@@LittleFamly7 They write in the text book and they have an extra math notebook for scratch paper as there really isn't enough room. I recommend NOT writing in the book and the you can reuse or resell
Thank you! I think I'll finish out 3rd grade with gatb and then switch to Saxon in 4th with the original saxon books and Nicole the math lady! Good plan! Thank you!
Great review! We are going to switch too. I feel the same way about TGTB so many times we have to rewatch videos. We have about 20 lessons left and I am counting down the days 😂😅
I switched 3 weeks ago to Saxon after hearing your daughter didn’t like the fluff in TGATB because that was exactly my 4th grade son 😂 Changing mid-year stressed me out at first but I just kept giving him the the tests until he started getting the same section problems wrong so we started at lesson 35 🤷🏻♀️ He is truly loving it and Nicole the math lady rocks! Paying the extra $20 for grading was the best decision I have made yet 😂
Switching can be stressful!! Glad it’s working out so far! I think we started around lesson 20 but we have to go back sometimes to review prior lessons which is why I love that it tells us what lesson it was taught in ☺️
I'm considering switching my eldest over to Saxon for 4th grade but from what I've gathered, the only editions that were written by Saxon are 1st-3rd and the company that owns it now has changed the newer editions. I'm finding the 2nd edition book used, but I can't find the workbooks or answer key. I wish they were still in print.
Your video was extremely helpful!!! We are in level 3 with TG&TB and plan to switch to this in the spring hopefully. Can I ask you if you feel like there are enough practice sheets with Saxon? I do feel like TG&TB could use extra practice sheets for like multiplication facts, addition etc. Musical multiplication is working well however, extra practice on concepts is just not there. So I am curious on this. Thank you so much you rock!!!
My daughter is taking saxon Algebra 1/2 through her coop, but once we move from this area, I'm sure going to need Nicole, the math lady, to take over 😄. Great review, thanks.
The amount of time lesson takes is comparable to TGAB, atleast when my daughter was in 3rd grade. She is in 5th grade and spends 30-45 minutes on her math lessons
I've been hearing such great things about Nicole the Math Lady. Might have to try her out one day. However, over an hour on math most days seems like a lot. Do you think that is because you guys are fitting everything into 3 days? Or do you think that would be the typical time frame for most kiddos? Thanks for sharing as always!
We were spending over an hour doing all the problems- such a struggle so we switched to Math U See with amazing results. My math hating 5th grader has no more attitudes:)
The teachers guide has all the answers, so with my older daughter I like having it if I need to help her with finding the answers or review a lesson. I would recommend buying it used as you don’t use it a lot of you are also using Nicole the math lady
One thing I’m struggling with is my son doesn’t write out the problems…he literally just solves them in his head. So I’m still trying to decide if I force him to write them out or just let his math brain keep trucking along until he is forced by the curriculum to write them out 😂
Might sound mean, but I wont help my daughter unless I see her work. So really only if she is getting it wrong she has to show me her work. That’s so i can understand what she is doing wrong. I’m sure she is doing some in her head which is fine because she is getting those correct ☺️
@@gatheredandgrounded so far he hasn’t needed my help but that’s a great idea! When he eventually asks me for help I’ll point out I can’t help unless I see your work🙌🏻
My son started with 5/4 and now is on 7/6. When we first started 5/4, he was in 3rd and we had the same issue, so I did write out every problem (I know that is a lot) but it helped avoid him trying to do everything mentally. Now in 7/6 he writes them himself. I know some people skip problems to make the lesson shorter but after 3 yrs I do not skip problems, because I believe the mixed practice is critical to reviewing and retaining past concepts
My son (5th grade) uses teaching textbooks and he does all the problems in his head too. If he gets one wrong, I write it down in a notebook and we do it together on Fridays as his “math review” and then he writes it out, so I can double check he understands it!
This is so funny- my son was the same thru algebra 1/2. After that I made him write them out. Algebra 1 he struggled an Algebra 2 was a fail- we switched to math u see and backtracked to Algebra 1 and he is getting all A's. Algebra 1 and 2 include geometry credit and I think thats why he struggled.
What are your thoughts on Saxon Math? What about the wonderful Nicole the Math Lady?
Thank you for this review, I was wondering if you sue the textbook as a consumable or if you have your daughter write out her math problems?
@@LittleFamly7 They write in the text book and they have an extra math notebook for scratch paper as there really isn't enough room. I recommend NOT writing in the book and the you can reuse or resell
Thank you.
School year here starts in February. I'll be switching from TGATB to Saxon Math too.
Thank you! I think I'll finish out 3rd grade with gatb and then switch to Saxon in 4th with the original saxon books and Nicole the math lady! Good plan! Thank you!
Great review! We are going to switch too. I feel the same way about TGTB so many times we have to rewatch videos. We have about 20 lessons left and I am counting down the days 😂😅
I switched 3 weeks ago to Saxon after hearing your daughter didn’t like the fluff in TGATB because that was exactly my 4th grade son 😂
Changing mid-year stressed me out at first but I just kept giving him the the tests until he started getting the same section problems wrong so we started at lesson 35 🤷🏻♀️
He is truly loving it and Nicole the math lady rocks!
Paying the extra $20 for grading was the best decision I have made yet 😂
Switching can be stressful!! Glad it’s working out so far! I think we started around lesson 20 but we have to go back sometimes to review prior lessons which is why I love that it tells us what lesson it was taught in ☺️
Great vid! Thank you ❤
I'm considering switching my eldest over to Saxon for 4th grade but from what I've gathered, the only editions that were written by Saxon are 1st-3rd and the company that owns it now has changed the newer editions. I'm finding the 2nd edition book used, but I can't find the workbooks or answer key. I wish they were still in print.
Oh and Nicole the math lady does teach the investigations 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
Your video was extremely helpful!!! We are in level 3 with TG&TB and plan to switch to this in the spring hopefully. Can I ask you if you feel like there are enough practice sheets with Saxon? I do feel like TG&TB could use extra practice sheets for like multiplication facts, addition etc. Musical multiplication is working well however, extra practice on concepts is just not there. So I am curious on this. Thank you so much you rock!!!
Yes lots of extra practice! We actually only do half the problems.
My daughter is taking saxon Algebra 1/2 through her coop, but once we move from this area, I'm sure going to need Nicole, the math lady, to take over 😄. Great review, thanks.
Very helpful. Thank you so much!
I love Saxon math for my son. We started with 5/4 and he is in algebra 1 now.
Is there somewhere I can go to see a list of concepts taught in Saxson 4?
I believe on the Nicole The Math Lady’s website she has that information
How long are the lessons my kids have adhd 😅 all 4 of them so lucky we are I just feel like the good and the BEUTIFUL is so long for them
The amount of time lesson takes is comparable to TGAB, atleast when my daughter was in 3rd grade. She is in 5th grade and spends 30-45 minutes on her math lessons
I've been hearing such great things about Nicole the Math Lady. Might have to try her out one day. However, over an hour on math most days seems like a lot. Do you think that is because you guys are fitting everything into 3 days? Or do you think that would be the typical time frame for most kiddos? Thanks for sharing as always!
It would be typical because we are just completing 1 math lesson ☺️
We were spending over an hour doing all the problems- such a struggle so we switched to Math U See with amazing results. My math hating 5th grader has no more attitudes:)
@@sarahbennett7235 we only do half the practice problems ☺️
So if you use Nicole the math lady do you need the teacher manual or you can just get the student book ?
The teachers guide has all the answers, so with my older daughter I like having it if I need to help her with finding the answers or review a lesson. I would recommend buying it used as you don’t use it a lot of you are also using Nicole the math lady
Ummm all math books should display the lesson it was taught!!!! GENUIS!
Right! Any lesson in any type of curriculum 😂
What is split the difference
Not sure what you mean
One thing I’m struggling with is my son doesn’t write out the problems…he literally just solves them in his head. So I’m still trying to decide if I force him to write them out or just let his math brain keep trucking along until he is forced by the curriculum to write them out 😂
Might sound mean, but I wont help my daughter unless I see her work. So really only if she is getting it wrong she has to show me her work. That’s so i can understand what she is doing wrong.
I’m sure she is doing some in her head which is fine because she is getting those correct ☺️
@@gatheredandgrounded so far he hasn’t needed my help but that’s a great idea! When he eventually asks me for help I’ll point out I can’t help unless I see your work🙌🏻
My son started with 5/4 and now is on 7/6. When we first started 5/4, he was in 3rd and we had the same issue, so I did write out every problem (I know that is a lot) but it helped avoid him trying to do everything mentally. Now in 7/6 he writes them himself. I know some people skip problems to make the lesson shorter but after 3 yrs I do not skip problems, because I believe the mixed practice is critical to reviewing and retaining past concepts
My son (5th grade) uses teaching textbooks and he does all the problems in his head too. If he gets one wrong, I write it down in a notebook and we do it together on Fridays as his “math review” and then he writes it out, so I can double check he understands it!
This is so funny- my son was the same thru algebra 1/2. After that I made him write them out. Algebra 1 he struggled an Algebra 2 was a fail- we switched to math u see and backtracked to Algebra 1 and he is getting all A's. Algebra 1 and 2 include geometry credit and I think thats why he struggled.