ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 มิ.ย. 2024
- When it comes to drop-top sports cars, it doesn’t get much better than the Mercedes-AMG SL 55 and the Porsche 911 GTS.
But what happens if you’re in the market for one and can’t decide which to choose? Well, Mat’s here to help you make that decision!
So let’s see how the two compare, starting with the design. The new SL 55 rolls up with a super aggressive front end, with a big AMG grille straddling the centre with big air vents on either side. It’s a bit tamer around the back, but at least you get quad-tailpipes with it. As for the Porsche, it has the traditional sloping bonnet up front for that classic 911 look. The rear end’s a bit large, but that’s what you expect when you choose a convertible.
One thing these cars both have in common is the quality of the interior. The AMG comes with its customary jet engine-style air vents, good-quality materials throughout, as well as a huge infotainment screen in the centre. You’ll also find carbon fibre trim on the centre console. As for the Porsche, it’s also made with high-quality materials throughout, and in our opinion has a slightly better build quality. The dials also look absolutely gorgeous!
But of course, it’s not all about style… Sports cars need to have performance, and neither of these cars is lacking in that department! The Porsche is powered by a 3-litre twin-turbo flat-six that can deliver 480hp and 570Nm of torque. As for the AMG, it’s housing a 4-litre twin-turbo V8 under the bonnet that can deliver 476hp and 700Nm. However, whereas the Porsche only drives the rear wheels, the AMG sends power to all four!
When it comes to the price, the Porsche comes in at just under £125,000, although if you spend £6,000 more you can get it with AWD. As for the AMG, it’s a whole lot more expensive, coming in at over £147,000!
So is it worth splashing more cash on the AMG? You’ll need to stick with Mat and see for yourself!
Chapters
00:00 Intro
01:38 Design
03:11 Roofs
04:05 Interior
05:32 Practicality
07:42 Engines
09:09 Heated Seats
10:38 Driving
14:47 Verdict
Sell your car with carwow: bit.ly/Buy-Sell-WOW
Mercedes-AMG SL 55 review: • Mercedes-AMG SL review...
Porsche 911 GT3 RS review: • Why I'm buying this car! - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
AMG SL 55 v 911 GTS: Which is best? VOTE BELOW!
VOTE: Porsche 911 GTS!
VOTE: AMG SL 55!
Sls
porsh911
@@carwow Porsche 911 GTS
Everytime I see a 911 I always predict it’s gonna win
Especially when its compared to a Mercedes...
Should stick to competiting with BMW, Audis etc
True haha
That’s called form. And you’re right!
When is Matt gonna peel that coat off?? 😂
@@rg6982 still wins
Mat is secretly a Porsche fanboy 😂 I like both brands, but it was easy to see which one he prefers.
I see he is in this video biased to porche car unfortunately 💔
@@Hamood_1995 wtf are yall talking about he told you the exact reasons why he prefers the porsche... did you really think an sl 55 can kep up with a 911 GTS? open your eyes
@@hellskitchen1566 exactly it's always been superior thanks to history
every car reviewer ever would take a 911 over an SL55. watch the reviews on the SL and they are not that great
Guys a 911 has history behind it. It's basically in supercar league. An SL has always been just an ordinary roadster
Germany never disappoints with their converible cars!
Yep. Germans and UK also.
Yep don’t judge I actually prefer German cars over japanese😅.no no don’t fight with me
Italy
What? 🤣 they disappoint full stop with their abysmal reliability. Two laps of a small track and these junk heaps are on a tow truck. Porsche now the most unreliable brand on earth. Ohh my how the mighty have fallen🤣
@@bigduphusaj162 you really live up to your name
Personally, would go GTS cuz I like the handling dynamics. But you can't go wrong with both. The SL is more about cruising comfortably and stylishly, with that roaring V8. Also to add to the bulbous-looking rear end of the 911 cabriolet, this is why I love the Turbo S cab. The rear wing really balances out the rear.
100% agreed. Especially comparing the Turbo vs Carrera models. The 992’s rear end hasn’t grown on me, especially when looking back at the beautiful 991.
Aero pack helps with that a lot. It looks gorgeous on a gts
@@MrOmarMoustafa I personally find the aero kit looks a bit too exaggerated. Every time I see one with an aero kit, I always feel like it's carrera trying to be a GT3.
i'm a big Porsche fan but damn, that SL is gorgeous😇
Even so the SL 55 cant match 911GTS. 911 GTS still 9.5/10.
Couldn’t agree more!
@@purwantiallan5089 looks only:
New SL = 10/10
911 Cabriolet = 8,5/10
911 Carrera Coupé = 9,5/10
911 Targa = 10/10
911 Turbo = 9,5/10
911 GT3 RS = 8,5/10
911 GT3 & GT3T = 9,5/10
911 SC = 10/10
911 Dakar = 8,5/10
@@jatterhogthe most accurate list I have ever seen
The major thing for me is the cruise control placement. Mercedes gets it right, Porsche gets it dead wrong. I will not buy a Porsche for that reason alone. The entire purpose of an automobile is motion. Cruise control controls motion; that has logical priority over a "phone"!
The new SL is so gorgeous top down, IDC if people disagree
Yep. SL 55 still 9/10.
It’s gonna age like milk
@@Geopolitica1946 Nah, most of Mercedes’ current design language will age well
@@BC08 not with ugly AMG grill looks like a failed Maserati
@@jambear7862 The current Mercedes front end styling is going to age well. Mark my words
And it looks nothing like a Maserati. Proportions, angles, overall aesthetic is totally different.
What you’re doing there is akin to me discounting Porsche styling by saying “The Porsche front end looks like a VW Beetle” …which is actually a more accurate “insult” that what you delivered with the Maserati / Benz comparison
I already knew that the porche will win, cause Mat loves porche cars :D
But still a fun video like always :D
Setsuna Yuki and Shioriko Mifune also love Porsche cars, Qunas.
@@purwantiallan5089 😳😳
the porch wins, because ts the better car ;)
@@davidkn I think you meant Porsche. Porch is something else entirely.
The airscarv in Mercedes convertibles is just marvelous.
Thank you carwow!
I couldn’t decide what to buy between these two beauties. This video helped me make my decision. I decided to go for Lada Yugo Convertible
Sorry , but there is no lada convertible , but you can get the Yugo tho .
Toyota Yaris convertible 🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶
you should find some sleep son
@@dzontravolta3952 what about Shelby Series 1??
@@bobateacuber7646 Shelby Series 1 has some words for you.
The SL is so clean 🤩 Like a baby GT
Rear end is dire. So is the interior. So are the driving dynamics. L of a car
@@gregmayled ur opinion
@@gregmayled nope. Its still W Car anyway.
@@purwantiallan5089 comes last in every group test. It’d a shadow of its former generations. Totally lost its meaning and place in the market. Such a shame. Adored the previous SL63, R129 etc
Sophisticated GT
I will never lose hope. I will buy these one day
Just based on pure looks. I will go for the SL 9 out of 10 times
For me always 911GTS.
Same. Plus, the 911 has become as common as a Prius.
911 is the icon
@@joshuathomas512 True. But ultimately, these cars are toys you buy for the way they make you feel. So, whichever makes you feel more special is the best.
@@usandutzdusting that Mercedes in my gts makes me feel better 😅
that benz looks sooo gooood
For me the Porsche looks way better especially from the rear
looks like a 911 attempt (2nd) into a mercedes (1rts) attempt AMG GT
@@Cars_with_max yep. The rear kinda similar to even Mercedes Vision GT tho.
As a serial SL owner, I’m a bit biased… But, the SL just sounds fab-u-lus! And, I think both rear’s look really good - the 911 reminds me of the old 356…
The only 2 sports cars I’ve driven in my life were an older sl55, and a new 911. The 911 was beautiful, but I have to say the V8 and big deep sounding exhaust of the sl55 kind of made it more exciting and fun
It's slower tho lol
Great comparison test Matt. Thank you very much. Love them both to be honest.
I just love the 911 GTS cab especially with roof down at night. It makes me miss my cooper s convertible I loved driving that at night and all the pops and bangs. Top vid Matt
Great comparison, thanks! These are both great cars and available in AWD hard to beat with power + handling + class + looks
I really like this setting for videos, snow, fall, dirt on cars. Makes it genuine
Mat we want more comparison videos like this one!
What about comparisons between Shelby Series 1 and Ford GT40?
I agree! The rear of the convertibles are so strange I would get the Targa every time!
Great review of both cars. I cross-shopped these and am now a very happy owner of the SL55. Love driving it and prefer the interior of the SL.
Matt, it needs clarification - the SL 55 does not feature the electrified turbochargers, nor does even the 63. Within the SL model line it's the 43 only that has that technology applied. As for the AMG's current line up, the only models with an electrified turbocharger are C 43, SL 43 and C 63 S E PERFORMANCE.
I love these comparison videos Carwow, keep em coming! 👍🔥
Hope Carwow also do a comparison video between BMW M3 GTR and PORSCHE 911 GTS.
The Merc is gorgeous
I recently purchased the Mercedes-AMG SL63 from my local Benz dealer. I have owned BMW & Mercedes during the past 25 years. Absolutely luv my new SL. Super sporty, comfy & elegant. Haven't tried Porsche yet ...
That SL looks fantastic. I’d have it in yellow.
𝙃𝙚𝙮 ☝️𝙔𝙤𝙪'𝙫𝙚 𝙬𝙤𝙣 𝙖 𝙥𝙧𝙞𝙯𝙚 🎉
Im a BMW fan, but since its release Ive fallen in love with the sl 63, or this 55. I agree the rear looks a bit odd compared to the front, which I love. I like the interior of it as well compared to other Mercedes products. Recently Merc has been doing too much closs and too many screens. the sl does not have that. But the car I do love
The 911 is an objectively better sports car, but that biturbo V8 is undeniably fun and exciting. Tough choice
Thank you for the car seat comparison!
Both of these cars are stunning. Would be my dream to have either!
That SL is just gorgeous looking car, waaay better than the legendary 911
Both lovely cars, love the sound of the SL 👍🔥😊
I own a 2022 992 and LOVE it! Nice review!
Thanks for giving us a proper verdict 😊
20 years on the sl55 makes exactly the same power as the old one. Give me the supercharged one all day 😎
They're both turbos..
Another excellent review: both informative and entertaining. Well done! Both great cars, but I think I would prefer the Porsche.
Thanks for watching
Expect more uploads sooner
You’ve been as a winner 📩
Quickly send a direct telegram message to acknowledge your prize 🎖congratulations once more🎊
I'm With you Matt I drive my two convertibles the Boxster s 981 and the F-Type roof down in the middle of winter in the middle the night what a great sensation that is
I have both the SLS gull wing and the 911S cab and both are magnificent cars but my 911 is just so light and uncomplicated - best car ever
Both beautiful cars.
FINALLY YOU UPGRADED THE CAMERA! NOW WE CAN SEE YOU AT NIGHT INSIDE THE CAR! THANK YOU!!!
They both look gorgeous.
SL55 gets beautiful interior and exterior design, 911 is prestigious for its performance and dependability. Hard choice!
Matthew... spot on reviews
𝙃𝙚𝙮 ☝️𝙔𝙤𝙪'𝙫𝙚 𝙬𝙤𝙣 𝙖 𝙥𝙧𝙞𝙯𝙚 🎉🎉
Great video!
Congratulations you have been selected amongst my lucky winner, text me on telegram to redeem your gift.
Congratulations you have been selected amongst my lucky winner, text me on telegram to redeem your gift.
never driven them but in terms of styling i'd definitely go for Mercedes. I feel like the AMG styling is much better and more aggressive which looks better on this type of car
Mat we want more drag races with hypercars like Bugatti, Hennessy, Rimac, McLaren, Ferrari and Koenigsegg!
I like your jacket. You seem like you driving a F1 with it :-). Great review as most of yours. Keep up with the good work.
Let's talk👆..
Great review
Both look great. However with the news that the AMG GT convertible is being absorbed into the SL, I have to say the SL doesn't look nearly as classic as the GT vert.
I really love the porsche 911, but not the cabrio version (the Targa is much more stylish); at the same time the new mercedes sl is one of the most beautiful car I’ve ever seen (according to my tastes at least), therefore I’d buy that one
I have a 992 Targa 4S and love it!
Great video! Can you please do a video where you compare al generations audi RS3? thanks so much. Love youre video's!
I live in the south of Spain and i Have seen the new 911 and the new mercedes amg gt and they both look good. They are testing them here and i see them almost every day. I have seen the new E-class as well and the Panemara, and the replacement of the Aventador.
For a [twin test] you still need a runway showdown - sprint, etc.
Nice roadtest nevertheless.
Al.
911 is another level❤️
Lol, the little jump-out at the beginning tickled me 😂🤣
Mercedes is way better all rounder for one car as you suggested in video . I realize you are Porsche enthusiast but .... Greatest car reviewer on the web ! Best wishes!
Mat: "You can feel your sperm dying" made me laugh a lot 😂
I really like the sl, but I think it’s a bit too expensive
SL 55 costed $168.000
you can get it with a fucking 4 cylinder :D and still pay 120k€........
@@AnteFuerst thats embarrasing from amg
I remember in 1993 my 300zx TT had HICAS the rear wheel steering as well. Back then it was innovative.
Congratulations you have been selected amongst my lucky winner text me on telegram to redeem your gift.!!!
Honda preludes had that back in 1987!
Good to see your normal bias shining through. Enjoyed the review, you should have done a tunnel test to get the full sound impact.
🏁 I Love AMG but the safe bet is the 911 because I’m sure it will maintain its value better than the depreciation King 😎🤙🏾
I like the redesigned SL but as you said the value will sink like a rock compared to the 911
SL has it in the looks👀 department but the 911 is the all around better option
@@justinfarmer6635 SL 55 is 9/10 imo. 911GTS still 9.8/10.
@@kaleek5362 yep. Even also compared to even Chevy Lacetti.
That would be true, but with the v8 biturbo being phased out, I think it will probably retain it value
Great job, Matt, really enjoyable!
I rate this 100/100.
*That colour is something special* 😍
Thanks for watching and leaving a comment..✅✅
you have been selected
among our shortlisted winners, send a Dm through the platform above🎉🎁
He’s hands down one of my top 3 all time car reviewers
Please do a comparison of bentley bentayga v8 and mercedes amg gls63
That's a neat jacket Mat has, I wish there was a way to find out what brand it is.
Either naff naff, or spliffy.
Judging by the checked pattern in the hood, I think it is Aquascutum 👍
Burberry
Zara
I did fit a front facing child seat in rear seat of the 911 and it works perfectly
The Merc has tubro with electrical assist? That is purdy coool.
On some cars if you switch of the ASC/DSC if will remove the soft limiters...worth a try.
Congratulations you have been selected amongst my lucky winner, text me on telegram to redeem your gift.........
PERFECT WEATHER FOR A CONVERTIBLE RIDE!
I like them both. How can you go wrong, they are both fantastic cars with tons of tech, and they are gorgeous, perfect for Summer fun and picking up girls!
6:46 This transition im dead💀💀
Congratulations you have been selected amongst my lucky winner, text me on telegram to redeem your gift....
I'd love to have to make a choice like this. In real life that is.
Two stunning cars! 9 times out of 10 in tests between Porsche against anything I prefer Porsche 992:s but in this match the win goes to Mercedes. Such a beautiful car.
Agree on the verdict. Good review.👍
Just waiting for the sounds on this one
Mat thank you so much for this insane video!
I liked comment
100/100.
I prefer the AMG, it looks more grown up. I am a creature of comfort so tend to lean towards the Benz and its equipment.
testing it in the winter
Congratulations you have been selected amongst my lucky winner, text me on telegram to redeem your gift........
that colour is mad nice on that AMG.
Just watch SL55 night drive, and then tell that porche has better interior. The ambient lighting in the Merc is outstanding.
100%, correct
A Mercedes é belíssima!
keep up the good work! cool video!
2 convertibles in the Middle of the winter. Nice🎉
Great Video Mate . I’ll go for the Porsche
Matt is working very very very hard to get that GT3 RS from Porsche 😀
Let's talk👆..🎉
Love the porsche. But my money goes to that merc.
The snug sitting in the SL 55 is really appealing. Seems very comfy...
Let's talk👆..
Gotta go with the 911 beautiful machine
Both are beautiful cars! In the meantime I love my Miata NC because that's the only convertible I can afford
Peace from 🎌
Carwow and Mat on top!
Always on top.
0:33Nice jump Matt!!!!! 🤣
WOW that Merc screen size !crazy..
10:15 I felt that
The way Matt said "you can feel your sperms dying". 😂
@@kesseykevin7037 exactly lmao
On the dark day like this , it would be so smart to drive gray car with the lights on.
10:16 "You can feel your sperms dying"
That came outta nowhere 😭
I would love to see a full review of a Porsche 911 Targa
The back sit of the Porsche will be for my accessories 😎