The three language formula has been sabotaged by north Indians, says Yogendra Yadav
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 มิ.ย. 2019
- If Uttar Pradesh learnt Tamil, then Tamil Nadu would surely learn Hindi. But if UP doesn’t want to learn Tamil, it can at least learn Punjabi or any other language, Yadav tells ThePrint’s Kritika Sharma
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
India is not just north and south, there is east and west as well
@Ganesh S I'm from the east..the north can go fuck itself.
South is there because it always fights for its rights.
Then fuckin fight for your rights and don’t let North push you around.
@@manmathsinghdeo5220 fuck east and south
@@manmathsinghdeo5220 you people get out of india and go to china or bhutan or nepal or tibet no need to stay here in india and trying to break it apart
If a child learns Tamil, English, and Malayalam as three languages in Tamil Nadu, will that satisfy the three language formula? For most rural Tamils, that kind of learning a neighbouring state language would be practically more meaningful. I would think learning the language of the state adjoining a place is more likely to be beneficial. Only those who wish to migrate to North would prefer Hindi. Others will even not like to be burdened with a third language until it is time. My suggestion would be mother tongue starting in class 1. English starting from class 6. Any third optional language from class 10.
I have lived and worked in 6 states of India and learnt every one of their languages. But the choice should be based on necessity and left to the choice of the individual. making it compulsory to young school children who may have no idea as to which third language they may need is a waste.
Soon we will have mobile phones with apps that may do the translation. So government may fund such research instead of trying to appease any votebanks.
If a child learns Tamil, English, and Malayalam as three languages in Tamil Nadu, will that satisfy the three language formula?
Mr Yadav seems to be implying "Yes".
This is a very sensible comment thanks for posting it sir .. hope everyone understands this
I totally agree with you Sir
After class 10 , student will not learn an additional language , they will learn only for job purposes. ....
I agree
I'm a Tamilan, and my Hindi is far better than my Tamil lol and I expect the opposite from the Northies.
The polish learn French, the Russians learn German. That has to do with economic and cultural impact of a region. North Indians got the lead in pop culture of this country and got a head start in leaving their footprint. But today a lot of North Indians work in Bangalore, Chennai and Hyderabad and are at least able to watch Telugu and Tamil content with open heart and even able to speak a few words. I think just like South Indians in Delhi and Kolkata speak Hindi because their work brought them to this place, and made them learn Hindi, companies in south should offer language courses for free for the north Indians to learn Kannada, tamil and Telugu. People will surely learn it
Good one!
@@suyashneelambugg I'm from Bangalore and can tell you that none of the Northies from Delhi or UP or Punjab make any effort in learning the local language. Infact they detest them. Here the feeling is when people from the North hate South Indian languages so much, why should we learn a language of a region that too which is far backward in all aspects compared to the rest?
Sir here agenda is not to learn local language but to make all indians learn atleast one common language... if at all hindi people to learn diff lang should learn Sanskrit..
@@ErTejinder atleast one common language is English there already, when then make to learn another common language ? People in TN learn Hindi too but why not UP wala and biharis or the Punjabis learn Tamil or Kannada?
That’s the point ,North has sabotaged it from 1970 to 2019{50 years}.So go and make hindi belt teach south languages-Telugu,Tamil,kannada,Malayalam for atleast 5-10 years and then come to south states and we will be overwhelmed to learn hindi.
Excellent point, not just in language, i feel it's in all domain. We don't get our fair share of taxes, fair share of rail projects, fair share of industrial corridors, fair share of constituencies...stop this step mother treatment.
Have you read the policy? Did you watch this video? That's exactly what everyone is saying. Have some sense before giving knee jerk reaction.
And why 5-10 yrs later? Are you India's son-in-law? Why can't it happen simultaneously?
It's all about implementation. Everyone will have to learn 3 languages. Idiots all around, North and South. People like you just love to hate and divide. Shame on you!!!
Well to be honest, it is my personal goal that I will be learning Sanskrit and then either Telugu or Tamil in my lifetime.
We, North Indians, get a lot of needless hatred for no fault of ours.
It is a fact that 70% of India speaks Hindi to some extent or the other. Hindi has the best chance to be a National Language.
I do understand that the Govt shouldn't mandate Hindi to studies or job, where even slight difference in language proficiency could cost candidate an opportunity.
@@kundankumar777 Genius, where is this implementation gone for last 50+ years ? Ask yourself how many of North Indians working in southern states have learn native language ?? and you expect this will change suddenly with the political base that you have in North??. Policy my foot policy, same old shit rotten education policy and deprived funded.
Teach only English and Sanksrit. English for the kitchen and Sanksrit for the soul. Rest will manage. Even if I learnt Hindi at school, its written form is of no use now. Colloquial Hindi can be learnt even without training.
The imposition comes in when Non-Hindi speaking states should learn their (Regional language + English + Hindi) whereas Hindi speaking states will get to choose the third language of their choice...Why not give Non-Hindi speaking states the same option to choose the third language of their choice?
It never says Hindi its says its optional what nonsense man grow up
@@niteshirav2969 You grow up and read it..At first it was just Hindi as 3rd language for Non Hindi speaking states and after opposition from all the southern states especially TN, the draft was amended to have an option still reiterating preferably Hindi..If u have balls prove me that there was no mention of Hindi as a 3rd language
@@preanand1938 That's the trick of making Hindi as mandatory by saying you are provided with optional languages to choose but we only have teacher for Hindi. These bastards know all sorts of trick.
@@awesomeservice True!!
@@awesomeservice Not only that they will propagate that instead of learning any third Language HINDI is spoken in 60% of the Country and will Indirectly force and Twist their minds to select Hindi 🙄
These Tactics will never go well with us (Tamizhs) 😆
I must congratulations Yogendra Yadav for such a superb articulation.
No doubt, you don't see street 🐕 dogs now a days, may be they started taking human form and now you can find a ring leader here!! The scarf on the neck is probably the broken belt!!!
@@vijayakrishna4632 Who knew one of those street dogs might be the PM today.
@@bunnybag and you are also one among them😂😃
TOTAL BULLSHIT - In "Non-Hindi" States it is - Regional Lang (assumed state Lang or mother tongue), English and !!HINDI !! And in Hindi States it is - Hindi, English and !! anyother language preferably South Indian Language !! So Hindi is a "constant" in all states. This is Blatant imposition. Why this differentiation of Hindi speaking States and Others. There lies the root of the problem. Why Not a uniform policy of State Lang, English and any other state language?? It's a clever heads I win tails you lose Game. Bull shit. It's a 1968 bullshit.
SouthIndians have no need to cross South borders. They have Bengaluru, Chennai, Hyderabad for job. Hindi is of no use for SouthIndians. This 3 language formula is a cheating, for SouthIndian states Hindi is mandatory. For Northindian states, South language is a choice.
English and local language is enough
There are people in the media too, who considering Indian cinema means bollywood cinema (others are considered 'regional'). Indian literature means 'hindi' others are 'regional'🙄
(Now i know years ago, why a delhi journalist reported-" now kerala honouring (bollywood hero) John Abraham by giving state awards in his name" - as he was ignorant who never heard about anything about the Malayalam film director, legendary John Abraham)😃
no hindi people will not learn any other language.they will make fun of all other languages specially southern.
They make fun of punjabi too,, punjabi is only non hindi language in north india
@Shashank Kumar .. it's not an inferiority complex.... How can non hindi belters have a complex about the most socially, politically and economically backward part of India..? The hindi belt is truly the armpit of India...
Every state in North India have their own regional language
@Shashank Kumar Meanwhile, the southern and the western states are 'rich' because they have important ports like Mangalore, Chennai, Surat, Kochi etc. connecting various countries for a long time to many European countries which were developed at doing business. That's the reason I think the eastern states aren't that 'rich'.
@Shashank Kumar Could you please tell me where you got such minute information? Your knowledge is history is impressive.
Very realistic solution to 3 language formula.
If north indian states start teaching other languages..it will help solve any doubts in minds of south Indians.
Let Sri Modi and Sri Amit Shaw speak in fluent Tamil and Telugu first and be exemplary.
If an UP guy is okay to learn Punjabi or Bihar with Bengali apart from Hindi + English, why not a Tamilian have a right to choose Malayalam as his third language? Or Malayalees for Kannada or Telugu?
Give the same choice to all Indians. One side, the policy says HINDI for South India and Choice for North Indians. This is what we call IMPOSITION.
This Happens only in India..... since 1947..... imposition of language must be absolutely dropped..... for so many years they have played word game
Being from Hindi place, I can say if Hindi is not taught compulsorily to south, it is good for Hindi states only.
All these years Hindi is national language has resulted in downfall of Hindi states only - UP, MP, Bihar, Rajasthan, Chatisgarh, Jharkhnd etc and ensured great progress only in non-Hindi states TN,Karnatak,Keral, AP, Punjab, Maharashtra, Gujarat etc.
There is a link between special status and this tragedy. Govt should withdraw and let English only be common throughout.
Suddenly Yogendra yadav is all over the media , what's happening?
No doubt, you don't see street 🐕 dogs now a days, may be they started taking human form and now you can find a ring leader here!! The scarf on the neck is probably the broken belt!!!
Veda Kumar - as he is now free of election duty he can appear in the news.
Its the TH-cam algorithm. Once you stop clicking on his videos TH-cam will stop recommending them.
Learning three languages is a severe burden for average students of South India . Hindi has no use for ninety five percent of South Indians. Teaching local language and English is more than adequate. People who want to learn other languages of their choice can learn them themselves. Why burden the students ? They need to learn math and science.
I wish all South Indian states fallow the lead of Tamilnadu. I want to hear all Indian languages in the parliament and aero planes just like you hear different languages in United Nations. We are in a technological era where translations can be provided .
YY reminds me of my old school teacher, very clear, very concise and too the point. He's a very charming person and I like him. Pls stop sledging him for no reason.
The manner in which hindi has been promoted over the last few decades, is what has done the most harm to hindi..... And ofcourse, if the hindi belt made some effort to learn some other language... Hindi would not invite the antipathy it does
Iam very much impressed by his views as he clarifies the language report in-depth, even common man can understand it. Thanks for uploading it.
Learning 4 languages between the age of2 to 8. What a tragedy for kids.
People have not given a thought to the victim of such policies
The kids!!
What
India has no history of torturing its children.LEARNING a third language is the perogative of the individual .
English and local language or the national language (any one of the above two) is enough
The indian education system is already a burden for the students
Intellectual vaccum of policy makers . very sad
No one questions, English bcuz it's a global language period. Whereas Hindi has no benefit whatsoever!
Agree that Hindi has no benefit outside a good portion of India other than on a social basis. Persons who go abroad and speak in Hindi in public international forums, just for the sake of speaking Hindi, defeat the goal of communication or the point of their speaking anything at all!
Because somenthing is being used globally, we should forget our history, culture, language. What kind of argument you are putting forward.
Chinese, Japanese, Europeans without speaking English are way more developed.
It's this slave mentality that still haunts India.
@@harshvardhansinha No one is telling you to forget your history.
My argument is that you stop imposing your culture, history and belief system onto others.
For my culture to thrive, all i need is Punjabi and similarly, keep Hindi for your culture. And let us communicate in English, like the South does.
@@harpreetsinghmann who is imposing bro. If Punjabi was spoken more widely in India as compared to Punjabi, I would have happily supported punjabi as a language taught all over India, because Punjabi is an Indian language and I will feel proud to speak Punjabi. But the truth is most of the Indians can speak Hindi, that why it was chosen to be taught all over India.
That's why this 3 language formula is appropriate. Anyday I would prefer Punjabi Tamil over English language
@@harshvardhansinha There are more Punjabi speakers on the otherside of the border.
I wouldn't support Punjabi to be taught in Kerala schools, when clearly they have their own language and they don't need it anyways.
Like YY said, how many people in hindi heartland are learning South Indian languages?!!
This time YY has got me confused. Why is he saying there is no imposition of Hindi? The draft does say that students in South will learn State language, plus English and Hindi. Whereas in the North, students will learn Hindi, English and any one language of choice. Why students in South not be given the same choice that is State language, English and any one language of choice? Let that choice be Hindi if they want to. Why compulsion?
4:16 "Preferably" South Indian Language. That is the issue, why can't it be "Compulsorily" South Indian language as it is for the Non-Hindi states which is Compulsorily Hindi.
@M T Knowing a South Indian language would be more beneficial for our NE brothers and sisters is what I feel, they are the best behaved lot here in South of India.
@surya gandla bro leave this MT guy. He is just consumed by the hatred for other region people. Leave north, these guys even hate neighbouring southern state like for eg. they hate karnataka for no reason.
Because of his hate, he has let go off his logic.
Hindi is understandable in most of the states, that's why it's being promoted.
Anyways leave them to their hate. That's why today Bengaluru (Karnataka), Hyderabad (Telangana) are prospering and these guys are going backward.
And kudos to you bro, for seeing the situation with open mind
Hindi is given importance cuz its spoken in the place where our capital city is located.... tomorrow if our capital city changes to Trivandrum, we'll malyalam in no time......
@M T : who said north indians don't learn south Indian languages? Go to any marwadi shop they all learn it......I am a north Indian but learnt to speak fluent Kannada. location of Capital city is important cuz government of our country operates from there. When we know our leaders sitting in Delhi Will only understand in Hindi, we learn it. All the paperwork of defense happens in Hindi or English from Delhi, that's why everyone in defence knows Hindi.
@M T : actually major reason for everyone to learn Hindi is cuz maximum number of government seats come from U.P....... and they dominate, easy! Next largest comes from m.p .. again dominate.....then bihar again hindi would be dominating.....it so happens that in these houses people end up conversing in Hindi..... so when we know our leaders can speak only Hindi then we learn it too.......
We non Hindi speakers been cheated,many of us have accepted the forumula,but why haven't the hindi belt states accepted?
People in Tamilnadu depend on Dhakshin Bharat Hindi Prachar Sabha for leaning Hindi. This organisation is fairly successful in southern states since early 1900s. Hindi is learnt as a extracurricular activity in Tamilnadu. Some persevere and complete all the 8 levels but majority would have done upto 4 level i.e.parichaya to rashtrabasha. Speaking hindi may be a challenge, but they are quite good in writing and usage of shuddh Hindi. It would be better if a similar organisation say - Bharatheeya Basha Prachar Samiti is formed. Each state can take responsibility to train other state language teachers as pracharak of their language. This informal learning methodology will succeed.
What the "Hindi Speaker" Yogendra Yadav is trying to side-step is this important issue.
A student from the Hindi belt is allowed to choose the third language.
A student from the South is given no such choice. He/she is FORCED to learn Hindi as per the three language policy. Had the policy been English + 2 languages OR English + Local + 1 language, WITHOUT forcing Hindi to be one of the compulsory languages, then and only then would it be a fair policy.
@Ganesh S He is saying that Hindi belt made a mockery by taking Sanskrit as the third language. Argues that there wouldn't have been anti-Hindi protests had the North opted for South Indian languages instead.
However, he still opines that the 3 language policy with English+Hindi+Third is good. He never says Hindi need not be one of the three languages.
A student in Tamil Nadu would be concerned whether he has choice in studying languages. He won't be too concerned whether ppl in Haryana are learning Tamil, as long as he has a choice in his curriculum.
@surya gandla మిత్రమా, నాకు డూడూడూ..బసవన్న, గాడిదె గుడ్డు అని మాట్లాడటం రాదు. నాకూ తెలుగు, అరవం, హిందీ, ఇంగ్లీషు మాట్లాడటంతో పాటు చదవటమూ రాయటమూ వచ్చు.
बात ये नही थी कि मेरे पास हिंदी पढ़ने का विकल्प है या नही। बात ये है कि क्या मेरे पास हिंन्दी या कोई और भाषा न पढ़ने का विकल्प है। केंद्र सरकार के 3 भाषा प्रस्ताव में हिंदी पढ़ना अनिवार्य था।
Regardless of the above point, in case of Telangana, the students had a choice of choosing two of the three languages Telugu, Urdu and Hindi , along with English (compulsory). So, if one wishes not to take Hindi, they could do it according to the state board rules.
I can speak , read, write, understand - Marathi , hindi nd English.... I live in Bhopal... My mother tongue is Marathi ,we speak in Marathi at home, outside hindi is language nd for global knowledge English is also important....
How many countries have Hindi as a National langauage?
The four main south Indian languages are very similar in sentence structure and words are also very similar. It is like similarity between Hindi and Punjabi OR Hindi and Marathi. The script is practically same between Telugu and Kannada. Other than languages of these 4 southern states, the language spoken in other parts of India, the sentence structure and spoken language are close to each other. Even the script is more or less similar. So broadly speaking there are 2 groups of languages in India. To ensure a equal treatment to all citizens, and considering promotion of unity of the country, all North Indians should necessarily learn one South Indian language and all South Indians should compulsorily learn any one of the North Indian language of his or her choice. Other than this there should be no compulsion to learn any one specific language. All citizens need to be treated equal; this will be the basic respect expected by all.
I don't have any hatred to Hindi or any other language. But my kids are forced to learn 3rd language as Hindi.
Completely agree with mr.yadav !!!
why burden a child with another subject to learn?. why this stupid 3language system?
THIS GUY IS A BHAIYYA AND HE IS BOUND TO SUPPORT HINDI. WE IN SOUTH NEVER ALLOW HINDI IN TAMILNADU. PERIYAR IS OUR HERO.
good for you...you will be left behind.. and most importantly isolated...
@@rahul077 Hindi speaking states are the poorer with low literacy and high infant mortality rates. The HDI in hindi speaking states is deplorable. Rather than teaching Hindi, please learn English. Only English culture and language will take India forward.
@@Email-mu1mv There is growing number of people who are going to ISIS from non-Hindi states. Is it because of their language? The English is anyway needed and practical to learn in Modern India. But Hindi is spoken by 54% of the Indian population. That's why it would enhance the opportunities among non-Hindi people to learn Hindi. Its more practical and fair.
@@sahayapurv Apurvanand Sahay Only 41% of population said their language is Hindi as per 2011 census. If population was the only determinant then Crow should be the national bird not Peacock and Rat should be the national animal not Bengal Tiger.
@@Email-mu1mv who's telling that hindi is the national language... It's the largest speaking population in India and it's 54% only. First check it
Hindi is given importance cuz our capital city is in a Hindi speaking belt.... tomorrow if our capital city changes to Trivandrum, in no time people would learn malyalam... today I can speak fluent Kannada cuz I am living here from so many years......
If you speak hindi you can use it is most of the states in North .but Tamil,Telugu,kannada is only usefull in the state they are spoken in.
@@atisanskari9814 : and why hindi should not be given importance? When maximum MPs MLAs MLCs come from hindi belt..... they work in Hindi...its easier for them.....
@@atisanskari9814 first learn one of the south language..
We will not learn Hindi..we then start learning our other South Indian language..
Three language policy is a huge burden on the students. Plus learning a third language is meaningless. India is a powerhouse in IT because of its english language. Hindi did not bring anything to this country. The three language policy is to discourage poor students from attending schools. I am surprised Yadav is so innocent, that he couldn't understand how Hindi is imposed on the students thru the back door. Unfortunately Tamils and kannadikas leaders are intelligent enough to understand the govt's tricks.Students cannot learn the language of their choice, they can only learn the languages provided by the school which ofcourse will be Hindi.
Good to hear 💐
If it was not imposition then why did they change, what did they change in that draft...
English is better than Hindi
Yeah and way better than tamil
@@harshvardhansinha being a telugu guy I prefer tamil than that stupid hindi
3:56 That's hindi imposition. Basically non hindi States don't get to chose any of the 3 languages. 1st language being State's language is obviously even for hindi states, 2nd language being English for es everyone is also obviously but hindi is the mandatory 3rd language for non hindi states whereas hindi states get to choose which language they want to be their 3rd language.
7:41 Because no non hindi Indian wants to fall behind in learning a language that even hindi Indians want their kids to learn for global success. Otherwise only hindi remains as the sole compulsory language & hindi being Indian can easily displace other Indian languages since they all have less political power than hindi.
8:14 English isn't the solution but those opposing English only see hindi as the solution & that's the problem. English is just a place holder, we'll need it as long as hindi is the only Indian language that's the official language of the Union.
9:06 If hindi is pre selected to be in the 3 language formula against the wishes of the states then it is making hindi mandatory across India & that's imposition. If hindi can also be an optional language in 3 language formula then it's obviously not a problem. Other than the State's own language the will be free to choose any of the 2 extra languages to be in their 3 language policy. Even English should be optional so no state can claim English is being imposed on them, they should be able to choose a different language if they want to.
Only one way to incentivize learning a particular language/group of languages. Make it advantageous in terms of marks scored. Maybe award bonus marks for studying a South Indian language if you're North Indian? Penalize (in terms of marks) the study of Sanskrit?
Good content, liked the anchor the way she conducted herself too.
Good information.
ENGLISH IS THE LINK LANGUAGE. IT WILL BE OUR NATIONAL LANGUAGE ONE DAY.
don't worry, we will never have national language. not now, not ever :)
Whatever he says yogendra is a frog of raining season :)
Respect all language don't impose
जय हिंद जय भारत
Imposition of Hindi has made
our country more fragmented than before. North Indians at the expense of state exchequer are trying to promote it shamelessly knowing well that other non hindi people are always at disadvantage when it comes to employment. Hindi is just like another regional language and it should be left to flow it’s own course rather than rush. Promotion of Hindi should be left to Bollywood which is doing great job in promoting it.
I don't know what the big deal in this.I studied in english medium and hindi & Gujarati were taught as second language.nobody had any problem.
I have observed that south Indians have learnt hindi but north Indians are not interested in learning south Indian languages. In fact most of the north Indian call every south Indian as Madrasi. My suggestion is that every student should learn at least three Indian languages and one foreign language other than English.
Why foreign language when u got 22 other languages in our country???
Good one!
I'm from Tamil Nadu..
Why I should learn Hindi...
Why I have no choice of Telugu,kannada,Malayalam...
It's called imposing
He doesnt have any idea what he is speaking .. Hindi already has a special treatment .... In what language do you think flight safety instruction between two cities in south India ?
I am a tamizhan.... Every private school in Tamil nadu teaches hindi.... It's the rich who gets globalized and its only the poor who are forced to become the torchbearers of Tamil identity....
So that these politicians can avoid real issues and instigates Tamil sub nationalism for another 70 years... I don't know much hindi... I wish I knew... A whole myriad of opportunities would have opened up for me.
And every Hindi speaking north Indian wish he could know English. I don't think Hindi would have created any opportunity. Only English matters in our country.
@@divyanshushankar8134 I agree with you.. But let me tell you... That I have travelled extensively through out the country.... And i am still astonished that how people speaking hindi had become prevalent even in remote areas of north east... Not everyone know English... And certainly no one knows tamil as far as i have travelled ...
I hate being that guy who is fucking clueless when people make jokes and plans... And also a burden that everyone has to translate everything for me in English...
But I wouid make sure my children couid speak equally good English and Hindi apart from Tamil....
As 80 percent population can speak hindi... So its not a question about linguistic identity but linguistic utility.
Actually more language u learn more intelligent u become. In my state West Bengal once communist party removed English from syllabus, now most of the Bengalis who passed from Bengali medium have a problem in understanding or speaking in English. Though hindi isn't present in the syllabus but since it has influence of neighborhoring state like Bihar and has sizeable Urdu or hindi speaking population they atleast understand hindi. The problem of this removal of English is so massive that now an extreme low income people also aspire to admit his children in a private English medium school rather than a good government school.
The Tamils who remain in the state or atleast roam in southern states won't face any problem rather those Tamils who go out to of South India will face problem because local people here knows their own language or could understand hindi. Most of low educated people doesn't know English. But on the contrary those north indian who probably done engineering and goes to Chennai or Bangalore doesn't face such problem because they already can speak English.
For me the draft is much required because such a linguistically diverse country like us, people needs to understand atleast 3 languages and u could rather not choose hindi and could choose Telegu as 3rd language being a Tamil. Those of ur south indian politician who says learning or just understanding hindi means it will take the place of ur own language r actually talking shit because there r somany languages in rest of India, no one is replacing their own mother language with hindi
@@plt7915 I know dude... The irony is that people still keep falling for that same old agenda... I have no problem learning Hindi... It's just the politicians whose own children learn Hindi.
I hv south friends who worked with me in Mumbai who did very well. They were not really discriminated. But yes, like u said, they could hv lost out on the jokes tht were cracked in Hindi in the social circle...
The only compulsory thing should be to teach any one Indian language different than your own. Other than that, there should be complete freedom to teach whatever other languages you want to teach.
How many teachers r there in each state to teach 22 scheduled languages. Tn follows 2 language policy. We can't burden ourself for someone's politics.
5:07 says no special status to Hindi,, Mr Yogendra this policy says non hindi States should learn hindi, then what does this mean, please grow up and then speak..
He is the man of facts.. that's what I like in him
Children from 1st to 5 th class should be taught 6 languages.
One North Indian,
One South Indian,
One West Indian,
One East Indian,
Sanskrit,
English.
Little bit of basics of
Mathematics,
Physics.
The rest he will learn from the 6th onwards.
Ya fuck maths, science, social and fuck his career for good
Well, Indianess is all about diversity so even if your comment is in a sarcastic tone it's not wrong. Most Europeans can speak at least four languages.
@@Pseudoswami
Observe the quality of the language!! Perhaps who knows only one or two!!
Isn't there scope for improvement?
For the matter of learning and inculcating the aptitude to learn maths, science, history & geography, including Sanskrit language is the most apt for the overall development. It's structure is like mathematics (of blocks of matrices, cryptography, etc.); it is based on concrete rules and has many texts on logic & laws; it's epics are about history, geography, politics and philosophy; yoga and Ayurveda is about better health (health is indeed wealth) and about cleanliness of body and mind.
We Tamil people don't want Sanskrit too..
@@unexpected7948
Westerners have brain washed tamilians so that they will hate Sanskrit and love English. Their intent was to convert them to Christianity.
Innocent tamilians have fell into their trap and still not come out of it.
The fact is that Sanskrit itself is modified extract from Tamil, Prakrit etc.
Siva the Primeval God of Tamil who created the Tamil language is himself the author of Sanskrit, which was created to be used in science.
#stophindiimposition #ಹಿಂದಿಹೇರಿಕೆನಿಲ್ಲಿಸಿ
I don't understand what's the big fuss around Hindi. I think south Indians should learn Hindi while north Indians should learn Tamil/Telugu/Kannada/Malayalam/Tulu, etc. This would simply help us to interact with each other better and also increase our work opportunities. There are too many things dividing us let's not make language one of the issues that divide us but it should unify us. Totally agree with Yogendra on this issue.
What is tulu?
@@hafeexius You dont even know what is tulu and you are trying to impose Hindi on us. Just see how aware the northies are ! No respect for others.
@@prashanthb6521 how do you know he is trying to impose Hindi on you ? The desperation of being offended is too much!. The policy was given by the committee on the second day of the Minister's tenure. Even before he reads it TN's political parties start shouting. They have consistently clarified that nothing will be imposed!. But that does not work in the politics of South.
Instead of learning South Indian languages, it is better to read ABOUT these languages and have a holistic overview of the dravidian culture.
Why south Indians should learn Hindi? What about Marathi, Bengali, Rajasthani, Punjabi??
😆😆😆 yogendra yadav i don't think you have any credibility left
Roopesh Kumar He is talking valid point. Just because he opposes BJP doesn’t mean he is not putting valid points.
The document is silent on common school system.
Learning a language as minimum basic day to day conversation like ordering in hotel buying vegetables etc are sufficient rather than as a script learning n marks as a scholar. Its useless after all u cant speak the language but vomited n passed out of it for marks n forget it? So usage is required n few useful sentences thats it. No need of this extensive classroom teaching. Arrogance n pride aspect will be gone as its extremely easy to learn basic language n u will be a fool if u dont do that n pressure will be there from locals.
Dont fix what is not broken..
At last Dr YY started talking sense instead of his boring monologues...
Whether you are a hindi speaker or non hindi speaker, you should know that we will always be English slaves because our policy makers since independence always tried to impose English on every citizen for helping few percentage of elite population.
Always keep in mind that policies will be in favour of those people who are in power or those who controls that power.
We people are only for vote so that they can call it a democratic process.
I was born in hindi background, completed my school in hindi medium and did engineering.
And now i am not fluent in any of these.
@Ganesh S stop this bullshit Hindi is spoken by more people than English, English has become lingua Franca due to dominance of English speaking country.
@@MAN-jz6qc There is a difference between a global language and a mother tongue. Why Indians are so successful in West? One of the reasons is that we are fluent in the language and hence, can assimilate our ourselves. Hindi isn't a global language. Moreover, around 49 percent of Indians have Hindi as their mother tongue but because of this all other non-Hindi speaking states are forced to learn it too. Yes, it helps in communication around India but don't impose it. Moreover, you can't replace English with Hindi because English is a globally more recognised. Mandarin in few years may become the new global language and in today's world, it is better to be fluent in global languages rather than Hindi.
@Ganesh S And English is forced by South indians on us north indians we don't need to learn English if it weren't you we would have been fine with Hindi stop force imposition of English on us.
@@JasleenKaur-io1us Actually you are an idiot Hindi is the most spoken language in the world if you include Urdu and let's not forget countries such as Nepal and Bangladesh who have credible fluency in Hindi, no langauge has as much reach as Hindi so please stop bullshit of global languages, I don't know why we even need to learn English we should instead promote our own indian languages and make them lingua Francas around like English or french due to this attitude hindi isn't recognised as official language in UN due to our own neglect, and indians becoming successful in West doesn't help India anyway.
@Ganesh S And do you remember what novjot singh siddhu said about you, that he doesn't have anything in common with you madrasis and you say they respect you how hypocritical, I think you black madrasis have short-term memory loss problem.
now a days you can learn any language from you tube. i learnt tamil but practicing it is a problem.
Govind Indurkar hello govind, which TH-cam channel you used to learn tamil ? My husband is looking for one.
Nadhiya S type tamil leaning on you tube.there are many vedios,but there are some 75 lessons by Mr.subbaiah which are very scientific.
With the rise of Tamil nationalism and freebyism, TN will soon go bankrupt. Students from TN have to learn Hindi. That'll help them to find some jobs like table-cleaning iin the hotels In the Northeast or running idli shops in UP.
Otherwise, they have to learn some basic conversational skills like कहाँ, कैसे and some sentences like the ones that goes like 'अल्लाह/भगवान के नाम पे....'
The number of hindi speakers actually doing this shit job is more and cleaning the dumps and so keep your racism to yourself and look at your own backyard we aren't the ones who are asking for central fund for building toilets
@@Gladiator-dg4qzEveryone except students of TN are having some basic ability to converse in Hindi. The TN govt is forcing not-that-well-to-do students to not learn any other language they would need (except for Urudu for a particular community). This is forcing many of them to be underemployed.
Also, the Tamil nationalism/separatism is on the rise, who are the real racists that wants all positions held by non-Tamil speakers (including you guys) to be stripped off (including other south Indians). Even if I wipe out the sympathy towards them, many business owners and scholars would leave the state. That'll make even more TNers unemployed. I feel learning a language other than Tamil, especially Hindi could help them in not electing such racists; or at least flind some jobs outside if such parties are elected to power.
Note: I may sound harsh. But my intention is not to abuse any people group. 3-4 years ago, I had a different opinion on this.
Why should the 3rd language be Hindi in non-hindi state, it could be any as well.
This by itself says there are other plans, Hindi is not a national language and needs no special status period.
@surya gandla btw, I too took 3rd Lang as Hindi and can read, write can't speak.
My point is all Lang are equal under the Constitution and let's keep it that way, anyone who requires Hindi for job by or business plz learn it by all means.
Just don't do a blanket enforcement.
Hindi is not the problem here, the politics behind it is.
You are failing to see what will happen if everyone learns Hindi - Hindi will replace English and local languages will lose all support and prominence.
If you are ok will Telegu becoming a dead language in a few decades by all means support it. These are very long term plans.
Can you show how many north Indians (excluding businessmen settled there) in Bangalore or Hyderabad learnt the local language beyond a few essential words.
Just for the record, no one on Tamilnadu hate Hindi , we too learn it if required.
@surya gandla Can u write iitjee, ibps, ssc, lic, rbi, aai, hpcl, etc in telugu even though if central govt job is in Ap/Telangana. But Hindian can in Ap/Telangana.
Given that Education policy has been sabotaged by North - Hindi imposition is absolutely a right allegation, it’s what will actually happen irrespective of what the letter and spirit of the policy. There is no smoke without Fire. These are the reasons I disagree with Yogendra Yadav. The proof of the pudding is after 70+ years which language has been pushed and spoken widely? What % of South India speak Hindi versus % that North Bharat speak any South Indian language?
why telgu in haryana sir ?? Haryana is part of punjabi civilisation so why cant punjabi be taught in haryana as third language ??
because of dispute between punjab and haryana..then haryana cm introduced telugu as third language instead of punjabi..he didnt want people to learn punjabi..in recently only haryana introduced punjabi as third language...
After anti curruption,psephology & agriculture
Ab ye banda language expert ban gya,nxt he will be discussing repo rates
Because he is a professor of CSDS worked with Tata Institute of Social Sciences(TISS), LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS (LSE) travelled across the country to understanding the problems of farmers and attracted the hon'ble supreme court attention on droughts , not just a entire political science degree holder , just winning a election can't erase all the issues
He was member of UGC, Member of National Advisory Council on Right to Education, Member of NCERT. Same thing he mentions about shallow thinking today, check basic facts man
@@avrdxjaihindsatymev acha to yeh gamcha liberal salim TISS ka padha hain
Ok then what supreme court did?
Winning a election,really two consecutive single party majority in india
His TISS qualification will help him discussing REPO rates next
BTW if u hv doubt on modi degree,file a PIL
@@pratik756001 read again I have mentioned a range of his work,next I'm guessing he will discuss REPO rates
NAC was a council which undermined PMO & this "Democrat" was a member
@@Akashkumar-oi7qt again shallow knowledge Akash. NAC led by Sonia Gandhi, and NACRTE (National Advisory Council on Right to Education) are completely different bodies with no relation to each other.
Each child can learn 4 languages easily. He is smoking the same thing modi smokes before Mann ki baat.
OK don't count Odisha in North India then..
Study Sumerian.
जाती, धर्म, देश की तरह भाषा भी एक थोपी हुई चीज है और किसी को, किसी एक को भी जबरदस्ती कोई भाषा पढ़ाने की कोशिश की जाती है तो ये मूर्खता और दुष्टता है।
Why does anyone take this guy seriously
I hope north Indians should learn south Indian languages coz majority UP, Bihar, Rajasthani, Gujarati's are working in bank , railways and doing business and selling pakoda, toys, etc. Specially in Karnataka I have seen lot of hindi speaking people leading their life without learning local language (more then 10 years) , and they are creating more problems. Most of our youths are not getting job coz of centralised exam system which is only in Hindi and English. No central govt are concerned about south Indians , they treat us like second class citizen
Hindi is not mandatory to learn in order to give central govt. exams. If you think people from the so called 'hindi belt' states don't have their own regional languages and don't face any problems when they go to another state, then you are a highly ignorant person. No one is taking anyone's job. Work hard and you'll do well in life. Bashing people from other states is not going to solve any problem.
@@prak_art_i Yes Hindi is not mandatory but why they are not giving space to regional language's in every central govt exams. We are working hard no doubt in it. And our states have more potential of growth and also we accept u all as our family thsts why u all getting job in our state but what govt doing to us ? I hope u can't understand ground problems what we are facing. We are not hating Hindi but u should learn our language and respect culture. If u really hard working and compitent then learn our language and work who will oppose u. Even we have tolerated people from years those who without learning our regional languages.
@@prak_art_i Learn Kannada Prakriti, its a very beautiful language. You will leave Hindi after that ! It is a classical lang, very old, unlike Hindi which is a mishmash of many languages, it has no identity of itself nor does it have the depth of our languages !!!
@@prak_art_i exactly, the literate people of South think that all north Indians can speak and write in Hindi which is far from truth. They even tag Gujarat in Hindi belts sometimes!
@@prashanthb6521 yeah sure but u should also learn Bengali. After all a Bengali poet is the only noble prize winner in literature. It's a beautiful and sweet language.
I am a malayali, truly glad that I studied Malayalam, English and Hindi in school
I wonder why is Yogendra Yadav the only expert for you guys. Such programmes can only pave the way for Modi' s third term in 2024.
He was talky sense here, can you even listen before criticizing.
I hate Hindi
Sorry
No document directly says "Hindi should be imposed in south India",it indirectly says south Indian students should learn hindi along with their mother tongue and english
What's the problem with hindi??
I am a tamizhan.... Every private school in Tamil nadu teaches hindi.... It's the rich who gets globalized and its only the poor who are forced to become the torchbearers of Tamil identity....
So that these politicians can avoid real issues and instigates Tamil sub nationalism for another 70 years... I don't know much hindi... I wish I knew... A whole myriad of opportunities would have opened up for me.
@@roopesh4769 .. no problem with hindi... It's just the way it is being imposed on non hindi speakers like me which is the problem
@@roopesh4769
Bro its simple.
Bimaru Politicians Both Bjp and Congress deny Tamil, Kannada, Bengali, Punjabi in every union govt exams and services just to promote Hindi. Then wtf we hav to prefer or learn ur Hindi.
They Deny Tamil just to force Hindi.
We prefer English just to deny Hindi. Karma
Ask Indian Govt to be Multilingual
Before u ask us to be Multilingual.
What is this big fuss over languages. Language is only tool to communicate no more no less. Some languages die and some come in prominence. Language is ever-changing thing not permanent. No language is spoken same as some dacades ago. This is no more than shallow politics.
Tell that to Telugu and Bengali people. Tell that to a Bihari whose accent is mocked everywhere in India as if everyone is a pundit in Hindi or English.
@@divyanshushankar8134 with this many people living in country there will be some bigots that don't mean everyone is bad. And one cannot force them to learn or unlearn anything. But as per my opinion languages are overrated to be proud of. Its our values and our content of our character that one should proud of.
Rassi jali par ainthan ni gayi
Tushar Tripathi Kia baat ki rassi , he is putting logical points .
@@732anoop bhakto ko palle nai padhta , dey eat gobar and drink mutra which is COW waste hehhe.Their IQ is below COW level , hence easily tamed by Modi
@@sourabhsiitg its better than being a padha likha chutiya 😂😂
Aap log padh likh ke aaloo daal sona nikalna ,ni sbke liye sab kuch free kar ke desh ko venezuela bana dena . Mai sirf mehnat mei vishwas rakhta hu.
Yogendra yadav is himself sabotaged...
Jokers :)
The lady is simply not comfortable !! Just saying,
Lack of understanding about the topic is very visible.
yaarrr ask him to wear proper dress, he is purposefully wearing the dheati dress to seem like a villager but he is not
ENGLISH + Regional lang is enough.
English = Primary language of India !!!
Get out of your villege and you'll understand why we need a common language... Every other country in the world has that, except for us. 💩💩
Pseudo Prophet Looks like your iq has dropped too low attending RSS shakhas. Grow a pair of grey cells and read my comment again. English is our common language. Period. If you don't agree get lost to Pakistan. Sanghi idiots !
@@prashanthb6521 A foreign Language as the Supreme Language is acceptable but not an Indian language?
Rahul Ray Hindi is also foreign !!!!
The British are now part of our history. If you still think English is foreign, then go and get your head checked. Because you and sanghis offlate have truck loads of hate for all unnecessary and small stuff. All the while doing hypocrisy in your personal lives. Mfking hypocrite goondas you sanghis are !
Practical considering the future of the world.
why should anyone learn three languages!!!...there is so much science and tech coming these days that we should focus on learning them, rather wasting time in learning three languages.
In my opinion, only two languages are more than enough. Learn your regional language and English.
No one learns tech in primary schools ..
We need to protect our culture.. English can't be made supreme language of India
@@PseudoProphet science and tech has a broad meaning..there are important subjects that kids have to read other than languages.
And CULTURE is nothing but a political tool to deceive people. People need skills, jobs, good standard of living and they should not be wasting time and resources in learning extra languages.
Is there any country in the world that doesn't have a common language? 🤔🤔
I don't think so.
Pseudo Prophet well India is not like any other country and Our nation is an amalgamation of many cultures. Please read more on our country and then speak
So what is your idea? To divide ? Or to to fine those who don't learn Hindi ?
@@hkp1450 to teach them Hindi, how is that dividing, that's uniting.
At least read what you're saying. 🙄🙄
@@concernedIndianCitizen there are several other countries like us... For example Nigeria... Stop fooling yourself by thinking we're special.
@@PseudoProphet
Belgium - 3 official languages.
Swiss and Singapore - 4 official languages.
English local language and Sanskrit must be
compulsory
No doubt, you don't see street 🐕 dogs now a days, may be they started taking human form and now you can find a ring leader here!! The scarf on the neck is probably the broken belt!!!
Why Sanskrit
We want Tamil..
He is a propagandist Of BJP, Modi & Shah. Very weird & biased views. This man always misleading the public & making mockery of a democracy.
🙏
Kitna time hai is bande k paas....har jagah pahuncha rehta hai
He is speaking plain truth. If north indians don't like it then it just exposes there biased view
shashi soni
बक बक कर नोट छाप रहा है ये भाजपा व मोदी/शाह का ये दलाल ! शिक्षा योजना केवल मोदी का एक छलावा है पहले हिंदी आएगी ख़ासकर दक्षिण मे की वहाँ जनता इनके नफ़रत भरे भाषण सुन सके और जातियों व धर्मों मे तनाव पैदा कर सकें केवल दक्षिण के ही राज्य हैं जहं इन मक्कारों की नहीं चली क्योंकि वे शिक्षित लोग हैं !
This guy doesn't have a job
But how does he go around giving free ka Gyan to everyone ???
Does anyone know from where he gets his money ?
Blue Sky He gives good analysis
Yogendra Yadav has no credibility left after poll results. Find someone who talks sense.
Regardless of his poll result, he is more capable than many of our current MPs of looking at things from an educated and informed position. So please recognise and respect that. Demonising the intelligent is a definite way to build a country full of fools.
@@BharathKumarIyer 'I want to grab people by collar in my constituency for voting BJP and tell them "you idiots"
- educated and informed Yogendra Yadav🤷
dr nayk You are putting just a part of it and in a wrong interpretation , if you would have heard the whole thing he said wrong thing would have to just say what you wrote but then he puts the main point why people voted for Modi and he gave good reasons for it.
@@732anoop I watched the whole video bro. There is nothing that justifies saying that. He concluded he misread people.
@@SuperDravin he was putting it in a frustrated tone. What is your social intelligence?
Don't worry tamilians are going to get outdated anyway..
Your point is factually wrong. Tamil Nadu boasts economic and intellectual superiority.
The four main south Indian languages are very similar in sentence structure and words are also very similar. It is like similarity between Hindi and Punjabi OR Hindi and Marathi. The script is practically same between Telugu and Kannada. Other than languages of these 4 southern states, the language spoken in other parts of India (broadly North India) the sentence structure and spoken language are close to each other. Even the script is more or less similar. So broadly speaking there are 2 groups of languages in India. To ensure a equal treatment to all citizens, and considering promotion of unity of the country, all North Indians should necessarily learn one South Indian language and all South Indians should compulsorily learn any one of the North Indian language of his or her choice. Other than this there should be no compulsion to learn any one specific language. All citizens need to be treated equal; this will be the basic respect expected by all.
Actually, broadly speaking there are 3 groups. North east gets forgotten as always. In NE there are many languages which are more Chinese / east Asian than Indian with much less to do with Sanskrit / Tamil etc. (Assamese an exception) and within themselves have a lot of diversity. In fact if you include dialects, NE has as much diversity as rest of the India combined.
I am from MH and I also kind of fill central India serves as an invisible buffer between this north v south war of words ;)
nice
- though the vocabulary of southern languages has large portion of distinct words - our sentence structure is also very similar to that of Hindi and other northern languages - ie where the subject, object , verb are in a sentence -
it seems a joke..no one from south would opt for a language other than hindi from north indian languages as the rest of the north languages are irrelevant when considered individually..and hindi stands the most suitable..while languages from south mainly the 4 languages are equally classic and prevailing..though tamil claims an upper hand.
i would say..english is must..any other language or languages preffered are appreciated..
Anas Thayyil :: Yes, probably, you could be right. At least, it will give a ego satisfaction to South Indians that they could have their choice rather than being “compelled “ .