Yes! Please! I think it could also be nice to dupe brands that are controversial that people don’t want to support like J* or dupe palettes that were crap like Melt Millennial Pink! For both of those I love the color story but won’t buy because of the owner for one and reviews for the other! Or recreate disappointing launches like how so many didn’t love the ND Circo Loco. You could create a whole new design. So many ideas!!!
Given you're doing a Melt palette, it seems that they're all that comes to mind right now... I'd love to see the Vida palette dupe and the Gemini one as well. I also would like to see a dupe on the night owl one given I missed out on it and am still beating myself off about it! Oh, and Coloured Raine Safari palette! :)
This was supposed to go up on Friday but I ended up having technical difficulties and a very busy weekend. Muerte is probably my most requested dupe ever so I hope you enjoy it 💙❤️
I'm really looking forward to the Kaleidos Flower Punk... for the mints... 👀👀👀 I feel like they are the one... because everything else I have, and from Melt at that... but the mint... and I have Huda's mint, but I feel like Muerte is a richer mint...
I actually thought the dupe side was the best, and thought that was the Muerte side! I have all those blues/greens and reds so I'm good, but Muerte is such a beautiful color story!
I'm so glad I picked this palette back in the day! Also I learned last week that Melt's palettes are magnetic!!! Now I can use Muerte to dupe other palettes, like Club Nebula haha 😅
i learned melt palettes was magnetic a few months ago and they are such life savers for duping other palettes! i used a few to dupe the last few kaleidos palettes so they have been saving me money🤑
I’d LOVE to see more like this! You killed it! I rarely get these things wrong but I thought the dupes were the palette! The dupe side appeared more vibrant. I think this is the kind of video people would really love! There’s so many limited edition things so this is just awesome!
I guessed wrong for what eye had what palette; I also don’t like the last shadow in the muerte palette, but it’s definitely overall one of the best palettes I own.
These are pretty nice dupes, I couldn't tell on the eye. Seeing how rich and beautiful this palette is though, makes me sad that I never bit the bullet when I had the chance, I fell in love with smokey blue too late.
Thank you for this!!! I couldn't buy Muerte when it was released, and when I finally went to go buy it, I was so sad to see it was no longer available 😩💔 this will be really helpful as I try to recreate it!
I could not tell the difference!! 😊 I hope your shot went well. My mom had a reaction 6 days AFTER her 2nd shot! Had a huge red/purple-ish rash all down her arm. The ER Dr. said they had been seeing this. They gave her an antibiotic & it is slowly getting better.
Oh no! I’m glad your mom is getting better. I felt completely wiped out for a few days and my arm still is a little sore and has some redness but overall doing good now. It was worth it ☺️
@@AmyLovesMakeup I felt wiped out as well with my 1st shot! The 2nd one went better for me. But my arm was very sore with both shots for several days (like yours). However, it was definitely worth it! I feel lucky to have gotten mine so quickly. *Other countries are not as fortunate as us right now.
these colors are just soooo rich and dark and sultry and moody and velvety ok another words i love them both!! I couldn't guess for the life of me..lol..
I don’t support the brand anymore, but I have a dupe when I combine the JS blue blood and blood sugar palettes, might as well use my JS since the purchase was made a long time ago.
I was so upset I missed out on this palette but I couldn’t afford it at the time and then it got discontinued 😩 also another dupe for that matte mint shade could be Give me Glow Cosmetics Mojito single shadow!
I have both palettes and no, they have a similar vibe, but they're not even close to be dupes. Muerte's is a dark base with teal shimmer, while Cheers to the Beauty's is a black with intense blue and violet sparkles. But, I remember swatching the shimmery blue from Kaleidos Astro Pink and that one seemed a very similar formula and same tones, but lighter.
I love videos like this! I also think it would be cool to use shades in other palettes for specific shade dupes (but that may be an unpopular opinion) just bc I like to see if I may have something already that is similar like how you mentioned club nebula
I realized that the original jacklyn hill and morphe pallette is dupping the muerte pallette except for the blues. It would be fun if you made this a series ❤️
Thank you so much for posting this!! I am so mad I missed this collection and have wanted this palette in particular, but won’t spend the money people are asking for it!!
I actually saw someone selling both Amor Eterno palettes for over $500! Muerte alone over $300! Scalper!😬 I enjoyed Amy all April. Thank you... I know it was a lot of work! I saved this video for reference.💚
Within 6 months and only a few month my Muerte pallete started smelling moldy and i got a rash on my eye so a dupe might be safer too. I was so sad. For me this video makes me so happy!
@@AmyLovesMakeup it's ok it is the danger of buying makeup i think. But i will keep it for the beautiful packaging! I love the color story and you have inspired me to go buy some singles and an empty pallete so thank you Amy.
Amy! This is awesome! I think I have most of the colors in my collection from this palette. Great inspo 💜 Guess: Viewer left is dupe, Viewer right is muerte. . . I was right🎉🎊🎉🎊🎉
Great video!! I tried for months to dupe Muerte for folks, using my singles as well. The only one I couldn’t get nearly perfect was Lagrimas- however, the bh Cosmetics palette Lost in Los Angeles has a virtually perfect dupe. Not a single but worth mentioning because it’s such a challenging shade to find!
Good afternoon Amy! Excited to watch this because I missed this release. I was only able to get my hands on the Vida palette when Melt had their secret restock 😐😒 Thank you for this video 😊💖
STACEY MARIE CARNIVAL XL PRO PALETTE is Also dupe of melt murrate palette and BPERFECT X STACEY MARIE CARNIVAL III LOVE TAHITI PALETTE is dupe for Vida palette
love this comparison! i do like the color scheme minus the blue and will build a custom palette around it. definately added a shade or two of your dupes to my wishlist :D thanks!
I did not guess correctly. Nice job. I will say, seeing the dupes actually makes me a little more wistful that I missed out. The colors do seem to have a unique depth that I haven't found elsewhere. Not really sure why they don't bring it back given how much they're being re-sold for and how much people still want this old palette that's been gone for what? Over a year? Maybe two? I think the fact that people still want it is a big sign that it would do well in a restock
I guessed correctly only because the shade on your right lid Alpine is less chunky like you said. Now I need to see if I can dupe these shades with my current collection. I have the Club Nebula but unfortunately I missed out on Muerte.
This was great! I would love to see more dupe videos, especially if there are dupe shades still available for those of us who missed out on some of these limited edition palettes. I’ve been admiring your pink and white dresser ever since you changed up your background and wondering where I can find something similar?
I know you have an amazing singles collection and this was already AMAZING but it'd be cool if you could give more dupe suggestions from palettes (even if it was just in the description). 🥰 Love that you noticed the similarities in Club Nebula, I just received mine and I'm excited to play with it. I love mixing palettes so it'd be great to know if there's a specific shade that might be a dupe for a limited edition palette.
Thank you for these dupes. This palette is the one that got away. I was wondering, maybe the matte red shades in Melt's Beetlejuice collab palette The Waiting Room, could be similar to the Muerte. If anyone reading this could confirm please. Thanks again. Definitely a good idea to begin a series duping LE palettes,
I was wrong in my guess. Forever disappointed I never got the muerte palette. Very dirty that Melt weren't transparent that it was LE until it was gone. Thank you, great video good to know since I already have a few of the dupe shades
When I saw u swatching the dark reds it occurred to me that the club nebula could work for most of the dark shades. And u mentioned it too. I had the chance to get the muerte palette in store but at the time I wasn't sure if I wanted it. And I had a $25 gift card too. I should've bought it, makeup regrets 😔
Thank you so much for doing this. The only palettes I ever had fomo for are Muerte and Vida. I appreciate your hard work for this I feel bad but I almost wish that one company that does ND "dupes" would do a comparable palette
Cries in Canadian :( Wish I could have got this when it was in Sephora Canada because getting these from individual sites with shipping, duties and currency exchange will be $$$. Really entertaining video though :)
I feel like I can get the looks that I would want to make with Muerte with the Club Nebula palette, and maybe one or two singles! So I am happy now that I have that palette. Do you have Cliondah Ice Algae? I feel like that might be closer for the light green matte.
Okay before watching the full video, my guess: Left eye (from my view, so technically right eye) is Muerte; right eye is dupe. ETA: Oh I guessed wrong!
Also check out Sample Beauty’s new Plush Palette: www.beautybay.com/p/sample-beauty/the-plush-palette/?ctyid=us&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=Cj0KCQjwvr6EBhDOARIsAPpqUPHUJVMgsYhX9HGaD7naqNclLLUiEOYYJIgCZBT0VRHgzAqz-r9LVw4aAgmBEALw_wcB Pretty much spot on.
Uggghhh why now?? I was just trying to dupe this palette a couple of weeks ago and I've already placed an order 😭 EDIT: Moaning aside, I do think this is a great idea for a video. I wonder how well the dupes that I bought will work out. 🤔
I’m guessing you have Muerte ☠️ on your right eye and the dupes on the left. Seriously, though, this palette is stunning, and the only way you can get it is by paying like $250 on eBay. Not gonna happen.
I’m seeing some comments I should do a series duping limited edition palettes. Comment under this comment which palette you would like to see next ☺️
Yes, please
Only if you want too. I like duping pallets in my collection.
I would love to see the Kaleidos neon 6-pan! I don’t even know what happened to it, but I totally wish I had it :)
Yes! Please! I think it could also be nice to dupe brands that are controversial that people don’t want to support like J* or dupe palettes that were crap like Melt Millennial Pink! For both of those I love the color story but won’t buy because of the owner for one and reviews for the other! Or recreate disappointing launches like how so many didn’t love the ND Circo Loco. You could create a whole new design. So many ideas!!!
Given you're doing a Melt palette, it seems that they're all that comes to mind right now... I'd love to see the Vida palette dupe and the Gemini one as well. I also would like to see a dupe on the night owl one given I missed out on it and am still beating myself off about it! Oh, and Coloured Raine Safari palette! :)
This is exactly the type of content I want to see.
Soooooo good! Duping limited edition palettes should be its own series 🤩
Thank you for the suggestion!
This was supposed to go up on Friday but I ended up having technical difficulties and a very busy weekend. Muerte is probably my most requested dupe ever so I hope you enjoy it 💙❤️
I'm really looking forward to the Kaleidos Flower Punk... for the mints... 👀👀👀 I feel like they are the one... because everything else I have, and from Melt at that... but the mint... and I have Huda's mint, but I feel like Muerte is a richer mint...
How did your vaccine go? I actually had worse side effects with the first shot than the second.
I LOVW THESE TYPES OF VIDEOS. WE need these at minimum once a month please and thiank u
I actually thought the dupe side was the best, and thought that was the Muerte side! I have all those blues/greens and reds so I'm good, but Muerte is such a beautiful color story!
This palette is my unicorn. It got away. Lol.
STACEY MARIE CARNIVAL XL PRO PALETTE is Also dupe of melt mirate palette
Same here
My biggest makeup regret is not getting my hands on the Muerte palette!!
I'm so glad I picked this palette back in the day! Also I learned last week that Melt's palettes are magnetic!!! Now I can use Muerte to dupe other palettes, like Club Nebula haha 😅
i learned melt palettes was magnetic a few months ago and they are such life savers for duping other palettes! i used a few to dupe the last few kaleidos palettes so they have been saving me money🤑
I actually got it right just because of the lethal shade in your inner corner. It's so much brighter and shinier.
I have the Muerte palette and Calaca is 💩 and ANY Lethal shimmer shade is definitely better!!!
I’d LOVE to see more like this! You killed it! I rarely get these things wrong but I thought the dupes were the palette! The dupe side appeared more vibrant. I think this is the kind of video people would really love! There’s so many limited edition things so this is just awesome!
Me too
I guessed wrong for what eye had what palette; I also don’t like the last shadow in the muerte palette, but it’s definitely overall one of the best palettes I own.
Thank you so much for this full month of amazing content, it's been great!! Enjoy a well deserved break now 🤗🤗🤗
Oh my goodness!!! I can't even tell the difference 🤯🧐🙌😊
Yasss! I feel accomplished ☺️
The palette that got away! 😩😩😂😂 Beautiful look! ❤️
I guessed right!! I think the dupe side is prettier than the Muerte side
These are pretty nice dupes, I couldn't tell on the eye. Seeing how rich and beautiful this palette is though, makes me sad that I never bit the bullet when I had the chance, I fell in love with smokey blue too late.
I love that you duped this / and I gotta say, I really like the brightness of the teal shimmer on the dupe side👌
The collab palette by Kaleidos is also a good dupe
Thank you for your hard work on Amy All April! We loved it!
Thank you for this!!! I couldn't buy Muerte when it was released, and when I finally went to go buy it, I was so sad to see it was no longer available 😩💔 this will be really helpful as I try to recreate it!
This is such a beautiful palette. Thanks for doing this
I could not tell the difference!! 😊 I hope your shot went well. My mom had a reaction 6 days AFTER her 2nd shot! Had a huge red/purple-ish rash all down her arm. The ER Dr. said they had been seeing this. They gave her an antibiotic & it is slowly getting better.
Oh no! I’m glad your mom is getting better. I felt completely wiped out for a few days and my arm still is a little sore and has some redness but overall doing good now. It was worth it ☺️
@@AmyLovesMakeup I felt wiped out as well with my 1st shot! The 2nd one went better for me. But my arm was very sore with both shots for several days (like yours). However, it was definitely worth it! I feel lucky to have gotten mine so quickly. *Other countries are not as fortunate as us right now.
I’m so happy I picked up Muerte and Vida when they were suddenly back in stock on Melt’s website.
these colors are just soooo rich and dark and sultry and moody and velvety ok another words i love them both!! I couldn't guess for the life of me..lol..
That deep blue Shimmer that you showed kind of reminds me of colour-pop antimatter
you did such a great job!! i seriously couldn’t tell the difference between the two eyes 😍😍👌🏻
Oooh! I guessed wrong. The dupe side is brighter! For the deep blue, Sydney Grace's #itsaboy or Indiana Love could possibly be dupes?
I don’t support the brand anymore, but I have a dupe when I combine the JS blue blood and blood sugar palettes, might as well use my JS since the purchase was made a long time ago.
You did an amazing job with those dupes!
You did a great job tho! Good eye. Shame this pallette isn't coming back. I feel this way about the waiting room
I was so upset I missed out on this palette but I couldn’t afford it at the time and then it got discontinued 😩 also another dupe for that matte mint shade could be Give me Glow Cosmetics Mojito single shadow!
Coloured Raine has an exact shade that is like the darker blue with purple sparkles but its in the cheers to the beauty palette.
I have both palettes and no, they have a similar vibe, but they're not even close to be dupes. Muerte's is a dark base with teal shimmer, while Cheers to the Beauty's is a black with intense blue and violet sparkles.
But, I remember swatching the shimmery blue from Kaleidos Astro Pink and that one seemed a very similar formula and same tones, but lighter.
You are the BEST at dupes. That’s how I originally found you ❤️
I love videos like this!
I also think it would be cool to use shades in other palettes for specific shade dupes (but that may be an unpopular opinion) just bc I like to see if I may have something already that is similar like how you mentioned club nebula
I realized that the original jacklyn hill and morphe pallette is dupping the muerte pallette except for the blues. It would be fun if you made this a series ❤️
Ooooh I could totally see that comparison!
I just pulled this palette out shopping my stash for May. I've barely used it since I got it (since I didn't wear makeup almost all last year).
Thank you so much for posting this!! I am so mad I missed this collection and have wanted this palette in particular, but won’t spend the money people are asking for it!!
I actually saw someone selling both Amor Eterno palettes for over $500! Muerte alone over $300! Scalper!😬
I enjoyed Amy all April. Thank you... I know it was
a lot of work!
I saved this video for reference.💚
ive been WAITIN for this one, god bless queen amy
😂😂
I got the muerte and vida palette and I absolutely love them. Awesome video btw.
Such a great video. Muerte is one of my favorite palettes. You did an awesome job with the dupes!
Omg I never clicked so fast on a video! Yess! Thank you 🙏
Within 6 months and only a few month my Muerte pallete started smelling moldy and i got a rash on my eye so a dupe might be safer too. I was so sad. For me this video makes me so happy!
Oh no! I’m sorry to hear that
@@AmyLovesMakeup it's ok it is the danger of buying makeup i think. But i will keep it for the beautiful packaging! I love the color story and you have inspired me to go buy some singles and an empty pallete so thank you Amy.
Amy! This is awesome! I think I have most of the colors in my collection from this palette. Great inspo 💜 Guess: Viewer left is dupe, Viewer right is muerte. . . I was right🎉🎊🎉🎊🎉
I have this eyeshadow palette and I’m so glad I didn’t sleep on it
Wow 👏😮👏 Amy you did an amazing job at dupes. Thank u so much😁😁
I got it right! This was a fun video 😁
Great video!! I tried for months to dupe Muerte for folks, using my singles as well. The only one I couldn’t get nearly perfect was Lagrimas- however, the bh Cosmetics palette Lost in Los Angeles has a virtually perfect dupe. Not a single but worth mentioning because it’s such a challenging shade to find!
Wow! Your look today is really striking. Thanks for this video :) I can’t guess which eye is which 🤓
Good afternoon Amy! Excited to watch this because I missed this release. I was only able to get my hands on the Vida palette when Melt had their secret restock 😐😒 Thank you for this video 😊💖
So excited for this!!! Thank you.
STACEY MARIE CARNIVAL XL PRO PALETTE is Also dupe of melt murrate palette and BPERFECT X STACEY MARIE CARNIVAL III LOVE TAHITI PALETTE is dupe for Vida palette
I don’t know what you did different t but the video looks even better than before no shade I like it
Carnival xl also has very similar dupes for every shade
love this comparison! i do like the color scheme minus the blue and will build a custom palette around it. definately added a shade or two of your dupes to my wishlist :D thanks!
I did not guess correctly. Nice job. I will say, seeing the dupes actually makes me a little more wistful that I missed out. The colors do seem to have a unique depth that I haven't found elsewhere. Not really sure why they don't bring it back given how much they're being re-sold for and how much people still want this old palette that's been gone for what? Over a year? Maybe two? I think the fact that people still want it is a big sign that it would do well in a restock
I feel like the bperfect carnival pro ii has basically muerte in it. Except for the super deep red shade.
I guessed correctly only because the shade on your right lid Alpine is less chunky like you said. Now I need to see if I can dupe these shades with my current collection. I have the Club Nebula but unfortunately I missed out on Muerte.
This was great! I would love to see more dupe videos, especially if there are dupe shades still available for those of us who missed out on some of these limited edition palettes. I’ve been admiring your pink and white dresser ever since you changed up your background and wondering where I can find something similar?
Thanks for the dupes. I'm in the market for a few of them. I really find this palette hard to work wish i could have returned it.
Wooooow this is what I really need, excellent video!
I know you have an amazing singles collection and this was already AMAZING but it'd be cool if you could give more dupe suggestions from palettes (even if it was just in the description). 🥰 Love that you noticed the similarities in Club Nebula, I just received mine and I'm excited to play with it. I love mixing palettes so it'd be great to know if there's a specific shade that might be a dupe for a limited edition palette.
Love this wish I had this melt palette. Thanks
I guessed correctly but they’re super close and I wasn’t confident in my guess when I made it
Thank you for these dupes. This palette is the one that got away. I was wondering, maybe the matte red shades in Melt's Beetlejuice collab palette The Waiting Room, could be similar to the Muerte. If anyone reading this could confirm please. Thanks again. Definitely a good idea to begin a series duping LE palettes,
That matte green is so hard to dupe. I'd love to know if the matte in Flower Punk is similar.
I was wrong in my guess. Forever disappointed I never got the muerte palette. Very dirty that Melt weren't transparent that it was LE until it was gone. Thank you, great video good to know since I already have a few of the dupe shades
I stopped buying from them because of this. And formulas have been sub par lately
When I saw u swatching the dark reds it occurred to me that the club nebula could work for most of the dark shades. And u mentioned it too. I had the chance to get the muerte palette in store but at the time I wasn't sure if I wanted it. And I had a $25 gift card too. I should've bought it, makeup regrets 😔
Thank you so much for doing this. The only palettes I ever had fomo for are Muerte and Vida. I appreciate your hard work for this
I feel bad but I almost wish that one company that does ND "dupes" would do a comparable palette
I feel the same way about calaca
How about palettes that are hard to get right now such as the flight club and Annette collab with menagerie? Or alien cosmetics?
Thank youuuuu! 😊
I bought the palette and I realized I couldn’t use the reds because it had ingredient that I was allergic to. I was so sad. 😞
You are awesome for this girl! :D
I LOVE duping videos.
Cries in Canadian :( Wish I could have got this when it was in Sephora Canada because getting these from individual sites with shipping, duties and currency exchange will be $$$. Really entertaining video though :)
I feel like I can get the looks that I would want to make with Muerte with the Club Nebula palette, and maybe one or two singles! So I am happy now that I have that palette. Do you have Cliondah Ice Algae? I feel like that might be closer for the light green matte.
OMG I typed that before you mentioned Club Nebula! HAHA too funny.
I liked your dupe side better 😊
Can you find a shade that is available for the red shade in the Melt palette?
That was the closest red single that I personally have. I think any true red pigmented matte would work though.
YES YES YES
About to watch, and if you can actually dupe this - particularly the dark mattes - I will love you forever.
Edit: goddamnit.
Okay before watching the full video, my guess: Left eye (from my view, so technically right eye) is Muerte; right eye is dupe.
ETA: Oh I guessed wrong!
I thought the same
I’m guessing the side closer to your palettes is the muerte side 🤔
i was wrong
I wanted that palette set so bad I paid $180 bucks for both. No regrets lol
Also check out Sample Beauty’s new Plush Palette:
www.beautybay.com/p/sample-beauty/the-plush-palette/?ctyid=us&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=Cj0KCQjwvr6EBhDOARIsAPpqUPHUJVMgsYhX9HGaD7naqNclLLUiEOYYJIgCZBT0VRHgzAqz-r9LVw4aAgmBEALw_wcB
Pretty much spot on.
I guessed wrong!
I guessed wrong ;o
I hope the vaccination went well!
It did overall. Thank you ☺️
Uggghhh why now?? I was just trying to dupe this palette a couple of weeks ago and I've already placed an order 😭
EDIT: Moaning aside, I do think this is a great idea for a video. I wonder how well the dupes that I bought will work out. 🤔
Im sorry 😭😭 Im sure your dupes will be great
I’m guessing you have Muerte ☠️ on your right eye and the dupes on the left. Seriously, though, this palette is stunning, and the only way you can get it is by paying like $250 on eBay. Not gonna happen.
I'm using my husband's account but you cannot tell a difference