Well, I think the reason the whole audience is quite supportive, other than the fact that most of them understand what she's been through, is also because most of them are performers, or someone who've lived through that world, and they're aware how sometimes, shit happens which prevented you from performing your best
People be acting like the panic attacks are just something so easy to deal with . SHE had a PANIC ATTACK before the performance that mean she couldnt breath well and u can hear her voice was shaking . U can hear that at the end of lytlm her voice got so much better .plus the second song was live but the music was a little bit more powerful than lytlm that's why it looks like it wasnt live . Give her a break she has so much good performances than bad ones . she has a soft sweet voice and i love it .
@@nora1423 no it´s not, she was really dissapointed because in her stories of the rehearsals she was doing it really good, but before going to the stage she had a PANIC ATTACK and that´s why her voice, hands, legs were shaking!
The panic attack was fake, Selenators on twitter admitted they faked that rumour so she wouldn’t get a lot of backlash from sounding ‘bad’ she may have been nervous which is why she might have been shaking/sounded shaky but the panic attack rumour was false
as someone that has seen her perform “sober” and “revival remix” at her tour I almost don’t recognize her on this performance, that’s why I believe that she gets so nervous singing to general public but she is so comfortable singing for fans on tour, and it’s where her voice definitely shines better
@@sigh.xxohoe6361 That's the only noteworthy part of the performance though. Everything else is basic af. (And even the C#5 isn't really that impressive at all, it's not really a high note for a mezzo like Selena)
As someone who’s been to her concert I can confirm she can sing. She’s not the worst singer but she’s also not the best singer. She’s way better than what you’d expect.
@@micha-estla6860 lol ITS A CONCERT RIGHT? IF u went to her concert u would now that she was singing live. Nobody goes and lip syncs at their concerts trust me.
The audio in the TV were different from the audio in the audience Unfortunately, all the videos were erased She had a little problem with the return, she wasn't hearing her in the beginning, but they corrected after, and of course, this was a really emotional for her, and I'm glad she made it through And your reaction were incredible, thanks for that
Thank you for understanding her. I know she is not the best world singer but she has a beautiful voice and on this performance it didn't go well because she was very nervous. Most people are very hard on her when it comes to singing.
After Watching "Selena Gomez: My Mind And Me" , this performance makes me cry. She's been through a lot. A lot of people in the comments are complaining that she can't sing, she's a "manufactured pop star'', she just makes excuses, she's a drug addict and was drunk that night, please just go and watch the documentary. The comment section just disgusts me. I hope Selena gets better and have a happy life cause she deserves the whole world. ❤
You should react to Taylor Swift - I did something bad American music awards . Its the best performance she ever done. Very dramatic and vocally 10/10.
I get people who are tired of the excuses with her voice but as someone who has panic attacks and anxiety it so makes a difference. I can sing better through any physical injury than I can when I’m anxious. Your throat locks up and it’s hard to speak and that’s definitely what’s going on here. I think she gets anxious during high pressure performances- her low pressure performances are always really great to watch. She’s not the best but it’s not even about that. I love her voice and her music. I kinda wish she’d turn down a lot of these big things but she’s probably contractually obligated to do them
Trust me, I know. If I'm comfortable and relaxed and belts notes just fine and keep the tone and pitch of the notes going smoothly. On the other hand, if I'm highly upset and try, it's like I lose my breath control and not only am I off key, I can't belt at all.
After I experience panic attacks I normally try sing to make myself calm but I will admit i cannot sing after panic attacks so I feel her if it was me I wouldnt have been able to go up
Selena can sig very well when she’s comfortable, but when she gets nervous it’s another story She can make great vocal notes in studio or small concerts, when she’s not experiencing anxiety Love her ❤️
Wow you are a classy lady, so respectful, so graceful. So professional of you to give your opinion and to be honest and be professional and to be kind and objective and positive and give advices and be constructive! You are the best!!!
I havent seen alot of selena’s performance. As an artist if she messed it up. Ok. Everyone has bad days. I sort of kind of maybe understand. But if she needs to slay the next performance. She needs to slay it harder than ever. Thats what artist do.
I'm really happy that you didnt judge this performance in a negative way. That you were honest and paying attention to what was going on with her at the moment. Dont think it's nice that people have laughed or made fun of that performance. Shes human too and it was an emotional song to sing in the first place given the personal content.
Selena was contractually obliged to make this presentation. She is a conatora who is very hateful and has health problems that make everything worse, on the day she suffered a terrible panic attack, she was given 2 pills of clonazepam (a remedy similar to anxiety and a strong sedative) and orbigated her up to the stage! there are sources who confirm that she was forced to take the drugs and take the stage by contract already signed. The remedy in question really freed her from anxiety and panic attack, but at this dose for an immediate response, it leaves the person sleepy and with little control of movements, there is a case that this dose is sufficient for the coma. In patients with low drug resistance.
I'm not sure why her fans have to keep mentioning her health issues. I am also a fan of selena's but just cause she has health issues doesnt negate the fact that it affects the quality of her voice. She doesn't sound good live. End of story
@@kittykatsanchez she does if she isn't nervous. We keep mentioning it because it's the cause of some of her bad performances. I, as a singer, a fan of Selena and as a person who suffers from mental health issues, it really makes a difference when you're anxious
The reason why I can’t take her serious is because I feel like there’s always an excuse or a reason as to why she’s always sub par when it comes to live performances or concerts even ! I love her music don’t get me wrong ! I feel like many artist have anxiety / panic attacks but still put their best foot foward , put on a show and put on an amazing show ! I feel like Selena needs to grow as a person and artist! I wish her nothing but love and success 💕
Sebastian Montes De Oca imagine every time, no matter how well you do ppl go on twitter saying that negative things about your voice. I assure you that when she’s on tour, with ppl that she knows that love her, she delivers a whole different attitude, revival tour is an exemple of that
@@gui1627 that doesnt happen to singers who can sing (find me one good or amazing singer who has been tarnished for their live performances). Therefore dont blame the people who are sick of a person gaining millions on a job she has no talent for.
you were so nice, ive been a Selena Gomez fan since her disney show wizards of waverly place. but we’ve all know, for a whole, she cannot sing live. she can’t. she never could. but that’s okay bc she’s still successful, she’s kind, we know she’s talented. i think it always had to do with health issues. or maybe just lack of training? but she could never sing live.
I agree she was so successful in disney that no matter what music she releases it would sell... So that's the path she went on.. But she's now releasing less vocally demanding music than her older days so maybe she can do better soon
Anxiety/depression is serious man. And I know from personal experience that it can incapacitate you... I haven’t been able to even get out of the house to go work, shop or eat for over 6 months. If she was really having an Attack before the performance, I’m surprise she didn’t just cancel; I know I would never be able to even get out of a room unaided if it happened...
Thank you so much for being nice and understanding. As you said, it was a very emotional moment for her, and that definitely had an effect on her voice. Moreover, there were technical issues during her performance of Loose You To Love Me, so she couldn’t hear herself, but they fixed them during Look At Her Now, that’s why she started to sound better. Billboard confirmed this on an article, so I’m not making it up hahahaha. Anyways, it’s nice to see you understand what happened, since almost everybody else just made fun of her.
ButeraVids c’mon. she can’t sing live and never coul. are you gonna write whole paragraphs like this ab what went wrong and why she didn’t sound good, but it wasn’t her fault... for every. single. performance? i’ve loved her since wowp but i always knew she couldn’t sing live. but it’s okay. she’s still kind, makes good music, is talented as hell, and beautiful.
having social anxiety myself, I could feel the panic she was feeling while performing, if u watch the revival tour performances she was in a way better state of mind and she sounds so much better
I’m suffering with panick attacks too, someone with this condition should know their strenght and ability but whatever. I feel for her but guys, why all of us suddenly pretend like Selena could ever sing? She was almost always like this. Come on.
I feel like she's just very anxious in front of an audience because she seems to not be at her best very often when in front of audiences, but when she sings live in a private or small venue she sounds really good
Then she should have chosen a different job lmao. A surgeon can't have any excuses for bad performances either or else people will literally die. And in Selena's case people's ears die
She was so nervous and had a break down and she was affected but lupus so and yall cant tell me you will not be hella nervous after not performing for 4 years
I literally almost cried seeing this, cause you can just see and hear, that she's exhausted and nervous. You can see, that she's had a rough time before the performance and the fact that she still went out and tried her best is admirable. Selena is not the best singer in the world but she can sing and everyone who says otherwise is just straight up lying!
Selena needs company, when She alone and everyone looking at her she was absolutely nervous and her voice shaking, When the dancers came out you can see that she's comfortable it's like in her own concert with the fans and the dancers
After watching her documentary ‘my mind and me’… I understood what was she going through My respect for this performance and this woman is indescribable
Selena Gomez can sing, her music is good. I will say she’s way better in concert and in studio. Live TV performances aren’t her thing, I think the pressure gets to her and there’s quite a many people that just have stage fright like that. She also had a panic attack and knowing everything she’s gone through she was understandably nervous.
I feel like most haters dont understand the pain she went through, and sending her more hate won't help, she scared to sing live cause she think if she mess up she will get more hate then she already gets, maybe Instead of sending hate send her love and support. and maybe u will get a better performance❤
Let me turn this around: I feel like most of her fans dont understand that going through stuff doesnt affect talent and that she is playing a victim. Most singers went through worse shit and sing like angels (Adele, MJ, Whitney and Ariana to name a few). And if she is so "nervous and panicy" she then simply isnt made for this job. After 13/14 years of singing she should be used to concerts by now. She sang even before Justin and her health issues (that she caused with all the drugs and alcohol anyway), and she even then had no talent. She isnt innocent. She was part of the problem too. You are only dismissing it because women are angels even if they abuse a partner apparently. This coming from a woman as well.
Here’s some thing about this performance you should know. 1. There was an audio issue, there is a video from someone in the audience where she sounds great. 2. This was her first performance in years, considering it’s in front of huge celebrities and being broadcasted to millions of people she was definitely nervous which explains it all. 3. She posted on her Instagram a week prior (she was in rehearsals) and she sounded amazing (she was also crouched over which makes it harder to sing and she still was hitting all the notes) 4. Idk if this was confirmed but it was rumoured she had a panic attack before the show. This was not a good performance but it’s understandable why it wasn’t very good.
There is always something. Selena's performances are 90% bad. But it's never her fault. Either she was sick or nervous or there was a technical issue etc. Interesting.
They’re always saying it’s a “panic attack”. She can’t perform live. She’s proved this time & time again & the excuses are always rolling in. People are acting like she’s never been in front of huge celebrities. She IS a huge celebrity. She’s been performing for years. It wasn’t good.
I felt like she sounded fine as she kept going, but when you only have 4 minutes you can't really be warming it up in that first minute or so. Lol. But yeah, in all fairness she hasn't performed on TV in years. I wish she had done more promo for the album, but hey, it's number 1 nonetheless and the album is fantastic. But this was clearly nervous, which I get.
people always make excuses for Selena when she gives a performance. Just say what you’re all thinking...she isn’t that great live, period. She sounds good on the record and that’s the only place we should hear her.
She's not the best singer. No one will say that. She's also had lots of bad live performances since her lupus started effecting her health. But she's also had amazing performances in the past such as her revival tour when she was at a point where she was just a tier below Demi or Ariana and looked promising as a live singer. Her style isn't fit for live performances either but during that time she was going for higher notes and a bigger vocal range. The fact that she doesn't sing in her normal voice also has a huge effect on that. But all that aside in this AMA performance she had a panic attack before her first performance which also had insufficient time for practicing the routine. And her live studio instrumental performances since this let down performance have been solid. Hopefully she can get healthy soon and be back at that revival level but she isn't as bad as people make her out to be and especially not as a singer overall (so if you count her work outside of live crowd performances). Also you do know this is a well respected professional vocal coach who's video you commented on right?
she had a panic attack, she was about to cry on the first song, she is very strong when she went out to sing with that state, even if she has tweeted, the bank to death because she is an incredible woman♥️
DISCLAIMER: I am not trying to send hate to Selena, it's just my opinion. I think it's time to stop excusing Selena. She can't sing and that's the truth. She always uses her mental health (or being emotional) as an excuse for her awful performances while there are other artists like Ariana Grande or Demi Lovato struggling with mental issues as well and they never sound awful when they perform. She has more failed performances than good ones, that clearly means something. /:
There is no way someone like selena who take a lot of vocal learning but she did not improve the problem is her mental is weak,,,, try understand that.
@@user-xo2vi5eu7v not an excuse at all , let take Billie eilish for example , she doesn't sing high notes often ( lwk like Selena LWK selena can't hit high notes) , anyways , Billie has mental issues since she was 15 but she still nail her live performances she literally does not wrong note she's always on pitch she has never sounded awful , and she used to performe with depression and she had suicidal thoughts , so yeah that was a example mantel issues are not an excuse , she can fail in some but not ALL , all the singers have bad performances it's ok they are humans too they can fail but not all the time it's not acceptable
Agreed. Have you seen Ariana performing at the Manchester Benefit ? Pretty sure the poor girl was traumatized and she still nailed her set. Selena Gomez puts out really good songs, "Loose you to love me" is definitely one of the better songs released this year and the studio version is beautiful. She just can't sing live and has never been able to.
@@pavitrarupa8716 one of the producers backstage literally confirmed that she did had a panic attack before going up on stage billboard confirmed it too, her friends even liked tweets relating to it so I suggest you to not pull things outta your b*** and make a narrative of your own about what you see online ♥️
Her performance was week.. she's an actress. She should be able to bring presence at least. I've seen some vocals that are good. But this was sad. All of it. I feel bad.
For everyone that says she isn't a good singer stop saying it. Actually if you see thia which I really hope, AMAS fooled selena and made her sound this way in the video. A fan that attended the Ama's took a video of selena singing at that moment and she sounded beautifully and angelic.
Helen riz Swift lmao y’all really are delusional and will make any and every excuse for this girl. She’s a terrible singer, always has been and she could improve if she actually tried but she doesn’t so please just stop it’s embarrassing
She performed anxiety with Julia Michaels a week before the amas and she sounded really good. You can tell the nerves got the best of her. Hopefully she performs soon again to show her improvement
I like to see any of these people who post negative comments get up on stage in front of millions of people and sing a song about someone you still love that has broken their heart into pieces... please. Be kind to one another!!!!
Oh, come on. It's her profession so expecting hate for not performing good comes with it. The performance was.. bad. I can't sing, so I won't sing live in front of millions because I don't want to make a fool out of myself!
So many mean, nasty comments, yes, this wasn’t a great performance, but she still pulled through,and she’s doing what she loves, that’s all that should matter, and her awards show it, if she wasn’t a good singer she wouldn’t be getting any, regardless of “auto tune” you still need a good voice. She’s amazing with what she does, and it’s crazy to see how many bash her when we should be supporting everyone for what they love doing. Idk maybe that’s me not being a hater 👀😝
Selena's voice is amazing but she just can't sing live. And thats perfectly fine. Her songs are great, she has quite a few bangers. But she could never sing live. We should stop pretending like she was ever good at that.
I really do like her songs, but honestly, her live performances are odd to me. I say that because they really aren't always bad. I mean, when she performed live for the song "Let Somebody Go" with Coldplay, she did a great job. I've heard other great live performances of hers as well. But when she performs poorly, it's like really bad. I don't really understand.
I do know one thing. When I sing, there are times when I sound great; however: when my physical illness or mindset is off, it's like I just lose the ability of breath control and then the worse I'm doing, the more tense I get. It's strange and possibly her issue too.
No everyone knows that you can't switch anxiety off but she's not the only singer that has anxiety and that has been through so much pain and hurt. Ariana Grande can sing so well and she can push through the pain because she has talent mixed in with in her, Demi Lovato can still serve you vocals even when the worst things happen to her we all saw her Grammy performance. The thing is with Selena Gomez fans don't understand that the girl has a mediocre voice to begin with she's not vocally strong but I feel like if she didn't feel ready to perform then she shouldn't have performed cuz even in her second half of the performance she wasn't dancing she was stiff, she didn't have energy she just needs to push she needs to at least look like she's trying.
Thandi Fihlani the think you don’t understand that your opinion over her voice does not bother general public or her fans hence why she is selling her song and having fans in the first place. I don’t know why it makes you so pressed seriously. If you don’t like just don’t listen to it. It’s that simple. Trashing her and trying to make her fans “accept” something that is not existed is quite pitiful
Ppl really needs to give Selena Gomez a break... y'all are not gonna do what y'all did to poor ole Britney Spears and tear this poor lady down, she has an excellent heart and has wonderful talent so some stop with the hate because it really pisses me off when ppl do that
Well maybe Britney's voice is destroyed but she's a performer she gives you energy on the stage but Selena neither this nor that like gurl ily but at the same time where are you from the level that you're at 😤
Please, Britney was at least a performer. She gave it her all on stage, and Britney has demonstrated that she CAN sing before her voice went. Selena has always been mediocre at best, she's not a performer, not a vocalist, nothing interesting about her whatsoever except that she;s popular and used to date Justin Bieber. I wouldn't usually credit a woman's success to a man but in this case it applies. She hasn';t shown any improvement in vocals and I for one think as a multi millionaire she should either invest in some erious vocal lessons or get out of the business and focus on acting or modeling or something if she doesn't want to be dragged.
For those of you saying she’s not a good performer, she has proven she can sing multiple times. She was under a lot of pressure that day and she apologized for it. She sounded amazing on rehearsals and just a couple of days before she performed anxiety with julia michaels and sounded great
I lost my voice in the middle of a performance due to anxiety. I had no idea what was going on with me. I was scared, embarrassed, and I had to walk off stage and cut songs from my set. Unless you’ve had this happen you’ll never understand how debilitating it can be and HOW STRONG THIS GIRL REALLY IS.👌🏼
I really appreciate n love ur reaction,people should stop hating on her because of this live performance, u can clearly tell that she was so emotional n holding back her tears.. That's why she was singing off-key n not doing well the choreography PS:sorry for my bad English
I was waiting for this one. Panic attack or not, I don’t think she can really sing as good as the album is portraying. I just wonder if she’s skating by on studio help. Do you think she’s genuinely a good vocalist or just a modern produced artist?
Andrew_Does_Hair of course she’s not particularly good. But she’s got a great production team writing good songs and mixing her voice right. Following her career since the beginning I have to say it seems like she’s not that into music in general. Sure, she might like preforming and of course the money and fame that comes with it, but it she really cared about singing she would’ve been a lot better.
Well, for most, it's true she can't really sing. But she's usually got great control on the lower register, being a mezzo. So while it's true she can't usually sing, she'd usually sang so much better for this type of ballad-like song with her lower register. I personally she's an average singer, though not a bad one at all, at least she's not tone-deaf. As long as she performs songs that's within her vocal range she could execute it with much ease
I don't think it's that Selena can't sing EVER she just can't sing reliably. There may be days where she sings somewhat well, but then there are too many where she's flat and/or pitchy. It's like a wild card with her, whereas other a lot of other singers don't have that problem (i.e. Beyonce, Ariana, Demi Lovato, etc.) And because Selena has so many problems singing well, a career as a musician probably wasn't the best choice. I wish she would have continued acting because her acting was always _so good_ compared to her singing
The truth is Most of her Live performances that have little auto tune are bad. Sure she can sing well once in a blue moon, but a good singer is one who consistently has good vocals. Selena’s live performances are very inconsistent, that’s why she’s a weak singer. Simple as that 🤷♀️
If this was Britney, she would've made front page news and everyone would be destroying her and putting her down...All other artists, its okay, they had a bad day.
I think her problem is big tv performances. When she’s on her own, in concerts and tours she does a lot better.
Sandcastles no the problem is .. she was drunk.
Seriously she has been caught lip syncing in her concerts way to many times
No she doesn't do well in her own concerts either
true
Wear a green mini dress and wear a push up bra and maybe no one will notices you can’t walk and your drunkin stumbling.
Well, I think the reason the whole audience is quite supportive, other than the fact that most of them understand what she's been through, is also because most of them are performers, or someone who've lived through that world, and they're aware how sometimes, shit happens which prevented you from performing your best
Thank you for your kindness and your empathy. This is a vocal lesson but also a life lesson too.
People be acting like the panic attacks are just something so easy to deal with . SHE had a PANIC ATTACK before the performance that mean she couldnt breath well and u can hear her voice was shaking . U can hear that at the end of lytlm her voice got so much better .plus the second song was live but the music was a little bit more powerful than lytlm that's why it looks like it wasnt live . Give her a break she has so much good performances than bad ones . she has a soft sweet voice and i love it .
the panic attack is fake lmao
@@nora1423 no it´s not, she was really dissapointed because in her stories of the rehearsals she was doing it really good, but before going to the stage she had a PANIC ATTACK and that´s why her voice, hands, legs were shaking!
❤️❤️❤️
The panic attack was fake, Selenators on twitter admitted they faked that rumour so she wouldn’t get a lot of backlash from sounding ‘bad’ she may have been nervous which is why she might have been shaking/sounded shaky but the panic attack rumour was false
dbharj2000 stop lying because I follow a lot of Selenators and this not a made up excuse she really had a panic attack
I’ve got to say this is the fairest view on this performance that understands what happened
True
I listened to her sing live in her concert. It was awesome!
You are such a sweetheart! Thank you for this honest reaction 💕
My pleasure 😊
as someone that has seen her perform “sober” and “revival remix” at her tour I almost don’t recognize her on this performance, that’s why I believe that she gets so nervous singing to general public but she is so comfortable singing for fans on tour, and it’s where her voice definitely shines better
Gui sober wasn’t live though. It was pre recorded
@@lauratejebarfoedthaysen4710 only the C#5 is prerecorded
@@sigh.xxohoe6361 That's the only noteworthy part of the performance though. Everything else is basic af. (And even the C#5 isn't really that impressive at all, it's not really a high note for a mezzo like Selena)
@@sigh.xxohoe6361 None of the performance was pre recorded.
I can make a video about it proving that the whole thing was live.
I will if you want
Her belting at the end of look at her now is actually really good
As someone who’s been to her concert I can confirm she can sing. She’s not the worst singer but she’s also not the best singer. She’s way better than what you’d expect.
She lip synchs in her concerts
@@micha-estla6860 lol ITS A CONCERT RIGHT? IF u went to her concert u would now that she was singing live. Nobody goes and lip syncs at their concerts trust me.
The audio in the TV were different from the audio in the audience
Unfortunately, all the videos were erased
She had a little problem with the return, she wasn't hearing her in the beginning, but they corrected after, and of course, this was a really emotional for her, and I'm glad she made it through
And your reaction were incredible, thanks for that
We Stan the best honest vocal coach
Taylor swift isso supportive and i need that kind of bestfriend 😭
Same sameee
Thank you for understanding her. I know she is not the best world singer but she has a beautiful voice and on this performance it didn't go well because she was very nervous. Most people are very hard on her when it comes to singing.
THANK YOU FOR BEING SO SWEET ABOUT THIS PERFORMANCE!!
I'm so glad for the review it's so constructive. 💗
After Watching "Selena Gomez: My Mind And Me" , this performance makes me cry. She's been through a lot. A lot of people in the comments are complaining that she can't sing, she's a "manufactured pop star'', she just makes excuses, she's a drug addict and was drunk that night, please just go and watch the documentary. The comment section just disgusts me. I hope Selena gets better and have a happy life cause she deserves the whole world. ❤
You should react to Taylor Swift - I did something bad American music awards . Its the best performance she ever done. Very dramatic and vocally 10/10.
Muhammad Yusuf that was epic
I get people who are tired of the excuses with her voice but as someone who has panic attacks and anxiety it so makes a difference. I can sing better through any physical injury than I can when I’m anxious. Your throat locks up and it’s hard to speak and that’s definitely what’s going on here. I think she gets anxious during high pressure performances- her low pressure performances are always really great to watch. She’s not the best but it’s not even about that. I love her voice and her music. I kinda wish she’d turn down a lot of these big things but she’s probably contractually obligated to do them
Trust me, I know. If I'm comfortable and relaxed and belts notes just fine and keep the tone and pitch of the notes going smoothly. On the other hand, if I'm highly upset and try, it's like I lose my breath control and not only am I off key, I can't belt at all.
After I experience panic attacks I normally try sing to make myself calm but I will admit i cannot sing after panic attacks so I feel her if it was me I wouldnt have been able to go up
I feel for her. She had panic attacks before most of her performances. Cause she's not a good singer.
she didn't have a panic attack, it's a rumor her fans made to justify her awful singing.
Gimme proof you can sing, tell me your range
@@shahlajaved1183 why do I need to prove myself to a complete stranger online.
@@shahlajaved1183range isn't everything.
Selena can sig very well when she’s comfortable, but when she gets nervous it’s another story
She can make great vocal notes in studio or small concerts, when she’s not experiencing anxiety
Love her ❤️
oh yeah do you know her personally?? lmao
😂
@@megthomas3816 nah but we’ve seen her sing in the studio
Wow you are a classy lady, so respectful, so graceful. So professional of you to give your opinion and to be honest and be professional and to be kind and objective and positive and give advices and be constructive! You are the best!!!
you calling her classy and respectful??! she fucking hates ariana and called her trash and so much worse when Ari's 10 times better than sel BYEEE
I havent seen alot of selena’s performance. As an artist if she messed it up. Ok. Everyone has bad days. I sort of kind of maybe understand. But if she needs to slay the next performance. She needs to slay it harder than ever. Thats what artist do.
I'm really happy that you didnt judge this performance in a negative way. That you were honest and paying attention to what was going on with her at the moment. Dont think it's nice that people have laughed or made fun of that performance. Shes human too and it was an emotional song to sing in the first place given the personal content.
Selena was contractually obliged to make this presentation. She is a conatora who is very hateful and has health problems that make everything worse, on the day she suffered a terrible panic attack, she was given 2 pills of clonazepam (a remedy similar to anxiety and a strong sedative) and orbigated her up to the stage!
there are sources who confirm that she was forced to take the drugs and take the stage by contract already signed.
The remedy in question really freed her from anxiety and panic attack, but at this dose for an immediate response, it leaves the person sleepy and with little control of movements, there is a case that this dose is sufficient for the coma. In patients with low drug resistance.
I'm not sure why her fans have to keep mentioning her health issues. I am also a fan of selena's but just cause she has health issues doesnt negate the fact that it affects the quality of her voice. She doesn't sound good live. End of story
@@kittykatsanchez she does if she isn't nervous.
We keep mentioning it because it's the cause of some of her bad performances.
I, as a singer, a fan of Selena and as a person who suffers from mental health issues, it really makes a difference when you're anxious
she didn’t have a panic attack one of her stans made that up to cover for her
Sure Jan 💅
Z A ikrrr but the fact that they lied so much that it made it to websites and articles shows that they did their job
@@cokolives I can't 😂 if you can't sing, you just can't sing
Yes
Oh I guess you're a mentalist
Demi cried at the Grammys and still sang like a goddess.... 🤷🏻♀️
Demi has always been a WAY better vocalist, it doesn't compare lmao
Typically Jodie so did camila I think Selena just can’t sing
Selena cant compare w Demi, Demi beats her ass off😂😂
PROUD LOVATIC Selena outsold her ass off
Demi who?
you're so sweeeet and kind omg
"I just really..... like her music"
girlie did not have a panic attack before this performance lmao her fans made that up
actually billboard reported it, keep it cute
Martim Mendonça yes
Stfu Arigators
She did.Billboard said it.Go watch the vids that the fans recorded they’re really different
Superbe It at least their faves can sing
Listen to her performance with Julia Michaels live it's actually really really good vocally she sounds really good great control and harmonies
kabeer hanif i Know ppl just wont give her that
It is amazing the quantity of Vocal Coaches in this comment section.
I love this reaction. Respectful and professional.
She’s more successful than any of the haters writing about her
She's the definition of mediocrity, that's why
No she only more successful than her fans
i love the way you react! you are so sweet
The reason why I can’t take her serious is because I feel like there’s always an excuse or a reason as to why she’s always sub par when it comes to live performances or concerts even ! I love her music don’t get me wrong ! I feel like many artist have anxiety / panic attacks but still put their best foot foward , put on a show and put on an amazing show ! I feel like Selena needs to grow as a person and artist! I wish her nothing but love and success 💕
Sebastian Montes De Oca imagine every time, no matter how well you do ppl go on twitter saying that negative things about your voice. I assure you that when she’s on tour, with ppl that she knows that love her, she delivers a whole different attitude, revival tour is an exemple of that
@@gui1627 that doesnt happen to singers who can sing (find me one good or amazing singer who has been tarnished for their live performances). Therefore dont blame the people who are sick of a person gaining millions on a job she has no talent for.
We love selena💖
Did she ever confirm the panic attack rumor started by her fans? Because there are too many bad performances that make me doubt she had one
There are bad performances but there are also good ones and the good ones are more than the bad ones
And yes it was confirmed by her team.
@@swiftiesvsselenators7464 lol no, u a delulu stan so u’re obviously gonna make excuses too, she’s just that bad sorry hun
@@ianalfonsooo you do have any talent yourself?? Hun
@@tamalysantra1023 HE IS NOT A SINGER HONEY, SELENA IS BEING PAYED
you were so nice, ive been a Selena Gomez fan since her disney show wizards of waverly place. but we’ve all know, for a whole, she cannot sing live. she can’t. she never could. but that’s okay bc she’s still successful, she’s kind, we know she’s talented. i think it always had to do with health issues. or maybe just lack of training? but she could never sing live.
She definitely can. I love listening her life (not this one)
I agree she was so successful in disney that no matter what music she releases it would sell... So that's the path she went on.. But she's now releasing less vocally demanding music than her older days so maybe she can do better soon
I love how halsey and taylor supported selena
Anxiety/depression is serious man. And I know from personal experience that it can incapacitate you... I haven’t been able to even get out of the house to go work, shop or eat for over 6 months. If she was really having an Attack before the performance, I’m surprise she didn’t just cancel; I know I would never be able to even get out of a room unaided if it happened...
Lady Gaga literally performed with a broken hip and did the rest of the show flawlessly... no excuses
Selena isn't Lady Gaga. Plus, she had a panic attack right before her turn to sing and perform. And she was also sick.
bruh comparing people doesn't mean anything...lady gaga is lady gaga...
@@stephen4681 Selena just can’t sing. When will her fans be done with the million of excuses for her?
@@bre7931 vocal coaches say she can so who cares what a stranger in the comment section of TH-cam thinks
Uhh.. lmk, is Selena’s hip broken, is Selena Lady Gaga??? Is Selena Gomez the GREATEST singer? No so plz stop before making a fool of urself ☺️
Can u react to taylor swift medley performance at amas
I did something bad - taylor swift (AMAS). I dont know how we forget this performance
Sertek Mertezt This performance is ICONIC ✨
Marcel Górny Yeah
Omg I love her 😭😭😭poor baby
And I love your reaction
Thank you so much for being nice and understanding. As you said, it was a very emotional moment for her, and that definitely had an effect on her voice. Moreover, there were technical issues during her performance of Loose You To Love Me, so she couldn’t hear herself, but they fixed them during Look At Her Now, that’s why she started to sound better. Billboard confirmed this on an article, so I’m not making it up hahahaha. Anyways, it’s nice to see you understand what happened, since almost everybody else just made fun of her.
ButeraVids c’mon. she can’t sing live and never coul. are you gonna write whole paragraphs like this ab what went wrong and why she didn’t sound good, but it wasn’t her fault... for every. single. performance? i’ve loved her since wowp but i always knew she couldn’t sing live. but it’s okay. she’s still kind, makes good music, is talented as hell, and beautiful.
@@delena4evertvd267 She can when she's comfortable. But I respect your opinion
YAY YOU DID THIS THANK YOU LOVE YOU
having social anxiety myself, I could feel the panic she was feeling while performing, if u watch the revival tour performances she was in a way better state of mind and she sounds so much better
She should stop doing this, she should focus on doing what she loves in some other way
I’m suffering with panick attacks too, someone with this condition should know their strenght and ability but whatever. I feel for her but guys, why all of us suddenly pretend like Selena could ever sing? She was almost always like this. Come on.
I agree I mean every time she has a bad performance they make up excuses for her.
The last part on Lose You To Love Me was very good tho
I feel like she's just very anxious in front of an audience because she seems to not be at her best very often when in front of audiences, but when she sings live in a private or small venue she sounds really good
Then she should have chosen a different job lmao. A surgeon can't have any excuses for bad performances either or else people will literally die.
And in Selena's case people's ears die
@@91clarie damn 😭
"Sang off key in my chorus" how ironic
I’m sure she was dyyyying inside at that line.
I just love you for considering her situation and what went on behind the scenes❤❤❤ you are an amazing person
She was so nervous and had a break down and she was affected but lupus so and yall cant tell me you will not be hella nervous after not performing for 4 years
I literally almost cried seeing this, cause you can just see and hear, that she's exhausted and nervous. You can see, that she's had a rough time before the performance and the fact that she still went out and tried her best is admirable. Selena is not the best singer in the world but she can sing and everyone who says otherwise is just straight up lying!
SHE CAN’T SING!!!
@@mollyganasa621 These people are delusional and will find any excuse for her. That’s how you know someone isn’t talented
Selena needs company, when She alone and everyone looking at her she was absolutely nervous and her voice shaking, When the dancers came out you can see that she's comfortable it's like in her own concert with the fans and the dancers
Stop lying. She already has company from her friends (Taylor swift) and support from her fans. Stop making excuses.
even if she is bad at singing which she isn’t , she still makes music that people love and that they listen to.
After watching her documentary ‘my mind and me’… I understood what was she going through
My respect for this performance and this woman is indescribable
When she first heard it she was like: What is this..
BEST REACTION EVER❤
Selena Gomez can sing, her music is good. I will say she’s way better in concert and in studio. Live TV performances aren’t her thing, I think the pressure gets to her and there’s quite a many people that just have stage fright like that. She also had a panic attack and knowing everything she’s gone through she was understandably nervous.
Her voice is weak
Just go from here. If you dont like her voice or singing then why are here. You’re so obsessed.
her in ear was not working + panic attack + error in the tv broadcast, the live in the theater was very good !!
Stop making excuses for her. Literally every live performance people make excuses for her. She IS NOT good live. Period.
I feel like most haters dont understand the pain she went through, and sending her more hate won't help, she scared to sing live cause she think if she mess up she will get more hate then she already gets, maybe Instead of sending hate send her love and support. and maybe u will get a better performance❤
what pain lol ariana went through worse and still hits all notes perfectly, stop justifying her lack of talent jeez.
WHAT PAIN?? she gave so much mental pain to justin and ariana had gone thru 10 times more Pain!! stop defending her she cant sing!
I'm sorry for her if she wasn't well but her mental health aside she could never sing
Let me turn this around: I feel like most of her fans dont understand that going through stuff doesnt affect talent and that she is playing a victim. Most singers went through worse shit and sing like angels (Adele, MJ, Whitney and Ariana to name a few). And if she is so "nervous and panicy" she then simply isnt made for this job. After 13/14 years of singing she should be used to concerts by now. She sang even before Justin and her health issues (that she caused with all the drugs and alcohol anyway), and she even then had no talent. She isnt innocent. She was part of the problem too. You are only dismissing it because women are angels even if they abuse a partner apparently. This coming from a woman as well.
@@sandhyabagde2735 some people take pain differently you can’t just say some one else had more pain when you don’t even know their life.
Thank you for this video, this was an objective analysis while still showing compassion and empathy.
Here’s some thing about this performance you should know.
1. There was an audio issue, there is a video from someone in the audience where she sounds great.
2. This was her first performance in years, considering it’s in front of huge celebrities and being broadcasted to millions of people she was definitely nervous which explains it all.
3. She posted on her Instagram a week prior (she was in rehearsals) and she sounded amazing (she was also crouched over which makes it harder to sing and she still was hitting all the notes)
4. Idk if this was confirmed but it was rumoured she had a panic attack before the show.
This was not a good performance but it’s understandable why it wasn’t very good.
There is always something. Selena's performances are 90% bad. But it's never her fault. Either she was sick or nervous or there was a technical issue etc.
Interesting.
Those were all excuses. She can't sing. End of story.
There we go again a Selena Gomez fan 😑😑
They’re always saying it’s a “panic attack”. She can’t perform live. She’s proved this time & time again & the excuses are always rolling in. People are acting like she’s never been in front of huge celebrities. She IS a huge celebrity. She’s been performing for years. It wasn’t good.
I felt like she sounded fine as she kept going, but when you only have 4 minutes you can't really be warming it up in that first minute or so. Lol. But yeah, in all fairness she hasn't performed on TV in years. I wish she had done more promo for the album, but hey, it's number 1 nonetheless and the album is fantastic. But this was clearly nervous, which I get.
In my opinion. At the end her face looked like she was disappointed really badly.
people always make excuses for Selena when she gives a performance. Just say what you’re all thinking...she isn’t that great live, period. She sounds good on the record and that’s the only place we should hear her.
She's not the best singer. No one will say that. She's also had lots of bad live performances since her lupus started effecting her health. But she's also had amazing performances in the past such as her revival tour when she was at a point where she was just a tier below Demi or Ariana and looked promising as a live singer. Her style isn't fit for live performances either but during that time she was going for higher notes and a bigger vocal range. The fact that she doesn't sing in her normal voice also has a huge effect on that. But all that aside in this AMA performance she had a panic attack before her first performance which also had insufficient time for practicing the routine. And her live studio instrumental performances since this let down performance have been solid. Hopefully she can get healthy soon and be back at that revival level but she isn't as bad as people make her out to be and especially not as a singer overall (so if you count her work outside of live crowd performances). Also you do know this is a well respected professional vocal coach who's video you commented on right?
great reaction! there was actually an audio issue too and she coudnt hear herself
she had a panic attack, she was about to cry on the first song, she is very strong when she went out to sing with that state, even if she has tweeted, the bank to death because she is an incredible woman♥️
TELL ME WHERE THIS PANIC ATTACK THING CAME FROM... DUDE IT CAME FROM A RANDOM SELENATOR TO COVER UP THIS
“I absolutely… LIKE her music” 😂
I LOVE YOU!!!! Thanks for this!!!! It’s sooo good as you understand!
✨Great gowns , beautiful gowns✨
Aretha Franklin RIP
so funny dumb
DISCLAIMER: I am not trying to send hate to Selena, it's just my opinion.
I think it's time to stop excusing Selena. She can't sing and that's the truth. She always uses her mental health (or being emotional) as an excuse for her awful performances while there are other artists like Ariana Grande or Demi Lovato struggling with mental issues as well and they never sound awful when they perform. She has more failed performances than good ones, that clearly means something. /:
Facts!!!!
There is no way someone like selena who take a lot of vocal learning but she did not improve the problem is her mental is weak,,,, try understand that.
@@user-xo2vi5eu7v not an excuse at all , let take Billie eilish for example , she doesn't sing high notes often ( lwk like Selena LWK selena can't hit high notes) , anyways , Billie has mental issues since she was 15 but she still nail her live performances she literally does not wrong note she's always on pitch she has never sounded awful , and she used to performe with depression and she had suicidal thoughts , so yeah that was a example mantel issues are not an excuse , she can fail in some but not ALL , all the singers have bad performances it's ok they are humans too they can fail but not all the time it's not acceptable
Dont compare struggles dude!!!!
Agreed. Have you seen Ariana performing at the Manchester Benefit ? Pretty sure the poor girl was traumatized and she still nailed her set. Selena Gomez puts out really good songs, "Loose you to love me" is definitely one of the better songs released this year and the studio version is beautiful. She just can't sing live and has never been able to.
I get she hurting, is sick and stuff but I don't think she's obliged to perform anyway. If she knew she couldn't do it, then she could've not done it.
I know that she fights lupus so I wonder if she was having a rough day. I also read that she had a panic attack right before she went on stage.
No she didn't had panic attack
@@pavitrarupa8716 one of the producers backstage literally confirmed that she did had a panic attack before going up on stage billboard confirmed it too, her friends even liked tweets relating to it so I suggest you to not pull things outta your b*** and make a narrative of your own about what you see online ♥️
Nicole scherzinger needs the recognition this girl has. She can actually sing
Great reaction. I agree 100%!
I swear you can read my mind. I watched her performance yesterday and wanted to hear you judge it.
And one day later i see this video
Her performance was week.. she's an actress. She should be able to bring presence at least. I've seen some vocals that are good. But this was sad. All of it. I feel bad.
Allie Smoley you can’t expect everything to be perfect...
Ugh I love you Georgina 😭
For everyone that says she isn't a good singer stop saying it. Actually if you see thia which I really hope, AMAS fooled selena and made her sound this way in the video. A fan that attended the Ama's took a video of selena singing at that moment and she sounded beautifully and angelic.
No one fooled her at all I saw live cameras too and she still sounded the same it's the fact that she CAN'T SING !
How hahahahha so true
Helen riz Swift lmao y’all really are delusional and will make any and every excuse for this girl. She’s a terrible singer, always has been and she could improve if she actually tried but she doesn’t so please just stop it’s embarrassing
You're in a lot of denial over a person you don't even know in real life.
ash marie Fr she never gets a vocal coach. Ok she sees everyone roasting her.
She performed anxiety with Julia Michaels a week before the amas and she sounded really good. You can tell the nerves got the best of her. Hopefully she performs soon again to show her improvement
I like to see any of these people who post negative comments get up on stage in front of millions of people and sing a song about someone you still love that has broken their heart into pieces... please. Be kind to one another!!!!
Oh, come on. It's her profession so expecting hate for not performing good comes with it. The performance was.. bad.
I can't sing, so I won't sing live in front of millions because I don't want to make a fool out of myself!
@@ICAMEINLIKEACHANNEL I 100%agree with you..
Tracy Krouse i do that a lot to but still not sound like that.. like i love her but im not delusional. shes not a good singer
So many mean, nasty comments, yes, this wasn’t a great performance, but she still pulled through,and she’s doing what she loves, that’s all that should matter, and her awards show it, if she wasn’t a good singer she wouldn’t be getting any, regardless of “auto tune” you still need a good voice. She’s amazing with what she does, and it’s crazy to see how many bash her when we should be supporting everyone for what they love doing. Idk maybe that’s me not being a hater 👀😝
Selena's voice is amazing but she just can't sing live. And thats perfectly fine. Her songs are great, she has quite a few bangers. But she could never sing live. We should stop pretending like she was ever good at that.
@@topkekkek2135she actually can sing live. I've saw some good performances from her.
My friend....at her level....it was pulled through even for armature status. You love her songs...but man, she can't sing live dude.
I really do like her songs, but honestly, her live performances are odd to me. I say that because they really aren't always bad. I mean, when she performed live for the song "Let Somebody Go" with Coldplay, she did a great job. I've heard other great live performances of hers as well. But when she performs poorly, it's like really bad. I don't really understand.
I do know one thing. When I sing, there are times when I sound great; however: when my physical illness or mindset is off, it's like I just lose the ability of breath control and then the worse I'm doing, the more tense I get. It's strange and possibly her issue too.
Hey! Luke White told me about you! I really respect your work! You are so interesting! 🙏❤️
Awesome! Thank you!
@@HonestVocalCoach No problem! i can't wait for luke and you livestreaming together on Wednesday! I'll be there!
You can’t really just “switch off” anxiety, lmao
No everyone knows that you can't switch anxiety off but she's not the only singer that has anxiety and that has been through so much pain and hurt. Ariana Grande can sing so well and she can push through the pain because she has talent mixed in with in her, Demi Lovato can still serve you vocals even when the worst things happen to her we all saw her Grammy performance. The thing is with Selena Gomez fans don't understand that the girl has a mediocre voice to begin with she's not vocally strong but I feel like if she didn't feel ready to perform then she shouldn't have performed cuz even in her second half of the performance she wasn't dancing she was stiff, she didn't have energy she just needs to push she needs to at least look like she's trying.
Thandi Fihlani the think you don’t understand that your opinion over her voice does not bother general public or her fans hence why she is selling her song and having fans in the first place. I don’t know why it makes you so pressed seriously. If you don’t like just don’t listen to it. It’s that simple. Trashing her and trying to make her fans “accept” something that is not existed is quite pitiful
Ppl really needs to give Selena Gomez a break... y'all are not gonna do what y'all did to poor ole Britney Spears and tear this poor lady down, she has an excellent heart and has wonderful talent so some stop with the hate because it really pisses me off when ppl do that
Well maybe Britney's voice is destroyed but she's a performer she gives you energy on the stage but Selena neither this nor that like gurl ily but at the same time where are you from the level that you're at 😤
Britney wasn't the best singer but she was more of a singer than Selena let's be honest.
Please, Britney was at least a performer. She gave it her all on stage, and Britney has demonstrated that she CAN sing before her voice went. Selena has always been mediocre at best, she's not a performer, not a vocalist, nothing interesting about her whatsoever except that she;s popular and used to date Justin Bieber. I wouldn't usually credit a woman's success to a man but in this case it applies. She hasn';t shown any improvement in vocals and I for one think as a multi millionaire she should either invest in some erious vocal lessons or get out of the business and focus on acting or modeling or something if she doesn't want to be dragged.
I love both but let's face it..britney is untouchable and no one can deny her talent and success
For those of you saying she’s not a good performer, she has proven she can sing multiple times. She was under a lot of pressure that day and she apologized for it. She sounded amazing on rehearsals and just a couple of days before she performed anxiety with julia michaels and sounded great
I lost my voice in the middle of a performance due to anxiety. I had no idea what was going on with me. I was scared, embarrassed, and I had to walk off stage and cut songs from my set. Unless you’ve had this happen you’ll never understand how debilitating it can be and HOW STRONG THIS GIRL REALLY IS.👌🏼
I really appreciate n love ur reaction,people should stop hating on her because of this live performance, u can clearly tell that she was so emotional n holding back her tears.. That's why she was singing off-key n not doing well the choreography
PS:sorry for my bad English
There’s nothing wrong with your English 😊
She hadn't a panick attack, she just was drunk. It was her team making excuses for her cuz they know she can't sing, that's all. Periodt.
The way y’all keep claiming she was drunk bc she stumbled in some heels, stay reaching
A exactly😭
Drunkkkkk
I was waiting for this one. Panic attack or not, I don’t think she can really sing as good as the album is portraying. I just wonder if she’s skating by on studio help. Do you think she’s genuinely a good vocalist or just a modern produced artist?
Andrew_Does_Hair of course she’s not particularly good. But she’s got a great production team writing good songs and mixing her voice right. Following her career since the beginning I have to say it seems like she’s not that into music in general. Sure, she might like preforming and of course the money and fame that comes with it, but it she really cared about singing she would’ve been a lot better.
Well, for most, it's true she can't really sing. But she's usually got great control on the lower register, being a mezzo. So while it's true she can't usually sing, she'd usually sang so much better for this type of ballad-like song with her lower register. I personally she's an average singer, though not a bad one at all, at least she's not tone-deaf. As long as she performs songs that's within her vocal range she could execute it with much ease
Everything about her music is good, but she is not a live singer. 😔
Justin S she has definitely sang live way better than this.
Truee
@@stevenkyle4350 she had a panic attack just before!!!
she had a LOT of good moments go check!! way more before her lupus surgery but that’s okay
Such a good video!! Thank you♥️
I think you guys need to see her best vocals. Then you would understand that she can sing.
Then why dont she sing more live and stuff?
I don't think it's that Selena can't sing EVER she just can't sing reliably. There may be days where she sings somewhat well, but then there are too many where she's flat and/or pitchy. It's like a wild card with her, whereas other a lot of other singers don't have that problem (i.e. Beyonce, Ariana, Demi Lovato, etc.) And because Selena has so many problems singing well, a career as a musician probably wasn't the best choice. I wish she would have continued acting because her acting was always _so good_ compared to her singing
People rather ignore all of her other great performances just because of one. That's really sad.
All of her good performances she use an auto pitch corrector mic.
The truth is Most of her Live performances that have little auto tune are bad. Sure she can sing well once in a blue moon, but a good singer is one who consistently has good vocals. Selena’s live performances are very inconsistent, that’s why she’s a weak singer. Simple as that 🤷♀️
I love your opinion, but I think what went wrong was that she was nervous, she hasn’t been on stage in years, also it’s a very emotional song for her.
Ricky’s World yes, something was clearly wrong. Under rehearsal perhaps?
I am not a big fan of hers but i am in love with this song
i feel like she's trying to stop herself from crying
I subscribed because of this video
If this was Britney, she would've made front page news and everyone would be destroying her and putting her down...All other artists, its okay, they had a bad day.
EXACTLY!!!!!!