My favorite Sagan quote is this: "One of the saddest lessons of history is this: If we've been bamboozled long enough we tend to reject any evidence of the bamboozle. We're no longer interested in finding out the truth. The bamboozle has captured us. It is simply to painful to acknowledge, even to ourselves, that we've been taken. Once you give a charlatan power over you, you almost never get it back." Carl Sagan
There are so many great Sagan quotations. One of my favorites : “If we offer too much silent assent about mysticism and superstition - even when it seems to be doing a little good - we abet a general climate in which scepticism is considered impolite, science tiresome, and rigorous thinking somehow stuffy and inappropriate.”
Consider that you are not falling for it. You are part of a growing awareness made possible by the internet. Critical thinking however is needed. Having access to a way to open the eyes is better than closing them. Be careful for the charlatans in science who also may promote certainty of the spiritual realm.
Thank critical thinking and science, I was able to break free from a religious cult after 36 years in it. Science is my new religion, and people like Sagan are my new “god’s”.
Now there was another interesting man. I wrote to him years ago regarding the ending of Robots & Empire and asked him if he had envisaged this ending and he said, no - it was how it came out. So humbled he took the time to write back.
@@jewelheart1708 So amazing, another one of my childhood heroes. Reading I, Robot changed my outlook on all things scientific and pushed me to be an engineer.
I've been listening to some of Isaac Asimov's interviews this week. He too was a science popularizer and a skeptic of religious and pseudo-science claims. He passed in 1992.
Every time I watch a Sagan video, it breaks my heart. 27 years later it's almost as if we haven't learned anything and He would be so disappointed and the same time we really need someone like him being a candle in today's darkness
no one would listen....people are entranced with pop culture and deep thinking and reflection is relegated to the introverts, geeks, nerds, hermits.....its not cool to understand what is happening to us....
It's sad he was spot on. We didn't listen. All I can do for my kids is to add this: Time for a 3rd party in congress (SCIENCE). They need to have a voice not just a resource of information .
1 Corinthians 1:22 For the Jews require a sign, and the Greeks seek after wisdom: 23 but we preach Christ crucified, unto the Jews a stumblingblock, and unto the Greeks foolishness; 24 but unto them which are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God, and the wisdom of God. 25 Because the foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men. 26 For ye see your calling, brethren, how that not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble, are called: 27 but God hath chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise; and God hath chosen the weak things of the world to confound the things which are mighty; 28 and base things of the world, and things which are despised, hath God chosen, yea, and things which are not, to bring to nought things that are: 29 that no flesh should glory in his presence.
You are familiar with the "public" Carl Sagan. In his reactions to friends and family, it is said, by THEM, that he was quite arrogant and demanding. But they had their reasons to love him, anyway......
@@sherrymiller2302 Yes, so say we all that are above the average intelligence. I have learned in my years to just nod and smile as family and friends say obviously inaccurate or simply wrong things. The familial connection is greater than the truth, because of their egos. As a nuclear engineer I can somewhat understand what an intelligence like Sagan must have gone through when interacting with "the others".
Carl Sagan was such a brilliant man. He could understand complexities & then explain them to the average person in understandable terms. That is such a gift. I miss him tremendously.
At 80 years old i still can't read "the pale blue dot" without a tear for the wisdom beyond the scientific knowledge that mankind has lost. His influence has emotionally influenced me for life in the best way
I have his photo and that picture of Terra, from all that distance away in my cube at work. It still blows my mind everyday when I look at it how we are just a little blue pixel in a moat of dust a part of an inconsequential part of an arm in an average galaxy among an incalculable number of other galaxies, and possibly universes!
The point of _Pale Blue Dot_ is that some of us need to leave Earth and the solar system because of dangers known and unknown that might threaten our long-term survival. Even if we can move asteroids to avoid another extinction-causing impact, there might be comets or interstellar asteroids that we can't intercept in time. One problem though is that space is incredibly dangerous. So in the short term if we have dozens, hundreds or 1000 people in near-Earth orbit, on our moon, Mars and the near-Earth asteroids, they will be at extreme risk of death or medical problem that could be more-easily treated on Earth.
This man was 100% the reason I turned toward science as a career. The Cosmos series and his book The Demon Haunted World literally changed my life. He died 20 years ago. RIP.
Marcia Palomar I didn’t see any hate. Saw a little anger. I disagree with Sagans humanism. Sagan says religion gets in way of science, but his science also disagrees with God.
@@charlesbaldo, you likely are a better puncher. My shoulders, wrists, and elbows can't do the hard hitting anymore. Guess the many years of doing it has taken its toll on this old man. That being said, I still box the robot but hit it softer. Sure is a lot of fun and nice workout.
@@2fast2block I know where you are coming from. As I get older my body heals much slower. I need more time between punching workouts. I make sure the speed bag isn't as hard too. I do enjoy it still and you are right, its a great workout, builds confidence in your soul too. I am going to favorite your stuff on my channel.
It was more than a decade after he died that I ran into the famous clip from Cosmos where he explains higher dimensions. That clip lead me to watch the entire series and that, quite literally, changed my life. I do believe I am a better person because of the legacy of this man.
the domesticating dogs and how that 1 act of wisdom from humans to say maybe some of these animals could help us survive and possibly even protect us and possibilities could be amazing. A single act of thought that literally propelled us up the food chain and even today a protector in your home of an intelligent animal...some trial and error im sure but an example of what knowledge has done for us and the need for science and free thought is incredibly beneficial to our species. No im not doing whole religion vs science or politics...never ending fights cant win and a waste of time and energy to try to change deep seeded bias and belief.
@@poweraccountabilityleague6877 No, it's the right - always has been, always will be. Conservatives go out of their way to destroy public education in favor of private/charter schools.
More & more, in my senior years, I read, listen & watch Carl Sagan. In this terrifying world we are living in, I feel I can find some peace & sense through his philosophy. We desperately need another Carl Sagan…
@@bathie2636 You seem like a real smart person to still be hung up on trump over words and not policy, while the actual standing president threatens the very nature of intellectualism in this country. The man cannot form a coherent sentence, let alone tell you which planet Jupiter is from the sun, or explain in general terms M-theory. Neither can trump I’m not defending either, but you’re just incredibly narrow minded for not acknowledging what’s happening in front of your face.
It would be difficult to fill his shoes in this modern era where so many people seem to think that consensus reality is really just a matter of personal opinion, and that the scientific community is full of nefarious types who have entered into a cabal with the goal of “taking away people’s freedom”
We lost something when we lost Carl Sagan. I believe there are people who come and go in the world and each of their minds are as valuable as the Library of Alexandria. When we lost them, it’s as tragic as the burning of that same library.
I fall asleep listening to Segan about 2-3 nites per week on average for the last several yrs. I’ve re-listened to Pale Blue Dot at least a dozen times. He’s brilliant and an amazing orator, with beautiful articulation, voice cadence and flow. Tell your kids to listen to this man, to read his work. Let’s keep Segan alive
I agree 100%! I adored him as a little girl, then in high school watching Cosmos, and now reviewing his countless speeches. PBD is on my Playlist for meditation and to help me sleep. What a kind soul he was....
My favorite Carl Sagan quote came when he was asked, "it seems that through the ages humans have created a mythological framework involving a higher spiritual power, but with that being impossible to prove where does that leave us" and his reply "on our own" is so simple and demanding accountability that it's perfect.
Impossible to prove? Of course you can " prove" it. Don't believe shit just because some dick says it man. That's ultimate stupidity , and very sad in your case.
When Dr. Sagan died I felt like I lost my father. He was truly the most influential individual in my life and his books and television shows inspired me like no other. Its a shame that no one since has emerged to take up the challenge of promoting common sense, critical thinking,science, skepticism and responsible technology.
Greg is obviously a moron troll, Left-wing libtard. There was nothing in my post that was political so leave your political opinions at the door because you wouldn't recognize true libertarian-conservative ideology if it smacked you upside your communist cranium.
Death To Liberalism There was nothing in your post about politics, but your username is an advertisement for your political beliefs. If you weren't expecting people to notice it, you're fairly naive. And you can do all the justifying you want, but Carl Sagan was a liberal, so his comment saying that it's odd that a person who hates liberalism looks up to a liberal isn't really that out of bounds.
My father was a scientist that also passed away from cancer when I was a young child. My family fell apart afterward and I had a very tough time growing up.. When my father wasn't there, Carl Sagan was a great inspiration. I'm now grown up with a great career in egnineering and a deep belief in the value of science. Thank you for your gift Dr. Sagan.
What? Engineering involves using mathematical equations and scientific knowledge to solve problems. It's a type of applied science, a field of study that also includes medical and veterinary sciences. Engineers perform research, design devices, structures and chemical compounds and test the effectiveness of their prototypes.
I wish people didn't report some posts as spam, it's always a good thing to show how ignorant some people are in their comments. Offer a good rebuttal instead of resorting to censoring these fools.
It isn't spam, it's troll talk. Who knows what they believe ? They sense deep truth and then parasitically attach to it and try to get attention. To anyone who reads forums and TH-cam comments, they're pretty obvious. Rebuttals just feed the drama llama. The WORST thing you can do to those people, is just ignore them.
***** Not at all ! Sometimes decent people can use a little guidance out there in the troll-infested Web. Just like you, I am most definitely the judge of spam and trollhood in my life. The proliferation of parasites that came with the miraculous Interwebs must make us all better censors of things for ourselves. They die when we do not allow them to attach : through censorship in the form of ignoring them. They're one type of that variety of parasite that survives by wasting your time, and liking it.
"The long dreamless sleep." One of the most powerful lines that he had ever said. We have been lucky to live in a day where no one ever dies digitally. We will never know the sound of Galileo's voice, but children in the future will see and hear this amazing man convey his most inward thoughts. A man for all time.
"But one thing that it has done, is to enhance my sense of appreciation for the beauty of life. And of the universe, and the sheer joy of being alive. ... Every moment, every inaminate object, and to say nothing of the exquisite complexity of living beings... Yeah, you imagine missing it all, and suddenly it's *so* much more precious." "May you live a long time. Thank you very much."
I met my all-time hero Carl Sagan 3 years before his passing. Shaking his hand was one of the greatest moments in my life. Over the decades since I often feel sad about the discoveries on Mars and about the universe as a whole that he missed and how much joy he would have gained from that knowledge.
I am 56 years old...Carl Sagan will be in my mind forever...I will be always thankfull for what has tought me....and the ones who made the series "Cosmos" possible....whatever....I'm just a guy somewhere in the world....but the world is my country....and science is my religion....
Would you rather sit on a tree stump, get an ass splinter, and die from infection the next time you take a shit or live in the 21st century with access to nearly infinite knowledge, freedom, and the ability to relax instead of being a naked hunter gatherer?
I think Carl passed away not long after this interview. He was such a great man, so deeply loved and sorely missed by many people who never even met him. In a sense his energy still lives in in the cosmos in the form of binary digital information that people can still enjoy. You are so much loved. Dr Carl Sagan. x
Dr. Sagan was prescient, he nailed the condition of willful ignorance we have today. We certainly needed this beacon of intellectual curiosity the past 27 years.
It's good to know that he was hopeful about his disease. Very upsetting to hear it today though. I'm so glad that his efforts live on and that I can read his work or see him speak on here any time. A very special person indeed
If you close your eyes and listen to this, it's as if the man is sitting across the table from you TODAY. That is a hallmark of a truly great speaker and communicator.
I am so sad to see such a brilliant mind died so young. There will not be another Carl Sagan in my lifetime. I felt so privilege to have heard him talk. I am blessed
We need more people like this amazing scientist, my grandfather introduced me to Carl Sagan when I was a kid, he used to watch Cosmos and I used to sit next to him and watch, and my mind just exploded. I certainly agree humanity is at a huge risk, and scientific way of thinking is the way to bring order back to this world. But there is also a reality behind all of this, unfortunately we have more poor people in this world than people with enough money to provide with education to their kids, and that is creating a huge amount of ignorance, in addition to all other stuff considered as first necessity, and those which are our future, are not prepared to handle it, that is what we should afraid the most at this point. A complete lack of values, living in a society who values more a smartphone than spending an entire day with their family... sad times are ahead.
Religious people who say "Sagan is in hell" oh man. The same feels you get from your deluded beliefs I get from reading/listening to Sagan. He leads me to truth, he helped me expand my mind. I'm absolutely disturbed that anyone could listen to this man so eloquently express himself and say anything negative. There is beauty in disagreement, and that beauty involves progress towards truth. I'm trolling because I'm not okay with anyone disrespecting Sagan to the extent they do on this video, not because I'm emotionally attached as much as I'm just truly disheartened that because he disagrees with you he deserves to go to hell. The logic there is why Sagan chose to speak out against Religion.
+Suzee Veronica ASMR Religion means zero. Sagan was about the truth, no agenda, I knew him well. My wife worked with him at NASA and Cornell. He believed that God might have created the universe, Spinoza s and Einstein s version, as I do, No daily intervention, no worship, etc. He thought that human spirituality was essential to deal with social ills, crime, drugs, child abuse, suicide, etc. He believed in alien life. He shared those views with Clarke, Hawking, etc. most scientists believe along those lines, including me. Having an agenda, religious, atheist, etc. hinders objectivity, solves nothing. He had no respect for people who wrote fiction novels, whether religious or atheists, to fool people out of their money. He did not like those debates, science vs religion, the thought it took away from the scientist s dignity to argue such childish foolishness. That is why, only ex. scientists participate in those debates, they get more money, if they are famous, for one/two debates, than a scientist makes in a year. I hope I did not offend you, your views, please?
carl violante I agree completely, I've studied his works very closely, I know how he felt about our species existential relationship with the universe. I study neuroscience, so for me, there are too many intricacies within our human brain that bounce off of the energies within our natural world to make such an ignorant claim that there aren't other higher powers at work. Carl stressed this, especially in his book Contact. Atheism and other ism's that claim to have some sort of answer are not doing themselves any justice. We do not have the mental capacity to grasp what could be out there, we are still an extremely young and naive species. Our prefrontal cortex's evolved so rapidly to have such awareness that it's baffling and can lead one to believe there is something else within our universe that is working with us, but there are also so many things that are not justifiable with such significance, such as natural error. I posted that comment to make a statement about why I feel it's so absurd to attack Sagan with such negativity, many are just not ready for what he was saying.
Your comment about Carl Sagan & the proposed resting place where he should apparently reside in hell. It's very disconcerting that idiots who wish ill on a fellow Human it's genuinely very dangerous, are we to await a future society where any difference of opinion is automatically outlawed & monitored by the thought policing agency. I laugh at the level of narrow mindedness that exists and for the foreseeable future for the lack of ambition for the truth that surrounds organised religion. Thank you for your comments brilliantly insightful, Regards .
***** Untrue. The bible was written about 1500 hundred years ago, by scholars, for scholars, the fact that it became popular with common people is another story. What eternal truths? Tony
When logic prevails!!...The Logical Legend that was Mr Carl Segan. Wish he was still around.... he was a lovely, humble, conscientious human in this sometimes chaotic world.✌from London.
1986 my best friend's dad gave me his large hardback Cosmos book. It's beautiful. Continue to read Sagan's work, always mesmerized by space and exploration
4:08 - "If we are not able to ask skeptical questions, to interrogate those who tells us something is true, to be skeptical of those in authority; then we're up for grabs for the next charlatan, political or religious, that comes ambling along." -Carl Sagan
I was steeped in hatred and anger at the time I saw this. I very quickly had to set that down and listen to the words of this amazing man. He changed my life and made me see the connection we all have to one another and to the universe itself. We are all made of star stuff and I can't express in words how much I miss this amazing and irreplaceable person. Hating someone for something as ridiculous as the color of their skin or their faith makes no sense. It's time we start to see the beauty in all of us and celebrate the potential within us all.
The magic of his language, the artistry of his words, they still resonate to this day. I'm so pleased and gratified that we have recordings of his voice.
I regret not knowing about this genius earlier. It would have been a revelation and given me courage to follow my heart and pursue a career in science.
Yep Yep - You might enjoy watching a famous PBS special that was broadcast in 1998 across the nation. Life Beyond Earth, by Timothy Ferris. Tim was the guy that made the Gold records for Carl Sagan to put aboard the Voyager spacecrafts. It ran as a 2-hour documentary and it's beautifully narrated by Ferris himself throughout the full run. You can just look it up, as it's available in TH-cam for free, by title and Tim Ferris's name, when you see it come up with a thumbnail icon showing the earth below photographed by the space station. I believe the runtime is 1 hour and 48 minutes. It has something in there for everyone. I played the 2-hour special for my students when I taught astronomy as an adjunct professor in 2004 at a local University here in Portland Oregon. At the end, as they're sending out a message to space to ask for a reply from any possible aliens listening out there, just before the credits begin to roll on the screen, it reads - for Carl Sagan.
Carl Sagan, you were taken from this world too soon. Thank you for your tremendous contributions to science and to the fabric of the human race as a whole. You are sorely missed.
I wish he would have lived long enough to see what an amazing tool for spreading knowledge the internet has become. I would have loved to get his insight on that.
***** Ya, but if we continue to teach people how to reason and not just regurgitate information, I have enough faith in humanity that logic and compassion will eventually win.
***** you're probably right. I try to believe that people want to learn from humanities mistakes and think independently but realistically, most people will fight, with vitriol, anything that contradicts their world view or comfort zone. I guess the earlier comment is something I WANT to believe.
***** same goes to you, deal with the fact that we are all unique individuals, stop trying to make everyone think like you. Let it go and be happy for what we have evolved to be, to think that everyone will have a scientific mind is like talking about some fairy tale.
Sagan said he never actually says, “billions and billions”, but, rather Johnny Carson used that expression in a skit referencing Sagan. Carson loved and admired Sagan.
The world from what? From Sagan's god of nothing? The world is free now from that dumbass but his followers still live on wanking off to their god of nothing and orgasming to its power even though nothing has no power but wankers don't care.
@@forsakenofgilead5209, whatever point you're trying to make, explain it by how it fits with physics. Real science says nothing does nothing. Real science says if there was something there already it must fit with the evidence of what we know. We know the 1LT says there's a conservation of energy. It can change forms and neither can be created or destroyed. Creation cannot happen by natural means. The 2LT has various aspects, one being the universe is winding down, entropy. Usable energy is becoming less usable, so at one point usable energy was at its max. This all points to a supernatural creation, by a supernatural creator at a certain point in which matter, space and time were created. When I read how it can happen otherwise, ALL the fools resort to science-fiction. Once a supernatural creation is accepted, then the next step is finding proof of what supernatural power did it. Physics proves creation had to be supernatural.
@@forsakenofgilead5209 ... oh, yeah... TYLER... but, you conveniently forget ! THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS NOTHING... TYLER... space is not a void. Space is... FULL... of energy. Light and stuff flows through IT. Space is a containing vessel that IS HOLDing a universe... TYLER... together... TYLER... in... IT... SEE... here, look 🍳 with this poached egg MAGINI-FIRE... thingy !!! SIGNED BY... the ROCK OF PHAGES ...
@@2fast2block Can we agree the Scientific Method is applicable to some fields of inquiry, and at least now, not applicable to other fields? If we cannot agree that this is the case, then why are scientists wholely ignorant about entire subjects of knowledge?
We lost so much with Carl Sagan. There are no outspoken individuals like him anymore. I hope that more can approach things with skeptical thinking like this.
Carl Sagan faced a lot of challenges he did his best to deliver the meaning of science in a very simple way but during 70's and 80's more people were narrow thinking even the tv interviewer didn't understand him well enough. Carl Sagan was True and Great scientist.
Especially starting at 7:15 through 10:00, as this is where most people, [biblical literists especially] have trouble reconciling with what is being discussed here about understanding the scientific methods. Carl Sagan describes it so well.
At 19:04, when discussing the possibility of his death, you can see him glance at the camera. I think in that moment, he was acutely aware of how the world would miss him. He remained humble, but he wasn’t wrong in the slightest.
+Alex Shi God will forgive you if you believe so you can rape, kill, murder and torture anyone you like! That is as long as you are a TRUE Christian though! If you are not a Christian then you are evil no matter what type of person you are and no matter how nice you are to others and you deserve to burn in hell!
I love and miss this genius of a man with all of my heart. His series, Cosmos (and esp. the reboot with Neil deGrasse Tyson) is indescribably thought-provokingm, astounding and thoroughly engaging. His wife, Ann Druyan, is equally as brilliant and a phenomenal writer. Dead at 62. Damn. Damn. DAMN!
@@thomasjefferson1010 To me it means that the human brain is capable of thinking many ways. A person can think scientifically, artistically, spiritually, socially, culturally, politically, competitively, compassionately, economically, etc. Thinking scientifically is one of many ways of thinking.
As a kid I grew up with Carl Sagan but I didn't appreciate him as much as I do now and now he is so much more accessible, at least video's of him anyway. But now I have Neil deGrasse Tyson and he the the Sagan for my daughters generation tough she is only 6, but I am appreciating him enough for the two of us for now. But I wonder what Carl would think of the world now, so much of what he fought for has failed while so much of what he worked on lives on. He almost makes me want to believe there is a heaven.
Carl's influence is even greater now than it was when he produced Cosmos. Now he is more recognized and I wish he could see this. I introduced him to my girlfriend and she enjoyed his show quite much. She even made a poster for me with one of his quotes :)
I gotta wonder, Tom, that your despair of your daughter comes from the tv politics of fear and confusion. Don't worry so much. She's online, and couldn't give a fig about tv. ;p
One of the greatest man on our planet. Deep respect! He will live on forever as quality always does. And he will inspire all coming generations for sure
"Being a scientist" doesn't mean working as a Scientist to make a livin in a society. A Scientist is any man of Science, which means a Human being who learnt this tool among others to understand where and why he is there. I may not work as a scientist in the future, but as a student, I will learn every bit of Science I can before leaving school someday.
Two engaged interesting intelligent men holding a learned conversation, speaking in full sentences, no one shouting, no one going for the one-liner, no one trying to speak over the other. How refreshing.
Life has value because we don't live forever. You will never value something that you cannot lose. Please learn that important life lesson. No pun intended.
This was an amazing interview with Carl Sagan he was a man of great belief, and his knowledge of the the universe ,was always a pleasure to listen to him speak, I wish I had met him when he was alive there are so many questions I would have liked to ask him about space and the universe, RIP Carl sadly missed but never forgotten 🙏🏽
Carl Sagan was such a beautiful human being, we miss him so much, a great scientist and humanist, and always so generous to his "opponents" He certainly changed my outlook on life,and I thank him for it.
It's almost his 88th birthday here from where I am writing this comment. I really feel like he had a beautiful way of bringing the universe down to the common man. We miss you Mr Sagan.
My favorite Sagan quote is this: "One of the saddest lessons of history is this: If we've been bamboozled long enough we tend to reject any evidence of the bamboozle. We're no longer interested in finding out the truth. The bamboozle has captured us. It is simply to painful to acknowledge, even to ourselves, that we've been taken. Once you give a charlatan power over you, you almost never get it back." Carl Sagan
There are so many great Sagan quotations. One of my favorites :
“If we offer too much silent assent about mysticism and superstition - even when it seems to be doing a little good - we abet a general climate in which scepticism is considered impolite, science tiresome, and rigorous thinking somehow stuffy and inappropriate.”
The aptness of this quote for today's politics is breathtaking.
Consider that you are not falling for it. You are part of a growing awareness made possible by the internet. Critical thinking however is needed. Having access to a way to open the eyes is better than closing them. Be careful for the charlatans in science who also may promote certainty of the spiritual realm.
Thank critical thinking and science, I was able to break free from a religious cult after 36 years in it.
Science is my new religion, and people like Sagan are my new “god’s”.
@@richgowell7166 You just couldn't resist going there.
“The saddest aspect of life right now is that science gathers knowledge faster than society gathers wisdom.” ~Isaac Asimov
Now there was another interesting man. I wrote to him years ago regarding the ending of Robots & Empire and asked him if he had envisaged this ending and he said, no - it was how it came out. So humbled he took the time to write back.
@@jewelheart1708 So amazing, another one of my childhood heroes. Reading I, Robot changed my outlook on all things scientific and pushed me to be an engineer.
Yes
He'd be 85 today. It'd be nice to have had him around for the last 25 years.
Yeah, my grandma is still around today and she’s born two years earlier than Carl Sagan.
He rests in peace, this world developed exactly as he foreseed.
We needed him
My dad's 85. We watched cosmos religiously despite me not knowing much of what I was watching as a kid it was interesting
@@Koexistence13 All CGI pycho babble. The earth is a closed system, you can't leave.
This man was a lone lighthouse in the darkness. We need him more now than ever. Truly an inspirational way to think and act.
Well said
We need a couple hundred of him!
He shed light on the world for me in a way no one else could. I owe him a great debt.
I really like how you said it.
I've been listening to some of Isaac Asimov's interviews this week. He too was a science popularizer and a skeptic of religious and pseudo-science claims. He passed in 1992.
Every time I watch a Sagan video, it breaks my heart. 27 years later it's almost as if we haven't learned anything and He would be so disappointed and the same time we really need someone like him being a candle in today's darkness
no one would listen....people are entranced with pop culture and deep thinking and reflection is relegated to the introverts, geeks, nerds, hermits.....its not cool to understand what is happening to us....
It's sad he was spot on. We didn't listen.
All I can do for my kids is to add this:
Time for a 3rd party in congress (SCIENCE).
They need to have a voice not just a resource of information .
We have Neil DeGrass Tyson
1 Corinthians 1:22 For the Jews require a sign, and the Greeks seek after wisdom: 23 but we preach Christ crucified, unto the Jews a stumblingblock, and unto the Greeks foolishness; 24 but unto them which are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God, and the wisdom of God. 25 Because the foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men. 26 For ye see your calling, brethren, how that not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble, are called: 27 but God hath chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise; and God hath chosen the weak things of the world to confound the things which are mighty; 28 and base things of the world, and things which are despised, hath God chosen, yea, and things which are not, to bring to nought things that are: 29 that no flesh should glory in his presence.
I don't think he'd be disappointed at all and would likely recognize that the world simply isn't as dark as it may initially appear.
20 years ago Sagan was predicting the nightmare of ignorance we are living through today.
Then we are up for grabs... for the next charlatan, political or religious, who comes ambling along.
(Trump. Putin. Johnson. Etc)
Absolutely
PATIENT 3036
He'd be horrified at what the liberals and conservatives have done
Absolutely, men and women can now magically switch genders or say they're neither, it's sad.
He died in 1996, yet his words have never been more insightful and valid as they are today. Amazing interview.
Unfortunately nobody listened to him and now we are doomed! Sitting most incompetent people in high ranks and destroying our world and us!
How did Carl Sagan die?
@@mrkitty777 Bone cancer, I believe.
His observations are timeless for anyone unafraid to listen. Much love Carl.
His net worth is "billions and billions" .Charlie Rose works hard to make himself sound like an intellectual. He is as phony as Dick Cavetto.
"Better by far, to embrace a hard truth than a reassuring fable." -Carl Sagan
YES !!!!!
what truth, which truth are you referring too?
Muitas fábulas, ele abraçou
Better to die standing than to live on your knees.
@@edmund184These days, if you don’t like real facts, there are always “alternative facts” that you can turn to
My eyes teared up seeing how fragile he looks, I want to hug him, and say thank you. The man was a poet and an inspiration to life.
He looked weak & fragile, but strong in himself & no self pity. I miss him
@@patkennedy2620 I got to know Sagan long after he died and I miss him too 😢
It's a pity that America doesn't care.
He is the GOAT
@@crespoopserc Indeed. I have a picture of him in my work cubicle, and only a few folks know who he is and how he helped us progress, so sad!
A most beautiful human being...thank you for having inhabited this planet, Carl. You surely were one of the best of us.
You are familiar with the "public" Carl Sagan. In his reactions to friends and family, it is said, by THEM, that he was quite arrogant and demanding. But they had their reasons to love him, anyway......
@@sherrymiller2302 Yes, so say we all that are above the average intelligence. I have learned in my years to just nod and smile as family and friends say obviously inaccurate or simply wrong things. The familial connection is greater than the truth, because of their egos. As a nuclear engineer I can somewhat understand what an intelligence like Sagan must have gone through when interacting with "the others".
Carl Sagan was such a brilliant man. He could understand complexities & then explain them to the average person in understandable terms. That is such a gift. I miss him tremendously.
To understand them is wonderful....the greatest is the ability to explain them, so the "LAY-PERSON " can enjoy that knowledge with you.
At 80 years old i still can't read "the pale blue dot" without a tear for the wisdom beyond the scientific knowledge that mankind has lost. His influence has emotionally influenced me for life in the best way
I have his photo and that picture of Terra, from all that distance away in my cube at work. It still blows my mind everyday when I look at it how we are just a little blue pixel in a moat of dust a part of an inconsequential part of an arm in an average galaxy among an incalculable number of other galaxies, and possibly universes!
@@anydaynow01true
he wasn't 80 here
“Is there intelligent life on Earth?” Carl Sagan, Pale Blue Dot. a.k.a. “ITILOE”
The point of _Pale Blue Dot_ is that some of us need to leave Earth and the solar system because of dangers known and unknown that might threaten our long-term survival. Even if we can move asteroids to avoid another extinction-causing impact, there might be comets or interstellar asteroids that we can't intercept in time.
One problem though is that space is incredibly dangerous. So in the short term if we have dozens, hundreds or 1000 people in near-Earth orbit, on our moon, Mars and the near-Earth asteroids, they will be at extreme risk of death or medical problem that could be more-easily treated on Earth.
This man was 100% the reason I turned toward science as a career. The Cosmos series and his book The Demon Haunted World literally changed my life. He died 20 years ago. RIP.
Kiki VI
what're you studying now?
Microbiology with a focus on immunology and virology!
kendo512 Do you smoke weed?
Used to, a lot. What gave it away?
20 years and he still generates immense feelings in people who never met him, and live thousands of miles from where he roamed. Beautiful!
@@2fast2block you respond in an angry, hateful manner which presents itself to be your ignorance and untelligence,,,sighh!
Marcia Palomar I didn’t see any hate. Saw a little anger. I disagree with Sagans humanism. Sagan says religion gets in way of science, but his science also disagrees with God.
2fast2block you are a puncher, so am I.
@@charlesbaldo, you likely are a better puncher. My shoulders, wrists, and elbows can't do the hard hitting anymore. Guess the many years of doing it has taken its toll on this old man. That being said, I still box the robot but hit it softer. Sure is a lot of fun and nice workout.
@@2fast2block I know where you are coming from. As I get older my body heals much slower. I need more time between punching workouts. I make sure the speed bag isn't as hard too. I do enjoy it still and you are right, its a great workout, builds confidence in your soul too.
I am going to favorite your stuff on my channel.
It was more than a decade after he died that I ran into the famous clip from Cosmos where he explains higher dimensions. That clip lead me to watch the entire series and that, quite literally, changed my life. I do believe I am a better person because of the legacy of this man.
the domesticating dogs and how that 1 act of wisdom from humans to say maybe some of these animals could help us survive and possibly even protect us and possibilities could be amazing. A single act of thought that literally propelled us up the food chain and even today a protector in your home of an intelligent animal...some trial and error im sure but an example of what knowledge has done for us and the need for science and free thought is incredibly beneficial to our species. No im not doing whole religion vs science or politics...never ending fights cant win and a waste of time and energy to try to change deep seeded bias and belief.
Some people should be immortal.. Carl Sagan is one of them.. world misses him terribly..
He is immortal because we're still talking about him.
Truly a great man. He inspired many and his message lives on in people like Neil deGrasse Tyson.
I love the way he spoke, his voice was so calming
Its a voice of great love and compassion...
There's no greater inspiration to me than a scientist who can exlain cold, hard truths in such a comforting, spiritual way.
"The sheer joy of being alive." Beautiful words from an amazing man. RIP Carl Sagan.
The NY Times article was ironic. It's the left which has destroyed the public education system and the reverence for science and logic.
@@poweraccountabilityleague6877 No, it's the right - always has been, always will be. Conservatives go out of their way to destroy public education in favor of private/charter schools.
More & more, in my senior years, I read, listen & watch Carl Sagan. In this terrifying world we are living in, I feel I can find some peace & sense through his philosophy. We desperately need another Carl Sagan…
Unfortunately with how things are going actually!… What we have is Trump, not an other Carl Sagan…. *Please God help us. Help the world!…*
@@bathie2636 And now it actually is worse with Biden. Satan has taken over the USA.
@@bathie2636 You seem like a real smart person to still be hung up on trump over words and not policy, while the actual standing president threatens the very nature of intellectualism in this country. The man cannot form a coherent sentence, let alone tell you which planet Jupiter is from the sun, or explain in general terms M-theory. Neither can trump I’m not defending either, but you’re just incredibly narrow minded for not acknowledging what’s happening in front of your face.
@@bathie2636 trump is also necessary to deal with peacefuls (muslims)
@@kaizen_monkwhat
The depth of the loss of Sagan is only overtaken by the depressing realization that no one has been able to fill his shoes.
It’s ok. Sagan said everything he needed to say. It is now up to us to implement his wisdom.
It would be difficult to fill his shoes in this modern era where so many people seem to think that consensus reality is really just a matter of personal opinion, and that the scientific community is full of nefarious types who have entered into a cabal with the goal of “taking away people’s freedom”
@@nomandad2000I fear it's too late.
@@skudlugs yep…
@@skudlugsit is never too late
We lost something when we lost Carl Sagan. I believe there are people who come and go in the world and each of their minds are as valuable as the Library of Alexandria. When we lost them, it’s as tragic as the burning of that same library.
I will always miss this wonderful intelligent inspiring man. One of the best!
best of the best
OYu can still find his pupil, Niel deGrasse Tyson and new series Cosmos:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmos:_A_Spacetime_Odyssey
One of the most enlightened human beings ever born. RIP great sir. I'm buying his books for my sons to read
Sagan could never answer this question... If the universe is only 14 billion years old, how can it be 92 billion light years wide?
@@ManuelBasiri Well said Manuel. His books are wonderful and I have all of them in my library. Your children are lucky to have a dad like you.
I fall asleep listening to Segan about 2-3 nites per week on average for the last several yrs.
I’ve re-listened to Pale Blue Dot at least a dozen times.
He’s brilliant and an amazing orator, with beautiful articulation, voice cadence and flow.
Tell your kids to listen to this man, to read his work.
Let’s keep Segan alive
well said 👍
I agree 100%! I adored him as a little girl, then in high school watching Cosmos, and now reviewing his countless speeches. PBD is on my Playlist for meditation and to help me sleep. What a kind soul he was....
Why?
My favorite Carl Sagan quote came when he was asked, "it seems that through the ages humans have created a mythological framework involving a higher spiritual power, but with that being impossible to prove where does that leave us" and his reply "on our own" is so simple and demanding accountability that it's perfect.
Yeah....we are on our own!....accept it....and move on...
Impossible to prove? Of course you can " prove" it.
Don't believe shit just because some dick says it man. That's ultimate stupidity , and very sad in your case.
When Dr. Sagan died I felt like I lost my father. He was truly the most influential individual in my life and his books and television shows inspired me like no other. Its a shame that no one since has emerged to take up the challenge of promoting common sense, critical thinking,science, skepticism and responsible technology.
I think Neil DeGrasse Tyson comes close. Not to mention Lawrence Krauss, and Richard Dawkins.
Greg is obviously a moron troll, Left-wing libtard. There was nothing in my post that was political so leave your political opinions at the door because you wouldn't recognize true libertarian-conservative ideology if it smacked you upside your communist cranium.
Death To Liberalism
Sagan was apparently the father you rebelled against by rejecting everything he said.
Death To Liberalism There was nothing in your post about politics, but your username is an advertisement for your political beliefs. If you weren't expecting people to notice it, you're fairly naive. And you can do all the justifying you want, but Carl Sagan was a liberal, so his comment saying that it's odd that a person who hates liberalism looks up to a liberal isn't really that out of bounds.
Steven Reed I think these gentlemen were talking about liberalism (which is a capitalist ideology) not socialism or communism.
My father was a scientist that also passed away from cancer when I was a young child. My family fell apart afterward and I had a very tough time growing up.. When my father wasn't there, Carl Sagan was a great inspiration. I'm now grown up with a great career in egnineering and a deep belief in the value of science. Thank you for your gift Dr. Sagan.
So you made your Dad proud then. Well played.
Good on you!
Engineering is not science though, so what’s your point exactly?
What?
Engineering involves using mathematical equations and scientific knowledge to solve problems.
It's a type of applied science, a field of study that also includes medical and veterinary sciences.
Engineers perform research, design devices, structures and chemical compounds and test the effectiveness of their prototypes.
@@richardcampbell8498he said deep belief in value of science
Magnificent. A true Visionary of our times.
More relevant than ever before.
RIP Carl.
What an extraordinary man. A loss for us all the day he passed. Thank you Carl
The world is a poorer place without Carl.
I think so., but we will regret it .. i'm sure!
Stephan Cumberland but hell is a richer place.
... how's abouts, a richer world, because of him?...
@@savedbygrace8867 ... if you truly believe that, you are lost, for sure...
No there is always be some other pepole inspiring like him
I wish people didn't report some posts as spam, it's always a good thing to show how ignorant some people are in their comments. Offer a good rebuttal instead of resorting to censoring these fools.
It isn't spam, it's troll talk. Who knows what they believe ? They sense deep truth and then parasitically attach to it and try to get attention. To anyone who reads forums and TH-cam comments, they're pretty obvious. Rebuttals just feed the drama llama. The WORST thing you can do to those people, is just ignore them.
***** Not at all ! Sometimes decent people can use a little guidance out there in the troll-infested Web. Just like you, I am most definitely the judge of spam and trollhood in my life. The proliferation of parasites that came with the miraculous Interwebs must make us all better censors of things for ourselves. They die when we do not allow them to attach : through censorship in the form of ignoring them. They're one type of that variety of parasite that survives by wasting your time, and liking it.
heebiejeepie I agree. Don't feed the trolls.
***** And we also have one Captain Capslock. We should swap avatars.
***** Hey, I'm trying to not feed the trolls, here.
The combination of ignorance and power is going to blow in our faces.
Great frase.
Rest in peace, Dr. Sagan.
You're dearly missed.
hey u spelled phrayze wrong
Taken from the world way too soon. I watched his series Cosmos and learned so much.
R. I. P., Carl Sagan. 😥
"We are like butterflies who flutter for a day and think it's forever."
"The long dreamless sleep." One of the most powerful lines that he had ever said. We have been lucky to live in a day where no one ever dies digitally. We will never know the sound of Galileo's voice, but children in the future will see and hear this amazing man convey his most inward thoughts. A man for all time.
"But one thing that it has done, is to enhance my sense of appreciation for the beauty of life. And of the universe, and the sheer joy of being alive. ... Every moment, every inaminate object, and to say nothing of the exquisite complexity of living beings... Yeah, you imagine missing it all, and suddenly it's *so* much more precious."
"May you live a long time. Thank you very much."
@@inafridge8573 Very nicely written.
This comment is so fantastic. Thank you
I met my all-time hero Carl Sagan 3 years before his passing. Shaking his hand was one of the greatest moments in my life. Over the decades since I often feel sad about the discoveries on Mars and about the universe as a whole that he missed and how much joy he would have gained from that knowledge.
I often forget just how brilliant this man truly was...
He tried to warn us of what we are seeing & living right now.
I am 56 years old...Carl Sagan will be in my mind forever...I will be always thankfull for what has tought me....and the ones who made the series "Cosmos" possible....whatever....I'm just a guy somewhere in the world....but the world is my country....and science is my religion....
jhombergh of course it is. Look where science is taking us. Nuclear war. Shame on your religion.
Would you rather sit on a tree stump, get an ass splinter, and die from infection the next time you take a shit or live in the 21st century with access to nearly infinite knowledge, freedom, and the ability to relax instead of being a naked hunter gatherer?
"The world is my country and science is my religion."
Christiaan Huygens :) (I did my homework!)
jhombergh don't turn science into a religion
@@illdrumatik391 Shame on your ignorance for taking faith over facts.
I think Carl passed away not long after this interview. He was such a great man, so deeply loved and sorely missed by many people who never even met him. In a sense his energy still lives in in the cosmos in the form of binary digital information that people can still enjoy.
You are so much loved. Dr Carl Sagan. x
The interview was in May 27, 1996. He died December 20, 1996.
Dr. Sagan was prescient, he nailed the condition of willful ignorance we have today. We certainly needed this beacon of intellectual curiosity the past 27 years.
he was a doctor?
One of the most important men of the last one hundred years. He inspired many young individuals to pursue a career in science.
It's good to know that he was hopeful about his disease. Very upsetting to hear it today though. I'm so glad that his efforts live on and that I can read his work or see him speak on here any time. A very special person indeed
The best interview I saw I'm my life. Thank you Carl Sagan for all your efforts to understand our world. You are an inspiration to all humanity.
The best at what? Are you a Harry Potter-style wizard, a Lord of the Rings-style wizard, what? You are confusing my biology with your programming.
@@grovercleveland3387 Let me Guess. Harry Potter lives upstairs in your house.
@@grovercleveland3387 you should have just let this be.
The best even by, especially by todays standards
Oh I don't know. The interview with daffy duck that bugs bunny did in the 70s was pretty damn good too
If you close your eyes and listen to this, it's as if the man is sitting across the table from you TODAY. That is a hallmark of a truly great speaker and communicator.
This interviewer, Charlie Rose, was much more intrigued with the sound of his own voice, than he ever was with the opinions of his guests.
i've had an auditory hallucination, Dr. Sagan, of your timeless voice telling me about the Cosmos. You are missed.
Jayanth Kumar, we always hear him whenever we hear 'BILLIONS'. Such a treasure of this planet this man is. Wonderful.
RIP Carl Sagan
I am so sad to see such a brilliant mind died so young. There will not be another Carl Sagan in my lifetime. I felt so privilege to have heard him talk. I am blessed
Wish he would've seen the pictures from james webb telescope
We need more people like this amazing scientist, my grandfather introduced me to Carl Sagan when I was a kid, he used to watch Cosmos and I used to sit next to him and watch, and my mind just exploded. I certainly agree humanity is at a huge risk, and scientific way of thinking is the way to bring order back to this world. But there is also a reality behind all of this, unfortunately we have more poor people in this world than people with enough money to provide with education to their kids, and that is creating a huge amount of ignorance, in addition to all other stuff considered as first necessity, and those which are our future, are not prepared to handle it, that is what we should afraid the most at this point. A complete lack of values, living in a society who values more a smartphone than spending an entire day with their family... sad times are ahead.
Religious people who say "Sagan is in hell" oh man. The same feels you get from your deluded beliefs I get from reading/listening to Sagan. He leads me to truth, he helped me expand my mind. I'm absolutely disturbed that anyone could listen to this man so eloquently express himself and say anything negative. There is beauty in disagreement, and that beauty involves progress towards truth. I'm trolling because I'm not okay with anyone disrespecting Sagan to the extent they do on this video, not because I'm emotionally attached as much as I'm just truly disheartened that because he disagrees with you he deserves to go to hell. The logic there is why Sagan chose to speak out against Religion.
+Suzee Veronica ASMR Religion means zero. Sagan was about the truth, no agenda, I knew him well. My wife worked with him at NASA and Cornell. He believed that God might have created the universe, Spinoza s and Einstein s version, as I do, No daily intervention, no worship, etc. He thought that human spirituality was essential to deal with social ills, crime, drugs, child abuse, suicide, etc. He believed in alien life. He shared those views with Clarke, Hawking, etc. most scientists believe along those lines, including me.
Having an agenda, religious, atheist, etc. hinders objectivity, solves nothing. He had no respect for people who wrote fiction novels, whether religious or atheists, to fool people out of their money. He did not like those debates, science vs religion, the thought it took away from the scientist s dignity to argue such childish foolishness. That is why, only ex. scientists participate in those debates, they get more money, if they are famous, for one/two debates, than a scientist makes in a year.
I hope I did not offend you, your views, please?
carl violante I agree completely, I've studied his works very closely, I know how he felt about our species existential relationship with the universe. I study neuroscience, so for me, there are too many intricacies within our human brain that bounce off of the energies within our natural world to make such an ignorant claim that there aren't other higher powers at work. Carl stressed this, especially in his book Contact. Atheism and other ism's that claim to have some sort of answer are not doing themselves any justice. We do not have the mental capacity to grasp what could be out there, we are still an extremely young and naive species. Our prefrontal cortex's evolved so rapidly to have such awareness that it's baffling and can lead one to believe there is something else within our universe that is working with us, but there are also so many things that are not justifiable with such significance, such as natural error. I posted that comment to make a statement about why I feel it's so absurd to attack Sagan with such negativity, many are just not ready for what he was saying.
+Suzee Veronica
Not every Christians is like the idiots you see in Westboro baptist church don't generalize
Your comment about Carl Sagan & the proposed resting place where he should apparently reside in hell. It's very disconcerting that idiots who wish ill on a fellow Human it's genuinely very dangerous, are we to await a future society where any difference of opinion is automatically outlawed & monitored by the thought policing agency. I laugh at the level of narrow mindedness that exists and for the foreseeable future for the lack of ambition for the truth that surrounds organised religion. Thank you for your comments brilliantly insightful, Regards .
***** Untrue. The bible was written about 1500 hundred years ago, by scholars, for scholars, the fact that it became popular with common people is another story.
What eternal truths?
Tony
When logic prevails!!...The Logical Legend that was Mr Carl Segan. Wish he was still around.... he was a lovely, humble, conscientious human in this sometimes chaotic world.✌from London.
1986 my best friend's dad gave me his large hardback Cosmos book. It's beautiful. Continue to read Sagan's work, always mesmerized by space and exploration
4:08 - "If we are not able to ask skeptical questions, to interrogate those who tells us something is true, to be skeptical of those in authority; then we're up for grabs for the next charlatan, political or religious, that comes ambling along." -Carl Sagan
I was steeped in hatred and anger at the time I saw this. I very quickly had to set that down and listen to the words of this amazing man. He changed my life and made me see the connection we all have to one another and to the universe itself. We are all made of star stuff and I can't express in words how much I miss this amazing and irreplaceable person. Hating someone for something as ridiculous as the color of their skin or their faith makes no sense. It's time we start to see the beauty in all of us and celebrate the potential within us all.
You are highly ignorant about the goal of Islam.
@@WayneMarion Uh, I don't think so. I used to be a Muslim.
The magic of his language, the artistry of his words, they still resonate to this day. I'm so pleased and gratified that we have recordings of his voice.
I regret not knowing about this genius earlier. It would have been a revelation and given me courage to follow my heart and pursue a career in science.
Do It now, man
what were his grades in college?
Wow what an amazing , intelligent and inspirational man. He saw the dangers years ago- that we are facing today. RIP Carl
A brilliant man who still lives on through the Internet always inspiring.
I think it would be a great time for a movie about Carl Sagan.
Yep Yep -
You might enjoy watching a famous PBS special that was broadcast in 1998 across the nation.
Life Beyond Earth, by Timothy Ferris. Tim was the guy that made the Gold records for Carl Sagan to put aboard the Voyager spacecrafts.
It ran as a 2-hour documentary and it's beautifully narrated by Ferris himself throughout the full run.
You can just look it up, as it's available in TH-cam for free, by title and Tim Ferris's name, when you see it come up with a thumbnail icon showing the earth below photographed by the space station. I believe the runtime is 1 hour and 48 minutes.
It has something in there for everyone. I played the 2-hour special for my students when I taught astronomy as an adjunct professor in 2004 at a local University here in Portland Oregon.
At the end, as they're sending out a message to space to ask for a reply from any possible aliens listening out there, just before the credits begin to roll on the screen, it reads - for Carl Sagan.
Carl Sagan, you were taken from this world too soon. Thank you for your tremendous contributions to science and to the fabric of the human race as a whole. You are sorely missed.
God tock him for his false teachings
truly a great man and blow to humanity to not have his wisdom, but his words will always remain.
I wish he would have lived long enough to see what an amazing tool for spreading knowledge the internet has become. I would have loved to get his insight on that.
*****
Ya, but if we continue to teach people how to reason and not just regurgitate information, I have enough faith in humanity that logic and compassion will eventually win.
Chris Turnblom or maybe I should say "compassion tempered with logic".
***** you're probably right. I try to believe that people want to learn from humanities mistakes and think independently but realistically, most people will fight, with vitriol, anything that contradicts their world view or comfort zone.
I guess the earlier comment is something I WANT to believe.
***** what would you suggest?
***** same goes to you, deal with the fact that we are all unique individuals, stop trying to make everyone think like you. Let it go and be happy for what we have evolved to be, to think that everyone will have a scientific mind is like talking about some fairy tale.
This interview will eventually be seen by billions and billions of people.
Sadly, I doubt it. I am here to view and place this on my county political page. We shall see.
Sagan said he never actually says, “billions and billions”, but, rather Johnny Carson used that expression in a skit referencing Sagan. Carson loved and admired Sagan.
Extraordinary human. Humble with great wisdom and knowledge . He will be remembered for ever.
Carl Sagan will NEVER be forgotten.
True gentleman and a scholar.
The world needs more Carl Sagans before it's too late!
The world from what? From Sagan's god of nothing? The world is free now from that dumbass but his followers still live on wanking off to their god of nothing and orgasming to its power even though nothing has no power but wankers don't care.
@@2fast2block Can objects exist without there being a space for them to occupy? Then there is one power of void right there.
@@forsakenofgilead5209, whatever point you're trying to make, explain it by how it fits with physics.
Real science says nothing does nothing. Real science says if there was something there already it must fit with the evidence of what we know. We know the 1LT says there's a conservation of energy. It can change forms and neither can be created or destroyed. Creation cannot happen by natural means. The 2LT has various aspects, one being the universe is winding down, entropy. Usable energy is becoming less usable, so at one point usable energy was at its max. This all points to a supernatural creation, by a supernatural creator at a certain point in which matter, space and time were created. When I read how it can happen otherwise, ALL the fools resort to science-fiction. Once a supernatural creation is accepted, then the next step is finding proof of what supernatural power did it.
Physics proves creation had to be supernatural.
@@forsakenofgilead5209 ...
oh, yeah... TYLER... but, you conveniently forget ! THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS NOTHING... TYLER... space is not a void. Space is... FULL... of energy. Light and stuff flows through IT. Space is a containing vessel that IS HOLDing a universe... TYLER... together... TYLER... in... IT... SEE... here, look 🍳 with this poached egg
MAGINI-FIRE... thingy !!!
SIGNED BY...
the ROCK OF PHAGES ...
@@2fast2block Can we agree the Scientific Method is applicable to some fields of inquiry, and at least now, not applicable to other fields? If we cannot agree that this is the case, then why are scientists wholely ignorant about entire subjects of knowledge?
We lost so much with Carl Sagan. There are no outspoken individuals like him anymore. I hope that more can approach things with skeptical thinking like this.
I do, but trump morons with trucks key my EV... Shame that I'm a USMC vet, and they're idiots who never had the courage to serve.
An unmatched clarity of thought and expression. He has influenced my thinking since the first publication of Cosmos. I miss him
Carl Sagan faced a lot of challenges he did his best to deliver the meaning of science in a very simple way but during 70's and 80's more people were narrow thinking even the tv interviewer didn't understand him well enough. Carl Sagan was True and Great scientist.
Excellent interview by Charlie Rose who knows how to ask pointed, sensitive and thought provoking questions.
True! That is becoming quite rare these days.
Especially starting at 7:15 through 10:00, as this is where most people, [biblical literists especially] have trouble reconciling with what is being discussed here about understanding the scientific methods. Carl Sagan describes it so well.
But he's a bit of an interrupter.
@@musket-hc1fc
Yes. He was an interrupter. It's an annoying style of a journalist carrying out his/her daily routine with smarter individuals.
The man was a wonderful genius...I could lisen to him all day..
God bless you Carl...
At 19:04, when discussing the possibility of his death, you can see him glance at the camera. I think in that moment, he was acutely aware of how the world would miss him. He remained humble, but he wasn’t wrong in the slightest.
RIP Carl. Great man!
Oh, so Carl Sagan is in hell you say? It's time for me to start sinning again.
+Alex Shi
God will forgive you if you believe so you can rape, kill, murder and torture anyone you like! That is as long as you are a TRUE Christian though! If you are not a Christian then you are evil no matter what type of person you are and no matter how nice you are to others and you deserve to burn in hell!
Tim Slee Thank you. i swear all the cool and smart people are in hell.
Alex Shi Yeah! :)
I was just spreading gods way of love!
+Tim Slee You forgot the genocide, rape, murder, jeolousy, arrogance and downright dishonesty. Oh wait! You're too lazy to read.
***** Haha, you're funny man. XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
I love and miss this genius of a man with all of my heart. His series, Cosmos (and esp. the reboot with Neil deGrasse Tyson) is indescribably thought-provokingm, astounding and thoroughly engaging. His wife, Ann Druyan, is equally as brilliant and a phenomenal writer.
Dead at 62. Damn. Damn. DAMN!
Thanks for keeping this available.
What a man. I was an admirer of him and his work whilst he was alive and still am, some 20 odd years after he passed. Mesmerising and sorely missed.
i hate the fact that i was to busy watching stupid movies instead of this guy on pbs or vhs or dvd when he was still alive
It's impossible that you watched DVD's when he was alive...
“Science is more than a body of knowledge, it’s a way of thinking. “ just amazing 🤩
And all inclusive. Challenging the unknown.
There is quite a bit that science can't explain
@@bennieknape4857Science will never explain everything. Only religion professes to do that, but that’s all conjecture based on fantasy narratives
Yeah but what's that supposed to mean exactly ?
@@thomasjefferson1010 To me it means that the human brain is capable of thinking many ways. A person can think scientifically, artistically, spiritually, socially, culturally, politically, competitively, compassionately, economically, etc. Thinking scientifically is one of many ways of thinking.
A legend having wisdom with clarity!
As a kid I grew up with Carl Sagan but I didn't appreciate him as much as I do now and now he is so much more accessible, at least video's of him anyway.
But now I have Neil deGrasse Tyson and he the the Sagan for my daughters generation tough she is only 6, but I am appreciating him enough for the two of us for now.
But I wonder what Carl would think of the world now, so much of what he fought for has failed while so much of what he worked on lives on.
He almost makes me want to believe there is a heaven.
Carl's influence is even greater now than it was when he produced Cosmos. Now he is more recognized and I wish he could see this.
I introduced him to my girlfriend and she enjoyed his show quite much. She even made a poster for me with one of his quotes :)
I'm right there with you.
I gotta wonder, Tom, that your despair of your daughter comes from the tv politics of fear and confusion. Don't worry so much. She's online, and couldn't give a fig about tv. ;p
theGhoulman what on earth are you talking about?
yeah sure.. bore me a little more.. No, you are just another hypochondriac..
It hurts to watch this video. I loved this guy and the way he made science so interesting and understandable for lay people like myself.
We all should be like him....😢how great man...the legend
Wish one day every human will Sagan so cares about humanity,the existence and the future😢😢
Carl Sagan is my absolute hero..
One of the greatest man on our planet. Deep respect! He will live on forever as quality always does. And he will inspire all coming generations for sure
If we don't destroy ourselves.
@@jeanscuderi It won't happen because God will destroy those who are destroying the Earth Revelation 11:18
What a wonderful , sentient being . I miss his presence on this Earth .
Immeasurable loss of this intelligent, eloquent, kind, humorous man. A great thinker and teacher. Wonderful interview, just not long enough.
Amazing! Thanks for uploading this! Carl Sagan was always one of my biggest inspirations and I love astronomy! R.I.P. 🙏🪐
If I could go back and do it all again I'd be a scientist. Such a cool career, I commend all of you young budding scientists out there. Stay curious!
Another way to put it: "Sapere aude" - dare to understand. Thumbs up!
education is the best provision for old age
Absolutely
being a scientist sucks in the free-market, most physicist i met went to insurance companies/banks... or went into a complete non research field.
"Being a scientist" doesn't mean working as a Scientist to make a livin in a society. A Scientist is any man of Science, which means a Human being who learnt this tool among others to understand where and why he is there. I may not work as a scientist in the future, but as a student, I will learn every bit of Science I can before leaving school someday.
Awesome interview. He died 6 months and 3 weeks after this interview.
Carl you effected me so profoundly in my life with your work. RIP!
Two engaged interesting intelligent men holding a learned conversation, speaking in full sentences, no one shouting, no one going for the one-liner, no one trying to speak over the other. How refreshing.
I was to young to internalize what this man was trying to impart to the world, but now I do all I can to spread his vision for us.
You hit the nail on the head, my friend...that is exactly how Carl will live on...in all of us who appreciated him.
Are you retarded?
Some people should live forever. Carl beening one of them. he was an amazing man
@paul w So what you're saying is he's basically like you !
True
He’s still with us - just like everyone else, he, too, was stardust.
Life has value because we don't live forever. You will never value something that you cannot lose. Please learn that important life lesson. No pun intended.
This was an amazing interview with Carl Sagan he was a man of great belief, and his knowledge of the the universe ,was always a pleasure to listen to him speak, I wish I had met him when he was alive there are so many questions I would have liked to ask him about space and the universe, RIP Carl sadly missed but never forgotten 🙏🏽
Thank you so much for uploading this
The world became a darker place when he died. He was a bright Light in the Darkness that is now upon us. I miss him.
Carl Sagan was such a beautiful human being, we miss him so much, a great scientist and humanist, and always so generous to his "opponents"
He certainly changed my outlook on life,and I thank him for it.
It's almost his 88th birthday here from where I am writing this comment. I really feel like he had a beautiful way of bringing the universe down to the common man. We miss you Mr Sagan.
Great human. Thank you for this xx
He was a poet, a dreamer as well as a scientist. I miss him so dearly, my childhood hero ...
He was a pedophile. But I hope he is loved in heaven as much as he was on earth for your sake. Always need good vibes
@@thomasjefferson1010 A bit too easy to throw an accusation at a dead man don't you think? What are your sources?