5:08 Terry Farrell was supposed to have the face prosthesis, but when she was cast for the part the director thought she was too beautiful (and he was right) to cover her face with anything. So the leopard spots were created instead.
@@walterwhite5354 Rom was a murderous fiend in the beginning. Go back to the season 1 DS9 episode called 'The Nagus' where he tried to kill Quark. But the writers completely retooled the character to make Rom into a bumbling but lovable and good-hearted genius. In my opinion, the inconsistency of Rom is one of the biggest mistakes made on DS9. They could have gradually had him change from how he was originally into a more likable character a few seasons into the series. Instead, they forced the change unnaturally and pretty much created a completely different character who happened to be named Rom.
1:28 Worf was adopted and raised by human parents, remember? Of course he'd have their habits and traditions, like sleeping with a mattress/pillow/blankets.
Odo was wrong about Rom, as was Quark. Once Rom was given the proper opportunities and training, he became a good engineer. This is character development
Or perhaps nobody paid attention to him, not even Odo who is great at keeping a file of everyone, specially considering the yuuge file he must have on his brother.
Just pointing out with the Klingon sleeping thing, that the only people sleeping was either worf, or someone sleeping in worfs quarters. Worf was raised by humans :p thanks foe the video though
Also the kid who wants what he hunted cooked was raised by romulans and was specifically not taught the ways of a Klingon warrior, seeing as he was being taught by worf, who does eat cooked food, it is very likely he left out that part :) while kern was raised as a klingon warrior apart from worf, and even comments on how weak he is multiple times, for being corrupted by human influence
Also I'm pretty sure that Klingon was trolling Picard. I'm sure the Klingons tend to sleep on harder surfaces over all but not all the time and different from person to person.
As Jazia Dax stated Klingons are as diverse a species / people as anyone else. There is a difference between a stereotype and the totality of a people as a whole
That one Klingon saying he won't take away the animal until it's cooked isn't a mistake. That was the episode where Worf discovered the community of Klingons raised by Romulans. That one Klingon never interacting with another Klingon outside of that community obviously wouldn't know about how much Klingon's love to eat their food live or raw.
Riker was right though, the borg are born as organic creatures, of different species, they live some portion of their lives, then they're assimilated into the collective.
Unless they could drastically accelerate the growth process, it would be very inefficient to "raise" a Borg baby. When they assimilated planets they'd likely either ignore small children or just kill them all.
Again I find nothing but nitpicking and ignorance of basic logic: Rom was character Development/general underestimation of him. Matresses are often integral to most bed designs. You only get a Bed Base underneat: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bed_base So removing them anywhere but the Defiant was not possible. The defiant had that nice "solid slab" design. Kahn: Nope, Starfleet Captains do not know 300 year old guys by their *face.* Heck, nobody even noticed that this one Historical Character looks a *lot* like Benjamin Sisko. Because he time travelled to become him. And if you notice, even the Enterprise crew had do get a refresher on him. I do know who Genghis Khan and Napoleon are, even if I could not *put a face to them.* Heck give him a shave, and I would propably not notice Hitler. And I am a german, that is literaly history for me. Chakotay: He might have re-considerd on the 7 years of journey. Or just choose to ignore that for a date with 7 of 9. And you *can* roast vegetables quite well. Roasted Potates would like to confirm that. Safety routines: Belana was already Chief Engineer. This was a shuttle. And she was the only XO on that suttle. Borg Reproduction: Yes, the vision of the Borg changed by "Best of both Worlds". And they stuck with that ever since. By 7of9 times they might have stopped doing that altogether. Honor & Hostages: "With a few exceptions, no Klingon in that time had any honor." - Star Trek Online about TOS times. Klingon Transformation: Why would he know about it? That is a part of 200 years of History with very low relevancy for every day work. Euydian Thumbs: Maybe that guy had just lost his thumbs? Makeup details. Very nitpicky. Symbiont and Transport: He was *injured.* Transports can be deadly for Injured people in a lot of cases. Heck, Bashir once moved a Fetus to save it for a long yourney and that is *less* disruptive then a transport. Travel Planning: Most civilian ships do *not* make warp 9.8. And they might even have intentional speed limits, due to subspace damage caused by warp travel. I mean he even mentions that it would take *only weeks* with the Enterprise. Regrowth: Kidney != Every organ. Dyalisis != Kidney missing. Layperson != doctor. A lot of organs may have unique ease of regrowth. The Liver is *very well* known for it's regenerative properties in todays time, for example. Regeneration might even be part of it's normal operating procedure. *IF* you still got 25% left, you can regrow a fulyl functional: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liver#Liver_regeneration Sickbay Items: Do I need to explain the difference between a historical display and tools? DNA: A few years between those. And there are *lot* of levels of analyzing DNA. DNA Services only decode like 0.02% of your DNA th-cam.com/video/uyRgk8Cqmzg/w-d-xo.html That little should be possible with a Tricorder too. Finding Data: They only picked up the general signature, still needing to find Before the hard way. Also this was a Trap by Nero. And Data was *dead* at this very moment. They needed to find his grave. Shields: The shields were focussed (and taxed to the limit) into holding the door open and the ship was like 100 yeras old. Technolog evolves. Fire: They definitely said "Fire supression is not working", and you are just being a Idiot ignoring that part. Jem Hadar wore armor. And Refire rate is *very* important in combat. And you only need to take out supports to collapse most buildings. Speed of light: Well, romulus should not have been destroyed by a supernova without literal decades to prepare. Except it travelled in subspace most of the way. Apparently something in this way of blowing up suns works the same way? The Child: Except the differentiation happens on Hormonal basis and this was a life energy entity. Sound: There is this technology called "Radio". It does travel through space. Self Sealing: A borg claw is inteded to cut stuff, *including* getting over self-sealing layers/abilities. A Romulan mines "I need to stick here" rods did not.
As far as the bed thing, their quarters were easily customizable. A Klingon wouldn't be stuck with a soft cushy bed if he didn't want one, especially if he claimed it was a cultural thing.
The video is nit picking you idiot, no one has ever denied that. It's just supposed to show some funny inconsistencies whether they be entirely accurate or not.
@@orgonkothewildlyuntamed6301 Wow, the "you got no life" routine? Could you find something modern please? Maybe ask a 5 year old. Asuming you get out that much.
Odo wasn't a Bajoran so couldn't be a collaborator ,he wasnt even a humanoid, the problems begin when he was employed as security when the station was handed over to the Federation/Bajor.
You could make a whole video of Odo collaborating while people say he wasn't a collaborator. The kira odo friendship might be the most unrealistic thing about the series. They met while he was interrogating her for the cardassians. She then tells him he is working for the cardassians. They never showed them becoming friends or odo even questioning what he is doing. They just magically are friends with kira defending him
A lot of these can be explained by simple arbitrary differences, simple misconceptions, semantics, or even bad context. For example; holideck safety protocols on the Enterprise-D are probably not the same as they are on the Voyager, i.e. the Enterprise requires 2 officers to deactivate safety protocals, Voyager only needs 1: Or Captain Terrel in Star Trek II probably did know Earth history, but he probably didn't think that Khan was Khan when he saw him most likely because he wouldn't have recognized Khan in his aged state, and the unlikelihood of them encountering Khan was very high so there was no reason to expect to find him.
@@nunya3163 It's likely Checkov was on the Enterprise. We just hadn't seen him. There was over 430 people on that ship. We saw only a couple dozen, total.
At 6:40 the display on the Sick Bay wall doesn't mean McCoy uses these instruments. It is a display of antique surgical instruments that are no longer used by 23rd Century Doctors. But, the fact is that McCoy himself,as a Human doctor, would also be obsolete by that time. Computerized Robotic Doctors are already being developed. They have already performed surgery on people.
I would agree with this, especially with the way they are hanging that's not a setup for every day use, but a display case. Though McCoy wouldn't be completely outdated. while computers and robotics would be playing a much greater role by that time then they are now. there are some fields that are not going to be fully automated and I think that is one of them.
For a sci-fi setting Star Trek is actually very backwards when it comes to robotics, with only a handful of exceptions. Apart from those exceptions we're actually more advanced than the entire Star Trek setting when it comes to that specific field.
"Worf, your adapted human parents raised you well, use knives and forks, not your hands, sleep on a matress, not a sheet of steel, and change clothes, not wear them constantly."
Sound won't travel through a vacuum, that is correct. However, the sound wasn't travelling through a vacuum, it was travelling through the suits which were touching each other.
" Sorry, Captain Picard, but Klingons only sleep on the most firm , Comfortable slabs of the highest quality steel. Nothing more, and nothing less. Sweet dreams!!."
Some of these are really funny because they're obvious errors but some of them could have an explanation, such as 9:34 when Kirk and Spock are in their spacesuits and Kirk is calling Spock to try and wake him. I don't think they were implying Kirk's voice could magically be heard through the vacuum of space, as I would assume their spacesuits have a radio comm system built into them and that's what we were hearing when he was trying to wake Spock.
@Connection Lost Nope. It never taste like the original because they simplified the paterns for storage. A proper steack pattern could take 5 times more memory space in the ship's memory banks.
It is funny though that each time we do see Worf sleeping on a mattress it appears to give him nightmares. Also we could assume that Riker was just assuming that the Borg reproduce naturally and install implants right away, those babies very well might have been captured along with their mothers. Voyager did later encounter a bunch of Borg kids as well.
The Borg baby was not a mistake. It was an infant being assimilated from a recently captured world. Riker simply did not misunderstood what was going on.
Meh, the vegetarian bit can be explaind as Neelix being a) a terrible chef (chakotay lied figuring it would be harder to burn a salad) and/or b) Neelix being a moron and getting Chakotoy's preferences wrong.
Funny how Star Trek has always been inconsistent with these sort of small things, even within the same series, and yet "true fans" lose their shit whenever anything from Enterprise onwards slightly contradicts an offhand remark from TOS.
I had always been bothered with how they presented the Borg behaviors different constantly. 1st they are born humanoid then given Borg parts. They BUILT Capt. Picard into Locutus. Then they suddenly have assimilation tubes & nano tech...what?
Bonus Baby i think they assumed that the borg made babies, i guess those babies are assimelated ones that they had picked up from a planet or something...
You’re right, ST sucks, ruined forever!!! From now on it’s just Star Wars for me, because nothing is wrong with any of those movies, tv shows, novels or comics. It’s all perfect and will be so FOREVER. Not like that crappy Star Trek, they can’t get anything right.
Much of the Mistakes presented in this video could have been due to lack of knowledge when the episode was written and filmed. The Trill Transporter issue could have been resolved between the time the TNG Trill Ambassador incident happened and Dax was introduced. As for some of the continuity errors, Chakotey being a vegetarian and then not could have been simply mistakes between writers not communicating with each other and incomplete character profiles. The Tricorder scanning DNA could have been a new design while the Enterprise Tricorders did not have that functionality yet. Many of the mistakes made between series especial TOS and TNG could largely be explained by outside knowledge of science being vastly different in the 20 years between the two series. As for the disabling of the Safety protocols of the Holodeck, Torres was the chief Engineer and adept at finding work arounds to problems, should could have written a backdoor subroutine into the Holodeck programming that permitted her to disable the Safeties without a second senior officer.
It's also well established on Star Trek that there are different levels of shields. Any starship will have a navigational shield to protect from space debris etc; they just don't protect from phaser/disruptor fire very well. It seems reasonable to assume that the Jenolan is holding the doors with its navigational shields, not its actual shields. For that matter, it's nearly 100 years older than the Enterprise; it's entirely plausible its shields don't block more advanced transporters. O'Brien managed to beam over to the Phoenix, a much newer ship than the Jenolan, when its shields were raised simply by knowing exactly when to time it between shield cycles.
Totally agreed with David, it also explains the torpedoes being able to penetrate the shields. It's just like what happened in Generations when the klingons got the Enterprise's shield frequency looking through Geordi's visor, and matched their torpedoes.
@Valami Izé no it's not. they would have a communication system built into the suit so they'd still be able to hear each other, not because the sound is traveling though the vacuum. but because it's getting picked up by the mic inside one suit, which transmits a radio signal to the other one, then that one sends the signal it got to the speaker on the inside. and vice versa when the other talks. the suit can take damage, and this still work as long as the audio and transceiver bits aren't hit to badly. and since we don't know where on the suit they are, it's possible they didn't get hit.
@SLOWPOKE RODRIGUEZ the suits are going to be pressurized so that the people inside the suit can breathe. that means there is a medium inside the suit. and that's all you need. because the sound doesn't have to travel between the suits. it just has to travel inside the suit. as they could have the same tech in their comm badges built into the suit, so that the suits are sending signals between each other. This is how all the real Astronauts have done it, sure the real one's have all used headsets. but I honestly don't see why we couldn't use a speakerphone type design if we wanted. and there for not even need to have any visible audio equipment. but still be using such to communicate.
the problem with that dialogue is that if the child only had her DNA then it would a female (basically a clone of her) , it's impossible to be a male otherwise , unless she's genetically a male or that Betazoid male and female seperation is not genetic
Perhaps the entity that became her son was well aware of this fact and choose to be a boy for that reason. Or betazoids are like lizards... They can change gender.
@@alexandriamaguire8224 That's actually a completely valid point, seeing as in one episode where a virus or something is causing the Enterprise crew to devolve, Diana is show soaking in a tub as something amphibian/reptilian :)
They likely didn't use wide field shots during the Siege of AR-558 on DS9 because they use a bunch more power and the Starfleet team there was extremely under supplied.
The only one I can defend here is Kirk calling out to Spock from one space suit to the other. There would have been communication devices in the suits to enable communication with each other.
I always questioned how they were able to beam Scotty and Geordie through the shields in the Dyson sphere. I assumed they looked up the Genolin's shield frequency?
The TOS Klingons' look was a result from experimentation on transgenic human DNA from the Eugenic war. This had to be classified on hight level. It's normal than Bashir did'nt know about it.
I really hated the entire attempt to explain the TOS klingons and it was totally unnecessary. It also would have been more amusing if when they arrived in the past Michael Dorn was suddenly in the TOS Klingon makeup and nobody noticed the difference.
Have u ever tought i of murdering alex kurtzman and replace as the head of the writing team on the newer star trek? you would do well with the canon lore ..lol
Actually quite a few of these can be reasoned away due to circumstance. For example Worf using quilts and bed linins when Klingons don't use any bed comforts. Worf has grown up with most of his life being spent within the federation, being exposed the their culture. And for Odo when he mentions that Rom isn't very clever, nobody on deep space 9 (except for Rom's son) really knew at that point that Rom was actually talented in the field of engineering since he was firmly under Quarks grasp at the bar. It wasn't until later that he was recognized as a competent engineer by Cheif 0'brian and the rest of the station. Some of the Starfleet rules present in TNG could easily have been changed by the time of Deep space 9 as well as some technological advanced too such as the blood DNA analysis. Some other things can simply be explained as "Good film making" since waiting several minutes for the suns explosion to register would've been a burden on the viewer even if they used a cut or explained it away with more fighting filler. Otherwise there are a few inconsistencies here and there. Mainly with the cannon of the old show and the Borg between TNG and Voyager. Fortunately it seems a good deal of this comment section agrees on this. Paying closer attention is usually the key here. Its not being nerdy its just called good observation haha.
I have no idea why it feels normal to see McCoy in 20th Century hospital scrubs. A lot of these mistakes aren't that deep. Sometimes the script has to forget something as simple as the shields still being up when the Enterprise D was escaping the Dyson Sphere. Some of them can be escused while some aren't. 🙄
Some i can forgive. Odo underestimates Ron like everyone does. The Chakotay hologram is just that a hologram, so there is room for error. The Borg maturation chamber, the Enterprise crew don't know about the Borg at this point
They forgot about that one episode from Star Trek Enterprise where an augmented human couple were sleeping in a bed made outta animal fur... Onboard a stolen Klingon raptor ship.
Yeah...the "We found a positronic signal we havent even calibrated for, from a direction the long range scanners werent even looking in" just to start the plot was stupid..
When people are healing I think they do hundreds of practice runs blaming themselves for things and often for things I didn’t even do but they’re just trying to understand where they went wrong in their own lives, not that I can speak for them. But I do love this video
sound does travel in space. space contains gases that come from different space bodies dirt etc.. all kinds of little things that vibrate. it just the frequency would be so low it would be impossible to hear with our present tech
Some of these are due to habits or sentimentality, but things like the phasers and tricorders are certainly a problem. Physics has always been a problem with Star Trek, and so has changing cultural norms. Star Fleet has always been at war with itself, either trying to be apolitical or spectra-political, martial or peace-loving. Things change all the time which is why so much of it is explained away by time period, personality and habits, and cultural norms.
I'm started wonder how's most of these are even mistake some are taken out of context or can be explained away by ignoring a number of things... this isn't like new trek either that has very clear continuity errors... If anyone else wants to explain each one I would like to give them a chance to do so because I feel like I can explain nearly all of these except spock thinking klingons don't have tear ducks maybe he was joking spock is half human it's possible but maybe that is the only one I don't have problems with suspecting as for the lack of history knowing history that one could be somewhat excusable but could also be just an over sigh the rest aren't really errors at all.
The TNG phasers aren't more powerful than the phase rifles in DS9, they just don't have them set to maximum power and spread like Riker did as they would deplete their power cells in a few shots and they're trying to hold off a whole army.
Some of these are good catches other can be explained away. All human fetuses start out as female changes have to be made I'm not a doctor but I believe something needs to be withheld before the male gender develops. also there are many species in the animal kingdom but can start off female and change to male or start off as male and change the female. As far as the surgical tools on Doctor McCoy's wall they were antique he was being nostalgic and a collector of these not using them for surgery. do you have so many things on here I never even thought about thanks for bringing that up I appreciate that now I'm curious seeing as how they had all these scientific minds behind the next generation when it was being created looks they goofed it up.
So,e of these so called mistakes can be debunked due to fact events take place further in future and technology has advanced to do it such as scanning for androids and DNA scanning
A lot of these aren't mistakes, they just you not understanding the character development or that we don't have hours to watch them traverse space when the show was only 45 minutes.
What they don't live in a constant universe that was most likely written on the spot for most episodes and only used what was useful for the plot? Better throw it all out.
Producer of course knows the speed of light. This scene is intentionally made. Do you want to wait several minutes in front of the screen? 製作者は、とうぜん光速は知っています。このシーンは、あえてこう作られてるんでしょ。 スクリーンの前で何分も待っていたいですか？
About detecting drones from light years away, while having problems with recovering data of pre-warp civilizations without breaking the prime directive, no, most androids emit subspace signals, and all of them emit radio and electronic signatures, wi-fi, whatever, that travel the speed of light and are detectable by sensors, they're not as good when listening to conversations, and even if they were, you need a closer look to know what your seeing, locate and replicate copies of their books and art, to know why what your seeing is what your seeing and why is it there, you can't do that with droid seeking sensory, specially when the civilization is pre-radio, TV or whatever. The opposable thumbs was great tho, I didn't realize that one and it's kinda obvious lol.
Well you could argue that Data was "offline", inactive, deactivated in that episode. B4 on the other hand was more or less active. Remember the hand was moving and the head was completely "awake".
Transparent aluminum exists today. It has been proven that women craft some make genes. The Klingon beliefs has changed over the "countries" before the warrior class they were more peaceful so it's possible for many to carry different ideas including what to sleep on
The instruments on McCoys wall were a collection, he never used them.
Beads and rattles...
Still that was funny
5:08 Terry Farrell was supposed to have the face prosthesis, but when she was cast for the part the director thought she was too beautiful (and he was right) to cover her face with anything. So the leopard spots were created instead.
200 Years later the Suit is worse..
Classic..
96% of the human body is water?
More than Jellyfish at 95%!
To be fair, everyone thought rom was an idiot in the beginning...
rom is ugly but he has a heart of gold and is a genius.
He is an idiot when it comes to common sense. He's autistic when it comes to engineering.
@@walterwhite5354 Rom was a murderous fiend in the beginning. Go back to the season 1 DS9 episode called 'The Nagus' where he tried to kill Quark. But the writers completely retooled the character to make Rom into a bumbling but lovable and good-hearted genius. In my opinion, the inconsistency of Rom is one of the biggest mistakes made on DS9. They could have gradually had him change from how he was originally into a more likable character a few seasons into the series. Instead, they forced the change unnaturally and pretty much created a completely different character who happened to be named Rom.
I remember him always walking like an idiot. Made it seem like he either had rickets or was about to shit his pants, or maybe both.
Nodak81 maybe he was the multi generational son of Torgo. 😉😁
Odo having two different outfits when he worked for the Cardassians hardly counts as a mistake.
Yeah, the green shirt outfit was his everyday work wear. The black outfit was for special occasions, like Bajoran executions.
The error wasn't that, but "odo wasn't a collaborationist" when he openly says "I was working with cardassians"
1:28 Worf was adopted and raised by human parents, remember? Of course he'd have their habits and traditions, like sleeping with a mattress/pillow/blankets.
He also had quite the Stereotype View on Klingons that clashed with reality later on in the series forcing him to find his own path.
I always assumed the Klingon was kinda screwing with Picard with the claim that they don't use any pad.
Odo was wrong about Rom, as was Quark. Once Rom was given the proper opportunities and training, he became a good engineer. This is character development
yeah Rom is still an idiot in many things (such as dealing with other people) and only a genius in very specific things like tech stuff
Or perhaps nobody paid attention to him, not even Odo who is great at keeping a file of everyone, specially considering the yuuge file he must have on his brother.
@@dominionwar1185 it's possible that Rom is autistic.
Until he received training he was an idiot
@@granudisimo Maybe Odo said that merely as a tactical argument to elicit a response so Quark would incriminate himself
Just pointing out with the Klingon sleeping thing, that the only people sleeping was either worf, or someone sleeping in worfs quarters. Worf was raised by humans :p thanks foe the video though
Also the kid who wants what he hunted cooked was raised by romulans and was specifically not taught the ways of a Klingon warrior, seeing as he was being taught by worf, who does eat cooked food, it is very likely he left out that part :) while kern was raised as a klingon warrior apart from worf, and even comments on how weak he is multiple times, for being corrupted by human influence
Also I'm pretty sure that Klingon was trolling Picard.
I'm sure the Klingons tend to sleep on harder surfaces over all but not all the time and different from person to person.
"Cowards take hostages. Klingons do not."
"What about a century ago?"
"We don't talk about that era."
Also used hostages in Star Trek III The Search for Spock. That's how Kirk's son died.
I usually just imagine they are from a different Klingon house with a different culture. Like different countries on earth
They were without honor, and thus not true Klingons in his eyes.
As Jazia Dax stated Klingons are as diverse a species / people as anyone else. There is a difference between a stereotype and the totality of a people as a whole
YES! I just finished "The Day Of The Doe" ST:TOS 3rd seasons, and Klingons commander says that Captain Kirk will be their prisoners.
That one Klingon saying he won't take away the animal until it's cooked isn't a mistake. That was the episode where Worf discovered the community of Klingons raised by Romulans. That one Klingon never interacting with another Klingon outside of that community obviously wouldn't know about how much Klingon's love to eat their food live or raw.
Kirk was using the comms to try and talk to Spock. Not a mistake.
Sound could also have traveled through his hands and suit, as well, although I don't know how audible it would be.
Even today, they have radios in space suits.
Notice Kirk's. Orbital diving suit from ST 7 ? .
The Borg had just assimilated a planet in Q Who which is where that infant may have come from, Rikers assertions shouldn't be taken as knowledge.
They were not yet assimilating people then only technology
@@NitpickingNerd Perhaps they decided to start with literally the easiest prototype of a person they could. A baby.
Riker was right though, the borg are born as organic creatures, of different species, they live some portion of their lives, then they're assimilated into the collective.
Unless they could drastically accelerate the growth process, it would be very inefficient to "raise" a Borg baby. When they assimilated planets they'd likely either ignore small children or just kill them all.
@@nodak81 wrong we already know from voyager that assimilated children are placed in maturation chambers.
Again I find nothing but nitpicking and ignorance of basic logic:
Rom was character Development/general underestimation of him.
Matresses are often integral to most bed designs. You only get a Bed Base underneat: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bed_base
So removing them anywhere but the Defiant was not possible. The defiant had that nice "solid slab" design.
Kahn: Nope, Starfleet Captains do not know 300 year old guys by their *face.* Heck, nobody even noticed that this one Historical Character looks a *lot* like Benjamin Sisko. Because he time travelled to become him.
And if you notice, even the Enterprise crew had do get a refresher on him.
I do know who Genghis Khan and Napoleon are, even if I could not *put a face to them.*
Heck give him a shave, and I would propably not notice Hitler. And I am a german, that is literaly history for me.
Chakotay: He might have re-considerd on the 7 years of journey. Or just choose to ignore that for a date with 7 of 9. And you *can* roast vegetables quite well. Roasted Potates would like to confirm that.
Safety routines: Belana was already Chief Engineer. This was a shuttle. And she was the only XO on that suttle.
Borg Reproduction: Yes, the vision of the Borg changed by "Best of both Worlds". And they stuck with that ever since. By 7of9 times they might have stopped doing that altogether.
Honor & Hostages: "With a few exceptions, no Klingon in that time had any honor." - Star Trek Online about TOS times.
Klingon Transformation: Why would he know about it? That is a part of 200 years of History with very low relevancy for every day work.
Euydian Thumbs: Maybe that guy had just lost his thumbs? Makeup details. Very nitpicky.
Symbiont and Transport: He was *injured.* Transports can be deadly for Injured people in a lot of cases. Heck, Bashir once moved a Fetus to save it for a long yourney and that is *less* disruptive then a transport.
Travel Planning: Most civilian ships do *not* make warp 9.8. And they might even have intentional speed limits, due to subspace damage caused by warp travel.
I mean he even mentions that it would take *only weeks* with the Enterprise.
Regrowth: Kidney != Every organ. Dyalisis != Kidney missing. Layperson != doctor.
A lot of organs may have unique ease of regrowth. The Liver is *very well* known for it's regenerative properties in todays time, for example. Regeneration might even be part of it's normal operating procedure. *IF* you still got 25% left, you can regrow a fulyl functional: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liver#Liver_regeneration
Sickbay Items: Do I need to explain the difference between a historical display and tools?
DNA: A few years between those. And there are *lot* of levels of analyzing DNA. DNA Services only decode like 0.02% of your DNA th-cam.com/video/uyRgk8Cqmzg/w-d-xo.html
That little should be possible with a Tricorder too.
Finding Data: They only picked up the general signature, still needing to find Before the hard way. Also this was a Trap by Nero.
And Data was *dead* at this very moment. They needed to find his grave.
Shields: The shields were focussed (and taxed to the limit) into holding the door open and the ship was like 100 yeras old. Technolog evolves.
Fire: They definitely said "Fire supression is not working", and you are just being a Idiot ignoring that part.
Jem Hadar wore armor. And Refire rate is *very* important in combat. And you only need to take out supports to collapse most buildings.
Speed of light: Well, romulus should not have been destroyed by a supernova without literal decades to prepare. Except it travelled in subspace most of the way. Apparently something in this way of blowing up suns works the same way?
The Child: Except the differentiation happens on Hormonal basis and this was a life energy entity.
Sound: There is this technology called "Radio". It does travel through space.
Self Sealing: A borg claw is inteded to cut stuff, *including* getting over self-sealing layers/abilities. A Romulan mines "I need to stick here" rods did not.
As far as the bed thing, their quarters were easily customizable. A Klingon wouldn't be stuck with a soft cushy bed if he didn't want one, especially if he claimed it was a cultural thing.
The video is nit picking you idiot, no one has ever denied that. It's just supposed to show some funny inconsistencies whether they be entirely accurate or not.
@@Fry09294 Insulting me. And insult my intelligency by claiming "it was just a joke"?
If you got nothing to say, please just keep silent.
u have wayyyyyyyy too much time on your hands & your comment was PRE-COVID i can imagine how you are at the supper table.....zzzzzzzzzzzzzz
@@orgonkothewildlyuntamed6301 Wow, the "you got no life" routine?
Could you find something modern please? Maybe ask a 5 year old. Asuming you get out that much.
Odo wasnt a collaborator
*Collaborates with the Cardassians*
Uh huh, Sure Kira
Well is he really collaborating if he stood there and did nothing? Still not good though.
Odo wasn't a Bajoran so couldn't be a collaborator ,he wasnt even a humanoid, the problems begin when he was employed as security when the station was handed over to the Federation/Bajor.
Odo was neutral his master was the law during those years, at least as best as he could apply it given the circumstance.
@@meris8486 Just following orders wasn't an argument at Nuremberg and it shouldn't be in Star Trek.
@@KaiserFranzJosefI
It's not the one I'm giving, Odo was a constable he worked to enforce the law as best he could despite the occupation
You could make a whole video of Odo collaborating while people say he wasn't a collaborator. The kira odo friendship might be the most unrealistic thing about the series. They met while he was interrogating her for the cardassians. She then tells him he is working for the cardassians. They never showed them becoming friends or odo even questioning what he is doing. They just magically are friends with kira defending him
A lot of these can be explained by simple arbitrary differences, simple misconceptions, semantics, or even bad context. For example; holideck safety protocols on the Enterprise-D are probably not the same as they are on the Voyager, i.e. the Enterprise requires 2 officers to deactivate safety protocals, Voyager only needs 1: Or Captain Terrel in Star Trek II probably did know Earth history, but he probably didn't think that Khan was Khan when he saw him most likely because he wouldn't have recognized Khan in his aged state, and the unlikelihood of them encountering Khan was very high so there was no reason to expect to find him.
Not everyone is a history expert especially of a few centuries
Right . If anyone were suddenly face to face with Napoleon, no one would recognize him.
The real mistake in that scene, was that Checkov was not yet on the Enterprise when Kirk found Kahn. So Kahn never should have recognized him.
@@nunya3163 It's likely Checkov was on the Enterprise. We just hadn't seen him. There was over 430 people on that ship. We saw only a couple dozen, total.
At 6:40 the display on the Sick Bay wall doesn't mean McCoy uses these instruments. It is a display of antique surgical instruments that are no longer used by 23rd Century Doctors.
But, the fact is that McCoy himself,as a Human doctor, would also be obsolete by that time. Computerized Robotic Doctors are already being developed. They have already performed surgery on people.
my thought was that was the mirror universe McCoy's medbay
I would agree with this, especially with the way they are hanging that's not a setup for every day use, but a display case. Though McCoy wouldn't be completely outdated. while computers and robotics would be playing a much greater role by that time then they are now. there are some fields that are not going to be fully automated and I think that is one of them.
Thank you, I was going to say that the display on McCoy's wall was clearly just that - a display.
Weird it didn't have a glass front to it, though.
For a sci-fi setting Star Trek is actually very backwards when it comes to robotics, with only a handful of exceptions. Apart from those exceptions we're actually more advanced than the entire Star Trek setting when it comes to that specific field.
Computer doctors are effective only for what they're programmed to do. Star Trek doctors are always thrust into unfamiliar situations.
They are actually developing transparent aluminum as I write this at NASA. It is called rylon
@Artur Terho thats a christal. similar to glass. only a lot harder, but at the same time more brittle
ALON, commonly referred to as transparent aluminium was patented in 1980 before the movie came out.
@Artur Terho Aluminium oxynitride. Really expensive but you can buy some.
"Worf, your adapted human parents raised you well, use knives and forks, not your hands, sleep on a matress, not a sheet of steel, and change clothes, not wear them constantly."
Sound won't travel through a vacuum, that is correct. However, the sound wasn't travelling through a vacuum, it was travelling through the suits which were touching each other.
Sound could travel through a radio or subspace communications system.
That Chakotay was a hologram. LoL.
Not the ine in the mess hall who ate meat with everyone
They often see replicated food as vegetarian because no animal died for it to be made.
@@sideshowkazstuff3867 I would too.
@@DanRaidersWarriorsSharksGiants yeah it's no different to veg-meat (except probably tastes closer to the real thing)
Also Voyager had problems with energy and resources. It would be retarded to continue to be vegetarian in survival conditions. You eat what you can!
Klingons ought to do mattress commercials XD
" Sorry, Captain Picard, but Klingons only sleep on the most firm , Comfortable slabs of the highest quality steel. Nothing more, and nothing less. Sweet dreams!!."
Some of these are really funny because they're obvious errors but some of them could have an explanation, such as 9:34 when Kirk and Spock are in their spacesuits and Kirk is calling Spock to try and wake him. I don't think they were implying Kirk's voice could magically be heard through the vacuum of space, as I would assume their spacesuits have a radio comm system built into them and that's what we were hearing when he was trying to wake Spock.
Replicated meat isn't real meat
Replicated anything isn't real anything.
@Connection Lost Yes, but no animal was killed for that.
@@darkchilde100 I can't believe it's not butter!
@Connection Lost
It's a bit like modern cell-cultured meat in that regard. It's identical physically, but no animal was killed in its production.
@Connection Lost Nope. It never taste like the original because they simplified the paterns for storage. A proper steack pattern could take 5 times more memory space in the ship's memory banks.
Suited Kirk calling to suited Spock would use the helmet communications link.
Or just touch visors.
@@ozchoz or just the vibrations going through the suits.
The JJVerse and STD was the biggest mistake.
When you realize to what Star Trek Discovery abbreviates , it should be a dead giveaway that it won't be any good.
Rick Berman disliked the shit out of this video
That was funny as, I love mistakes & plot holes they are hilarious
Worf eats with fork.and spoon,.Worf has cozy quarters. Worf sleeps on a mattress. No wonder the other Klingons make fun of Worf.
It is funny though that each time we do see Worf sleeping on a mattress it appears to give him nightmares.
Also we could assume that Riker was just assuming that the Borg reproduce naturally and install implants right away, those babies very well might have been captured along with their mothers. Voyager did later encounter a bunch of Borg kids as well.
7 was a Borg child at one point.
I love how this video doesnt tell you, it straight up shows you the proof lol
The Borg baby was not a mistake. It was an infant being assimilated from a recently captured world. Riker simply did not misunderstood what was going on.
The Klingon animal on the table....different planet. Different culture. They cook.
Meh, the vegetarian bit can be explaind as Neelix being a) a terrible chef (chakotay lied figuring it would be harder to burn a salad) and/or b) Neelix being a moron and getting Chakotoy's preferences wrong.
Funny how Star Trek has always been inconsistent with these sort of small things, even within the same series, and yet "true fans" lose their shit whenever anything from Enterprise onwards slightly contradicts an offhand remark from TOS.
Including Generations in a mistake video? That's kinda like shooting fish in a barrel isn't it? That whole movie was a mistake.
Why do people always hate on generations? It was a good movie.
Neelix "Commader Chakotay is a Vegetarian".... Commander Chakotay "How does Roasted Chicken sound" was you best edit and made me laugh
Of course sound doesn't travel through space. So it only makes sense that each space suit has a communications system. DUH!
Spocks suit didnt open a channel
Worf is a bad example for the beds because he was raised by humans
I had always been bothered with how they presented the Borg behaviors different constantly. 1st they are born humanoid then given Borg parts. They BUILT Capt. Picard into Locutus. Then they suddenly have assimilation tubes & nano tech...what?
Bonus Baby i think they assumed that the borg made babies, i guess those babies are assimelated ones that they had picked up from a planet or something...
You’re right, ST sucks, ruined forever!!! From now on it’s just Star Wars for me, because nothing is wrong with any of those movies, tv shows, novels or comics. It’s all perfect and will be so FOREVER. Not like that crappy Star Trek, they can’t get anything right.
@@russellharrell2747 did Star Wars kill your dog or something?
this got explained in Voyager by seven of nine can't remember which episode it is the one were they meet the children from the damaged Borg cube
Wanna meet a grouchy woman? Try a human woman, 8 months pregnant, who also happens to be Borg. Takes assimilation to a whole new level, lol!
I agree, its pronounced aluminium not aluminum XD
Much of the Mistakes presented in this video could have been due to lack of knowledge when the episode was written and filmed. The Trill Transporter issue could have been resolved between the time the TNG Trill Ambassador incident happened and Dax was introduced. As for some of the continuity errors, Chakotey being a vegetarian and then not could have been simply mistakes between writers not communicating with each other and incomplete character profiles. The Tricorder scanning DNA could have been a new design while the Enterprise Tricorders did not have that functionality yet. Many of the mistakes made between series especial TOS and TNG could largely be explained by outside knowledge of science being vastly different in the 20 years between the two series.
As for the disabling of the Safety protocols of the Holodeck, Torres was the chief Engineer and adept at finding work arounds to problems, should could have written a backdoor subroutine into the Holodeck programming that permitted her to disable the Safeties without a second senior officer.
Maybe Chakotay was vegetarian except for replicated meat since it isn't made of real animal flesh.
It's also well established on Star Trek that there are different levels of shields. Any starship will have a navigational shield to protect from space debris etc; they just don't protect from phaser/disruptor fire very well. It seems reasonable to assume that the Jenolan is holding the doors with its navigational shields, not its actual shields.
For that matter, it's nearly 100 years older than the Enterprise; it's entirely plausible its shields don't block more advanced transporters. O'Brien managed to beam over to the Phoenix, a much newer ship than the Jenolan, when its shields were raised simply by knowing exactly when to time it between shield cycles.
Also Federation ships likely have ways of beaming from one ship to another without dropping shields by matching shield frequencies.
Totally agreed with David, it also explains the torpedoes being able to penetrate the shields. It's just like what happened in Generations when the klingons got the Enterprise's shield frequency looking through Geordi's visor, and matched their torpedoes.
Starfleet ships have structural integrity fields too.
I loved how the old woman just shoved the medicine in her mouth like it was candy,
"Sound doesn't travel through the vacuum of space."
That's true. It _does,_ however, travel through their _suits._ That's what we're _hearing,_ here.
@Valami Izé no it's not. they would have a communication system built into the suit so they'd still be able to hear each other, not because the sound is traveling though the vacuum. but because it's getting picked up by the mic inside one suit, which transmits a radio signal to the other one, then that one sends the signal it got to the speaker on the inside. and vice versa when the other talks. the suit can take damage, and this still work as long as the audio and transceiver bits aren't hit to badly. and since we don't know where on the suit they are, it's possible they didn't get hit.
@SLOWPOKE RODRIGUEZ the suits are going to be pressurized so that the people inside the suit can breathe. that means there is a medium inside the suit. and that's all you need. because the sound doesn't have to travel between the suits. it just has to travel inside the suit. as they could have the same tech in their comm badges built into the suit, so that the suits are sending signals between each other. This is how all the real Astronauts have done it, sure the real one's have all used headsets. but I honestly don't see why we couldn't use a speakerphone type design if we wanted. and there for not even need to have any visible audio equipment. but still be using such to communicate.
9:27 excuse me, it's been a while since I watched TNG, but wasn't she only half betazoid?
the problem with that dialogue is that if the child only had her DNA then it would a female (basically a clone of her) , it's impossible to be a male otherwise , unless she's genetically a male or that Betazoid male and female seperation is not genetic
@@MajorGrin good point, Major.
Perhaps the entity that became her son was well aware of this fact and choose to be a boy for that reason. Or betazoids are like lizards... They can change gender.
@@alexandriamaguire8224 That's actually a completely valid point, seeing as in one episode where a virus or something is causing the Enterprise crew to devolve, Diana is show soaking in a tub as something amphibian/reptilian :)
3:01 she said rack! 😜
I believe Deanna's last name is "Troi". I'm probably wrong. Good job on your channel.
They likely didn't use wide field shots during the Siege of AR-558 on DS9 because they use a bunch more power and the Starfleet team there was extremely under supplied.
Sisko's crew had just arrived. they should have brought a box full of fully charged hand phasers with them
The only one I can defend here is Kirk calling out to Spock from one space suit to the other. There would have been communication devices in the suits to enable communication with each other.
They're touching helmets I think, which also works
9:30 they are talking through communicators built into the suit, they aren't talking through space
I always questioned how they were able to beam Scotty and Geordie through the shields in the Dyson sphere. I assumed they looked up the Genolin's shield frequency?
Maybe the ship was only using forward shields?
They would've given over the shield frequency. Allowing them to transport.
maybe because it was an old ship and the shields were also very weak and about to collapse
2:55 that's not actually Chakotay, that's a hologram
I think replicated meat might be seen as different to non replicator meat. It’s never been alive.
The TOS Klingons' look was a result from experimentation on transgenic human DNA from the Eugenic war. This had to be classified on hight level. It's normal than Bashir did'nt know about it.
I really hated the entire attempt to explain the TOS klingons and it was totally unnecessary. It also would have been more amusing if when they arrived in the past Michael Dorn was suddenly in the TOS Klingon makeup and nobody noticed the difference.
Jeff Umbach That would have been amazing! I think it would be too comedic to fit overall but damn I would have loved it
Klingons exaggerate.
Plant stem cells + James Webb rendezvous with new formulas (all thorny thicket formulas captured) + rainbow syfy + biodiversity + Cuzz Coll
Have u ever tought i of murdering alex kurtzman and replace as the head of the writing team on the newer star trek? you would do well with the canon lore ..lol
The surgical instruments mounted in Sick Bay were items from Dr.McCoy collection. He never used them in actual medical practice.
Actually quite a few of these can be reasoned away due to circumstance. For example Worf using quilts and bed linins when Klingons don't use any bed comforts. Worf has grown up with most of his life being spent within the federation, being exposed the their culture. And for Odo when he mentions that Rom isn't very clever, nobody on deep space 9 (except for Rom's son) really knew at that point that Rom was actually talented in the field of engineering since he was firmly under Quarks grasp at the bar. It wasn't until later that he was recognized as a competent engineer by Cheif 0'brian and the rest of the station. Some of the Starfleet rules present in TNG could easily have been changed by the time of Deep space 9 as well as some technological advanced too such as the blood DNA analysis. Some other things can simply be explained as "Good film making" since waiting several minutes for the suns explosion to register would've been a burden on the viewer even if they used a cut or explained it away with more fighting filler. Otherwise there are a few inconsistencies here and there. Mainly with the cannon of the old show and the Borg between TNG and Voyager. Fortunately it seems a good deal of this comment section agrees on this. Paying closer attention is usually the key here. Its not being nerdy its just called good observation haha.
Eurydians DONT have opposable thumbs, those were just one of the heavy demands rhat Riker patiently accommodated
I have no idea why it feels normal to see McCoy in 20th Century hospital scrubs. A lot of these mistakes aren't that deep. Sometimes the script has to forget something as simple as the shields still being up when the Enterprise D was escaping the Dyson Sphere. Some of them can be escused while some aren't. 🙄
Some i can forgive. Odo underestimates
Ron like everyone does.
The Chakotay hologram is just that a hologram, so there is room for error.
The Borg maturation chamber, the Enterprise crew don't know about the Borg at this point
In "Birthright" Worf tells the story of Kahless losing his sword to the sea, however in DS9 the sword was stolen from the Klingon homeworld.
They forgot about that one episode from Star Trek Enterprise where an augmented human couple were sleeping in a bed made outta animal fur... Onboard a stolen Klingon raptor ship.
Yeah...the "We found a positronic signal we havent even calibrated for, from a direction the long range scanners werent even looking in" just to start the plot was stupid..
When people are healing I think they do hundreds of practice runs blaming themselves for things and often for things I didn’t even do but they’re just trying to understand where they went wrong in their own lives, not that I can speak for them. But I do love this video
sound does travel in space. space contains gases that come from different space bodies dirt etc.. all kinds of little things that vibrate. it just the frequency would be so low it would be impossible to hear with our present tech
Some of these are due to habits or sentimentality, but things like the phasers and tricorders are certainly a problem. Physics has always been a problem with Star Trek, and so has changing cultural norms. Star Fleet has always been at war with itself, either trying to be apolitical or spectra-political, martial or peace-loving. Things change all the time which is why so much of it is explained away by time period, personality and habits, and cultural norms.
I'm started wonder how's most of these are even mistake some are taken out of context or can be explained away by ignoring a number of things... this isn't like new trek either that has very clear continuity errors... If anyone else wants to explain each one I would like to give them a chance to do so because I feel like I can explain nearly all of these except spock thinking klingons don't have tear ducks maybe he was joking spock is half human it's possible but maybe that is the only one I don't have problems with suspecting as for the lack of history knowing history that one could be somewhat excusable but could also be just an over sigh the rest aren't really errors at all.
The word bedding situation isn't a mistake. He has adapted to living amongst humans, which includes soft bedding.
The TNG phasers aren't more powerful than the phase rifles in DS9, they just don't have them set to maximum power and spread like Riker did as they would deplete their power cells in a few shots and they're trying to hold off a whole army.
Some of these are good catches other can be explained away. All human fetuses start out as female changes have to be made I'm not a doctor but I believe something needs to be withheld before the male gender develops. also there are many species in the animal kingdom but can start off female and change to male or start off as male and change the female. As far as the surgical tools on Doctor McCoy's wall they were antique he was being nostalgic and a collector of these not using them for surgery. do you have so many things on here I never even thought about thanks for bringing that up I appreciate that now I'm curious seeing as how they had all these scientific minds behind the next generation when it was being created looks they goofed it up.
Some of these are understandable, but honestly a character's vital info should include things like dietary habits.
They had to up the Science and the Ingenuity of all the equipment as the Trek fanbase got better at pointing out the Bullshit ;D
So,e of these so called mistakes can be debunked due to fact events take place further in future and technology has advanced to do it such as scanning for androids and DNA scanning
A lot of these aren't mistakes, they just you not understanding the character development or that we don't have hours to watch them traverse space when the show was only 45 minutes.
Disliked for putting the same clip in multiple times to stretch the video to just over 10 minutes so you can put in extra ads.
According to stardates Chekov was on board the Enterprise when Khan was.
this ruined my life i thought star trek was real. God forbid they make some minor mistakes over the 651 hrs of footage
What they don't live in a constant universe that was most likely written on the spot for most episodes and only used what was useful for the plot? Better throw it all out.
Just one species without opposable thumbs. That's all we are asking.
Kinda weird they dont accept that Odo is a collaborator, by any modern standards he most certainly was.
at least the ST shows were enjoyable unlike Prometheus which was pathetically illogical
Producer of course knows the speed of light. This scene is intentionally made.
Do you want to wait several minutes in front of the screen?
製作者は、とうぜん光速は知っています。このシーンは、あえてこう作られてるんでしょ。
スクリーンの前で何分も待っていたいですか？
If you know the frequency of a ships shields you can transport through them and fire upon them
It's called progress.
progressing to worse space-suits
About detecting drones from light years away, while having problems with recovering data of pre-warp civilizations without breaking the prime directive, no, most androids emit subspace signals, and all of them emit radio and electronic signatures, wi-fi, whatever, that travel the speed of light and are detectable by sensors, they're not as good when listening to conversations, and even if they were, you need a closer look to know what your seeing, locate and replicate copies of their books and art, to know why what your seeing is what your seeing and why is it there, you can't do that with droid seeking sensory, specially when the civilization is pre-radio, TV or whatever.
The opposable thumbs was great tho, I didn't realize that one and it's kinda obvious lol.
the problem is they were never able to find Data so easily in the series
Well you could argue that Data was "offline", inactive, deactivated in that episode. B4 on the other hand was more or less active. Remember the hand was moving and the head was completely "awake".
Wasn't all the food Chakotay ate replicated? So, he's still technically a vegetarian.
Ppl used her pattern so much……🌾🎓🍧🍏🍇📈💹😅🤗☕️👽🐰
Does replicated meat still count if you're a vegetarian?
McCoy saving the Grandma gives me life too.
4:09 It was a sensitive matter... we don't talk about it with outsiders.
Many of these aren't mistskes, but character growth.
Not many mistakes shown other then the crying klingons
Too many writers and they may not watch star trek was we fans do. So they make mistakes
alot of this is taken out of context, yes there are mistakes thru and thru but most of theses are not
3:02 Damn!
Transparent aluminum exists today.
It has been proven that women craft some make genes.
The Klingon beliefs has changed over the "countries" before the warrior class they were more peaceful so it's possible for many to carry different ideas including what to sleep on
Real ine is ceramic not metal. Not same thingl
Your not the hero we deserve but the hero we need!
We have transparint aluminum now.