I Hate Your Deck #60 Thalia and The Gitrog Monster v Nath Ranar v Omnath v || Commander Gameplay MTG
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ส.ค. 2024
- Join our Patreon today! / ihateyourdeck
We appreciate all the support from all of you. So excited to have you all to keep seeing these awesome episodes we have lined up!
A New Magic the Gathering Commander show that highlights a decks true absurd potential! Enjoy the fun banter and gameplay! Become a Patron to support our content, receive awesome rewards, join our exclusive community and more! We love to play test in our discord for Patrons only.
If you want some T-shirts or hoodies check out our store:
i-hate-your-deck.creator-spring.com
----------
Show Notes:
We encourage the Pregame and Rule 0 talk before every game, to help set expectations to create a healthy community, where we can all have fun playing this game.
Whose deck will we hate most?
----------
Deck lists: Can be found on our Patreon for our Patrons! Thanks for helping us grow as a channel so we can keep brining you more commander content! A lot of work goes into this show and we want to keep getting better for you all. We'll keep showing off interesting, fun or crazy decks on the show.
----------
Follow us on Twitter!
@Hate_your_deck
Follow us on Instagram:
@I_Hate_Your_Deck
Follow us on Facebook:
/ ihyourdeck
Email us: ihateyourdeck@gmail.com
----------
Commander/EDH Official Rules, Banlist, FAQ, and more: mtgcommander.net
“My fiancée helped me make this deck, she doesn’t play magic but loves control”
HA!
“Is that a full on tap land with no other benefits?”
Randy sitting over there quietly while the others fight it out haha
Then he wins!
As much as I love Thalia and The Gitrog Monster, it puts such a large target on your back because of the ''enter tapped'' ability.
Well, depending on your deck, an effect like this really breaks your neck. Imagine an Encore/Blitz or any onther "One Turn hasty Token" Style deck. That really stinks :D
people don't like not playing the game what can you say
It’s all who you play with. If your okay group can’t handle Thalia or shoot her because she’s the “threat” when other threats exist maybe you should play with other people
If Randy wants to add some nasty control, insert Lavinia of the Tenth in the deck. With Soulherder or Conjurer's Closet out, you can almost completely shut down other people's boards with her detain ability.
I may be wrong, but because Meren's ability targets a creature card in the graveyard, Ayli may not have been able to sacrifice reclamation sage with Braids and then return it to hand with Meren's trigger as part of the same stack.
This is 100% correct. Meren's ability needs to have a target as it's put on the stack. Since the stack can't start to resolve until all targets are selected Rec Sage would not be able to be targeted. Surprised Ayli didn't catch that herself.
21:20 Ayli couldn't return reclamation sage to her hand because it wasn't a legal target at the beginning of the end step when Meren triggered. I don't think she had any creatures in her graveyard she could target
I just pulled Thalia and Gitrog last Friday. This is perfect timing.
Same here, so tempted to build a new deck now....
@@toddwhittaker4233 dooooo iiiit. I build the duo a bit stax-y with landfall and the end game of trying to meld the brother's war Titania. Fun deck.
I'm putting it into my 99 in my Kathril deck I think she helps Kathril a bit with the sac ability giving her possibility of more keyword counters. plus protects Kathy with the tap ability a bit. And who doesn't like the extra land draw.
Ayli's deck presentation:
It has combos, but none are infinite - very cool
There's some forced discard in it - oh no
Tergrid is in the deck - OOH NOO
Got beat by Randy playing the Ranarr precon deck XD
20:40 and 21:15 Meren and Braids triggers both go on the stack at the same time, so you have the pick a target for Meren's ability then. Rec Sage wasn't in the bin yet, so Ayli couldn't have brought it back with Meren since it wasn't there when she should have picked the target. Roper caught it the second time. I feel like it was talked about at 27:10 but it got cut.
Pretty sure braids and meren both triggered at the end step, once merens ability is on the stack it has to target sometime before braid resolves. So I don’t think she was able to get the rec sage back since it wasn’t in the graveyard while merens ability was put onto the stack
I love all the GREEN!!!
Love everything you guys put out! I’ve learned so much about building spicy decks from you!!!!
Lynch I bet you could make an awesome Rocco, Street Chef deck honestly.
38:17 I see you RANDYY Great joke that no one noticed!!! Great game man!
Representing the floating mana is cool but maybe use some other tokens or just half the land cards? it gets a little confusing when out of a sudden there is extra lands on the table
Or dice!!!
idk about you but that "extra land" to me at least appears to be an un-sleeved land. So i don't think that get confusing at all.
Playing chains means you can’t complain about the outlet bs out there
I don’t like being called out by Randy. “Except you krrik players” 😅
Ranar?? Oh I’m ready to see what that deck does!
Yes, us kriik players love searching.
Theres actually 3 arts for Thalia and Gitrog
18:21 Roper points out that Kosima enters tapped due to Thalia and Gitrog. But just played 2 creatures untapped LOL 😂
I play mono-green Omnath too, he took all the hatred. Killing Doubling Cube, Wilderness Reclamation, Sword, and Omnath twice was brutal. And the discarded Pathbreaker Ibex. He should have Chorded for a Seedborn Muse, Nyxbloom Ancient, or Terestadon though. I cut Craterhoof from my deck, there just aren't enough creatures and I don't play Avenger of Zendakar. Planar Portal + Seedborn is the 'I WIN' button.
If you're running doubling season and roaming throne, you've got some threats down.. just say you've played Rampaging Baloths.. then you follow up with reshape the earth - that rampaging baloths triggers 10 x for each land down, roaming thrones triggers a second instance of everything thus far, so effectively that's 20 triggers so far.. and then doubling season would double that figure making 40 x 4/4 beasts - if you don't get board wiped or still have the mana to get craterhoof out that's 40 x 40/40 beasts. Then ya boy zopandrel comes in, hung like a donkey, pumps your boys up to 80/80.. that's 3200 damage to distribute from 40 different sources. if you don't get countered, that's a table wipe.
there's nothing more delightful than a judge playing commander with necropotence in play. the only thing that matters.
I don't think Aili could have gotten the reclamation sage on that meren trigger since it didn't exist in the graveyard at the time the ability would go on the stack and have to pick targets. Could be wrong
I really think Ranar is under-rated. It's definitely because Brago is just so much more consistent as a flicker commander, but Ranar is strong in his own right.
The problem with Ranar is that he really is mediocre. He doesn't provide card advantage and the payoff isn't great either. Vega the Watcher is a legit better Foretell commander.
As far as Blink goes, Brago, Yorion and Oji are better options.
@@ferdithetank7535 you only looking at the foretell side of things. He rewards value by flickering things there making a spirt army. Vega take much building because the only thing it provides is card advantage then you have to run a lot of foretell and rely on cards like ethereal angel heavy.
I love Nath Stax. Been playing it for years now but I and others run into this same scenario practically every game. The other 3 players will focus all damage on you regardless if you're no longer the threat. People just straight up hate discard/stax over mill, creature hate, board wipes, prison, land destruction etc. to the point that they throw out all logical threat assessment.
Bro straight up brought a precon to troll
Been here since the 8 minute waiting time. Can't wait to see how it plays.
Man I'll admit it. I'm in love with Ayli
its ok to be gay
Love seeing ranar pop off
Congrats Randy well earned!!!
"My fiancé helped me build this" 😂
That Ranar deck was almost entirely the precon and the precon sucks at foretelling lol
Can't return rec sage on first meren trigger, I think. No big deal :) Great game!
I always expect for the control player to do a Farewell on the field and ruin everyone’s hopes
Fair magic always wins !!!!!!
Looks like a blast to play with all y’all. Tons of fun. Catch y’all on the flippity !
I feel like there was a tree lighting just before the camera turned on.
UPRGRADED PRECON for the WIN! lol.... (really its the ranar precon hes playing with a couple changes_) straight power
I don’t know what’s hotter, the take backsies sauce or the song at the end of the episode!
Let’s gooooo
My friends bought Ranar precon as a 1st commander deck, upgraded IT but he never belives on its while i think this deck can be super awsome.
I started magic with this deck but focused on the flicker dude as my commander. It gets a good board state if left alone but without decent cards it's hard to get wins with. I built a homebrew kaza and extus a few years in and those are my two favorite decks still
I don’t think ayli can target reclamation sage with meren. Because both braids trigger and meren trigger go on the stack at the same time, at which you choose targets. Since reclamation isn’t in the graveyard to be targeted until the braids trigger resolves, meren can’t target it.
I see that she targeted the elvish visionary with meren which was already in the graveyard so no game rules were broken there, but I just wanted to clarify that she couldn’t have gotten Rec sage back that turn anyway
I hate your what? .. oh... I misheard.
Necropotence, eh😏😏
21:20 So this is a bit of a misplay I'm afraid. Yes Ayli can stack the beginning of end step triggers how she wants, but upon triggering the Meren ability she must choose a target in her graveyard. This choice happens before both the resolution of the Meren ability and the resolution of the Braids ability, therefore she can't choose the creature she sacrificed with the Braids ability Aka Rec sage, which was her choice. Technically an illegal play.
A sad battle, would have loved to see ayli more time in it with that deck. I think politics was rushed a lot when omnath obviously was the real enemy.
That guy needs to bring back henzie!
Foretold cards go face down. Preferably sideways in order to distinguish them from morphe cards on the battlefield.
Thought about making Thaalia and Gitrog, but felt a bit oppressive, didn't seem that bad in this game... definitely slows the game a bit though
T&G is grade A haterade.
Deck lists i cant even afford 😢
Kind of a bummer it was such a gang tackle game.
Has Ayli won a game yet? I don’t think she has but she’s come so close plenty of times lol
I think there was one with her Mono White Kemba Deck
Shout out to Ayli's hair!! Loving it!
Roper got some clothing and got to throw out that potato sack he was in last time. I'm so happy for him!
Thalia the human fog.
That first Meren trigger getting back the Rec Sage shouldn't work. Meren targets and the rec sage was not a valid target when the ability triggered at the beginning of the end step.
Bringing discard deck to any game is like putting target on your own back. It just makes games so boring and insufferable...
Lets goooo made my friday
how can i get decklists?
se had it coming do to fact she drop necropotence. also when someone drop that card they become priority number one to take out.
Honestly, her grabbing Necropotence cost her the game. She should have just grabbed Sadistic Hypnotist and stripped everyone's hands. Doing that would have most likely let her win in the next two-ish turns since she had Elvish Harbinger in hand.
In regards to Lynch's flooding, how much land do y'all run in your commander decks?
The most I run is a Aesi lands matter deck and it's 44 but I have 2 other decks that run 35 and they all play great but I hear all the time it's nowhere near enough. Thoughts?
I base my land count on when I started building standard I was told %40 is a good rule of thumb, more for control and less for agro and just directly applied it to edh
When I start a new deck 37, 38 is the land count I start with 🤔 it usually depends on playstile draw fixing etc. So If your deck works fine it works fine with 35 lands. If you allways have to ask to draw another full mulligan, because you never have enough in your starting hand you should think about it. And another thing is Ramp is no ramp without a landdrop usually, soo if it often happens that you pay for ramp but don't have one think about adding more lands. That's my perspective 😅
Agreed, in a landfall build 44+ feels correct (I'm running 52 in borborygmos enraged), in most decks I'm sitting around 37 lands.
Never heard of the commander ||. Gonna be interesting for sure.
Hey all a lil late but thisll be a good one
Why did he bounce Cosima instead of wall of omens?
Except you kirrk player 😂 lol nice
Aside from Lynch cutting a bit too much slack towards Omnath, I am fine with threat assesment in this game.
But also understand him, the black stax are just unbearable
Ayli punted the game so hard.. why tutor for Necropotence when you can tutor for Sadistic Hypnotist, play it and strip everyone's hands and then the following turn play Elvish Harbinger to get Allosaurus Shepherd and most likely win...
How is his deck a control deck? He just sat there the entire game
WHERE EXQUISITE MUSTACHE MAN
Soon friend, stay tuned... every other Friday:)
Lol that game was pretty predictable honestly. Randy please comment here and let me know if I'm right. The tat on your right arm, is that the demon slayer logo of Grey from Fairy Tail???? 👆
Why’d he go get craterhoof? Loose 6 power from omnath just to give trample? Kinda lame when people search for the bangers of the format in bad situations. It’s like searching for a dockside to get 3 treasures
It is annoying yet hilarious when people get so focused that someone like Randy wins because they are so worried about one person they do not think about the long game.
What exactly is the difference between salty and spicy for a magic deck ?
Couple of factors.
The pod your in and if you can follow it up.
The pod is just the general powerlevel and how much removal or other tools they have to deal with the nasty plays.
The follow up means: it is okay to be in bad situation with magic, if that bad situation is reasonably quickly resolved either by removing it or by the player playing it winning the game :p
I would have stood up and left as soon as she played chains. what a card to bring to friendly magic
Why? The card is suboptimal in "friendly" games. It's mainly good in extremely high powered or cedh games or decks that are trying to draw to the moon and back. If anything the card probably did more damage to her that game than anyone else.
12:45 what are the talking about?
funko pop landfill I think
what's the song name?
4 dudes playing magic
Just 4 males, 4 decks, and 1 winner! Nice episode
7:27 Priest of Titania can't be tapped for two because she only controls one elf... how was that missed?
It’s all elves in the battlefield for Priest of Titania so his elvish mystic is the second elf.
What is the dude real name?
Chains is due for a reprint. $1200 card
You're in luck. Since the reserve list is no longer sacred according to that dancing clown; Maro, it will likely be reprinted.
Good thing they won't reprint the great reserve list
Pretty sure she was playing a proxy, it’s on the reserved list so it and tabernacle or moat will never be along with many others.
Proxy
🔧 👕
Love seeing black players get ganged up on after making the game hell for everyone else
Does Ayli have any real cards? I watch this to see how high end cards are because I can't afford them. Every game she plays are proxies. I understand rule zero but I watch this show because it is " I wish I could afford a deck like that. Heck fare I could build better decks than these using proxies!
I know a lot of people put their real versions in a binder and just use proxies as a place holder. I personally prefer using the cards in my deck but will use proxies if I need more of that card for other decks because you can accidently damage cards by constantly swapping them between decks
Ayli is on a lot of shows. Always with real expensive "proxies". Never see the "real" cards.
This show is not a gallery for good cards. Than you might have to watch legacy events or so. If you watch cedh or stuff usually proxies are totally accepted since you play with power not with your wallet.
Further I wouldn't say that the powerlevel of this show is to the moon. It depends on the video, but mostly it's casual higher power like 7 maybe 8.
@@kushiel8169 could just be she doesn't like playing with the real thing in her deck. I have a friend that keeps his reserve list cards in a binder at the bank. I personally am very selective on who I even let touch my Nath deck because there are no proxies and its all expensive foils and cards like Cradle, Nether void, etc - used to have Chains in it too but I sold it once I stopped playing as much Cedh.
Most of the time. I just don't have enough copies of 1 card. Others I have spending limit. During this particular recording, I had been moving. So finding everything was in-fucking-possible