Remember when that mom was feeding her kid and he wouldn’t eat. so she tried to feed a teddy bear and the teddy wouldn’t eat so she punched the teddy bear. She tried to feed him again and then the baby ate the food.
As a parent, I try very hard to watch my own behaviour and words that I use especially when I am in front of the kids. Sometimes fatigue and stress will get the better of me. Every time I see these clips about how much children's behaviour is influenced by their surrounding, I am reminded that I need to do better.
It's human to make mistakes sometimes and it can actually be pretty good for children to see a parent model healthy ways to own up to mistakes and apologize.
@Train of Taught no. It's the opposite. Bullies fear the strong, and those who feel indifferent to bullying. The Bully must lose interest in you. If u behave weak, the Bully will be determined to bully you more. At the same time, don't challenge the bully to a fight if u can't beat him. Just look in the eyes of the bully, as if they are some vermin.
@Train of Taught No it's not the same because the bobo doll doesn't hit you back. Go punch a punching bag. Fun and easy, right? You can do this all day, easy, no worries, no second thoughts. Now go punch a fighter. The weak kids are punching bags and the strong kids are fighters. Even if you beat the fighter, you're going to walk (limp) away with two black eyes and think very hard and carefully before you go punch that fighter again. You might even get beat by the fighter and then take out your frustration on the punching bag aka the weak kid. So please, be a fighter not a punching bag. Even if you lose, you must stand up for yourself. Don't be a Bobo doll.
I find the use of terminology a bit unclear. The question at the beginning and the supporting visuals imply that the question is if we can learn a skill through observation. But the experiments seemed like they were less about learning how to punch, but rather if they would copy the adult's behavior. The kids didn't "learn" how to punch the doll, they learned/adopted the behavior.
The other day, I saw two women at a supermarket, accompanied by a young boy. The little boy was frustrated and hitting one of the women. She threatened spanking him if he didn't behave. I wonder WHERE the little boy learned that he could express his frustration by hitting others when they didn't behave the way he wanted. Truly a mystery for the ages, I think.
To the *incredible person* seeing this, I wish you all the best in life❤ don't over blame yourself, accept things and go forward. Don't let others define what “success” is for you. Get up, learn the skills needed and get after it, all the keys to a happy life is in your hands. Keep pushing.
At most, you helped people insignificantly. Please stop, you're wasting your own time unless you're a bot. These types of comments aren't what people want to see, they want comments relevant to the video.
The fact that kids also learn by observing others was considered a profound revelation for the psychology world? My god… these are the experts, the professionals, and the highest paid amongst us?
I remember we once gave our dog a command we had never taught her and she did it immediately. She had picked it up from observing her friend-dogs following the command during walks, without being taught it directly herself.
I mostly learned what not to do. By watching my caregivers and family I recognized I didn't want to imitate them. They all seem to follow a particular pattern, even though choosing different careers, that still made them miserable and not very good parents.
1 learning is a cognitive process that takes place in a social setting learning can happen by observing behaviour and the concequeces of such learning can happen without an observable change in behaviour 4 reinforcements play a role, but are not entirely
@2:34 “ seeing other being rewarded does not necessarily motivate us to copy they behavior.” I wonder if a reward has an significant monetary value will that influence the behavior to be copied?
I found this part of the theory interesting considering we mostly use models that follow positive reinforcement with children nowadays. Whilst children’s overall behaviour has certainly dramatically reduced, we are hoping to improve their mental health- but won’t know if we have succeeded until these children grow into adulthood I suppose.
1.Kids are more likely to copy same gender adults 2. Males are naturally more aggressive than females 3. Females are naturally more prone to be intimidated by punishments ( given to others)
I definitely think we copy our parents as kids. I am 32 and have never seen disagreements between my parents become demeaning or disrespectful. So I have always thought that, that is a person should argue. So I have soldem do it if I do I feel horrible and always apologise.
@TOS100 Returns the whole point of teaching is "grooming", molding kids into productive members of society. That's not illegal yet. If you have a problem with that I suggest home schooling (although you still need to teach enough to pass a GED)
@@harlequingnoll5 No one is missing what I am saying. I'd the law does not fix the problem, then the parents will. Teachers.....be afraid and keep your noses clean.
@@harlequingnoll5 And by the way, we ALL WILL PAY SPECIAL ATTENTION TO INDIVIDUALS LIKE YOURSELF AND OTHERS that say the things you say. Adults that care about kids are SICK AND TIRED of adults that want to "groom" (as you put in quotes) and abuse kids.
@@antarahmoody575 I would argue the parents are a bigger contributor to a child's personality than a new teacher every year. (I'll admit that might just be an anecdote and some kids get the same teacher for a decade or whatever). My advice would be to say " Raise your kid right by asking them what they were taught each day and helping them with homework." My advice for everyone REGARDLESS of parental status is to consume your news intake from more than 1 source.
learning is a cognitive process that takes place in a social setting learning can happen by observing behaviour and the concequeces of such 4 reinforcements play a role, but are not entirely responsible for learning 5 cognition, behaviour and environment all mu
I also disagree, that this is a study on aggression. Bobo Doll is after all a toy, like a ball, you kick that too, regardless if you aggressive or not. You can not really tell, whether the children hitting the Bobo Doll are doing it out of hidden rage or joy. Children learn and adapt. In conclusion this episode does not make me hold Albert Bandura in awe. After all, he was bored, when attend psychology class, maybe he could use a Bobo Doll to pass time.
I would like to share the videos from this channel with my mom. However, she can’t listen and understand English, and so I would like to make an Indonesian subtitle for her. How do I submit subtitle to these videos?
I see a fallacy of describing one adaptive behavior and stating that the behavior is the only method to achieve the goals of the said adaptive behavior. In other words, I argue for multiple learning matrices.
I don't think anyone was arguing that learning through observation was the only way to learn, the discussion was about learning through observation being possible.
Our government is using this knowledge to force compliance. In Canada, if you do what they want you’re ok, if you Don’t do what they want; no more banking, no mtg payments or insurance transacted so you and your kids are on the streets. Punishment does more to provoke behaviour then reward. Alas, this is effective
its true. When i was a kid I had this doll pretended it was a baby would beat it up. Turns out that happened to me when I was a baby, not from my parents btw somobdy else
So, those children who went through those was taken advantage of, right? Wer they ever able to unlearn what they learned. Marred forever? This is also abuse. With the kind of shows today, Television and cartoons is such a nuisance to their mental emotional and brain development. (my opinion). Children are your responsibility, parents. Spent purposive time with them. Do not verbally abuse them, but heal them with your words and touch.
great video with simplest explanation! My greatest teachers are youtubers I am also a small youtuber so I am heavily influenced by great youtubers of my niche
So true. The reason he turned water into wine was because he was at a party when he was younger and the local bullies made fun of him and said he'd never be fun at a party ever and he cried but his tears formed a puddle which turned into a rainbow which is why God hates gays.
Nope! I play violent shooters since 1999 first was Unreal Tournament my whole life! I visit Lan partys! 300 psycos caged in a small room over 3 days without light and crappy food and no sleep! All playing this violent onlineshooters! Never one beatup happens! This is why i think this study nonesense!
Hitting dolls is unfortunately not an unbiased act so I don't get how you can infer that kids don't respond well to watching others receive positive, or negative rewards, as a result.
Unnecessary to watch or learn about Bandura - its sufficient to watch nature where adult animals teach their offspring by showing how to do something right. And the children then will repeat it and understand - if i do it i will live well, have food and be safe. Often the solution is about going out into the world and start observing without going too much into school and book teachings. And just as some critics - saying "The Man do it" or the "Female Actor do it" is discriminating and distorting peoples perception - I had to ask myself "WTF are they saying - that man are aggressive and women just act to be aggressive?" Who the actual fuck made this audio track. Its man and woman. Done.
I’m so tired of people thinking they are more high-class by pronouncing the ‘t’ in ‘often’__ they aren’t __ this affectation has become a trend in the past couple of years _______________
@@gerardo49078 What do you even mean? it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out that kids follow in their parents footsteps that’s literally common sense monkey see monkey do dummy 🙄🙄🙄
@@shine.9241 You’re comparing apples to oranges How is it hard to understand that children literally copy their parents??? like what? this video didn’t even explain why it is like that 😂 y’all are pseudo intellectuals Gravity , unlike childrens psychology, needs to be proven with mathematics and physics 👉🏾🙄😂
My brothers and I had one of those punch dolls in the mid 60's....we punched the crap out of that poor doll because it was fun, until we punched it so hard it hit and broke the ceiling light fixture made of glass that put a rip in our punch doll. RIP Punch Doll....mom had no punches in the game, dad was no where to be seen.
as a psychologist,i say : this clip is NOT true !!! it's apalling and i'm outraged of this clip. what bandura demonstrated is that the MOST important thing is the punishment or reward that the agressive adult receives. the children will be more agressive if the model was rewarded,and less agressive if the model was punished. everything else is a lie
Support our work on learning how to learn: patreon.com/sprouts
Remember when that mom was feeding her kid and he wouldn’t eat. so she tried to feed a teddy bear and the teddy wouldn’t eat so she punched the teddy bear. She tried to feed him again and then the baby ate the food.
:)
Should had punch the baby
That’s sick and abusive
@@JFS1215 the baby needs to eat
@@shawnshawn8888 abusive to the teddy bear
As a parent, I try very hard to watch my own behaviour and words that I use especially when I am in front of the kids. Sometimes fatigue and stress will get the better of me. Every time I see these clips about how much children's behaviour is influenced by their surrounding, I am reminded that I need to do better.
You my friend are a very considerate parent and honestly might be one of the best parents ever
Same Lol
tru
It's human to make mistakes sometimes and it can actually be pretty good for children to see a parent model healthy ways to own up to mistakes and apologize.
Atleast someone agrees
Learned about this in my adolescent psychology class, it’s nice to be reminded of useful theories and studies like these. Bandura a goat 🐐
Interesting. Another good reason why we must read stories to children. They observe images and learn!
interesting study. although i would think that people would naturally punch the bobo doll just for fun because it keeps coming back up
you can make a weeble wobble but it won't fall down
@Train of Taught no. It's the opposite. Bullies fear the strong, and those who feel indifferent to bullying. The Bully must lose interest in you. If u behave weak, the Bully will be determined to bully you more. At the same time, don't challenge the bully to a fight if u can't beat him.
Just look in the eyes of the bully, as if they are some vermin.
@Train of Taught No it's not the same because the bobo doll doesn't hit you back. Go punch a punching bag. Fun and easy, right? You can do this all day, easy, no worries, no second thoughts. Now go punch a fighter. The weak kids are punching bags and the strong kids are fighters. Even if you beat the fighter, you're going to walk (limp) away with two black eyes and think very hard and carefully before you go punch that fighter again. You might even get beat by the fighter and then take out your frustration on the punching bag aka the weak kid. So please, be a fighter not a punching bag. Even if you lose, you must stand up for yourself. Don't be a Bobo doll.
Haha
A good confounding factor. I am sure they would like ot incorporate that in replicating the experiment if it were to be performed today.
I find the use of terminology a bit unclear. The question at the beginning and the supporting visuals imply that the question is if we can learn a skill through observation. But the experiments seemed like they were less about learning how to punch, but rather if they would copy the adult's behavior. The kids didn't "learn" how to punch the doll, they learned/adopted the behavior.
Noted. Thanks
The other day, I saw two women at a supermarket, accompanied by a young boy.
The little boy was frustrated and hitting one of the women. She threatened spanking him if he didn't behave.
I wonder WHERE the little boy learned that he could express his frustration by hitting others when they didn't behave the way he wanted. Truly a mystery for the ages, I think.
1.Which book would you suggest for further reading.
2.Is there any books that are a "must read" when it comes to psychology
To the *incredible person* seeing this, I wish you all the best in life❤ don't over blame yourself, accept things and go forward. Don't let others define what “success” is for you. Get up, learn the skills needed and get after it, all the keys to a happy life is in your hands. Keep pushing.
go away with your toxic positivity BS
What's your point?
At most, you helped people insignificantly. Please stop, you're wasting your own time unless you're a bot. These types of comments aren't what people want to see, they want comments relevant to the video.
@@ExoticBloxed Okay 👌🏾. Thank you 🙏🏾
I'm watching this for a school project
The fact that kids also learn by observing others was considered a profound revelation for the psychology world? My god… these are the experts, the professionals, and the highest paid amongst us?
Your mission presented at the end is inspiring, thank you guys.
Thanks. Join us ;)
best video so far on this topic
Thank you! These videos are so incredibly helpful for me.
I mostly believe this to be true. I could list things of examples of that happening in my family.
My son is five and his been watching MMA and boxing since he was born. I'm a big fan and now he thinks his a warrior and he loves to wrestle
I remember we once gave our dog a command we had never taught her and she did it immediately.
She had picked it up from observing her friend-dogs following the command during walks, without being taught it directly herself.
Brilliant
I mostly learned what not to do. By watching my caregivers and family I recognized I didn't want to imitate them. They all seem to follow a particular pattern, even though choosing different careers, that still made them miserable and not very good parents.
1 learning is a cognitive process that takes place in a social setting
learning can happen by observing behaviour and the concequeces of such
learning can happen without an observable change in behaviour
4 reinforcements play a role, but are not entirely
I keep telling parents kids learn by example, if you're watching tv they will watch it to
if hey see you reading books they will too.
I can't believe I've never heard of this before.
@2:34 “ seeing other being rewarded does not necessarily motivate us to copy they behavior.” I wonder if a reward has an significant monetary value will that influence the behavior to be copied?
I found this part of the theory interesting considering we mostly use models that follow positive reinforcement with children nowadays. Whilst children’s overall behaviour has certainly dramatically reduced, we are hoping to improve their mental health- but won’t know if we have succeeded until these children grow into adulthood I suppose.
These theories are pretty cool and awesome.
1.Kids are more likely to copy same gender adults
2. Males are naturally more aggressive than females
3. Females are naturally more prone to be intimidated by punishments ( given to others)
Second observation is not precise. I would say (based on this video alone) that boys are more likely to EXPRESS their agressivity.
We can learn through direct experience and also from studying others
Thanks, I was waiting this video!
Funny how some/most people before/after this experiment didn't understand these simple principles.
I definitely think we copy our parents as kids. I am 32 and have never seen disagreements between my parents become demeaning or disrespectful. So I have always thought that, that is a person should argue. So I have soldem do it if I do I feel horrible and always apologise.
This is why groomers need to be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.
Well so far teaching isn't an illegal profession yet so "fullest extent" doesn't go very far. The word you wanted I'm guessing is persecuted.
@TOS100 Returns the whole point of teaching is "grooming", molding kids into productive members of society. That's not illegal yet. If you have a problem with that I suggest home schooling (although you still need to teach enough to pass a GED)
@@harlequingnoll5 No one is missing what I am saying. I'd the law does not fix the problem, then the parents will. Teachers.....be afraid and keep your noses clean.
@@harlequingnoll5 And by the way, we ALL WILL PAY SPECIAL ATTENTION TO INDIVIDUALS LIKE YOURSELF AND OTHERS that say the things you say. Adults that care about kids are SICK AND TIRED of adults that want to "groom" (as you put in quotes) and abuse kids.
@@antarahmoody575 I would argue the parents are a bigger contributor to a child's personality than a new teacher every year. (I'll admit that might just be an anecdote and some kids get the same teacher for a decade or whatever). My advice would be to say " Raise your kid right by asking them what they were taught each day and helping them with homework." My advice for everyone REGARDLESS of parental status is to consume your news intake from more than 1 source.
Bobo's Bizarre Adventure
this channel is boon, thank you so much for creating awesome ANIMATED VIDEOS especially to adid the visual learns, best channel for higher studies
Thanks! That’s exactly why we make them.
learning is a cognitive process that takes place in a social setting
learning can happen by observing behaviour and the concequeces of such
4 reinforcements play a role, but are not entirely responsible for learning
5 cognition, behaviour and environment all mu
Life imitates art.
Girls voice behind this video is so ❣️
She will make such a cute lovely teacher
Little kitten voice she has.
Haha funny I have a test with this experiment next week. Tanks for the revision material 👌
Really enjoying this
I also disagree, that this is a study on aggression. Bobo Doll is after all a toy, like a ball, you kick that too, regardless if you aggressive or not. You can not really tell, whether the children hitting the Bobo Doll are doing it out of hidden rage or joy. Children learn and adapt. In conclusion this episode does not make me hold Albert Bandura in awe. After all, he was bored, when attend psychology class, maybe he could use a Bobo Doll to pass time.
The first part of your argument was reasonable. The second half, however, was just plain Ad Hominem
who said this was a study on aggression?
@@gerardo49078🫱🏽🫲🏾
I would like to share the videos from this channel with my mom. However, she can’t listen and understand English, and so I would like to make an Indonesian subtitle for her. How do I submit subtitle to these videos?
Marvellous animation 🙌
Consequences are important
Memo: Bandura= learning from others. Conditioning
It is also known as *Will Smith slaps Chris Rock Social Experiment.*
Good one bro😅😅
Fun & Entertainment they should both get fined for ‘ ham acting ‘ 😂
A very clear explanation, thank you.
Hollywood does not condone violence. 🕊
🧢
Didn't know Bandura was a lefty 01:52.
I see a fallacy of describing one adaptive behavior and stating that the behavior is the only method to achieve the goals of the said adaptive behavior. In other words, I argue for multiple learning matrices.
I don't think anyone was arguing that learning through observation was the only way to learn, the discussion was about learning through observation being possible.
@@bramvanduijn8086 Perhaps another viewing.
Hello, author. I want to know what kind of animation software you use? I really want to learn. Can you tell me? thank you!
I love the shit they used to get away with in "science experiments"...
Yes
Very useful thank u
thank you!
Operant conditioning, not operational conditioning.
I think we all copy the people we admire
Our government is using this knowledge to force compliance. In Canada, if you do what they want you’re ok, if you Don’t do what they want; no more banking, no mtg payments or insurance transacted so you and your kids are on the streets.
Punishment does more to provoke behaviour then reward. Alas, this is effective
What was the sample size like for these experiments?
36 boys and 36 girls
Thank you
Our pleasure:)
Conclusion: girls are built different
its true. When i was a kid I had this doll pretended it was a baby would beat it up. Turns out that happened to me when I was a baby, not from my parents btw somobdy else
So, those children who went through those was taken advantage of, right? Wer they ever able to unlearn what they learned. Marred forever? This is also abuse. With the kind of shows today, Television and cartoons is such a nuisance to their mental emotional and brain development.
(my opinion).
Children are your responsibility, parents. Spent purposive time with them. Do not verbally abuse them, but heal them with your words and touch.
great video with simplest explanation! My greatest teachers are youtubers I am also a small youtuber so I am heavily influenced by great youtubers of my niche
Awesome! Thank you!
Hypothesis should include another scenario where the kid denies to go that room to begin with 🤔 Let alone observing. 😮
All these studies when the Bible had literally said, children live what they learnt 😅
Memo: Reciprical determinisms
Buttttttt.....is the bobo doll alone in the room where the subjects could vent their frustrations into?
Many people's idea of sex first came from porn. A lot of things make sense now given social learning theory.
Depends
intteresting
Interesting
This is why the story of Jesus is so effective. He forgave those who bullied him. Its a hard thing to copy though.
So true. The reason he turned water into wine was because he was at a party when he was younger and the local bullies made fun of him and said he'd never be fun at a party ever and he cried but his tears formed a puddle which turned into a rainbow which is why God hates gays.
Matthew 3:17: 'Haters gonna hate'
Video Games?
Why MY MARKS WAS REDUCED IF IT WAS A PRANK ,WHY MY FRIEND GONE IF IT WAS A PRANK ....answer it truely ....
10mins ?? Jeeeezuz
Nope! I play violent shooters since 1999 first was Unreal Tournament my whole life! I visit Lan partys! 300 psycos caged in a small room over 3 days without light and crappy food and no sleep! All playing this violent onlineshooters! Never one beatup happens! This is why i think this study nonesense!
Hitting dolls is unfortunately not an unbiased act so I don't get how you can infer that kids don't respond well to watching others receive positive, or negative rewards, as a result.
Hey are you doing this video, for improving your speaking skills , Bhai btao please
Unnecessary to watch or learn about Bandura - its sufficient to watch nature where adult animals teach their offspring by showing how to do something right. And the children then will repeat it and understand - if i do it i will live well, have food and be safe. Often the solution is about going out into the world and start observing without going too much into school and book teachings.
And just as some critics - saying "The Man do it" or the "Female Actor do it" is discriminating and distorting peoples perception - I had to ask myself "WTF are they saying - that man are aggressive and women just act to be aggressive?" Who the actual fuck made this audio track. Its man and woman. Done.
Hintz Shoal
I’m so tired of people thinking they are more high-class by pronouncing the ‘t’ in ‘often’__ they aren’t __ this affectation has become a trend in the past couple of years _______________
L + Ratio + Mald
Wait, people don’t pronounce it?
Please add the traduction of arabic
this seems extremely common sense
gravity also seems extremely commom sense
it's not about "being right in front of out eyes", it's about proving why it is like that
Right?
Yeah, pretty easy to claim today's knowledge is common sense when someone already did the hard job
@@gerardo49078 What do you even mean? it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out that kids follow in their parents footsteps that’s literally common sense
monkey see monkey do dummy 🙄🙄🙄
@@shine.9241 You’re comparing apples to oranges
How is it hard to understand that children literally copy their parents???
like what?
this video didn’t even explain why it is like that 😂
y’all are pseudo intellectuals
Gravity , unlike childrens psychology, needs to be proven with mathematics and physics 👉🏾🙄😂
Can I give the online classes for telling lies.🤔
We need Arabic translate
my conclusion: internet, film, and mass media is the destroyer of humanity
nope. not quite I think.
Boo Boo
So that's why Andrew tate
First!
My brothers and I had one of those punch dolls in the mid 60's....we punched the crap out of that poor doll because it was fun, until we punched it so hard it hit and broke the ceiling light fixture made of glass that put a rip in our punch doll. RIP Punch Doll....mom had no punches in the game, dad was no where to be seen.
And everyone said violent game film and animation still safe for children. Yes, those who said that never learn this theory.
Hu guys frow CVLIS
I only say this: "monkey see, monkey do"
True
as a psychologist,i say : this clip is NOT true !!! it's apalling and i'm outraged of this clip. what bandura demonstrated is that the MOST important thing is the punishment or reward that the agressive adult receives. the children will be more agressive if the model was rewarded,and less agressive if the model was punished. everything else is a lie
Thanks for sharing your criticism
Wow ,this video is great ,and the explanation is outstanding 💓🤌
Girls voice behind this video is so ❣️
She will make such a cute lovely teacher
Little kitten voice she has.