I absolutely love the way, Carter spits out the ice because it brings it all the way back to him being Benton's student. Like it was just yesterday. The best cameo scene on the season.
I love how Benton is wearing the L token Carter gave to him around his neck when he was gifted it all leaving all those years ago...shows you how much Benton actually cared for Carter
But I love these guys and I love how uncomfortable this is, and I love that they're both clearly happy to see each other again, but neither of them really knows WHAT to say after all that time, and I love the little moment of silence right before Benton leaves, when you can see Carter in happy disbelief, and I LOVE how much is unsaid but instead communicated in their looks.
@@live2rock13 The whole stabbing and resultant tragedy fucked me up bad as a kid when the episodes first aired. It took me over 20 years to watch them again. Benton is amazing.
We saw the real depth of Benton’s love for John when he showed support for him in the “lounge drug intervention”, and outside the hospital when John fell apart. And who DIDN’T know Peter was going to be sitting beside John on the plane to Atlanta? Show of hands? That’s what I thought.
I love them together. I still see John’s first day as Peter’s medical student. Peter was so hard on him. But Carter knows he pushed him because Peter knew he had it. He flew to Atlanta when Carter went into drug rehab. Peter held him when he cried. They’re strong bond will always be there.
Even on his way out Benton still pushed Carter to be the best doctor he possibly could. Carter: Hey Peter, I’m a good doctor and it’s because of you. Benton: No you’re not but keep trying. (he says with a smile.)
@@sarakennedy2633-The actors- Eric LaSalle and Noah Wyle were actually good friends in real life? Is that what - IRL stands for- In Real LIfe. If that is true, I wish even more that Eric LaSalle would have guess starred on the Sci-Fi Show NOah did after ER- Faling Skies. It would have been really good to see those two acting together again.
The chemistry in this professional and personal relationship was so polar that it worked beautifully! Kudos to the story writers for building these character arcs around that anti-magnetism
This is a good reason why you should be careful asking people if they have kids. I still get sad every time I have to answer that question to someone, for similar reasons to Carter.
Can just imagine that amongst the many emotions Carter is feeling right then, relief is a big part of it. Sometimes, in a rough situation, an unexpected visit from your toughest, best teacher can help take the pressure off, can push away the uncertainty and doubt. Carter knows Benton is there and can trust in that, and also if Benton says he's in good hands with another surgeon, Carter knows it's no b.s.
what a reunion for both of them !!!! was so difficult for Benton to admitt his feelings for him after all those years . Carter instead appears very happy to see him in good condition
The last time Carter saw Benton was at Mark Greene’s funeral. It was sweet to see them reunite again and the happy look in Carter’s eyes and Benton is like well well look what the cat dragged in, my old med student haha 😂
And who was there when Carter was getting his new kidney Benton and who made sure the fluid for the new kidney when there was a problem during the operation Benton, the love between these two makes me cry with pleasure 😢😊❤️
Hermosa relación que formaron carter y benton!!!!! 😀😀😍😍👍👍👍Como lo cuida el , siempre lo apreció mucho primero fue su maestro , para terminar siendo como un padre!!!
In this scene, Carter asked the questions that we (the audience) wanted to ask Benton since we saw him leaving County for the last time: His son Reese is entering his teenage years. Benton returned to working at another Chicago hospital after a few years doing private practice. We can see Benton is doing fine for himself and living a stable life. It was clear both men lost touch with each other for a long time - which is a reminder that despite the medical fraternity it is no different than a paying job anywhere... you can befriend colleagues, but once you leave the hospital for other places or they do, chances are you will never see each other again even if you live in the same city. Carter was lucky he was in the hospital Benton was employed at.
He went to work at the Schaumburg Surgi-Centre actually. He worked out a completely new job in less than one day after Romano wouldn't budge on his schedule at County.
Something interesting that someone pointed out to me not too long ago is that Benton is wearing the L Token that Carter gave him the day he left County as a necklace here. Really cool little touch for this scene.
Why is Benton confused about Carter being in renal failure? He's the one who operated on him when he was stabbed and they almost couldn't save the kidney...anyway love the bromance they have lol although Benton's more of a mentor :)
Benton was able to save the kidney. What Benton doesn't know is that a few years later the kidney failed, and shortly after that, Carter caught some disease in Africa that basically took care of the other kidney.
Alyks Balewa that makes more sense. Do you know when they did the transplant how did they do it did they actually take his kidney out and put a new one in. I would love if u would get back to me so I can find out how they did it
@@graciegravitt6227 During kidney transplants, the old kidney does not come out. It’s position in the abdominal cavity as it were is termed “retroperitoneal”. Thus means that they lie behind “retro” the peritoneum which is a membrane that covers and is the lining of the major abdominal organs (it is obviously difficult to appreciate the anatomy without the use of pictures). In order to get to the kidneys, the peritoneum would need to be unnecessarily disturbed and leading to a high probability of infection by “gram negative enteric flora”(shit). They just put the new one in the front rather the back and say a quick prayer and close the FUCKER up
You know, I'm just still curious how the hell Benton would know that Carter is a)in Africa and b)married. Unless Carter sent out christmas cards from Africa with a picture of him and Kem that says "me and my wife", that makes no sense. ;)
Logical explanation: Benton likely bumped into other County staff by chance after he left there, and one of them told Benton of what Carter was last doing after asking about him. That is how he knew about the Africa story and the marriage but nothing further.
Was there a one year time jump that I keep forgetting because Reese was born in season 3 and this is season 15, so if they did not have a time jump, he should be 12, not 13. Or is this a retcon thing as it was with Rachel, who was five in the first season and was later retconned to have been seven?
There is an unsubstantiated rumor that the show will be re-booted. Several scripts have been gathering dust for quite some time but in the past year, some have gathered interest. Apparently, two scripts, in particular, may involve a cross-over episode(s) with other canceled NBC shows. Some recently canceled shows like "Third Watch" and others 'not so recent'. One of the "crossover" pilots will involve the two stars of the 1970s TV show "Emergency!". Interestingly both stars from that show Randolph Mantooth and Kevin Tighe appeared [separately] in the original run of "ER", but not in their "Emergency!" roles. The other script will reintroduce some characters from the ER cast and a few memorable patients as well as close some open storylines. This later script is written as a movie and may be presented as a two or three-parter. Curiously it would not be presented in the usual pilot series or "TV Movie" format for back-to-back viewing, within a week. Instead, the episodes would be broadcasted one day out of the week, over a two or three-week span. If it does get 'greenlit' look to see Anthony Edwards, Eric La Salle, and Noah Wyle producing, acting and or directing. Mr. La Salle was the closest to the late Mr. Crichton, and I would not be surprised if he and or Mr. Edwards directed this new chapter in the lives of "Those folks from County...".
Блять, я хихикаю как сука с их реюниона. Лучшие просто. Если вы вдруг решили просмотреть эту легенду - добро пожаловать на лучшую сторону этого сериала. Вы не прогадали.
![Republic Commando: 100% Walkthrough - Longplay [No Commentary] [4K] Hard+No Damage](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DIeNxsjq8OA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Warhammer 40k: Space Marine 2 | เพื่อจักรพรรดิ ! [ตอนเดียวจบ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4M0ckYMA4-U/mqdefault.jpg)
I absolutely love the way, Carter spits out the ice because it brings it all the way back to him being Benton's student. Like it was just yesterday. The best cameo scene on the season.
I love how Benton is wearing the L token Carter gave to him around his neck when he was gifted it all leaving all those years ago...shows you how much Benton actually cared for Carter
I never noticed that!
yeah. it's a fondamental moment for both of them and it's so a difficoult ammount of feelings still present there !!!!!!
Yeah...well...that's not the token - LaSalle wears this necklace all the time - it has a cross on it....
Never noticed this
As already commented here, it is not an L token… it’s indeed a cross that Eriq La Salle can still be seen wearing at events recently.
But I love these guys and I love how uncomfortable this is, and I love that they're both clearly happy to see each other again, but neither of them really knows WHAT to say after all that time, and I love the little moment of silence right before Benton leaves, when you can see Carter in happy disbelief, and I LOVE how much is unsaid but instead communicated in their looks.
This 💯
Benton running to his side after his stabbing was the most powerful thing.
Agreed!
"IS HE CONCIOUS!?!?!"
That whole episode messed me up for a while.
@@live2rock13 The whole stabbing and resultant tragedy fucked me up bad as a kid when the episodes first aired. It took me over 20 years to watch them again.
Benton is amazing.
We saw the real depth of Benton’s love for John when he showed support for him in the “lounge drug intervention”, and outside the hospital when John fell apart.
And who DIDN’T know Peter was going to be sitting beside John on the plane to Atlanta?
Show of hands?
That’s what I thought.
@@cards0486That's the scene for me. Still tears me up to this day.
This was amazing. Student and mentor reunited. I’ll never forget how hard Benton used to be on Carter back in seasons 1-2
Os benton leave the series or they met up after a long time can u explain me this?
He was hard on him because he showed the most potential of any med student he ever had.
@@fareehamughal2676 Both
Carter is like a little brother to Peter and they have such an amazing relationship
I love them together. I still see John’s first day as Peter’s medical student. Peter was so hard on him. But Carter knows he pushed him because Peter knew he had it. He flew to Atlanta when Carter went into drug rehab. Peter held him when he cried. They’re strong bond will always be there.
Even on his way out Benton still pushed Carter to be the best doctor he possibly could. Carter: Hey Peter, I’m a good doctor and it’s because of you.
Benton: No you’re not but keep trying. (he says with a smile.)
They just work well together. From the beginning to the end. Great acting 👏
Laura MacGregor the fact that they were good friends IRL probably helped.
@@sarakennedy2633-The actors- Eric LaSalle and Noah Wyle were actually good friends in real life? Is that what - IRL stands for- In Real LIfe. If that is true, I wish even more that Eric LaSalle would have guess starred on the Sci-Fi Show NOah did after ER- Faling Skies. It would have been really good to see those two acting together again.
"You look ridiculous,Carter." haha love that line.
Lara Abdallah my favorite is what the hell are you doing.
"You look ridiculous Carter"
What was once an insult from Benton to Carter as teacher to student, is now a friendly barb between two close friends.
Eriq La Salle....absolute legend....
He truly let his Soul Glow…
@@gawainethefirst I bet he got that from fighting lions and tigers and sh…
The chemistry in this professional and personal relationship was so polar that it worked beautifully!
Kudos to the story writers for building these character arcs around that anti-magnetism
Awwww, this is so sweet!! Men who don't want to show their deep feelings but you can tell the feelings are definitely there. :)
24 dislikes???? These 2 had a better relationship than twilight and any other film pair!
Thousands of movies are better then twilight trash
These two need to star in a series together again. Great chemistry.
carter's hesitation after benton asked if he has kids is heartbreaking
Yet he knew he was in Africa and that he was married
This is a good reason why you should be careful asking people if they have kids. I still get sad every time I have to answer that question to someone, for similar reasons to Carter.
What was the problem?
@@carinabaptista9726 his baby died.
Benton didn’t know about baby Josh? 💔😢
Can just imagine that amongst the many emotions Carter is feeling right then, relief is a big part of it. Sometimes, in a rough situation, an unexpected visit from your toughest, best teacher can help take the pressure off, can push away the uncertainty and doubt. Carter knows Benton is there and can trust in that, and also if Benton says he's in good hands with another surgeon, Carter knows it's no b.s.
I love that all the original staff came back for the last couple episodes.
Spitting the ice out like it was back to Season 1 and Carter was a 3rd year MADE this for me.
what a reunion for both of them !!!! was so difficult for Benton to admitt his feelings for him after all those years . Carter instead appears very happy to see him in good condition
The last time Carter saw Benton was at Mark Greene’s funeral. It was sweet to see them reunite again and the happy look in Carter’s eyes and Benton is like well well look what the cat dragged in, my old med student haha 😂
Eric has such a beautiful smile I missed seeing him in the later episodes
HES WEARING THE EL TOKEN AS A NECKLACE CARTER GAVE HIM
Kareem C oh my god he is! 😱🥰
Holy crap, how did I miss that?!
Wow I never noticed that
holy shit
Wow I had forgotten about the tokens for the el and subway trains here. I used to always have rolls of those before they got rid them.
And who was there when Carter was getting his new kidney Benton and who made sure the fluid for the new kidney when there was a problem during the operation Benton, the love between these two makes me cry with pleasure 😢😊❤️
I feel like Dr. Benton is forever saying "I've got a hernia"...
This was a really good show and this amplified that
I forgot how awesome this show was.
In the words of carter "is a long story"
Watch the 6,7,8,9,10 and 11 seasons.
Cater and Benton together again
I love them together.
Love carter
Hermosa relación que formaron carter y benton!!!!! 😀😀😍😍👍👍👍Como lo cuida el , siempre lo apreció mucho primero fue su maestro , para terminar siendo como un padre!!!
Excuse me, but in this Country we speak English.
at 1:10, after Benton asks Carter if he's got children -- Carter's face -- Josh would be about four if he had survived, would he? Mwah...sad.
ashli674 Aaaah, who's Josh??
Catherine Gabriel Carter and kem's baby that died shortly after birth.
@@sarakennedy2633 he died inside Kem's womb...she had to deliver him...so , so sad😔😔😔😢
I..,,can’t even imagine having to literally push.a baby out when it’s not alive….so awful 😢 😩
Carter’s baby boy who was stillborn 💔
Reese would be 27 now…. And probably in residency!! 😮
In this scene, Carter asked the questions that we (the audience) wanted to ask Benton since we saw him leaving County for the last time: His son Reese is entering his teenage years. Benton returned to working at another Chicago hospital after a few years doing private practice. We can see Benton is doing fine for himself and living a stable life. It was clear both men lost touch with each other for a long time - which is a reminder that despite the medical fraternity it is no different than a paying job anywhere... you can befriend colleagues, but once you leave the hospital for other places or they do, chances are you will never see each other again even if you live in the same city. Carter was lucky he was in the hospital Benton was employed at.
*Carter was lucky he was in the hospital where Peter was employed.*
Reese is deaf, right?
What a scene!
i remember when in like season 3 carter operates benton
smarty1727374757 why did Benton have surgery
Gracie Gravitt appendectomy.
Oh, there is a God!!! (Scrubs his skin out of his arm) 😁😁😁
@@veroniquelebeau2692
With that Kool-Aid smile...
benton is my idol..ever since the very first season...sucked he left
I remember Benton leaving to go to Northwestern back in s8
He went to work at the Schaumburg Surgi-Centre actually. He worked out a completely new job in less than one day after Romano wouldn't budge on his schedule at County.
carter's watching the ellen show xD
Reese was in love with Rachel Greene cause she was so smart
Benton came in like: *"JUSS LET YO SOOOOOUL GLOOOOOOWWW!!"*
Something interesting that someone pointed out to me not too long ago is that Benton is wearing the L Token that Carter gave him the day he left County as a necklace here. Really cool little touch for this scene.
Was that Dr Doug Ross at the very end of the video?
lamingtons101 yes, it was. it was like a coming together type of thing
One of the best epidodes in the later years of ER when carol Doug and Benton all come back for an episode
Doug and Carol were working as transplant/ donor coordinators in Seattle (I think). Great episode
Benton showed up for Carter when he opened up that center in honor of his son
Finally, Peter Benton becomes General Surgeon or other more prestigious specialty???
I MUST get the series on DVR, because I DON'T remember this at all! (NOT to mention Reese turning 13)?? I only remember Reese being a baby.
Catherine Gabriel IT'S ON HULU NOW!!!
Catherine Gabriel its on Hulu all seasons
my mouth was on the ground when Peter walked in i was like ' NO FRIGGIN WAY!!! BENTON'S BACK!!
Why is Benton confused about Carter being in renal failure? He's the one who operated on him when he was stabbed and they almost couldn't save the kidney...anyway love the bromance they have lol although Benton's more of a mentor :)
Benton was able to save the kidney. What Benton doesn't know is that a few years later the kidney failed, and shortly after that, Carter caught some disease in Africa that basically took care of the other kidney.
Alyks Balewa that makes more sense. Do you know when they did the transplant how did they do it did they actually take his kidney out and put a new one in. I would love if u would get back to me so I can find out how they did it
@@graciegravitt6227 You mean how they did it with Carter or kidney transplant in general?
@@graciegravitt6227 During kidney transplants, the old kidney does not come out. It’s position in the abdominal cavity as it were is termed “retroperitoneal”. Thus means that they lie behind “retro” the peritoneum which is a membrane that covers and is the lining of the major abdominal organs (it is obviously difficult to appreciate the anatomy without the use of pictures). In order to get to the kidneys, the peritoneum would need to be unnecessarily disturbed and leading to a high probability of infection by “gram negative enteric flora”(shit). They just put the new one in the front rather the back and say a quick prayer and close the FUCKER up
@@graciegravitt6227 Watch the full episode
He's watching Ellen lol.
Happy birthday noah alias carter john from italian boy live in rome and I m fan of er
Carter was Benton's student
Peter reminds me of my big brother.
Make no mistake ER is the story of John Carter.
I still remember when Dr. Benton didn't know his own blood type.
Haha on one of her episodes she mentioned that she was in ER and then they showed this scene lol :)
“Her” who?
EDIT: 11 years ago? Nevermind.
Yes! What the hell???
My childhood
Peter has the coin he made onto a necklace
Ellen?
Who saw he was watching Ellen on the TV lol
Carter met Benton in 1994 so the title is inaccurate.
It's that guy from Logan
NMH looks way nicer inside in real life. :-D
sunrise10086 Who is NMH??
Northwestern Hospital most likely
Reunion
Benton and Carter law and order Chicago
You know, I'm just still curious how the hell Benton would know that Carter is a)in Africa and b)married. Unless Carter sent out christmas cards from Africa with a picture of him and Kem that says "me and my wife", that makes no sense. ;)
Logical explanation: Benton likely bumped into other County staff by chance after he left there, and one of them told Benton of what Carter was last doing after asking about him. That is how he knew about the Africa story and the marriage but nothing further.
See Peter knew he was in Africa and that he had gotten married
Was there a one year time jump that I keep forgetting because Reese was born in season 3 and this is season 15, so if they did not have a time jump, he should be 12, not 13. Or is this a retcon thing as it was with Rachel, who was five in the first season and was later retconned to have been seven?
I think they did do a time jump for at least the series finale but I’m not sure
Maybe when Abby goes in the rehab
Today noah wyle 52 years
Happy birthday at eriq la salle from italian boy live in rome and i m fan of er
There's ELLEN in the background.has anyone notice?
What season is this
Melissa Humphrey it's season 15
Melissa Humphrey season 15 aka the final season.
What hospital was Carter at again?
Northwestern (thus the NW on Benton’s coat).
What season was this?
last
How is that possible cater is watching the ellen degeneres show.
Now er was filmed on the same lot building before the ellen show aired..
Dinah
BrittneyGdbis
There is an unsubstantiated rumor that the show will be re-booted. Several scripts have been gathering dust for quite some time but in the past year, some have gathered interest. Apparently, two scripts, in particular, may involve a cross-over episode(s) with other canceled NBC shows. Some recently canceled shows like "Third Watch" and others 'not so recent'. One of the "crossover" pilots will involve the two stars of the 1970s TV show "Emergency!". Interestingly both stars from that show Randolph Mantooth and Kevin Tighe appeared [separately] in the original run of "ER", but not in their "Emergency!" roles. The other script will reintroduce some characters from the ER cast and a few memorable patients as well as close some open storylines. This later script is written as a movie and may be presented as a two or three-parter. Curiously it would not be presented in the usual pilot series or "TV Movie" format for back-to-back viewing, within a week. Instead, the episodes would be broadcasted one day out of the week, over a two or three-week span. If it does get 'greenlit' look to see Anthony Edwards, Eric La Salle, and Noah Wyle producing, acting and or directing. Mr. La Salle was the closest to the late Mr. Crichton, and I would not be surprised if he and or Mr. Edwards directed this new chapter in the lives of "Those folks from County...".
Nope
What season is this? I’m on season 9 and haven’t seen this yet????
I believe this is the last season. They called back all the OG cast including the bigwigs lime George Clooney.
Блять, я хихикаю как сука с их реюниона. Лучшие просто. Если вы вдруг решили просмотреть эту легенду - добро пожаловать на лучшую сторону этого сериала. Вы не прогадали.
Watch your language
@@l.a.3479 Вотч ё ленгвидж, мудила. Ты мне еще, блять, расскажи как любимый сериал обсуждать. Иди нахуй. Люблю тебя.
What season was this
Season 15
Do you remember want episode
15x19 “old times”
There's ELLEN in the background.has anyone notice?
adnamaLOVE Had anyone NOTICED (past tense)
@@catherinegabriel760 Actually, it's: "Has anyone noticed?" 😉 (Present Perfect)
Past Tense would be: "Did anyone notice?" 😏