I don't think she ever intended to replicate the studio version, she always changes phrasing and add libs, dodge some notes but hits others even more impressive than the recording itself, that's why she's amazing and keeps you on the edge
This is one of the hardest songs in Xtina's career, not even she performed this song with the same studio vocals, but it's the only one that can get so much emotion singing her live.
Christina has had a 20 year career of belting some incredibly high and challenging songs, we all know she can do it but at this point I'm much happier with her taking smart choices during performances and not tiring her voice out too much. I don't think these songs were ever written to be taken on tour, doing show after show of high belty songs.
Ahh yeah. This! I noticed that when I sing higher, I can belt high note perfectly, but when I sing lower, something like stuck in my throat and I can't produce the intended belt note.
@@ilockeyou that’s because the connections between the different passages of your voice isn’t developed yet. I’ve had similar issues in the past, and it’s not really easy to solve.
I mean we all know she is a vocal powerhouse, but she seriously needs to consider consult a vocal coach to coach her on executing some of her songs better, especially this one. The studio version of this song was flawless, powerful and easy to listen to. But all of the live version of this song were kinda hard to listen to; its either she dodged the high notes, or she strained too hard and caused this cracking voice. I mean she should find a way to perform this song better, either she lower the key or find another vocal technique to deliver those notes safely.
She could never eclipse that part live and on the spot. She did it w/ such ease in the studio - granted that they do multiple takes. Her struggle area is high belts. She's always wanted to do the Whitney thing and I get it, but girl... That's not yo' range. She has a lovely voice, but when she starts straining and grunting for no reason, she messes everything up.
I really don't get it how she's able to do it so well in studio and not even once is she able to replicate it live. Not just this song but many others. Still an amazing singer though
Absolutely HATED the she never ever sung it like the studio version, same with Beyonce's Single Ladies at the bridge, when she sings "don't treat me to the things of the world" differently.
icant find the best one like when she record it but when she sing live she will change the arrangement she cant sing live shes trying hard. filipino singer is far better 😢
![[Vocal Battle] Christina Aguilera - Light Lyric Soprano VS Mezzo Soprano (Eb3-F#5-G5)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Zij4S74nMMA/mqdefault.jpg)
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.77[1/2] ก็ไม่ได้ชอบเอาชนะ แต่เรื่องอะไรต้องแพ้!!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JraaBYOd7I0/mqdefault.jpg)
I don't think she ever intended to replicate the studio version, she always changes phrasing and add libs, dodge some notes but hits others even more impressive than the recording itself, that's why she's amazing and keeps you on the edge
This is one of the hardest songs in Xtina's career, not even she performed this song with the same studio vocals, but it's the only one that can get so much emotion singing her live.
Christina has had a 20 year career of belting some incredibly high and challenging songs, we all know she can do it but at this point I'm much happier with her taking smart choices during performances and not tiring her voice out too much. I don't think these songs were ever written to be taken on tour, doing show after show of high belty songs.
The clips from the x tour are by far the best!!
Definitely 2019 vocals are the best. You can see the improvement
2019 she had an improvement 😍😍😍😍
At 5:00, one of her back-up singers wanted to leave the stage. Queen!
She should have lowered the song, then she wouldn’t have had to dodge the notes so much.
Ahh yeah. This! I noticed that when I sing higher, I can belt high note perfectly, but when I sing lower, something like stuck in my throat and I can't produce the intended belt note.
@@ilockeyou that’s because the connections between the different passages of your voice isn’t developed yet. I’ve had similar issues in the past, and it’s not really easy to solve.
Still wonderful technique out there. Legend. And thats a fact. Fighter since i was 6 😁💪🏻
Her voice gets heavier that she is unable to take upper belt. Expected as high as in studio album
I mean we all know she is a vocal powerhouse, but she seriously needs to consider consult a vocal coach to coach her on executing some of her songs better, especially this one. The studio version of this song was flawless, powerful and easy to listen to. But all of the live version of this song were kinda hard to listen to; its either she dodged the high notes, or she strained too hard and caused this cracking voice. I mean she should find a way to perform this song better, either she lower the key or find another vocal technique to deliver those notes safely.
She most likely sang it a couple of semi tones lower in the studio and then had it enhanced to a slightly higher key. Lots of singers do this.
If only she didn't lower it, she might hit the belt note. Because it's easier to belt with higher note than lower note.
Wonderful bell, but it has a nutty technique !!!
She could never eclipse that part live and on the spot. She did it w/ such ease in the studio - granted that they do multiple takes. Her struggle area is high belts. She's always wanted to do the Whitney thing and I get it, but girl... That's not yo' range. She has a lovely voice, but when she starts straining and grunting for no reason, she messes everything up.
She's good low to mid range. It's the high parts that she struggles with.
@Mariah&WhitneyLamb it'll never happen
I agree. I love her lower register, and I greatly appreciate it on live versions of this song.
You could have added the year of the performance
She never even bothered to hit a single E5.. how sad
imo none of these are great, the phrasing is too disjointed and it just sounds like a struggle for her.. studio version is lovely though
I really don't get it how she's able to do it so well in studio and not even once is she able to replicate it live. Not just this song but many others. Still an amazing singer though
Art Aspire Well in the studio you get a million tries, I guess she put the best sounding vocals and combined them
I knowww but she has sung live 1000s of times in her whole career and not once was that lucky time when she even accidentally sounded like the studio.
Art Aspire Well her technique isn’t the healthiest, so it’s probably very straining on her voice
@@TvOfMike I know all that, even her good studio vocals arent sung with a healthy technique but they re much better than live.
that must've hurt lol the studio version is ❤
Absolutely HATED the she never ever sung it like the studio version, same with Beyonce's Single Ladies at the bridge, when she sings "don't treat me to the things of the world" differently.
Strain as hell, phrasing is totally disjointed, dodges everywhere, I mean just very bad
first of all check your grammar before commenting, then get tf out if u don't like🖕🏻 and second of all can u sing like that, of course fcking not😏
@@iamhuydamn Stop😭😭😂.
can you just like, shut up?
icant find the best one like when she record it but when she sing live she will change the arrangement she cant sing live shes trying hard. filipino singer is far better 😢