Thanks! This was my first episode that was majority unscripted, this approach was probably unique to the episode since the story that made sense to me to tell was how different everyone's reaction was compared to mine.
the horse episode was my favorite episode in 5 years or so. I've been with my gf for almost 4 years and this was the first and only episode i shared with her because I thought it was so funny
This episode was everything I hate about modern AVGN, but I'd say you should put it in what tier you think it should be in because it's your ranking video series.
It's interesting because this recent Sim City one is an example of what I hate most about modern AVGN, not very fond of that last Castlevania one as well
@SuperAnthony23MJ I would've liked the Castlevania episode if it wasn't for the bizarre nonsensical takes, lol. I'd just rather have a more chilled out episode with only occasional outbursts rather than all the constant overacting.
@@GenghisConnThr333 my thing with the castlevania episode was that it felt like he had done that episode before many years ago telling us his favorite castlevania game was one we already knew from the many castlevania vids he'd already done. I felt like this video should have been more of a major celebration of AVGN and its 20 year history than a bland walkthrough of these games
@@SuperAnthony3 Aaaah, so you get both ways. A like for you and for the episode all the while you get an idea for what your fambase think of the episode.
Yea, I've been yelling at that clouds about that exact same thing. And then when he does the "Today... I'm gonna give myself a break and review a... good game for once... yeaaa" and then people seem to react like it's a great episode, to me it misses the point.
We've gotten to the point where the only way James can be somewhat entertaining is to deliberately humiliate himself. (As opposed to Rex Viper where he only unwittingly humilliated himself.)
I never used to miss a nerd episode but while I’m still subbed I’ve not watch a new episode since I think Pepsi man. Just feels like watching someone begrudgingly make them.
I hated this episode, but I am glad you enjoyed it. Sometimes our opinions don't align with the majority, and that's fine. You are free to voice your opinion and rank the episodes based on how you feel.
I didn't like the episode at first but your opinion has at least widened my worldview in regards to it, so who can say where it belongs, it's your list. If I had a dollar for every time someone told me I ranked something wrong I could probably afford a pint.
First viewing on the episode just felt profoundly off, was F-tier worthy for me (not the worst of the worst though, to me Toxic Crusaders, Life of Black Tiger, and maybe Majora's Mask compete for that, felt on Mask it was the worst AVGN was as a critic, trying to shoot an old sacred cow but did not bring anywhere near good enough ammunition for it) but I also can see it just being a c-tier thing that's fine enough in construction, just not my cup of tea. I think a bit might be based on what you get from the nerd, for me, especially when I first watched him as a young kid that shouldn't have been watching him. He was like a time machine back into generations before mine, even if he mostly was showing the rankest parts of the period. It was nice to get perspective with the comedy, the difference to the scenes with atari/pong consoles and trying to get the phone charger is it's a dad joke in a way I don't like, where before it was him being pissed off at the 'good ole days', now its a standard boomer joke. I am not innocent to the Internet's relation with ponies, nor forgot things like Elsa gate and the momo scare so weird stuff in the app market isn't as big a shock like seeing Life of Black Tiger when it was first covered by Jim Sterling. As for the list, I always saw it as your own and say you should tier it as you damn well please, make it B, C, F, Pie, whatever you think it's worthy. Perhaps, as a far future endeavor, you could try a community poll to tier the AVGN videos.
Watching your impressions on this felt like I had entered a bizarro world where what I consider totally unbearable and unfunny is actually comedy gold. I wish I liked this epsiode even half as much as you did! And I totally don't mean that as a dig against you or anything, I just find it interesting how we have nearly complete opposite views with this one
hah, dig away! I hope I did a good job of poking fun of myself in this video. It's funny to me that my favorite episode in a long time happened to be everyone's least favorite so that's what made this fun to do
Thanks! About a month and a half ago I was ready to wrap this episode up and then I just decided to do that intro... it took quite a bit of time. Hope it was worth it!
By the way...yes...BIG RIGS, TOKYO '97, SEAMAN...these are absolute peaks of the Nerd. My wife & I are also big fans of the TAITO ARCADE GAMES episode.
I didn't think the episode was bad. My least favorites are the ones with tons of toilet humor. I can take a little toilet humor, but sometimes he goes overboard.
Completely and utterly irrelevant to the video, but... The thing is, modern AVGN does (IMO) still work overall. Contra, the Last Ninja (iirc), Sim City, the last Jekyll and Hyde, the new Castlevania comparison, and probably FF6 (haven't seen it since I don't want the game spoiled, but James probably cares about FF6 so it's probably good) are all genuinely (IMO) very good, with worst of them being _maybe_ 6/10's and the best genuinely being modern classics... Only to completely bomb every other episode. Even if Horse Prince is (IMO, generously) not counted as a bomb, that doesn't stop the others from being so. It's like Dreamworks' consistency but with internet videos.
Haha, with the exception of Last Ninja, I think you named like all of my least favorite ones! :) It's all good, if anything the point of making this video is acknowledging that in some cases there's no accounting for taste and what a person sees and doesn't see in any form of media.
I appreciate everyone's sentiment to have me keep to my own list, for me I'm okay with a little it of fan input at times, horse prince will definitely live in infamy
this episode was interesting. It certainly was different. I kidna liked it and hated it at the same time it's weird. I understand both the hate and the praise. xD
Dude , avgn has so many episodes and we all have different tastes and what we find great and funny , like one of my favourite episodes is the Atari 5200 but others it'll be mario 3 and some mad lads will find the LGN episode the best . We're all fans and we just want to share our opinions about what we like and dislike with hundreds of people calling you the scum of the earth
Just sitting down for dinner anthony. What a treat this is gonna be 😂 Edit: i fucking love the 1st spiderman movie by sam rami. What a great intro man!!
Thanks! This one was from the 2nd rami film, loved that intro... that said... I think people are gonna be majorly disappointed by the content of the rest of the video :)
@@SuperAnthony3 sorry for the confusion but the 1st one i had on vhs as a kid. Watched it so many times, so it reminded me of it lol. Im not gonna hate your opinion on the video. If you liked it and saw things you liked im not gonna hate for that. I watch content to see different opinons. I like to see an opinion through someone elses eye. Id rather watch your REview of the episode than watch it. Good vid and the editing is great 👍🏿
Thanks I appreciate it! Spent a lot of time on the vid and it's a different style from my others so I hope it's not too off putting and feels like fluff, but in the end, it's the vid I wanted to make, so there it is. Thanks again!
Im part of video, yeah! But seriously, comedy is subjective, you should rank episodes how you feel about them, i've disliked Texas Chainsaw Massacre episode since it first aired, and im still not a big fan, but many people likes it :)
Music by Roomgoers 😂 I honestly thought the episode was fine. Like you said it was something new and refreshing. I'd rather have another Horse Prince than another Shrek. I despise that one.
These kinds of rankings will always be super subjective. If you want to appeal to the opinions of the fans you'd have to do a gigantic poll or something. I think it's totally fine to just give your own and explain why you feel that way. Maybe "ranking" isn't even the way to go in the first place and every video should just be reviewed and rated? Anyway, my personal opinion about that episode was also very negative. I was never a Cinemassacre hater, always defended the show and such. I don't think of this as a "new low" or something, but there was just something off-putting about the way James was acting I think. Yes, he was overacting before, but I think it was simply too much in this one? Maybe the overacting in combination with the phone camera made it look even worse? To be fair, I didn't like his overacting in previous episodes either, I think it's always the worst part whenever he is trying to fake laugh. I don't think it fits the character in the first place. And sure, opinion will change, rankings don't hold up ... I don't think it needs to be this serious. So I "disliked" the video since I hope you'll just give your own opinion, because if I want to see the opinion of others I'm just gonna go on Reddit or something. Video itself was great btw. loved the intro, liked the idea of also filming this with a phone and the Spider-Man 2 joke of wanting to quit etc. Good stuff!
Thanks for the kind words! Yea, I mean the ranking thing is fun and for me the focus definitely has been the "review" part and making something that I think is entertaining. At the end of the video, hopefully it's clear that I'm acting a bit and it's not so serious, that's why I enjoy a bit of fan participation. It will mostly be my list, but I also like the idea of incorporating the audience where I think it makes sense and can add fun for the group.
@@SuperAnthony3 That seems like a good way to go. Was just a bit worried (because of the like/dislike bit) that it might result in a popularity contest later down the line. If it's just for exceptions like this where the opinions differ dramatically I guess it doesn't hurt that much :)
I am kind of in the middle. I HATED PepsiMan. It actually angered me. I HATED Vegas Stakes...my wife & I still refer to that to this day as the worst episode ever. I disagreed with you on Jurassic Park Trespasser...I found the episode a bit of a mess, plot-wise...but found it educational (like some of my favorite episodes). But Horse Prince...I actually forgot it even existed. It was completely forgettable to me. Not that bad...but not that great.
Pepsiman was definitely a weird one, was a bit of a milestone episode for me too in thinking things were changing. I mean, I guess what I don't like about episodes like Trespasser is when there is the potential for something strong but then gets messed up by the really bad and incoherent writing. I think it would have been a lot better if the episode didn't try to go big and focus on the game development process.
I dunno, I do think it was on the bad side, weird ass choice for a game and all that; Im just not fan of AVGN doing modern mobile stuff. But there was definitively an overreaction against this episode just for the facecam gimmick, it was not that bad, just experimental.
Yea, I mean, I feel like if I was trying to make a "point" it would be that, a lot of the complaints about this episode existed long before My Horse Prince and for me personally, I think I'm at a point where I would take this over Sim City which I think was terribly bland and just a "walkthrough" of a popular game for clicks
@@SuperAnthony3 I couldnt even bother to watch more than a few minutes of Sim City; I knew it was just another "oh James just talks about an objectively good game" one which to me is against the spirit of AVGN.
@@SuperAnthony3 it's just another example. I think even most hardcore fans would admit that James burned out long ago. AVGN just pays the bills, that's all. The last true creative thing he did with the Nerd was Polybius episode (where he was out of character).
James should just shave his head or wear a cap. When baldness is so ugly and distracting it's just not good for the channel since his face is on all the thumbnails.
I personally couldn't care less about the balding, but he should perform tattoo removal surgery. Why did he even get that "Google images tribal tattoo" in the first place? it looks freaking terrible.
Thanks for the engagement guys! Let's be careful about pointing fingers at each other regarding appropriate fandom and such. Everything is in good fun. Even when I shout to the world why I think Super Mario World is garbage it's mean to be done with a laugh.
@@marloges he's not a nerd though, at least not a video game one. The character was originally a parody of Matei and it's obviously all an act. James has very little interest in video games outside of the few he played as a kid (e.g. Castlevania)
The early going is dead even so far 8 likes (F tier) 8 dislikes (C Tier) | Update: 51 [F] to 38 [C]
This is James' Minecraft with Gadget, i think they will appreciate this episode down the line like what they did with Mike's video
It will definitely be one of the more memorable ones!
cool intro!
Thanks! This video drags out a bit, your cameos appear at 7:55 and 12:55 (there to knock sense into me)
That intro was absolutely amazing Anthony!
This is definitely an interesting new take you went with, Anthony. Excellent work.
Thanks! This was my first episode that was majority unscripted, this approach was probably unique to the episode since the story that made sense to me to tell was how different everyone's reaction was compared to mine.
Do you know what ? This video made me go back and watch this episode with a new appreciation
I did it!!!
Yes, the intro is certainly one of the best I have seen.
I like the super exposed phone camera to parallel the episode
the horse episode was my favorite episode in 5 years or so. I've been with my gf for almost 4 years and this was the first and only episode i shared with her because I thought it was so funny
Awesome! Did she like it!
@@SuperAnthony3 yea she thought it was funny
This episode was everything I hate about modern AVGN, but I'd say you should put it in what tier you think it should be in because it's your ranking video series.
It's interesting because this recent Sim City one is an example of what I hate most about modern AVGN, not very fond of that last Castlevania one as well
@SuperAnthony23MJ I would've liked the Castlevania episode if it wasn't for the bizarre nonsensical takes, lol.
I'd just rather have a more chilled out episode with only occasional outbursts rather than all the constant overacting.
@@GenghisConnThr333 my thing with the castlevania episode was that it felt like he had done that episode before many years ago telling us his favorite castlevania game was one we already knew from the many castlevania vids he'd already done. I felt like this video should have been more of a major celebration of AVGN and its 20 year history than a bland walkthrough of these games
It's refreshing to hear some positivity on modern avgn
Hah, well from me this is a bit of a rare exception, ironically it's for an episode that was universally hated :D
The duality of enjoying the video but also wanting the episode to be in C tier because it's actually good.
What do I do?
WHAT DO I DO?!?
"DISLIKE" IT!
@@SuperAnthony3 You know, now that I think of it, it would have made much much more sense if you placed the C as the LIKE and the F as the DISLIKE.
@@vaggos2003 hah, I figure if someone votes it F, I should at least get a "like" for it :)
@@SuperAnthony3 Aaaah, so you get both ways. A like for you and for the episode all the while you get an idea for what your fambase think of the episode.
@@vaggos2003 yep, I'm just a cheap ass hoe :)
Took so long, James somehow put out 3'OV'UM between the last ranking and now.
Yea I'm amazed, that said I feel like that Sim City one was like a walkthrough that James just talked over.
@@SuperAnthony3 huh. Didn't watch it, no time. Busy watching his 540 other films
@@SuperAnthony3that's why I'm not a fan of episodes on good games. It's just a commentary or review video, not an AVGN episode.
Yea, I've been yelling at that clouds about that exact same thing. And then when he does the "Today... I'm gonna give myself a break and review a... good game for once... yeaaa" and then people seem to react like it's a great episode, to me it misses the point.
We've gotten to the point where the only way James can be somewhat entertaining is to deliberately humiliate himself. (As opposed to Rex Viper where he only unwittingly humilliated himself.)
My next goal for this channel is to eclipse the Rex Viper subscriber count
Great film, Anthony!
What an intro
Thanks! It took up quite a bit of editing time!
While i thought this episode wasnt great, it definltey wasnt as bad as everyone made it out to be.
I'd say rank it in C tier since its your own list
I'm right there with you in thinking Horse Prince was a lot of fun to watch tbh.
We should form our own support group :)
I never used to miss a nerd episode but while I’m still subbed I’ve not watch a new episode since I think Pepsi man.
Just feels like watching someone begrudgingly make them.
Pepsi man was definitely a stand out episode for me in that way too.
I hated this episode, but I am glad you enjoyed it. Sometimes our opinions don't align with the majority, and that's fine. You are free to voice your opinion and rank the episodes based on how you feel.
I haven’t watched it fully, only too see the comments but I’m surprised you like it, also W opinion even if modern Avgn is now a mixed bag
I didn't like the episode at first but your opinion has at least widened my worldview in regards to it, so who can say where it belongs, it's your list.
If I had a dollar for every time someone told me I ranked something wrong I could probably afford a pint.
It's all in good fun, I'm happy with fan participation!
It was the first episode I quit halfway thru 🤷♂️
With that view count it seems a lot of people quit before it started :)
First viewing on the episode just felt profoundly off, was F-tier worthy for me (not the worst of the worst though, to me Toxic Crusaders, Life of Black Tiger, and maybe Majora's Mask compete for that, felt on Mask it was the worst AVGN was as a critic, trying to shoot an old sacred cow but did not bring anywhere near good enough ammunition for it) but I also can see it just being a c-tier thing that's fine enough in construction, just not my cup of tea. I think a bit might be based on what you get from the nerd, for me, especially when I first watched him as a young kid that shouldn't have been watching him. He was like a time machine back into generations before mine, even if he mostly was showing the rankest parts of the period. It was nice to get perspective with the comedy, the difference to the scenes with atari/pong consoles and trying to get the phone charger is it's a dad joke in a way I don't like, where before it was him being pissed off at the 'good ole days', now its a standard boomer joke. I am not innocent to the Internet's relation with ponies, nor forgot things like Elsa gate and the momo scare so weird stuff in the app market isn't as big a shock like seeing Life of Black Tiger when it was first covered by Jim Sterling.
As for the list, I always saw it as your own and say you should tier it as you damn well please, make it B, C, F, Pie, whatever you think it's worthy. Perhaps, as a far future endeavor, you could try a community poll to tier the AVGN videos.
Watching your impressions on this felt like I had entered a bizarro world where what I consider totally unbearable and unfunny is actually comedy gold. I wish I liked this epsiode even half as much as you did! And I totally don't mean that as a dig against you or anything, I just find it interesting how we have nearly complete opposite views with this one
hah, dig away! I hope I did a good job of poking fun of myself in this video. It's funny to me that my favorite episode in a long time happened to be everyone's least favorite so that's what made this fun to do
Yo that intro was crazy
Thanks! About a month and a half ago I was ready to wrap this episode up and then I just decided to do that intro... it took quite a bit of time. Hope it was worth it!
By the way...yes...BIG RIGS, TOKYO '97, SEAMAN...these are absolute peaks of the Nerd. My wife & I are also big fans of the TAITO ARCADE GAMES episode.
I didn't think the episode was bad. My least favorites are the ones with tons of toilet humor. I can take a little toilet humor, but sometimes he goes overboard.
Completely and utterly irrelevant to the video, but...
The thing is, modern AVGN does (IMO) still work overall.
Contra, the Last Ninja (iirc), Sim City, the last Jekyll and Hyde, the new Castlevania comparison, and probably FF6 (haven't seen it since I don't want the game spoiled, but James probably cares about FF6 so it's probably good) are all genuinely (IMO) very good, with worst of them being _maybe_ 6/10's and the best genuinely being modern classics... Only to completely bomb every other episode. Even if Horse Prince is (IMO, generously) not counted as a bomb, that doesn't stop the others from being so.
It's like Dreamworks' consistency but with internet videos.
Haha, with the exception of Last Ninja, I think you named like all of my least favorite ones! :) It's all good, if anything the point of making this video is acknowledging that in some cases there's no accounting for taste and what a person sees and doesn't see in any form of media.
That episode was not that bad. Do YOUR list if that was the plan. Yes, make it about YOU.
I appreciate everyone's sentiment to have me keep to my own list, for me I'm okay with a little it of fan input at times, horse prince will definitely live in infamy
I would say c tier
i personally didnt really enjoy the episode, but Im glad you did
Fuck man... to say thats next level with the intro, would be a SEVERE understatement. I have to like out of respect. Yous a true fan. 🫡
Much appreciated!
This was, indeed, James at his best
this episode was interesting. It certainly was different. I kidna liked it and hated it at the same time it's weird. I understand both the hate and the praise. xD
Put it in A tier, this episode is great.
Dude , avgn has so many episodes and we all have different tastes and what we find great and funny , like one of my favourite episodes is the Atari 5200 but others it'll be mario 3 and some mad lads will find the LGN episode the best . We're all fans and we just want to share our opinions about what we like and dislike with hundreds of people calling you the scum of the earth
Just sitting down for dinner anthony. What a treat this is gonna be 😂
Edit: i fucking love the 1st spiderman movie by sam rami. What a great intro man!!
Thanks! This one was from the 2nd rami film, loved that intro... that said... I think people are gonna be majorly disappointed by the content of the rest of the video :)
@@SuperAnthony3 sorry for the confusion but the 1st one i had on vhs as a kid. Watched it so many times, so it reminded me of it lol. Im not gonna hate your opinion on the video. If you liked it and saw things you liked im not gonna hate for that. I watch content to see different opinons. I like to see an opinion through someone elses eye. Id rather watch your REview of the episode than watch it. Good vid and the editing is great 👍🏿
Thanks I appreciate it! Spent a lot of time on the vid and it's a different style from my others so I hope it's not too off putting and feels like fluff, but in the end, it's the vid I wanted to make, so there it is. Thanks again!
Im part of video, yeah! But seriously, comedy is subjective, you should rank episodes how you feel about them, i've disliked Texas Chainsaw Massacre episode since it first aired, and im still not a big fan, but many people likes it :)
Music by Roomgoers 😂
I honestly thought the episode was fine. Like you said it was something new and refreshing. I'd rather have another Horse Prince than another Shrek. I despise that one.
Shrek has been highly requested. I need to go back and watch that one again.
These kinds of rankings will always be super subjective. If you want to appeal to the opinions of the fans you'd have to do a gigantic poll or something. I think it's totally fine to just give your own and explain why you feel that way.
Maybe "ranking" isn't even the way to go in the first place and every video should just be reviewed and rated?
Anyway, my personal opinion about that episode was also very negative. I was never a Cinemassacre hater, always defended the show and such. I don't think of this as a "new low" or something, but there was just something off-putting about the way James was acting I think. Yes, he was overacting before, but I think it was simply too much in this one? Maybe the overacting in combination with the phone camera made it look even worse? To be fair, I didn't like his overacting in previous episodes either, I think it's always the worst part whenever he is trying to fake laugh. I don't think it fits the character in the first place.
And sure, opinion will change, rankings don't hold up ... I don't think it needs to be this serious. So I "disliked" the video since I hope you'll just give your own opinion, because if I want to see the opinion of others I'm just gonna go on Reddit or something.
Video itself was great btw. loved the intro, liked the idea of also filming this with a phone and the Spider-Man 2 joke of wanting to quit etc. Good stuff!
Thanks for the kind words! Yea, I mean the ranking thing is fun and for me the focus definitely has been the "review" part and making something that I think is entertaining. At the end of the video, hopefully it's clear that I'm acting a bit and it's not so serious, that's why I enjoy a bit of fan participation. It will mostly be my list, but I also like the idea of incorporating the audience where I think it makes sense and can add fun for the group.
@@SuperAnthony3 That seems like a good way to go. Was just a bit worried (because of the like/dislike bit) that it might result in a popularity contest later down the line. If it's just for exceptions like this where the opinions differ dramatically I guess it doesn't hurt that much :)
Yea, more often, it would be about tie breakers where I'm not even 100% certain if something should be 106 or 105
"Do I make this about me" t. Present in 90% of this video's visual content.
Good intro, though.
I mean, I would like to think that the way it is "shot" is clearly a parody of the AVGN Horse Prince video itself
It was wrong then and it’s wrong now
Well, this episode was the return of ME
I think ist' a d tier ep
That's fair!
Rank it what you'd want to rank it lol personally i'd put it in C but you are free to rank whichever XD
I am kind of in the middle. I HATED PepsiMan. It actually angered me. I HATED Vegas Stakes...my wife & I still refer to that to this day as the worst episode ever. I disagreed with you on Jurassic Park Trespasser...I found the episode a bit of a mess, plot-wise...but found it educational (like some of my favorite episodes). But Horse Prince...I actually forgot it even existed. It was completely forgettable to me. Not that bad...but not that great.
Pepsiman was definitely a weird one, was a bit of a milestone episode for me too in thinking things were changing. I mean, I guess what I don't like about episodes like Trespasser is when there is the potential for something strong but then gets messed up by the really bad and incoherent writing. I think it would have been a lot better if the episode didn't try to go big and focus on the game development process.
Honestly this episode was funny to me. I’d probably give it a B
I dunno, I do think it was on the bad side, weird ass choice for a game and all that; Im just not fan of AVGN doing modern mobile stuff.
But there was definitively an overreaction against this episode just for the facecam gimmick, it was not that bad, just experimental.
Yea, I mean, I feel like if I was trying to make a "point" it would be that, a lot of the complaints about this episode existed long before My Horse Prince and for me personally, I think I'm at a point where I would take this over Sim City which I think was terribly bland and just a "walkthrough" of a popular game for clicks
@@SuperAnthony3 I couldnt even bother to watch more than a few minutes of Sim City; I knew it was just another "oh James just talks about an objectively good game" one which to me is against the spirit of AVGN.
This episode was so bad it deserved to jump the ranking.
Different strokes for different folks. imo it was cringe and picking a game like this to begin with screams lazy.
That's kind of how I felt about Sim City
@@SuperAnthony3 it's just another example. I think even most hardcore fans would admit that James burned out long ago. AVGN just pays the bills, that's all. The last true creative thing he did with the Nerd was Polybius episode (where he was out of character).
James should just shave his head or wear a cap. When baldness is so ugly and distracting it's just not good for the channel since his face is on all the thumbnails.
I personally couldn't care less about the balding, but he should perform tattoo removal surgery. Why did he even get that "Google images tribal tattoo" in the first place? it looks freaking terrible.
Because it's bad ass! Yeaaaa!
People like you are the reason that everyone is looking super fake on the internet. Just let him be a nerd, lol.
Thanks for the engagement guys! Let's be careful about pointing fingers at each other regarding appropriate fandom and such. Everything is in good fun. Even when I shout to the world why I think Super Mario World is garbage it's mean to be done with a laugh.
@@marloges he's not a nerd though, at least not a video game one. The character was originally a parody of Matei and it's obviously all an act. James has very little interest in video games outside of the few he played as a kid (e.g. Castlevania)