Charles Fernandez Db major is considered the “moon key” if you arpeggiate a Db major chord (wide) it just sounds so calm. Like a “stroll in the moonlight”
Charles Fernandez Chopin, like other composers such as Liszt, felt a strong connection to certain keys over others. Chopin loves C sharp, so he wrote a lot of music in that key. Now we live with the beautiful music of C sharp
So glad someone finally played Chopin properly (without oversenteimentalizaing it) Leave it to a program without emotion to express emotional outpouring more satisfactorily than a human.... People take way too much liberty with the metronome and rhythm in Chopin's music in general that I became so fed up with literally every single performer to play Chopin that you can possibly name or Google and intentionally searched for this piece midi in an effort to hear how it is supposed to sound....ironically
I don’t think this performance is even comparable to a real one. This is accurate to the sheet but not how it is supposed to sound or feel, or are you forgetting that Chopin was human too? Perhaps more human than most of us.
I love the trio of the scherzo, its the most beautiful music ever written. In my imagination it symbolises the longing for peace and quietness between al the death an fighting of the scherzo
Its just a chromatic scale, the same thing happens in the a minor etude as the main melody are the large left hand cords with a top run consisting of a chromatic scale and alternating harmonies
why today people run after despacito , etc. they are all shit the true music lied in the genius compositions of chopin , liszt , beethoven , schubert , mozart ,etc.
Manuel Castro While I disagree that there are no new great songs, mainstream pop and rap are the furthest from creative music has ever been. It’s been industrialized, it’s to the point where 99% sounds barely different and is indistinguishable from many others. It may take theory, but Chopin had more variety himself alone than 100 of today’s writers and composers.
Because people tend to listen to things that they grew up with. It's that simple. If you wouldn't grow up with classical music, chances are low that you would listen to it now.
Songs can be beautiful. Same as pieces. There is many trurly beautiful songs I think the point that OP is making and that I agree with is what people MOSTLY listen to today. This is stuff like mumble rap etc. which dares call itself music. This shit has been advertised so much that millions of people listen to it and at the end of the day anybody could come up to a microphone and start making random sounds. Most music today follows a very similar pattern and a lot of music is also indistungishable. I was on vacation recentley. In a nearby hotel there was music playing. It was always the same baseline which just feels like your head is getting banged into the floor every second you listen to it. Everything today is the same and if it changes it somehow changed for the worse. Not much music theory is needed to make most of today’s music. The thing is that many have never even listened to classical music and don’t know how shit what they listen to is.
@@CatkhosruShapurrjiFurabjiactually i like it but idk how to say it its just seems disrespectful i guess that someone would just come and tag and hear only that part thats like idk watching only last season of breaking bad its good but nowhere close to being as good as if u saw all the character develpment and from the begining listening to just the funreal march is like only reading a good part of a book idk i think the rest of this piece deserves more recognition and i see no point taging it here when u can go watch just the part
I love the piece as a whole. The sonata is incomplete without a cadenza/part. Its just so sublime that I can't keep a fav section. I love the third movement, but the others as well. I listened to the whole piece. And you're right, its like reading the favourite part of the book and not knowing the remaining events and episodes. Just tagging one part is crappy. I'm asking boldly now, have you seen any f***ing pianist play his/her favourite part in a concert and leave the rest? @Marek Smíd, I completely agree with you.
You've stumbled upon what might be one of the great tragedies of romantic music here. There's evidence to suggest that Chopin's German editors shifted the beginning of the repeat four bars to the right, apparently not believing that Chopin could intend for something as shocking and ugly as that introduction to be repeated. Modern practice has (inadvertently, I think) inherited this neglect of the introduction. It's a total waste, as 1. The introduction is a brilliantly conceived thing, and the repeat would emphasize its structural relevance to the music, and 2. The end of the exposition, if you think about it, obviously wants to use the introduction to return to the original key of B-flat minor. The use of the introduction would also ease the transition into the development (the initial tonality of the development section mirrors the deceptive harmony of the introduction.).
Yes! When the introduction is repeated, it leads to a conclusion into b-flat, which only proves how essential it is the whole ritornello. I had found some recording (maybe pogorelich) that repeated the whole thing, but unfortunately I can't find it anymore :(
![Chopin - Sonata No. 2 in B-Flat Minor, Op. 35 (Cho) [Score]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VUk3_qTTVg4/mqdefault.jpg)
0:17 that sounds so cool
Looks like you’re sitting on a horse running along the sunset
its the best ;/
Last movement is pure genius. Chopin anticipated the music that would come a century later....
Impressionism?
Sabrina Chen no, atonalism
Roast?
practicboi 40hrs How is it a roast?
It sounds like rachmaninov
22:06 what thats ending... Absolutely beyond of human
Its so weird.. like some kind of a chromatic fuga or something
4:35 This is my favorite part
me too
Yes
22:13 Sounds like his Scherzo No. 2!
yh i think its the same idea as scherzo 2
22:12 great ending
Sounds like scherzo no 2
@@santiagosolis4621 well same key also🤣
I love the biginning and the end of this sonata and of course everything that is in between!
15:30 my favourite part in this sonata
My favorite is 20:55
Why are all the beautiful and dramatic pieces are in C# minor/Db major?
its funeral march but i loved it
Charles Fernandez Db major is considered the “moon key” if you arpeggiate a Db major chord (wide) it just sounds so calm. Like a “stroll in the moonlight”
Charles Fernandez Chopin, like other composers such as Liszt, felt a strong connection to certain keys over others. Chopin loves C sharp, so he wrote a lot of music in that key. Now we live with the beautiful music of C sharp
Zero dislikes? This is what I want to see on every video on this channel!
Charles- Valentin Alkan you just had to say something
you totally jinxed it. people disliked the video just to spite you....
2:01 I love this ^^
3:37 6:03 :)
Even 4:36 is outwardly!
i learned it
My favorite sonata of all time, the marche funebre part always makes me cry
I thought that Funeral March was a separate piece on it's own, not a part of a sonata, until I saw THIS vid right here!!!
Yes, many people think that way, and also the same with Clair de Lune. It's not a piece on its own, it's actually the 3rd movement of his suite.
Chopin always thought that it needed more notes
this is one of my favorite pieces of Chopins work, beautiful
4:33-5:53 epic climax
I gotta say something about this Sonata? I don't wanna butcher it by commenting or judging on it; its way too sublime.
Wtf
@@stravinskyfan hi
So glad someone finally played Chopin properly (without oversenteimentalizaing it)
Leave it to a program without emotion to express emotional outpouring more satisfactorily than a human....
People take way too much liberty with the metronome and rhythm in Chopin's music in general that I became so fed up with literally every single performer to play Chopin that you can possibly name or Google and intentionally searched for this piece midi in an effort to hear how it is supposed to sound....ironically
I don’t think this performance is even comparable to a real one. This is accurate to the sheet but not how it is supposed to sound or feel, or are you forgetting that Chopin was human too? Perhaps more human than most of us.
Happy 208th birthday chopin!❤️
HAPPY 220TH (late
Is the piano underwater lmao
It’s played quietly and is sustained ok?
So how do you play the left hand there (6:35)?
Chopin: Yes.
Lmao
Use the right hand🙃
I love chopin
7:31 / 12:26 sounds too good!
listened to marios video on this and it makes your vid sound like heaven
Yes, like a real human, no like a robot.
9:56 / 10:58 sounds too calming
I love the trio of the scherzo, its the most beautiful music ever written. In my imagination it symbolises the longing for peace and quietness between al the death an fighting of the scherzo
2nd Movement genious!
The ending sounds like scherzo no. 2
which Movement?
Memento Mori 4th
Actually scherzo is quite playable, and sounds amazing
7:22
I like the 2nd one.
please make rachmaninoff piano concerto n 2
1st movement is mostly a# major
5:07 Winter Wind reference?
I always confused the two...
Its just a chromatic scale, the same thing happens in the a minor etude as the main melody are the large left hand cords with a top run consisting of a chromatic scale and alternating harmonies
Yeah lol, that's literally the easiest arpeggio to think up
Chopin loves chromatic scales
No🤣
why today people run after despacito , etc.
they are all shit
the true music lied in the genius compositions of chopin , liszt , beethoven , schubert , mozart ,etc.
You know that there is still composers ? Today's music isn't just radio's music..
Manuel Castro While I disagree that there are no new great songs, mainstream pop and rap are the furthest from creative music has ever been. It’s been industrialized, it’s to the point where 99% sounds barely different and is indistinguishable from many others. It may take theory, but Chopin had more variety himself alone than 100 of today’s writers and composers.
EXACTLY
Because people tend to listen to things that they grew up with. It's that simple. If you wouldn't grow up with classical music, chances are low that you would listen to it now.
Songs can be beautiful. Same as pieces. There is many trurly beautiful songs I think the point that OP is making and that I agree with is what people MOSTLY listen to today. This is stuff like mumble rap etc. which dares call itself music.
This shit has been advertised so much that millions of people listen to it and at the end of the day anybody could come up to a microphone and start making random sounds.
Most music today follows a very similar pattern and a lot of music is also indistungishable. I was on vacation recentley. In a nearby hotel there was music playing. It was always the same baseline which just feels like your head is getting banged into the floor every second you listen to it.
Everything today is the same and if it changes it somehow changed for the worse. Not much music theory is needed to make most of today’s music.
The thing is that many have never even listened to classical music and don’t know how shit what they listen to is.
7:43 7:25 7:29
why is the beginning of 1st movement all in blue
1:46 Tristesse
Etude Op. 10 No. 3 ?
@@Dylonely_9274 yep. Btw lol you turned Chopin into a minor with your profile pic lol. 😂 And btw happy b'day chopin! 🎊
@@CatkhosruShapurrjiFurabji Happy Birthday to this legend
4:53
7:25
15:30
21:20
15:30
@@Dylonely_9274 Yeah I wrote it
@@T-J-S Ikr
hey did you consider putting Timestamps for the Movements into the description?
Yeah sorry didn't get to do it at first. It's there now
+PianoCzarX oh wow that was fast thank you :) Keep doing your work and dont forget the Timestamp for Pieces with Movements :3
first movement is killing my hands, sb help me pls
noice
Myrtle Beach
8:15 messed up
It's a computer, it can't mess up.
ComposaBoi or keyboard
@@nighster77skyhightower4 no, the notes played are too precise.
ComposaBoi & 2 fast
@@nighster77skyhightower4 Too fast? Have you ever heard a real person play this?
Nice Nice Nice
Carowinds
You completely messed up the pedal from the climax at 4:33
0:34
This sounds like you are trying to listen to it trough a wall. Why is the sound limited?
Listening to piano through a wall is not perfect. Have you tried getting rid of it? Let me know when you break free of that wall, I'm rooting for you!
To me it just sounds like the sound is being held back or something. Like its muffled. I can't explain it
You're right, when it comes to Chopin's music, it's important not to get overexposed to it. Muffling the sound offers good protection against that
Overexposed???
Yeah, it's very very dangerous.
13:21
stfu
Marek Smíd you seem to hate the funeral march part.
@@CatkhosruShapurrjiFurabji yeah
@@CatkhosruShapurrjiFurabjiactually i like it but idk how to say it its just seems disrespectful i guess that someone would just come and tag and hear only that part thats like idk watching only last season of breaking bad its good but nowhere close to being as good as if u saw all the character develpment and from the begining listening to just the funreal march is like only reading a good part of a book idk i think the rest of this piece deserves more recognition and i see no point taging it here when u can go watch just the part
I love the piece as a whole. The sonata is incomplete without a cadenza/part. Its just so sublime that I can't keep a fav section. I love the third movement, but the others as well. I listened to the whole piece. And you're right, its like reading the favourite part of the book and not knowing the remaining events and episodes. Just tagging one part is crappy. I'm asking boldly now, have you seen any f***ing pianist play his/her favourite part in a concert and leave the rest? @Marek Smíd, I completely agree with you.
Why doesn't it have a full introduction repeat??
You've stumbled upon what might be one of the great tragedies of romantic music here. There's evidence to suggest that Chopin's German editors shifted the beginning of the repeat four bars to the right, apparently not believing that Chopin could intend for something as shocking and ugly as that introduction to be repeated. Modern practice has (inadvertently, I think) inherited this neglect of the introduction.
It's a total waste, as 1. The introduction is a brilliantly conceived thing, and the repeat would emphasize its structural relevance to the music, and 2. The end of the exposition, if you think about it, obviously wants to use the introduction to return to the original key of B-flat minor. The use of the introduction would also ease the transition into the development (the initial tonality of the development section mirrors the deceptive harmony of the introduction.).
Yes! When the introduction is repeated, it leads to a conclusion into b-flat, which only proves how essential it is the whole ritornello.
I had found some recording (maybe pogorelich) that repeated the whole thing, but unfortunately I can't find it anymore :(
Eppur lol I was about to say that totally sounds like him
@@thegreenpianist7683 Does anyone have downloads of any of Eppur's videos? The channel is closed for some reason :(
1st movement is b flat MAJOR not minor
5 flats in the sheet music
PianoCzarX u should definitely fix the description
5 flats is Bb minor
@@nighster77skyhightower4 2 bs are B-flat major
Silas Kunkel I meant 1st movement not 1st & 3rd
Are you sure the 2nd Mvt is in Eb minor? It looks more like F# minor to me.
It is in fact in Eb minor, according to the sheet music
2nd mvt is Gb minor not Eb minor
Edit: major ;)
But don't look at what's played throughout the piece. The initial key is the key of the piece, in this case, e flat minor
Pranav Rajesh my bad 🤦🏼♀️
Pranav Rajesh or f#/d#
Dynamics?
It’s a computer playing
2nd mvt is gb major not Eb
Eb minor. The second mvm is set in an A-B-A form which is Eb - Gb maj - Eb so it would be called what it first starts off as ( Eb )
Did it reach her?
@@Murcielag0scuro it was a joke. Also I sent that 2 years ago.
Wow I was found people from the past
Computer-generated music? Awful!
this was written by a human
@@eboone: why not played by human then?
*13:21*
stfu
4:34
7:26
7:51
2:42