Yo I just had a trial of some sort (sounds like a cult but it’s not) and part of it we had to fast, all I had for food is a box of raisins and a pop tart. Would this be enough to slow my metabolism down. Because I have pretty high metabolism and I’m in puberty so I was confused why I wasn’t really hungry.
I think that the reason Finnick starts with rescue breaths when he's doing CPR is because he comes from the fishing district, so he's probably used to doing CPR for drowning victims, which is the one case where you ARE supposed to start with breaths before compressions
In the book, Peeta's leg doesn't heal. They get the infection under control, but they end up amputating the leg once they get out of the game because a tourniquet that was later used blocked off the blood supply for too long.
Fun Fact! Peeta's wounded leg is amputated in the book as a result of being stabbed in the thigh and it being left to fester like in the scene. He uses a prosthetic leg in the books though they chose not to amputate his leg in the movie at all. Meanwhile, Katniss is partly deaf in one of her ears due to being too close to the explosion when she set off a mine destroying the most fight efficient kids food supply. This affects her ability for the rest of the 1st game. She is healed later on but has a deformed ear due to external damage. The books are really good. It shows mental health issues, addiction to morphine, and going through traumatic grief and ptsd. The theme of how the media chooses what to promote and what to hide, where Katniss' drive for survival is turned into just a romance story (exactly what the irl media did btw) was probably what was most lost in translation to film.
I love the books I'm probably gonna read them for the sixth time just because of this video, and I don't like how the films didn't include katniss' deafness it wouldn't have been a big thing to include 😊
I agree. I enjoy the movies, but the books were more immersive for me. I think the movies should've gone full-on Hunger Games... You need that brutal grittiness (injuries, actions, politics, etc). It's a chilling "what if" and a reminder of what humans are technically capable of as a society.
@@EmpressMeg yeahh exactly, I do love dystopian books for exactly the reason you said! Like film adaptations are good but the books are way better, especially with Shadowhunters and divergent series
Not quite. Peeta's festering wound is mostly healed from the medicine Katniss retrieves at from the cornucopia. But he sustains another injury lower on his leg while escaping from the mutts. Katniss can only stop the bleeding by applying a tourniquet, which results in the amputation.
in the book katniss references the fact that she feel pain from the burn as good, as just like Dr Mike said, if the wound is extremely bad the nerve endings are damaged, which she knew from when her mother was treating burn victims from the mines
I think it’s important to note that the Hunger Games take place like 300 years into the future or something like that. They often use things that have a base that we recognize (regular wasps to tracker jackets, mustard gas turned into the poisonous fog) which has been scientifically modified to be extremely deadly. But that also means they have advanced medicine, like the healing salve. Also, Johanna was joking about the lung. It’s her taking a jab at how she views Katniss as being coddled.
@@ShethTora fennick (?) was from the fishing district so the only cpr he would probably be trained in would be for someone drowning which I believe you do start with rescue breaths for
While I'm not qualified to pick out all medical inaccuracies, I will give a pass to CPR not being done right. It's probably not good to do real CPR on someone who is just *pretending* to need it.
@@NinjaFlibble Also Finnick is from the Fishing District where he's probably used to doing CPR on drowning victims where you are supposed to start with rescue breaths, he's probably never learnt how to do it another way
This movie happens way in the future in the first book they have technology good enough to heal every one of katniss's wounds in less than a day so the tech and medicine they have are likely far better than currently
The scene where Johanna says, “I’m surprised they haven’t found you a new lung,” is meant in a sarcastic way. Johanna didn’t exactly like Katniss, but they ended up quite close after that scene. Finnick is from a fishing district which explains the breaths first. Cato’s death is so much more drawn out and traumatic in the book that Peeta actually ends up with a prosthetic. Peetas wound was to the bone and he had blood poisoning which is what that medicine was for. The Capitol had been engineering the mutations for years so the Tribute/Wolf mutts and the Trackerjackers were more lethal than a snake could ever be. Well besides Dr Gaul’s rainbow snakes that cause colorful blisters and death in the cases that aren’t treated immediately.
@@LetMeFLY649 Yes this, the mockingjays which were titular in the series were another example of a mutant engineered for war. What cracks me up is this hellscape society has wasps like that which exist in nature now. We can't do anything about the wasps we have now and these jackasses made worse ones.
i think what primrose meant was "it missed your eye. Doesn''t need stitches." as in two separate statements. anyways †hat wink from Bear was everything
Yeah that’s my interpretation too. She was saying, “It missed your eye, AND it doesn’t need stitches,” rather than “It missed your eye, SO it doesn’t need stitches.”
Aktually Finick did mouth-to-mouth because he is from a fishing district. so he probably only learned it that way. Funny thing Katniss never seen anyone doing that so she though he was legit just kissing a dying peeta!
I thought the same! I don’t know if Suzanne Collins wrote in the mouth-to-mouth intentionally knowing that rescue breaths are part of drowning protocol, but it fits with the character nonetheless!
@@pomelopompelmoKatniss mentions how Finnick looks like he’d done it many times before so I think Suzanne was alluding the fact his district trade meant he’d encountered his fair share of drowning vicitms.
Katniss didn’t think Finnick was kissing Peeta-she didn’t trust him yet, so she drew her bow and arrow thinking Finnick was going to hurt Peeta further.
I actually didn’t know that about doing mouth to mouth first for drowning victims until now. The more you know. And it does fit for Finnick’s character.
A couple things about the mouth-to-mouth and chest compressions scene. Katniss comes from a very poor and uneducated district and actually does not know about CPR (she's very confused about what Finnick is doing to Peeta). Also, Finnick (the one doing mouth-to-mouth and compressions) comes from a water district and knows CPR because it's useful in an aquatic area. I assume the CPR he is trained in is only for drowning, so he just knows to give mouth-to-mouth when someone isn't breathing. It seems wrong in the moment, but that's kind of the point. The districts are very oppressed and lacking a lot of education/knowledge. Also, Katniss's mother (the one with the shaking hands) does not have Parkinsons. She's just a very nervous and mentally broken person and was shaking from her nerves.
If that was intentional and not just a movie medical misconception like the shocking to bring someone back that has flatline rhythm that would be an impressive attention to detail.
The reason her hands were shaking is because she was a healer, the towns greatest, but then her husband dies in a mine explosion and she becomes very distant, like distant enough that she basically disappeared for years. She never really becomes herself again, ever. Plus with Katniss having been in the games before she's got a lot of mental trauma.
Which would also be more medically accurate, or realistic anyway. Although technichally I think the reason they amputaded his leg was because Katniss made a tourniqet and Peeta lost bloodflow to the leg for so long they had to amputate
Also, his name is Peeta, he got a sponsor (someone who sends tributes gifts during the games), of the camouflage supplies. He is so good from decorating cakes in his parent’s bakery. Edit: I think he made the paints by himself actually, oops…
Katniss' mom's hands were shaking because she had a lot of mental health issues and anxiety. She was better by the time the movies take place but she still had a lot of anxiety and gets nervous easily. Treating Gale, a close friend of her daughter's and the son of her late husband's friend (who died when her husband did), was hard on her. Which is why Prim took over because they know how hard she struggles mentally when things get tough.
In the books, it says that Prim had to grow up too fast because of her family's hard times, and during those times she was helping her mother, tending the sick and wounded like a pro. Fun fact, Katniss is the hunter but gets squeamish around wounds on people and unsure how to help them, while Prim is a timid little girl who would never hurt any living thing, and here she is treating various sicknesses and horrible wounds without flinching! She was being trained to become a doctor in District 13. That's why...she was in the Capitol, trying to save wounded children when the Rebels attacked. She was officially one of the medics. And then...the second parachutes went off.
During an interview at the time of the movies, Jennifer Lawrence said that her costars called her character "Catpiss Neverclean" behind the scenes just for giggles.
As someone who has read he books, Tracker Jacker stings are MUCH worse than the movie shows them. Katniss actually hallucinates oranges bubbles, and ants crawling up her and eating her eyes out, as well as Glimmer having green ooze seeping from her giant blisters, ouch. Also,'Peter the stone' got me dying 😅
about the bruised lung comment: I think she was being sarcastic. That character is very cynical and is referring to the fact that Katniss is the resistance's 'Golden Girl' into starting (and hopefully winning) a full on revolution. So they'd give her preferential treatment, especially for medical situations.
In the first book Katniss mentions that her mom had brought in patients with 4th degree burns and that she was scarred from that and ran out of the house but found out that the patient wasn’t in as much pain because the nerves were burned off. So she was hoping that is what had happened and she almost threw up after viewing the burn that she had.
To add context as to why Katniss's mum's hand is shaking, it's because she hasn't had to treat a flogging in a long time. The dude flogging Gale is the new head Peacekeeper, and he was much harsher than those who came before
8:54 she didn't say katniss didn't stitches because it missed her eye. She said two separete non related things It missed her eye. She doesn't need stitches.
They were also in a poor and uneducated district so maybe she didn't really know it could still need stitches. or maybe gales injuries were of more concern with possibly limited stitching materials.
I love how Doctor Mike watches these with none to very little context! He's understandably busy, so I'm sure he's given selected clips. It find it amusing af...but also frustrating when it's something I know intimately like Hunger Games, HP, House, etc. It's not so much the lack of in-verse (in-universe?) knowledge, but knowledge that, if Doctor Mike knew of it, could give us even more informative and interesting med info. I hope he does Star Trek. Not the reboots, but the older series like TNG, DS9, VOY, and ENT. Some injuries, he can only make an educated guess on what's happening. But certain medical advancements are actually possible, given enough time n research. A Bio-bed and a medical tricorder would be a perfect start.
That would be awesome! Star Trek ages so weirdly because they have warp drives and transporters, but their computers and medicine are half stuck in the 90s, and half absurdly and unrealistically advanced. Like in Voyager, when Neelix gets his lungs stolen and they give him holographic lungs, which will probably never be possible, but they somehow can't 3d print (or replicate) him new ones even though we're like 20 years away from being able to do that. I know they were doing an iron lung metaphor, but it's still strange to me.
@@mushu_beardie2556 And wasn't Neelix unable to move much because the holo-lungs were only in one spot? Like, moving misaligned them a bit? I would think The Doctor could program the lungs to move with Neelix.. He'd still be stuck in Sickbay, but able to move around. But I guess they needed it for the drama. But, yes, they could have used Neelix's own DNA to grow him some new lungs. I find it strange that the Doctor used one of Kes's lungs. Besides blood types and other factors (I assume, in the Trek future, they can do something to donor organs/tissues to make them compatible so there's no rejection), Ocampa and Talaxians are very different. Ocampa give birth out of their backs, so wouldn't their organs be different (location, size, shape, etc) to accommodate that? And the Ocampa lifespan is only nine years.. So that lung would only be expected to function adequately for...well, however many years Kes had left when that incident occurred with the Vidiians. She had to be two or three years old, so six or seven years left on that lung..
@@EmpressMeg I think the rationale for the lungs is that they needed extreme precision to stay connected, but the holographic projectors weren't precise enough to quickly correct for normal movement. They could still adjust them, but not fast enough to prevent suffocation. They were only able to use Kes's lung after the Vidiians shared their advanced medical technology that could modify organs to be suitable for a new host.
@@mushu_beardie2556 Yeah, but the doctor himself uses those same holographic projectors to do all kinds of very precise procedures, so I'm not sure that explanation works.. As for using the Vidiians med tech to adapt Kes's lungs, yes, that makes sense. They can make any organ/tissue to be compatible with their own -- though they don't seem to be able to make those parts *look* like Vidiian organs/tissue. If they can't change the look of the skin or eyeballs that they steal, how much change can they do to the organs (beyond negating rejection and, say, altering numbers of valves or lobes, gastrointestinal length, other organ sizes, etc)? Though they are Vidiian-compatible to a degree, there would have to be some characteristics that still look a bit like their original form. So that makes me wonder how complete those procedures truly are. If they don't look 100% Vidiian, are they fully functioning Vidiian organ/tissue -- as in exactly the same function, health, and lifespan of a real Vidiian organ/tissue? Rather than a complete transformation, it seems more of a "it gets the job done -- for now." I guess the Ocampan lung to altered Talaxian-compatible lung is still a question. He has just the one, mind you. And does this lung function just as well (and last as long as) one real Talaxian lung? It's also possible that Ocampa-to-Talaxian happens to be easier/better whatever Vidiians are altering for their own physiology. It is surprising, too, that The Doctor (or any of the scientists on Voyager) didn't study what was done. Like a sample of Kes's lung vs a sample of the adapted one.. Or the procedure notes.. The Vidiian woman who was communicating with The Doctor didn't send over as much info as they had regarding that tech? Could've been quite useful to the Voyager crew, considering the long journey ahead of them. I mean, weren't they 70-something years from home at high warp? As far as they knew, they'd have plenty of time, including their next generation to research this. I mean, it's a scientific exploratory vessel, so there'd be a lot of scientists onboard, incl Janeway herself. A good portion of those scientists would be biologists. What was everyone doing? Crossword puzzles? ((For the record, I do love Voyager. LOL ❤️))
9:42 when katniss’s mom’s hand was shaking was because she is scared of Gale dying since they’ve known gale for a long time and gale has been really helpful to them surviving and district 12 so then prim helps her mother.
And Gale is the son of her late husband’s late friend. They both died in the mine. Since both families were grieving, they banded together, with Gale taking on a big-brother role for Katniss’ family too.
“I’m surprised they didn’t get you a new lung” was a joke. Johanna is pointing out how valuable Katniss is to the rebels that she makes a bitter joke about how they would do anything for Katniss, even something completely unnecessary, just to make sure she’s safe. Meanwhile, they left Johanna behind to be physically and mentally tortured for weeks or months (can’t remember exactly how long).
Part of the reason he used breaths with CPR is because he’s from a fishing district so most of the CPR he’s done are drowning related, so it’s probably muscle memory
I remember in the book, when Katniss sees Finnick give Peeta CPR, she sees him pinch his nose to give him rescue breaths, and she attacks him because she thinks he’s trying to cut off Peeta’s oxygen and kill him, because she doesn’t know what CPR is. I don’t remember the details, but I believe that in the districts, medical knowledge and technology has essentially gone backwards because they can’t go to medical school, they don’t have doctors or medical training, etc., the districts are kind of slaves of the Capitol, they’re only purpose is to provide food and resources to them, and the Capitol clearly doesn’t care when people in the districts die, so no one in the districts really even has access to read or learn about basic medical care. The Capitol wants to keep them as powerless as possible, and the more knowledge they withhold from the districts, the more powerless they are. Basically, Katniss’s mother and sister are the “medics” of the town, even though they know they don’t have extensive knowledge or real training, all they really can provide are medicines they can make from the plants and herbs available to them, because that’s all they’re allowed. The Capitol has intentionally withheld all access to medical care and knowledge for the past 75 years, so while the districts know medical science is extremely advanced, nobody knows anything about how to provide medical care really. The fact that Finnick even knows what CPR is and is able to do it effectively enough to bring Peeta back, is kind of subtle hint at how rebellious Finnick is for him to have even learned how to do this, and foreshadowing that his real goal isn’t to win the Hunger Games, but to help Katniss win so the Capitol can be overthrown. So even though it’s probably not intentional in the movie, I forgive the improper form as just part of the complete lack of medical knowledge and training the districts are allowed.
Adding that rescue breathing is used when someone drowns and he's from the fishing district, which is possibly why he starts with breathing and then begins chest comprehensions.
@@TheWitchesList I didn’t remember that detail, but that makes sense! Also kind of implies he doesn’t have formal training, otherwise he probably would’ve known he doesn’t need to do breaths when the person hasn’t drowned. That or Suzanne Collins doesn’t have CPR training lol.
She’s going to be shaking out of fear when someone is bleeding out on a table. Especially when it’s someone she knows very well and is one of her only food sources for her and her daughter. It’s stressful😅
@@Strawberrybl0ndebaddieshe was the town doctor, she wasn’t nervous. I don’t recall exactly but in the books I’m pretty sure she was developing a condition that was damaging her mind
@@WandaMaximoff1998 Also, Im only talking about the movies, but if I also remember correctly, ever since the 1st movie, before Katniss got on the train, Katniss talked down to her and "forced" her to stay grounded and take care of her (Katniss') sister. That she has to forget about her (Katniss') dad, as Prim is the only thing that matters rn and stuff. She had problems since then
9:08 They can’t use water bro. They live in District 12. Most of the immediate water the residents have access to is polluted or infected with pathogens. The nearest “clean” water is collected rain water, plumbing and sewage lines that only the upper class residents can use, or the river/lake that is blocked from the public out in the woods.
Clearing stuff up: Finnick is from the fishing district which aligns with hus CPR style Morphling is a POWERFUL painkiller and targets the nervous system to shut down pain and feeling temporarily. Prim probably meant "It didn't hit the eye and she doesn't need stitches" over "It didn't hit eye SO she doesn't need stitches." Trackerjacker venom targets the nervous and blood system and has similar affects to intense anaphylactic shock and snake venom. Katniss sounded like a teathered from US when her vocal cords were damaged.
"Some snake venom is a neurotoxin." Procedes to show a python (right after the venom milking clip), who not only have puppy faces but are not venomous.
Interestingly though, pythons (at least ball pythons) do have a bit of anticoagulant (blood thinner) in their saliva. It's not venom, but it helps keep blood from clotting. It's not enough to be really problematic for humans. The only time my ball python ever bit me, I didn't bleed much, but it was definitely more than I should have based on the size of the tiny pinpricks. But if a rat gets bitten by a python that small amount of extra blood loss is enough to weaken it and make it a little easier to kill.
10:20 "you need your skin to stay hydrated" me looking at all the cuts and small wounds I keep accidentally collecting 👀 so... you saying I need to drink more lemonade?
The real question about Peeta painting himself to camouflage with the rock: how in the hell did he find time to do something so realistic on his face with no reliable reflective surface while injured and, presumeably, being pursued?!?
In the pre-games training he saw someone who was a master painter and he also is a hobby artist iirc (at least in the books) so he just picked it up I suppose, not sure where he got the material though lol
@@AjZ530 The way I think of it is since the gamemakers knew he was artistically gifted from his private demonstration of skills (forget what that part's called) they placed those supplies in the cornucopia. But yeah OP, I do wonder how he was able to do it without a mirror while severely injured. At that part I do have to suspend my disbelief.
Nobody sent him anything though. They talked about it with Katniss and he was quite surprised she received something. I think they wanted us to believe he found those colours naturally in the area.
Well, I have a theory. We know he was near water when Katniss found him, and we know water has a reflective surface. He probably used the river/lake as a mirror. And as far as the painting/camouflage, it tells us in the book that as a baker’s son he would often decorate cakes. He said he got the skills for camouflage from decorating cakes (more descriptive in the book, and briefly mentioned in passing in the movie).
@@OTGamer95 The river almost certainly had currents making the surface more like a broken mirror, it likely wouldn't give a clear enough image. Certainly not clear enough for the detail realism requires.
In the book the poison for gives surface burns and is a nerve issue and causes a lack of motor control leading to them losing the ability to walk. Thay also have to use a cream after the water to heal the wounds.
Now that I remember that Gale was whipped, you should TOTALLY cover Outlander in one of your videos. Probably more than one since the protagonist is a nurse (later becomes a surgeon), and her lover keeps getting badly hurt in prison, during battles, etc.
They did not. I feel like they should have because it helped to show that no matter how advanced Panem was (at least the Capitol), they still couldn't save Peeta's leg.
yeah i feel like Dr. Mike would like the books for the medical accuracies like the blood poisoning and Katniss being squeamish around medical stuff unlike her sister Prim who thrived in a medical environment
I’m so glad you mentioned right in the beginning that more people in movies should injured during their falls from great heights. My husband fell from a roof and broke both his feet a few years ago and seeing scenes like that upsets him every time!
Not enough people talk about how Doctor Mike is hands down one of the best TH-camrs. He’s educational, funny, obviously smart, editing is on point AND he teaches using pop culture. I love this dude!
10:40 Well the reason why the guy gave breaths first is because he is from a District that is known for fishing where drowning is probably common and as a lifeguard myself we are taught to give a person breaths first if we have just pulled them from the water, so he was probably just putting into practice what he is familiar with.
In the book she used the burn cream first then during the “feast” at the cornucopia she gets the injection. Mike didn’t show the injection or the “feast”.
I do believe, in the book the writing clears up Prim's statement in Catching Fire. I do remember it saying "missed your eye, you don't need stitches," meaning Prim was making two different, only loosely connected statements. She was saying 'and' not 'because'.
I know Doctor Mike is reacting to and explaining every injury so we can learn, but I can't help but laugh when he says stuff like "That's gonna cause problems" or when he speaks about long-term effects I can't help but think, I don't think that's going to be a problem for much longer...🤣
I've also seen combat surgeons say the blood out of the mouth in movies is really funny because that doesn't happen unless you're wounded directly in the esophagus.
9:17 In the army we had a dude who was medic. He was on a shift at the barracks hospital and got drunk from hand sanitizer on watch duty. He was transferred to a warehouse duty and legend says he got banned from the hospital. Imagine that. Army medic who spent most of his time as a warehouse worker because he got drunk on hand sanitizer.
I'm sorry, but I can't help it... Do you know Shoot it from the Hip comedy club? Because they did an entire bit with that line coming up over and over again and it is iconic at this point. "Small bottle of hand sanitizer?" They were suppose to make up the scene of only random lines they've found in the books audience members gave them. All improv. It's on yt in case you'd like to check it out. :) I keep coming back to it, because those guys are comedy gold.
Wow. There was so much interesting life saving information in this video. I don't even know how to share this around with people because I know people have short attention spans but, wow.
Thank you for explaining the rule of 9s! I always wondered where doctors got their burn percentage estimates from. I didn't realize there was such a simple rule to help estimate that quickly.
Doctor Mike, there is an organism in nature that causes terrible pain, major hallucinations, and death! The first thing I thought of when I heard that line was the Irukandji jellyfish, native to the waters around Australia. There was a new medical condition named for its sting because it caused such a consistent and severe feeling of "imminent doom" in people who were freshly stung.
As a former EMT, I had many patients with chronic alcoholism issues, many times they would steal hand sanitizer from office building bathrooms and grocery stores to get drunk. Never knew it could cause blindness.
@@kth124 I’m not sure if it’s the same alcohol as in some hand sanitizer, but wood alcohol was a problem during prohibition for the same reason. Unlike drinkable alcohol, wood alcohol would break down into two other poisons inside the body and cause blindness and death. One of those toxins is formaldehyde.
fun fact! In the books, peeta ends up losing the leg after the games, and has a prosthetic that ends up affecting him throughout the rest of the series. (I kinda understand why they couldn't just make the actor have an actual prosthetic, but it does make his injury look a lot more miraculously-cured than it is in the books)
I don’t as it could have easily been done with CGI, especially since it would have only been there for a few minutes in the first movie. Representation for people with disabilities is also very important.
0:26 tbf it looks like she landed on some soft foliage, which would definitely cushion the fall. Also, while not perhaps the most pleasant it is possible to land from a somewhat good height without rolling while not getting hurt if you make sure to absorb the impact properly through your whole leg
The "demon dogs", according to the book, are mutated mutts made from the 21 dead tributes. Each was designated with a specific collar for what district they used to represent
to clarify on doc point with the butterflies it was documented that during the industrial revolution in Britain grey moths became more common because of the layers of soot on everything. furthermore after cleaning measures where introduced and the soot levels dropped the amount of grey moths dropped as well
STAY FOUND?!‼️‼️😂😂🙏 LOVE THE PROFILE PIC it’s true what they say when stays are literally everywhere but I did not expect to see a stay in A DOCTOR MIKE vid
This is random, but as I sit here procrastinating revising for my 3rd year OSCEs (practical exams in UK medical schools), and I remember how I've been watching your videos since highschool, I just wanted to say thank you for keeping me motivated and inspired (as well as entertained)
Love your videos!! ❤️ By no means a medical expert but one thing I took away from first responder training was that the goal of CPR shouldn’t be to revive the person but to preserve the brain function until defib. I know you know that I just feel like that’s a key factor that generally people don’t understand and would cause them to give up on CPR if there is no result before the ambulance arrives. Love your emphasis on compressions always!
Finnick does CPR Dr. Mike: what you do in such a situation is, CPR and wait for first responders. I think Dr Mike needs to understand what the hunger games are 😂
I’ve been rewatching the Hunger Games movies bc they’re my all time favorites but now each time I see one of these scenes it makes me think of this video😂😂
13:10 good that Mike brings up the DNA-damage, here. Sulfur mustard is also quite carcinogenic, so even if you survive the blistering (hopefully avoiding your eyes and lungs), you are quite likely to develop cancer alter in life.
I think the reason they perform puny chest compressions on real people is that they don't want to mess with their health. The actor playing Meredith on Grey's Anatomy commented after the drowning scene: "After a while, your body starts to respond." What we see as a short clip in the film is a result of many takes that may have taken hours of repeating the same actions. Seems that doing proper CPR for an extended period of time on a person whose heart is functioning, will interfere with the actual heart rhythm and might also crack ribs.
I think @marepungas624 means that when filming a movie, you can’t do proper CPR on an actor as you can seriously hurt them That’s why it never looks “right” on TV
Thank you for watching! Sign up and upgrade to Grammarly Premium to level up your productivity: grammarly.com/drmike06
Yo I just had a trial of some sort (sounds like a cult but it’s not) and part of it we had to fast, all I had for food is a box of raisins and a pop tart. Would this be enough to slow my metabolism down. Because I have pretty high metabolism and I’m in puberty so I was confused why I wasn’t really hungry.
Hello Doctor 🤘
I’m shocked you didn’t notice how bad the chest compressions were, in the scene where Peeta ( the rock ) got hit by the force field
ITS PEETAAAA
DOCTOR MIKE YOU SHOULD REACT TO THE OUTER BANKS SHOW INJURIES
I think that the reason Finnick starts with rescue breaths when he's doing CPR is because he comes from the fishing district, so he's probably used to doing CPR for drowning victims, which is the one case where you ARE supposed to start with breaths before compressions
thats what i was thinking as well
Would make sense!!
wow makes sense!
That has always been my interpretation of why he does it! That due to his experience and how he learned this is what he knows to do!
I was also thinking that back in 2010 thats what we did first and how it was taught
In the book, Peeta's leg doesn't heal. They get the infection under control, but they end up amputating the leg once they get out of the game because a tourniquet that was later used blocked off the blood supply for too long.
I was just gonna say this! I don't think I've ever forgiven the movie for leaving out that detail about Peeta.
Came here to say this.
Yup. But I think they didn't want it to be cumbersome to Josh as Peeta and probably wanted to tone down some of the Dark storylines from the book.
Bruh, I read the books and I have zero memory of his leg being amputated 😅😅😅 granted I was like 12 when I read them and am almost 24 now
The mutant dog at the end injuries him further. That's why they take the leg.
Fun Fact! Peeta's wounded leg is amputated in the book as a result of being stabbed in the thigh and it being left to fester like in the scene. He uses a prosthetic leg in the books though they chose not to amputate his leg in the movie at all. Meanwhile, Katniss is partly deaf in one of her ears due to being too close to the explosion when she set off a mine destroying the most fight efficient kids food supply. This affects her ability for the rest of the 1st game. She is healed later on but has a deformed ear due to external damage.
The books are really good. It shows mental health issues, addiction to morphine, and going through traumatic grief and ptsd. The theme of how the media chooses what to promote and what to hide, where Katniss' drive for survival is turned into just a romance story (exactly what the irl media did btw) was probably what was most lost in translation to film.
I loooove the books! The mutts are a lot freaker too! Since they used the other tributes' to create them from.
I love the books I'm probably gonna read them for the sixth time just because of this video, and I don't like how the films didn't include katniss' deafness it wouldn't have been a big thing to include 😊
I agree. I enjoy the movies, but the books were more immersive for me. I think the movies should've gone full-on Hunger Games... You need that brutal grittiness (injuries, actions, politics, etc). It's a chilling "what if" and a reminder of what humans are technically capable of as a society.
@@EmpressMeg yeahh exactly, I do love dystopian books for exactly the reason you said! Like film adaptations are good but the books are way better, especially with Shadowhunters and divergent series
Not quite. Peeta's festering wound is mostly healed from the medicine Katniss retrieves at from the cornucopia. But he sustains another injury lower on his leg while escaping from the mutts. Katniss can only stop the bleeding by applying a tourniquet, which results in the amputation.
in the book katniss references the fact that she feel pain from the burn as good, as just like Dr Mike said, if the wound is extremely bad the nerve endings are damaged, which she knew from when her mother was treating burn victims from the mines
Very knowledgeable you are
I thought of that too when he pointed it out !!
It’s funny how Mike calls Katniss Catnip because that’s exactly what Gale does in the first book
Eeeeew Gale
ik thats what I thought 😂
@@allygator616ikr 🤢
i love gale
@@jjustmeena Nooo🤬🤬
I think it’s important to note that the Hunger Games take place like 300 years into the future or something like that. They often use things that have a base that we recognize (regular wasps to tracker jackets, mustard gas turned into the poisonous fog) which has been scientifically modified to be extremely deadly. But that also means they have advanced medicine, like the healing salve.
Also, Johanna was joking about the lung. It’s her taking a jab at how she views Katniss as being coddled.
But also after at least 75 years of limited education for most of the population, hence CPR not being common knowledge anymore
I JUST SAID THE EXACT SAME THING THEN SCROLLED FOR A FEW SECONDS AND FOUND THIS. Including the fact johanna was joking!
@@ShethTora Well, regular people are basicly slaves in the series..... So only those would be taught CPR who actually has a practical need for it.
@@ShethTora fennick (?) was from the fishing district so the only cpr he would probably be trained in would be for someone drowning which I believe you do start with rescue breaths for
The loss of his leg was because of the tourniquet Katniss used on him, it is mentioned in the book that he tourniquet had saved his life though
I love the idea that Mike still has hope that every movie will be medically accurate
While I'm not qualified to pick out all medical inaccuracies, I will give a pass to CPR not being done right. It's probably not good to do real CPR on someone who is just *pretending* to need it.
@@NinjaFlibble Also Finnick is from the Fishing District where he's probably used to doing CPR on drowning victims where you are supposed to start with rescue breaths, he's probably never learnt how to do it another way
cool
This movie happens way in the future in the first book they have technology good enough to heal every one of katniss's wounds in less than a day so the tech and medicine they have are likely far better than currently
@@J_Games_2.15😊
"In hope that first responders come..." Yeah, that isn't happening.
Lol
I was thinking the same thing 🤣
I was looking for this comment! 😂 Sorry, Dr. Mike... no first responders in the Hunger Games!
The only first responder you’re getting is the giant claw that carries away your corpse😂
In fairness though, SPOILERS first responders did show up at the end of the movie.
The scene where Johanna says, “I’m surprised they haven’t found you a new lung,” is meant in a sarcastic way. Johanna didn’t exactly like Katniss, but they ended up quite close after that scene.
Finnick is from a fishing district which explains the breaths first.
Cato’s death is so much more drawn out and traumatic in the book that Peeta actually ends up with a prosthetic.
Peetas wound was to the bone and he had blood poisoning which is what that medicine was for.
The Capitol had been engineering the mutations for years so the Tribute/Wolf mutts and the Trackerjackers were more lethal than a snake could ever be. Well besides Dr Gaul’s rainbow snakes that cause colorful blisters and death in the cases that aren’t treated immediately.
iirc the mutants were made for wartime purposes no? like the trackerjackers were remnants from wartime being reused in the games?
@@LetMeFLY649 Yes this, the mockingjays which were titular in the series were another example of a mutant engineered for war. What cracks me up is this hellscape society has wasps like that which exist in nature now. We can't do anything about the wasps we have now and these jackasses made worse ones.
i think what primrose meant was "it missed your eye. Doesn''t need stitches." as in two separate statements. anyways †hat wink from Bear was everything
Yeah that’s my interpretation too. She was saying, “It missed your eye, AND it doesn’t need stitches,” rather than “It missed your eye, SO it doesn’t need stitches.”
@@OTGamer95Yeah that makes sense
They prob should’ve added an “and” in there then
Tell me you've never seen the hunger games, without telling me you've never seen the hunger games
Mike:
Right 😂😂
Peeta* not Peter 😂
When he started going on about real snow it made me laugh so much.
peteR the rock
He ain't got time 😂 he out here so doctoring
Aktually Finick did mouth-to-mouth because he is from a fishing district. so he probably only learned it that way. Funny thing Katniss never seen anyone doing that so she though he was legit just kissing a dying peeta!
I thought the same! I don’t know if Suzanne Collins wrote in the mouth-to-mouth intentionally knowing that rescue breaths are part of drowning protocol, but it fits with the character nonetheless!
@@pomelopompelmoKatniss mentions how Finnick looks like he’d done it many times before so I think Suzanne was alluding the fact his district trade meant he’d encountered his fair share of drowning vicitms.
@@pomelopompelmo probably. She doesn't miss the mark on hardly any details in the books.
Katniss didn’t think Finnick was kissing Peeta-she didn’t trust him yet, so she drew her bow and arrow thinking Finnick was going to hurt Peeta further.
I actually didn’t know that about doing mouth to mouth first for drowning victims until now. The more you know. And it does fit for Finnick’s character.
A couple things about the mouth-to-mouth and chest compressions scene. Katniss comes from a very poor and uneducated district and actually does not know about CPR (she's very confused about what Finnick is doing to Peeta). Also, Finnick (the one doing mouth-to-mouth and compressions) comes from a water district and knows CPR because it's useful in an aquatic area. I assume the CPR he is trained in is only for drowning, so he just knows to give mouth-to-mouth when someone isn't breathing. It seems wrong in the moment, but that's kind of the point. The districts are very oppressed and lacking a lot of education/knowledge.
Also, Katniss's mother (the one with the shaking hands) does not have Parkinsons. She's just a very nervous and mentally broken person and was shaking from her nerves.
If that was intentional and not just a movie medical misconception like the shocking to bring someone back that has flatline rhythm that would be an impressive attention to detail.
„he has raccoon eyes, which could be a sign of a basilar skull fracture… OH and he’s violent“ love it hahaha 10/10 diagnostics
The reason her hands were shaking is because she was a healer, the towns greatest, but then her husband dies in a mine explosion and she becomes very distant, like distant enough that she basically disappeared for years. She never really becomes herself again, ever. Plus with Katniss having been in the games before she's got a lot of mental trauma.
Fun fact for non book readers. The infection got so bad that Peta ended up losing the leg.
It wasn’t from the infection- it was from the mutts cutting his leg when they were climbing up the cornucopia, the medicine healed his leg
Which would also be more medically accurate, or realistic anyway. Although technichally I think the reason they amputaded his leg was because Katniss made a tourniqet and Peeta lost bloodflow to the leg for so long they had to amputate
@@bridgetnatalie3423 Ah, misremembered. Either way they should have kept it in the movie.
Fun indeed.
Damn I read the books and I don’t remember that lol
**Dr Mike talking about how cato getting shot in the hand will cause problems**
Me: yeah, those are the problems he will have to deal with
Years after I am still salty AF about Cato dying and I do not know why
Well, they did impact him for the rest of his life
@@endorb lol
-Snow? Snow is not that problematic. I CANT
I know! I laughed so much! 😂
I remember a fair amount of icy snowballs that I found highly problematic
The president name is snow
I literally lol'd, I didn't expect that.
Maybe Catnip just doesn’t like the cold?
Also, his name is Peeta, he got a sponsor (someone who sends tributes gifts during the games), of the camouflage supplies. He is so good from decorating cakes in his parent’s bakery.
Edit: I think he made the paints by himself actually, oops…
And, he's also a painter. He paints beautiful pictures too.
I don't remember him getting a sponsor in the book, was that in the movie?
@@hiswayservicesblog9288 Oh yeah! Thanks!
@@allygator616 I think…. It might’ve been in a backpack at the cornucopia..
@@Silvia_Shadowspark6677 That’s what I thought, i am rereading the books after a few years and i’m nearly at that part haha
Mike not knowing the context of the storyline makes his comments so much funnier.
Katniss' mom's hands were shaking because she had a lot of mental health issues and anxiety. She was better by the time the movies take place but she still had a lot of anxiety and gets nervous easily. Treating Gale, a close friend of her daughter's and the son of her late husband's friend (who died when her husband did), was hard on her. Which is why Prim took over because they know how hard she struggles mentally when things get tough.
In the books, it says that Prim had to grow up too fast because of her family's hard times, and during those times she was helping her mother, tending the sick and wounded like a pro. Fun fact, Katniss is the hunter but gets squeamish around wounds on people and unsure how to help them, while Prim is a timid little girl who would never hurt any living thing, and here she is treating various sicknesses and horrible wounds without flinching!
She was being trained to become a doctor in District 13. That's why...she was in the Capitol, trying to save wounded children when the Rebels attacked. She was officially one of the medics.
And then...the second parachutes went off.
During an interview at the time of the movies, Jennifer Lawrence said that her costars called her character "Catpiss Neverclean" behind the scenes just for giggles.
That's so funny, I can't-
That's so much more amazing than Cantmiss Evershot from the Starving Games
I remember seeing a parody book where she was called Can'tkiss Neverclean
CANT MISS@@caffeinatedpossum
I love Mike reacting to this, clearly displaying the fact that he does NOT watch these movies
When Prim said, "Miss your eye, doesn’t need stitches," she was saying two separate observations on Katniss's injury
As someone who has read he books, Tracker Jacker stings are MUCH worse than the movie shows them. Katniss actually hallucinates oranges bubbles, and ants crawling up her and eating her eyes out, as well as Glimmer having green ooze seeping from her giant blisters, ouch. Also,'Peter the stone' got me dying 😅
about the bruised lung comment: I think she was being sarcastic. That character is very cynical and is referring to the fact that Katniss is the resistance's 'Golden Girl' into starting (and hopefully winning) a full on revolution. So they'd give her preferential treatment, especially for medical situations.
Yeah that’s how I saw it
That is exactly what she meant. She was making jabs at Katniss.
I love how he's doing these videos on the subject that he's not like 100% familiar with and it just ends up just adorably funny
"Has Peeter turned to stone?" "Peter the stone" ITS PEETAH❤😂😂😂
Peter the Stone and Catnip Evergreen
Yes, Lois, my bad
Peter actually means stone in greek.
Peeettttaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@lukelyall5879 peter and kantmiss evershot
In the first book Katniss mentions that her mom had brought in patients with 4th degree burns and that she was scarred from that and ran out of the house but found out that the patient wasn’t in as much pain because the nerves were burned off. So she was hoping that is what had happened and she almost threw up after viewing the burn that she had.
To add context as to why Katniss's mum's hand is shaking, it's because she hasn't had to treat a flogging in a long time. The dude flogging Gale is the new head Peacekeeper, and he was much harsher than those who came before
“we have one enemy and that’s snow” 😂😂 sounds like a line from a farming thriller
Farmers love snow. They protect the fields from serious frost.
It can be an enemy if you're Wintering at the Overlook with Jack, but a savior if you're clever enough..
As a minnesotan, snow is absolutely one of my number one enemies 😂
Or Something from Game of thrones... winter is coming...
I take some comfort knowing that the medical information was *slightly* more accurate in the books.
8:54 she didn't say katniss didn't stitches because it missed her eye.
She said two separete non related things
It missed her eye.
She doesn't need stitches.
They were also in a poor and uneducated district so maybe she didn't really know it could still need stitches. or maybe gales injuries were of more concern with possibly limited stitching materials.
@@cuppy3874 agreed, it's prob triage…
Yes she said that with a comma!!
Doctor Mike: Avoid screaming, obviously.
Katniss: THESE PEOPLE!
4:48 That’s why in the books he loses his leg because they didn’t have any medicine
I was about to comment this 😅
I love how Doctor Mike watches these with none to very little context! He's understandably busy, so I'm sure he's given selected clips. It find it amusing af...but also frustrating when it's something I know intimately like Hunger Games, HP, House, etc. It's not so much the lack of in-verse (in-universe?) knowledge, but knowledge that, if Doctor Mike knew of it, could give us even more informative and interesting med info.
I hope he does Star Trek. Not the reboots, but the older series like TNG, DS9, VOY, and ENT. Some injuries, he can only make an educated guess on what's happening. But certain medical advancements are actually possible, given enough time n research. A Bio-bed and a medical tricorder would be a perfect start.
That would be awesome! Star Trek ages so weirdly because they have warp drives and transporters, but their computers and medicine are half stuck in the 90s, and half absurdly and unrealistically advanced. Like in Voyager, when Neelix gets his lungs stolen and they give him holographic lungs, which will probably never be possible, but they somehow can't 3d print (or replicate) him new ones even though we're like 20 years away from being able to do that. I know they were doing an iron lung metaphor, but it's still strange to me.
@@mushu_beardie2556 And wasn't Neelix unable to move much because the holo-lungs were only in one spot? Like, moving misaligned them a bit? I would think The Doctor could program the lungs to move with Neelix.. He'd still be stuck in Sickbay, but able to move around. But I guess they needed it for the drama.
But, yes, they could have used Neelix's own DNA to grow him some new lungs. I find it strange that the Doctor used one of Kes's lungs. Besides blood types and other factors (I assume, in the Trek future, they can do something to donor organs/tissues to make them compatible so there's no rejection), Ocampa and Talaxians are very different. Ocampa give birth out of their backs, so wouldn't their organs be different (location, size, shape, etc) to accommodate that? And the Ocampa lifespan is only nine years.. So that lung would only be expected to function adequately for...well, however many years Kes had left when that incident occurred with the Vidiians. She had to be two or three years old, so six or seven years left on that lung..
@@EmpressMeg I think the rationale for the lungs is that they needed extreme precision to stay connected, but the holographic projectors weren't precise enough to quickly correct for normal movement. They could still adjust them, but not fast enough to prevent suffocation.
They were only able to use Kes's lung after the Vidiians shared their advanced medical technology that could modify organs to be suitable for a new host.
@@mushu_beardie2556 Yeah, but the doctor himself uses those same holographic projectors to do all kinds of very precise procedures, so I'm not sure that explanation works..
As for using the Vidiians med tech to adapt Kes's lungs, yes, that makes sense. They can make any organ/tissue to be compatible with their own -- though they don't seem to be able to make those parts *look* like Vidiian organs/tissue. If they can't change the look of the skin or eyeballs that they steal, how much change can they do to the organs (beyond negating rejection and, say, altering numbers of valves or lobes, gastrointestinal length, other organ sizes, etc)? Though they are Vidiian-compatible to a degree, there would have to be some characteristics that still look a bit like their original form. So that makes me wonder how complete those procedures truly are. If they don't look 100% Vidiian, are they fully functioning Vidiian organ/tissue -- as in exactly the same function, health, and lifespan of a real Vidiian organ/tissue? Rather than a complete transformation, it seems more of a "it gets the job done -- for now."
I guess the Ocampan lung to altered Talaxian-compatible lung is still a question. He has just the one, mind you. And does this lung function just as well (and last as long as) one real Talaxian lung? It's also possible that Ocampa-to-Talaxian happens to be easier/better whatever Vidiians are altering for their own physiology.
It is surprising, too, that The Doctor (or any of the scientists on Voyager) didn't study what was done. Like a sample of Kes's lung vs a sample of the adapted one.. Or the procedure notes.. The Vidiian woman who was communicating with The Doctor didn't send over as much info as they had regarding that tech? Could've been quite useful to the Voyager crew, considering the long journey ahead of them. I mean, weren't they 70-something years from home at high warp? As far as they knew, they'd have plenty of time, including their next generation to research this. I mean, it's a scientific exploratory vessel, so there'd be a lot of scientists onboard, incl Janeway herself. A good portion of those scientists would be biologists. What was everyone doing? Crossword puzzles?
((For the record, I do love Voyager. LOL ❤️))
“OHHH THAT PERSON DISAGREED WITH WHAT SHE WAS SAYING” HAD ME DEAD 😭😭
Frrr I was wheeezing
But he wasn't wrong tho.
9:42 when katniss’s mom’s hand was shaking was because she is scared of Gale dying since they’ve known gale for a long time and gale has been really helpful to them surviving and district 12 so then prim helps her mother.
And Gale is the son of her late husband’s late friend. They both died in the mine. Since both families were grieving, they banded together, with Gale taking on a big-brother role for Katniss’ family too.
“I’m surprised they didn’t get you a new lung” was a joke. Johanna is pointing out how valuable Katniss is to the rebels that she makes a bitter joke about how they would do anything for Katniss, even something completely unnecessary, just to make sure she’s safe. Meanwhile, they left Johanna behind to be physically and mentally tortured for weeks or months (can’t remember exactly how long).
13:45 I don't really think there's anything "IDEAL" in The Hunger Games, Dr. Mike. That's the whole premise.
Part of the reason he used breaths with CPR is because he’s from a fishing district so most of the CPR he’s done are drowning related, so it’s probably muscle memory
And the movie was made before taking away the breaths from CPR
I agree it was probably just a reflex reaction
I remember in the book, when Katniss sees Finnick give Peeta CPR, she sees him pinch his nose to give him rescue breaths, and she attacks him because she thinks he’s trying to cut off Peeta’s oxygen and kill him, because she doesn’t know what CPR is. I don’t remember the details, but I believe that in the districts, medical knowledge and technology has essentially gone backwards because they can’t go to medical school, they don’t have doctors or medical training, etc., the districts are kind of slaves of the Capitol, they’re only purpose is to provide food and resources to them, and the Capitol clearly doesn’t care when people in the districts die, so no one in the districts really even has access to read or learn about basic medical care. The Capitol wants to keep them as powerless as possible, and the more knowledge they withhold from the districts, the more powerless they are. Basically, Katniss’s mother and sister are the “medics” of the town, even though they know they don’t have extensive knowledge or real training, all they really can provide are medicines they can make from the plants and herbs available to them, because that’s all they’re allowed. The Capitol has intentionally withheld all access to medical care and knowledge for the past 75 years, so while the districts know medical science is extremely advanced, nobody knows anything about how to provide medical care really. The fact that Finnick even knows what CPR is and is able to do it effectively enough to bring Peeta back, is kind of subtle hint at how rebellious Finnick is for him to have even learned how to do this, and foreshadowing that his real goal isn’t to win the Hunger Games, but to help Katniss win so the Capitol can be overthrown. So even though it’s probably not intentional in the movie, I forgive the improper form as just part of the complete lack of medical knowledge and training the districts are allowed.
Adding that rescue breathing is used when someone drowns and he's from the fishing district, which is possibly why he starts with breathing and then begins chest comprehensions.
@@TheWitchesList I didn’t remember that detail, but that makes sense! Also kind of implies he doesn’t have formal training, otherwise he probably would’ve known he doesn’t need to do breaths when the person hasn’t drowned. That or Suzanne Collins doesn’t have CPR training lol.
And because she’d never seen mouth to mouth she thinks he’s kissing Peeta and she’s like “go off shoot your shot but is this really the time?”
"Why are her hands shaking?" "Maybe she has Parkinsons" I CANT
Like bro I think she was just nervous or smth 😭
There's a man lying on her table bleeding from deep whip wounds. Most people would tremble in fear.
She’s going to be shaking out of fear when someone is bleeding out on a table. Especially when it’s someone she knows very well and is one of her only food sources for her and her daughter. It’s stressful😅
@@Strawberrybl0ndebaddieshe was the town doctor, she wasn’t nervous. I don’t recall exactly but in the books I’m pretty sure she was developing a condition that was damaging her mind
@@WandaMaximoff1998 Also, Im only talking about the movies, but if I also remember correctly, ever since the 1st movie, before Katniss got on the train, Katniss talked down to her and "forced" her to stay grounded and take care of her (Katniss') sister. That she has to forget about her (Katniss') dad, as Prim is the only thing that matters rn and stuff. She had problems since then
9:08 They can’t use water bro. They live in District 12. Most of the immediate water the residents have access to is polluted or infected with pathogens. The nearest “clean” water is collected rain water, plumbing and sewage lines that only the upper class residents can use, or the river/lake that is blocked from the public out in the woods.
Clearing stuff up:
Finnick is from the fishing district which aligns with hus CPR style
Morphling is a POWERFUL painkiller and targets the nervous system to shut down pain and feeling temporarily.
Prim probably meant "It didn't hit the eye and she doesn't need stitches" over "It didn't hit eye SO she doesn't need stitches."
Trackerjacker venom targets the nervous and blood system and has similar affects to intense anaphylactic shock and snake venom.
Katniss sounded like a teathered from US when her vocal cords were damaged.
“Is Peter a rock?” Peeta: 🗿
I mean the name peter mean the rock
😂😂😂
"Some snake venom is a neurotoxin." Procedes to show a python (right after the venom milking clip), who not only have puppy faces but are not venomous.
Just mentioned this
Had this thought too!
was about to comment this
Interestingly though, pythons (at least ball pythons) do have a bit of anticoagulant (blood thinner) in their saliva. It's not venom, but it helps keep blood from clotting. It's not enough to be really problematic for humans. The only time my ball python ever bit me, I didn't bleed much, but it was definitely more than I should have based on the size of the tiny pinpricks. But if a rat gets bitten by a python that small amount of extra blood loss is enough to weaken it and make it a little easier to kill.
You see the only accuracy we care about in this channel is medical 😂😂
If Dr. Mike was in the games he would definitely write a deep meaningful message before he dies, but no one would know what he wrote.
10:20 "you need your skin to stay hydrated" me looking at all the cuts and small wounds I keep accidentally collecting 👀 so... you saying I need to drink more lemonade?
Katniss: "you were dead:(" Doctor Mike: "Well at least that is factually accurate :D" 12:04
The real question about Peeta painting himself to camouflage with the rock: how in the hell did he find time to do something so realistic on his face with no reliable reflective surface while injured and, presumeably, being pursued?!?
In the pre-games training he saw someone who was a master painter and he also is a hobby artist iirc (at least in the books) so he just picked it up I suppose, not sure where he got the material though lol
@@AjZ530 The way I think of it is since the gamemakers knew he was artistically gifted from his private demonstration of skills (forget what that part's called) they placed those supplies in the cornucopia. But yeah OP, I do wonder how he was able to do it without a mirror while severely injured. At that part I do have to suspend my disbelief.
Nobody sent him anything though. They talked about it with Katniss and he was quite surprised she received something. I think they wanted us to believe he found those colours naturally in the area.
Well, I have a theory. We know he was near water when Katniss found him, and we know water has a reflective surface. He probably used the river/lake as a mirror. And as far as the painting/camouflage, it tells us in the book that as a baker’s son he would often decorate cakes. He said he got the skills for camouflage from decorating cakes (more descriptive in the book, and briefly mentioned in passing in the movie).
@@OTGamer95
The river almost certainly had currents making the surface more like a broken mirror, it likely wouldn't give a clear enough image. Certainly not clear enough for the detail realism requires.
"Snow is not THAT problematic" 😂😂
👀 👀
Very fitting that Dr Mike is a Israhell apologist making this statement lmfao
Ah yes, my favorite duo: Peter the Rock and Catnip Evergreen.
In the book the poison for gives surface burns and is a nerve issue and causes a lack of motor control leading to them losing the ability to walk. Thay also have to use a cream after the water to heal the wounds.
Now that I remember that Gale was whipped, you should TOTALLY cover Outlander in one of your videos. Probably more than one since the protagonist is a nurse (later becomes a surgeon), and her lover keeps getting badly hurt in prison, during battles, etc.
3:43 coincidentally, the name Peter (or Petra) literally means "rock"
I thought Peeta is a work on Pita Bread since he was the son of the Baker.
@@horseygirl6232it is
So I can’t remember if they showed it in the movie or not- but (spoiler) Peeta lost his leg in the books because of the wound Cato gave him.
They did not. I feel like they should have because it helped to show that no matter how advanced Panem was (at least the Capitol), they still couldn't save Peeta's leg.
yeah i feel like Dr. Mike would like the books for the medical accuracies like the blood poisoning and Katniss being squeamish around medical stuff unlike her sister Prim who thrived in a medical environment
It was actually from the mutt dogs- they sliced his calf 🙈
@@bridgetnatalie3423 OMG IT WAS THE MUTTS. Time to reread the series since Im forgetting stufg
They didn't.
I’m so glad you mentioned right in the beginning that more people in movies should injured during their falls from great heights. My husband fell from a roof and broke both his feet a few years ago and seeing scenes like that upsets him every time!
Mike perfectly showcases how to introduce a completely unrelated topic (grammarly) into the main one (The Hunger Games).
Not enough people talk about how Doctor Mike is hands down one of the best TH-camrs. He’s educational, funny, obviously smart, editing is on point AND he teaches using pop culture. I love this dude!
doctor mike in the hunger games: let me just write you a formal email about why i should win
10:40 Well the reason why the guy gave breaths first is because he is from a District that is known for fishing where drowning is probably common and as a lifeguard myself we are taught to give a person breaths first if we have just pulled them from the water, so he was probably just putting into practice what he is familiar with.
Tell me you’ve never seen The Hunger Games without telling me you’ve never seen The Hunger Games
Dr. Mike:
“Peter the Rock”
“Catnip Evergreen”
„Wait for first responders“
@@julius5256 he doesn't mean for the characters to wait for responders, he means if you're in a situation like that, that is what you should do.
...waiting for first responders to come to Peeta's aid
Ironic considering Gale’s nickname for her
This is so true
“He’s gonna need a hand surgeon” “ope. Doesn’t matter now. The doggies got him”.
10:37 love the fact that her nickname is Catnip
3:52 Peeta! Not Peter!
Peeta, the horse is here...
Fr fr
In the case of medicating Peeta's leg wound, in the book it was an injection, not a cream, with really powerful capital medicine.
In the book she used the burn cream first then during the “feast” at the cornucopia she gets the injection. Mike didn’t show the injection or the “feast”.
That's right. Thanks for the reminder.
16:58 Mike reaction to when Katniss Everdeen shot President Coin with a single arrow instead of Snow was my first reaction to that scene as a teen!
I do believe, in the book the writing clears up Prim's statement in Catching Fire. I do remember it saying "missed your eye, you don't need stitches," meaning Prim was making two different, only loosely connected statements. She was saying 'and' not 'because'.
I know Doctor Mike is reacting to and explaining every injury so we can learn, but I can't help but laugh when he says stuff like "That's gonna cause problems" or when he speaks about long-term effects I can't help but think, I don't think that's going to be a problem for much longer...🤣
*cuts to Cato falling from the Cornucopia*
Mike: Nevermind 🤣
I've also seen combat surgeons say the blood out of the mouth in movies is really funny because that doesn't happen unless you're wounded directly in the esophagus.
9:17 In the army we had a dude who was medic. He was on a shift at the barracks hospital and got drunk from hand sanitizer on watch duty. He was transferred to a warehouse duty and legend says he got banned from the hospital. Imagine that. Army medic who spent most of his time as a warehouse worker because he got drunk on hand sanitizer.
I'm sorry, but I can't help it... Do you know Shoot it from the Hip comedy club? Because they did an entire bit with that line coming up over and over again and it is iconic at this point. "Small bottle of hand sanitizer?" They were suppose to make up the scene of only random lines they've found in the books audience members gave them. All improv. It's on yt in case you'd like to check it out. :) I keep coming back to it, because those guys are comedy gold.
Omg I'm about to see shoot from the hip live at the Edinburgh fringe in Scotland!@@petrastein2531
3:19 looks like micheal jackson lmao
Wow. There was so much interesting life saving information in this video. I don't even know how to share this around with people because I know people have short attention spans but, wow.
Thank you for explaining the rule of 9s! I always wondered where doctors got their burn percentage estimates from. I didn't realize there was such a simple rule to help estimate that quickly.
The awkward pool of blood is to symbolize that Coin would end up being another President Snow. 17:05
Also PG13 rating. Most of the time you can't show blood at all.
Doctor Mike, there is an organism in nature that causes terrible pain, major hallucinations, and death! The first thing I thought of when I heard that line was the Irukandji jellyfish, native to the waters around Australia. There was a new medical condition named for its sting because it caused such a consistent and severe feeling of "imminent doom" in people who were freshly stung.
“Oh he came back” that was your response.I was sobbing like “Catnip Evergeeen”
Since i watched hunger games recently in my head i was like oh I wish dr mike would do a reaction on the hunger games and well here we are
You, "Nice shot, you hit him right in the hand!" Me, "Thanks! I was aiming for his face!"
nice one Dr Reid
As a former EMT, I had many patients with chronic alcoholism issues, many times they would steal hand sanitizer from office building bathrooms and grocery stores to get drunk. Never knew it could cause blindness.
Only if it's Isopropyl alcohol based, which for that very reason is few and far between nowadays.
Maybe hand sanitizer is coagulated home brewed moonshine?
Anyone know how it causes blindness out of curiosity?
@@kth124 I’m not sure if it’s the same alcohol as in some hand sanitizer, but wood alcohol was a problem during prohibition for the same reason. Unlike drinkable alcohol, wood alcohol would break down into two other poisons inside the body and cause blindness and death. One of those toxins is formaldehyde.
fun fact! In the books, peeta ends up losing the leg after the games, and has a prosthetic that ends up affecting him throughout the rest of the series. (I kinda understand why they couldn't just make the actor have an actual prosthetic, but it does make his injury look a lot more miraculously-cured than it is in the books)
I don’t as it could have easily been done with CGI, especially since it would have only been there for a few minutes in the first movie. Representation for people with disabilities is also very important.
0:26 tbf it looks like she landed on some soft foliage, which would definitely cushion the fall. Also, while not perhaps the most pleasant it is possible to land from a somewhat good height without rolling while not getting hurt if you make sure to absorb the impact properly through your whole leg
8:35
I think she was saying it missed his eye, and doesn't need stitches
The "demon dogs", according to the book, are mutated mutts made from the 21 dead tributes. Each was designated with a specific collar for what district they used to represent
to clarify on doc point with the butterflies it was documented that during the industrial revolution in Britain grey moths became more common because of the layers of soot on everything. furthermore after cleaning measures where introduced and the soot levels dropped the amount of grey moths dropped as well
I can’t tell if the granmarly tag is on purpose or not
Me too
Right!!!
STAY FOUND?!‼️‼️😂😂🙏 LOVE THE PROFILE PIC it’s true what they say when stays are literally everywhere but I did not expect to see a stay in A DOCTOR MIKE vid
Where
You need to grammarly 😭😭😭
doc the amount of knowledge and laughs i get from ur videos are AMAZING I LOVE YOU NO HOMO
This is random, but as I sit here procrastinating revising for my 3rd year OSCEs (practical exams in UK medical schools), and I remember how I've been watching your videos since highschool, I just wanted to say thank you for keeping me motivated and inspired (as well as entertained)
Love your videos!! ❤️ By no means a medical expert but one thing I took away from first responder training was that the goal of CPR shouldn’t be to revive the person but to preserve the brain function until defib. I know you know that I just feel like that’s a key factor that generally people don’t understand and would cause them to give up on CPR if there is no result before the ambulance arrives. Love your emphasis on compressions always!
Finnick does CPR
Dr. Mike: what you do in such a situation is, CPR and wait for first responders.
I think Dr Mike needs to understand what the hunger games are 😂
LOVE the hunger games AND this channel!
Get him to do maze runner next!!
I’ve been rewatching the Hunger Games movies bc they’re my all time favorites but now each time I see one of these scenes it makes me think of this video😂😂
I was 13 when i saw the first one in the cinema and glimmers death really bothered me for ages after the movie. Im glad you reacted to that one
13:10 good that Mike brings up the DNA-damage, here. Sulfur mustard is also quite carcinogenic, so even if you survive the blistering (hopefully avoiding your eyes and lungs), you are quite likely to develop cancer alter in life.
"Bulbasaur, poison fog!"
"the fog u talkin about?"
I think the reason they perform puny chest compressions on real people is that they don't want to mess with their health. The actor playing Meredith on Grey's Anatomy commented after the drowning scene: "After a while, your body starts to respond." What we see as a short clip in the film is a result of many takes that may have taken hours of repeating the same actions. Seems that doing proper CPR for an extended period of time on a person whose heart is functioning, will interfere with the actual heart rhythm and might also crack ribs.
If you're doing CPR and don't crack a rib, you're not doing it correctly.
I think @marepungas624 means that when filming a movie, you can’t do proper CPR on an actor as you can seriously hurt them
That’s why it never looks “right” on TV
calling her catnip evergreen is such a dad thing to do 😭😭
15:54 "Avoid screaming, obviously." *Cuts directly to a clip of her yelling*