A Russian victory would end the global order, says Yuval Noah Harari | GZERO World with Ian Bremmer
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- @YuvalNoahHarari warns that Russia's potential victory in Ukraine could signal the end of the global order by violating the fundamental rule against imperial conquest and potentially sparking a domino effect of territorial aggression akin to a third World War.
Subscribe to GZERO on TH-cam and turn on notifications (🔔): / @gzeromedia
Sign up for GZERO Daily (free newsletter on global politics): rebrand.ly/gze...
Watch full episode here" to say "Watch the full conversation between Yuval Noah Harari and Ian Bremmer on this episode of GZERO World right here: • Yuval Noah Harari expl...
The Ukraine war remains the most important geopolitical conflict in the world, says bestselling author and historian Yuval Noah Harari.
In a wide-ranging conversation with Ian Bremmer filmed live at the 92nd Street Y in New York City, Harari says that if Russia wins in Ukraine, the global order as we’ve known it for decades is over. "The most fundamental rule was that you cannot just invade and conquer another country just because you're stronger. This is exactly what Putin is trying to do in Ukraine."
The conversation also touches on the potential ripple effects of Russia's actions, suggesting that a successful annexation could embolden other nations to follow suit, destabilizing global peace. Harari even entertains the notion that we might be in the early stages of a third World War, unrecognized in the current moment, much like the early years of World War II were not immediately identified as such. "If he gets away with it, we'll see more and more Putins all over the world” Harari says. "There is a scenario that we are already living in the midst of the third World War and we just don't know it."
Watch full episode here: • Yuval Noah Harari expl...
Catch GZERO World with Ian Bremmer every week on TH-cam: • GZERO World with Ian B...
Also available at gzeromedia.com... and on US public television. Check local listings.
Want to know more about global news and why it matters? Follow us on:
Instagram: / gzeromedia
Twitter: / gzeromedia
TikTok: / gzeromedia
Facebook: / gzeromedia
LinkedIn: / gzeromedia
Threads: threads.net/@g...
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel and turn on notifications (🔔): / @gzeromedia
Sign up for GZERO Daily (free newsletter on global politics): rebrand.ly/gze...
Subscribe to the GZERO podcast: podcasts.apple...
GZERO Media is a multimedia publisher providing news, insights and commentary on the events shaping our world. Our properties include GZERO World with Ian Bremmer, our newsletter GZERO Daily, Puppet Regime, the GZERO World Podcast, In 60 Seconds and GZEROMedia.com
#GZEROWorld #YuvalNoahHarari #RussiaUkraineWar #UnstoppableUs #YuvalNoahHarari
Thanks for watching! If you like the discussion, get more insights and analysis from GZERO Media and Ian Bremmer delivered to your inbox in our free daily newsletter: gzeromedia.com/subscribe.
I am capable to disprove the Sapiens basic idea and methods. However this interview, your analysis of a direct dynamic context of world war in progress that we are watching as a phenomenon of political dismemberment day after day is a superb description of what is just really happening.
Brasil
@@KRYPTOS_K5 0:34
...
Do you know Jesus Christ can set you free from sins and save you from hell today
Jesus Christ is the only hope in this world no other gods will lead you to heaven
There is no security or hope with out Jesus Christ in this world come and repent of all sins today
Today is the day of salvation come to the loving savior Today repent and do not go to hell
Come to Jesus Christ today
Jesus Christ is only way to heaven
Repent and follow him today seek his heart Jesus Christ can fill the emptiness he can fill the void
Heaven and hell is real cone to the loving savior today
Today is the day of salvation tomorrow might be to late come to the loving savior today
Romans 6.23
For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.
John 3:16-21
16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God.
Mark 1.15
15 And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel.
2 Peter 3:9
The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance.
Hebrews 11:6
6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him.
Jesus
Really, no one’s invaded another country in the past several years? Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya?
Dictatorships are not "countries". They are stolen goods from the people. One single guy or one oligarch minority with absolute power is a failure and a danger for everyone on this planet, because these minorities in power terrorize people to stay in power and constantly threaten other countries.
At some point you'll realize how stupid that sounded. You're just not there yet.
@@Ioanides001Pathetic just Pathetic
no? Not even Isreal invading practically all its neighbors and launching terror attacks for 75 years? @@Ioanides001
@@Ioanides001 I loved his books on AI …stories … now he is spinning a fairy tale story . Syria …Libya ..didn’t invade anybody . Come on. Wake up. Hari. Be logical Now there are a number of US bases in Syria .
Afghanistan, Syria, Libya, Iraq, Yugoslavia, Vietnam... the list goes on and on. Which demonstrates the rules-based "order" you talk about, where no country can invade another by force, is a lie.
I was thinking the same thing. We can also Isreal to the list. "Hey guys, we have this book that says that our ancestors lived here about 6000 years ago, so we just going to go ahead an take it from you."
these countries were invaded but not annexed. Big difference.
You are spreading whatabolism Russian propaganda with fake TH-cam account made 1 year ago. War in Afghanistan was supported internationally in;using Russia. There was also UN resolution. Who is supporting Putin’s war?
None of what you just listed demonstrates an imperial invasion with seizing of assets and force conscription of troops, I can't believe people are still making these kind of comparisons. USA is an angel by comparison to what Russia is carrying out and what China is gearing up to do soon.
@@absusup Well I guess you will be glad if some country invades your country
It's not annexation
What global order? What we are afraid of is loosing western hegenomy.
So, an Eastern Hegemony should replace it, with annexations topped up on the former?
@@tesfayekenea8533 It was not Russia that came to the borders of NATO and violated the agreement on the non-deployment of NATO east of Germany. Also, it was not Russia that violated the agreement that Ukraine is a non-aligned state. It was not Russia that bombed Yugoslavia, Iraq, Libya, Syria and other countries. So you should just shut up.
@@tesfayekenea8533Typical white nationalist!
@@user-yj1on3bf1v U must either a kid or a gullible. So, better you shut up!
Russia did get involved in Ukrainian internal affairs too, not just the west. It has been trying to more Kremlins friendly candidates elected same as the west trying to get more western friendly politicians elected.
His analysis of a Russian invasion and victory in view of the Israeli conquest and occupation of Arab countries is profoundly ironic.
he is not an expert
@@irynasakharchuk7044 he is a dilettante.
Israel has been attacked and is fighting back, but Ukraine has never invaded Russia. These two things are completely different. It looks like there is something wrong with your analysis.
@@bjorndebar8361 Israel is an apartheid state that wants to expell it's inferior race underclass, it's literally out of Hitler own book. The Nazis would be proud of what the IDF is doing in Gaza, and every Palestinian would only dream of being treated by the Israelis in the same manner as the Russians are treating the Ukrainians, this would be an one-state solution with citizenship for all.
@@bjorndebar8361 The westbank population has attacked Israel? That's funny! So yes, Israel's and Russia's aggression is quite similar.
"The rule: you cannot invade a country just because you are stronger. This was the case, for centuries, for thousands of years." Really, dude? Really? What the hell are you talking about? Really, what the hell are you talking about?
When he says “This was the case…” he meant “invading just because you are stronger was the case for centuries..”. Notice the intonation. His point is that since WWII invasions like that of Russia towards Ukraine had stopped, and now they started happening again
He’s talking about Israel and the US. Dude is the biggest hypocrite
@@LucaMelchionna-lmelkbut just last century Israel annexed parts of Syria
@@diogobezerra467 I’m not arguing in favour or against Harari’s point, I am just makimg it clear since it seems to have been misinterpreted
@LucaMelchionna-lmelk they have not stopped, it's BS. NATO bombed Serbia in 99 because NATO was stronger
This guy always speaks as if he is saying something new. All he says is air, hot air written by his lord's.
He's just pointing out what we already know from the patterns we see in human history. Yes, it is self-evident and nothing new.
The person who claimed there would be no wars and avoided criticizing Islam at all costs.
I am glad all of us get it in the comments. Peace to all of you.
We need to be more selective with our „Experts“
Hypocrisy.
One point of view
Your are 🤮
No
@@user-dx8fk3tt3w yes
Russia is a fascist state run by criminals with criminal imperialist intentions. Period.
Israel is doing that for 70 years
I irony this dude is from Israel 😂
All of Israel wars, all of them, were defensive wars. Israel never started a war.
Not really. Israelis are worldly and smart!
@@asafhenig3833hasbara lies! Stop lying to Americans.
@@asafhenig3833 😂😂😂
@@welcometosemeticpalestine - stop fabricating conspiracies to hide your j..w hate
What he failed to mention is that his own country, Israel, is illegally occupying Palestine for 75 years. Hypocrisy.
Mr Yuval is strongly condemning a country that “invaded” another but belongs to a country that formed itself in the land of other people. Unfortunately he’s not so much critical condemning the genocide of that other people…
Highly hypocritical as Israel is doing more damage to Gaza than Russia is doing to Ukraine (relatively obviously).
Ukraine did not attack Russia, but Israel was attacked. that's not comparable
@@davidkay7201 19 thousand children kidnapped to Russia, a total of 500 thousand dead, including soldiers. In total, Putin is responsible for 1.5 million deaths based on all 14 wars he fought.
@@bjorndebar8361 Israel stole land, imprisons Palestinians with impunity and allows soldiers and extremists to murder Palestinians without punishment.
@@bjorndebar8361 Russia doesn't want to expell the Ukrainians, it says Ukrainians are Russians. If Israel treated the Palestinians the way Russia treats the Ukrainians, than it wouldn't have half the international condenation it currently has.
This psycho-genius needs to be educated in the past 20 years !
He is hardly a genius. Just a psycho i guess. 😂
True. Talk about your Iraq as an example ... Yes, there aren't American citizens settling in Iraq and it has not become an official 51st State of the US. Nonetheless, Iraqi resources (e.g. oil, gold etc.) has been *extracted* and the American military has been very present at occupying it. In other words, a military threat.
look up his ethnicity and tell me if you find something intresting
@@billnyedarussianspy1921 He's a Jewish homosexual.
He's not making absolute statements. He correct that when compared to the past, both the frequency and volume of war had decreased dramatically.
For such an accomplished historian, Harari's logic is so deeply rooted in generalizations and such a lack of attention to details and sense of process when talking about today's geopolitics...
@@roddeazevedo very, very true.
He is very comfortable living in Israel, yet he talks about one nation using force to change its border
So the more than 50% who voted against Trump in 2016 should have left the country? Supporting a country doesn't mean supporting its leadership. He's against Netanyahu.
Typical Liberal/Zionist double talk!
You do know that he opposes Netanyahu?
@@thl205 😂🤣See that My comments were erased ! What does that supposed to mean as if Zionism started with Netanyahu and Is-Hell wasn’t always a white nationalist settler state serving global imperialism!
@@4411825 most israelis are non-white. I think you have also missed the point. If Israel marched into Egypt and set their border within Egyptian territory, then that would be wrong. Similarly, Russia marching into Ukraine to take their land is wrong. Yes, Israel did have the Sinai peninsula but that was won in a defensive conflict when Egypt invaded, and was returned following the Egypt-Israel peace treaty. If you want to draw comparisons, it would be fair for Russia to return all Ukrainian territory in return for a peace agreement. Do you agree?
Harari is just Harari because he works for the biggest Corporations.
Yuval harari for all his brilliance, cherry-picks his information, speaks half-truths, and concocts narratives that align with the West. I don't think it is a coincidence but rather a pattern he deliberately embarks on.
Hasbara
And still...WEF nazi soldier.
never trust a Zionist who wanted to reduce the human population, for NWO. Better dont give this boy a platform.
Why is he brilliant though? We had the same level of talk in uni cafeteria. He's brilliant because everyone thinks he's brilliant and he puts on the act. What does he know about military reality? Not all that much. That RUS would win was rather evident to any observer.
Spot on. No respect for this man any more.
Order? What order? Whose order?
Pax Americana
He’s a WEF guy, that’s all they talk about in the most creepy way
The peace we've had since ww2
@@kylecollins5463 and WMD in Iraq?? Afghanistan?? Libya .?
What about
Afghanistan Syria Iraq Serbia Vietnam Libya
Palestine
Never heard of the last one
@@JeTaimeIsraelwell you lack education and you disconnected from the world typical western propaganda!
Not one of them is comparable 😂
Afghanistan was no invasion. It was based on UN resolutions - same for Libya and Syria - and followed a help request by the government of Afghanistan.
Serbia would have been based on a UN resolution, if Russia did not veto to protect a genocidal country.
Palestine has no context here. Iraq would be the only good example and is still completly different. Ukraine: peaceful, democratic country. Iraq: Neigbours attacking dictatorship. USA: No intentions of stealing land and giving people free elections. Russia: Stealing land, trying to destroy it and committing genocide...
@@frederikzinn6568 looks like them bot wages are going up
Are those countries part of America now?
The West accusing other countries of imperialism 😂 Can't make this stuff up.
Old British/US tradition - accuse the opponent exactly of what you are doing.
Western hegemony is finished, get over it.
Hahaha 🤡
clinical hypocrisy
Signs of psychopath?
@@BetterWorld2012 the hubris, the hypocrisy and unwillingness of the west to do diplomacy pisses me off
He's right. I can't find the fault in his arguments and I was once a fundamentalist Muslim
I clicked on this because I heard Harari was intelligent, a genius even. But his rant was at the level of your local Subaru Outback driver.
Same. not surprised though once i knew that where he is from
Not true what about Iraq, afghanistan and Syria and North Africa, what about yugoslavia.
how many of them are owned by western nations and are flying their flag?
Those were unimportant geopolitically I’m sorry. It’s been civil war forever over there. Yugoslavia is the Balkans. See exhibit A: civil wars. You’re comparing a nation of 100+ million Russians and one of the biggest economies in the world to…small countries in the Middle East.:: and the poor Balkans..
@@txbre8758 Bombing of Yugoslavia was pure illegal aggression by NATO, followed by forcible border change.
Ukraine is just simple regional/local war too, there is nothing "global" about it. And Yugoslavia was very "global" because it was first time NATO was used offensively.
The backstory includes: In the first Yugoslavia conflict there was a genocide in Srebrenica from the Serbs to the Bosnians, all of Europe was shocked because it had the power to prevent it but didn't. A few years later there was the second conflict in the region and again there was a genocide in Račak. There was a risk of further genocide, this time action was taken quickly, that led to NATO intervention, anyone who doesn't understand that is not human in my opinion.
@@bjorndebar8361 you don't understand the origin of the civil war. Intervention by NATO was not in order to stop any genocide. There has been more than 14k Russian killed in eastern Ukraine.
hypocrisy at its peak
J's are gonna J.
@@okiedokie1238 yeah, they had reasons for their solutions 😂
Western propaganda
But what about the MINSK agreement!! We have broken it, and putin warned us don't, BUT WE DID!...
Yuval Noah Harari is a genuine Gobshite. Ask the next person you happen upon on the street, they will exhibit more knowledge or and insights.
Lol, absolutely. Cannot get used to that word without laughing. Calling a pompous person a gobshite makes me laugh every time. It really is pulling down their tracksuit bottoms.
"You cannot just invade and conquer and annex another country just because you are stronger". USA: 🗿🗿🗿
E X A C T L Y.....
This is exactly what the global order is.
A Russian victory may end the global order [of the USA]
he can't even see what he has just pointed out about America and why the rest of the GLOBAL MAJORITY wants Russia to stick it to NATO and AMERICA.
Call me a single country that was conquered and annexed by USA?
So you agree Yuri, Russia is not better then the USA. But 100 times more incompetent.
When he says Global order he means American order
by whom Israel gets unlimited money, weapons and immunity against war crimes, genocide, illegal settlements, apartheid and crimes against humanity.
If Russia wins, goodbye WEF.....
no, wef will stay in control of western aligned nations. It only wont affect you if you live in a none western aligned country.. which is the case today anyway..
@@joecater894 poor western aligned nations. I do not envy their fate...
@@georgekaradov1274the west is still the best... which doesnt say a lot about the rest..
@joecater894 The West is not the best... the alphabet people and the green cultists are running the place now....
Russia will not win, France, Germany, England, Poland and some countries will not allow it, that would be the end of Europe. here is no doubt about it.
While I don't condone Russia's actions in Ukraine, it's crucial to acknowledge the glaring hypocrisy evident in other geopolitical maneuvers. For instance, Israel's annexation of the Golan Heights and NATO's division of Serbia highlight a double standard when it comes to changing borders by force. Hypocrisy and double standards pose a significant threat to modern democracy and the rule of law, undermining the very principles they claim to uphold.
Under IL if a nation initiates a war of aggression towards another sovereign nation and loses that war, the land lost can be legally annexed. The 1967 war between Israel and Jordan and Israel and Syria were acts of aggression started by these arab countries. Historians have documented these ME wars extremely accurately. There is zero occupation. Especially in Judea. Jordan occupied Judea between 1948-67 illegally and in 1967 Israel got back its own territory.
true.. going forwards there should be negotiation.. but that came about because countries around Israel launched a massive war on Israel trying to wipe it from the map.
Let me tell you a little secret: these were "justified on moral grounds". Not any kind of law, but moral sense of NATO politicians. Putin has moral too, but "his moral is shorter than Biden's", you know, typical guys' thing of measuring who has bigger. Moral.
@@subchan6595 not true. Israel provoked those wars by settling illegally
@@subchan6595 not true. Israel provoked those wars by illegally settling
"you can't just invade another country just because you're stronger" I mean yeah, you have to put up a good show first. How's search for these weapons of mass destruction going?
Hello Bot.
@@bjorndebar8361 sup
Your book Sapiens was great. I think you're out of your depth here, professor. What global order are you talking about? The US starting and losing every war since Vietnam?
He's right: Calling Russia a "gas station with a nuklear arsenal" and moving the N-A-T-O closer and closer to it's border is exactly the behaviour of a imperialistic power that has the intention to take over the resources and in the process forced Russia to defend the red line set out years ago: No further expansion. Same happened during the Cuban crises just the other way round (after Russia got pressured by rockets placed in Turkey). The war would never have taken place if they would have respected to keep distance in the form of a neutral state. The war would have ended soon after it begun based and talks in Turkey but the West oped for war by claiming to support for whatever it takes.
He wrote a good book, but I think this is one of the stupidest things I've heard. The whole reason why we're in this situation is because the US organized a coup in Ukraine...
Did he write ia book? Or was it AI?
Ironic than a Isaeli talks about impelialism nowadays !!
what a hypocisy
It's so much irony and hypocrisy compacted in a few sentences!
So the continuous shooting of innocent Russian civilians in Donnbass for 10 years was completely normal? azov and aidar types of nazi ultra right divisions in the ukrainian army, have perhaps only a 10% share of the whole. but they have the biggest mouths and are the most aggressive to continue to provoke Russia? This is how they intimidate the entire Ukrainian army! and Russia had to endure everything passively and continue to accept these kinds of atrocities? what do you mean, invasion of a neighboring country! the history of the whole is repeatedly ignored! So does the West want to risk nuclear war to continue helping these ultra-right challengers in Ukraine...
an Israeli says "you cannot just invade another country just because you are strong and Russia should not be allowed to win". Looks like Israel is the only country on earth that is allowed to "win".
You are only looking at one side of the coin
he's from Israel
What about the Israeli colonisations??
You mean, U.S. Congress?
There is no Palestine
Yeah the Arabs invaded and colonised the Israeeli land. But it was centuries ago. But what do you want to to - send them back to Arabia. That is crazy.
There was no country called palestine also the land was berlay settled by arab invaders. Israel is a legit country. Cry
@@shivanandtripathi7821 says the pajeet clown
So, is this guy so much smarter than any of us... I'm not so sure...
He is a cult leader crank.
He is W.E.F 😂😂😂
How can we describe what the state of Israel is doing to Palestinians? Is it even comparable to what is happening in Ukraine?
How is it imperialism if one nation absorbs its own land?
They don't have honor and think a paper defines nationality
This man is Also advisor of Klaus schaw 😊
Everything that keeps some jew from talking about what Israel is doing in Gaza is pure gold...
What global order is the expert talking about? The global order is , when it matches the interest of the collective West, ....
Si fuera otra persona diría que es limitado intelectualmente, pero sabiendo quien es, tengo que decir que sabe que miente, que es un hipócrita y que sencillamente es una mala persona.
Yes... and furthermore, this israelite expects the audience to be uneducated, brainwashed and so admire and believe his despicable, unadulterated, blatant lies.
Someone needs a lesson on very recent history to understand why Russia went into Ukraine in the first place.
Meanwhile America has been on a rampage around the world for 70 years without criticism
The reason is simple. Putin cried big crocodile tears about the dissolution of the Soviet Union and doesn't see Ukraine as an independent country. Oh and he's also an ex KGB Thug.
200 years
@@tricky2014 so what usa n west also doesn't recognise Palestine when the whole global south does ....
I would have asked Yuval: Why have conservative parties become “suicide missions”?
more like, "what tf do you even mean by saying that?" Dude clearly has an agenda
Fraud ... 💯
WEF puppet talking about global order lmao
Why doesn't he address what's happening in his own country Whats is obsession with Russia. 😅
He does question it and publicly oppose it.
He hasn't condemn Israel.
Yet another pathetic Liberal.
@@marlonbryanmunoznunez3179Typical white nationalist neoliberal and hypocrite who wants to maintain the imperialist Rules Based Order!
The obsession with Russia 🇷🇺 is unlike Iraq 🇮🇶 or Libya 🇱🇾 Russia 🇷🇺 is independent with the three F’s which all real power rest on! Russia is an energy superpower (Fuel), Russia can feed itself ( Food) and Russia can defend itself (Fight) and all of those things are a serious threat by a state that challenges the white nationalist aka imperial Rules Based Order!
Hasbara propaganda
This when you got McDonald's diploma and think Mongolians were imperialists:)) And by the way, people of Iraq, Afganistan, Yugoslavia, Sirya would like him to explain something more ..
This is what happens if you get a big share of the current system. You get blind to the rest 90% percent of the people suffering from the system. I wonder if people in Ouest Africa or the Maghreb or any small country feel safe from US or French intervention. You can also call slavery a rule based system does that mean that everyone needs to accept these rules favoring only the hegemonial minority?
I think his brain is stuck on
Auto pilot, maybe he got
Exposed at davos without headgear and its frozen?
Didn’t Israel occupied neighbouring countries land??
Yes for them and their allies it's ok, but some other does it, it would change the global order 🤔
after a war in which it was attacked by all surrounding nations. If that war had never been launched Israel would be much smaller.
That is "good occupation", God blessed, written in Old Testament etc.
@@joecater894you know they still occupy a whole country don't you?
We keep imposing our views and perceptions of the world on others and keep demanding and expect them to live by what standards we set.
Col Douglas Macgregor Ret
Colonel Douglas Macgregor and Scott Ritter both work for a Russian publication called RT which stands for Russia Today. Russia Today has been called "The propaganda arm of Vladimir Putin". RT is 100% funded by the Russian government.
Douglas Macgregor and Scott Ritter would say that black is white and white is black if Putin/Russia want them to say it. Macgregor and Ritter are both paid by the Russian government.
If you don't believe what I have written, I would suggest that you do a little research. If you do some research, you will realize that what I have written is true.
Ask yourself a simple question. - Why don't Macgregor and Ritter publicly admit that they work for RT? The answer to this question is very obvious. If they admit that they are paid by RT/Russia, no educated or reasonably intelligent person will believe anything that they say. Both Ritter and Macgregor are popular in Russia because they say things that Russians want to believe. They are part of a propaganda effort by the Russian government.
The reason that Americans or people from other countries such as members of the European Union would believe things that are said by people like Macgregor and Ritter is because they are either naive, uninformed, uneducated or just plain stupid.
I would say to anyone, before you believe something, check your sources.
It's pullshet,
what about Iraq Afghanistan Vietnam ... +17 countries?
Yuval ,
You don’t forget that we are living now at postmodernism era . Therefore, chaos and wars it’s parts of relativism mindset of postmodernism.
hello from algeria
There's a RAT in the kitchen...
Pity to see such an intelligent man so deluded.
When your faction controls everything everywhere, especially information and money and Western military --- then the world at large is forced to conform to your "reality", rational or not.
Remember "1984": "How many fingers am I holding up, Winston?"
What "global order"?
the one dictated by the yanks
@@sashakeltane4763 and the jews..
@@sashakeltane4763 The one dictated by Esau.
The one dictated by the superior whyte race. The rest of "humanity" is uncivilized and barbaric. Funny how this notion is bone deep for most westerns
Some might say that an Israeli victory would mean the same--Yuval is not one of them.
What about colonionalism including French colonisation of Africa that still exist and Macron is pissed off because Russia kicked them off?
This guy is so busy pointing at the speck of dust in the other guy’s eye he can’t see the plank of wood in his own/own side. I despair
WHAT YOU ARE STANDING FOR IS EXACTLY WHAT THE AMERICANS HAVE BEEN DOING FOR MANY YEARS IN A ROW
So destroyed Iraq, hopeless Afganistan, bombed into Middle Ages Libya is alright… wasn’t a problem for the peaceful world. Suddenly it’s only Russia that matters… I thought Hariri is a thinker, but he behaves like a propagandist… sad
A marketeer profiting from capitalist fiction...
It was the case years ago when Iraq was invaded by Americans, and so was Libya. Maybe Europeans think as long as it did not happen to a European country then it's ok, but now it happened in white Ukraine and they cry aloud
europeans aren't against Russia, just a very few of us that unfortunately happen to be our politicians.
@@jerrygallo8314 Well, you voted for those politicians and I see so much Russophobia coming mainly from western Europe. China, Africa, South America doesn't hate Russia. All the anti-Russia sentiment I see is from Europe and North America.
@@jerrygallo8314 Yes we are, because they are killing innocent people on Ukraine, children ? Hello bot, are you there ? This idiocy, that you wish Russians to win just because you dont like USA is unbelievably ridiculous and stupid, you lost your mind.
@@jerrygallo8314 Yes we are, because they are killing innocent people on Ukraine, children ? Hello bot, are you there ? This idiocy, that you wish Russians to win just because you dont like USA is unbelievably ridiculous and stupid, you lost your mind.
propaganda ... shame!
Remember in his book "Homo Deus", he was talking about famine, plague and War are the things of the past? How wrong he was! He has lost all credentials as a thinker!
This will put an end to a world order in which somebody cares about the opinions of people like Harari.
He is absolutely correct about the fundamental rule that you cannot just invade and conquer and annex another neighboring country. This rule does that not apply if those countries are far away in the Americas, Africa, and Asia. He is very clever with words.
Not global order ITS western influence of interests
My comments are honest. Censorship is dishonest and anti-American.
Betray Ukraine is like betray Czechoslovakia in 1938. Everybody would condemn and regret this in next years. And everybody would regret for their support of WW3
Lol,
Would take more than a Ukrainian victory. That’s just Russia protecting its border from NATO incursions.
Massive difference.
This is the stupidest thing I’ve heard! This guy has lost all credibility!
You can put it however you want, but Putin is a hero for most of the world's countries.
This fella has no clue. Russia invaded to defend itself from Western imperialism. If there was no Western imperialism into Ukraine, Ukraine would be whole.
Which means, when read between the lines--
"We can't let Russia win, or nativists (citizens) everywhere will get the upper-hand against globalism and the elites, collaborators, etc. benefiting from it. That is, if Russia wins the real, non-immigrant, native-populations of all the countries of the earth will have a shot at reversing the last few hundred years of despotism, of callous rulers importing/exporting immigrants to aid & abet despotism at home and abroad, etc.
The people who are "world citizens", the people for whom the world is their pearl, the people who have no inherent need, desire, reverence, etc. for something clean, pure, undefiled, for something akin to filial-piety, to the preservation of multi-generational heritage/legacy, etc. These are the people who have gained from the last hundred-plus years. These are the people who need to worry about a Russian victory, which is nothing more but a barometer for the victories of the subjugated nativist peoples of the world.
P.S. This man is either genuinely aloof or malfeasant. Conservatism is conservatism even when it has no choice but to stand on its ground. Clearly, conservatism doesn't look like conservatism when you have allowed despotism to thrive for so long, when any action will look revolutionary by definition. The conservative is still conservative, the only problem is that his rulers, before Trump, were knowingly collaborating, aiding & abetting, the non-conservative forces, and as a result, when the turning point arrives, a choice has to be made, no matter if it looks conservative at all.
He who feeds him controls what he says.
so all countries felt safe ??? when russia said i dont feel safe with ukraine in nato , where have you been ????
If Russia doesn't win we doom, Russia needs to get help from Africa and middle East.
You can't invade country? Really? Are you clueless or you are just like Old Joe, forgetting things?
global order or the US order? It is ok for US to invade Iraq unilaterally?
The U.S. didn't try to annex Iraq or Afghanistan and when they left Afghanistan it went down the dumpster.
Even US journalists call it an invasion
The US was wrong to invade Iraq and George W Bush should be rotting in jail. Like Putin.
@@Dan-uf2vhAmerican imperialism is still in Iraq 🇮🇶 even that government has asked them to leave on many occasions! The imperialist are in Syria 🇸🇾 illegally and sponsors violence all over the world 🌍 but you Liberals with your fake moral superiority can’t see that 🤔
@@Dan-uf2vh lol the US stole all the oil from Iraq so what is the difference?
Russia didn't invade Ukraine because she is stronger, but because she refuse to have nuclear missile in her border as Ukraine join nato
These warmongers need to be stopped
That's what Russia is doing, stopping the mentally-ill warmongers in NATO and the EU. Not a pretty sight all those masks coming off either.
Where was this global order when the U.S. invaded Iraq and Afghanistan and installed proxy governments? As long as Russia installs a puppy government in Kiev, it's gonna be OK, then, because it's just like the U.S.
Hey, Harari don't be so sure about what imperialism is. You seem to forget about USA invasions? And don't worry, Russia doesn't need your approval to win😛
Harari says you cannot annexe a neighbouring country just because you are stronger. He needs to go on Israel TV.
Mongol examples seem very relevant.
BTW, WW2 started in 1932 when Japan invaded China.
sorry which country is Israel invading?
@@josefgatti9328 Palestine.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_recognition_of_the_State_of_Palestine
For thousands of years? Tell that to USA/ Mexico/Hawaii/Puerto Rico....
Usa took part of Serbia because is rich part of Serbia and because they are stronger. Now when Russia do the same it is problem 😂
WW5, WW3 was “the cold war, WW4 was “the war on terror”.
Very much a western world point of view. What he is saying doesn't go with my point of view. To me, Russia is the last hope for the non western world. Because Nato has became a threat to us all.
Russia winning or losing the war in Ukraine, won't mean anything, unless the warmongers want to promote a bigger war.
War mongers in russia won't stop in Ukrane.
same as they said about Hitler.
@@joecater894 and Bush, but nobody stopped Bush. Nobody stopped Clinton when he attacked Sudan, then he attacked Yugoslavia etc.
It means Ukrainian people have lost their beloved homeland to a barbaric and crazed dictator.
This can not be allowed to happen . Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦 💪🏼🇺🇦💪🏼🇺🇦
@@kingsindian8948 Dd you use the same words when Iraqi people lost their land to psychotic president who was in some kind of delusional "crusade"?
Yuval, you're a smart guy! Please DO question your own words and learn more about reasons behind Russian attack on Ukraine.
NATO annexed Kosovo from Serbia. (Kosovo teritory is in UN recognized borders of Serbia)but he does not count it because he is biased