I mean, tbf that probably wouldn't have gone well for him, she's kasrkin, far more capable than a guardsman, and in this scene, he only has a few guardsmen regs behind them (who other kasrkin are already pointing their guns at mind you) so if he tried that he would have likely died and accomplished nothing but possibly killing the commissar (who is weirdly more on the Officers side then wanting to finish the mission). not to mention if I recall right, he isn't carrying a gun, especially not a plasma pistol which the kasrkin sergeant has, so even by a miracle he succeeds the munitorium knows what was issued to the Sergeant, it would be awfully weird for a plasma pistol to leave a lasgun wound.
The Rambo Bros would have said we have a new commissar coming? Okay 5 minutes later excuse me the commissary is dead.... He stepped on the cute flower The krieg? Retreat??????????..... Commissar why are you speaking this heretical word? Boom! 💥 This is the krieg squad 3 our commissar is dead he was a traitor to the emperor CHARGE THE ENEMY!!!!
The absolute worst part was the smug and dismissive administratum lady who just said ''uh no this is wrong, destroy all of it, thank you come again'' making the entire struggle pointless, stay classy administratum....
The end felt a little grim-derpy to me. Like I understand the "inefficient and bogged-down" Imperium... But this made no sense. The garrison has ammo. The administration wants ammo, however, they have different values for each munition. It makes absolutely no sense that a Supply Officer wouldn't specify what they need. If I want heavy bolter rounds, Griffon mortar shells, and basilisk rounds, I'd make that clear. It's silly that you'd send all of your ammo transports down with no idea as to what the garrison has on hand, and further still, take it when it's of no value to you...
@@boydc.5629 It's almost like the Departmento Munitorum is a bloated bureaucratic nightmare. Who's effectiveness wavers from barely acceptable to actively harmful. Oh wait... That's exactly what it is.
@@scorchercast8366 have u noticed real life is the same? Look at the current conflict and how lives are disregarded. Being impossibly stupid is unbelievably common. I would imagine our living condition wont be that much different if we make it to 40000 years in the future and i hope for all our sake that what u say really turns out true.
The commissar feel remorse.After that. He stay with the guard until the end. Giving is ammo and only fight with is chainsword. True chad. He know the duty was bullshit but he is forced to do it. He decided to die with the guardsman because he cannot deal with this munitorum bullshit anymore.
A certain band of Astartes knows this tale All Too Well. Ahem Badab Wars. Seriously the most justified instance of turning against the Imperium( Munitorum)
@@Sujad nope....the administratum , therefore the tithes , must be payed....this rule is absolute....and a commissar didnt stand about the administratum
@@Endurius Not from an active warzone though. The Guard don't tithe themselves. They tithe the factory worlds for supplies. The commissar, if written correctly, would have summarily executed whoever issued those orders. Commissars are outside the chain of command for a reason. Your reply shows a tourist level understanding of the setting.
By the way, SPOILERS, this sacrifice was all for nothing, and they all died in the end. All of this because the Munitorum considered Ammo more Vallubale then human lives. And pepole say that Warhammer 40k lost his grimdark.
Worse still, what ammo they did bring up was then deemed too cheap for the storage space it took up and was disintegrated to make room for more expensive equipment/ammo.
with enough ammo, you can cause explosion big enough to critically damage one big enemy, rather than waste it piecemeal on little enemies that are worth nothing. You gotta start thinking like Emperor if you want the Emperor to one day be reincarnated
With millions of space marines running around beating everything into submission, 2 returned primarchs perfect to reorganizing/stabilizing the imperium, one of witch has a ability that works alot like teleportation across sectors and with new advanced tech at the read. Yeah the grim part has been lessoned, if anything these alot more hope.
No matter if its 600 year BC or 40000 years AC it doesnt matter, there is something poetic about a soldier receiving an order, going at attention and then leaving on a jog to deliver information.
Tragic, actually. That same response to orders is how the US ended up being responsible for the deaths of over a million civilians in Iraq alone for an action justified entirely by lies.
Nah dude he's gonna eat it in the same way slaanesh eats aeldari souls. Hell he already eats 10,000 human psyker souls a day on the throne. You're fucked in every way possible
It is such a depressing thought imagine defending your home your planet fighting for something you believe in only to have your only means of defending yourself taken from you, left to die for nothing. WH40k can be epic but fuck it always reminds you why it is grimdark
@@Sujad Grimdark is the true essence of comedy, which is funny because hope remains inspite of what would otherwise be utterly horrific. These men have faith, they have solidarity, they must doom one another to go to their doom, doom they hope to find salvation in, that's the grimdarkness of this scene.
The book "Dead men walking" has a Krieg Colonel order a withdrawl during the final big battle the book had been working up to , abandoning the world to the Necrons because they suddenly determined it to be too costly, leaving behind all civilians and Krieg trained PDF
@@FelicitousCitizenStruggler Except the commissar wouldn't have accepted the orders. It goes against everything he'd have been taught as the Schola. Hell, even Beije wouldn't have followed those orders.
The whole point of laser weapons is that their ammo is supper cheap and ubiquitous. It's made on planetary scales all throughout the imperium. Why are they short-changing these guys?
The ammo, I recon in this regard, is of the heavy variety; heavy machine guns, AA's, mortars and artillery. The humble lass-rifle can only be so effective, when amassed in superior numbers OR accompanied by heavy support fire.
There is also the problem of warp travel. The Imperium might have a lot of ammo but not the sector, and the ammo delivery could come tomorrow or in a thousand years.
Logistical issues are common place in a buracracy that administrates billions of world from just two planatary centres. This isn't even that bad entire planets can starve because a form gets lost by a clerk, reinforcemnet and resupply can arrive three centuries too late because of a small clerical error.
The Emperor - No guys, don't force them to surrender the ammo. Give them a chance. Commisar- The Emperor demands your sacrifice. Emperor - For fuxks sake, man.
they get fragged all the time... thats why so many is trained and sent to units :D some units go trough dozens of em before one sane one comes from pipe line.
It depends on the regiment Catachans regularly frag their commissars for being too douchy Krieg also sometimes do, but because they think the commissars arent loyal enough, which i think is very funny
When I finally pieced together this full episode it became one of my favorite starting places for 40k lore outside of the astartes medias that everyone goes after
the best part of 40k is that it takes off the ability of thinking from the imperial officers and in its place the faith which is funny because the one think that defines an officer is the ability of critically thinking
Spoiler for this episode: All the ammo collected wasn't even worth the space it would've taken up in the ships above, so it was ordered destroyed at the end of the episode. The people who sent the ammo collecters wanted artillery shells and heavy weapons ammo for another theatre on the same planet or in the same system. All they got from these poor bastards was rifle and pistol ammo. The AA batteries surrounding the area this conversation is taking place in couldn't even fire because they had run dry already.
Only a willful traitor or a heretic would choose to weaken the Imperium by requisition all of the ammo and heavy fire support on a world being attacked by Xenos. The Ministorum is stupid as fuck, they are not *that* stupid.
the problem with 40k is that there are millions in the munitorium doing millions of things and the communication is slow as hell, by the time someone discovers this it will have passed centuries and the person did or more mistakes and was turned into a servitor or didnt make more mistakes and was just push under the radar. This is why 40k can have things like this happening because the chaos in everything to make the imperium survive.
@@MarcosAlexandre-no3qx but at same time if world doesnt pay its tithe it will take hundreds of years before someone comes and asks why.... they could just not have delivered the ammo.
@@alexius9072 the problem with that is that when they come usually they come in strenght and seeing the planet as rebelious. Yeah the imperium is strange.
@@zayffon1325the amount of people who think the Imperium is a perfect governement which only does the correct thing is baffling to me. Have they not read the very introduction paragraph of 40k ? Do they even own a single codex or read the wiki ? How can they think the Imperium wouldn't do stupid and cruel thing ??? It's the entire point of the Imperium !!!
i love how the imperium changed from mankind first to the god emperor first. am convinced the imperium is ruled by chaos cults, and the inquisition is unknowingly protecting them.
Spoiler: The planet they deliver the ammo to was 'overstocked' so it was destroyed. I like the idea of an entire planet being a stockpile (shows the scale of Warhammer 40K) but it seems like a dumb idea. Just send a small fleet to target the ammo and the entire planet blows up and the sector has no or very little ammo.
These armory worlds are some of the most heavily defended worlds in the Imperium having defenses that needed to be disabled on the ground for a fleet to stay in orbit long enough to do orbital bombardment and often times these armors are also stored deep under ground making it harder to destroy with just the fleet. Also the invading forces for these worlds wouldn't want to destroy it, as the weapons and technology there are what they want to steal and too precious to risk just orbital bombardment to get to it. The only two factions that wouldn't care as much and just orbital bomb them would be the necrons and Eldar. Chaos: that precious resources not to be squandered. Orkz: Loot Tau: potential tech for reverse engineering Tyranids: want to eat the planet so auto ground invasion regardless.
What is to stop the commissar to talk to an astropath to contact segmentum command, and give a sitrep of the situation with the imperial guard commander?
Even by the standards of the imperium this was an absolutely shit order, orders like that waste lives and lives are the Emperor's Coin. Being loose with His currency is heresy, and heresy means death.
@@FEURVERM They really can't but they can still force the issue but forcing the issue on a world where "We're all fucking doomed anyway" is prrrooooobably not your best option, here.
And they just up and burn it cause the vault planet is barely holding together cause it’s over stocked. And parts of the galaxy can’t even get the needed material to build and retaliate against their own.
Im pretty fucking sure they arent allowed to do this shit since its a active warzone the most they will do is slow down the ammo and fuel shipments for more important warzones
They do this all the time. For example, they exterminate the whole planet if they found seeds of chaos corruption to prevent the spread of chaos influence to neighbouring planets. They also exterminate an entire planet fill with life just to slow down the tyranid invasion.
This makes no fucking sense. The Guard make use of las gun packs. Las gun packs can canonically be recharged by being tossed into a fire place. They may be losing their auto cannons and bolter rounds, but their lasguns and las cannons should still be good if they are only taking ammo.
It made no sense and that was the point. Administratum wanted to recall ammo to be sent to another world. The paperwork was in error, and instead of only heavy artillery being requested, all ammo, regardless of what, was requested instead. And the guard did as they were ordered, sending every single battery pack, grenades, light and heavy ammo, all of it to the ships. Because that was their duty- To follow orders. In the end the ammo was discarded by the administratum because it was not what they wanted, though it was precisely what they requested. The sacrifice was meaningless due to imperium's incompetent bureucracy eating away at what human soul remains inside Imperium- Or perhaps, that arrogant hubris and incompetence is precisely the human soul in 40k. The point of the whole episode was to show how pointless duty was in 40k- And despite that, how humanity in 40k will do their duty despite that- Either because they don't know better, or are stubborn enough to not change.
@@Warhamer116See, I interpret that differently. They recognize the situation is hopeless yet fight on anyway because to do otherwise is to admit humanity is destined to die against the oncoming night. I still hate the lore inconsistency cause again las packs are a thing, but I get the intent at least now.
@@shadowofhawk55 Las packs are not integrated to the lasguns. They are ammo, only that they can be field recharged. But if the order is to surrender all ammo, including the las packs, it doesn't matter if you can field recharge the ammo or not- It goes to the pile. How it functions is irrelevant.
@@Warhamer116 once you make one las pack its basically an infinite resource. Why would you need to take those? I get needing to requisition auto cannon rounds or mortar shells, but las packs?
It amazes me that more guardsmen don’t execute their own commissars. Yarrick is the only one I’ve ever heard of who wasn’t a completely insufferable twat.
usually comissars are in a class of their own and aren't that much of an asshole, usually being designed to green squads to maintain morale as thoses don't know the horror of war yet. Besides most of them are really good commanders and make sure you will live as long as they can
Most of the commissars are excellent leaders except for a few individuals. And they are trained in schola progenium. It takes balls to kill a commissar they are good combatants
don't take the memes of 40k Commissars as face value lore wise Commissars generally don't going around blaming every soldier that disagrees with them off the bat. And those that do don't live that long. Alot of those commissars do get fragged by their own soldiers, or by another commissar or higher officer for being wasteful
for me i feel it don't make sense this whole setup feel like a big traitor scheme more than a normal situation. you don't make the guard in battle abandon them ammo. it's like abandoning the world to the xeno, what the imperium never do... either they fight until the last men for protect it or simply exterminatus it. you don't leave any potential threat in the hand of the xeno. on one side the story is well written but the setup feel...forced and not really in tunes with what is the imperium. commisar and even the high command of the astra militarum will have not followed this order. and for people saying i'm wrong... hellreach. yes, they can move troops from line to line, but never they abandon a war.
that part have me kinda upset, i feel the setting is setup for make it grimdark. no one will have allows this order to pass... you don't abandon a world to the xeno, worst, if they have wanted to stop this war.... exterminatus. you don't cripple your own army for no good reason.
@@Beldhan they don't see those guardsmen as people, they don't see the good in protecting that planet and yes it was infuriating for them to do that But well.....nobody is a good guy in 40k
@@scarletfoxfrostnovember3407 yes, they see guardsmen as tool. but loosing tool over a taxes feel wrong. the tithes will not be collected from the front line... if they want to collect ammo from a front line it will happend when they decide to do an exterminatus and remove any troop from the surface. loosing a planet to the xeno it's something they don't allows... the imperium follow the rule of: you will not get this world, and if we can't control it, we will burn it to ground. mostly because each world lost increase the strenght of the enemy. that why i have said that the setup feel artificially grimdark. the one behind it, didn't take in account that warhammer 40K it's a story about war, yes you have decision that are stupid, but the whole idea to abandon a world without burn it to the ground feel alien. worst abandon guardmen without ammo is something the astra militarum will not tolerate... yes guardmens are tool ,but you don't throw away a tool that can still be used.
The Emperor unable to speak: God you guys can't think for yourselves.
So loyal, yet so stupid are my followers- Big E sitting on a golden throne.
It's easy to understand why you would turn to Chaos. The Emperor cannot help you.
God? The Emperor would never said that word, you're heretic
He can speak, and has spoken since being dead emperor on throne. Just they aren't valuable enough yo speak out for.
You sound like the warp has overtaken you!
Oh no, a terrible friendly fire incident, the commissar died and the one who negligently discharged her weapon was shot.
ahahah
remind me of that one scene from space marine 2
I mean, tbf that probably wouldn't have gone well for him, she's kasrkin, far more capable than a guardsman, and in this scene, he only has a few guardsmen regs behind them (who other kasrkin are already pointing their guns at mind you) so if he tried that he would have likely died and accomplished nothing but possibly killing the commissar (who is weirdly more on the Officers side then wanting to finish the mission). not to mention if I recall right, he isn't carrying a gun, especially not a plasma pistol which the kasrkin sergeant has, so even by a miracle he succeeds the munitorium knows what was issued to the Sergeant, it would be awfully weird for a plasma pistol to leave a lasgun wound.
The Rambo Bros would have said we have a new commissar coming? Okay 5 minutes later excuse me the commissary is dead.... He stepped on the cute flower
The krieg? Retreat??????????..... Commissar why are you speaking this heretical word? Boom! 💥 This is the krieg squad 3 our commissar is dead he was a traitor to the emperor CHARGE THE ENEMY!!!!
Commissar 2.0: oh?. He was an a-hole
Guardsman: any issues
Commissar 2.0: no, that happens all the time, carry on soldier.
The absolute worst part was the smug and dismissive administratum lady who just said ''uh no this is wrong, destroy all of it, thank you come again'' making the entire struggle pointless, stay classy administratum....
This is why we love 40k. Imperfection and disregard for human live mimics real life so closely and becomes relatable
@@jeffxie6334 Yup, no demon or gigantic space bug will ever compare to the monster that is sheer human hubris and incompetence.
The end felt a little grim-derpy to me. Like I understand the "inefficient and bogged-down" Imperium... But this made no sense.
The garrison has ammo. The administration wants ammo, however, they have different values for each munition. It makes absolutely no sense that a Supply Officer wouldn't specify what they need.
If I want heavy bolter rounds, Griffon mortar shells, and basilisk rounds, I'd make that clear. It's silly that you'd send all of your ammo transports down with no idea as to what the garrison has on hand, and further still, take it when it's of no value to you...
@@boydc.5629 It's almost like the Departmento Munitorum is a bloated bureaucratic nightmare. Who's effectiveness wavers from barely acceptable to actively harmful.
Oh wait...
That's exactly what it is.
@@scorchercast8366 have u noticed real life is the same? Look at the current conflict and how lives are disregarded. Being impossibly stupid is unbelievably common. I would imagine our living condition wont be that much different if we make it to 40000 years in the future and i hope for all our sake that what u say really turns out true.
The commissar feel remorse.After that. He stay with the guard until the end. Giving is ammo and only fight with is chainsword. True chad. He know the duty was bullshit but he is forced to do it. He decided to die with the guardsman because he cannot deal with this munitorum bullshit anymore.
A certain band of Astartes knows this tale All Too Well. Ahem Badab Wars. Seriously the most justified instance of turning against the Imperium( Munitorum)
This is a bad fanfiction of 40K. It goes into grimderp territories. A commissar would have executed whoever issued those orders.
@@Sujad nope....the administratum , therefore the tithes , must be payed....this rule is absolute....and a commissar didnt stand about the administratum
@@Endurius Not from an active warzone though. The Guard don't tithe themselves. They tithe the factory worlds for supplies. The commissar, if written correctly, would have summarily executed whoever issued those orders. Commissars are outside the chain of command for a reason.
Your reply shows a tourist level understanding of the setting.
@@Sujad I see so the rules of the Tithe only apply to those who are not in an active warzone?
By the way, SPOILERS, this sacrifice was all for nothing, and they all died in the end.
All of this because the Munitorum considered Ammo more Vallubale then human lives.
And pepole say that Warhammer 40k lost his grimdark.
Worse still, what ammo they did bring up was then deemed too cheap for the storage space it took up and was disintegrated to make room for more expensive equipment/ammo.
with enough ammo, you can cause explosion big enough to critically damage one big enemy, rather than waste it piecemeal on little enemies that are worth nothing. You gotta start thinking like Emperor if you want the Emperor to one day be reincarnated
This isn't grimdark, this is grimderp. I've seen better fanfiction from overly edgy 14 year olds.
With millions of space marines running around beating everything into submission, 2 returned primarchs perfect to reorganizing/stabilizing the imperium, one of witch has a ability that works alot like teleportation across sectors and with new advanced tech at the read.
Yeah the grim part has been lessoned, if anything these alot more hope.
Something tells me the guy who ordered all the ammo to be gathered was a heretic, trying to gaslight the other guy to do what he says.
No matter if its 600 year BC or 40000 years AC it doesnt matter, there is something poetic about a soldier receiving an order, going at attention and then leaving on a jog to deliver information.
Tragic, actually. That same response to orders is how the US ended up being responsible for the deaths of over a million civilians in Iraq alone for an action justified entirely by lies.
It's order within the chaos. Don't matter what you think, or how you feel. You're told to do it so you do.
@@lface7426 Well yeah, insubordination means execution.
Warhammer didn't lose the Grimdark, We just became so used to it that it no longer phases us.
People want to see daemonculaba or other chaos horrors, I think
I wouldn't even say this is grimdark more just stupid bureaucracy and the imperium having the worst logistical nightmare I've ever seen.
this isn't grimdark lmao, this situation happened a lot IRl, you're just soft as fk
@@phoenixx913 ppl have no idea what "grim" or "dark" means it seems
Giving rise to its silly lil bro, Grimderp.
The emperor protects" doesnt mean he will protect your life, he will protect your soul from chaos when you die.
Hahahaha! Pfft.
Nah dude he's gonna eat it in the same way slaanesh eats aeldari souls. Hell he already eats 10,000 human psyker souls a day on the throne. You're fucked in every way possible
if he had asked the Krieg Korps to surrender he would've been shot for Defiance
It is such a depressing thought imagine defending your home your planet fighting for something you believe in only to have your only means of defending yourself taken from you, left to die for nothing.
WH40k can be epic but fuck it always reminds you why it is grimdark
This isn't grimdark, it's grimderp.
@@Sujad Grimdark is the true essence of comedy, which is funny because hope remains inspite of what would otherwise be utterly horrific. These men have faith, they have solidarity, they must doom one another to go to their doom, doom they hope to find salvation in, that's the grimdarkness of this scene.
The book "Dead men walking" has a Krieg Colonel order a withdrawl during the final big battle the book had been working up to , abandoning the world to the Necrons because they suddenly determined it to be too costly, leaving behind all civilians and Krieg trained PDF
@@FelicitousCitizenStruggler Except the commissar wouldn't have accepted the orders. It goes against everything he'd have been taught as the Schola. Hell, even Beije wouldn't have followed those orders.
@@Sujad Dude youve replied the same thing under like 4 different comment threads, give it up and stop whining
The whole point of laser weapons is that their ammo is supper cheap and ubiquitous. It's made on planetary scales all throughout the imperium. Why are they short-changing these guys?
The ammo, I recon in this regard, is of the heavy variety; heavy machine guns, AA's, mortars and artillery.
The humble lass-rifle can only be so effective, when amassed in superior numbers OR accompanied by heavy support fire.
This really should have been impossible. Tithes are for imperial governments, they don't apply to the imperial guard anyway.
There is also the problem of warp travel. The Imperium might have a lot of ammo but not the sector, and the ammo delivery could come tomorrow or in a thousand years.
Logistical issues are common place in a buracracy that administrates billions of world from just two planatary centres. This isn't even that bad entire planets can starve because a form gets lost by a clerk, reinforcemnet and resupply can arrive three centuries too late because of a small clerical error.
In the grim darkness of the future... There is only accounting errors and endless beuracrautic bullshit.
I cannot wait for the day the Emperor returns to pass judgment.
The Emperor - No guys, don't force them to surrender the ammo. Give them a chance.
Commisar- The Emperor demands your sacrifice.
Emperor - For fuxks sake, man.
With commands like this. No wonder people join the tau first chance they can
and how's that going for them . . .
Can't understand how commisar's don't get fragged more often
they get fragged all the time... thats why so many is trained and sent to units :D some units go trough dozens of em before one sane one comes from pipe line.
It depends on the regiment
Catachans regularly frag their commissars for being too douchy
Krieg also sometimes do, but because they think the commissars arent loyal enough, which i think is very funny
When I finally pieced together this full episode it became one of my favorite starting places for 40k lore outside of the astartes medias that everyone goes after
this episode was a microcosm of how the Badab war started
The officer just go:"oi, fck you, how dare you question my loyalty"
I think the commissar who speaks up after the sergeant says a thousand words with his facial expressions
This like that lady mechanicus who told a guardsmen that victory for the Imperium was leaving a planet alone with few orks
"Your duty doesn't end until death is order by Emperor!"
the best part of 40k is that it takes off the ability of thinking from the imperial officers and in its place the faith which is funny because the one think that defines an officer is the ability of critically thinking
“The Big E protects…… now give me all your armour and ammo”
The imperium must fall. 2024 The emperor is a monster of the warp as much as any.
Love how commissar handles the situation with liutennant. It's so commissar.
See, this is what happens when Tzeentch infiltrates the custodes.
and makes female custodes and then says they were there the whole time
Spoiler for this episode:
All the ammo collected wasn't even worth the space it would've taken up in the ships above, so it was ordered destroyed at the end of the episode. The people who sent the ammo collecters wanted artillery shells and heavy weapons ammo for another theatre on the same planet or in the same system. All they got from these poor bastards was rifle and pistol ammo. The AA batteries surrounding the area this conversation is taking place in couldn't even fire because they had run dry already.
This episode did annoy be, basically got their men killed...
Welcome to 40K everyone.
Welcome to 40K where everything hates you even your own people because in their own mind you are just a piece of meat
Average day in the Astra Militarum
First time?
Average newcomers try to logicalize WH40k with their ideologies
Such a Good Episode, So Sad
nah the second that other guy just nodded when the guy said the emperor protects i know hes a traitor
poor cadian, was fighting back till faith came in, had to back down
This is like the opposite of the episode with the white Templars in a sense
~Something something Badab War.~
Only a willful traitor or a heretic would choose to weaken the Imperium by requisition all of the ammo and heavy fire support on a world being attacked by Xenos.
The Ministorum is stupid as fuck, they are not *that* stupid.
the problem with 40k is that there are millions in the munitorium doing millions of things and the communication is slow as hell, by the time someone discovers this it will have passed centuries and the person did or more mistakes and was turned into a servitor or didnt make more mistakes and was just push under the radar. This is why 40k can have things like this happening because the chaos in everything to make the imperium survive.
@@MarcosAlexandre-no3qx but at same time if world doesnt pay its tithe it will take hundreds of years before someone comes and asks why.... they could just not have delivered the ammo.
@@alexius9072 the problem with that is that when they come usually they come in strenght and seeing the planet as rebelious. Yeah the imperium is strange.
Someone forgot the point of 40k
@@zayffon1325the amount of people who think the Imperium is a perfect governement which only does the correct thing is baffling to me. Have they not read the very introduction paragraph of 40k ? Do they even own a single codex or read the wiki ? How can they think the Imperium wouldn't do stupid and cruel thing ??? It's the entire point of the Imperium !!!
i love how the imperium changed from mankind first to the god emperor first. am convinced the imperium is ruled by chaos cults, and the inquisition is unknowingly protecting them.
The smell of chaos
Give these guys a glass of water😂
The World Breaks Before The Guards!!
Wish i could subscribe to this in canada.
god abondened us only inquisiton remained
that's s pretty small hat commisar
The harsh reality of war. The truly scariest genre of horror is Reality.
like krieg: human are a resource and shells are valueable
keep in mind in this world Gods, Emperor in the Warp and souls are confirmed fact. You can't use today's POV when thinking about his mindset
Gorak 5 neglars lost brother came back. Now
God damn I can every single pore on that commissar. The model maker is inhuman.
What do I need to search to watch the full version of these shorts.
Someone cranked the height map on those skin textures way too high...
So uh, how does one Commissar deal with the other when he knows the call is BS?
Spoiler: The planet they deliver the ammo to was 'overstocked' so it was destroyed.
I like the idea of an entire planet being a stockpile (shows the scale of Warhammer 40K) but it seems like a dumb idea. Just send a small fleet to target the ammo and the entire planet blows up and the sector has no or very little ammo.
These armory worlds are some of the most heavily defended worlds in the Imperium having defenses that needed to be disabled on the ground for a fleet to stay in orbit long enough to do orbital bombardment and often times these armors are also stored deep under ground making it harder to destroy with just the fleet. Also the invading forces for these worlds wouldn't want to destroy it, as the weapons and technology there are what they want to steal and too precious to risk just orbital bombardment to get to it. The only two factions that wouldn't care as much and just orbital bomb them would be the necrons and Eldar.
Chaos: that precious resources not to be squandered.
Orkz: Loot
Tau: potential tech for reverse engineering
Tyranids: want to eat the planet so auto ground invasion regardless.
If the salamanders or even Guilliman learn about this, none of them will ever let this slide. Word of advice, don't go for the weapon
Bro said we dying on this planet
i love how people are like "wow this is 40k" and it's like, people having a reddit conversation
The mouths piss me off for some reason
Cuz they're british lmao
Nah 💀
Is it the cracked lips
It's that overexaggerated Disney trademark style
For me it’s the fact that both lips are sooo animated, in real life your top lip barely moves unless you are making specific sounds.
Never mind ammo, that guy needs some lip balm
What is to stop the commissar to talk to an astropath to contact segmentum command, and give a sitrep of the situation with the imperial guard commander?
Goddamn the writing, VA, and animation is getting good in these. Need a major motion picture soon. Cavil get on it!
In the context of the universe the commissar is correct. In the context of real life morals it seems crazy
Even by the standards of the imperium this was an absolutely shit order, orders like that waste lives and lives are the Emperor's Coin. Being loose with His currency is heresy, and heresy means death.
The commissar was completely in the wrong they can't take tithes in a world with active invasion
@@FEURVERM They really can't but they can still force the issue but forcing the issue on a world where "We're all fucking doomed anyway" is prrrooooobably not your best option, here.
his duty is to that planet. The Imperium is a bloated, uncaring monster.
The duty of that lieutenant is to his emperor first and the planet second. The duty of the commissar is to emperor first and to his duty the second.
heh... he said dootie
And they just up and burn it cause the vault planet is barely holding together cause it’s over stocked. And parts of the galaxy can’t even get the needed material to build and retaliate against their own.
The movement, designs of characters, this animation reminds of blizzard’s of work. Not too sure how I feel about it.
How to find this full video on TH-cam
Hacer lo correcto o cumplir con tu deber
Welcome to 40k everything sucks and there is no hope whatsoever
Just bad frag your commissar and draw little wheels on your armor.
Well, only if you're an Imperial. If you're Tau or Ork, everything's pretty good!
what did the imperium decide to abandon the world?
Tithes are not collected from the world's under active xeno invasion btw. They are postponed and will be collected after.
Basically this was a complete violation which led to their death at the end because of this commissar
Guy in red hat was definitely a heretic in this.
anyone know where i can watch this uncut? im poor and would love to watch it
What movie is this?
in the title
Combination of the worst human traits for our future in this setting is right. The lack of question to leadership is sad.
But dont lasguns have basically infinite ammo? The charge paks can regain energy overtime and contain thousands of shots.
Where can I watch this show?
I feel like the guardsmen of Krieg should have been sent instead
M bison??
Im pretty fucking sure they arent allowed to do this shit since its a active warzone the most they will do is slow down the ammo and fuel shipments for more important warzones
They do this all the time. For example, they exterminate the whole planet if they found seeds of chaos corruption to prevent the spread of chaos influence to neighbouring planets. They also exterminate an entire planet fill with life just to slow down the tyranid invasion.
where's a catachan when you need one? they are always misplacing commissars.
Where I can watch this?
guys why is everyone falling to chaos? lol
Geez dude are they wearing full body gimp suits under the uniforms? One finger moves and they creak for hours.
where do we watch this whole clip?
Femstodes aren't canon.
soviet commissar cool
The female custodes episode made me drop this series. Would be cool if they would stop pandering and stick to cannon
Is that yarick?
Where's this from?
This makes no fucking sense. The Guard make use of las gun packs. Las gun packs can canonically be recharged by being tossed into a fire place.
They may be losing their auto cannons and bolter rounds, but their lasguns and las cannons should still be good if they are only taking ammo.
It made no sense and that was the point. Administratum wanted to recall ammo to be sent to another world. The paperwork was in error, and instead of only heavy artillery being requested, all ammo, regardless of what, was requested instead. And the guard did as they were ordered, sending every single battery pack, grenades, light and heavy ammo, all of it to the ships. Because that was their duty- To follow orders.
In the end the ammo was discarded by the administratum because it was not what they wanted, though it was precisely what they requested.
The sacrifice was meaningless due to imperium's incompetent bureucracy eating away at what human soul remains inside Imperium- Or perhaps, that arrogant hubris and incompetence is precisely the human soul in 40k.
The point of the whole episode was to show how pointless duty was in 40k- And despite that, how humanity in 40k will do their duty despite that- Either because they don't know better, or are stubborn enough to not change.
@@Warhamer116See, I interpret that differently. They recognize the situation is hopeless yet fight on anyway because to do otherwise is to admit humanity is destined to die against the oncoming night.
I still hate the lore inconsistency cause again las packs are a thing, but I get the intent at least now.
@@shadowofhawk55 Las packs are not integrated to the lasguns. They are ammo, only that they can be field recharged. But if the order is to surrender all ammo, including the las packs, it doesn't matter if you can field recharge the ammo or not- It goes to the pile. How it functions is irrelevant.
@@Warhamer116 once you make one las pack its basically an infinite resource. Why would you need to take those? I get needing to requisition auto cannon rounds or mortar shells, but las packs?
It's Amazon. They try to ignore lots of lore and details to make drama.
It amazes me that more guardsmen don’t execute their own commissars. Yarrick is the only one I’ve ever heard of who wasn’t a completely insufferable twat.
usually comissars are in a class of their own and aren't that much of an asshole, usually being designed to green squads to maintain morale as thoses don't know the horror of war yet. Besides most of them are really good commanders and make sure you will live as long as they can
Most of the commissars are excellent leaders except for a few individuals. And they are trained in schola progenium. It takes balls to kill a commissar they are good combatants
Yarrick and Ciaphas Cain.
don't take the memes of 40k Commissars as face value lore wise Commissars generally don't going around blaming every soldier that disagrees with them off the bat. And those that do don't live that long. Alot of those commissars do get fragged by their own soldiers, or by another commissar or higher officer for being wasteful
Where can I watch this
Warhammer TV app.
for me i feel it don't make sense this whole setup feel like a big traitor scheme more than a normal situation.
you don't make the guard in battle abandon them ammo. it's like abandoning the world to the xeno, what the imperium never do... either they fight until the last men for protect it or simply exterminatus it. you don't leave any potential threat in the hand of the xeno.
on one side the story is well written but the setup feel...forced and not really in tunes with what is the imperium.
commisar and even the high command of the astra militarum will have not followed this order.
and for people saying i'm wrong... hellreach. yes, they can move troops from line to line, but never they abandon a war.
And all those takings, just to end up being destroyed instead of returning it to the soldiers down there fighting greenskins
that part have me kinda upset, i feel the setting is setup for make it grimdark.
no one will have allows this order to pass... you don't abandon a world to the xeno, worst, if they have wanted to stop this war.... exterminatus. you don't cripple your own army for no good reason.
@@Beldhan they don't see those guardsmen as people, they don't see the good in protecting that planet and yes it was infuriating for them to do that
But well.....nobody is a good guy in 40k
@@scarletfoxfrostnovember3407 yes, they see guardsmen as tool. but loosing tool over a taxes feel wrong. the tithes will not be collected from the front line... if they want to collect ammo from a front line it will happend when they decide to do an exterminatus and remove any troop from the surface.
loosing a planet to the xeno it's something they don't allows... the imperium follow the rule of: you will not get this world, and if we can't control it, we will burn it to ground.
mostly because each world lost increase the strenght of the enemy.
that why i have said that the setup feel artificially grimdark. the one behind it, didn't take in account that warhammer 40K it's a story about war, yes you have decision that are stupid, but the whole idea to abandon a world without burn it to the ground feel alien. worst abandon guardmen without ammo is something the astra militarum will not tolerate...
yes guardmens are tool ,but you don't throw away a tool that can still be used.
Is this a Warhammer episode
Did the guy from Taken voiced on these mfs?
and this is why I always make my Wrath and glory characters anti-munitorum, those guys suck >:c
Why does in recent warhammer animation the female guards are increasing and there body looks no different that of mans body, why is that ?
Might be because they wear the same armor as the men, just a thought
@@DontKnow-hr5my I don't think that the case the armour is a swallow one not a big bulky one like the Marines
no ammo fix the bayonet..
Surrender 🖕
Making a final stand melee style 😎
Do as THEY command? wtf. NeoEnglish at work
that is NOT how the imperial tithes work
They do when there's a saboteur and a traitor giving the orders..
Like and Subscribe for more videos
www.youtube.com/@OLLPersson2499?sub_confirmation=1