Use of AI Images here and my feelings on the comments: 1) I feel very bad about artists losing work because of AI and this is not an issue I hear often in Japan. TH-cam is an amazing platform where I get to interact with my audience (you) and if there is an aspect like the images you didn't like, I am very grateful for the feedback! My goal is to make each episode enjoyable so you learn something incredible about Japan. 2) I did not rely on AI images to make this episode. It accounts for about 1% of the video which is 33 min long. Each image was just a canvas and required much more work in Photoshop because AI is far from perfect, as you can see. I get some don't like it - and thank you for letting me know why - but also if you are an artist upset, respect the work I took a year to make about an inspirational man and story I researched for a long time, traveled to these locations - for you and the story - to see first hand. I would very much appreciate comments on the story as well. 3) I DO NOT intend to use AI images often in my work. It is not a crutch to make content for me. I LOVE to leave my house and explore. No one has gone the distance to make a historical video like this on Manjiro! It was expensive, it took time, but I was obsessed to do it. I hope you feel that enthusiasm in the work. My test audience that saw the AI images liked it and I didn't get any negative feedback so my test group was not large enough and I'll fix that in the future. 4) It is my job to listen to you. I rely on my audience to watch it. I'm doing my best to do that and learn from everyone. I don't know anyone successful who doesn't listen well to their audience and you're important to me to be a better creator. Much love, John ^_^
The reaction to AI generated art is some luddite-level ridiculousnes. Scribes shrieking at the invention of printing press. I have an enormous stake at this and even I don't freak out the way these guys do. Both my art and profession is being directly threatened by AI. It's simply a asinine, knee-jerk reaction by people who put their own short term interest over progression of humanity. World's changing, hundreds of occupations went obsolete in the past. Do you see any astrolabe makers around? That's a gorgeous contraption. Oh no, none makes a good astrolabe anymore. lol. Being human is to adapt and overcome. Screaming at the coming tsunami will only make fools out of you to be mentioned in passing in history books of future. If you are really talented, you can also find ways to create value even facing a formidible competitor such as AI. But I wonder 95 percent of any of these people even put any thought into this ludicurous outrage. It is just the latest bandvagon they hopped on.
@@meticulouslyeliminatinghaters I have a theory. There are two kinds of people. Person 1: "Hey look at this funny video of this crazy thing that just happened!!" Person 2: "It's a funny situation but it is staged and trying to be passed off as a real event. It's fake." Person 1: "Well it's still funny to me!" Person 2: "I don't find things that are staged trying to be passed off as real as funny" These are the exact same two types of people in the AI argument. Yes AI can assist in the creation process, reducing the amount of work for a creator and some people can appreciate it. And others would rather experience something more real and less artificial, and wince at AI artwork because of the inevitability of it being passed off as real and authentic content. Unfortunately I am not one of those people who find staged "really just happened!!!" videos funny. You do you. You are allowed to like it, others are allowed to dislike it.
@@mattcy6591That's a false dichotomy also a false analogy. 1. You can enjoy blatantly staged things e.g. Movies, theatre etc. 2. If none believes the "authenticity" of art, origin does not matter anymore. Which will inevitably happen. No amount of complaining can stop this. 3. Staged funny videos may fail in your example only if the fun factor solely depends on prerequisite of authenticity. Authenticity of a claimed candid happenstance does not translate well into aesthetic/visual art, music, fiction...
@@meticulouslyeliminatinghaters you are not catching what I said. People can like things and others can dislike things. All I am saying is the people on both sides of the AI imagery fall into similar stances as people that enjoy and dislike staged "reality videos". Some find it enjoyable, others find it deceitful. In my example I am specifically using an example of funny videos that try to be passed off as real actual events when they are fake or staged. Whether it be someone staging something for clicks or to deceive or a viral marketing agency made video of this "omg real thing that just happened." Or Reality TV shows where every line and situation is scripted, but fakes being naturally occurring candid moments. Again, if you like those, fine. If you don't like those, fine. I am just making a comparison. I am not telling you that you need to not like those. Movies, comedies, etc are not trying to pass themselves off as being real actual things that happened and a camera just happened to be recording. Even Punk'd type shows while staged, present a funny situation to an unwitting individual. In the end they are not pretending to the viewer that these things actually happened naturally to these people. There is tongue in cheek. Some people are vehemently turned off by this content. Others enjoy it, and still enjoy it after finding out about the inauthenticity.
@@mattcy6591I understood it perfectly, I am just saying that's a non-argument due to two reasons. Reason 1. Your example does not apply to the conversation around AI art. There are hundreds of ways of funny, beautiful, aesthetically pleasing, awe inducing,inspiring... all the ways an artwork can be. Your example is not even art if it's not staged. It's just happenstance. It's real life documented just happens to be funny. It is not an analogy that makes sense in the context artwork which byitself comes with an implication of cognizant intervention. Reason 2. Whether or not anyone enjoys/accepts this happening is not important. It will happen regardless and when it does there will be no way to be sure of authenticity anymore. Once that happens everything might as well be AI generated. You will see 100 percent human made art and will think they were AI. At that point if the two origins produce exactly the same art down to minute detail by the strike of a crazy probabilty scenario without knowing you'll enjoy/dislike them to the same degree. So there is no point for arbitrary restrictions for art. Again, your example is not even art. It's real life documented. It doesn't even have to be funny. Any sort of false claim of documented real life is deception. What you don't enjoy is not AI generated art. You just dislike deception. If a human tries to push a AI generated image as their own art, it does not detract from the quality of the artwork, if you would have enjoyed it otherwise. It is the deception of claimant you dislike. Since the art in question is not real life documented the artwork itself is divorced from deception because it just is as it is. As it would be if it was made by a human artist.
You can watch the TV series "Shōgun". The story is similar to that of Manjiro but in the TV show it is an English sailor who ends up shipwrecked in Japan. The story is partially based on real historical figures. There is also the movie "the last Samurai". The story about the historical figure "Yasuke" is also interesting.
My Japanese school used the Minna No Nihongo textbook. In it, there was a short story about Manjiro. When I read it, I was blown away. Even with current technology, I sometimes find it difficult to travel in Japan. There are so many differences in not just the language but the culture. And if I get lonely, I can always do a video call with friends and family back in America. I can't imagine what it'd be like to go from having zero knowledge about a foreign country, to wind up living there and being the only person of your nationality. It must've been ROUGH. Shout out to Captain William Whitfield for taking Manjiro under his wing. And of course, thanks to Manjiro for helping bridge Japan to the U.S.
Woahh there was a little movie going through my head while I watched this... that's a documentary. I can only imagine how much work it was to visit all these places, collect info and put them together in such a cohesive story. Hope this video gets at least 1mi views. Thanks John!!!
The story of Nakahama "John" Manjiro is absolutely amazing, and you've made an incredible documentary about it. From Kochi, to Hawaii, Fairhaven and Okinawa, your dedication to crafting a thorough and compelling video is truly inspiring. Thank you for sharing this story.
Hustling gold to get the homies back home and then visiting your own grave stone: so badass. John, I would have never had heard this story during late History Channel even though this would have been right up their alley of unconventional and larger than life. You did it again. Amazing work.
History Channel should cover this! When I heard about this story, I said WHY HAVEN’T I HEARD OF THIS BEFORE? It’s because he doesn’t get the same amount of respect as other samurai like Sakamoto Ryoma. Maybe because he was a peasant? But the Manjiro story is coming back and going to burst into US TV sometime! I hope this video inspires more interest in Manjiro and I’ll be happy 😊 because Manjiro deserves it.
This is absolutely amazing! I really want to go visit the museum now! A guy with no family last name makes it to the US and changes history for Japan and the world! Thank you John M for your achievement and to John D for putting his fantastic story together for all of us who want to learn more about Japanese history!
As I watched this, I was thinking about your live streams from each of the locations, and how much time you must have put into telling this amazing story! It was time well spent. Great work, John!
@@onlyinjapan John you are the one with many talents,. I think you could write a script. And it would be a delight to see the Movie or Netflix series.
I was waiting for this episode ever since I saw the livestream at Fairhaven. Really liked it and appreciate the hard work that went behind this. I find the love-hate stories between Japan and USA so fascinating and I am not even from one of these two countries originally. Edit- I gifted my 8 year old nephew a book on Manjiro on his last birthday called "Heart of a Samurai". He's 2nd gen American and loves Japan already. He'll be coming here in japan in a few months!
Wow John, you've outdone yourself with this full on production! I was completely engrossed in your documentary and want to learn more about Manjiro now. Awesome work.
This makes me so happy! I became a fan of Manjiro’s after hearing a basic story of his, and when I dug deeper, it’s absolutely incredible! His love for coffee and sweets, I can relate to him in so many ways 😂
John Manjiro's story is quite amazing and you did a great job of bringing us his story and adventures. Appreciate all the hard work you've put into this one and it shows! Well done! 👏👍
Excellent! What an amazing story. I’ve watched 4 times already. John your talent with storytelling and editing is incredible. Love your work. You seem to outdo yourself every time. Thanks for sharing this wonderful story and your talent.
Wow John, I can't even begin to describe how much I enjoyed this episode, let alone comprehending how much research work, arranging and putting together what's important surrounding Manjiro life to eventually producing such a compelling, heartwarming and meaningful story. It really showed the extent of Manjiro's life contributing to sowing a deep connection between the two countries which is really cool as someone who loves Japanese history. This is really so well produced, thank you for creating and sharing it with the world so that such valuable story continues to live through generations to come 🙏🏻😊
Thank you so much and I really appreciate you watching this particular episode on the most inspiration story I’ve heard in Japan! So glad you had an amazing trip here!
Wow, I think this is the best documentary you've made to date. The pace is not too fast for me to understand these detailed concepts of the biography. I also like how you merged the Google earth angle with your drone shot! Or when you noticed in one interview that an important conversation was happening and that camera in your hands started recording so fast. Ha ha The use of AI art was a surprise, but a happy surprise. The best utilization of it I've seen. Some of the reason for the ai criticisms maybe because it's a new ingredient to your formula of design. Amazing look into the legend. Have a great day sir!
I spent extra time with the timing of the scenes so this makes me happy to hear. I think these tools we get like AI and google maps are just tools we can use like spice for the footage we do take. B-roll we say, spice for the main course. It is certainly going to grow, but how we use it will be very important. I read the comments today and know many don't like the AI stuff even though I had to add a lot of myself into what you see. It was all AI generated. This episode took ages to make. But over time, it won't be an issue at all, just now, people are not used to it nor should they be. Too many abuse it. It is far from perfect but the (nearly all of the) tools of tomorrow will be better than today. I don't intend to use much AI stuff but for history like this, how else does one tell a story that would require so much money to hire actors, sets. In a year, these comments (and perhaps this video) will look dated but the video's story is timeless! Thank you so much for the feedback.
Ahhh, finally another John Daub brilliant history content. I miss this style of yours John. This one is priceless. Well researched and studied which is typical of your old blogs. THANK YOU!!...more of this please.😊
Hi John, this has got to be your finest professional work ever. As soon as it started, I was hooked. Living in the UK, I have never heard of this great Japanese person, Manjiro. Thank you for another outstanding documentary.
Thank you for this, I've been getting hounded for using ai tools so that has been distracting more than I thought it would be for the audience. The audience isn't wrong, they watch with feeling and I appreciate the feedback, but your comment makes me very happy because you caught the story which is the point and absolutely incredible!
Well done, John! Thanks for putting in all of the work to bring this story to life for us. I've been a subscriber of yours for several years, and this is one of your best projects to date!
How he is not more widely known is mind blowing. Guy deserves his own movie. I first learned about him in 2007, went to his old town where they have a marker where his house used to be at Ashizuri Misaki (Point). They said it burnt down but I see you went to an actual house. Also visited his other "hometown" in Fairhaven, MA and met Gerry in 2011. Well done! You should be very proud of this documentary. You hit on so many great details of his interesting and adventurous life!
I loved this! Very well made, like a tv show from a series! and my husband, being Japanese, knew the story very well! Thanks for sharing such a remarkable story that shaped Japanese history! It inspires me to be more open minded to learn more .I did not know this story at all. Wow, how his mom would have grieved over him, but somehow could feel he was still alive! He had such an inquisitive desire to learn! He is an inspiration for all of us who have lived many places on thus globe! I did laugh, never realised Shikoku looked like a mini Australia! 😂 Got the pleasure of living in Perth, Australia for 9 years! Thanks for all the work you put into sharing these types of videos!
This is easily your best produce video ever! Something on par with some of the best documentaries I've seen. Wonderful work, John! This deserves way more views!
Absolutely fascinating. Have learned a lot from watching this. Although this story is nearly 200 years old, we can take a lot from what happened back then. Thank you John for your extensive research on this project. Take care and thanks again, from Australia
John this must have been a cool learning experience for you, you did John’s story justice. I’d never heard of this story, and enjoyed every minute of John’s story. Just the thought of being executed for coming home was so brave. Thank you for doing an awesome job telling us this story.
I wonder what was in his mind when he sailed into Ryukyu. He'd been there before, had a good feeling so risk was low - but man, he must have been worried when they arrested him. I heard he was treated very well in Kagoshima. They knew his value, but the also followed the rules. There's a lot I left for others to learn themselves - can't say it all but enough to get people interested. SO many footnotes of interest through an amazing time in history.
@@onlyinjapan I wondered the same thing about John going home to Japan. He must’ve been a very confident, young man. Johns education in the USA must have led to his confidence, that just maybe he’d have the chance to win over the leaders and not be executed, he had big kahunas lol. John had such a wonderful story and his zest for life. I’m sure it was a huge gamble on his part to go home,to regain the faith of the leaders of that time in history really is amazing to me. Thank you again for bringing us Johns story, he was an amazing man we can learn from still. I love all your videos, they’ve been a huge education for me.
I have been watching your videos for many years, i have always liked the videos and been subscribed to this and other channels off yours, but i have never left and comment, as i became a bit jaded over the years from the comment section on TH-cam and other platforms. But i felt i had to say that this one was one off the best videos that i have seen from you, John and the passion for this story really shows. Thank you for doing what you do and i promise i'l come here more often.
I’m very grateful you took the time to write me about this episode in particular and the encouragement and feedback from so many has been uplifting. TH-cam is still a social media and the comments certainly become an important part of the story. My friends in Kochi are also reading and surprised that so many didn’t know about Manjiro and pleased his story is so inspirational as it was to me when I stumbled upon this museum and wondered, why hadn’t I heard of this before? So I made it my mission to make sure as many could learn about it and it’s that emotion I had that I hope translates through the work. Thank you for commenting. It really made me happy to read it.
John, I think this is one of your finest productions. Fascinating, rare story very few would have known about without this.... It is obvious you spent a lot of time, effort and love in bringing this story to us. Thanks very much.
This is a criminally underrated video. I'm amazed by the way you presented this in depth research through your style of story telling. Genuinely a masterpiece!
It’s such a hard episode to title correctly, how to do it so people believe there’s value in it. That is perhaps harder to do right than producing this video across so many lands and seas 😂 it’ll grow, when they make it a movie!
Thank you for telling this remarkable story John, I really enjoy Japanese history and this time period is so interesting. I know you're not into anime, but "Rurouni Kenshin" takes place around this turbulent time and the aftermath, so was happy to learn more about this period and Manjiro. Got to say that the shot at 19:16 was just beautiful 😊.
John, wonderful presentation of the story of Manjiro, worthy of praise. I plan to share this unique journey whenever possible, mahalo ! I look forward to viewing such quality of work in the future !
Thank you, John for this amazing story of John Manjiro! I would have never heard of it otherwise…great job with all your work that you put into it! It’s so amazing that the families still keep in touch and honor John Manjiro and Captain Whitfield.
What an incredible story of a man I have never really known about til now. You did a great job telling his story and going to all theses locations to show it. You can see all the effort you put in to this in the production. I hope more people will find this video.
Such amazing episode John, heck, John Mung and John Daub! You certainly bridge the gap for all international TH-cam viewer on your channel and shows the side/history of Japan we don't know or known. Definitely a great episode you have put together over a year and definitely have seen some of your other video (snippet) and location where you went as a "sneak peek" before this video is out. Kudos to you, John and John. :) Mata-ne! :)
GREAT video. Thank you for this. What an amazing story. This video was done so well and in-depth. Thank you again. By the way, the shot of the Ryugu Shrine is mind-blowing.
It’s one of my top 5 “secret” spots, a few KM from Manjiro’s birth house. So amazing - you come out of the jungle and WOW! I did a live stream here 8 months ago in Aug 2023. th-cam.com/users/liveziWDfmbiCYY?si=fchJQmFBTZEV75Pp
Hello John. My name is Mana Tanaka, and I'm a member of the Tosashimizu Group who met John at Fairhaven. I attended the festival with my family, and we held an event to shave bonito. I was also in the karaoke scene with Jerry. I was moved by such a wonderful video and the depth of John's knowledge. I will share it with everyone, and have subscribed to your channel! We have been working on various things related to John Manjiro, so this video made us very happy. Thank you very much. We wholeheartedly support John's future activities.
Yes! This was an amazing story, so well done John! I'm amazed that there hasn't been a movie done of this extraordinary man and his accomplishments. This video even kept my partners undivided attention away from his cell phone! LOL! No mean feat indeed! Keep up the great work John.
This is great. I would actually love to see a longer cut. I know you did so much on location having seen your live streams here there and everywhere! Your interview subjects were clearly enthusiastic & knowledgeable. The Ryugu Shrine scene was a spectacular shot yet made contemplative with the added sound of the waves. Impressively put together.
Gosh, if I had one more month! I’d go to Nagasaki, Ogasawara, dig deeper in Tokyo! More on his family but he had a stroke shortly after seeing the Captain again in 1870. That ended his career mostly for diplomacy and I didn’t talk much about it because people will discover it, there’s more to the story for sure!
John, amazing story telling and an amazing episode I feel bad it’s taken me a little bit to sit down and watch it. Thank you for telling this story I’m not sure I would’ve ever heard it otherwise
John such an excellent job, well done! I really enjoyed your video and learned a lot. I appreciate your efforts to share and educate us. Please create more like these. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Well done John. All your traveling and research really paid off. I've never heard of "John Mung" so his story was really an eye-opener and inspiring. He must have been a really nice person because he was trusted by the Shogun. In many ways, you too are an ambassador, especially in showing us about Japan and Japan about the USA. Thank You. We'd love to see more of the stories inside Japan.
Just wanted to say really great video!!!! So much time, effort, and money to shoot on location in at least 7 places far from each other: Fairhaven, Honolulu harbor, Okinawa, Nakanohama, Kochi Castle, Shimoda and Zoshigaya cemetery. INSANE!!!!!!!!!! But truly the best way to help us feel invested in the story is to go on site and share these places with us. YOU SERIOUSLY ROCK!!!!!
Incredible video! I'm playing "Manjiro" in a production of Pacific Overtures soon and this was everything that I needed. Thank you for taking the time to make such a comprehensive video that was equally informative and entertaining!
Oh wonderful! I will do the one of these years, have to go all in, 3 months and really slow life down, remember what's important. Good luck! Def stop in and see the John Mung museum!
Congratulations on an epic episode! The research you did is impressive and I can see why it took you a year to put this together. Your attention to detail is wonderful, and I learned so much. This piece should be shown in all the schools in Japan!
Amazing video John. Its a damn shame that this video doesnt have more views. Very welll made video and it must have taken alot of work. Thanks for making this!
Wow, this was such a good video. The way it was laid out and played made me feel like I was watching a Veritasium video. Obviously this is original content all on its own but the voiceover with the animation styles plus all of the information given just comes together to make a very good finished product that is reminiscent of what id expect from the Veritasium producer. I'm a little late to the party but that's because I like to try to save your stuff for when I can't wait to see something new anymore lol. Keep up the awesome work like you always do!!!
Thank you so much John for such a valuable national treasure history. This could've been a great movie with all aspects of life, the wonderful ones without the war and killings. What's an inspirational.
Awesome awesome story. I love the history that tie America and the USA. From Hawaii there is also a deep connection to Japan. My great grandparents are from Japan. So John Manjiro story coincides with Japanese moving to Hawaii. Thank you for the great stories. Mahalo and Aloha. Keep up the great work.
This Manjiro story touched on so much history, doesn’t it!? Amazing how important Hawaii was at this time! It grew leaps and bounds. I’d love to have seen a natural Waikiki Beach without hotels and Diamond Head in the distance 🤩 we lived through Manjiro for 30 minutes, me for a year, and it was pretty awesome! Mahalo!! ^_^
That was an amazing story. Thanks for the year-long effort and for telling the story so well. I had zero knowledge of any of this and so it was quite the journey you took me on.
What an increible story and told well enough to be the next Netflix documentary. More people should give this their time. Thanks John, thoroughly enjoyed it.
It’s a tough topic to title and “sell” to viewers with a click and watch. But those who watch leave with the same impression of Manjiro as I had when I learned this story - wow! 🤩
Well done. Thank you for bringing attention to this excellent story. And I agree with the other commenters that this should be a miniseries, but you did a wonderful job making it real.
When I was living in Boston I tried riding my bike to Manjiro friendship house but failed haha. It's amazing that you actually went to some of those places where Manjiro set foot--it's impressive even with modern day transportation
Such history could easily have inspired a fantasy story like One Piece. What an adventure, filled with comradery and hope to reunite with his blood family and later with his mentor so to speak. Some times real history surpass fiction. Great short doc!
Loved this informational video so much ❤️❤️. Thank you so much John for sharing another great story with us through your videos. Wishing you well wishes to you and your family John ❤🙏
Such amazing history presented by a wonderfully talented storyteller! The background music seemed to add something special to the video; really well done.
Love this episode, I love learning about the history of Japan and America. Being American myself, but growing up in Japan. But back living in Florida It’s beautiful to see the families still connected. I’m it makes me want to go up to New Haven for the festival. ❤️ 🇯🇵
Use of AI Images here and my feelings on the comments: 1) I feel very bad about artists losing work because of AI and this is not an issue I hear often in Japan. TH-cam is an amazing platform where I get to interact with my audience (you) and if there is an aspect like the images you didn't like, I am very grateful for the feedback! My goal is to make each episode enjoyable so you learn something incredible about Japan. 2) I did not rely on AI images to make this episode. It accounts for about 1% of the video which is 33 min long. Each image was just a canvas and required much more work in Photoshop because AI is far from perfect, as you can see. I get some don't like it - and thank you for letting me know why - but also if you are an artist upset, respect the work I took a year to make about an inspirational man and story I researched for a long time, traveled to these locations - for you and the story - to see first hand. I would very much appreciate comments on the story as well. 3) I DO NOT intend to use AI images often in my work. It is not a crutch to make content for me. I LOVE to leave my house and explore. No one has gone the distance to make a historical video like this on Manjiro! It was expensive, it took time, but I was obsessed to do it. I hope you feel that enthusiasm in the work. My test audience that saw the AI images liked it and I didn't get any negative feedback so my test group was not large enough and I'll fix that in the future. 4) It is my job to listen to you. I rely on my audience to watch it. I'm doing my best to do that and learn from everyone. I don't know anyone successful who doesn't listen well to their audience and you're important to me to be a better creator. Much love, John ^_^
The reaction to AI generated art is some luddite-level ridiculousnes. Scribes shrieking at the invention of printing press. I have an enormous stake at this and even I don't freak out the way these guys do. Both my art and profession is being directly threatened by AI. It's simply a asinine, knee-jerk reaction by people who put their own short term interest over progression of humanity. World's changing, hundreds of occupations went obsolete in the past. Do you see any astrolabe makers around? That's a gorgeous contraption. Oh no, none makes a good astrolabe anymore. lol. Being human is to adapt and overcome. Screaming at the coming tsunami will only make fools out of you to be mentioned in passing in history books of future. If you are really talented, you can also find ways to create value even facing a formidible competitor such as AI. But I wonder 95 percent of any of these people even put any thought into this ludicurous outrage. It is just the latest bandvagon they hopped on.
@@meticulouslyeliminatinghaters I have a theory. There are two kinds of people.
Person 1: "Hey look at this funny video of this crazy thing that just happened!!"
Person 2: "It's a funny situation but it is staged and trying to be passed off as a real event. It's fake."
Person 1: "Well it's still funny to me!"
Person 2: "I don't find things that are staged trying to be passed off as real as funny"
These are the exact same two types of people in the AI argument. Yes AI can assist in the creation process, reducing the amount of work for a creator and some people can appreciate it. And others would rather experience something more real and less artificial, and wince at AI artwork because of the inevitability of it being passed off as real and authentic content.
Unfortunately I am not one of those people who find staged "really just happened!!!" videos funny. You do you. You are allowed to like it, others are allowed to dislike it.
@@mattcy6591That's a false dichotomy also a false analogy.
1. You can enjoy blatantly staged things e.g. Movies, theatre etc.
2. If none believes the "authenticity" of art, origin does not matter anymore. Which will inevitably happen. No amount of complaining can stop this.
3. Staged funny videos may fail in your example only if the fun factor solely depends on prerequisite of authenticity. Authenticity of a claimed candid happenstance does not translate well into aesthetic/visual art, music, fiction...
@@meticulouslyeliminatinghaters you are not catching what I said. People can like things and others can dislike things.
All I am saying is the people on both sides of the AI imagery fall into similar stances as people that enjoy and dislike staged "reality videos". Some find it enjoyable, others find it deceitful.
In my example I am specifically using an example of funny videos that try to be passed off as real actual events when they are fake or staged. Whether it be someone staging something for clicks or to deceive or a viral marketing agency made video of this "omg real thing that just happened." Or Reality TV shows where every line and situation is scripted, but fakes being naturally occurring candid moments. Again, if you like those, fine. If you don't like those, fine. I am just making a comparison. I am not telling you that you need to not like those.
Movies, comedies, etc are not trying to pass themselves off as being real actual things that happened and a camera just happened to be recording. Even Punk'd type shows while staged, present a funny situation to an unwitting individual. In the end they are not pretending to the viewer that these things actually happened naturally to these people. There is tongue in cheek.
Some people are vehemently turned off by this content. Others enjoy it, and still enjoy it after finding out about the inauthenticity.
@@mattcy6591I understood it perfectly, I am just saying that's a non-argument due to two reasons.
Reason 1. Your example does not apply to the conversation around AI art. There are hundreds of ways of funny, beautiful, aesthetically pleasing, awe inducing,inspiring... all the ways an artwork can be. Your example is not even art if it's not staged. It's just happenstance. It's real life documented just happens to be funny. It is not an analogy that makes sense in the context artwork which byitself comes with an implication of cognizant intervention.
Reason 2. Whether or not anyone enjoys/accepts this happening is not important. It will happen regardless and when it does there will be no way to be sure of authenticity anymore. Once that happens everything might as well be AI generated.
You will see 100 percent human made art and will think they were AI. At that point if the two origins produce exactly the same art down to minute detail by the strike of a crazy probabilty scenario without knowing you'll enjoy/dislike them to the same degree. So there is no point for arbitrary restrictions for art.
Again, your example is not even art. It's real life documented. It doesn't even have to be funny. Any sort of false claim of documented real life is deception. What you don't enjoy is not AI generated art. You just dislike deception. If a human tries to push a AI generated image as their own art, it does not detract from the quality of the artwork, if you would have enjoyed it otherwise. It is the deception of claimant you dislike. Since the art in question is not real life documented the artwork itself is divorced from deception because it just is as it is. As it would be if it was made by a human artist.
Now this is an adventure worthy of a television serie!
Yes!!! It really would be. These decades were full of great change, the end of samurai and modernization. Such speed! From feudal to cities!
You can watch the TV series "Shōgun". The story is similar to that of Manjiro but in the TV show it is an English sailor who ends up shipwrecked in Japan. The story is partially based on real historical figures. There is also the movie "the last Samurai". The story about the historical figure "Yasuke" is also interesting.
@@Hype363 I saw the original Shogun series back in the 80s but will definitely see the new one too, also love the Last Samurai!
Don't let Netflix see this they gonna add unnecessary woke thing
That was the first thing I thought about. A movie or maybe Taigadorama. There doesn't seem to be such a thing. So wierd.
My Japanese school used the Minna No Nihongo textbook. In it, there was a short story about Manjiro. When I read it, I was blown away. Even with current technology, I sometimes find it difficult to travel in Japan. There are so many differences in not just the language but the culture. And if I get lonely, I can always do a video call with friends and family back in America. I can't imagine what it'd be like to go from having zero knowledge about a foreign country, to wind up living there and being the only person of your nationality. It must've been ROUGH. Shout out to Captain William Whitfield for taking Manjiro under his wing. And of course, thanks to Manjiro for helping bridge Japan to the U.S.
You were the first channel who introduced me to the wonders of Japan, your appreciation of the culture and respect stay with me!
Thank you! I’m glad we can share that, it’s such an amazing country.
Woahh there was a little movie going through my head while I watched this... that's a documentary. I can only imagine how much work it was to visit all these places, collect info and put them together in such a cohesive story. Hope this video gets at least 1mi views. Thanks John!!!
Manjiro deserves my best 😉 thank you!
@@onlyinjapan 🤗💛
I think this would make a awesome movie. Thank you for spending the time doing this story.
Yes, 100% it would! After all the research, I hope the bring me in on the team to help produce it ^_^
@@onlyinjapan you would be the only person I think makes sense
The story of Nakahama "John" Manjiro is absolutely amazing, and you've made an incredible documentary about it. From Kochi, to Hawaii, Fairhaven and Okinawa, your dedication to crafting a thorough and compelling video is truly inspiring. Thank you for sharing this story.
The production was an adventure too! I’m so glad you enjoyed this ^_^
Hustling gold to get the homies back home and then visiting your own grave stone: so badass. John, I would have never had heard this story during late History Channel even though this would have been right up their alley of unconventional and larger than life. You did it again. Amazing work.
History Channel should cover this! When I heard about this story, I said WHY HAVEN’T I HEARD OF THIS BEFORE? It’s because he doesn’t get the same amount of respect as other samurai like Sakamoto Ryoma. Maybe because he was a peasant? But the Manjiro story is coming back and going to burst into US TV sometime! I hope this video inspires more interest in Manjiro and I’ll be happy 😊 because Manjiro deserves it.
This is absolutely amazing! I really want to go visit the museum now! A guy with no family last name makes it to the US and changes history for Japan and the world! Thank you John M for your achievement and to John D for putting his fantastic story together for all of us who want to learn more about Japanese history!
As I watched this, I was thinking about your live streams from each of the locations, and how much time you must have put into telling this amazing story! It was time well spent. Great work, John!
It was almost a year ago I started. It feels really good to finish it today ^_^ and I’m glad you were with me live here too!
@@onlyinjapan John you are the one with many talents,. I think you could write a script. And it would be a delight to see the Movie or Netflix series.
I was waiting for this episode ever since I saw the livestream at Fairhaven. Really liked it and appreciate the hard work that went behind this. I find the love-hate stories between Japan and USA so fascinating and I am not even from one of these two countries originally.
Edit- I gifted my 8 year old nephew a book on Manjiro on his last birthday called "Heart of a Samurai". He's 2nd gen American and loves Japan already. He'll be coming here in japan in a few months!
Wow John, you've outdone yourself with this full on production! I was completely engrossed in your documentary and want to learn more about Manjiro now. Awesome work.
This makes me so happy! I became a fan of Manjiro’s after hearing a basic story of his, and when I dug deeper, it’s absolutely incredible! His love for coffee and sweets, I can relate to him in so many ways 😂
@onlyinjapan this took a lot of work and time to produce. Thank you for this masterpiece! 🤙🏽
What an epic adventure to produce this high quality video, John. Congratulations on delivering a story that you feel a close connection to.
What an impressive episode! Great job
John Manjiro's story is quite amazing and you did a great job of bringing us his story and adventures. Appreciate all the hard work you've put into this one and it shows! Well done! 👏👍
What an amazing life he lived! Thanks, John. Wonderful episode.
Excellent! What an amazing story. I’ve watched 4 times already. John your talent with storytelling and editing is incredible. Love your work. You seem to outdo yourself every time. Thanks for sharing this wonderful story and your talent.
Thanks John, another piece of Japanese history, I missed your documentary style videos
Thank you Aiken!, R-san! Another one on the way in a couple of days :)
Wow John, I can't even begin to describe how much I enjoyed this episode, let alone comprehending how much research work, arranging and putting together what's important surrounding Manjiro life to eventually producing such a compelling, heartwarming and meaningful story. It really showed the extent of Manjiro's life contributing to sowing a deep connection between the two countries which is really cool as someone who loves Japanese history. This is really so well produced, thank you for creating and sharing it with the world so that such valuable story continues to live through generations to come 🙏🏻😊
Thanks! Loved this episode so much! You made my first trip to Japan a success after watching you for years. 🙏
Thank you so much and I really appreciate you watching this particular episode on the most inspiration story I’ve heard in Japan! So glad you had an amazing trip here!
Wow, I think this is the best documentary you've made to date. The pace is not too fast for me to understand these detailed concepts of the biography.
I also like how you merged the Google earth angle with your drone shot! Or when you noticed in one interview that an important conversation was happening and that camera in your hands started recording so fast. Ha ha The use of AI art was a surprise, but a happy surprise. The best utilization of it I've seen.
Some of the reason for the ai criticisms maybe because it's a new ingredient to your formula of design.
Amazing look into the legend. Have a great day sir!
I spent extra time with the timing of the scenes so this makes me happy to hear. I think these tools we get like AI and google maps are just tools we can use like spice for the footage we do take. B-roll we say, spice for the main course. It is certainly going to grow, but how we use it will be very important. I read the comments today and know many don't like the AI stuff even though I had to add a lot of myself into what you see. It was all AI generated. This episode took ages to make. But over time, it won't be an issue at all, just now, people are not used to it nor should they be. Too many abuse it. It is far from perfect but the (nearly all of the) tools of tomorrow will be better than today. I don't intend to use much AI stuff but for history like this, how else does one tell a story that would require so much money to hire actors, sets. In a year, these comments (and perhaps this video) will look dated but the video's story is timeless! Thank you so much for the feedback.
Awesome video John. Thanks for all the time, effort and attention to detail you showcase in all your videos but especially ones like this.
Ahhh, finally another John Daub brilliant history content. I miss this style of yours John. This one is priceless. Well researched and studied which is typical of your old blogs. THANK YOU!!...more of this please.😊
Hi John, this has got to be your finest professional work ever. As soon as it started, I was hooked. Living in the UK, I have never heard of this great Japanese person, Manjiro. Thank you for another outstanding documentary.
Thank you for this, I've been getting hounded for using ai tools so that has been distracting more than I thought it would be for the audience. The audience isn't wrong, they watch with feeling and I appreciate the feedback, but your comment makes me very happy because you caught the story which is the point and absolutely incredible!
the story is so unbelievable to be true but it is! so amazing! thank you for telling us this awesome adventure story.
That is what made me say, I HAVE TO DO THIS STORY! But it took me so far. I hope many love it too.
Well done, John! Thanks for putting in all of the work to bring this story to life for us. I've been a subscriber of yours for several years, and this is one of your best projects to date!
This is such a great story!! Thank you for all your hard work. This is amazing!!!
Thank you for introducing Manjiro. Awesome and impressive video.
How he is not more widely known is mind blowing. Guy deserves his own movie. I first learned about him in 2007, went to his old town where they have a marker where his house used to be at Ashizuri Misaki (Point). They said it burnt down but I see you went to an actual house. Also visited his other "hometown" in Fairhaven, MA and met Gerry in 2011. Well done! You should be very proud of this documentary. You hit on so many great details of his interesting and adventurous life!
Thank you for making this video.
My word , if this isn't one of the most riveting stories I've ever heard ! Thanks John for your meticulous story telling , thank you !!
TH-cam just isn’t suggesting it 😢 share the word in Manjiro! ٩(^‿^)۶ one of the best true stories from the 19th century anywhere in the world!
I loved this! Very well made, like a tv show from a series! and my husband, being Japanese, knew the story very well! Thanks for sharing such a remarkable story that shaped Japanese history! It inspires me to be more open minded to learn more .I did not know this story at all. Wow, how his mom would have grieved over him, but somehow could feel he was still alive! He had such an inquisitive desire to learn! He is an inspiration for all of us who have lived many places on thus globe! I did laugh, never realised Shikoku looked like a mini Australia! 😂 Got the pleasure of living in Perth, Australia for 9 years! Thanks for all the work you put into sharing these types of videos!
There NEEDS to be a movie about Manjiro!
What an amazing story! Thank you for all the travel and hard work to share it. I'm anxious to learn more.
This is easily your best produce video ever! Something on par with some of the best documentaries I've seen. Wonderful work, John! This deserves way more views!
Absolutely fascinating. Have learned a lot from watching this. Although this story is nearly 200 years old, we can take a lot from what happened back then. Thank you John for your extensive research on this project. Take care and thanks again, from Australia
Incredible production. Amazing story. Thank you for putting this together.
My aunt is from Haroshama, Japan major. Thank you for doing what you do!!❤
❤❤❤
Excellent production John. One of your best works.
John this must have been a cool learning experience for you, you did John’s story justice. I’d never heard of this story, and enjoyed every minute of John’s story. Just the thought of being executed for coming home was so brave.
Thank you for doing an awesome job telling us this story.
I wonder what was in his mind when he sailed into Ryukyu. He'd been there before, had a good feeling so risk was low - but man, he must have been worried when they arrested him. I heard he was treated very well in Kagoshima. They knew his value, but the also followed the rules. There's a lot I left for others to learn themselves - can't say it all but enough to get people interested. SO many footnotes of interest through an amazing time in history.
@@onlyinjapan I wondered the same thing about John going home to Japan.
He must’ve been a very confident, young man.
Johns education in the USA must have led to his confidence, that just maybe he’d have the chance to win over the leaders and not be executed, he had big kahunas lol.
John had such a wonderful story and his zest for life.
I’m sure it was a huge gamble on his part to go home,to regain the faith of the leaders of that time in history really is amazing to me.
Thank you again for bringing us Johns story, he was an amazing man we can learn from still.
I love all your videos, they’ve been a huge education for me.
I have been watching your videos for many years, i have always liked the videos and been subscribed to this and other channels off yours, but i have never left and comment, as i became a bit jaded over the years from the comment section on TH-cam and other platforms. But i felt i had to say that this one was one off the best videos that i have seen from you, John and the passion for this story really shows. Thank you for doing what you do and i promise i'l come here more often.
I’m very grateful you took the time to write me about this episode in particular and the encouragement and feedback from so many has been uplifting. TH-cam is still a social media and the comments certainly become an important part of the story. My friends in Kochi are also reading and surprised that so many didn’t know about Manjiro and pleased his story is so inspirational as it was to me when I stumbled upon this museum and wondered, why hadn’t I heard of this before? So I made it my mission to make sure as many could learn about it and it’s that emotion I had that I hope translates through the work. Thank you for commenting. It really made me happy to read it.
Thanks!
Thank you ^_^
John, I think this is one of your finest productions. Fascinating, rare story very few would have known about without this.... It is obvious you spent a lot of time, effort and love in bringing this story to us. Thanks very much.
What a beautiful piece of history, thank you for the extraordinary video on it!
This is a criminally underrated video. I'm amazed by the way you presented this in depth research through your style of story telling. Genuinely a masterpiece!
It’s such a hard episode to title correctly, how to do it so people believe there’s value in it. That is perhaps harder to do right than producing this video across so many lands and seas 😂 it’ll grow, when they make it a movie!
Thank you for telling this remarkable story John, I really enjoy Japanese history and this time period is so interesting. I know you're not into anime, but "Rurouni Kenshin" takes place around this turbulent time and the aftermath, so was happy to learn more about this period and Manjiro. Got to say that the shot at 19:16 was just beautiful 😊.
Great story really enjoyed it thanks for sharing.
John, wonderful presentation of the story of Manjiro, worthy of praise. I plan to share this unique journey whenever possible, mahalo ! I look forward to viewing such quality of work in the future !
Thank you! Mahalo ^_^
This is a brilliant piece of history….
Thank you, John for this amazing story of John Manjiro! I would have never heard of it otherwise…great job with all your work that you put into it! It’s so amazing that the families still keep in touch and honor John Manjiro and Captain Whitfield.
What an incredible story of a man I have never really known about til now. You did a great job telling his story and going to all theses locations to show it. You can see all the effort you put in to this in the production. I hope more people will find this video.
Such amazing episode John, heck, John Mung and John Daub! You certainly bridge the gap for all international TH-cam viewer on your channel and shows the side/history of Japan we don't know or known. Definitely a great episode you have put together over a year and definitely have seen some of your other video (snippet) and location where you went as a "sneak peek" before this video is out. Kudos to you, John and John. :) Mata-ne! :)
GREAT video. Thank you for this. What an amazing story. This video was done so well and in-depth. Thank you again. By the way, the shot of the Ryugu Shrine is mind-blowing.
It’s one of my top 5 “secret” spots, a few KM from Manjiro’s birth house. So amazing - you come out of the jungle and WOW! I did a live stream here 8 months ago in Aug 2023. th-cam.com/users/liveziWDfmbiCYY?si=fchJQmFBTZEV75Pp
Hello John.
My name is Mana Tanaka, and I'm a member of the Tosashimizu Group who met John at Fairhaven.
I attended the festival with my family, and we held an event to shave bonito. I was also in the karaoke scene with Jerry.
I was moved by such a wonderful video and the depth of John's knowledge.
I will share it with everyone, and have subscribed to your channel!
We have been working on various things related to John Manjiro, so this video made us very happy.
Thank you very much.
We wholeheartedly support John's future activities.
Thank you Mana! We’ll come back to Tosashimizu to visit again soon ❤️ it’s such an important and extraordinary city in Japan.
You deserve to win an award for this film.
Absolutely Fascinating Epic Story!!! ❤🤗❤ The drone video footage was especially nice to get an overall view of the locales!!!
Yes! This was an amazing story, so well done John! I'm amazed that there hasn't been a movie done of this extraordinary man and his accomplishments. This video even kept my partners undivided attention away from his cell phone! LOL! No mean feat indeed! Keep up the great work John.
Impressive story telling John, you really took this to a whole new level!
What an important story! And you have told it so beautifully! This should make everyone a lover of history. Fantastic work, John!
This is one of my favorite OIJ episodes ever!
Amazing work!
This is great. I would actually love to see a longer cut. I know you did so much on location having seen your live streams here there and everywhere! Your interview subjects were clearly enthusiastic & knowledgeable. The Ryugu Shrine scene was a spectacular shot yet made contemplative with the added sound of the waves. Impressively put together.
Gosh, if I had one more month! I’d go to Nagasaki, Ogasawara, dig deeper in Tokyo! More on his family but he had a stroke shortly after seeing the Captain again in 1870. That ended his career mostly for diplomacy and I didn’t talk much about it because people will discover it, there’s more to the story for sure!
John, amazing story telling and an amazing episode I feel bad it’s taken me a little bit to sit down and watch it. Thank you for telling this story I’m not sure I would’ve ever heard it otherwise
this is a fantastic video about a awesome inspiring story! thanks for the share!
Thank you! I’m grateful for the encouragement ♪（ｖ＾＿＾）ｖ
John such an excellent job, well done! I really enjoyed your video and learned a lot. I appreciate your efforts to share and educate us. Please create more like these. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Thank you for bringing us the amazing story of John Manjiro. What a life of adventure.
Well done John. All your traveling and research really paid off. I've never heard of "John Mung" so his story was really an eye-opener and inspiring. He must have been a really nice person because he was trusted by the Shogun. In many ways, you too are an ambassador, especially in showing us about Japan and Japan about the USA. Thank You. We'd love to see more of the stories inside Japan.
What a great and moving story!!! Thank you John for sharing it!!!
Amazing story, thank you for telling it 😊
Great job John!!! I had no idea about this!! thanks for sharing this with all of us!
Amazing work! Your channel is a treasure.
This was an incredible episode. Thank you John!!
Just wanted to say really great video!!!!
So much time, effort, and money to shoot on location in at least 7 places far from each other: Fairhaven, Honolulu harbor, Okinawa, Nakanohama, Kochi Castle, Shimoda and Zoshigaya cemetery.
INSANE!!!!!!!!!!
But truly the best way to help us feel invested in the story is to go on site and share these places with us.
YOU SERIOUSLY ROCK!!!!!
Incredible video! I'm playing "Manjiro" in a production of Pacific Overtures soon and this was everything that I needed. Thank you for taking the time to make such a comprehensive video that was equally informative and entertaining!
Excellent! That’s an amazing role! Good luck, really appreciate the comment. Everyone should learn about Manjiro!
What an amazing story! Thank you for all your hard work on this episode! Thats part of what you were doing while you were here! I will share this!
I am starting the Shikoku pilgrimage tomorrow, thanks for this now I am even more excited to visit the John Mung museum and surrounding area!
Good luck on your advenrure, hope to walk it soon!
Oh wonderful! I will do the one of these years, have to go all in, 3 months and really slow life down, remember what's important. Good luck! Def stop in and see the John Mung museum!
Thank you John, for this remarkable video. Your videos are much appreciated.
Congratulations on an epic episode! The research you did is impressive and I can see why it took you a year to put this together. Your attention to detail is wonderful, and I learned so much. This piece should be shown in all the schools in Japan!
Amazing video John. Its a damn shame that this video doesnt have more views. Very welll made video and it must have taken alot of work. Thanks for making this!
Wow, this was such a good video. The way it was laid out and played made me feel like I was watching a Veritasium video. Obviously this is original content all on its own but the voiceover with the animation styles plus all of the information given just comes together to make a very good finished product that is reminiscent of what id expect from the Veritasium producer. I'm a little late to the party but that's because I like to try to save your stuff for when I can't wait to see something new anymore lol. Keep up the awesome work like you always do!!!
Thank you so much John for such a valuable national treasure history. This could've been a great movie with all aspects of life, the wonderful ones without the war and killings. What's an inspirational.
This is a great story that I didn't know before. Especially because you also visited the places where he was. Thank you for this video. :)
John, this is perhaps one of your best videos to date, and I really love the nichibei 日米 aspect of this.
Awesome awesome story. I love the history that tie America and the USA. From Hawaii there is also a deep connection to Japan. My great grandparents are from Japan. So John Manjiro story coincides with Japanese moving to Hawaii. Thank you for the great stories. Mahalo and Aloha. Keep up the great work.
This Manjiro story touched on so much history, doesn’t it!? Amazing how important Hawaii was at this time! It grew leaps and bounds. I’d love to have seen a natural Waikiki Beach without hotels and Diamond Head in the distance 🤩 we lived through Manjiro for 30 minutes, me for a year, and it was pretty awesome! Mahalo!! ^_^
Thank you John! Great work! Keep doing great videos like this, you are an amazing!
That was an amazing story. Thanks for the year-long effort and for telling the story so well. I had zero knowledge of any of this and so it was quite the journey you took me on.
What an increible story and told well enough to be the next Netflix documentary. More people should give this their time.
Thanks John, thoroughly enjoyed it.
It’s a tough topic to title and “sell” to viewers with a click and watch. But those who watch leave with the same impression of Manjiro as I had when I learned this story - wow! 🤩
So well told story!!! Thank you, John!!!
Well done. Thank you for bringing attention to this excellent story. And I agree with the other commenters that this should be a miniseries, but you did a wonderful job making it real.
When I was living in Boston I tried riding my bike to Manjiro friendship house but failed haha. It's amazing that you actually went to some of those places where Manjiro set foot--it's impressive even with modern day transportation
amazing video Love learning about history.
Such history could easily have inspired a fantasy story like One Piece. What an adventure, filled with comradery and hope to reunite with his blood family and later with his mentor so to speak. Some times real history surpass fiction. Great short doc!
Aloha 🤙 from Honolulu!!! What an amazing life Manjiro had. I bet you it went by fast. Well done 👏 John. Excellent video! Thanks.
Hey John, I've been watching for videos for a number of years now and this was one of your best! Absolutely riveting story.
Loved this informational video so much ❤️❤️.
Thank you so much John for sharing another great story with us through your videos.
Wishing you well wishes to you and your family John ❤🙏
Absolutely loved this episode, John! A truly inspiring adventure about bonds and hope. Terrific storytelling as always ❤
Great video and very informative, thanks!!
Amazing story, thanks for taking the time and continued efforts to bring everyone these great stories of Japanese history.
What an amazing video. Thank you for sharing. It’s neat how the families still get together.
Such amazing history presented by a wonderfully talented storyteller! The background music seemed to add something special to the video; really well done.
Love this episode, I love learning about the history of Japan and America. Being American myself, but growing up in Japan. But back living in Florida It’s beautiful to see the families still connected. I’m it makes me want to go up to New Haven for the festival. ❤️ 🇯🇵