@@parjanyashukla176Well Muslims were largely comfortable with Hindus. Jinnah filled poison in Muslim minds & the subsequent outcomes made Muslims intolerant to Hindus so much that were ready to kill Hindus without provocation just with one command from Jinnah. Partition nahi hota to two child system laakr vese bhi unka proportion badhne ni dete. Emergency me Indira gandhi ekad karod Ms ki nasbandi krne hi wali thi. Abhi 20% ke aspas hote aur pura India bhi hota apne pss. I hope you’re intelligent enough to realize 20% Muslims in Akhand bharat is anyday better than 15% muslims in broken India of today.
@@parjanyashukla176 Weak & fearful i think you are as a matter of fact. But that’s the beauty of Laws of nature. They only favor the brave. Therefore you & likes of you won’t make it to the table to decide. You’re more of a Sudama type Shukla and not Parshuram type shukla.
Ishtiaq sahab is a person we all know about. But let me say that this other young guy too is largely intellectually honest. That’s the scene when real scholars meet.
Thank you Ayesha Jalal for having pioneered the conversation and Dr Ishtiaq for having taken it a notch further and Asad for having pointed out the possibility of further inquiries. May Allah bless our Quaid. Pakistan Zindabad.
Hahaha.... The condition of both Pakistan and Congress has enough to say if they were right or wrong. If someone is still searching for something to justify his own stand, that's nothing but amusing. Mr. Asad Rahim is just doing that. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Speaking truth is the greatest crime in Pakistan . Mr Asad is proponent of spreading false history .Prof Ishtiaq should not have appeared with this fofellow . People love th hesr what they have studied since 1947 . So truth is a great crime
Ishtiaq is a joker with hollow conclusions, if you listen to his various interviews you very quickly find duplicity in his conclusions and the lies contained within.
Prof Ishtiaq research is based on facts, actual quotes and real history, although your hate and religious bigotry is stopping you research and find the truth. If you’re young and not killed by mullah or military, watch Bharat regain its glory by 2047!
Jinnah was a doctor who cut appendix of India. Though the operation was painful, we hindus in India thanks Jinnah today
Not the appendix, but the cancerous tumour.
@@parjanyashukla176Well Muslims were largely comfortable with Hindus. Jinnah filled poison in Muslim minds & the subsequent outcomes made Muslims intolerant to Hindus so much that were ready to kill Hindus without provocation just with one command from Jinnah. Partition nahi hota to two child system laakr vese bhi unka proportion badhne ni dete. Emergency me Indira gandhi ekad karod Ms ki nasbandi krne hi wali thi. Abhi 20% ke aspas hote aur pura India bhi hota apne pss. I hope you’re intelligent enough to realize 20% Muslims in Akhand bharat is anyday better than 15% muslims in broken India of today.
@@Arunh9-pw7lp
Smoking pot I think you are.
I would never have more of them within
@@parjanyashukla176 Weak & fearful i think you are as a matter of fact. But that’s the beauty of Laws of nature. They only favor the brave. Therefore you & likes of you won’t make it to the table to decide. You’re more of a Sudama type Shukla and not Parshuram type shukla.
Ishtiaq sahab is a person we all know about. But let me say that this other young guy too is largely intellectually honest. That’s the scene when real scholars meet.
About to say this. Opposition is well read.
Thank you Ayesha Jalal for having pioneered the conversation and Dr Ishtiaq for having taken it a notch further and Asad for having pointed out the possibility of further inquiries. May Allah bless our Quaid. Pakistan Zindabad.
Asad is a sensation, it was a pleasure listening to his arguments, and unbiased approach to history.
😆 enjoy your mulk
Hahaha.... The condition of both Pakistan and Congress has enough to say if they were right or wrong. If someone is still searching for something to justify his own stand, that's nothing but amusing. Mr. Asad Rahim is just doing that. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Rightly said😆😂😂 they are not even struggling, they have failed completely 😆
Speaking truth is the greatest crime in Pakistan . Mr Asad is proponent of spreading false history .Prof Ishtiaq should not have appeared with this fofellow . People love th hesr what they have studied since 1947 . So truth is a great crime
Moderator is talking too much.........
Ishtiaq is a joker with hollow conclusions, if you listen to his various interviews you very quickly find duplicity in his conclusions and the lies contained within.
Truth hurts.
@@RahulMishra-ld2bo truth? More like fantasies and stupidities.
Prof Ishtiaq research is based on facts, actual quotes and real history, although your hate and religious bigotry is stopping you research and find the truth.
If you’re young and not killed by mullah or military, watch Bharat regain its glory by 2047!
@@GSR356 bharat is an idiotic fantasy created in a bowel movement. 😂
Please discuss facts not idiotic fantasies.