Every Single Difference Between the Half-Blood Prince Book & Movie (Harry Potter Explained)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2021
- Patreon: / overview
Twitter: / movieflameprod
Personal Instagram: / morgan_ross18
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@movieflamemor...
Facebook: / movieflame
Philosopher’s (Sorcerer’s Stone) Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Chamber of Secrets Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Prisoner of Azkaban Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Goblet of Fire Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Order of the Phoenix Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
FANART:
Horace Slughorn: www.hp-lexicon.org/?attachmen...
Narcissa Malfoy: www.deviantart.com/luinia/art...
Narcissa Begging Snape by obfuscatesart: i.pinimg.com/originals/78/43/...
Dursley’s & Dumbledore: www.deviantart.com/harry-pott...
Tom Riddle Sr: www.deviantart.com/littlechmu...
Dean & Ginny Caught Kissing: blvnk-art.tumblr.com/post/163...
Ginny & Harry Kiss: www.deviantart.com/greendesir...
Ginny Leaning on Harry’s Leg: burdge.tumblr.com/post/584434...
Gibbon: www.deviantart.com/madcarrot/...
Bill With Scars: www.pillowfort.social/superhi...
Hokey / Hepzibah Clip: • Voldemort: Origins of ...
Music- By Ross Bugden • ♩♫ Sad and Emotional M... - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
80% comparing book and movie
20% roasting the movie’s decision
can’t complain
it's actually crazy how some incompetent directors/screenwriters can make the (imo) two best books of the series (GoF & HBP) into the two worst movies of the series!
@@JuanMataCFC ootp is the worst
@@user-mn5si5jd5z I think HBP is the worst book and movie 😂
@@literallycannotbeasked POA and GOf are better than HBP
Though cuaron did a good job
Newell had the worst adaptation im series
@@literallycannotbeasked the HBP book is actually a great read with little to zero romance drama in it unlike the film
Biggest difference:
Book: Great mystery, investigation kinda thriller, Ginny is cool
Movie: Cringy teen drama, Ginny has never even heard of personality
lmao 😂😂😂
Bro hella true
Yah and that kiss scene b/w harry and ginny were soo poorly executed in movie its after griffindor win house cup by beating ravenclaw in common room infront of every one and ginni reply to Ron when he disturb kiss b/w ginny and Dean also were not specified in movie and make her look like a doll with out any character
Funny that you'd say that. I agree that the Voldemort past was awfully rushed in the film. Yet I found movie Ron to be much more likeable than his novel version (especially the last two books) and found the love triangel in the book much worse.
@@samlerf Dude why are you so attacking everywhere with this same comment on every thread?
There is another VERY crucial difference between book and movie:
During the final battle in front of Hagrids cabin Harry tries to curse Snape several times and Snape manages to block them all very easily.
THEN Snape says: "Blocked again and again and again until you learn to keep your mouth shut and your mind closed, Potter!”
This is an amazing and crucial Snape moment! Where he actually teaches Harry something very important!
Also the moment in the book when we see how painful it is for him to be called a coward, especially by Harry since he has been risking his life to protect him. In the movies he barely reacts to being called a coward by anyone.
@@smithereens388 yes exactly! And how Harry reveals at the very end that Snape is the most courageous man he knew.
Exactly. Also the scene in the book when Harry tried to use levicorpus on Snape (the same spell James had used on Snape in Snape's worse memory to sexually harrass and humiliate him) shows Snape was still traumatised from that as he reacts completely different compared to the other spells Harry throws at him, (even crucio and sectumsempra) both spells that can permanently damage him and one spell could kill him.
@@marie.naturallysims2179 true! I forgot that one! The movie just doesn't respect their characters... but that's nothing new isn't it? 😅🙃
@@fnopi Yeah I really wish they had made a whole series with these actors so they wouldn’t have had to cut so much stuff from the books. Alan Rickman was an excellent actor but he’s only in the films for about 30 minutes in total and his Snape is really toned down, he really could have pulled off the book version of Snape.
I always love when McGonagall says "Dumbledore would have been happy to know there was a little more love in the world"
I like that too❤❤
"But there's alot that happens in between these two scenes."-MovieFlame, 2021
There a lot that happens, that should be his tagline or something
Quote of the series
@Gryffindor_Galaxy MovieFlame should make merch
Haha 😂
@@holytank9738 Totally
Biggest difference: the book isn't some dumb fail teen romantic comedy that's trying to go Twilight but is filled with intrigue, conflict, and struggle as Voldermort rise from the shadows. Damn, I hate this movie.
Agreed tenfold. The teen love theme in the movie is almost nauseating.
Yeah, the book is *actually good*. The movie is fucking stupid.
@@catz_circus See, for all the shit Morgan gave Goblet Of Fire (he's not entirely wrong), I would pick that movie any day over Half Blood Prince.
tell that to goblet of fire they adapted that one even worse but yeah a lot of missed potential here with voldemorts story
@@arthurlamora8520 I admit Goblet of Fire has a lot of flaws. The first 5 hours of the book being condensed down to the first 15 minutes in the movie for example... That being said, I just can't over just how poorly written Half Blood Prince is. Almost everything is just completely off. I just feel like Half Blood Prince is a bigger offence considering how much it has to set up for Deathly Hallows, and instead it is basically a teen rom-com some of the worst dialogue the series has ever had.
If Goblet of Fire didn't have that great graveyard scene, and easily the best spell special effects in the entire series, I'd say it's up there with Half Blood Prince. It's not winning awards from me either way.
In the book, Harry being the one who hid the Potions book made him see the diadem for the first time, which made him realized where it is in the deathly hallows
I must confess that I love the scene of Lavander and Hermione's argument in the hospital wing. The way Dumbledore breaks the tension is possibly the closest we see Gambon get to book Dumbledore.
I would have traded it to get the hospital argument where Fleur completely goes off on Mrs. Weasley
nah, the closest he is to book dumbledpre is when he gets pissed at barty crouch/mad eye in the goblet if fire, makes sense thi
@@leglessdumbass The closest to book Dumbledore interrogating Barty Crouch is when he screams at Harry
I think every Romione shipper will agree that Ron and Hermione’s big fight in this book was the lowest point of their relationship but the movie should have kept these scenes in:
•Ron absent-mindedly saying “I love you” to Hermione when she corrects his homework and she blushes cutely.
•Hermione smiling when Lavender confronts Ron about “spending” a lot of time with Hermione.
•Ron and Hermione in tears hugging each other for comfort at Dumbledore’s funeral.
I find it hilarious that Lavender thinks Ron is cheating on her with Hermione lol, but yeah their fight in this book was not their highest point. They were BOTH awful to each other not just Ron. The movie didn’t make Hermione as cruel to Ron with the birds attacking him and all the shit that happend after Ron got with Lavender.
yeah hermione ron didnt send birds at your face when you were with krum
@@puttrik4865 "They were BOTH awful to each other not just Ron."
Yep. I hated when the book tried to make Hermione a victim, and Ron the villain. They were both terrible to each other, but it was "all" Ron's fault. He was the one who should apologise (Harry), he was mean (Luna).
@@Scion141 are you saying that Harry should apologise to Luna Lovegood? Why? Harry and Luna were very close.
@@eurywoulahan7412 He meant that Harry told Ron to apologise to Hermione and Luna said how unkind Ron can be.
It's just that Ron is called by them for his rudeness towards Hermione but Hermione isn't called out for physically attacking Ron.
Can we just appreciate the fact that every week he films and edits an entire 1hour+ video just for us to be entertained? Not to mention that he goes through all of the books and all the movies again and again to sort out every single difference. He needs a crown
I would absolutely appreciate the fact it was an hour plus video when really it's just a 45 minute video and 25 minute complaints
@@FATE522 Bruh start focusing on why Morgan really made the video. To sort out the differences and entertain.
@@teso9520 If that was the sake of it all then he would not be so negative.
@@FATE522 But everyone agrees that they books have always been way better than the movies. They made Movie HBP a boring and stupid Rom-com, while the book is an awesome mystery, adventure, action book, and way more, with little romance.
@@teso9520 So if everyone agrees with this consensus then why don't we focus on the positive instead and just focus on the narrative differences overall?
Take a shot every time “But there’s a lot that happens between these two scenes.” Is said.
And be comatose in the first 5 minutes haha
I'd rather not suffer from mass-liver damage, thanks!!!
If you don't drink, can the shots be substituted with chocolate?
what i like is how he calls screenwriters out for not putting better effort into writing yet says this quote and a few other repeated lines..
lmao i'm drunk
"But I am the chosen one" that was actually quite a funny line and doesn't come across as arrogant at all
I love how Harry in this book was acting like James
- He used Langlock twice on Filch
- He used a toe-nail growing hex on Crabbe
- He used Levicorpus on Ron to testing it
and Ron found it funny,
- He was in the detention most of the year
*his sarcastic smart mouth against Snape ("There's no need to call me "sir" Professor)*
- both father and his son used the spells that Snape invented against him
it’s like rowling reminds us that Harry is still James's son
also it gets harder and harder for Snape because Harry gradually turns into James and yet he protects him lol
Yeah well that's his job and that's the least he can do after causing the death of his parents, not to forget that he still mentally abuses harry throughout this book too.
@@beans1697 but I still think it wasn’t snape’s fault when lily and James died. He didn’t think through his actions, and what Lord Voldemort would do. And to make up for it he saved Harry’s Life on countless occasions. BUT… He was still stupid for calling Lily a Mudblood
@**Maiosh** Me 2
@@Chessler-qs4ni he was a death eater for goodness sake, do you even know how many deaths he'd have caused especially since he was one of the most powerful death eaters and one of the most loyal to Voldemort? Also, saying he was stupid for calling lilly mudblood is like calling someone stupid if they discriminate against the blacks or any other race. Racism isn't a fucking joke. He was a racist a$$hole and a child bully.
@@Chessler-qs4ni
In fact, Everything was his fault
He told his master about a child and didn't care if Voldemort killed him but when he found out that he was Lily's child, he was afraid only for Lily 😀??
and Dumbledore kept reminding him that Harry was still a part of her which is why he protected harry because of his obsession with lily
Not to mention that he didn't understand Lily, he didn't care about the death of her husband and child, I mean seriously
did he expect her to run into his arms after he was the cause of her family's death
+
He bullies the students, especially Harry, he blames him for his father's sins
I don't deny that he's a complex, contradictory, and amazing character in the series
but I only accepted and loved him because of Alan Rickman.
Snape is an unbearable character in books
he's the reason his life is ruined, not James or Lily
Movie Hermione is the perfection Book Hermione wishes she could be.
Movie Ron is the failure Book Ron fears he could be.
Movie Ginny is to Book Ginny what the Peter Johnson films are to the Percy Jackson books.
Underrated comment 👏
Movie Hermione is a Mary Sue
Brilliant
I agree that they refined Hermione's character more in the films and they did the same to Harry's. I wouldn't call the film version of her to be the idea that book version thrives to be, it only appears like that because Ron's role is reducted badly and the writer's favouritism of Hermione.
I don't know about Percy Jackson books or films, but I know they aren't faithful to the source material. In regards of Ginny, they tried to speedrun their relationship which came out half cocked. They needed to give her character in the previous films, but then again they removed alot between books and films as it is.
Pretty much
Justice for Ron! Hermione is book smart Ron street/ wizarding word smart. This made it soooo painfully obvious how badly Ron’s character is diminished only to press Hermione’s “brilliance” “smartest witch of her age”. It’s actually more interesting that she is so naïve in a lot of ways and try as she might to read everything she doesn’t know everything that’s the whole point of her being friends with Ron and Harry they all need each other to be better. Also …. Gahhh you can’t teleport in any form on the grounds of hog warts .
You're right and it's a point the books make explicitly. I wonder how the director and screenwriters made the decision to do that, but movies tend to shove in comic relief even when it's inappropriate
No, hermione is street smart too, she explains to harry and ron a lot of social situations, not just with girls but also with what teachers mean sometimes, she reads between the lines like what she did with umbrige
she isn't as funny and playful as ron but that doesn't make her any less of a street smart than ron is
That's technically not true. Dumbledore was able to do it with fawkes
@@Chris-ks4sw i don't think he appareted, fawkes just has abilities different than wizards, kinda like elfs
@@yatooxx9316 op said teleport in any form, not just apparition
While the scene of Harry asking a random waitress out was weird and out of place, the two of them still had better chemistry than he did with movie Ginny by a thousand miles.
What do you care? What does chemistry have to do with anything? It's No big deal.
By that I mean you're taking it a bit too seriously.
@@brysontipton1893chemistry means a ton when writing and acting out a relationship. If the main love interest of the main character has no chemistry with him it’s not nearly as good.
Do you believe that or do you think you misinterpreted the scenes with them.
By that I mean teens act awkward all the time.
31:27 - that detail from the book is very important, because it made Ron realize that what helped him in the match wasn't luck, but rather his own talent and his confidence. That helped solidify his confidence, which I think is fantastic writing on Rowling's part.
I love these videos so much dude. These are stellar.
YEAH!
Me too!!!
Stellar comment
Here Me: Thinking of 2023 Half Blood Prince Illustrated by Jim Kay.
Hey your the guy that doesn't like skylanders
I was really disappointed on how emotionless they made the scene with Narcissa and Snape. The scene in the last film where she lies about Harry's death to protect Draco would have made a lot more sense if they had shown how much Narcissa loved her son.
Can we talk about how Tom riddle Sr had every right to act that way merope gaunt litterly gave him love potion for a year, sexually assaulted him, he had every right to walk away and not acknowledge the kid.
Tom Riddle Sr was extremely good looking and rich & the son of the town Little Hangelton's chief. He was in love with a very pretty Cecilia and was a horse rider. All was going well in his life until the ugly, cross eyed, dim-witted Merope's eyes laid upon him. He kindly smiled at her which she mistook for love as she was abused by her father & brother. He was tormented by her brother who used a hive spell upon him because **she **liked him.
Once Gaunt & Morfin were sent to Azkaban, Merope abducted, raped and molested Tom for more than year cuz the evil witch forced him to drink water on a hot day in which she drugged love portion. And the worst part is, he wasn't even in his consciousness so he couldn't resist.
everyone gossiped that the squire's son had run off with the tramp's daughter. Tom was raped again and again until Merope was satisfied and sure she was pregnant so he would be forced to stay with her. Planning he wouldn't leave as she bore his child & he would've fallen in love with her in the past year, she released him from the love portion.
Tom seized his chance and escaped from the monster who turned him into a living corpse for her own enjoyment right back to his parents house. He lived the rest of his life in their house never recovering from this experience as no one would believe him stating that she was a witch, and importantly that he was male sexual abuse victim. The strikingly handsome man was alone because no one was willing to marry the lunatic who had eloped with the weirdest girl in town.
16 years later "the son" he didn't even know who existed but was named after him, came out of the blue one night murdered him & his parents and framed it on his uncle Morfin who perished in Azkaban till his death. Them being the first of the thousands that would follow. He wasn't even left alone to rest in his grave. 50 years later, his murderer again came to the manor to dig up his decaying body and tear it apart to collect his bone.
Tom Riddle's Sr's whole life was a tragedy only because of the lust filled Merope. She proved true that she was Salazar Slytherin's descendant as she made any means to make ends meet. He lived and died a pitiful life not even knowing why he died. Movieflame says he abandoned her as if she was Princess Diana
@@ashleypanzica1316 It'd been amazing if Harry Potter had been a series, even with filler-episodes of just random Fred and George adventures or whatever. :'')
That's the point lol it's part of the reason why Voldemorts backstory is so fucked up
@@ashleypanzica1316 Tom Riddle was always destined to be Volvemort because he was born from false love. Conceived by a person using magic to make someone else "love" them. That's what made Voldemort incapable of love.
@@drd444 this is never stated in the books. Voldemort is a psycho, he bullied others and believe he was above them because of his magic powers that he exibited. You cant put the blame in his parents or in the love potion (is screwed up off course). What Dumbledore says in the books is that Tom grew without love, because he did not have any type of parent, but that is it.
Watching these videos makes me look at the films very differently. I now fully realize just how much the filmmakers screwed over Ron in favour of Hermione, and it’s honestly maddening! While Hermione is the labelled as the brains of the trio, she is ultimately the book-smart one whereas Ron is meant to be the street-smart one from being the one of the trio to be raised in the Wizarding World. The films almost made Ron inconsequential, and I agree when you said the he the most underrepresented character when compared to his portrayal in the books.
Yep. I love Ron in the books, but not the movies.
Ron is amazing! I can’t think about his film butchering too much...it makes me angry.
Not to mention this particular movie did absolute shit with ginny
@@Anonymous-gf5gl don't get me started
Books: Laughing with Ron. Hermione is a flawed genius through effort.
Movies: Laughing at Ron. Hermione is a flawless genius with hardly any effort.
I hated how the movies made everyone able to fly in that smoke shit. Voldemort being able to fly without a broom was a HUGE deal in the books. He was the only one and it was one of his calling cards
Can't snape do that too in the books?
@@beans1697 yes Voldemort taught it too him
At least I think so
Couldn't agree more!
+Ken Hamms cousin I mostly like the beginning scene where the Muggles in the office are shown looking at the window and seeing the Dark Mark in the sky and when the Death Eaters attack.
I feel like in other books, Harry can act not as humble, which is something that the movies rarely delve into, so I don't hate that they added the "But I am the Chosen One" line. I agree, he would never say this about being the Chosen One, but at the same time, the movies sometimes make Harry seem a little too polite or "perfect" and not like a normal teenager. Just take how in the movies they make Harry "be honored" to go to Slughorn's club parties when in the books, it's the last place he wants to be.
I think on some level it shows movie Harry being smarter than his book counterpart because Dumbledore had initially wanted him to get into Slughorn’s good graces in order to get the memory, so he did just that. They even had the scene talking about it in the movie, which was also another book/movie difference because Book Dumbledore told Harry to be on his guard around Slughorn which never quite make sense to me if the original goal was to make them close.
@@krisynthiagomez5883 In no way movie Harry is smarter than book Harry. Movie Harry is just bland and forgettable, the one in the books is sassy and charismatic
@@dannyjorde2677 Sassy yes, charismatic? Hm I’ve never really seen that. The only time we see Harry being remotely charming was under the influence of Felix Felices and he doesn’t draw attention to himself necessarily because of his own qualities but because of his story.
I don't even think it's arogant... it was a joke told to his friend, he couldn't even say it with a straight face and didn't act upon it or anything
I'm pretty sure he was kidding or was telling a true fact, not bragging
I was so mad we never got to see Ginny fly into Zacharias. It's criminal how badly they portrayed her in the movies, and that one scene could've gone a long way
That would be setting a bad example for young viewers. By that I mean it made Ginny look like a jerk by attacking him just because of insults, which weren't killing anyone
And besides Zacharias was portrayed as much nicer in the movies. He applauded Fred and George's fireworks, congratulated Neville for disarming one of the patil twins, and applauded Harry's lessons when everyone left for Christmas break. In the deathly Hallows part 2, when draco got hugged by voldemort and everyone was watching, you'll find a blonde kid next to dean Thomas and that is zacharias. This proves that in the movie, he did fight in the battle of hogwarts and air go, the movies made him a real hufflepuff, so you wouldn't catch him trash talking the Gryffindor quidditch team in the movie.
@@brysontipton1893 is there a rule that these characters need to be examples for young viewers?
They should be. If your child saw a scene like the scene with Ginny slamming zacharias and started doing something similar to that in real life and got in trouble, you'd think that scene would be a bad example.
@@brysontipton1893 No I wouldn’t, because a child young enough to mimic anything they see on screen is also too young to watch a film with wizard nazis in it.
I mean why call this film the Half-Blood Prince if there’s barely anything about Snape’s backstory in this film?
I thought there was some backstory: Hermione uncovers the story in both Book 6 and Movie 6: Snape calls himself the Half-Blood Prince because his Mum was a witch named Elaine "Prince" while his Dad was a Muggle-born guy with the last name of Snape. Hence, Severus Snape is a Half-Blood Prince, using his Mum's name as pen name and his Dad's name as his given last name. More of Snape's backstory is described in Book 7 in the chapter titled "The Half-Blood Prince's Tale" via the Pensieve in Dumbledore's office. Harry uses Snape's tears as the basis for reliving Snape's background; we discover that Lily Evans and Snape are lovebirds until Snape calls Lily "mudblood", which drives her into the arms of James Potter, whom she rejected earlier as a BF because she considered hm to be an arrogant dishrag. James and Lily marry, she bears James a son named Harry, and they end up getting killed by Voldemort.
In addition to the foregoing info, we also discover that Snape still loved Lily even after she married James, which means that Snape loved Harry even though he didn't always demonstrate that affection in the movies. Finally, in the epilogue, we discover that one of Harry and Ginny's sons is named Albus Severus Potter. Why? Because as older Harry tells Albus on the train platform, while Albus was concerned about where he would be Sorted--Gryffindor vs. Slytherin, Dad Harry reminds Albus that he was named for two headmasters of Hogwarts, and one of them was a Slytherin. He was one of the bravest men Harry had ever met.
Yep, harry finds this random ass book and at the end of the movie Snape is like: Oh ye Harry, i am half blood prince. Cya!
@@shepwillner7507 lily and snape weren't lovebirds
Because that's what the book was called
@@shepwillner7507In Book Harry uses a less liquid less gas thing which was leaking from Snape...
Book Slughorn: Bald, large mustache
Movie Slughorn: Full-set of hair, no mustache
Warner Bros really said, *"Why, it's Opposite Day!"*
The one change i would do in the hbp movie: Change slughorns look
Was Bob Hoskins alive then? Someone told me it be him.
What in the series of unfortunate events
@@vikkran401 As he said movie has hair which i dont like
And it was easy to make Jim Broadbent appear bald, but he gave a good performance regardless of the look
My favorite change from book to movie is when Dumbledore talks about "the boy who made all the wrong choices" just before his death. It's an emotional comment that could refer to himself, Voldemort, or Severus all of whom had a stake in this powerful scene.
Or grindelwald.
Or draco
@@thatweirdo150 no, Draco was the one he was talking to.
This is my favorite book and I’m really disappointed in that they left out all the gaunt family, and the rest of Harry’s “lessons” with Dumbledore…literally those are my favorite chapters.
05:38 There is also when Dumbledore greeted Petunia and said to her "We have corresponded, of course" and Harry - along with the reader, again - thought that he meant the howler of the previous summer, yet we find out in the Deathly Hallows that he meant the letter she sent him via mail begging him to accept her in Hogwarts along with her sister.
this is such a cool easter egg in DH, but ofcourse the movies managed to screw it up. in fact i'm pretty sure Petunia's letter to Dumbledore isn't even touched upon in DH2.
Just like that moment when harry thinks Petunia is talking about James like he was a stupid but she meant Snape because we see on DH how Petunia was spying Snape and Lily when they were talking about azkaban
Oh, yeah, right. Petunia still maintains her point of view that Lily is a freak, and yet she wants to attend the same school as Lily. Let's follow that scenario to its conclusion: Lily and Petunia travel in separate compartments on the Hogwarts Express, and then are taken to the castle in the self-propelled row boats where all the first years are greeted on the big staircase by McGonagall. Then they enter the Great Hall and are called by name to be assigned to their House by the Sorting Hat. The Sorting Hat, however, seems to have trouble with assigning Petunia, and eventually assigns her to Slytherin House, the same combined fraternity-sorority where all other ugly, ambitious, and spoiled kids end up.
Fast forward to the end of the 5th year; Petunia is undergoing her OWLs, and unlike her nicer sister, she fails almost every subject except for History of Magic and Herbology. McGonagall and Slughorn both counsel Petunia because of her poor marks in most of the OWLs subjects, she can't continue her studies and is expelled from Hogwarts. The embittered Evans girl somehow gets employed as a secretary with Dursley's employer; they meet at a company Xmas party, they date and then marry. Petunia bears Vernon a boy they named Dudley. Fast forward one more time and they are burdened with the duty of being reluctant parents to an orphaned baby named Harry Potter.
Fast forward two more times and we see how the Dursleys, except for Dudley, treat Harry: not as an accepted second son as Dumbledore hoped, but as an abused kid they treated cruelly. By the time Harry turns 11 YO, the family is visited by Rubeus Hagrid, who tells him he's a wizard; Harry gets the admission letter to Hogwarts, and Harry's story progresses from that point. By the time Deathly Hallows Part I approaches in the 7th and final year of Hogwarts schooling, Harry gets taken to an Order of the Phoenix safe house; fortunately for the Dursleys, they are spared killing by the Death Eaters, and they're forced to evacuate their home to avoid that fate. So what happens to Petunia after that evacuation? I don't know, and I don't care. She and her family are no longer in Harry's life.
Take a shot, every time Morgan says "There's a lot that happens between these scenes"
U'll get drunk
@@MovieFlameyep
@@MovieFlame btw i luv your vids u kinda got me into harry potter i am grateful.❤
**dies of alcohol poisoning**
Or… “They were made just for the film”
i totally HATE the fact that the movies cut bill and fleur
AND Charlie. He's made so forgettable you forget to forget him 😔.
then don't watch em lol
One thing that always struck me as odd in the movie was how little Dumbledore seemed to know about Voldermort's secret to power. It's weird that the word "horcrux" was censored in the fake memory. It made it seem like not only did he not realize Voldemort made a horcrux, but it almost seemed like Dumbledore, one of the most accomplished and brilliant wizards in the series, didn't even know what a horcrux was. The book seemed to tackle this in a much better way. Dumbledore hypothesized that Tom made a horcrux, but wanted to pry for more information on the theory.
To be fair Horcruxes were an insanely rare piece of Magic with Herpo the Foul being the only other person in history to have made one.
This series is incredible Morgan! Can't wait for Deathly Hallows Part 1 and 2!!
I’m looking forward to Morgan roasting how the Part One film screwed over Ron’s character arc.
That movie did Ron the worst since the third one.
@@scaranvostok3637 I hate how they always make Ron stupid and dumb and make Hermione have no flaws. If anything, it should be the other way around!
Same and I agree
The perfect example of quality,not quantity
... what exactly? The video? The topic?
@@JoAnHe0604 the book im assuming- hbp felt short after reading ootp
@@JoAnHe0604 the video
@@cruz.c honestly, It took me much more time to read Goblet of Fire and even Half-Blood Prince than OOTP, I guess it was because I read OOTP more frequently, but I really felt like OOTP was more faster to read it all than GoF and HBP.
The “but I am the chosen one” was a bit of funny sarcasm
I thought the line "I am the chosen one" was kinda cheeky and playfull not arrogant. Like he knew Hermione was gonna hit him when he said it.
Was searching the comments for this!
I totally agree - I really like how he says it, and also her reaction. This kind of chemistry in any relationship (especially friendship, but also wherever you like) just feels great in my opinion. "arrogant" was the wrong word in my opinion. Maybe book Harry wouldn't have said this when he's too worried about other things, but I can also imagine situations where he might say it. In exactly that way and not arrogant at all, just with his friends.
09:21: Divination (Harry's weakest subject); History of Magic (Fainted mid-way during the exam, rendering him unable to finish his paper)
Astronomy testing was where Umbridge took out Hagrid. Harry and the group that were on the Astronomy tower watched as Professor McGonagal was hit with 4 separate curses to her chest.
@@Goldengirl48 Oh, yeah, during the practical exam late that night when the attempted ousting of Hagrid and McGonagall's attack took place. Both the students and proctors turned their attention to the two attacks. Harry and Ron both got an 'Acceptable' (equivalent to either C5 or C6 grade of Singapore-Cambridge GCE 'O' Level examinations), but didn't apply to continue on with Astronomy at NEWT (or 'A' Level) level (they may not have qualified).
“But in the film, Hermione said this”
No surprise there
Half-Blood Prince was my favorite book, especially with all the Riddle/Gaunt backstories so well explained in the book. I really did not like how the movie did not make these memories the main focus of the movie, and again...like all the movies, hated how they diminished Ron. He is kind of like the "Sam to Frodo" equivalent in the HP story and they really did him dirty in all the movies.
I actually enjoy the movie if I separate it from the book and treat it as a different entity. However one part that is unforgivable is Harry’s and Ginny’s kiss (and relationship as a whole). I remember being 10 and reading this part of the book and being so happy. Only to be completely let down by this when the movie came out. Why did they have to change the scene and also include random and cringy shoelace/cookie moments?
Because apparently the writers were Harry/Hermione shippers and Ron and Ginny got in the way. So they butchered the Weasleys for it.
You're a harry/Hermione shipper for believing that. Guys and girls can be best friends and not romantically involved all of the time.
Every time he says "There's a lot that happens between these two scenes" take a shot of firewhiskey
lol
You will need a Horcrux to not die from that.
We aren’t trying to die bro…
Aye
Or that was just made for the movie
I’m currently taking a shot every time he says, “there was a lot that happened between these two scenes”.
Update: I’m now drunker than Winky.
Bonham Carter is so perfect as Bellatrix that I can't be annoyed by her "intrusions" in the movie's plot.
“But there’s a lot that happens inbetween this two scenes” gets me all the time 😂 and the fact that this guy has in his facial expression, the anger by which screenwriters use to sandbag movies like this one, it’s just hilarious. 😂😂
ya he needs to stop
@@ricorofficial why?
@@Thjesht_Teo he just says that all the time and it gets on my nerves lol. It’s clear that he’s pissed off at how the movies adapted the books but that’s his problem.
@@ricorofficial man, if you get pissed of from that line, you have problems.
@@ricorofficial The irony. That is also your problem. So you should be quiet
In my opinion Jim Broadbent was a great casting choice for Slughorn as although he didn’t look like how he does in the book but is perfect in the way he acts - I also love how he calls Ron Wallaby.
Wallenby
You seem like such a genuine person. I appreciate all the hard work and dedication
“But I am the chosen one” hermoine then proceeds to hit harry. One of the most funniest line ever
Im not gonna lie, the "I AM the Chosen One" line I absolutely love
Basically;
- Replaced most of the story revolving around Voldemort and his life in favour of a teen romance comedy (Harry and Dumbledore looked at 2 memories, and they cut out the actual love stories regarding Tonks/Lupin and Bill/Fleur)
- Continued making Ginny a bland side character (I'm pretty sure this movie is what created the theory that Ginny gave Harry a love potion, what with how forced and awkward everything is)
- Took away more of Ron's moments of value
- Took the battle at Hogwarts and moved it to the Burrow (a pale imitation of the proper fight)
Cuz the stupid producers thought this is what us fans want, since at the time, most of us were around that age. Little did they know that the best of the book is riddle past and the background of the horcruxes……
I did like the movie but it wasn’t as faithful
@@anneneville6255 I thought the Battle at Hogwarts was unnecessary when the previous book already had a long fight at the end that was way better, and the book after will have another one. the other memories were cool but weren't essential by any means. I don't think a script where Harry and Dumbledore watch 7 videos of things that happened in the past would make for a good movie.
So you are saying they should Cut out one romance plot for another one lool
@@nanoff815 its not only about the entertainment. The memories have an essential role to play in defeating voldemort
Books: Promote a Ron/Hermione and a Harry/Ginny ending and opposes a Harry/Hermione.
Steve Kloves: But I ship Harry/Hermione and don’t have any respect for Ron and Ginny’s characters.
Also Steve: Tries to build up unneeded tension between Harry/Hermione while at the same time butchering Ron and Ginny’s characters.
Me: THIS IS AN ADAPTATION NOT YOUR FANFIC STEVE!!!!
Facts. Goldenburg should have been the screenwriter for movies 5-8 and in fact all of the films. It should have been him since Kloves was good at adapting shorter novels - the first 3 films. But he struggled to adapt Goblet of Fire and Goldenburg adapted Ootp phenominally. So it makes sense to keep Goldenburg since he would have adapted HBP and DH- these books are longer than the 1st 3 books.
I am not the one to defend Kloves and I do appreciate Goldenberg's take on the fifth and I guess our paths did cross in the Order of the Phoenix video about the same point.
But even Kloves aside, Hermione did have her shining moments in The Order of The Phoenix that either weren't in the book or were taken from Ron as usual, not mentioning the removal of chunks of the book that discussed interrelations between Harry, Cho, Ron, Hermione, Ginny, Luna, etc. so I wouldn't blame Kloves for that one. I would have been interesting to see what would happen if Goldenberg handled the sixth, but I doubt it would have been fundamentally different. His different approach could have been better, but I don't think it would be able to save much.
@@haythamfaisal8113 I personally think Goldenburg should have done the last three films. Why do you think Ron and Ginny felt a lot closer to their book counterparts in OoTP?
But unfortunately, Kloves had to wreck Goldenburg's work later on.
Who cares for the romance 😔
@@haythamfaisal8113 but Goldenberg must have seen previous movies and all the books he must have realised that his predecessor has damaged Ron's character a lot so he could not have made Ron smart and loyal all of a sudden that would cause a lot of consistency problems.
Screenwriter 1: "I feel like I forgot something..."
Screenwriter 2: "Well, if you forgot, then it probably wasn't important"
Screenwriter 1: "Yeah, you're right
MovieFlame: "There's A LOT that happens in between those two scenes!"
I really enjoy at the end of the book, after the cave when Dumbledore is all weak and near death, then once he sees the Dark Mark above the castle, he’s immediately reinvigorated… His students are the most important thing to him
54:47 Also during their conversation she mentioned that she been warning Dumbledore for a long time about the lightning struck tower, probably as far as the time she was in his office when Harry came for his lesson. The tower is where Dumbledore died later. It shows that yet again Trelawney prophesied events that took place.
imagine how Dumbledore (who by this point has already arranged his own death with Snape) must be feeling when Trelawney is repeatedly trying to warn him about a "great unexpected tragedy" that is about to happen at Hogwarts! 😂
@@JuanMataCFC It might not be the great unexpected tragedy for Dumby but it sure was the Order and Hogwarts.
At the ending of the book, both Ron and Hermione says to Harry that they're coming with him to the quest and supports him while in movie in movie Hermione says this to Harry while Ron sits alone and quiet in the back
I hated that.
@@scaranvostok3637 same
More proof to show that apparently in the movies the writers don’t care about Ron shame.😞😢
I love how thorough these are. HP is my escape “safe space” thingy.
Goblet of fire: The one where everybody needed a haircut
Half blood prince : where everybody (including the screenwriter) needed to calm their hormones down.
Man.... as youtuber I can understand the amount of hours and effort behind this series of videos.
Dude... you have my respect ( imagin me yelling "respect" like the crazy guy from the movie Parasites).
How are you not verified?
Big respect! Awesome vids
If they ever decide to redo these films, I feel it's incredibly important that you be in the room during any final editing. I find it impossible to disagree with you and the world could benefit from your dedication to the accuracy of the novels.
Why would they redo the series? I know they've redone comic book and slasher series, but never a book series.
I hope they never redo them
They need to redo them as a TV series, with time to do the story and characters justice
Wish they would remaster the entire series by better directors
The only movies they should redo is GoF, HBP and morph both parts of deathly hallows into one, 3 hour-long movie. I feel like that would be much better than having it split into 2 parts and it would stick out from the other movies being the longest one and more ambitious.
the whole Half-Blood Prince movie is cringe.
"but there is a lot that happens between these two scenes in the novels" As am watching these back to back I started taking a sip anytime those words or words to that effect are uttered. Especially with this adaptation... they did this book so dirty.
Because so many locations, and character moments were not shown or not done justice, I beg to have a Harry Potter TV series reboot in the form of photo-realistic animation; not live action. This will allow more time and space to explore everything from the books and have more effective CGI. 1 book= 1 season and 1 chapter= 1 episode.
Season 1: 17 episodes
Season 2: 18 episodes
Season 3: 22 episodes
Season 4: 37 episodes
Season 5: 38 episodes
Season 6: 30 episodes
Season 7: 37 episodes
It doesn't always need to be one chapter per episode, some can be combined.
But I honestly wouldn't mind some filler episodes with completely original stories, just so we can have extra worldvuilding and character developments.
The problem is some chapters are over 30 pages and The Dementors Kiss chapter had 9 pages so that'll be a problem
@@filipfilip1507 Chapters could be combined.
Like, in season 1, episode 1 could be chapters 1 and 2. (prologue and trip to the zoo)
episode 2 could be chapters 3, 4 and 5. (letters, hut on the rock, Diagon Alley)
episode 3 could be chapters 6 and 7. (Hogwarts Express and Sorting Seremony).
and so on.
@@wariolandgoldpiramid episode 1 should end with Hagrid kicking down the door and revealing himself to Harry and the Dursleys
I’ll never forgive Steve Kloves for butchering Ron and Ginny just because he thought Harry and Hermione were going to be a thing.
He treats the books more like his own fan fiction.
lol you should make Potter a smaller part of your identity. There is no reason to get this mad typing 3-4 comments about how bad the movie is.
@@toonsoffun5733 ootp is the worst movie followed by gof hbp is much better and more enjoyable
@@toonsoffun5733 this has nothing to do with identity, its just sat that the movies butchered ron...
@@caturix4541 You have to understand the context. This person wrote like 3-4 comments complaining about the movie. One is fine but more than that is just silly.
@@toonsoffun5733 Dude, I suffer from “book elitist” disorder.
I love how much he despises when Steve Klove's implies his weird obsession with pairing Hermione with Harry 😂
i know the part where harry says "but i am the chosen one" was really unrealistic- but it was pretty goddamn funny
I’m not even a huge Harry Potter fan, I read the books as a kid and enjoy the movies, but I love your videos, which speaks to their quality. Massive respect for the work you put into them. Keep it up man
I really wish that Harry and Ginny’s first kiss was like in the book in front of everybody 🤩
The movie kiss was 💩 ! 😠
Me too
Yess, i was so cut off about that
Hermione was even beaming that Harry and Ginny finally kissed!
Ron’s confused reaction was hilarious
My only nitpick about it was we don't read Ginny's reaction to Harry kissing her. Obviously it was positive as they start dating, but I would like to know her reaction and the expression on her face. Other than that, the kiss was great!
This film should have been called “Harry Potter and the Raging Hormones” they cared more about teen love triangles then the great story that was book 6. Smh
Bro him saying he is the chosen one is one of my FAVORITE lines of the entire series! It’s a small glimpse of Harry actually being proud of being the chosen one for once, and you could even tell he was half joking anyways!!
This is my favorite movie because of how hilariously charming Daniel Radcliffe is throughout the movie, especially when he takes the liquid luck, it’s SO GOOD!!
This movie has its flaws for sure, as they all do, but I think it’s the most enjoyable and just can’t help but smile every time I watch it.
The movie is different from the books, and this is something people really can't accept. In Movie 6, Harry is, for the first time in a long time, just enjoying life, (outside of hunting Malfoy and trying to unweave his plot) there's an ease and grace in which Harry (well, Daniel Radcliffe) moves through the scenes, its the closest we get to see what Harry would have been as a normal boy. This sense of calm is broken utterly by the finale and I feel that may have been the movie maker's intentions.
Also, I felt the movie handled Malfoy excellently in this movie, despite not saying much, we are given his perspective a good number of times and we can see him unravelling, this is best shown when there's a party going on in one part of the school and it switches to Draco ruminating at the top of the Astronomy tower.
Loved the video! I also hate that they failed to include the fact that Harry gave Fred and George the money to start the joke shop because we didn't get the scene where they pull him aside and tell him he's not allowed to pay for anything there. It was so sweet 🥺
Ironic that the book is arguably the best of the series while the movie is largely seen as a disappointment
same with GoF. by far the two best books, but also the two worst movies!
@@JuanMataCFC bedy.book is POa and goblet not hbp
@@JuanMataCFC Disagree, I quite like GOF
Am I the only one who enjoyed it like I liked that we were able to kinda feel there friend ship
Its my favorite film, regardless of how well the adaptation is.
This guy deserves way more subs, his detail and through explanation and objective judgement is something that I have never seen, and the times he does put in personal opinions, he gives credible and valid explanation for it.
Harry in the book: In shock, kneeling over Draco, in disbelief and horror without what the spell had done.
Harry in the movie: aight guess I’ll leave
Having just read the books for the first time, my least favorite thing is how they did Ginny in the movies. She’s got so much spunk and personality in the book, and there is NONE of that in the movie. I get having to drop elements from the book to film, but they took out great lines from Ginny, and put in their own TERRIBLE lines. I’m not saying you have to capture her lines word for word, but there is none of the spirit of Ginny in the books, in this movie
They did not wanted anybody to outshine Emma Watson
There was one good scene when they were doing the quidditch tryouts in movie 6 and ginny just silences everyone with one shout.
@@rabiyaashraf950 Almost definitely by her own demand.
She’s got so much what in the book??
@@joshuamitchell5530 spunk, like charisma or fieriness
You missedd the one where Mrs. Weasley thanks Harry for pretty much saving everyone in her family. Much more touching than the movie. But great work. A lot of thought put into it.
"But I am the chosen one" is still one of my favorite lines though, and I love it so much ❤😂
Earned a new sub getting baked and watching these after work has been nice. Great video dude.
In the book Harry sometimes tries to actively avoid joining Slughorn's meetings. Dumbledore doesn't mention his intention behind bringing Slughorn back until very much into the book. But in the movie, he mentions it to Harry in their first meeting. So there is a clear difference in Harry's interaction with Slughorn in the books and the movies.
Yup
In the book: Harry is not ostentatious and never was, he hated being the center of attention and that's all slughorn wanted from him, and that's why Harry evaders from him
but in the movie: they made Harry loves his fame and seem to enjoy it (I'm the chosen one, who wants to see me open the egg)
a big difference between his character in the books and the movies
"But there's a lot that happens between these two scenes." That's his new catchphrase.
HBP was my favorite book, but when I saw the film I was so broken-hearted. It was completely butchered. This book is literally the beginning of Snape's backstory beginning to be known. We got a little with that scene where Harry learned his father was a bully in OK TO, but this is where big clues about Snape, his history, and clues about his true loyalty are begnning to show. Snape is literally my favorite character from the Harry Potter series, and to see them basically spit on what helped make him the bitter, complex man he was killed me. As yet I have not been able to bring myself to watch the two DH films because of what they did here.
The 2 DH films are supposedly alright but im devestated also. They threw away Half-Blood Prince
These are so good- it’s just like reading/watching the books and movies at the same time- brilliant
Seamus and Dean don’t actually take Potions in this book. The trio sits with Ernie MacMillan and there’s four Ravenclaws and four Slytherins as well. Once again, an amazing video!
They forgot to explain abou the Owls and that's why they skipped everything about that plot
what's the trio
@@israshugrisulubxuseen1805 Harry, Ron and Hermione
@@israshugrisulubxuseen1805 H,H and R
I honestly like the decision that Bellatrix wants Snape to make the vow as it fits her character perfectly as voldemort seemed to somewhat trust snape more than bellatrix making her jealous as she is infatuated with voldemort. Bellatrix also suspects Snape of not being loyal, so of course she would make the vow in order to secure control over snape as if he did not help draco he would be proven unloyal and die making it Bella's victory.
the audacity of Bellatrix to accuse Snape of not being loyal at the start, and then not even be present for the Battle of the Astronomy Tower at the end!
I found it more meaningful to have it be Narcissa. It shows how much she cares about Draco and better builds up to the Malfoys abandoning Voldemort in the next book.
@@JuanMataCFC to be fair, Voldemort didn't expect Draco to succeed. He wanted Draco to either be killed or punished by himself to get back at Lucius for failing to get the prophecy. So bellatrix wouldn't have been risked
maybe this is just me but when I saw the movie, Lavender came across less like she was into Ron and more heavily obsessed with him. Like…creepy obsession. I literally joked with my parents by saying, “Run!” During the scene on the train. Idk we kept thinking that someone drugged her with a love potion to make her obsessed with Ron. When the movie ended I was like,”What was the point of the love potion shit!?”
The love potion theme didn't connect to anything because they never talked about Tom Riddle Sr. :( That was the whole point of the love potion being presented
Thank you so much for these videos. I watch these on repeat when I’m having a hard time or really bad anxiety. Thank you for all of it. ❤️
The movies didn’t do Ginny any justice. This movie has the most objections with the book lol… but it’s actually my favorite movie.. visually lol.
MovieFlame, you should read the arc of a scythe series. It seems right up your alley, and it is an amazing series
What about The Stormlight Archive.
Would that fit his mold, you think?
I just finished reading this trilogy last month!
Has he read *The Dark Tower* ? (there's 7 books, plus one that came out long after the series was done, and which takes place between books 4 & 5 )
I was so pissed off by the "movie adaptation" ... you can't even do a "every single difference" on it since most of it is made up and is just taking elements here and there from the books while being a sequel at the same time...
I hope the upcoming tv show with Jasper Pääkkönen as Randall Flagg and as Sam Strike as Roland will be good.
(The recent "The Stand" tv show wasted a perfectly good Flagg, I'm still salty about it)
“But I am the chosen one” top 5 lines in cinima/movie history
Appreciate your hard work, you have just made a 1-hour video with so many details and unique visuals. Kudos
The only part of this movie that I loved was Harry’s arrival (so many hugs!) at the Burrow although I wish they did not cut the scene in the shed with Dumbledore. I also wish Tonks was in the movie more.
+Ty Ashley Yeah, I love Harry’s arrival at the Burrow in the movie too with all the hugs! He also apparently arrived before 1:00 a.m. I also agree with the other two bits you’ve said.
We, as 11 year old kids decided that it was a good idea to watch Half Blood Prince with our school teacher. Little did we know that the movie would have so much snogging and kissing and other teen drama..! We were sooo awkward and embarrassed that whole time and wanted the movie to be over ASAP
Awkward moment
@@filipfilip1507 so awkward that I remember it 100%
Lol I watched it when I was 10
Wasn't THATTTT much
Eh idk
I feel you, first time I watched this movie was in the theaters at about 16 and was just cringing the whole way through. I hope that wasn’t your first Harry Potter experience because this movie is not the best introduction.
I'd prefer this be a Voldemort movie rather than a teen drama movie
Side quest: count how many times he says something like “the movie then cuts to _____, but there’s a lot that happen between these two scenes.”
I agree with every complaint except for the scene at Hargrid's with Slughorn. One of my favorite scenes in any of the movies.
That was a very good scene.
Dude I'm so supportive of all that you do 100. But the line " but I am the chosen one" is one of the best lines in the whole series. This moment shows Harry being more real and stepping outside the "boy who lived" shadow. It makes you identify with his character more.
I really like the scene in the books with Snape remarking on Tonks' Patronus because it foreshadows his own. Of course he'd be the one to notice it has changed because she's in love. He also mocks it for looking "weak" which is pretty funny considering his Patronus (and his love) is one of the strongest in the series AND he probably knows what Lupin's Patronus is.
Man...The nostalgic background music on your hp videos is just pure GOLD!
The movies went so far out of their way to set up the idea of Harry and Hermione as a couple it’s not even funny.
This series is the reason I started reading the Harry Potter books
Oooh, how far have you come?
@@mariannek6735 almost done with half blood prince
@@jacobmccoy7498 Oh wow! You're a fast reader!
How are you liking the series compared to the movies? Sorry I'm just a massive HP nerd lol
@@mariannek6735 I love the books better but both books and movies are great
@@mariannek6735 it does help that I am listening to the book while also following along with a hard copy
I feel like the movies completely forgot that Dumbledore is supposed to be a very humorous and collected person and not this serious and angry old man.
Even Rowling confirmed that he's gay. Doesn't seem homosexual in the movies at all
@@pierreracine8338 Cuz that was only said by Rowling long after the movies were finished. Honestly the woman just throws out stupid random nonsense online about the series these days
@Majora Twili actually she confirmed it around the time the sixth movie came out, but even if you don’t attribute his behaviors and eccentrics as being gay which the more I think about it kind of do, it is true that Book Dumbledore is a much more laidback, cheerful, if Machiavelli character than portrayed in the movies.
They didn't forget
After the second film, the original person who played dumbledore had died (Richard Harris) and didn't want to get replaced, so Michael Gambon instead of replacing him, chose to create his own dumbledore
Please keep doing what you’re doing, hooked to the content!
These videos are fantastic! Such a good job in the explanation.