Jerry Garcia & Bob Weir - Throwing Stones - 12/4/1988 - Oakland Coliseum Arena (Official)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ย. 2024
- Jerry Garcia & Bob Weir - Throwing Stones
Recorded Live: 12/4/1988 - Oakland Coliseum Arena - Oakland, CA
More Jerry Garcia & Bob Weir at Music Vault: www.musicvault.com
Subscribe to Music Vault on TH-cam: goo.gl/DUzpUF
Shows how Good Jerry was. No effects pedals just straight guitar flat picking. RIP Jerry
Shows how horrible Bobby is. You can tell he figured out playing guitar on the job.
@@spotteddogmemphis You're not wrong and that's not a bad thing. Bob's entire thing is complimenting Jerry's playing, and he does it well.
He actually is an extremely wrong cuck
@@spotteddogmemphiswell that’s the dumbest shit I’ve ever read
Jerry’s lead on this is amazing
So melodic indeed
I can’t understand why musicians aren’t in as much awe over these guys as deadheads are!!! The way they build music,keep in time as amazingly as they can, play their own parts masterfully!!! Just amazed every time I hear this one!!!
There are plenty of excellent professional musicians on TH-cam who dissect, instruct and otherwise dedicte hours of quality Dead related content. But yeah. I've had people say to my face, they can't understand how people consider Jerry the next messiah. And I'm wondering how people don't get it. 🤔
@@Karmakatt6 wasn't that kind of the problem? From the sounds of it he didn't exactly adjust well to the idolization.
Because musicians know the world is full of countless thousands of "unknown" musicians who are "better" than those who become famous. Classical, jazz, and bluegrass musicians, to name just a few genres, blow away those in rock.
With rock, it's all about the SONGS, and there's nothing wrong with that.
I dont know any musicians that dont like them. What seems strange to me is when people like a musician, but dont care who that musician likes. Its like they dont want to see how the sausage is made.
I like licorice!
I have no idea why some people don't like this song. The words, they mean something. Bob's having fun with it.
so relevant- politicians throwing stones !
Who doesn't like this song? Just about every dead cover I've ever seen has played it frequently
One of my favs. Bobby is missing step in a few places but his enthusiasm helps.
Everybody LOVES this song.
Jerry was always A-political whereas Bobby was a Left-leaning climate changing Liberal.
I love this song. It's a moving mixture of optimism and pessimism, hope and cynicism. It takes me back to my high school and college days in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Sentimentality is one of my biggest weaknesses. Or is it a strength? I don't know.
Sometimes I cry to this song and I’m a 42 year old adult
it was often mocked. I embraced it
Jerry Garcia the greatest guitarist singer that ever lived
Yes he is
Bobby really shines on this with those chord changes and his singing. Awesome!!!
These guys are legends...This video saved my life this summer. i am eternally Grateful...
I was at this show and at the end I caught Bobby's hair tie, which I cherish on my alter to this day.
That’s just weird lol
Bobby fills this band in so nicely. What an absolutely monster performance
Jerry had his own signature sound, no matter what he played. I love that
bobby is the most number one #2 ever
Equals for sure, but bobby is known as the #1, #2 ever these days. Probably the greatest honor for playing rhythm...
He was so handsome back then. I am sure lots of ladies would love to grab that ponytail, lol Bobby aged decades after Jerry left but still sounds fantastic. His is a life well-lived and I hope he keeps going and going and going....
If Bob shaved that gnarly beard he'd probably still not look that old.
Casin Whitehead
Casin Whitehead couldnt of said it better
The two best musicians ever to live.
Thanks again
Well, that may be a bit of an overstatement but it has a "mythical truth" that can be particularly powerful when heard while consuming a particular mushroom.
Miles Davis and Fred Durst would like a word with you son.
Oh yeah ! What a ridiculous statement.
@@buckodonnghaile4309now that’s funny😂
Man, this is hot. What a bunch of ringers in this trio.
Im in my mid 20s and I was turned on to the Grateful Dead world a few years back. It literally changed my life I love being in a DeadHead community and would like to learn more. Thanks for keeping the grateful dead music alive for newer generation. Nothing left to do but smile, smile smile.
Baddest throwing stones right here
I remember when they played this at 3 Rivers Stadium. The stomping from the upper tiers made the whole floor jump in time with the music.
And here it is again!! A Dead recording!! The only place on TH-cam where you can read through the comments and not find bickering back and forth, ppl trolling to stir shit up and just rude and derogatory insults being thrown around. Instead you find everyone in one way or another giving gratitude to one another, the world and to this group of musicians. Maybe all of us here are fortunate to still be like kids////////......" And the politicians throwing stones, so the kids they dance they shake their bones"
The main reason for that, is because we're very fortunate and blessed to be part a "GRATE" community of incredible "DEADHEADS". I've met many longtime GRATE friends from long ago, during my years of touring, until about 10 years ago when a drunk driver caused me to flip my Toyota 4runner 5 times, being clinically dead for 3 minutes and 15 seconds, they used the defibrillator paddles on me for 3 times before I had come back. I was in YORK Hospital in a coma for 9 days, but remained in that hospital for a total of 6 weeks. I was then transferred to Moss Rehab Hospital in Philadelphia. While there I had to relearn too walk, talk, read, and write. Then 2 years ago my neorologist found a brain tumor. My 1st neurologist Dr Sterling was a very cool cat. He was a huge Deadhead.
Now my neurosurgeon Dr Winer, is the same story. He's an even bigger Deadhead than Sterling. anyway, I just had cool doctors. Dr Winer couldn't get all of it. The portion that has grown tight against the upper left side of my brainstem, plus part of the tumor has grown wrapped around the brainstem. o well, shit happens. Sorry for the length of this aimlessly babbling session. Y'all have a "GRATE" night.
..yeah? Well, sez you, fella!
Wadda you know?
;=}
It's in response to the original comment. He said this is "[t]he only place on TH-cam where you can read through the comments and not find bickering back and forth, ppl trolling to stir shit up and just rude and derogatory insults being thrown around." So I replied with a comment that uses all the platitudes that Internet trolls love to fall back on. It's satire. Get it now?
Gotcha man, it just didn't seem satirical when I had read it man. Plus it being right under my comment it seemed as if though it was directed towards me 100%. That's why I didn't really get the whole "rape culture" thing,lol. My bad!!!
Eli Warner I second that emotion my friend. there's no place like home.
I do not hear the flaws others hear when commenting on this version. This is the best version of this great song i have found on YT. Weir's energy and vocals are on point and i love Jerry's playing here. The acoustic setting is nice.
Ross McCloud definetly best version on TH-cam
Jerry is a bit out of pocket. He was either high or he meant to do it. It looks like he can’t hear his monitor actually, as it goes on. Great tune nevertheless. Jerry’s fingerprints are indeed rare...
Cover of rolling Stone
@@agnostic1247 he didn't need to hear Bobby because that parts was deeply imbedded in his head already but he hadn't played with Wasserman in bass often so the non-Phil was throwing his timing a little.
But mostly you are correct: Jerry held his guitar up near his face so he can hear it. I've done the same.
mu6best I hadn’t even noticed Wasserman was on bass. I was distracted watching Jerry. I’ve heard a lot of live tapes and it feels to me like Jerry would drift from time to time even under the best of technical circumstances. It’s part of the airiness that is his style. He could play out of pocket and at times it’s like an ethereal dance over the top of the band. He was so unique and a rather underrated talent outside the Dead community. I just read what I wrote. It sounds pretentious and it’s not exactly what I wanted to say but it’s close. Anyway, this was what I implied as Jerry leaving his fingerprints.
"Ashes Ashes all Fall Down" -- in a George HW voice? Priceless!
Read my lips, "ashes ashes" ;)
jerry is top ten all time best guitarists all time easy
john doe I hung out on a bus wit him for a week or two in 1985
10. who are the other 9????????????????????????/
I love this music, but he isnt even in the top 50 IMO.
Said by someone nobody cares. not top 50. Ok. Doke. Go now.
I got #1.
The darkness never goes from some men's eyes
How can you opine on this song you just can't wrap your mind around it it's so astounding!
This is so smoking .. a really good one!!
Truly my favorite version of this song. So happy this video exists.
Bobby had his moments, great rhythm sideman, and there are a few songs where he is just wow. He is a victim of circumstance, and in his life the circumstances came to fruition.
Rip
On Bobby ... Is he the victim or the crime? I don’t know that I’d call him a victim of circumstance. He’s more the Saint of Circumstance if you really look at it.
This music is still the best for me
Jerry is a master of his craft.
Love listening and watching The Dead play acoustic!!
Miles Feulner ... me too. The new and better #me too.
Not to argue, I prefer the electric Dead...✌
OMG THIS WAS THE SHOW I SAW THEM PLAY THIS FOR THE FIRST TIME YOU CANNOT HEAR HOW LOUD THE FANS WERE. MY MIND WAS BLOWN.
Love this acoustic version 🙏
Simply awesome. Doesn't matter the format. Seriously!!!
Wow... 34 yrs. ago today. The yrs. do fly by the fastest.1:04 am 12-4-22
Wow what a rarity ⚡️⚡️⚡️🔥
just a huge "WOW!" for this
I remember this I was there
that is a lot of work, what an anthem
Happy Birthday Jerry I've seen you over 500 times in every form solo the dead everybody 65/1995 35 you made me very very happy very happy went to places that I would have never seen ended up living in San Francisco meeting your best friend Can hanging out with him. I wouldn't change anything thank you for the continued releases the music will never stop
Wish they had shown a little more of Rob Wasserman - some of the best of this tune is near the end (c. 8:00 and on) when he and Garcia were tossing a few ideas back and forth, obviously to Garcia's delight.
he was a great bassist for real!
Some of my favorite Dead music is Bob singing and Jerry riffing behind. Bobby Mcgee, El Paso, Black Throated Wind, Looks Like Rain, especially in the early 70's. Listen to the last night of Winterland '74 El Paso, Jerry rocks it out while Bob sings. I really grew up on early 70's shows and I've never lost my my love of the sound. The Black Throated Wind from Steal Your Face, the complete version on Relisten, is magic. It goes on past the album and is amazing. Had that tape in the early 80's, think it snapped.
Cornell 77 Minglewood rocks my socks
How great that young guy joined up ! Bob Weir!
Neil Young"s Bridge School benefit concert. Was amazing!!..Bob Dylan, CSN, Tom Petty, Tracy Chapman and others.
Yup billy idol really high dosed by a fan...
hearing the dead makes me feel so alive
Very nice. ❤
Seeing. that acoustic guitar n Jerry's. hand is like seeing Lennon's. Mother. At MSGarden !! Innocent.!! And eternal !! Thanks. for some of the best music,. ever !
So glad this exist
Amazing rendition of this song, thanks for sharing!! Definitely going in my favorites
And I personally feel that this is a great example of how "on" those two can be. Bob gives Jerry some damn good rhythm.
JG is like a 🎩🪄 with the 🎸.
Not sure I've ever heard Bob's voice so strong as here.
I've always really been drawn to Jerry and is acoustic sound. Really the whole band acoustic.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY BOB WEIR!
Rip Jerry
Jerry is not the greatest guitarist ever. But there is no other guitarist I’d rather hear. The Greatful Dead is something special. They have no rival. Nothing can touch them. If you’re a Head, you’re lucky. We got IT!! Others, I’m sorry for you
You can close your eyes feel the music and hide from your problems from life. I get a feeling in my stomach like 🦋
OMG such perfect sentiments!!
"Greatest" is entirely subjective. Jerry is up there among some of the greatest.
This song is around 35 years old. And still rings true today.
Jerry is at the hieght of his addiction here. Much like the drummer of guns and roses at the same exact time. Jerry's later acoustic wizardry is recorded a few years later at msg on his cd. For the song, the wier/ Wasserman stones and also victim are excellent
damn, initially underestimated how hot this was
acid acid all fall down
Jerry and Bobby! I love you guys!
My memory of this song was hearing it for the first time at Ventura Fairgrounds about 83 or so. 84 maybe? In any event they had played it a few times and word was out and a couple tapes. I liked it then and I like it now. I felt it was pretty different for the dead.
I miss these days SO!
Love you Bobby from Patti Cornell
Roll on forever Jer
Amazing rendition of a great dead song!
I got on the bus at age 8 June of 85, Hershey Pennsylvania to be exact. It's something I'll never forget, saw the rest of that summer tour and I've been riding the bus ever since. They are much more than just music, they are bigger then music, they fed off of us while we were feeding off them from show to show... It's not that they are the best at what they do........ THEY ARE THE ONLY ONES TO DO WHAT THEY DO. AS far as Jerry and his guitar playing he's definitely in the top five, when you have people like Eric Clapton just to name one saying in interviews that he doesn't know how he did the things he did, the riffs and notes he would put together on his guitar, Eric said he tried to recreate some of his solos and host couldn't do it and he wasn't the only one to say this like that. When Jerry was on he couldn't be touched. The fact that we were alive and got to see Jerry, Brent and the boys while they graced this earth to me is a true blessing and a gift... There 2 generations of there that ask they know is the renditions of the boys videos and recordings of the boys after Jerry left this broke down palace. Has there been some magic made since then yes but nothing, NOTHING LIKE THE MAGIC THE GRATEFUL DEAD HAVE US. IF YOU KNOW YOU KNOW. I'M SO GLAD I WAS THERE. I'VE SEEN THE BOYS 187 TIMES, JGB I SAW 104 WEIR AND WASSERMAN 74 TIMES, IF YOU INCLUDE RATDOG IN THAT WELL THEN IT WOULD BE JUST SHY OF 200.. I ALSO SEEN EVERY RENDITION SINCE THEN AND IM GRATEFUL FOR EVERY MINUTE, GRATEFUL TO STILL BE ABLE TO GET TOGETHER WITH OLD FRIENDS WHILE MAKING NEW FRIENDS AND TALK ABOUT THE PAST MEMORIES WHILE MAKING NEW MEMORIES. THERE NEVER WILL BE ANOTHER GRATEFUL DEAD, JERRY, BRENT, BOBBY, PHIL, MICKEY AND BILLY. WHAT THEY DID FOR US, FOR MUSIC, FOR LIFE AND FOR THE JAM BAND SCENE AND ALL THE JAM BANDS THAT ARE AROUND TODAY AND IN THE FUTURE IS BECAUSE OF THEM.. THEIR MUSIC TRULY WILL NEVER STOP. THANK YOU BOYS FOR THE MUSIC, THE FRIEND'S AND THE MEMORIES OLD AND NEW, THANK YOU FOR THE LONG STRANGE TRIP THAT I WILL TAKE TILL THE DAY I'M LAID TO REST. NFA FAMILY (~);-}
Let us not forget pig...tom....kieth....donna..they all brought a smile to my soul
This goes so deep, this is further,
Can't people just let Jerry be Jerry who cares if he hits every note perfect.gfy.
As Jerry says, "it's the notes you DON'T play that really matter..."
Tasty treat. This song is great. Guess who gets to pay the price.
.
Nice jem to stumble upon. My 1st Dead album was Reconing. Took me a number of shows before hearing this song- such memories, glad to have grown up Then - there will never again be a band to tour and concerts to attend Like The Grateful Dead
Yea you make a great point, I always wonder who the 1 tool is that gives Jerry a thumbs down low ever.....you don't give your delic- Claus a thumbs down EVA!
So long, we'll see you down that long dark river.
Great version. These two gentlemen were one. Glorious.
I am so stoked for tour this year (~):}
Had a Toronto tape had this on the end with I think the wheel is turning intertwined fall 88 washing dishes
They were on!!
Beautiful stuff here!!
Bobby knew enuff to turn his guitar down it was up to high. Genius ...
Jerry jerry jerry. The master. Bob sounds awesome.
thanks for posting this. awesome
I love this performance
this is so good
I love the smile Jerry keeps sending Wass//
Pranks fer sharin//
+S. Rakes those fellas had plenty of pranks for sharing ;)
Will TH-cam please stop putting commercials in the middle of songs...?
🔥🔥 fire
Thanksss...!!!
Something this real, should be against the law...
Nah man get that shit out of here.
One of favorites Bob kill it.
"Smashed it" Brilliant
"And the politicians throwing stones...ashes to ashes we all fall down".
im listening....
I was at this show. We also got an acoustic Ripple.
Love the music
I'm crying
I hope I write a real song like that someday
Nice.
Amazing! so glad you posted it...!!
Nice jam!
ty
Poor Yngwie and companions. They’ll never achieve this inexplicable magic.
Jerry finger lickin guitar pickin!
If the game is lost we are all the same. Time is ripe to Play to win, my friends.
NOT FADE AWAY