Glossop Line Review ~ Train Sim World 3
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- This is a surviving section of the old Woodhead Route, depicted in its present-day condition with Northern Class 323s running commuter services from Manchester Piccadilly to Hadfield and Glossop. Personally, I think this route should've been set in the early 1980s, complete with the old British Rail Class 506 EMU.
The route is alright, but the elephant in the room is its short length (only 14 miles in total). Consequently, there's not that much to do, and I don't get why Dovetail make these really short routes so frequently.
![The Flood : London Overground : Train Sim World 4 [4K 60FPS]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4YXcwwhh2LA/mqdefault.jpg)
I recently bought the Clinchfield Railroad route. Since it is anything but linear I highly recommend it to you.
I've had that route for a couple of years now, but the freight trains are very difficult to handle.
I love the f7 on that route. To me a beautiful train. The scenerio are actually hard aswell. IMO.
I think it is overall decent, and I found that you can do a round trip in about 80 minutes from when I timed it. I would go into Free Roam and then switch cabs before the AI did it, and go on from there.
If you have class 66, you also get some freight runs on this branch line. Very limited but you do have a freight yard just past Guide Bridge if you stay on the route up to Stalybridge which is off the map. They are some short runs up to Ashbury, or services that run through Manchester Piccadilly, platform 14 toward the container yard at Old Trafford. It also layers for traffic which is realistic for them congested platforms 13 and 14. You'll often see freight services running through them around the busy passenger lines.
Maybe Train Simulator World 3 should have Bigboy 4014 DLC pack with steam excursions and that pushing a stalled freight train scenario in Blair Hill
I feel like this is a route that can easily be forgiven of its flaws purely because of how much cheaper it is compared to a normal route. With route prices going up from TSW2 to TSW3, it's amazing to see a recent release have the same price as the original Isle of Wight and the West Somerset Railway. It's probably more fun to drive than those other two as well, the 323 is a lovely little unit.
On a side note, I find it interesting that along with this route being sold at a reduced price, the upcoming Class 700/0 will be at a price cheaper than all the locomotive add-ons that released for TSW 2020. It's very unlike DTG to release several pieces of content for a notably cheaper price than usual.
Perhaps they've finally realised that people are unhappy with the high prices.
They have new owners. But perhaps they’ve heard the chatter. I certainly have second thoughts on dlc now. I would snap everyone up. Not now.
I feel like maybe Focus Entertainment had something to do with it. Just maybe.
Focus has had no impact on dtg
Now that I rewatched this video, I think added the Photomode to TSW4 because of that scenario
The only problem I have with this one, is I think it should have been included in a whole much bigger Suburban Manchester route. They should have released this as an Extension for Huddersfield in TS Classic Instead.
I play TSW3 a lot and I'm always looking for addons and these videos really help to make decisions on what the different routes are like and which ones I want to buy. Thanks from Wellington :)
Having the Birmingham city line, this route represents very poor value.
I love Birmingham but it is linear and lacks variety. This new route would be worse because of its length.
And the fact rivet got involved in this is another reason not to buy. I’ve been burnt by their dlc before. Never again will I buy third party from dtg.
I don't blame you, since Rivet and Skyhook have a very poor track record. I just hope that whatever Just Trains makes will at least be decent.
@@DC4260Productions here’s hoping.
Rivet helped with the environmental art, not the train or gameplay. They also helped with cathcart and that turned out just fine. A 3rd party helping doesn't make a dlc bad.
Not all 3rd parties are bad by the way. Tsg is an example
TSG is probably the only good 3rd party developer, because the G6 and the Niddertalbahn are exceptional add-ons.
I am really upset the 158 has no diesel smoke why. I have sent tickets but no reply. I feel you have a diesel train and no diesel smoke but all the other trains have why had two updates and still not fixed.
did you intentionally say great western express 3 times it sounds like you did but i’m not sure
Yes, that repetition was intentional.
Yes the power notch is super annoying jumps from brake 2 to power one or from brake 2 randomly into emergency. very annoying on console. complained about this on the bcc version
They could have got more out of this if it had been set in the 1990s, since class 47, class 101s, & sprinters (possibly Pacers too after the JT route) could be layered on passenger with class 31, class 37, and class 47 layered on freight to make the Piccadilly area look busier. It does help that the current Alstom transistor based inverters were programmed to operate identically to the original Holec GTO thyristor based inverters with the benefit of them sounding the same as they originally did (although maybe a little quieter) so sounds could just be tweaked slightly to create an original class 323. I have ridden this line IRL and I am especially familiar with Piccadilly and it has been modelled very accurately.
Platforms 13 and 14 in real life are arguably some of the most dangerous in the UK, maybe even Europe. The fact the island platform is rather small width ways doesn't help. In regards to the shorter route thing, I don't get why the timetable workings are split into three either.
Can you review the Class 700 when it comes out?
I won't make a dedicated 700 review, but it will get its own section in a review of the SEHS route.
I’ve been reading the forums and I’ve seen rumors about TSW4, and supposed “leaks” I personally wouldn’t be suprised because DTG have been absolutely quite last month or 2. they’ve been making shorter routes, buggy routes, incomplete routes, unnecessary cashgrabs and lazy DLC, and linear routes, they also went quite around the end of the TSW2 lifespan, and they’re doing that now. They’ve also made the recent roadmaps bare and very empty. Either dovetail have turned there team to TSW4 or 3 big routes this summer. Just sharing my off topic opinion :)
It's happening next year dtg the end game for TSW3 will be crazy
To make the route better they should also do an extension of Piccadilly to Rose Hill Marple as well.
This is the only “good” train game on consoles, which is why it’s still here. If NEV, the creator of trainz decided to make one for consoles, which with the ps5 and xbox series x, it could be done, people would switch over to that, especially if jointed rail was included and made content for console. TSW would still be there but only because they would step their game up on tsw if trainz came to consoles. Trainz would probably even let you have more freedom the day it came than tsw does right now. The only thing that probably wouldn’t be added from the pc version is the create you own map feature. You could make the session exactly how you want, the train consist would be how you wanted, actual manifests in sessions, etc. If trainz came to consoles id easily choose it over tsw.
Problem is dovetail makes real routes which most people would probably prefer.
@oParkLikesTSW4 yeah but with trainz people make real routes for it
It's decent but 1 train for £20 might be a decent deal but doesn't excuse the lack of variety of service pattern Birmingham cross city has more variety and that's got the 323 aswell trust me about this big release it's going to Be like TSW2 rushour 3 or 5 routes for like £30 or a season update like TSW1 - TSW2020 the same game just give some extra routes thrown in for existing owners it was main spessart bahn, NTP and long island that was thrown in. My predictions for the 3 routes are there going to be something from the TSW2 era they might throw in Bakerloo line UK, for Germany either naverkher dresden or tharandter rampe could be both but unlikely USA or Canada either harlem line or sandpatch grade. (this is my prediction for the update not saying it's gonna happen.)
The reason why they made this route even though DTG won't say it is because it's just a filler route for the big summer release coming in August or September so it's a way for DTG to get some money in.
I won't be buying this route for sure. It's way too short and boring
I just hope that the big release isn't TSW4. We don't need yet another pointless sequel, given that there are still issues with the current iteration that Dovetail seemingly don't want to fix.
@@DC4260Productions I hope tsw4 won't be a thing either
@@DC4260Productions tsw4 will be taking the Michael. If you get my drift.
Don’t get me wrong but tsw3 was a step up from tsw2. But surely the can just release the update.
I think also they should perhaps move to a subscription model.
There's no way there can be a TSW4 *this* summer. However it can be a possibility for next year... Who knows...
@@nicholasmills6489 a subscription model would draw people away even more. The last thing players want is a trainz where only those with a subscription get all the benefits while those who don't get nothing
3:16 that's definitely too quiet...
What they could have done to make this slightly less linear C.N is add the Manchester Piccadilly-Manchester Airport section. Personally i wouldn't mind if Dovetail did part of The Hope Valley line either from Manchester Piccadilly-Sheffield including Totley Tunnel or Sheffield-Doncaster.
There will always be a unique if not alien feature about The Class 323's it's traction motor sounds that make them stand out from even The Class 465/2 and 465/9 Metro Cammell built Networkers.
You want DTG to care about DLC and bringing properly interesting new content to their game? Nope, wrong dev team 😂
Would you be able to do a review of Steam Sounds Supreme's Stainmore and Shap route at some point?
I think it's easy to tell that this route was made purely as a way for DTG to chuck something small out the door to fill the gap before the release of TSW4. Compared to other UK routes I personally see it as looking more nicely detailed, but I also wouldn't be surprised if that was the case because DTG were seeing the work going into JT's Blackpool route and knew they needed to up their game. Or perhaps it also reused assets from the ECML route which was more than likely in development at the same time. Not to mention the fact that it was probably the easiest choice they could have made, given its short length and the fact that the only train they had to make for it was a reskin of one they had just released only months earlier.
So MML next? Again, too bad you didn't review it when it came out haha it was truly terrible
The Edinburgh route has a working elevators at edinburgh waverly
I’m just wondering when TSW3 will get a Merseyrail route
Would you be planning on doing a re-review of the Brighton Mainline and Great Western Express routes? I have recently bought TSW for the sake of BML (Brighton mainline) and the 377s. And I wonder what everybody thinks about them.
Love your reviews on these route and now I understand what shitshow is going on in TSW’s development department
I haven't reviewed either of those routes yet. I plan on covering GWE at some point; not sure about the Brighton route.
@@DC4260Productions ooh I see. Nice to hear that GWE route will be getting a review. I hope that you will do the Brighton route in the future as well.
@@ludwigtailswhat Brighton route? There’s the one to Eastbourne and the one to Victoria right?
@@claimediraq9715 the original op post said Brighton mainline
19:11 Just noticed you said "Great Western Express" 3 times
I actually agree with alot you've said I am enjoying the Glossop line tbf it's a nice little short route with the 323 which I like I think we should have longer routes but I think perhaps they aren't doing longish routes because they struggle on last gen consoles just my thought really the new just trains route coming soon is 48 miles long which is a decent length overall I do agree with you though on alot of things
Length has nothing to do with what what console you have. I don't know where you're getting that information from since it's clearly not true. There have been longer routes which run just fine on consoles. The truth is that routes take a really long time to make. Imagine having to model everything of a 50 mile railway with rolling stock that are modeled true to life with a full timetable. That's a massive amount of work
They should do tje elizabeth line from Paddington to Shenfield
Clearly management is on top of what routes to make. They choose what they can do in least amount of time/work that makes them more money, in other words, small routes or "conversions" routes from TS take less work/development times therefore better money wise...
it's the same for the development teams, what happen to the preservation crew? having a team for fixing bugs or update old routes does not necessary bring them money...
What DTG needs is competition, hopefully that SimRail game can make for a nice competitor.
Thanks for the vids and cheers for Portugal :)
Are you going to,review the 700?
The reason why they made this route for TSW 3 is because of the latter is about to get its 4th Game, apprently something regarding Train Sim world 4 Was actually leaked on the forums multiple times and usually smaller routes are made in order to signal that something significant is about to be released or will be annouced very soon. Which is good and bad and ugly imo because now this was basically a cop out route just to give the fanboys another bone after barking for new content
I don't know why Dovetail think TSW4 is a good idea. It'll probably just have very little (if any) changes, once again.
@@DC4260Productions I know right, it's obviously that they didn't take any of the feedback from Train Sim World 3 and now they are making an entirely new game. Where are the bug fixes for Several routes especially with routes that still have MISSING OHL and wires. Such a shame that Train Sim World 3 will suffer the same fate, but in a much more crueler way than Train Sim World 2
they just rehash routes rather than give us longer routes - lets behonest that what we want - why couldnt this route have 3 models ??
This route doesn't feature any parts in any other routes. The models for TSW 3 take a lot to produce as they are fully modelled in a lot of detail rather than just MSTS style models, with separate cabs and basic control physics like some other simulators still use on new models today.
Why doed TSW not the enter global
No license=can't do
this is just a diffrent branch from the same station that trans pennine runs it just goes straight on rather than take the right turnoff that trans pennine dose take they reuse same locations at manchester just made it look modern
Northern Trans-Pennine goes out from Manchester Victoria, not Manchester Piccadilly.
@@DC4260Productions victoria station is alot smaller tho and only has like 4 platforms and newer it looks like the one on trans pennine went through but they biult the shopping center blocking off the ends so it looks like it dose in manchester to glostop
@@bigdikboiCJ Its a totally different line, Northern Transpennie runs from Manchester Victoria via Ashton to Stalybridge, This route runs from Manchester Piccadilly via Guide Bridge, where if you turn right you go past Guide Bridge sidings before the line from Manchester Victoria, features in Northern Transpennie joins it just before Stalybridge before going onto Huddersfield and Leeds. That happens off the map, however. Victoria looks smaller now because they closed some platforms and reused them for the Manchester Tram service, but different stations and routes.
Hi do you know when there going to update the New York Trenton
I'm afraid I don't because I don't work at DTG.
@@DC4260Productions lol
Ngl the most painful thing about this route is the inclusion of Drax biomass transport services (that I see often IRL) with everything being wrong about it,
I mean not only does it not use acrual Drax cars, it users railfreight coal hoppers from another dlc but also instead of using colas rail freight locomotives like a class 60, it uses EMS class 66s which they constantly reuse.
It makes zero sense so why add it?
I'm guessing it was just to make the route look a little more busy, but it doesn't excuse the blatantly inaccurate rolling stock.
Players are going to be unhappy either way.
Some players want more traffic on a route which means dtg have to use, that's if it's nothing too crazy and unrealistic, existing rolling stock.
Some players want realism so no layers that don't make sense at all which decreases traffic. But sometimes dtg don't have the license or it's difficult to get so there's that
Although dtg want to make layers toggleable, there are no plans to do that so it's either or which depends on what dtg decides to do