I'm unable to stop staring at how perfectly the level of the Remus on the wall lines up the the bottom of the shelf to its left. That is OCD perfection.
I really like Dans list. Even though all but one is finished, the finishing can add such complexity of flavors to the whisky that is just an experience. Also like how he threw in a few cheaper options like Top Floor. That’s my go to crushable whisky.
So the double barrel on the fort Hamilton I believe is a bit of a misnomer. It is the blending of 2 different barrels not rebarreled. I sampled some of their rye distillate sent to me by the owner for a barrel pick and it is pretty good.
I was at sagamore this weekend and the port was 100. I did like it but I only gonna buy 1 bottle and I liked the sherry finish better, so went with that one. But I do recommend checking out sagamore if you’re in the area.
Good video. I am not sure if I will see any of these in our area. I dol like what you did for your bottle storage in the back. Looks great lit up like it is.
Had the Bardstown orgin bourbons last September when I did a tour. Really enjoyed all 3, but the high rye was my favorite. Tried them all straight from the barrel at about 126 proof, and they were great.
How the heck do I know which list is better. I haven’t even heard of 8 of these picks. So much Bourbon out there. I should have started sooner in life. Thanks for the content fellas.
Been searching for the Chatt Cab Finish for weeks and finally got my hands on it today. So stoked to grab it and it fully held up. Was absolutely floored by it. Big fan!
Love y’all’s channel! Do you guys have a video about that wall and it’s set up? That’s sick! I’m doing a whiskey/cigar room and would love something like those single bottle lighted shelves
I am in Texas and appreciate fine whiskey from all over - but especially Kentucky - and love Rebecca Creek (with the exception of their BiB which I think is overpriced at $50 for what it is). The Double Barrel Spanish Oak from Rebecca Creek is so good, I'm on my 3rd bottle! Absolutely delicious desert whiskey worth every penny!
Really cool that you did the Diet Coke for Mom.A+I (in my opinion) wish I could see you guys responces if there are any. But in essence that makes my comment “One Sided” Hopefully I will figure out how to see responses because I’ve been watching you guys for 5-6 years and ya make it fun
@Dan you pronounced Boordy Vinyards right (board-ie). I drive by Boordy on my way to work each day. A lot of folks (wine snobs) don't like Boordy cause their wines are particularly very sweet and are often compared to basically being Welch's grape fruit juice. That being said, I can 100% see how that would lead to being solid barrels for finishing whiskey. Love the lineup on this video. Keep doing great things, fellas. I'm cheering you on.
Michigan guy here I was shocked how much I enjoyed new Holland origins And Bardstown white label is fucking fantastic for the price and availability.. beats out every other 40ish bottle whiskey that’s not rare breed.. maybe put it above four roses single barrel which is hard for me to say out loud
Gotta go with Sean here. I love the starlight finishes, especially the VDN and Cigar batches. Also, gotta love Chattanooga whiskey. A brand that ive been obsessed with recently is New Riff, there stuff is awesome.
I think High & Wicked is sourced from New Riff (undisclosed sources). If that is truly is the case you are better off getting a barrel pick of their rye. or the 100% malted rye. amazing juice.
Dan the Sagamore port 2022 release is amazing I love it. It’s alot better then batch 10 of MWND. That being said I think it’s basically distillery only this year not nearly as wide as the sherry finish which is also fire
Speaking of Justin’s House of Bourbon… you should do a discuss video about the investigation that was released the other day. Curious to hear your perspective on the whole situation and how it might affect the market in the future
Live right next to Rebecca Creek in the state that Sean had a hard time pronouncing. Will say that one is dang good. Definitely their best release I've had.
I have to give the win to Sean just because he put Starlight in there since Im the ultimate fanboy. But the best bottle in the video might be that Sagamore, they are killing everything they put out! So a very close 2nd to Dan. Overall, a great list and some bottles that everyone needs to have on their shelves!
@@davidvoth7218 any of their family reserve bottles that they put out on Repeal Day are always exceptional. As far as more easily found bottles, Honey finished rye, Rum finished rye, Double oaked bourbon and rye, and probably Pineau de Charentes finished rye would be my top 5 that I currently have.
Haven't tried the port yet, but I've compared the Starlight Sherry Finish and Sagamore Sherry Finish side by side and the Starlight took the win for me.
I think you misquoted the price on this year's sagamore port finish. It's $100 at the distillery. That said, you're completely right, better than Midwinters Act 10, at least to me. Great list!
If you could break into the video, ninja style, and grab 2 bottles without Sean & Dan noticing, which 2 bottles would you grab??? Mine would be Stagg & Old Carter. But that’s just because 1910 isn’t on the wall. It’s “a cherry pop tart on a traeger!” Lol. ❤ you guys!!! But be sure to lock the studio!!!
Depends who you are. In my experience people who are huge buffalo trace fans dont like the full proof much, and people who are not big buffalo trace fans think its the worst one. Im personally of the opinion that full proof is by far the best, but im also rarely into bt products.
I was able to get a bottle of Rare Character Kentucky Rye that is BBC first run at 95/5... it is absolutely incredible. When their own rye distillate reaches 6 years the single barrel program will be loaded
Great video. The 3 most recent bottles I've bought are Starlight, Sagamore, and Bardstown. All hitters. I look forward to trying some of your other recommendations.
Sean, been on the fence about the Cab Chatt. I love their Single Barrels and haven’t loved many wine finished bourbons. I am now going to be 60 smackers poorer. Thanks! #TEAMDAN😂
I hear ya! Just giving you a hard time. It stands alone at the top of the mountain for value at $50. It is the clear exception. Great content as always.
I'm unable to stop staring at how perfectly the level of the Remus on the wall lines up the the bottom of the shelf to its left. That is OCD perfection.
😱ohhhhhh so satisfying
Sagamore is just knocking it out of the park lately with their finished ryes. The Sherry, Port and Rum cask finishes were fanfreakingtastic
I appreciate this review. I will picking up Segamore Rye And Stonehammer when I next see it.
Thaks
Loved Dan's dig right out the gate and making that Early Times metal screw cap comment.
For a non-finished Sagamore, go with the 8 Year Reserve Series. Cask strength 8 year rye for $75 is hard to beat.
I was 9-1/2 lbs when I was born and I was a month early. Spent a month in the preemie ward with all the 2lb babies. Nurses called me The Hulk.
How tall are you now though?
@@easye47 5'7". It didn't last, lol.
@@danrudnick5252 I was also 9 1/2 pounds and I got to 6’3. Crazy how that happens
I was premie at about a month and a half early, 5lb’er & spent a month in the premie ward as well i got to 6’3
Sounds like gestational diabetes. Kids come out big but need extra support just for a few weeks.
I really like Dans list. Even though all but one is finished, the finishing can add such complexity of flavors to the whisky that is just an experience. Also like how he threw in a few cheaper options like Top Floor. That’s my go to crushable whisky.
So the double barrel on the fort Hamilton I believe is a bit of a misnomer. It is the blending of 2 different barrels not rebarreled. I sampled some of their rye distillate sent to me by the owner for a barrel pick and it is pretty good.
I was at sagamore this weekend and the port was 100. I did like it but I only gonna buy 1 bottle and I liked the sherry finish better, so went with that one. But I do recommend checking out sagamore if you’re in the area.
Stumbled across that Bardstown for under 50. I had to read it 2x, 6 yr old of their own stuff...and it's great.
Good video. I am not sure if I will see any of these in our area. I dol like what you did for your bottle storage in the back. Looks great lit up like it is.
I have the sherry sagamore, it's fantastic. Very rich, like chocolate raspberry cake.
Had the Bardstown orgin bourbons last September when I did a tour. Really enjoyed all 3, but the high rye was my favorite. Tried them all straight from the barrel at about 126 proof, and they were great.
Love this video idea guys. My hitter is Sagamore double oak. Just so freaking tasty.
How the heck do I know which list is better. I haven’t even heard of 8 of these picks. So much Bourbon out there. I should have started sooner in life. Thanks for the content fellas.
Been searching for the Chatt Cab Finish for weeks and finally got my hands on it today. So stoked to grab it and it fully held up. Was absolutely floored by it. Big fan!
Just picked up the both Bardstown Origin series. Both are great, wheated is greater.
So glad that Rebecca Creek made the list. Such a great bottle. And only 54ish bucks.
The sagamore port is legit!! It also wins it for Dan because that bottle is fantastic!! Cheers
Loving this!!!
Next time you’re in Brooklyn, be sure to stop by!
Cheers 🥃
Just picked up the white label Bardstown for $45. I live in Michigan. Looking forward to popping it tonight
Love y’all’s channel! Do you guys have a video about that wall and it’s set up? That’s sick! I’m doing a whiskey/cigar room and would love something like those single bottle lighted shelves
We might on an old vlog
Just tried a 7 year Sagamore barrell pick, and hot damn! It’s hard to imagine beating that one, except maybe a finished one
Recently went to Fort Hamilton and did a tasting. Their cask strength rye was really good. If you can get your hands on that, I think you’d like it.
The pick I bought is a cask strength rye its great!
I am in Texas and appreciate fine whiskey from all over - but especially Kentucky - and love Rebecca Creek (with the exception of their BiB which I think is overpriced at $50 for what it is). The Double Barrel Spanish Oak from Rebecca Creek is so good, I'm on my 3rd bottle! Absolutely delicious desert whiskey worth every penny!
The Key & Peele insert was hysterical 😂
So bartstown is getting rid of the fusion series and they have a bottle and bonded coming out and it so good check it out when u see it
Really cool that you did the Diet Coke for Mom.A+I (in my opinion)
wish I could see you guys responces if there are any.
But in essence that makes my comment “One Sided”
Hopefully I will figure out how to see responses because I’ve been watching you guys for 5-6 years and ya make it fun
I also must say I have a bottle of Mellick bourbon I really love this bottle
Fort Hamilton is an army base in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn NY. Walking distance from where I used to live.
So how does one get these whiskies? Most of them are not available in Michigan.
That Bardstown origins is so good....and available!
Benchmark Top Floor, Bonded & Full Proof are limited releases...not distributed to many states.
@Dan you pronounced Boordy Vinyards right (board-ie). I drive by Boordy on my way to work each day. A lot of folks (wine snobs) don't like Boordy cause their wines are particularly very sweet and are often compared to basically being Welch's grape fruit juice. That being said, I can 100% see how that would lead to being solid barrels for finishing whiskey.
Love the lineup on this video. Keep doing great things, fellas. I'm cheering you on.
Gotta go with Dan's list. Sometimes those younger and less expensive whiskies need a little help with some finishing.
Sagamore Rye Sherry Finished is also a hitter
The Woodenville Port Finished Rye is also a MWND comparator and at about 40% of the cost. Great bottle just impossible to find outside of WA.
That high rye origin from Bardstown is fucking awesome. Such a crushable bottle
Dan's so hammered!😂😂 love it cheers 🥃
I have been watching youz guyz awhile now and just realized you are from my neck of the woods I am from Midland Michigan
Probably the best Sean haircut I’ve seen to date. 😅
Going to Holland this week, can you buy Origin at the Distillery?
Pretty sure you can
@@BourbonJunkies got it, a couple of the single malts and the amazing Wheater they have!
Michigan guy here
I was shocked how much I enjoyed new Holland origins
And Bardstown white label is fucking fantastic for the price and availability.. beats out every other 40ish bottle whiskey that’s not rare breed.. maybe put it above four roses single barrel which is hard for me to say out loud
Since you guys mentioned Justin’s you should talk about the ATF raid that happened there a few weeks ago.
I thought the new Sagamore Port was distillery only or otherwise very limited? Price also sounds too low.
Yea people have commented that it's actually $100
Have you guys tried any of the tim smith line?
So, only 3 of the 10 can be found in a store in MI? Which online retailers are the ones who avoid MI shipping restrictions?
Gotta go with Sean here. I love the starlight finishes, especially the VDN and Cigar batches. Also, gotta love Chattanooga whiskey. A brand that ive been obsessed with recently is New Riff, there stuff is awesome.
That Benchmark Top Floor is $13.50 in Houston. 💪💪💪
So they're basically giving it away 😂
I couldn’t agree more with the RC Double Barrel. My local store was selling their pick for only $45 so I bought a few. Just crazy good.
Ever had Ben Holladay bottled in bond bourbon from Missouri?
I think High & Wicked is sourced from New Riff (undisclosed sources). If that is truly is the case you are better off getting a barrel pick of their rye. or the 100% malted rye. amazing juice.
I really enjoy the little descriptions under yalls names.
Fort Hamilton rye is delicious. If you can find a higher proof store pick 👏👍
Dan the Sagamore port 2022 release is amazing I love it. It’s alot better then batch 10 of MWND. That being said I think it’s basically distillery only this year not nearly as wide as the sherry finish which is also fire
Got that Chattanooga for my birthday. It’s a hitter.
I totally just got the Rebecca Creek for my cousin and myself when I was in Texas! Haven’t gotten into it yet, but excited
Where the hell did you guys find this year's port finish for 80? It's 99 at the distillery, and I didn't think it had any distribution yet.
I think Dan was just wrongly stating the price
How did you find the cask strength high n wicked? Couldn't find it anywhere online and I haven't seen it in any stores
Being honest it was sent to us, but we have heard people finding it in the wild. There will be more batches, excited to see them
I love the hoodie Sean. Is it available for purchase anywhere? I couldn't find it on your site
What are oak cubes?
They're literally just hunks of wood in a mesh sock they put into the barrels
What do you guys think of Russell's Reserve for a $30-40???
I've been enjoying Legent lately. The neck pour is a little grainy and young, but after it gets some air into it; solid.
Shoutout to Chatt Whiskey!! Love the Cabernet finish
Sean, without a doubt wins with his list.
Speaking of Justin’s House of Bourbon… you should do a discuss video about the investigation that was released the other day. Curious to hear your perspective on the whole situation and how it might affect the market in the future
Live right next to Rebecca Creek in the state that Sean had a hard time pronouncing. Will say that one is dang good. Definitely their best release I've had.
BUT TEN WHISKEYS WONT FIT IN THE SHARE BAG! So excited to get mine Canada post is terrible and will take till mid next week, ordered last saturday
I'm in Houston, but I'm not a fan of TX whiskey. I'll give the RC a try. Thanks for the recommendations!
I have to give the win to Sean just because he put Starlight in there since Im the ultimate fanboy. But the best bottle in the video might be that Sagamore, they are killing everything they put out! So a very close 2nd to Dan. Overall, a great list and some bottles that everyone needs to have on their shelves!
a win is a win, I'll take it!
I also love Starlight. What do you think are the top 5 bottles Starlight makes?
@@davidvoth7218 any of their family reserve bottles that they put out on Repeal Day are always exceptional. As far as more easily found bottles, Honey finished rye, Rum finished rye, Double oaked bourbon and rye, and probably Pineau de Charentes finished rye would be my top 5 that I currently have.
Haven't tried the port yet, but I've compared the Starlight Sherry Finish and Sagamore Sherry Finish side by side and the Starlight took the win for me.
the audio is so much better when you use the mics vs the ones with the mic arms
I think you misquoted the price on this year's sagamore port finish. It's $100 at the distillery. That said, you're completely right, better than Midwinters Act 10, at least to me. Great list!
he was giving me crap for my $90 recommendation too!
Did they go up? I got my sherry for 78
@@GamerNxUSN the 2022 port finish sagamore was aged for a collective period of 8 years which had them push the price up for that bottle.
love the list! Is that an Octamore on the shelf back there?
Yes it is
I haven’t had the Bardstown Origin rye mash bourbon. The wheater bib is fantastic.
That is our Monday review, we really liked both though!
Rebecca Creek is a good mixer or neat in a pinch. They model their flavor profile on Crown.
Whats the link to that t shirt!?
Bought my starlight double oak store pick last week
My son told me that Sledgehammer at Fred Meyer (Kroger) in Monroe, WA is $25.00.
If you could break into the video, ninja style, and grab 2 bottles without Sean & Dan noticing, which 2 bottles would you grab??? Mine would be Stagg & Old Carter. But that’s just because 1910 isn’t on the wall. It’s “a cherry pop tart on a traeger!” Lol. ❤ you guys!!! But be sure to lock the studio!!!
Why no close-up shot for Chattanooga? 🥺
The Chattanooga’s have become a favorite…. The Cabernet, Cask, and Founders are excellent…
Starlight is killing it right now. Great stuff over there
Is that BM Top Floor better than the Full Proof?
Depends who you are. In my experience people who are huge buffalo trace fans dont like the full proof much, and people who are not big buffalo trace fans think its the worst one. Im personally of the opinion that full proof is by far the best, but im also rarely into bt products.
Sagamore sherry finish was better than the port finish imho but both were/are 🔥
The Bardstown Origins Rye is fantastic. Once it finally goes retail, you gotta try it. The BiB is super good too
I was able to get a bottle of Rare Character Kentucky Rye that is BBC first run at 95/5... it is absolutely incredible. When their own rye distillate reaches 6 years the single barrel program will be loaded
Great video. The 3 most recent bottles I've bought are Starlight, Sagamore, and Bardstown. All hitters. I look forward to trying some of your other recommendations.
Green spot is a pretty amazing Irish whiskey. If you haven't had that I HIGHLY recommend 👌
Big Starlight fan. The number of SL bottles in my collection is getting up there.
Love Top Floor. $14 here too!
Sean's list was better overall, but Dan finished strong with the Sagamore (tie for first between Sagamore and Bardstown)
Sean recommend that Chatty Cabernet finish. That’s enough to completely discount his opinion. Just awful! 🤢🤮
I have a Store Pick from Makers Mark that’s ridiculous and it’s Cask Strength I need to send
A key to keeping your bourbon secret is to come out of nowhere with a brand new company and ask for $90+ a bottle.
Cali Distillery's Mavericks DoubleWood! Double Wood and only $31! Ridiculous. 👍
I think you gents and I should have a sit down and a couple of drinks.
So, great content as always!
I plan on buying Bardstown 8 next week. After that, probably just staple rebuys.
Ragged branch wheated bib?
Check out Coppersea Distilling out of New Paltz NY
Sean, been on the fence about the Cab Chatt. I love their Single Barrels and haven’t loved many wine finished bourbons. I am now going to be 60 smackers poorer. Thanks! #TEAMDAN😂
Well I hope you enjoy it as much as I do!
“Gotta stop expecting the world for $50 whiskey!” Rarebreed says “Hello”.
yea but it's now few and far between for bottles in that category, and it's a legacy distillery with a line that's existed forever.
I hear ya! Just giving you a hard time. It stands alone at the top of the mountain for value at $50. It is the clear exception.
Great content as always.
Pursute united is amazing