I think you were pretty spot on with most of this list, but Throne of Eldraine should be sitting in perfection with Ikoria and honestly MH2 deserves to be up there too
Agree with everything apart from Kamigawa (should be in Prickly Perfection). You guys did a good job! Steve you need to draft Mystery Booster! Might be the best draft set of all time!
GIVEAWAY 🎉 Leave a comment saying your favourite and least favourite set from this tier list and we’ll pick one person at random, and send you a booster from your favourite set! 😊 Winner to be announced in the next video…
Fav set prob pherexia as i just really like some of the cards and art from it and least is probably jumpstart soley because of all the promo packs ive gotten have had dog awful pulls cool video though guys thanks for taking the time :)
Its Modern Horizons 2 thats my favourite out of all of these sets. I made a cube with this set as a base and added a few things to it to spice it up. Still never managed to open a Ragavan though! 😂
My favourites out of that lot is Dominaria utd. and Throne Of Eldraine, while my least favourite was the forgotten realms D&D and.. get ready... Ikoria!!
Bro you have 25 sets here. None of which I've heard of as an old-school magic the gathering player. There are 167 sets released over the past 31 years. I see in your description you clarify the clickbait title.
As Arena player I feel the same, Ikoria was the worst ever. Kinnan is absolutely overpowered, companions mechanic was broken by itself, some of the companions are overpowered and some unplayable at all, mutate mechanic is now almost useless and forgoten. In historic brawl only Lurrus, Winota and OP Kinnan can be seen today on regular basis. When there are sooo many staples from both Innistrad sets - curse of silense, wash away, fateful absence, infernal grasp, consider, fading hope, memory deluge, Jadar, meatchook masssacre, burn down the house, augur of autumn, Teferi. Plus much more healthy for the game commanders like Vadric, Tovolar, Jadar, Old Stickfingers.
honestly motm aftermath is the easiest to hate on but god karlov manor just felt disappointing and thematically and conceptually boring, at least motm *couldve* been good. feels the same as how things look with thunder junction and universes beyond with wotc caring less and less about the worlds and characters they made. fav out of them has to be either mh2 for the banger cards, or kamigawa and brothers war for the style/theme
D&D + Magic = Perfection. LOTR + Magic = Perfection. Now make a Harry Potter set WoTC. Don't let the tragic pathetic losers that hate JK rule your judgement
You guys focused too much on a hand-full of powerful cards from each set rather than whether sets had fun synergies and replay value.
I think you were pretty spot on with most of this list, but Throne of Eldraine should be sitting in perfection with Ikoria and honestly MH2 deserves to be up there too
-Hides under a rock with my adoration of the collective innistrad 2021 set-
@@adeadphish7931 🤣🤣🤣
Agree with everything apart from Kamigawa (should be in Prickly Perfection). You guys did a good job!
Steve you need to draft Mystery Booster! Might be the best draft set of all time!
Retrospectively I agree that Kamigawa needs to be higher
Kamigawa was only good if you're a w33b.
More recent, Bloomburrow was such a great set. Llorwyn part 2 with some of the best draft experience in years.
GIVEAWAY 🎉
Leave a comment saying your favourite and least favourite set from this tier list and we’ll pick one person at random, and send you a booster from your favourite set! 😊
Winner to be announced in the next video…
My favourite set is Theros Beyond Death.
My least favourite set is Brothers War
Fav set prob pherexia as i just really like some of the cards and art from it and least is probably jumpstart soley because of all the promo packs ive gotten have had dog awful pulls cool video though guys thanks for taking the time :)
Its Modern Horizons 2 thats my favourite out of all of these sets.
I made a cube with this set as a base and added a few things to it to spice it up.
Still never managed to open a Ragavan though! 😂
I’m in that club too! So many packs opened and not a single ragavan 😅
I feel like core set 21 was almost perfect. Strix and kald was my favorite sets behind Ikoria and core 21.
My favourites out of that lot is Dominaria utd. and Throne Of Eldraine, while my least favourite was the forgotten realms D&D and.. get ready... Ikoria!!
Ikoria is the GOAT and I won't hear otherwise haha
Bro you have 25 sets here. None of which I've heard of as an old-school magic the gathering player. There are 167 sets released over the past 31 years.
I see in your description you clarify the clickbait title.
My favourite set is crimson vow and my least favourite is ikoria
You’re an absolute animal 🤣
As Arena player I feel the same, Ikoria was the worst ever. Kinnan is absolutely overpowered, companions mechanic was broken by itself, some of the companions are overpowered and some unplayable at all, mutate mechanic is now almost useless and forgoten. In historic brawl only Lurrus, Winota and OP Kinnan can be seen today on regular basis.
When there are sooo many staples from both Innistrad sets - curse of silense, wash away, fateful absence, infernal grasp, consider, fading hope, memory deluge, Jadar, meatchook masssacre, burn down the house, augur of autumn, Teferi. Plus much more healthy for the game commanders like Vadric, Tovolar, Jadar, Old Stickfingers.
Yay, I am not alone under my rock of shame for liking Crimson Vow
Crimson Vow is Perfection !
Innistrad is my favorite set
Both of em, Ivorian is one of my least
I've never heard this said, ever haha
@@GatheringTheMagicYT ikoraia not Ivorian
More my favorite plane than set… but I still really like it.
What do you mean the first player reward card thats confidant or solemn? I don’t remember which came first.
honestly motm aftermath is the easiest to hate on but god karlov manor just felt disappointing and thematically and conceptually boring, at least motm *couldve* been good. feels the same as how things look with thunder junction and universes beyond with wotc caring less and less about the worlds and characters they made.
fav out of them has to be either mh2 for the banger cards, or kamigawa and brothers war for the style/theme
Are you rating these across all formats
We went for a variety of things. Enjoyment of playing/drafting the set, cards from the sets that we liked, and a variety of things!
Dominaria remastered???
Nice clickbait thumbnail lol
@@slackreviews thanks mate 😅😂
D&D + Magic = Perfection.
LOTR + Magic = Perfection.
Now make a Harry Potter set WoTC. Don't let the tragic pathetic losers that hate JK rule your judgement