Also, in the books, when Cedric is told that Harry passed out, he demands that Hufflepuff’s win be nullified, as he didn’t think it was fair with Harry
i love that harry is so much more mischievous in the books. like telling vernon about how his god father is an escaped murderer just to scare him. i wish his mischievousness was more prominent in the movies to show how alike he was to James
One of my favorite mischievous harry moments i think is from book 5 where his uncle asks him why hes listening to the news and harry replies "well you see, it changes everyday" Book harry is also very sarcastic and i love that
I love how J.K Rowling wrote Ron’s character as she made him the purest out of all of them and I heard she based Ron off one of her longtime best friends. But I was really disappointed when Steve Kloves completely degraded his character. They took away all of Ron’s great qualities and gave them to Hermione and took all of Hermione’s bad qualities and gave them to Ron
@Olivia Yang Alfonso Cuarón didn’t write the fucking screenplay it was written by Steve cloves . All Alfonso did was take his mediocre script and try to make it good .
@@jennipark6107 They even make Ron whine about chopping his broken leg off while they get out of the Shack. EXCUSE MOI RON CARED MORE ABOUT HARRY THAN HIS BROKEN LEG.
Book Ron and Book Hermione: A street-smart pragmatic jock and a book-smart logical nerd. Movie Ron and Movie Hermione: A lackey village idiot and an all-knowing goddess.
this is why Hermione slapping (not punching btw) Malfoy feels that much better in the book. it's so much more out of character for Book Hermione to physically assault a student than Movie Hermione, who for some reason got painted out to be much more than she actually was. *EDIT* : also book Hermione is supposed to have buck teeth (which i believe Morgan covered in his PS video), and that only goes away when in GoF Malfoy (or was it Goyle?) jinxes her & makes them grow even longer, and then she tells Madam Pomfrey to shrink them to even shorter than what it was previously! it's only after this that Hermione's "beauty" is ever mentioned, and this is when Ron started noticing her as a potential dating partner (which ironically started with their awkward moment at the Yule Ball).
@@jovanym2931 why not Chandler and Ron had insecurities associated with his family and witty and practical Monica and Hermione had issues with their appearance and are very smart and loves to be the leader
I liked how Ron defended Hermione against Snape even when he was angry with her over crookshanks. Also, Ron stood ON A BROKEN LEG to tell a apparent murderer that he wouldn’t let him near his best friend. Both of these moments highlight his character and shows his loyalty and bravery. It’s a shame they changed it in the movies.
@@cinnagrits You are a draco stan, but like you are not obsessed with him. You still think ron amd hermionie deserve each other, and harry and ginny deserve each other and you dont ship dramionie right?
This is making me realize, especially as someone who has only watched the films, that Ron is not that bad, but actually a good character and overall a great friend which wasn't really represented all too well in the films
You forgot to mention them giving Harry’s “I trusted you!” line in the book to Hermione in the movie, which was one of the most irritating changes because it made no sense because Harry was the one who bonded with Lupin. Not Hermione… 🤦♂️
Well in Hermione’s case she thought she was the only one who knew Lupin was a werewolf, but she was willing to keep it a secret for him because she thought he was a good man and teacher.
1st Harry Potter Movie Differences: 30 minutes 2nd Harry Potter Movie Differences: 40 minutes 3rd Harry Potter Movie Differences: 40 minutes 4th Harry Potter Movie Differences: 10 hours Edit: omg I hit 1k likes lmao thanks
I always hated the scene where Ron agrees with Snape when he calls Hermoine an insufferable know-it-all. Just another way the directors completely butchered Ron's character.
Aging up the Marauders, Lily, and Snape actually annoys me. Part of the tragedy is how young Lily and James were when they died. They had barely left school or had time to start their lives, and yet they were prepared to die fighting. I've always felt this is part of the reason why Harry accepted the need to fight so young, because that is what his parents did. Snape's character also makes so much more sense if he is 30, rather than nearing 50. Snape's life basically freezes or ends when Lily dies. When Lily died he was only out of school for about two years. That is mostly why he is still so angry at his high school bullies, and still so deeply in love with his childhood best friend. That is why he was stupid enough go to Voldemort to save Lily and why he was immature enough to not care if James lived or died. Snape was still a kid when he was a death eater.
Underrated opinion. So true, the youth of Harry's parents and all their contemporaries feels important to Harry's character, the war, and the playfulness, strength, and hope (not middle-aged wisdom) that are embodied in Lily and the Marauders.
Ron :- Is street-smart, brave, deeply cares for everyone he loves and is fiercely loyal to his friends. Steve Kloves:- I'm gonna end this man's whole career
I will never forgive that Steve Kloves for taking away Ron’s famous line: ”If you want to kill Harry, you’ll have to kill us too!” and giving it to Hermione. Here we have Ron Weasley, standing up straight on a frickin BROKEN LEG (that he got from trying to PROTECT HARRY). Enduring pain that would make a pro wrestler cry like a little bitch, just to tell a known mass murderer to F*CK OFF from his friend. That’s some real loyalty and bravery. AND IT WASN’T IN THE MOVIE.....
@@voltrainer It also kinda sucks considering the fact that Rowling agreed to the butchering of Ron because Hermione was hers and the directors favourite. Even Harry was downplayed because of Hermione.
The reason the broken leg scene change pisses me off is because it sets a parallel to Lily's sacrifice. A mother willing to die in order to save her son speaks as much volume as a best friend standing on a broken leg to shield you from a presumed murderer. What's even more fantastic, the only other character who shares the same wand characteristics as Ron (willow with unicorn core) is Lily!!!!
"I, Sirius Black, Harry Potter's GODFATHER, hereby give him permission to visit hogsmeade at weekends" This is one of my favourite lines in the whole franchise ❤️
Technically Sirius actually had Crookshanks buy the Firebolt for Harry because he couldn't be seen at the Owl Office placing the order, though Crookshanks bought it with Sirius' money in Harry's name. The movie completely fails to portray how ridiculously smart that cat actually was in the books.
Crookshanks wasn’t even a regular cat. I can’t recall the name, but essentially the species that Crookshanks owed part of his lineage to were essentially a species of feline familiars, possessing vastly higher intellects. Additionally, Sirius had informed Crookshanks of who Scabbers truly was and the danger he posed to the trio, thus why he continued to pursue them in the hopes of bringing them back to Sirius in his dog form.
@@hiddendesire3076Crookshanks actually knew that was Peter was an Animagus. Just like Hermione figured out Rita was an Animagus in the 4th book. Crookshanks was Hermione’s familiar, not just her pet…
I actually like the movie showing ice forming when Dementors are around. It used to annoy me because it differed from the book, but the film doesn’t give us the internal monologue of them making everyone feel cold inside. This was the film makers’ way of conveying that and I’ve really warmed up to it. Pun intended 😉
100% agree, I started reading the books recently as I was just a child watching the movies so I'm going back and forth reading a book then watching the film adaptation, and I actually really enjoyed how they portrayed the "coldness" of the dementors
I thought the cold was a good way to portray the despair they give off. But I did not like the fact the gave them flight. Harry on a broom during quidditch looked down on the dementors during the first quidditch match. They didn’t fly.
Still hate how the screenwriter gave Hermione Ron’s line of “if you want to kill Harry, you’ll have to kill us, too.” It was one of Ron’s amazing brave moment. It was the moment where he showed how much he cared about Harry that he was even willing to _die_ with him. Right there, he bravely stood up to Sirius, who he thought was a freaking murderer. And declaring that, if he (Sirius) is going to kill Harry, then he should kill him, too. And he did that ON A BROKEN LEG. but of course, the screenwriter just _had_ to give his moment to Hermione. Just like he did with plenty of other Ron moments. Is giving Ron his own lines and moments a torture or something?
The way the movies portrayed Harry and Ron’s friendship made people misunderstand their relationship. Harry and Ron were CLOSE, like inseparable. They immediatly became friends on the train and Ron was already very loyal offering to be Harry’s wingman in the midnight duel and even sacrificing himself in the game of chess. The movies did fine in the first two, but then it slowly got toned down and they didn’t seem nearly as close as they were in the books.
@@puttrik4865 Yess. In the books, Hermione is the third wheel when it comes to hanging out like teenagers. But in the films, Ron acts like the unneeded third wheel. I was mad how they screwed up Harry and Ron's reunion in DHP1 after destroying the locket. The entire emotional conversation thry ha din the book is not even there in the film!!!!
@@kavishbedi9281 yea it’s very disappointing , since the source material was all there in front of them, all they needed was to follow it, but for some reason they seemed to hate the weasley’s (ginny was butchered and even fred and george got nerfed).
@@tuopsy cuz they loved her a little too much id say. I actually liked hermione because of her flaws its make her more human and interesting. Air brushing her flaws just make her seem boring and unrealistic and also a completly diffrent character in the process
If you want to kill Harry you'll have to kill us too. The one thing I'll never forgive this movie doing is giving Hermione's Ron's line. that was one of his most defining moments of friendship and loyalty to Harry
Honestly I’m more pissed of at the addition of the “he’s got a point you know” line because at least the removal of the “ you want to kill Harry you have to kill us too” was at least inconsequential
I loved the foreshadowing in Philosopher's Stone where Hagrid says to Dumbledore that Sirius let him borrow his motorbike. Already heard about Sirius in the first book without even realising!
@@davidw.2791 Sirius Black was in Gryffindor, not Slytherin. Oh, but if you are talking about how Gryffindors are also "Evil" then yes, that does beg the question. For instance, later when we find out about Pettigrew. He is a Gryffindor that went bad. And also, if you count bullying, then the Gryffindors is just as guilty of that as the Slytherins (just look at James, Sirius, Harry and Ron bullying other students and Filch).
@@dannyjorde2677 That’s the point though! Yes Sirius was framed, but the real perp (Wormtail) and the officially accepted traitor (Sirius himself) until PoA… were both Gryffindors! And yet Hagrid gotta maintain that bigotry at all costs!!! It’ll be like claiming that, say, black people never murder their spouses, in a world where OJ Simpson was indeed found guilty, and is serving jail time!
@@TheMbangel Hagrid’s famous line is that ALL VOLDEMORT’s FOLLOWERS COME OUT OF SLYTHERIN (if it wasn’t All Dark Magicians, Period). You only need ONE opposite example to prove such a statement wrong. And boy howdy does Wormtail/Sirius blow that precious little bigotry up to kingdom come?!
One missing difference here: In the film Harry sees a cloud shaped as the Grimm but in the book he just sees Sirius sitting on the Quidditch stand as a Dog. So from a secret friend who wanted to see his godson play they changed to The worst Omen of death.
Thank you! and it's such an emotional moment in the Shrieking Shack when Sirius tells Harry he only got in to watch him play Quidditch... that he plays like his dad... and looks at him in the eye and tells him he'd rather die before betraying Lily and James and Harry believes him... that's such a beautiful moment
the book brings across the relationship between harry and sirius much better. This leads to movie 5 where it wasn't that sad when sirius died but in the books it was so so freakin tragic
Also Crookshanks was a very smart cat, he knew in diagon alley that scabbers was not a rat and later he helped Sirius because he realised Sirius was not a dog and Sirius had explained everything to crookshanks and crookshanks decided to help after a lot of deliberation. Crookshanks hadn’t trusted Sirius immediately
In the book, Harry was ten minutes late for defense against the dark arts the day Snape filled in for Lupin because Oliver Wood held him up discussing their upcoming quidditch match. In the film, he was on time for class and Wood's role from the book was cut from the film entirely.
wood, percy, lavender, pervati, cho, lee jordan, wood, cedric and others were almost entirely left out, or completely left out. Its actually so crazy to me. I wanna see all their lines on a movie even if it's boring
I recently realized that, right before Sirius escapes on Buckbeak, in the book, he asks about Ron ("What about the other boy--Ron?"), while in the movie, he does not ask about Ron ("I'll be eternally grateful for this. To both of you (Harry and Hermione).").
The actor who played Goyle was injured before filming started and couldn't work on this movie. Later its Crabbe who is replaced (in the movies) after he was arrested on drug possession charges.
This may just be my hot take here, but I actually really like Lupin’s werewolf form in the movie. The scrawniness, hunched back, and crackling bones (while he’s transforming) makes it seem like an ungodly affliction. Something that you wouldn’t even wish on your worst enemy. (Edit): Also, the wolfsbane potion didn’t completely stop Lupin from turning into a wolf. It just allowed him to “keep his mind” while he was one. “I was a very small boy when I received the bite. My parents tried everything, but in those days there was no cure. The Potion that Professor Snape has been making for me is a very recent discovery. It makes me safe, you see. As long as I take it in the week preceding the full moon, I keep my mind when I transform... I am able to curl up in my office, a harmless wolf, and wait for the moon to wane again. Before the Wolfsbane Potion was discovered, however, I became a fully fledged monster once a month. It seemed impossible that I would be able to come to Hogwarts. Other parents weren't likely to want their children exposed to me.”
I haven’t read the books in a while, but if I remember correctly Cedric tried to have the match replayed because he realized what happened to Harry, and he didn’t think it was fair for Hufflepuff to win that way Gryffindor turned him down but it’s a nice little moment that shows you what kind of a person Cedric is
They could have done this. They could have done it without even having to cast a guy to play Cedric one film before his big outing in GoF. But Cuaron decided the Quidditch mid game (where Harry DID successfully cast a Patronus but it “doesn’t count” as the dementors were not real ones) and finale (where Gryffindor wins partially so that Malfoy can stfu about being smug that Buckbeak was gonna die).
Lily and James: So how was your first meeting with our son? Snape: I called him a celebrity, asked him some potion related questions and took 10 points from Gryffindor because his neighbor made a potion that nearly killed the whole class. Remus: I saved him from a Dementor and gave him chocolate. Sirius: I kidnapped his best friend to get his rat, broke his ankle, then he and his friends beat me up, Remus came and we talked for hours about our school days, then Snape came almost caught us but got knocked out, Peter turned human again, me and Remus tried to kill him but Harry wouldn't let us, Remus changed into a werewolf, Peter escaped, and we got attacked by dementors, but don't worry Harry from the future came and saved us. Oh, and I asked Harry to stay with me over the summer and he said yes! Everyone: .... Snape: and you all think I'm the one with issues?
I’m glad someone finally pointed out how many important plot details were missed during the Shrieking Shack scene. No one ever complains about them but it completely skips over who Moony, Wormtail, Padofoot and Prongs are, how Sirius escaped from Azkaban (a question brought up during the Knight Bus scene) etc…
@@dannyjorde2677, really? I guess for die hard book fans that’s true but when it comes to casual fans and cinephiles, I never see them complain about this plothole
It absolutely baffles me how Steve Kloves thought that by erasing all of Hermione’s endearing flaws from the books he was “fixing” her character. Like, I don’t know, Steve. A character with zero flaws and relatability who knows exactly what to do and how to do it in every given situation sounds like a pretty boring character to me. 🤷♂️
@@securityc.a.m.9539 But knowing how J.K. has been like in all these recent years, I wouldn't feel good if she has a say should they make a television series reboot.
@@kavishbedi9281 That’s a fair point, but I was talking about pre-Twitter J.K. You know, while the original movies were being created and released. She should have been the screenwriter then.
I really hate how the movies cut off important scenes like these and giving hermione half of Ron's lines like in the chamber of secrets when malfoy called hermione a mudblood she understands the meaning and explain it not Ron's like there making hermione the pureblood and Ron's the muggleborn.
I cannot remember correctly, but I believe the Marauders and Harry’s parents’ casting choices were influenced by casting Alan Rickman as Snape. Since he is older, they had to make the others older.
I feel like they really changed the entire character of Ron and his loyalty towards Harry in the movies. They also made him overshadowed and changed his intelligence levels in the films. I think they wanted to just make him a more likeable, easy going, and Harry's sidekick. They should have let Ron's character shine a bit more and it is really upsetting with some of the changes.
Another small detail that people don't mention is that students at Hogwarts usually wore Wizarding clothes and not just muggle jeans and shirts... something which becomes important as in the Half Blood Prince Snape cuts points from Gryffindor because Harry entered the school grounds wearing muggle clothes. While in the film we saw all the time the trio are wearing muggle clothes
The movies from the third on lost the magic. Everything is gray and dull, rarely people are using wizards clothes, and spells are just a bunch of colored explosions without any effect or fun to them.
16:10 the wolfsbane potion actually doesn't stop a werewolf from turning, it just makes em lazy and less harmful and if I remember correctly also reduce the pain in transforming 😃 I love your videos btw keep going!👍
Finished reading a few days back and I’m shocked at how much more I enjoyed the book compared to what most believe to be the best film in the series. The difference between heaven and earth imo.
@@joshz2491 It's a great movie and adaptation. Aside from them butchering Ron a bit, it's a fantastic film that I would argue is better than the book in many ways.
It's really annoying how they left out all the marauders back story and why Hermione had a time turner. I also felt frustrated when Harry and Hermione didn't tell Ron what happened but I imagine they told him off-screen.
I really loved the scene of Snape protecting the trio from Lupin. It shows that even though he is a horrible teacher, hes still a teacher and cares about his students.
That was totally out of character. I've always annoyed by some stupid comments like Alan Rickman is a perfect Snape and Emma Watson is a perfect Hermione.
I'm reading the books and Harry actually comes of as a little dumb sometimes x) maybe it's because I already know the outcome of the story (since I've watched the films) but Harry can be insufferably stupid at rare occasions.
Harry: *spares Pettigrew* Sirius: *casts Imperious curse on Pettigrew* Everyone: *stops Snape to tell him what happened, then they turn Pettigrew in* Lupin and prob Sirius: *deals with Lupin's transformation* Hermione & Harry: *uses time turner to save Buckbeak* *End credits and story is all better* ❤️
Unfortunately, it is a contest between Sirius and Severus on who’s moar immature. Just look at Sirius’s choice to bang Snape’s head on the tunnel ceiling, when, with Snape all tied up, Sirius could wake him up and force him to look at Wormtail. For justice reasons, and for “Rub it in Snivellus’s face” reasons.
I know Steve Kloves loves hermione and made her this untouchable genius, but he must have had some sorta hatred for Ron the way he just absolutely butchered his character
Thank you for summarizing. Unfortunately you forgot a little scene. You forgot the scene in which Lupine shoots chewing gum in Peves' nostril after he tried to stuff it into a key lock.
Theory: Crookshanks is actually James and Lily's previous cat, and when they died he was placed in a pet shop. He recognized Sirius in his dog form and his human form, and he also recognized Peter which is why he was always after him. And if Ron let Crookshanks eat Scabbers, Dobby, Tonks, Cedric, Lupin, Sirius, etc would all be alive as Voldemort would have never been revived. The hero of the story would be a cat!
Another theory is that Crookshanks is actually Serious’s brother (idk how to spell his name) who knew how to turn in a animajis because Serious did and left a something lying around that told you how to turn into a animal. And he survived Voldemort’s horcrucks and was angry when Peter framed Serious. So he decided he wanted to eat Peter. This theory is kinda off some parts don’t make sense but it’s still know throughout Pinterest.
The bond of the Marauders and how that plays as a character motivation for Harry is one of the most important parts of the series and it really saddens me that they cut nearly all of that background information in POA. Harry's "Prongs" line is so emotional and not only is it not in the movie, but it wouldn't make sense if it was there. I still see POA as the best movie though, I think Alfonso was the best director of the 4 and he did a great job adapting the book to a movie. The way he shows the time-turner and the interactions between future and past Harry and Hermione here is more comprehensible than it is in the book, and more interesting.
A lot of people consider this their favorite movie mainly cuz of the style. Realistically though, it contradicted so much of the established HP universe and left out so many plot essential details. The worst atrocities are the trio walking around Hogwarts grounds in MUGGLE CLOTHING, and the use of magic outside school.
@@nahor88 It's just a great movie all around. Most people who criticize the movies can't do so without comparing them to the books. It's a great adaptation aside from a few things.
one of the only changes i prefer in the movie over the book was lupin's werewolf form. That lanky almost human appearance that looks more wolf-like the closer u get to it was actually terrifying when I was young. It still creeps me out, but I like just how horrifying he looks compared to the book where u could confuse him with an actual regular wolf which is scary too, but not as visibly disturbing. Like one look at movie Wolf-lupin and u can feel why he hates his werewolf side
The whole thing with Hermione and the Firebolt being cut is to be expected considering how Steve Clovis’ favorite character is Hermione so he didn’t want to make her look awful in any way.
How tf would it have made her look awful? More like intelligent and caring. It's common sense not to accept anonymous gifts when you know there's a serial killer after you.
Potter fans: hey writers do you think we could stop giving all of Ron’s important lines and discoveries to Hermione ? Potter Movie Writers: I guess we can let him find and chase scabbers
Correction: Pettigrew is not using a wand to turn into Scabbers. He just picked up a dropped wand and tried to attack Sirius and Lupin and only transforms back when Harry disarms him.
This is really the beginning of Ron getting his moments shafted in favor of proping up Hermione because she's a certain screenwriters favorite character.
Me too. The book was instantly my favourite and when I first watched the movie it was with my childhood best friend, I slept at hers that night. For this memory alone I just have to love the movie
I didn’t like the movie very much. I get how much had to be cut because of time restraints, but they cut out the best parts. Like Harry learning about his father’s stag form. Plus they cut out the Quidditch final and the Griffindors winning the title. They also cut out the what the prophecy was and Dumbledore learning about it. And Ron’s shocking but funny quote to Peter, “I let you sleep in my bed!”
@@Capri_00 I know that the movie left out all those things, but it is my favourite Harry Potter movie anyway, especially because of the memory of watching it for the first time
Hi even though you probably won’t see this I just wanted to say that I ve been having rly hard times recently and your videos make me forget about all my problems so thank you very much Love the videos and keep it up
The editing of these videos makes the content even more enjoyable - very well analysed, and it’s been releasing just in time with me starting to read the books! Awesome job, thank you!
The fact that they made Ron agree with Snape will forever haunt me lol The fact that he took her defense even when he was mad with her because of her cat says a lot about their relationship. He cares for her no matter what. That's without having to mention how they stripped him from his lines and him standing up against Sirius, defending Harry.
It's such a coincidence because all 8 of the hp movies are showing on tv every saturday, and Prisoner of Azkaban just came on tv yesterday, and the next day this video comes out. Truly incredible.
Great clip as usual ☺️. One correction, though: the potion Snape gives Lupin does not stop him from turning (if it did, he wouldn't have to stay away at all), but it lets him keep his own sense of mind like a "harmless wolf".
17:12 I believe there is one more difference that you didn't mention, is that in the film, Harry sees the Grim in a cloud before getting attacked by the dementors, and in the book, he sees Sirius' animagus form, that looks like the Grim
Book readers knew it from the very beginning that POA is where the movies actually started getting bad in terms of story telling and character development. POA is only good from Cinematic POV.
Nah a lot of the things in this film were done really well, they did Ron dirty and left out the marauders but other than that it was a great adaptation, condensing weeks into a night is just good writing if you kept it all it would be 4 hours long at least and it would be quite boring.
I’m so impressed by all of these facts that you listed. This is a 41 minute video of you listening tons of random facts from the Harry Potter book. It’s so much detail and must have taken so long. It’s so impressive. You really are one of the greatest TH-camrs out there always putting so much effort into your videos
as for the ages of the marauders- the casting directors really wanted alan rickman as snape, so they aged up the others in order to have alan as a convincing snape
Great work as usual. I’ve read the books several times over, most recently in audiobook format, so I know all about the various differences between the 2 mediums. Still enjoy watching these for how they’re presented tho. Yet saying that the fact that Lupin’s werewolf form is more like that of a regular wolf in the book has always escaped me for some reason. Probably ‘cause I have a habit of picturing the characters as they appear in the films ever since watching those. Interesting choice by the filmmakers given what JK was obviously going for.
27:51 Emma Watson didn’t mean to throw a punch at Tom Felton. The script called for her to slap him just like in the book, but Emma got carried away and threw a punch instead. After the director yelled “Cut”, she went to see if Tom was okay and apologized for what she did. Not the only time a Harry Potter actor got a little to physical with another actor. In one of the later movies, Helena Bonham Carter, who played Bellatrix LeStrange, stuck her wand in Matthew Lewis’s ear…and accidentally perforated his eardrum, resulting in the Neville Longbottom actor going deaf in that ear for a week!
Two of my favourite moments from this movie: 12:30 Malfoy saying "It's killed me! It's killed me!" and 13:50 Malfoy saying "This class is Ridiculous" and Crabbe nodding 😂😂
He also for got that lupin tells them that while being less wolfish in the mind while with his animagus friends, and that because of this they used to run around outside not in the shrieking shack😕
I think the actors being older works because all three characters are super stressed and prematurely aged. Harry even says that Lupin and greying hair. Being left in Azkaban I think that Sirius would also look stressed out and much older than he really was.
I tend to be a purist when comparing book to movie conversions. Though I do understand that there are things that don't convert well, like inner monologues. With that in mind, I can give a pass for depicting frost when dementors are around in the movie as a way of showing the intense cold that is felt in the book.
![[MV] A leap of faith...ความเชื่อใจครั้งสุดท้าย (From "Petrichor the series")](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U1piZH2CNXA/mqdefault.jpg)
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for watching! Stay tuned for Part 4!
Ok
Thanks for making them!!!
Sure
I’m tired
:D
man is out here grinding and representing Ron fans 🙏
Y E S
Fr
And we love him for that
@@pxxv5370 True
@@kavishbedi9281 like I still love hermione but I honestly like the book one better because she is much better with flaws
Correction: the Wolfsbane Potion does NOT prevent Lupin from turning into a werewolf. It simply allows him to keep his mind while he's in wolf form.
^ yes, he still turns into a wolf, but it’s like an animagus turning into an animal, they still have their human mind.
And he is also very sleepy and just peacefully sleeps while in his transformed form
Yup, difference between this video and book.
@@pike239 I want to draw that
Exactly, there's no cure for someone that's contamined with werewolf bites
Also, in the books, when Cedric is told that Harry passed out, he demands that Hufflepuff’s win be nullified, as he didn’t think it was fair with Harry
Nice
I love this ❤️
I’m surprised he missed this
i didn't know this and i think this comment just made me have a crush on Cedric 😂
@@fishiesgaminghahah welcome to the Cedric Diggory appreciation society
i love that harry is so much more mischievous in the books. like telling vernon about how his god father is an escaped murderer just to scare him. i wish his mischievousness was more prominent in the movies to show how alike he was to James
Didn’t he also harass Cho Chang?
One of my favorite mischievous harry moments i think is from book 5 where his uncle asks him why hes listening to the news and harry replies "well you see, it changes everyday"
Book harry is also very sarcastic and i love that
@@IdiotSandwich69420loluh what? No. That NEVER happened
@@AnInkStick um in the fifth book?
@@IdiotSandwich69420lolexample?
I love how J.K Rowling wrote Ron’s character as she made him the purest out of all of them and I heard she based Ron off one of her longtime best friends. But I was really disappointed when Steve Kloves completely degraded his character. They took away all of Ron’s great qualities and gave them to Hermione and took all of Hermione’s bad qualities and gave them to Ron
Taking away arguably Ron’s bravest moment in standing up to an alleged murderer while on a BROKEN LEG and giving it to Hermione burns me to this day
Yup.
@Olivia Yang
Alfonso Cuarón didn’t write the fucking screenplay it was written by Steve cloves . All Alfonso did was take his mediocre script and try to make it good .
Same dude, same
Same. As well as the scene when instead of talking back to Snape and defending Hermione, he agrees with Snape’s insult to his friend. 🙄🙄😡😡😡😡
@@jennipark6107 They even make Ron whine about chopping his broken leg off while they get out of the Shack.
EXCUSE MOI RON CARED MORE ABOUT HARRY THAN HIS BROKEN LEG.
Book Ron and Book Hermione: A street-smart pragmatic jock and a book-smart logical nerd.
Movie Ron and Movie Hermione: A lackey village idiot and an all-knowing goddess.
@Olivia Yang
After he finished it
this is why Hermione slapping (not punching btw) Malfoy feels that much better in the book. it's so much more out of character for Book Hermione to physically assault a student than Movie Hermione, who for some reason got painted out to be much more than she actually was.
*EDIT* : also book Hermione is supposed to have buck teeth (which i believe Morgan covered in his PS video), and that only goes away when in GoF Malfoy (or was it Goyle?) jinxes her & makes them grow even longer, and then she tells Madam Pomfrey to shrink them to even shorter than what it was previously! it's only after this that Hermione's "beauty" is ever mentioned, and this is when Ron started noticing her as a potential dating partner (which ironically started with their awkward moment at the Yule Ball).
Like Chandler and Monica
@@incognitouser8256
No
@@jovanym2931 why not
Chandler and Ron had insecurities associated with his family and witty and practical
Monica and Hermione had issues with their appearance and are very smart and loves to be the leader
I liked how Ron defended Hermione against Snape even when he was angry with her over crookshanks. Also, Ron stood ON A BROKEN LEG to tell a apparent murderer that he wouldn’t let him near his best friend.
Both of these moments highlight his character and shows his loyalty and bravery. It’s a shame they changed it in the movies.
How many of these comments are there, this must be an irritating difference.
@@MarioGame2
It’s EXTREMELY irritating! The movies completely ruined Ron’s character and they made Hermione way too perfect :(
@@cinnagrits Sont bother him. He is probbably a Draco Stan.
@@CorporealNatural1
Hey! I’m a Draco Stan.😐 (although I see where you’re coming from👍🏼)
@@cinnagrits You are a draco stan, but like you are not obsessed with him. You still think ron amd hermionie deserve each other, and harry and ginny deserve each other and you dont ship dramionie right?
This is making me realize, especially as someone who has only watched the films, that Ron is not that bad, but actually a good character and overall a great friend which wasn't really represented all too well in the films
Same here.
They made him out to be a useless filler character in the movies. In the books through the entire series he was an important character.
Nah, he was a good character in the movies as well.
@@legoyoda9782 nah they made them look bad especially in the deathly hallows movies
In the movies he was a looser and in the books, they’re pretty close to each other and that’s how the trio was formed.
You forgot to mention them giving Harry’s “I trusted you!” line in the book to Hermione in the movie, which was one of the most irritating changes because it made no sense because Harry was the one who bonded with Lupin. Not Hermione… 🤦♂️
Right
they really do milk Hermione in the films, it makes her go from intelligent and kind to a bit of an insufferable "get out of jail free card"
Yeah, WTF were they thinking?
Well in Hermione’s case she thought she was the only one who knew Lupin was a werewolf, but she was willing to keep it a secret for him because she thought he was a good man and teacher.
This is something I picked up in the movie without ever reading the book. I was like "Huh? Why did you trust him so much?"
Let’s give MovieFlame some credit for doing this even whilst recovering.
Yeah I absolutely agree
@@gibbsterV Same
Fr
Recovering from what?
@@heatherroberson8981 idrk
1st Harry Potter Movie Differences: 30 minutes
2nd Harry Potter Movie Differences: 40 minutes
3rd Harry Potter Movie Differences: 40 minutes
4th Harry Potter Movie Differences: 10 hours
Edit: omg I hit 1k likes lmao thanks
did you put your name in the goblet of fire he said calmly
@@sh0ts420 HARRY, DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE!!
Yeah....the movie screwed the book so badly
From this point on, the videos are probably going to be hours long. It'd be worth it though.
What about order of phoenix
There have been many and many left
And i am sure it would take 2 parts
I always hated the scene where Ron agrees with Snape when he calls Hermoine an insufferable know-it-all. Just another way the directors completely butchered Ron's character.
You've got a point, you know.
I feel like they had some sort of Vendetta against the Weasleys lol, like they made Ginny bland as a blank sheet of paper
@@cringeygachakidthatalsodoe7154 True, they all butchered my fav fictional fam. 😒
@@kavishbedi9281 But I think Fred and George were great tho 😭
@@dardarya223 So was Molly
Aging up the Marauders, Lily, and Snape actually annoys me. Part of the tragedy is how young Lily and James were when they died. They had barely left school or had time to start their lives, and yet they were prepared to die fighting. I've always felt this is part of the reason why Harry accepted the need to fight so young, because that is what his parents did.
Snape's character also makes so much more sense if he is 30, rather than nearing 50. Snape's life basically freezes or ends when Lily dies. When Lily died he was only out of school for about two years. That is mostly why he is still so angry at his high school bullies, and still so deeply in love with his childhood best friend. That is why he was stupid enough go to Voldemort to save Lily and why he was immature enough to not care if James lived or died. Snape was still a kid when he was a death eater.
Yep. According to a lot of psychologists and psychiatrists the brain reaches adulthood when one becomes 25.
Yeah the actors are great, especially Alan Rickman, but too old for the characters.
Underrated opinion. So true, the youth of Harry's parents and all their contemporaries feels important to Harry's character, the war, and the playfulness, strength, and hope (not middle-aged wisdom) that are embodied in Lily and the Marauders.
@@coloredpencils01 they played it of as Stress aged them faster
Were they actually aged up or just played by older people, because there is a difference
Ron :- Is street-smart, brave, deeply cares for everyone he loves and is fiercely loyal to his friends.
Steve Kloves:- I'm gonna end this man's whole career
Yup
And now let’s end Steve Kloves’ career……….
And now he's back at it in Secrets of Dumbledore, I wonder what he's done now.
It was personal for that d*mb f*ck m. 😒
I will never forgive that Steve Kloves for taking away Ron’s famous line: ”If you want to kill Harry, you’ll have to kill us too!” and giving it to Hermione.
Here we have Ron Weasley, standing up straight on a frickin BROKEN LEG (that he got from trying to PROTECT HARRY). Enduring pain that would make a pro wrestler cry like a little bitch, just to tell a known mass murderer to F*CK OFF from his friend. That’s some real loyalty and bravery.
AND IT WASN’T IN THE MOVIE.....
Yes very VERY infuriating
book Ron is a f*cking hero holy shit
@@aki4ketski it's ok. He's expressing something we all felt for a long time in a way that most of us would have done.
he's basically tied with samwise the brave for most loyal book friends
And him standing up to Snape too , that line says so much about who Ron was as a character but the movies destroyed his image.
They really stole everything from Ron didn’t they.
Yes, yes they did
Yess they did ron dirty, like Hermione did all the work and ron was always left out
Yes. It's insane how the movies flat out do ron dirty to fluff hermione up. Which we know is Rowlings semi-self insert.
@@voltrainer It also kinda sucks considering the fact that Rowling agreed to the butchering of Ron because Hermione was hers and the directors favourite.
Even Harry was downplayed because of Hermione.
The reason the broken leg scene change pisses me off is because it sets a parallel to Lily's sacrifice. A mother willing to die in order to save her son speaks as much volume as a best friend standing on a broken leg to shield you from a presumed murderer.
What's even more fantastic, the only other character who shares the same wand characteristics as Ron (willow with unicorn core) is Lily!!!!
"I, Sirius Black, Harry Potter's GODFATHER, hereby give him permission to visit hogsmeade at weekends"
This is one of my favourite lines in the whole franchise ❤️
When I first read this line.. I cried..it was really beautiful..😭😭
@@fauziyalateef7477 Me too
I don't know why but I had read that line many times and still feel heart touching
They shouldn't have killed sirius😩
You mean...Dogfather🐶
@@Rachel-md5ss that's been taken.
@@v.k.rt.m.6030 wdym
Technically Sirius actually had Crookshanks buy the Firebolt for Harry because he couldn't be seen at the Owl Office placing the order, though Crookshanks bought it with Sirius' money in Harry's name. The movie completely fails to portray how ridiculously smart that cat actually was in the books.
Crookshanks wasn’t even a regular cat. I can’t recall the name, but essentially the species that Crookshanks owed part of his lineage to were essentially a species of feline familiars, possessing vastly higher intellects. Additionally, Sirius had informed Crookshanks of who Scabbers truly was and the danger he posed to the trio, thus why he continued to pursue them in the hopes of bringing them back to Sirius in his dog form.
@@hiddendesire3076 he was part kneazle.
@@hiddendesire3076Crookshanks actually knew that was Peter was an Animagus. Just like Hermione figured out Rita was an Animagus in the 4th book. Crookshanks was Hermione’s familiar, not just her pet…
yesss. That's why her cat was always after rons rat. He knew who he was the whole movie. Only if he could have talked lol@@Yvanehtnioj2000
How would a cat go to a shipping company and send a broom to harry without anyone thinking that a bit weird
I actually like the movie showing ice forming when Dementors are around. It used to annoy me because it differed from the book, but the film doesn’t give us the internal monologue of them making everyone feel cold inside. This was the film makers’ way of conveying that and I’ve really warmed up to it. Pun intended 😉
Plus it gives them the “oh shit, they’re here!” factor
100% agree, I started reading the books recently as I was just a child watching the movies so I'm going back and forth reading a book then watching the film adaptation, and I actually really enjoyed how they portrayed the "coldness" of the dementors
I thought the cold was a good way to portray the despair they give off. But I did not like the fact the gave them flight. Harry on a broom during quidditch looked down on the dementors during the first quidditch match. They didn’t fly.
Still hate how the screenwriter gave Hermione Ron’s line of “if you want to kill Harry, you’ll have to kill us, too.”
It was one of Ron’s amazing brave moment. It was the moment where he showed how much he cared about Harry that he was even willing to _die_ with him. Right there, he bravely stood up to Sirius, who he thought was a freaking murderer. And declaring that, if he (Sirius) is going to kill Harry, then he should kill him, too. And he did that ON A BROKEN LEG.
but of course, the screenwriter just _had_ to give his moment to Hermione. Just like he did with plenty of other Ron moments. Is giving Ron his own lines and moments a torture or something?
The way the movies portrayed Harry and Ron’s friendship made people misunderstand their relationship. Harry and Ron were CLOSE, like inseparable. They immediatly became friends on the train and Ron was already very loyal offering to be Harry’s wingman in the midnight duel and even sacrificing himself in the game of chess. The movies did fine in the first two, but then it slowly got toned down and they didn’t seem nearly as close as they were in the books.
@@puttrik4865 Yess. In the books, Hermione is the third wheel when it comes to hanging out like teenagers.
But in the films, Ron acts like the unneeded third wheel.
I was mad how they screwed up Harry and Ron's reunion in DHP1 after destroying the locket.
The entire emotional conversation thry ha din the book is not even there in the film!!!!
@@kavishbedi9281 yea it’s very disappointing , since the source material was all there in front of them, all they needed was to follow it, but for some reason they seemed to hate the weasley’s (ginny was butchered and even fred and george got nerfed).
i’m not sure what the screenwriters were thinking. like, why did they insist on giving Hermione everything?
@@tuopsy cuz they loved her a little too much id say. I actually liked hermione because of her flaws its make her more human and interesting. Air brushing her flaws just make her seem boring and unrealistic and also a completly diffrent character in the process
If you want to kill Harry you'll have to kill us too.
The one thing I'll never forgive this movie doing is giving Hermione's Ron's line. that was one of his most defining moments of friendship and loyalty to Harry
Same here
They really nerfed ron and ginny in the movies
Honestly I’m more pissed of at the addition of the “he’s got a point you know” line because at least the removal of the “ you want to kill Harry you have to kill us too” was at least inconsequential
Yep
@@johnheneghan5743 that too
Really waiting for the "Dumbledore asked calmly" part
Just one more... Just about there.
Lol
all of us should spam it when he does book 4
@HerronAriela sure
@@v.k.rt.m.6030 I somehow read your username as Viktor Krum.
I loved the foreshadowing in Philosopher's Stone where Hagrid says to Dumbledore that Sirius let him borrow his motorbike. Already heard about Sirius in the first book without even realising!
Which raises an interesting question though! - WHY ON EARTH DOES HAGRID INSIST THAT ONLY SLYTHERINS EVER TURN EVIL, WHEN SIRIUS BLACK EXISTED
@@davidw.2791 Sirius Black was in Gryffindor, not Slytherin. Oh, but if you are talking about how Gryffindors are also "Evil" then yes, that does beg the question. For instance, later when we find out about Pettigrew. He is a Gryffindor that went bad. And also, if you count bullying, then the Gryffindors is just as guilty of that as the Slytherins (just look at James, Sirius, Harry and Ron bullying other students and Filch).
@@davidw.2791 Sirius Black was in Gryffindor, though 🤣
@@dannyjorde2677 That’s the point though! Yes Sirius was framed, but the real perp (Wormtail) and the officially accepted traitor (Sirius himself) until PoA… were both Gryffindors! And yet Hagrid gotta maintain that bigotry at all costs!!!
It’ll be like claiming that, say, black people never murder their spouses, in a world where OJ Simpson was indeed found guilty, and is serving jail time!
@@TheMbangel Hagrid’s famous line is that ALL VOLDEMORT’s FOLLOWERS COME OUT OF SLYTHERIN (if it wasn’t All Dark Magicians, Period). You only need ONE opposite example to prove such a statement wrong. And boy howdy does Wormtail/Sirius blow that precious little bigotry up to kingdom come?!
Alright boys, the comparison of “Did you put your name in the goblet of fire” is getting closer
Movie Dumbledore got some anger management problems that’s for sure
That "scream" of Lily always sounded and still sounds like a train to me not a scream.
Exactly! They didn't even portray that correctly. Whenever I heard that I was like: That's not a scream 😂
When i first watched the Prisoner of Azkaban movie, I thought that the scream was the Hogwarts train-
I know it’s weird
Lol. IKR it sounded more like an old fashioned kettle scream to me
Wait, the scream was in the movie?
One missing difference here: In the film Harry sees a cloud shaped as the Grimm but in the book he just sees Sirius sitting on the Quidditch stand as a Dog. So from a secret friend who wanted to see his godson play they changed to The worst Omen of death.
Thank you! and it's such an emotional moment in the Shrieking Shack when Sirius tells Harry he only got in to watch him play Quidditch... that he plays like his dad... and looks at him in the eye and tells him he'd rather die before betraying Lily and James and Harry believes him... that's such a beautiful moment
Surprised he missed this
@@eliord142 oh yes I love that lines about him rather dying for his friends and Harry finally accepting the truth
the book brings across the relationship between harry and sirius much better. This leads to movie 5 where it wasn't that sad when sirius died but in the books it was so so freakin tragic
The fifth book came out in 2003, I don’t understand why this film doesn’t try to connect the things.
😭 atleast mention you are giving a spoiler before saying.
Just finished this book .
😔
Also Crookshanks was a very smart cat, he knew in diagon alley that scabbers was not a rat and later he helped Sirius because he realised Sirius was not a dog and Sirius had explained everything to crookshanks and crookshanks decided to help after a lot of deliberation. Crookshanks hadn’t trusted Sirius immediately
In the book, Harry was ten minutes late for defense against the dark arts the day Snape filled in for Lupin because Oliver Wood held him up discussing their upcoming quidditch match. In the film, he was on time for class and Wood's role from the book was cut from the film entirely.
wood, percy, lavender, pervati, cho, lee jordan, wood, cedric and others were almost entirely left out, or completely left out. Its actually so crazy to me. I wanna see all their lines on a movie even if it's boring
@@YenellyT Hopefully we will get them in tv series several years from now
I recently realized that, right before Sirius escapes on Buckbeak, in the book, he asks about Ron ("What about the other boy--Ron?"), while in the movie, he does not ask about Ron ("I'll be eternally grateful for this. To both of you (Harry and Hermione).").
Yeah
Oof Ron's character really was the afterthought in the movies
The actor who played Goyle was injured before filming started and couldn't work on this movie. Later its Crabbe who is replaced (in the movies) after he was arrested on drug possession charges.
Oooh, so that's what happened! I always wondered.
@@XimenaConstanza no wonder why those two familiar actors were gone in later years.
This may just be my hot take here, but I actually really like Lupin’s werewolf form in the movie. The scrawniness, hunched back, and crackling bones (while he’s transforming) makes it seem like an ungodly affliction. Something that you wouldn’t even wish on your worst enemy.
(Edit): Also, the wolfsbane potion didn’t completely stop Lupin from turning into a wolf. It just allowed him to “keep his mind” while he was one.
“I was a very small boy when I received the bite. My parents tried everything, but in those days there was no cure. The Potion that Professor Snape has been making for me is a very recent discovery. It makes me safe, you see. As long as I take it in the week preceding the full moon, I keep my mind when I transform... I am able to curl up in my office, a harmless wolf, and wait for the moon to wane again. Before the Wolfsbane Potion was discovered, however, I became a fully fledged monster once a month. It seemed impossible that I would be able to come to Hogwarts. Other parents weren't likely to want their children exposed to me.”
I haven’t read the books in a while, but if I remember correctly Cedric tried to have the match replayed because he realized what happened to Harry, and he didn’t think it was fair for Hufflepuff to win that way
Gryffindor turned him down but it’s a nice little moment that shows you what kind of a person Cedric is
They could have done this.
They could have done it without even having to cast a guy to play Cedric one film before his big outing in GoF.
But Cuaron decided the Quidditch mid game (where Harry DID successfully cast a Patronus but it “doesn’t count” as the dementors were not real ones) and finale (where Gryffindor wins partially so that Malfoy can stfu about being smug that Buckbeak was gonna die).
Lily and James: So how was your first meeting with our son?
Snape: I called him a celebrity, asked him some potion related questions and took 10 points from Gryffindor because his neighbor made a potion that nearly killed the whole class.
Remus: I saved him from a Dementor and gave him chocolate.
Sirius: I kidnapped his best friend to get his rat, broke his ankle, then he and his friends beat me up, Remus came and we talked for hours about our school days, then Snape came almost caught us but got knocked out, Peter turned human again, me and Remus tried to kill him but Harry wouldn't let us, Remus changed into a werewolf, Peter escaped, and we got attacked by dementors, but don't worry Harry from the future came and saved us. Oh, and I asked Harry to stay with me over the summer and he said yes!
Everyone: ....
Snape: and you all think I'm the one with issues?
Lmfaooooo 😭😭 this is amazing
😂🤣lmaoo
They got problems
The fact this is exactly what they’d say
@@jessfidler2356Yeah.
Snape was a toxic friend that Lily cut off when he seemed to become irrecoverably toxic.
Padfoot Mooney and Wormtail otoh…
I’m glad someone finally pointed out how many important plot details were missed during the Shrieking Shack scene. No one ever complains about them but it completely skips over who Moony, Wormtail, Padofoot and Prongs are, how Sirius escaped from Azkaban (a question brought up during the Knight Bus scene) etc…
Finally? Many people have done it already
@@dannyjorde2677, really? I guess for die hard book fans that’s true but when it comes to casual fans and cinephiles, I never see them complain about this plothole
I love how long that scene is
Once again glad you're healthy enough to post these videos, and glad you're feeling better. I'm looking forward to watching this
It absolutely baffles me how Steve Kloves thought that by erasing all of Hermione’s endearing flaws from the books he was “fixing” her character. Like, I don’t know, Steve. A character with zero flaws and relatability who knows exactly what to do and how to do it in every given situation sounds like a pretty boring character to me. 🤷♂️
Steve Kloves was a terrible job for writing. He let his bias and arrogance fail the films.
@@kavishbedi9281 Agreed. Now if J.K. herself had written the scripts…then we could have avoided all this.
@@securityc.a.m.9539 But knowing how J.K. has been like in all these recent years, I wouldn't feel good if she has a say should they make a television series reboot.
@@kavishbedi9281 That’s a fair point, but I was talking about pre-Twitter J.K. You know, while the original movies were being created and released. She should have been the screenwriter then.
@@kavishbedi9281 But yeah, they should keep her away from a potential television reboot. Same goes for Steve Kloves.
I really hate how the movies cut off important scenes like these and giving hermione half of Ron's lines like in the chamber of secrets when malfoy called hermione a mudblood she understands the meaning and explain it not Ron's like there making hermione the pureblood and Ron's the muggleborn.
I know right?!
Recently I found PoA probably is the worst adaptation of them all. Yes, I think even GoF did a better job than this film.
I cannot remember correctly, but I believe the Marauders and Harry’s parents’ casting choices were influenced by casting Alan Rickman as Snape. Since he is older, they had to make the others older.
Sharp.
They didn’t HAVE to otoh. Snape looks old for 31+ but he’s also a bitter man who lives under a L O T of stress.
This was long. Goblet of fire is gonna be 5 hours. Good video yet again
Yeah...not looking forward to that one.
I just thought the same thing lol
@@PHSDM104 i would love a 5 hour vid, i am looking forward to that one
@@fumusolol
@@fumuso Only because he's gonna dig into that director again. LOL
Dementors were only supposed to hover inches from the ground. But they had them flying like birds in the movie.
The 4 dislikes are the doctors who told him to rest longer but he refused and made the vid
I like this comment a lot
Best comment I’ve seen in a while 😂😂😂
@@MovieFlame aaah thank u for liking and replying to my comment, I was a bit down and this made my day :)
huh but arent there 44 dislikes?
@@harrypotterfan_0886 at the time they wrote the comment, there was probably 4 dislikes
I feel like they really changed the entire character of Ron and his loyalty towards Harry in the movies. They also made him overshadowed and changed his intelligence levels in the films. I think they wanted to just make him a more likeable, easy going, and Harry's sidekick. They should have let Ron's character shine a bit more and it is really upsetting with some of the changes.
But don't you think Ron was more likeable in the novels than in the films?
Another small detail that people don't mention is that students at Hogwarts usually wore Wizarding clothes and not just muggle jeans and shirts... something which becomes important as in the Half Blood Prince Snape cuts points from Gryffindor because Harry entered the school grounds wearing muggle clothes. While in the film we saw all the time the trio are wearing muggle clothes
The movies from the third on lost the magic. Everything is gray and dull, rarely people are using wizards clothes, and spells are just a bunch of colored explosions without any effect or fun to them.
It’s funny to imagine Alan Rickman dress up for the boggart scene.
He must’ve been so humiliated
XD😂
I bet Rickman had fun with this scene.
16:10 the wolfsbane potion actually doesn't stop a werewolf from turning, it just makes em lazy and less harmful and if I remember correctly also reduce the pain in transforming 😃
I love your videos btw keep going!👍
Finished reading a few days back and I’m shocked at how much more I enjoyed the book compared to what most believe to be the best film in the series. The difference between heaven and earth imo.
Cinematically it is the best but as an adaptation it’s the beginning of seriously disrespecting the characters and plot.
@@joshz2491 I wholeheartedly agree
When you know... you know
Josh Z Disrespecting and with no plan b to fill in the gaps later.
@@joshz2491 It's a great movie and adaptation. Aside from them butchering Ron a bit, it's a fantastic film that I would argue is better than the book in many ways.
Professor Flitwick was also part of the conversation about Black in the Three Broomsticks. He explained the Fidelius Charm.
Makes sense. Man is the CHARMS professor after all .
I like the drink he ordered from madam rosmerta. Very fitting 😂
It's really annoying how they left out all the marauders back story and why Hermione had a time turner. I also felt frustrated when Harry and Hermione didn't tell Ron what happened but I imagine they told him off-screen.
I really loved the scene of Snape protecting the trio from Lupin. It shows that even though he is a horrible teacher, hes still a teacher and cares about his students.
that's the only scene I'm glad the movies made, the one in a lifetime moment I wish something from the movies made it to the books lol
Same because he genuinely did care for them
The movie snape did. Book snape didnt give a wet fart about them.
@@AnInkStick tbf he was unconscious during this scene in the books
That was totally out of character. I've always annoyed by some stupid comments like Alan Rickman is a perfect Snape and Emma Watson is a perfect Hermione.
i am so happy for you to be healthy after your surgery
35:27 It's amazing how many things Harry figured out for himself in the books were just given to Hermione in the movies
True. And you then have people saying Harry only won because of dumb luck and Hermione.
No, it was Harry's story. Not Hermione's.
I was thinking the same thing so it’s not just Ron! Lol
I'm reading the books and Harry actually comes of as a little dumb sometimes x) maybe it's because I already know the outcome of the story (since I've watched the films) but Harry can be insufferably stupid at rare occasions.
DROOG He does have a good helping of Plot Armour.
@@kavishbedi9281People always show compassion to movie Ron, but they usually ignore that Harry's also stolen by Hermione.
Harry: *spares Pettigrew*
Sirius: *casts Imperious curse on Pettigrew*
Everyone: *stops Snape to tell him what happened, then they turn Pettigrew in*
Lupin and prob Sirius: *deals with Lupin's transformation*
Hermione & Harry: *uses time turner to save Buckbeak*
*End credits and story is all better* ❤️
Unfortunately, it is a contest between Sirius and Severus on who’s moar immature.
Just look at Sirius’s choice to bang Snape’s head on the tunnel ceiling, when, with Snape all tied up, Sirius could wake him up and force him to look at Wormtail. For justice reasons, and for “Rub it in Snivellus’s face” reasons.
Can we get that fanfiction please?
Remus drinks wolfsbane potion:
I know Steve Kloves loves hermione and made her this untouchable genius, but he must have had some sorta hatred for Ron the way he just absolutely butchered his character
Steve Kloves was really a poor choice.
@@kavishbedi9281 but surprisingly, a rich choice for secrets of dumbledore, the 3rd Fantastic Beasts movie.
@@kartikadewi3270 ‘Cause Hermione wasn’t in it.
@@kavishbedi9281 he should've been left out throughout the entire movie series.
Gotta love these videos. Imagine how long the videos would be if he did it for other books and movies like Percy Jackson and the Last Airbender
@Autumn Gavin 39 hours is an understatement.
Percy Jackson movie is like a whole different storyline haha
I don't even want to think about how long those would be 😆
@@shailijain8 48 hours?
Or kotlc when the movie gets released
Thank you for summarizing. Unfortunately you forgot a little scene. You forgot the scene in which Lupine shoots chewing gum in Peves' nostril after he tried to stuff it into a key lock.
Waddiwasi!
I love that scene. A subtle nod to his troublemaking days
Theory:
Crookshanks is actually James and Lily's previous cat, and when they died he was placed in a pet shop. He recognized Sirius in his dog form and his human form, and he also recognized Peter which is why he was always after him. And if Ron let Crookshanks eat Scabbers, Dobby, Tonks, Cedric, Lupin, Sirius, etc would all be alive as Voldemort would have never been revived. The hero of the story would be a cat!
Your so right
@Ida Good Point!
Another theory is that Crookshanks is actually Serious’s brother (idk how to spell his name) who knew how to turn in a animajis because Serious did and left a something lying around that told you how to turn into a animal. And he survived Voldemort’s horcrucks and was angry when Peter framed Serious. So he decided he wanted to eat Peter. This theory is kinda off some parts don’t make sense but it’s still know throughout Pinterest.
@Jacob Gordon I couldn’t spell it right
@Jacob Gordon what does that stand for
The bond of the Marauders and how that plays as a character motivation for Harry is one of the most important parts of the series and it really saddens me that they cut nearly all of that background information in POA. Harry's "Prongs" line is so emotional and not only is it not in the movie, but it wouldn't make sense if it was there.
I still see POA as the best movie though, I think Alfonso was the best director of the 4 and he did a great job adapting the book to a movie. The way he shows the time-turner and the interactions between future and past Harry and Hermione here is more comprehensible than it is in the book, and more interesting.
It's like reading the books again...
Thank you for this series, much appreciated.
Also get well soon.
As a fan of both the books and movies and growing up literally with Harry, this is a fantastic presentation. 👏
A lot of people consider this their favorite movie mainly cuz of the style. Realistically though, it contradicted so much of the established HP universe and left out so many plot essential details. The worst atrocities are the trio walking around Hogwarts grounds in MUGGLE CLOTHING, and the use of magic outside school.
@@nahor88 It's just a great movie all around. Most people who criticize the movies can't do so without comparing them to the books. It's a great adaptation aside from a few things.
one of the only changes i prefer in the movie over the book was lupin's werewolf form. That lanky almost human appearance that looks more wolf-like the closer u get to it was actually terrifying when I was young. It still creeps me out, but I like just how horrifying he looks compared to the book where u could confuse him with an actual regular wolf which is scary too, but not as visibly disturbing. Like one look at movie Wolf-lupin and u can feel why he hates his werewolf side
It really irks me that Hermione gets Ron's dialogue in the shack.
The whole thing with Hermione and the Firebolt being cut is to be expected considering how Steve Clovis’ favorite character is Hermione so he didn’t want to make her look awful in any way.
I dont get why this would have been awful, she was just protecting harry
How tf would it have made her look awful? More like intelligent and caring. It's common sense not to accept anonymous gifts when you know there's a serial killer after you.
frr I think this person just doesn't like hermione. She was using common sense @@ahsink.3080
Potter fans: hey writers do you think we could stop giving all of Ron’s important lines and discoveries to Hermione ?
Potter Movie Writers: I guess we can let him find and chase scabbers
I hated how they cut out Crookshanks and Sirius's relationship in the film!!
I’ve spent the last 8 hours watching your Harry Potter videos, and then you happened to upload this!
Correction: Pettigrew is not using a wand to turn into Scabbers. He just picked up a dropped wand and tried to attack Sirius and Lupin and only transforms back when Harry disarms him.
This is really the beginning of Ron getting his moments shafted in favor of proping up Hermione because she's a certain screenwriters favorite character.
Prisoner Of Azkaban is my favorite movie, it just reminds me of my childhood. Amazing video! I was waiting for it.
Me too
I also like prisoner of azkaban film is my 2nd favourite
Me too. The book was instantly my favourite and when I first watched the movie it was with my childhood best friend, I slept at hers that night. For this memory alone I just have to love the movie
I didn’t like the movie very much. I get how much had to be cut because of time restraints, but they cut out the best parts. Like Harry learning about his father’s stag form. Plus they cut out the Quidditch final and the Griffindors winning the title. They also cut out the what the prophecy was and Dumbledore learning about it.
And Ron’s shocking but funny quote to Peter, “I let you sleep in my bed!”
@@Capri_00 I know that the movie left out all those things, but it is my favourite Harry Potter movie anyway, especially because of the memory of watching it for the first time
Take a shot everytime he says "this did not happen in the book"
That would be suicidal
Hi even though you probably won’t see this I just wanted to say that I ve been having rly hard times recently and your videos make me forget about all my problems so thank you very much
Love the videos and keep it up
Hang in there!! One step and one day at a time
Sending good vibes ur way
Thank you very much guys
Hang in there! Reach out for help.
All the people who liked and replied are with you! And so is the creator of this video!
The editing of these videos makes the content even more enjoyable - very well analysed, and it’s been releasing just in time with me starting to read the books! Awesome job, thank you!
The fact that they made Ron agree with Snape will forever haunt me lol The fact that he took her defense even when he was mad with her because of her cat says a lot about their relationship. He cares for her no matter what. That's without having to mention how they stripped him from his lines and him standing up against Sirius, defending Harry.
Half of this: this happened later/earlier
Other half: in the book Ron actually said that.
Another 30% the movie actually didn’t include this, and instead made this up…
It's such a coincidence because all 8 of the hp movies are showing on tv every saturday, and Prisoner of Azkaban just came on tv yesterday, and the next day this video comes out. Truly incredible.
It's not really a coincidence. They play the movies on tv constantly and have been for years.
What channel are thg they on?!
Please respond
@@lilzzak nope in my country the movies haven't been on in 7 years. I only became a fan a few months ago and have been waiting for a really long time.
My country's channel-?
basically, everyone took others' lines... especially Hermione.
Quite greedy isn't she, Hermione
@@rowisaweirdo4941Hermione is not greedy. Its the screenwriter who made it
Great clip as usual ☺️. One correction, though: the potion Snape gives Lupin does not stop him from turning (if it did, he wouldn't have to stay away at all), but it lets him keep his own sense of mind like a "harmless wolf".
17:12 I believe there is one more difference that you didn't mention, is that in the film, Harry sees the Grim in a cloud before getting attacked by the dementors, and in the book, he sees Sirius' animagus form, that looks like the Grim
Book readers knew it from the very beginning that POA is where the movies actually started getting bad in terms of story telling and character development.
POA is only good from Cinematic POV.
True. PS and CoS are perfect adaptations even though they had a few minor annoyances which Incan forgive.
@@kavishbedi9281 They were the easiest to adapt lol
Oh shut up films don’t have to be a straight book to film adaptation to be good
@@IamJustAnotherUtubeR Facts. Do people realize how big the books were lol
Nah a lot of the things in this film were done really well, they did Ron dirty and left out the marauders but other than that it was a great adaptation, condensing weeks into a night is just good writing if you kept it all it would be 4 hours long at least and it would be quite boring.
Bruh. If you do this to the Percy Jackson movies it'll be hours...
Totally agree!
It’d be like having the lotus flowers
**visible confusion**
"Every difference between the Goblet of Fire book and Movie"
Isn't there like a 10 hour limit on youtube videos tho? You'll need at least 3 parts
😂😂
Its not 10 hr limit
Probably do part 1 and part 2
@@an1me_cxrs how much
@@filipfilip1507 12 hrs
I’m so impressed by all of these facts that you listed. This is a 41 minute video of you listening tons of random facts from the Harry Potter book. It’s so much detail and must have taken so long. It’s so impressive. You really are one of the greatest TH-camrs out there always putting so much effort into your videos
as for the ages of the marauders- the casting directors really wanted alan rickman as snape, so they aged up the others in order to have alan as a convincing snape
Justified tbh
But it works for Remus and Sirius anyway. Sirius was in prison for 12 years, and Remus was a werewolf with painful transformations every month
@@jessfidler2356Snape too. He doesn’t care about himself and he lives under a L O T of stress.
By casting director, you mean JK Rowling. She wanted Alan Rickman to play Snape
Great work as usual. I’ve read the books several times over, most recently in audiobook format, so I know all about the various differences between the 2 mediums. Still enjoy watching these for how they’re presented tho.
Yet saying that the fact that Lupin’s werewolf form is more like that of a regular wolf in the book has always escaped me for some reason. Probably ‘cause I have a habit of picturing the characters as they appear in the films ever since watching those.
Interesting choice by the filmmakers given what JK was obviously going for.
Jeez, you are such a legend. Literally who takes the time to look at every single difference between a book and a movie? Only someone who cares :)
Wow !!! This is such a detailed review between the book and the movie !!
Thank you so much Morgan !!
Let's all be grateful that Morgan took a lot of effort and made this video when he just had surgery. Thank You SO MUCH Morgan!
27:51 Emma Watson didn’t mean to throw a punch at Tom Felton. The script called for her to slap him just like in the book, but Emma got carried away and threw a punch instead. After the director yelled “Cut”, she went to see if Tom was okay and apologized for what she did. Not the only time a Harry Potter actor got a little to physical with another actor. In one of the later movies, Helena Bonham Carter, who played Bellatrix LeStrange, stuck her wand in Matthew Lewis’s ear…and accidentally perforated his eardrum, resulting in the Neville Longbottom actor going deaf in that ear for a week!
Jk Rowling had to tell the films to slow down the relationship between Ron and hermione as they was going to fast
I am so looking forward to see the half blood prince version of this since that’s my favorite book❤️❤️ and great job Morgan big fan of your channel
Two of my favourite moments from this movie: 12:30 Malfoy saying "It's killed me! It's killed me!" and 13:50 Malfoy saying "This class is Ridiculous" and Crabbe nodding 😂😂
This man is recovering and still pushing content respect
You didn't mention about cedric refuses the win because of Harry's accident. That is the 1st time we knew about cedric and his character.
WOW. THIS MOVIE DROPPED A LOT OF INFO...
"poor professor lupin. He's having a really rough night" always cracked me up in the movie.
I HATE snape
@@audreybosak679 yeah... Til deathly hallows
He also for got that lupin tells them that while being less wolfish in the mind while with his animagus friends, and that because of this they used to run around outside not in the shrieking shack😕
Bethany Flarrety Honestly if Snape needs to be condemned for teenage terrorism affiliations, those other guys need to be condemned for those “walks”.
Snaps:
“Animagus”
Hermione:
Your saying it wrong it’s “animajus” not “animagus”
*snape
@@bradydoyle6966 good that you corrected yourself
Lol
Snaps lmaooooo
@@bradydoyle6966 You can edit comments, y'know
I think the actors being older works because all three characters are super stressed and prematurely aged. Harry even says that Lupin and greying hair. Being left in Azkaban I think that Sirius would also look stressed out and much older than he really was.
I tend to be a purist when comparing book to movie conversions. Though I do understand that there are things that don't convert well, like inner monologues. With that in mind, I can give a pass for depicting frost when dementors are around in the movie as a way of showing the intense cold that is felt in the book.
Kinda pretty cool though, for the dementors that is.