vibes as I see that this episode hit you in the same way ❤
This one is a guaranteed tear jerker.
One of those episodes that transcends the genre. It would still be 45 minutes of great TV even if it was the only Dr Who story ever told.
This is more than my favorite episode of the season, I think its my favorite episode ever.
Wish I could give you a hug. I hope you know we appreciate you and we are giving you your flowers. Your videos make my days as I’m sure they do for others. Thank you! 🤗
The museum guy plays Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean :D Bill Nighy
I weep every time I watch this episode, some of the best television ever.
YES, this episode!!! ❤❤ This is the one that tugs the heartstrings EVERY time. And that song at the end…
Such a great reaction. Thank you guys.
This episode always makes me cry
The scene with Vincent in the museum always gets me 😢
No one is immune to the Van Gogh episode of Doctor Who.
Love this episode. Loved the discussion afterwards.
Well done, gentlemen! 🖖
When you channel first came up in my feed, right after your first Doctor Who reaction, THIS episode is what I stuck around for!
Dr Who can be very emotional. Pass the tissues 😢
This, along with Blink, is considered one of the best DW episodes of all time. WARNING: The room might get a little dusty.
Absolutely! Live Deep dive coming today at noon
th-cam.com/users/liveOSai6g6ATuo?si=dNTNhxMuMmW5YpNS
This episode is a masterpiece. I even showed it to my old mum who's not into scifi at all, but art. :)
That opening shot reminded me of Gladiator. You know the movie with the Roman soldiers?
You know back in the days of Cleopatra
They mentioned that movie they just didn't name it, but named the main character.
I’ve been waiting for you guys to get to this episode.
It's considered easily as one of the top 10 episodes in Dr. Who fandom.
The one bit they neglected to mention in this episode quite understandably being too dark as Dr. Who is a kid's show.
It goes abit deeper than depression Vincent Van Gogh cut off his left ear when tempers flared with Paul Gauguin, the artist with whom he had been working for a while in Arles. Van Gogh's illness revealed itself: he began to hallucinate and suffered attacks in which he lost consciousness.
There is no unaminous agreement on Van Gogh's incapacitating illness. Historians and researchers have variously felt that he might had suffered from elpilespy, bipolar disorder, sunstroke, acute intermittent porphyria, lead poisoning, absinthe intoxication, Meniere's disease, and digitalis toxcity.
The grafayiss is a good metaphor for many types of mental illness.
It is an invisible thing that disrupts a person's life, and the actions a person takes when trying to fight against it or work around it (especially without support) are rational from the perspective of the person dealing with it.
But to others those actions may appear strange, irrational, unreasonable, unsettling etc.
Other people who have some knowledge or experience with mental illness of their own can provide support and help, but even they can only perceive reflected glimpses of the individual's problem, because it is different for everyone.
The last ten minutes 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. Thank you guys for all your work
This episode makes me cry every time! Before I started watching these reactions it’d been like 10 years since I watched the show and I forgot a lot but what I always remember is the scene of Vincent in the museum
Such a beautiful and heartbreaking episode
The museum scene always gets me too.
it took me a couple days to watch this reaction, because just recalling my memories of this ep brought up tears and shuddering breaths. i remember the first time i saw it distinctly... and it wrecked me HARD for the rest of the day. the hyperbole and oscillating heart of an artist and their crushing self doubt yet "we" still persist.
"Tenacity" is the new "Hero Mode", but it can be exhausting for a wounded heart!
Another _Shaun of the Dead_ actor -- Bill Nighy, who played Shaun's stepfather.
This is one of my all time favorite episodes.
I am not a big 11th Doctor fan, but I love this episode. It is a shame Richard Curtis did not write more episodes. He said he wrote this as a tribute to his sister who had suffered severe depression and took her own life.
no matter how many reactions ive seen that scene in the museum never fails to make me cry
Another wonderful part of this episode is seeing Vincent Van Gogh’s most famous paintings come alive… starry night, terrace at night, his bedroom, self portrait, the fields of Provence. Just magical.
Wise wise words 'Guv'nor' and ( to connect another Doctor Who theme) was it Winston Churchill who called depression the 'Black Dog' that always follows you around.
January 5th 2010, my mother's birthday. Me, my sister and her went to Cardiff Bay because there was an IMAX down there (the first James Cameron Avatar film in 3D). Little did we know they were filming the "taking van gogh to the museum" scene outside the Millennium Centre. (Not far from where they parked the TARDIS "over the rift")