Pokemon Scarlet and Violet REVIEW: The Best & Worst Pokémon Games:
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 มิ.ย. 2024
- In this video I review Pokémon Scarlet and Violet.
[NEW SHIRTS]: truegreen7.creator-spring.com/?
-PATREON REWARDS - / truegreen7
-JOIN - / @truegreen7
-TWITTER: / truegreen7
-INSTAGRAM: / truegreen7_ron
-T-SHIRTS! - teespring.com/stores/truegreen7
-My Podcast! - • We Started A Podcast! ...
Some footage from:
Mixeli
Gamer’s Little Playground
Nintendo Unity
Meloo
Shirrako
0:00 Intro
1:39 Performance
5:14 Visuals
7:39 Gameplay
11:47 New Pokemon
13:15 New Region
15:43 Characters
17:09 Story
20:02 Music
22:08 Postgame
23:21 Conclusion
#Pokemon #Truegreen7 #pokemonscarlet #pokemonscarletviolet #pokemonviolet - เกม
![อาจารย์ยอด : ลุงแว่วเล่าเรื่องผี [ผี]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fd2Qsy4dqpM/mqdefault.jpg)
It's not a question whether it is the best or worst, it's a fact that it's both the best AND worst game so far, and I love it.
true
Facts I love the game
even with the bugs, the gameplay and how good the game is overshadows them.
@@trle964 This game will be remembered for its superb story, superb gameplay and
bugs
@@factomaniac1138 exactly LOL, imo even with the bugs its become one of my top 5 favorite pokemon games, and we cant forget the MUSIC
something I really appreciate about this game is how the game allows you to build an actual relationship with the legendary. normally you get the legendary in the late game and not everyone plays the postgame so some people don't spend enough time with the legendaries to build an attachment to them. this way, you have them right at the beginning, they show personality, and you utilize them throughout the story in a way that isn't OP
Yeah, and also it feels like your it’s caretaker in a way, just defeating the titans to get it back to full health just feels extremely rewarding. Not only that but every other challenge feels rewarding. I don’t care what people say I had such a blast playing this game and even started a second save cause I just can’t get enough of it. It really captures that magic of playing Pokémon games on your ds or gba ad a young child. I absolutely adore this game and props to gamefreak for making all of this in only 3 years!
I mean Sun and Moon kinda already did this before
@@jeremiahgreen5632but this time it was executed better. The whole game lily goes "nebby get in the f***ing bag". It's only at the alter of the sun/sun where u see your cosmic friend turn legendary. Here this dragon bike eats sandwich🥪 & provides itself as a souped-up Cyclizar being able to do all means of travel.
They are the worst games in terms of performance and it’s frankly insane for a game to be permitted to release in this state.
That being said this is some of the most fun I’ve had with modern Pokémon in such a long time and the HOLISTIC experience of playing ScaVio was so emotional and meaningful.
*scarvio
*or LetLet
I always think this but ifGameFreak had just payed for a couple extra employess to nicely polish the graphics this game would be perfection. It has such an intense and emotional story that it often frustrates me when i hear people calling it trash because of the graphics. Yes, I understand the performance is bad but I think thats the only problem and its quite frankly taking the spotlight and making a lot of players ignore the incredible characters (except Nemona, you bunch of simps) and the amazing story, not to mention the dialogue is hilarious.
@@Ditto.007 I don't think 'a couple more employees' could have saved it. It's an unfinished product, not as broken as 2077 mind you, but the hardware suffering under the asumed unoptimised coding.
I like the main storyline, the twist with the missing professor is a highlight, as is the absence of an 'evil' team. But it gets me that there are so few Spanish things in Pokemon Spain. We get Brazilian Carnival Dancer, Haitian Hoodoo Croc and hyperhumanized Catgirl for starters. Japanese salaryman in the arena and top four, Chinese cursed objects for legendaries, ninja and kabuki/luchador in starfall.
Besides the small bursts of story along main arcs the world feels barren. With all other traines being optional, this just adds to the feeling.
Especially considering there are mandatory parts of the story that run terribly and they're inescapable. There's no way a game test failed to run into the glaring flaws.
i never explained bug or glitches in my Pokemon Scarlet
Scarlet and violet did the “the friendships we made along the way is the real treasure” trope but they did it right
True!
In the most literal sense lol
@Choas_Lord_512 just say you don’t have good taste
@Choas_Lord_512 Penny’s storyline is her being a caring friend and wanting to keep her friend out of trouble?? How is that a bad character
@Choas_Lord_512 I don’t understand why you felt the need to reply you aren’t changing my mind I’m not listening to someone who clearly didn’t read any of the dialogue in the game
I lost my dad to cancer in 2017 and I just so happened to choose violet. I also put my 16 year old lab down just a couple months ago. Arvins story had me bawling. Just an incredible story, incredible pokemon design, and by far the best music/endgame in any pokemon game.
Sorry for your loss
Sorry for your loss buddy, here is your virtual hug (if u want it)
Really sorry for your loss
@@arshu_parshu1999 thanks brotha
@@Ditto.007 I appreciate it friend
Team Star has to have the most engaging battles imo. It was so freaking cool when they sent out their Starmobile
I love the little twist that GameFreak did where the proffessors were "bad" and the "evil" team were good
And then there’s the music, that shit didn’t have to go so hard
@ChaosLord5129i at first thought i were just a mr negative but after seeing you in multiple comments i think yur just stirring up drama
Glad you called out the Academy Tournament theme, after spending hours throughout the game listening to the Academy theme while taking classes to get all the character interactions, it was so gratifying to hear a battle theme based off of it, and it's honestly probably my favorite. It does such a good job taking a motif you've heard a ton and making it new by going through so many different emotions and styles.
Tbh I didn’t really experience as many of the bugs that everyone else apparently is besides the occasional visual goof, so my only real complaint is the poor performance (and to a lesser extent no level scaling but I can live with that) All in all still a very fun time
I think you have to push a bit for the game breaking ones, I also only got bad visuals.
@@claran3616 worst I got was my character’s arm glitching during the final team star cutscene which kinda ruined the mood, as well as my pokemon occasionally launching themselves off the balls during picnics
@@kyleheck5363 One of mine fell(slowly)off a cliff at a picnic. And that stupid pokeball in the middle of some rooms. That's got to be a coding thing.
@@claran3616 oh yeah forgot about the random magically appearing pokeball lmao, saw that one a few times
@@kyleheck5363 I don't know much programming, but I would guess it started as a way to mark the reference point. "We need every thing coded to walk around this point so it looks cohesive" Then they forgot to truly delete their marker.
A VERY levelheaded review. Perfectly realistic with the issues but gave it credit where credit was due.
It's such a shame that Scarlet and Violet were released this way. Game Freak had FINALLY gained the public's trust in them again with Legends Arceus, only to have it damaged again, right after. At this point, yearly releases need to stop. TCPi NEEDS to allow Game Freak to have more time to make these games. This they keep releasing unfinished games, Pokemon will forever be a laughingstock in the general publics eye.
Honestly, this might itself be a big break. Yes, Pokémon is self-sustaining in the worst way possible, but perhaps an argument can finally be made to The Pokémon Company that even Game Freak wants to do more with Pokémon and that the release cycles should not be so strict so that the mainstream games are not basically 3 year-long code jam projects.
If not that, then the almost-guaranteed disaster of Gen 10’s Pokémon game will convince them.
I am (again after Arceus gave me some hope back) pessimistic as hell but the fact that this thing has 73% on Metacritic (plus strong review bombing, but that happened even with Sword/Shield) gives me at least SOME hope. Sword/Shield had 80% which was already a considerable drop from Sun/Moon (86%) but 73%? that is getting DANGEROUSLY close to the magical 70%.
Sadly.. More than likely there's a 0% chance of that happening, TPC relies on the games releasing so that they can make new sets for the tcg, start up the new season of the anime, and just make new merchandise based on the new pokemon. So sadly delaying the games are probably never gonna happen,
@@iantaakalla8180 The more I see people describing this game and more context that's provided the more I feel that this game get comparable to Sonic 06
@@KazShiro I haven't play Sonic 06 but Scarlet/Violet is easily one of the most inexcusably rushed and half-finished game I have EVER played. is it still fairly fun in many aspects? yes. but that 73% on Metacritic is maybe even a bit too generous.
We had to put down our oldest dog back in July. He had cancer and was slowly withering away. Some days, he’d seem to be doing better and some days, he couldn’t swallow or walk. So needless to say, Arven’s story with Mabosstiff really made me super emotional. If this game would’ve been released any other year, it wouldn’t have hit me as hard.
The bigger issue than any of the performance is the fact that you can't wear anything but the school uniform imo. I love customizing my character in pokemon games and felt like this game was a bit lacking as a result. Which sucks because the character models are more detailed and customizable than ever.
Everything else outside of the performance was mostly awesome. The games aren't perfect but they're a hell of a lot of fun and they push Pokemon in a good direction.
As someone who also likes to explore every house and every nook and cranny, I was also disappointed by the lack of interiors. In general, there were a lot less of the little touches from interacting with the environment than Pokemon typically has, which was sad for me. Other than that and the performance, I loved it though!
Yea I noticed that’s a recurring thing with the last few games
Your explainer in the beginning saying having fun doesn’t mean you’re ignoring the issues. That’s exactly what I’ve been telling all the homies.
This was my first Pokémon game ever, and I loved every second of it. I bought the game after the patch to fix the glitches, and I haven’t had any performance issues at all. These games made me a new Pokémon fan 🥺
Same! I bought the game 1-2 weeks ago and holy fuck what an emotional rollorcoaster. No game has ever make me cry but listening to the credits roll I actually cried.
My main issue with the games was how, while the games are open world, there is little reason to do things out of order, as you still need to go back and do the skipped content, which will be very easy now that you are such a higher level
I had the opposite problem of accidentally skipping gyms so I'd be fighting a gym leader close to my current level cap, which presented quite a spike in difficulty.
This mechanic in particular makes it hard to do much of anything until you've collected most of the badges.
It REALLY annoys me that Game Freak would rather patch that duplication glitch, instead of the objective flaws like the performance and bugs. I hope they get their priorities straight and patch all or at least most of the bugs and glitches, but I'm getting my hopes up.
I don’t know if this already sent or not, (wifi issues), but I’d blame the Pokémon company, not game freak. The Pokémon company is the company making demands and setting deadlines, and the reason game freak had to put out such a rushed product.
To be fair, it may have been an easy fix for the duplication glitch and a much harder and longer fix for the performance, so they priorotized what they could fix asap for the first patch. It's what I'd do as a game dev - fix what I can as soon as I can to get _something_ out at least. (Well, actually, I'd like to think I wouldn't let a game go out in that condition.)
@@7thlittleleopard7 Exactly. A glitch due to unintended or incorrectly input code is much easier to correct than an issue with overall performance. One could take weeks or months of testing and optimization, and the other could just amount to rewriting a line of code. Not all flaws are created equal, nor are their fixes. It's kinda disingenuous to say gamefreak would rather do this instead of that, when one solution could be patched up within a couple days and the other would require extensive testing and the time to actually finish the game so it can as it was supposed to, which, even then, would naturally mean that if they were fixing the two side by side, one would be ready to go way sooner than the other one
The team star tracks are one of the best in the franchise’. The grunt music slaps, as good as Galar’s gyms and don’t get me started on the bosses. It’s probably my favourite music in Pokémon. Great vid. Excited for top 20 music.
As a long time sub (since your unova music tier list), I've always appreciated your channel as being positive about almost every aspect of pokemon. Frankly, I experienced many framerate issues and bugs with s/v which really soured my experience and I am thankful that you touch on the highs and lows like this for both the positive side and negative side. The new mon designs and music are great and I'm looking forward to your music ranks!
I loved these games inside and out. Great characters, great story even if it was a little bit sad and the best rival in years.
I doubt you mention it, because no one ever talks about it, but you can also do mini "missions" with Arven, Penny, and Nemona after you do the post game stuff. It's not much, you just chase them around the school and talk to them learning about their development after the main story, you can unlock their rooms to hang out in. Plus you can redo the bug and grass gym trails. In my opinion the times olive roll is a lot more fun as well as more challenging than the actual gym trail. But from what I've seen in my game and online the grass challenge might be bugged cuz most people can never find the last one.
if you define the champion by being the final boss battle, then Geeta isn't the "champion". The "champion" would then be the professors. They did say they were champion-level.
If you look at the list of past champions in the game, the professors name is actually found there.
@@V-Jes The hall of fame in this game isn't a list of past champions. As Clavell states, it's an honor given to students(or former students) with outstanding achievements
Great hearing your summarized thoughts about the new pokémon we've gotten, Ron!
But if you were to ask me this new dex easily surpasses that of gen 8 and I've defended the pokémon there a ton. Paldea's pokémon design wise just vibe with me so much more!
Can't wait to see your video talking about them all though!
As a gamer, it's extremely difficult to enjoy the game because you're playing a game with smooth performance then you start up pokemon and the poor performance is very noticeable. And you can tell that they are simply unfinished.
It's such a crazy relationship with he game. Conceptually, it's everything we've ever wanted in a Pokémon game. However...the lack of polish is just so obvious. Still having fun playing it.
Always look forward to hearing your thoughts on the new games!
I miss the story mixing with the gym challenges as it felt like the anime going through them "as the story continues" like ash and co
Although I am only half into the game, you said this all so well! I've been having so much fun playing Scarlet. Every weekend I do a rival battle with my brother. Since we both work full-time we both progress slowly and it's been great fun.
Very good review! Honestly, you summed everything up really nicely and I share many of the same sentiments. This was my favorite Pokemon game ever by a considerable margin and it's a shame that not everyone can enjoy it due to performance.
I can't wait for the Top 20 Soundtracks in SV, revisiting all the best music from these games with someone as passionate in music as you are is sure to be a treat :)
I definitely agree with you on a lot of topics! The rivals were some of my favorites in the series and hearing them all chat with eachother in Area Zero was the best! It's kind of like what they wanted to do with the XY friend group, but completed. Personally, the post-game of the gen is pretty boring and I can't find myself wanting to play unless it involves shiny-hunting...BUT! The story from the main game really makes up for it because I got around 80 hours of gameplay before completed the main story. So it's definitely worth the money I spent! One of the best pokemon games ever! The only complaints I had were some of the pokemon designs being so... bland. I was super disappointed when I found out the long-awaited dolphin pokemon is just a dolphin. I know it changes into hero Palafin, but I think they could've made the design more dynamic. The other designs I was disappointed in were Flamigo, Pawmi evolving to just stand up, bramblin evolving to become slightly bigger, and Iron Jugulis. I do really like all of the starters and chose sprigatito! The starter signature moves are very fun too. Now I will patiently await DLC... super excited for more...
Thanks for this review Ron! You weren't scared to criticise the flaws and yet again praise the games for it's high points. I also agree that you don't need the perspective of a "true gamer" or needing to compare these games with others or playing other games in order to play these games, it just feels so unnecessary to me.
Your stance on the reviews online are greatly appreciated too, i have seen many rating this game either a 1/10 or 10/10, it's ridiculous seeing so many reviews like this, SV is both the best (In terms of gameplay, story and characters) and worst game (In terms of performance) and i really appreciate your honest review.
Also i am not saying that everyone shouldn't criticise or enjoy what they want, but please do this in an appropriate manner and not shove opinions in front of others, i strive to have a peaceful community as possible and TrueGreen 7 seems to have created a positive and fair one.
The champion fight could have been so much more memorable and challenging. Have her lead with glimmora and still terastalize it (so the player is unlikely to one shot it and thus probably set up 2 layers of toxic spikes). Then kingambit can be her final Pokémon, benefiting from the full possible boost its ability can give. Heck, give some of her mons phasing moves to play into the entry hazard gimmick and indirectly counter setup sweepers (her espathra's ability already plays into this design space).
Her fight could've been on par with Cynthia's in terms of difficulty, but they seemingly handicapped her in order to play up how much more of a challenge Nemona was going to be.
Video Idea! Designing new paradox forms for pokemon, that would be very interesting
I really like how you articulate your thoughts, thanks for the great vid! ps. got some favorite new pokemon?
Can't wait to see your tier lists for this game
Not level scaling was a shame. I ended having 2 teams since I didn’t know the intended level. So I broke out my lower level team when I figured out the area was lower level. It only burnt me once when Nemona was a much higher level than the area I was in when she challenged me.
Gonna put this on my to watch list for after I’ve finished the game xD
You're right, the Ace Tourney theme really made me feel Dendra's energy once I finally got to battle her. Vs Team Star Boss is my favorite though, kept me pumped even while losing multiple times to Eri.
Finally someone talks about how much of a banger the Ace Tournament theme is, either my favorite or second favorite with the professor's battle theme
One of the neat things about the music is how each area’s theme can transition so seamlessly into its respective wild battle theme. When you start a battle, all that changes is the camera angle. You’re in the spot spot, and the same people and Pokémon are still there. Sometimes foolishly walking through the clash. But they’ll nail that one soon.
Performance, visual glitches, pop-in… these are all things that could conceivably be patched. Story and atmosphere cannot. The gym/league atmosphere seems lackluster after Gen 8, (also, could we get a rematch with Geeta with Glimmora first and Kingambit packing Sucker Punch last TYVM) but Team Star set up their bases in some beautiful locations, and I love the red cliffs where Klawf live. And they can obviously create atmosphere where it counts… Area Zero. The waterfalls, the crystal sands on the wind, the mysterious soundtrack… the creators of Myst would be speechless.
There are so many cherries on top. Great new Pokémon like the Charcadet and Varoom lines, amazing naming like Smoliv, Scovillain and Nacli, seeing grown men cry over Mabosstif, adorable Tatsugiri and Greavard shenanigans, and the unbelievable twist about Clive. Oh, and that part with the professor was aight, best plot ever including Black/White, whatevs.
Didn’t really get any bugs in my game, storyline was cool and inmade alot of screenshots. I enjoyed every moment of the game
"im the type of person to go in every building." Then how can this be one of your favorite regions. There is literally nothing to do in the cities and routs besides catching pokemon and doing the gyms. Above that the region has no real identity or lore. Its just a wild area with cities that all have the exact same stores and zero interesting npc's to talk to. Like what are you gonna be nostalgic about in terms of the region?? "Awh yeah remember that town with the....................... sandwich shop where you entered and only got a menu screen, good times." Remember that snowy mountain which was really big, but didn't have any interesting areas to visit or anything to do besides catching the copy and pasted pokemon."
pretty well rounded review, good job.
So my only gripe (glitches aside) is thst it needs more dialogue with NPCs, houses and stores you can go into, more detailed world and biomes, and whats an open world without side quests granted by NPCs. Imagine you pass by a town where the protective fence is dammaged and taurus have run wild causing mayhem in the town you have to fix the fence and drive the taurus out of the town unlocking some areas of the town like the pokecenter, mart or something else. Theres so much potential of what could have been and its also a good sign of things to come.
I respect your opinion on the future paradox Pokémon but I would've much preferred something to like what you guys did in the art challenge that resulted in the Whale Vaporeon. That's inspired as hell. Way more so than just Iron this or Iron that. But great counterpoint to the past ones just being feral, i suppose at the end of the day the biological and monstrous elements of Pokémon is what draws me in, but it doesn't haev to be what draws everybody in!
I'd love to see more new evolutions for two stage pokemon, anhialape has been an incredible design and upgrade to a really cool pokemon for 1st gen
Ceruledge and Armarouge look like plastic toys though. Weird in a game where metal is so good looking for the armor pokemon to look plastic.
My review of the game? 10 out of 10. You can avoid almost all the glitches just by playing the handheld vertion, and it’s really fun!
Same here, these games are way better than people are saying they are.
Great video as always.I hope Gen 10 Pokemon will be about Greece if there will be one, like gen 9 that is about Spain, because I AM GREEK .
Great to see that there's a person around here who doesn't blame fans for having fun with S/V i hate it when people blame other people for some games short comings i know these games have flaws on yeah they do but it's still an engaging experenice i've ever had i cried inside while playing some parts of these stories i feel like these games story is better then SwSh and i love SwSh
I agree! The Acadamy Ace Tourney theme is great. It reminds me of Mario Kart music. My personal favorite is probably Arvens though. Such a bop!
everyone talks about how good the gameplay is but i....disagree. it's hard to not compare it to Arceus since it came out the same year and LA beats Scarlet Violet without even sweating in every single aspect :/ i was very disappointed the entire time playing, with the exception maybe during the arveen cutscenes
The biggest addition for me this gen is the breeding. Its soooo so so easy to breed and get egg moves this gen compared to any other gens. Biggest downside was the not scaling levels. The poor performance is just secondary
To be honest, the region is kind of a letdown.
I love modern Pokemon, but this... well, I did have fun.
The fact that nothing from PLA was used is a letdown, the stories other than Victory Road weren't fun, a LOT of the new Pokemon are uninteresting or bad e.g Tinkaton the overused, any of the Paradox Pokemon, the starters, etc, and the music is just so clearly made by Toby Fox that it doesn't feel like a Pokemon OST and instead feels like an Undertale OST (except the Team Star Boss theme and the Quartet of Ruin's theme. Those were amazing).
Also, Penny's theme is bad. It actually hurts my ears (no, seriously. It actually hurt my ears when first listening to it during Penny's battle) and is just horrible.
Also. Fuck Arven. Arven's an asshole to Koraidon/Miraidon and the Dragons are good bois.
Even I enjoy 'Acacia' by Bump Of Chicken than 'Celestial' by Ed Sheeran. Voice acting is the best in B2W2 with Homika singing "Dogars". Rock music and symphonic music work in any journey-themed series. I can even take trumpets from Houen.
12:40 someone agrees! I actually think some of them are good in the ancient paradox side, but so are the futuristic paradox side, like iron thorns for example, that thing looks bad ass!
Gimighoul and it's evolution plus finding them like korak seeds was amazing. Area zero and the MUSIC 🎶 my gawd. The bugs existed but so much overpowers it
Haven’t had this much fun playing a Pokémon game since 2010 (B/W). Thought I had grown up and was just jaded, but S/V proved me wrong. I love this game with all its flaws. The glitches are endearing in a way lol.
I’m excited and jealous of those experiencing this game as children. Nostalgia for this adventure is gonna hit so hard in 10 years.
Before SV, I had only played Emerald, Pearl, Let's Go Eevee, and Shield. (side note, I've since watched people doing challenges in Pearl and... I don't remember playing the game at all, despite Palkia being my favorite legendary for years)
I finished Violet in three days and went to buy Scarlet four days later. The first time I hit the Elite Four theme, I absolutely loved it. It had me amped for the battles _instantly._ Area Zero just blew me away. And the climax of the story was *so good.* I'm one Pokemon away from a living dex (I need to catch some more randoms to finish trading from Violet to Scarlet and nab my Slowking), which I've never bothered to do before (actually, it'll be my first complete Pokedex altogether). I'm looking forward to restarting Violet once all my mons are safely in Scarlet, so I can try again with a new team.
The bugs are... honestly, terribly frustrating. But I can't help enjoying these games A LOT. Here's hoping for more patches to iron this stuff out.
I think you're right that some areas of the game feel underdeveloped, like the towns not always feeling distinct enough, and the lack of significant landmarks with lore about them (first thing that came to mind, Pokemon Tower in Lavender Town). My thinking is, they focused a lot on the radical changes to how the game works, and with more games from here, they'll get better at bringing forward some of the most fun stuff from past games into this new open-world format.
Finally, I'm hoping in the future - like you brought up - the big battles scale to the player to _really_ give the "any order you want" some weight. My thinking is, some minimum succession (to push the player to level up - and maybe a maximum succession to avoid hitting 100 before the final battle) and otherwise scale the opponent's ace to the player's highest level mon (either on team, or altogether) give or take a few levels depending on the opponent's attitude to being hard on trainers, and then scale the rest of their team slightly down from there. Then after first try their team locks, so you have a level-appropriate challenge on first try and if you lose you can grind for the win, encouraging strategy without significantly punishing players who are bad at it or just don't want to, since an appeal of Pokemon is its wide accessibility.
I love your review you represent my perspective and I did exactly what you did I followed the exact layed out path which is one of my bones to pick we shouldn’t have to follow a path in an “open world game” so our experience is the most optimal the games should scale to you and we shouldn’t have to deal with unoptimized games. That said the music is banger I love the majority of the designs and the 3 story paths are amazing. I don’t like the future forms much they are okay but why are they robotic? The past ones yes perfect Exactly what I wanted. I also don’t like sandwich making and camping I prefer the way galar did it.
Nice vid!
Probably the best review I have seen of Scarlet and Violet. Everyone else focus so much on the tech trouble that you couldn't trust their opinions.
I played through the game straight and while it did have a few issues it was playable and enjoyable. Best story of any pokemon game!
That's because the tech issues tarnish everything else, it IS a deal breaker for many people, hence the reviews on Metacritic...if you don't understand that you are blinded by fanboyism.
@@FarAwaySoda I am a fan but I also played the game all the way through and while I did have some issues, I didn't have as many as most of the reviewers seem to have. I have also played it through now 3 times and will be starting another run doing a 2nd nuzlock of some type. The issues themselves are crappy and the game shouldn't have shipped with much of these issues it has not stopped me from enjoying the game.
@@Brad2411 well keep on justifyimg Gamefreak, we will never get a finished game at this rate, congrats on endorsing a crappy product
So, from what I've seen (can't really afford to play it at the moment), I think the bugs and glitches are major enough to disqualify Scarlet and Violet from being the best Pokemon games. Where it ranks though, is tougher to place because everything else is good to great, but again, the bugs and glitches muddy the water enough to where it's hard to judge the game purely on its merits. Maybe if I get a chance to play it I'll have a better idea, but for now this is my opinion
not really. people overblow the glitches by a lot, and as someone who has played it, the only thing that really affects your playthrough at all is performance, but even then, it wasnt something that made the game unfun. i mean, at least it doesn't have a glitch like brilliant diamond where you could skip to cynthia's room in less than 20 minutes. scarlet and violet are very enjoyable and fun games with very good stories, and performance and glitches don't ruin that.
bro the bugs arent even THAT bad. its not preventing you from playing the game at all and the fact that it upsets people is beyond me. the game is so good that it overshadows the bugs. and honestly the bugs make this game so much better bc its funny. like i havent laughed so hard at a pokemon game
It's not the glitches that constantly drag the game down. It's the terrible performance. I shouldn't need to avoid going into cities or looking towards the center of the map unless absolutely necessary because they make my game unbearably slow
@@grunkleg.3110 I would put performance with bugs and glitches, especially what you've described. I'm not saying that this is the worst main line game we've had, I just don't think it can be the best.
@@arvincastillo158 I haven't seen a lot of Twitter threads outside of what Yong Yea covered, so I don't know what fans are actually saying. This is mostly based on what I've seen from playthrough's on TH-cam. My opinion might change if I get a chance to play it, but this is my initial reaction to what I saw. I still think it's a top four game, and it's story as well as gameplay definitely are a plus. I just feel like the bugs+perfomance issues take it down from a phenomenal game to a great game
Great review but it would really help if u played a few other rpgs to sorta pickup on ways other games handle certain aspects and compare them to aspects in pokemon
Bro when the redesign Pokemon will come? I'm eagerly waiting... I'd be really happy to see my art recreated by u ❤️
So are the Pokémon games your only Switch Games? That's really unique if so. Never heard of someone only playing 1 game series like that. Great video as always, keep it up!!!
You said that because the gyms don't scale you have to zig-zag around the map. I did Grusha fourth, not knowing he was the last gym, so I was very over leveled for a part of the victory road path
in terms of new pokemon, imo Gen 9s roster isn't nearly as strong as Galars pokemon, Paldea has a ton of stinkers imo. But the good pokemon in Gen 9 are some of the best Designs we've gotten in a long, LONGGGGGG time. Also the Box art legends are the best ones since palkia and Dialga fight me
I'm currently halfway through my 2nd Playthrough (deliberately choosing to do the quests in a different order this time), and for me the fun elements to the game vastly outweigh the graphical/performance issues. I hope Pokemon Home connectivity comes around sooner rather than later, as that will just add even more replayability to the game.
I'm surprised how much I like scarlet, haven't noticed anything major glitch wise. The graphics are lovely and I am tempted to get violet for another play through with a different team 😅
When I was growing up and playing pokemon, my dad thought the music was annoying so I never played with the music on and 15 years later, I still don't.
One small problem for me is that they took away the vibrate effect for the healthbar after a super effective move was hit on it. They did it in sun and move and it felt right, because it really showed the power of the move.
To me, the worst performing parts of the game were the lakes and oceans. Good god did they lag.
I’d also like to point to the school- an instance of map that should be running the most smoothly- running like molasses. Nothing is more immersion breaking than being about twenty feet away from something and seeing low poly models or the inner mesh of a model or something. The janky animation of the students and Cyclizar on the schoolyard, seeing a glimpse of the interior of Hassel’s model- these sorts of things were incredibly offputting. I’m fully convinced that the only things the game fully renders is anything within about ten to fifteen feet of the player. Everything else instantly jumps to low poly jank.
I absolutely love this game and want to play so badly...
Easily one of my favourite games in the franchise, along with gen 5.
Never played Pokémon before. (Ever) So I’ve been new to this type of game.
I’ve really enjoyed it. I Didn’t think I would (considering how little I know about Pokémon)
so far I’ve played 60 hours or so with no glitches or massive bugs. I think it stopped by itself maybe 3 times in my whole play through, and I’ve only noticed a slight lag in the game when there are large groups of creatures/people.
I still have much more to do with Tera raids, filling the Pokédex, finding a way into the shrines. (Maybe even battling all the gym leaders again)
But I actually really hope they do more games like this ……it might attract more people that are new to the franchise (and I would play another game like like this)
This could change if i ever get around to playing first-hand, but even if they didn't have the bugged out to hell aspects, i don't think these would be my favorite games or ones i consider the best. But there certainly is a lot to like for sure. Just some of those small things that make pokemon pokemon to me that aren't here definitely dock it down conpared to others. Though i share that feeling with a lot of recent beloved titles in franchises i love that are dipping their toes in the open world pool. It's a fun shift for some but i truly hope the trend mellows out soon getting a bit tired of hearing about it.
Regardless, I hope that release schedule gets changed cause sheesh.
I loved Scarlet Violet, right now on my second replay I’m making three separate teams for each path it’s fun so far
Warning: this post does contain spoilers for the games, reader discretion is advised.
I think is the best review I've ever seen of this game. Most reviews only focused on the graphical and audio glitches and never on the gameplay. As for my feelings: I will admit this game has problems. The only major glitches I found were mainly graphical stuff like shadows only rendering in certain angles, and there was one when I was in Area Zero and Arwen was just slowly descending into the crater in the center. I thankfully never ran into the Elite Four theme 10 second loop glitch. For a game that advertises itself as a game that you can challenge the gym leaders in any order, they don't scale levels for not just gym leaders depending on what badges you have, but also for Titans, and Team Star bosses. And that's something even Pokémon Origins addressed. I picked Brassius first, and I thought he was way harder than Katy, who was intended to be the first Gym Leader. Same thing for Mela who I went after first instead of Giacomo. What was wrong with the level scaling? And also, they clearly intended for you to do all the tasks in a certain order, see I did the Titans first, before winning all the Gym Badges and beating all the Team Star bases. So, I was unfortunately spoiled on Cassiopeia's identity. I won't do so here, but anyone who did the same thing I did, can see where I'm coming from. I also thought Geeta was by far the most pathetic Champion in the series, the game does a fantastic job building her up as the top Trainer in Paldea, she's called La Primera, I half expected her to be on par with Steven or Cynthia/Volo in terms of battle prowess. Instead, she felt more on par with Diantha, another easy Champion.
But enough negativity, here's the positives. I loved the story; the soundtrack was kickass. (Levincia might as well be my new favorite town theme in the whole series. Sorry, Driftveil City, you have been dethroned!) I liked how the Elite Four are much more involved in scouting out potential competition. Instead of just four Trainers who have to stay in individual rooms waiting for a challenger to show up. And I loved the tragic story of Sada/Turo. They had the makings of your typical Pokémon main antagonist: grandiose ambitions, absence of ethics, terrible parenting, you know the drill. But having that professor die as a result of their hubris was just shocking and it makes you feel horrible for Arwen. Especially after everything he's been through. I honestly can't wait to see what the DLC has in store for us next year.
So, in conclusion, the game has problems that could've been improved on if it just had more time in the oven, but did I have fun with the game overall? Yeah, of course.
When even casual players notice intense framerate drop and performance issues, you know it's really bad. Pokemon Scarlet and Violet just needed a few more months in the oven and it would've been perfect, I'm still disappointed that this is the state they release it in.
More like a year, half a year to polish most of the bugs and another half year to add some kind of level scaling.
@@milonchello1643 It takes 3 hours to design level scaling for the bosses and gym leaders.
First, sorry for any english mistake, brazillian guy here. Whatever, my way to describe scarlet and violet is simples:
Pokémon scarlet and violet are the best pokemon games ever made, but they are lock in a rough package, making hard to reach the wonderful things game freak did.
I have the Scarlet version and my game has crashed SO many times. Although it's annoying, it was a good game. There was a lot to do and the open world was seriously OPEN, I continuously find places I haven't been through completely. I wish there was more interaction with characters in the towns but I do appreciate that anyone worth speaking to has a yellow speech bubble and everyone else has white, I learned very quickly not to waste my time on them. I miss going into buildings, I'm not a fan of having only shops, and then just having a menu instead of physically walking into them. I understand why Arceus had the catch mechanics that it did and why they didn't include it in this game but I do hope it comes back in the future! Finding out shinies didn't make noise anymore was so disappointing!! Especially when you are running on your legendary, pokemon don't spawn fast enough so im sure people are constantly missing shinies all the time 🥲 I was never into shiny hunting in previous games, but Arceus made it extremely fun and made me want to play for hours post story.
I wish they included more activities to do with friends, they marketed that as a major part of this game and you can barely do anything, it was basically just added so you could catch their exclusives yourself instead of trading, and even then, your friend has to be near you in the open world or the pokemon won't spawn. I wish they gave an interaction menu when playing with friends with features such as trading, battling, physical actions like dancing, hugging, etc.
The map view could use 1 extra zoom out option before showing you the overview, raid glitches need to be fixed as well. They really tried to make their characters inclusive and I appreciate that; we have plus size characters, muscular characters, androgynous characters, different skin tones, names from various places, BUT WHAT ABOUT OUR CHARACTER? I've been waiting years and years to finally be able to customize my person and have them be chubby and I guess I'll have to keep waiting.
When I started playing I have to admit I was so disappointed, I kept comparing it to Arceus and that was my issue, not the game's. Once I was able to put aside my bias, I had a great time and I actually really love Scarlet/Violet. I hope they take their time on the next game and iron out all the wrinkles, as well as take real players suggestions and preferences into consideration.
I'm going to delay picking this up. I can't support a game released so unoptimised like this - though I'm glad for those who picked it up and genuinely enjoyed it.
I'm also disappointed with lack of level scaling of any kind which is tied with your progression of the game's three main quests. Unless it's obvious in how you are meant to beat the game in the order intended by the developers then I know I would just do my own thing and would just steamroll certain sections when I have to go back.
Again lack of any difficulty setting upsets me which shows a lack of respect to more mature players of the series that have been with it since the beginning. A turnbased JRPG is probably the easiest game to implement a difficulty setting e.g. higher levels, max IVs and EVs, better movesets or movesets which apply a certain strategy, and more.
If those three things are fixed I would definitely pick it up now or when patched - but Nintendo/GameFreak/TPC aren't a type of company that would release such large patches like this.
Edit: Also lack of voice acting. Many of us have seen the fan edits and it's so much better with voice acting even if its nothing groundbreaking in itself but credit to the VAs and producer. Especially after they teased us with the gym leader trailer that had voice acting albiet in Japanese only.
All I want is a game that meets modern standards and I think most of the above are reasonable requests for a game released in 2022.
You're not really missing out. Story is boring. Performance is really really bad. The new Pokemon are kinda cool.
Nintendo is laughing in our faces and still raking in the money...
@@Jay-sd9ye it's the Pokémon company. Nintendo knows how to make good open world games unlike game freak.
Should do a episode of get the community to draw pokemon from the same description
In terms of performance,visuals and all that kind of stuff,I feel like Game Freak should do a Pokemon Ultra Sun/Moon type of thing and recreate Pokemon Scarlett and Violet with even more depth,less lag,no crashing and better graphics. By that I mean graphics that are more clean and such.
Loved the review
I fully explored Area Zero before finishing the plot. On foot. It was grueling. Plenty of items and Pokémon around, though.
The cliff textures are almost unbearable, there’s no variation, just the same homogeneous texture, no moss, no brush, no erosion outside of area 0 (the map is like 50% cliff, how have there been no landslides?), no trees on more than a 10 degree slope
It looks like a glorified topography map
Will you do a music ranking video?
Great review. Fair and to the point.
I kind of find the gameplay disappointing. There isn't anything that makes it feel like an open world game that isn't just the open terrain. It's basically just non-linear pokemon, which isn't great because that's not what open world is imo. Open world is about finding secrets, cool collectibles with nice information about lore, crafting and resourcefulness, side quests that expand on the world-building, and just general freedom of doing things your way (like for example riding a horse to a castle that doesn't allow mounts). But even with that there are mini-games that could be pokemon specific like pokemon interactions that would fit right in too (I don't consider spraying your sudowoodo with water to be bonding per say). I just feel like there is nothing other than the pokemon formula to really add to the gameplay, but maybe that's just me. It just feels empty.
Despite the linearity, I feel like prrvious games like BW2, ORAS, and HGSS have more gameplay than SV.
i was praying you'd give this game a fair review, and you did so well. 100% agree with what you said.
although i think it is my favorite Pokemon game of all time
Creatively, it’s probably one of the best Pokemon games. In terms of the quality of performance and other tech categories? Awful to the point of sometimes feeling like the game is punishing me for daring to go to the desert during the weather that happens to the desert the most, or going into Tagtree at all. It’s nigh-tortuous to go from the best stories I’ve seen in a Pokémon game in a long time straight to the slowest areas I’ve ever played, several times
For me I mainly have nitpicking complaints about S/V since the main issues of performance is known and held by everyone. I mainly have some menu and option nitpicks with auto heal being a good inclusion not actually being a full auto heal because you can’t use auto heal to revive a fainted Pokémon or heal status conditions and in the bag menu if you wanted to just manually heal your Pokémon they took away the ability to use multiple of the same item. So I could understand if you got rid of it if auto-heal actually fully auto-healed but it doesn’t so it requires me to go into the bag and confirm every single revive or other item I want to use.
The menus are also really slow and especially the clothing menu which takes awhile for the items you want to see load in so changing clothes takes along time and just navigating the box and other menus just really sucks.
Only other nitpick I have is with overall music, the music didn’t really catch me not that I wasn’t a fan it just didn’t pop to me as Galar’s music. I liked the gym theme but compared to what we just had in Galar it doesn’t hit as hard but I would say with Galar being very battle focused and Paldea being adventure focused I guess it makes sense. I did also experience the bug with the Elite Four theme so I was really disappointed by that a lot until I heard the actual song. This region Elite Four has to be the elite four that you learn about and care for the most since in most games you meet like 1 or 2 or never meet any at all until the end. So slowly meeting these guys as you continue to do the gym challenge and especially having Hassal as your art teacher was fun to see, not to forget about Larry pulling double duty as both Gym Leader and Elite Four in the same region is a first and totally fits the joke with Larry.
I really like the design of alot of characters in this game and the gym leaders and Elite 4. I enjoyed the new designs for certain types like a streamer being used for electric with Iono and a rapper for Ghost with Ryme lots of cool designs but the characters overall aren’t the best because you don’t interact with them too much with Iono, Ryme, Grusha and Larry being the stand outs.
My biggest nitpick and complaint revolves around Greeta. She has to be the most hyped up champion every in game. Everyone talks about her and how strong she is, some people like her and other people don’t like her at all. She’s La Primera, the Top Champion but battle was a let down, her theme is cool when I was actually able to listen to it but her theme is eh, she has some cool Pokémon but others are very confusion and a simple change of order of her Pokémon with lead and ace would have made her battle better. Is she the worst champion I would say no because Diantha to me is still worst champion character wise but Diantha at least had a challenging battle which I cannot really say for Greeta.
I overall really want more games like Scarlet Violet and hope that this is the direction Pokémon will be going. As someone who was ok with BDSP because they never advertise the game as another other than faithful remakes of D/P and enjoyed the game and difficulty of it and as someone who is in the minority of not liking Legends Arceus at all. While I understand the appeal of PLA it’s not for me and it’s not where I want Pokémon to go because I do not enjoy a lot of what they introduced mainly on the battling side of Pokémon because I don’t want them to really change the battling system because to me if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. I do enjoy some of the other mechanics but don’t want them to really change a lot of what we already have just improve on it. I want Legends to stay in its own series of games and that’s it really
I didn't encounter many bugs, only minor stuff like clippings and some frame drops, so I really enjoyed playing these games
That being said, developers should not be rushed like that, Pokemon games need to be given more development time, with enough polish those could be among the best pokemon games ever, if not the best
I agree on the take of less S tier mons
In gen 8, my S tiers were Dragapult, Inteleon, Rillaboom, Cinderace, Cursola, toxtricity, regidrago, regieleki, and eternatus. This is not including hisuian mons, which I think all of them are great. If we include those, I would include hisui Samurrot, ursaluna, and basculegion
In this game, it’s tinkaton, Skeledirge, gholdengo, the ruin legends and maybe iron valiant. A good amount less.
But the final battle before the post game was SO GOOD. One of my favorite battles of all time. I fought it with equal level Pokémon, and I almost lost. Had 30 hp on my last 3 Pokémon
Personally I had no technical issues while playing through scarlet. The only thing that could kinda count is npcs walking in a low framerate but that happens in a lot of games and didn't effect anything. Hands down scarlet is my favourite pokemon game (so far, I haven't play legends arceus yet but I have a copy so it might change. I doubt it though lol.) I loved the story and koraidon is my new favourite pokemon. Also I got a shiny dondozo which made my month
I think corporate just wants new pokémon games out asap regardless of quality so they can make the bulk of their money selling new Pokémon merch. I'm having fun with Scarlet, but I can't help notice all the issues and lack of innovation. It's important to keep key aspects of Pokémon in place, but if they're just going to turn the main series into garbage... well forget it! I love Pokémon, but I hope they at least patch the game and come back with something completed, polished and just better overall next time. They can't rely on the brand name forever.
I hope that eventually they’re gonna hit themselves in the foot if they keep shooting at it.
I caught a Basculin early thanks to a glitch. He swam under a bridge while I was taking my Golduck on a walk and Basculin ran into him
The past pokemon were just all "feral" i think is more natural than saying pokemon will evolve to machines/robot in future and the naming of future mons with just iron + _______. 🤷♂️
Your video informed me that I played the whole elite 4 with the music bug. You can’t play the elite 4 again in the postgame. I will never get the opportunity to play it properly because of the bug. My fiancée had it too and we both were surprised at how bad the song sucked for no reason.