Bc its not live lol. Live tracks often have a lot of breathing and mistakes in it, and that’s ok. SM needs to let them sing live bc when they did, they ATE like brooo
Something called breath control exist, Idk im usually always one to say oh it is precorded, but some members sung the backup vocals louder then the main, Their choreography isnt too powerful where I feel like if they practiced often, they wont be out of breath@@cynosure2
If someone ever said this is pre-record, nope. You can hear a bit flaw here and there along with the dance move. it just all of them are very stable and talented
SM (and a lot of other companies) pre recordings have flaws in them to give off the illusion of a live performance. It’s IMPOSSIBLE to sound this good while doing this choreography 😭 i’m a MY but please can we think a little here !
9 หลายเดือนก่อน +43
@@pshenha been looking for this kind of comment.. this is CLEARLY a pre recording.. MYs cant be that delusional can they?
I was looking for a comment similar to mine too! Their voices stay the same volume, and it’s smoother and less shaky compared to their other live performances-and they are literally dancing their heart out in this stage. If kpop fans can’t tell the difference between live and prerecorded, then we are doomed lmao 🤧
Same. I was looking for comments to call it out too. This is a clear pre recording. I'm shocked by the amount of the people they've tricked. must be kids.
Do yall remember when SM wouldn't let them sing live? Now we know why? They are the vocal queens unbeatable they had to least give a chance to the competition before crushing them all
Even for their prerecorded stages they're still superior cause they can actually SING, i mean it's still them singing and doing all those high notes and everything
No, These girls always use pre-recorded voices, they rarely sung live like in coachella and you can notice the difference, they don't have much physical resistance
@@meeehbi3530why you're lying lmao ? coachella was live and their spicy come back they ssang live most of the stages + during the festivals they do too
Hatter gak percaya bett klo gue bilang ini live . Soalnya gue sempet denger nafas Gisel . Bener aja kan mereka live😂 . Saking sempurna nya live performance mereka Ampe hatter gak bisa bedain mana live mana lipsing 😂😂
gue liat bbrp video lain dn ini bener' murni mr removed tanpa edit, dan gila siii sejauh yang gue tonton suara aespa sama babymonster pling stabil berasa lipsing
Pre record means they go to record few rehearse stage first. Like all . They hv to rehearsal few time .. its not that they pre record the song they nv sing. .
This is pre-recorded. They’re barely breathing hard or at all really. There are a lot of moves where you would at least hear some disturbance in the singing. Not saying they should be struggling but there’s an almost impossible chance that they’re doing the choreo and it sounds like they’re standing still. Even at the end, they sound as though they just started. Ps. This isn’t out of hate, I really like Aespa and each of the members individually. I just see a lot of incorrect comments. Also I’m very much aware of their talent, like come on. They’re talented as hell but two things can be true at once: they’re talented and this is prerecorded.
if its prerecorded or live, its fine. at least its not straight from the studio recording 😅😅 but still, aespa is SM. and SM vocalists are top-tier, so i wouldnt be surprised if this was live. but tbh, with those kind of bouncy movements? i rlly think they'd sound a bit shaky... buut if proven wrong then this means aespa's a vocal powerhouse.
![[CLEAN MR Removed] aespa - Armageddon | Mnet Mcountdown 240530 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3hjcmyL5wyg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[R(ae)cord] aespa 에스파 ‘Drama’ Recording Behind The Scenes](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JGAbMfbJiLk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] BLACKPINK (블랙핑크) - Pink Venom (핑크 베놈) MR제거 220827](/img/n.gif)
winter and ningning voice is crazy wow.
No wonder. SM Town Concert in jakarta they were singing very LIVE. SO GOOOOD
Is this sarcastic or what?!
@@oneoftherandompersoninYT nope. that's true
😂
@@oneoftherandompersoninYTnope, i was there. They sing LIVE like they are so good FR! I went for NCT and TVXQ but i was amazed by aespa
Idk about what u said but i think its pre recorded@@KxxSxrx
You wouldn’t think even the rappers would be able to sing so well… aespa really are amazing
Because KARINA and GISELLE are both Lead Vocalist level
WINTER AND NINGNING SLAYED THAT HIGH NOTE OMGGG
ALL OF THEM ARE SO STABLE
AND NINGNING WINTER VOCALS IS FIRE😭
they don’t sing live
they are super talented but it’s not live here
They’re not singing live here bro 😭😭 but when they do sing live they sound amazing
Ningning vocals are so stable omg
Ningning omg she slayed ....I mean all the members slayed but her vocals omg
3:08 that part is so heavenly. It is literally the same as the studio ver. Winter is so dman stable. Vocal queen indeed
It was prerecorded :(
@@lucy_channdo you understand what prerecorded mean? The performance was recorded hours or day before but they keep singing live when it's recorded 😅
@@nuriindahsari5133no, the vocals are prerecorded
@@nuriindahsari5133yeah but they aint dancing when its recorded so basically its different from singing live on stage
@@anatalias who said they ain't dancing when it's recorded? Do you mean it's recorded separately?
Winter is sooo stableee
it's crazy how smooth Ning's runs are. Main vocal indeed and you can always trust SM to have those vocalssss
this is insane, four of them were so stable like how? incredible! 😭😭
They are the group with most stable members for a reason
Bc its not live lol. Live tracks often have a lot of breathing and mistakes in it, and that’s ok. SM needs to let them sing live bc when they did, they ATE like brooo
Something called breath control exist, Idk im usually always one to say oh it is precorded, but some members sung the backup vocals louder then the main, Their choreography isnt too powerful where I feel like if they practiced often, they wont be out of breath@@cynosure2
@aetherr5755watch nmixx’s stage practices they have amazing stable control
NINGNING VOCALS LIKE OH MY GOOOOOOSHH
If someone ever said this is pre-record, nope. You can hear a bit flaw here and there along with the dance move. it just all of them are very stable and talented
Yeah I can hear them mispronouncing a little here and there.
SM (and a lot of other companies) pre recordings have flaws in them to give off the illusion of a live performance. It’s IMPOSSIBLE to sound this good while doing this choreography 😭 i’m a MY but please can we think a little here !
@@pshenha been looking for this kind of comment.. this is CLEARLY a pre recording.. MYs cant be that delusional can they?
I was looking for a comment similar to mine too! Their voices stay the same volume, and it’s smoother and less shaky compared to their other live performances-and they are literally dancing their heart out in this stage. If kpop fans can’t tell the difference between live and prerecorded, then we are doomed lmao 🤧
Same. I was looking for comments to call it out too. This is a clear pre recording. I'm shocked by the amount of the people they've tricked. must be kids.
SM이 ningning을 pick한 이유가 있었네. 닝닝 힘든 춤 추면서 안정적인 노래실력 대단하다ㅎㄷㄷ.
당연하지 녹음한걸 틀어왔으니까;;
@@user-29dddggg피어나 검거
ningnings vocals are unreal 😍😍
Their vocals are insane. Even the main rapp and main dancer has very stable vocal. Ningning and Winter on fire 🔥🔥🔥
Do yall remember when SM wouldn't let them sing live? Now we know why? They are the vocal queens unbeatable they had to least give a chance to the competition before crushing them all
Bet you haven't heard the new girl group Kiss of Life
@@gra.cie27Aespa is still better
@@gra.cie27haven't, and probably wouldn't
@@gra.cie27they are good but aespa is another level
@@gra.cie27theyre good but theyre not stable. Belle’s voice breaks a lot. Theyre still very good and definitely one of my fav groups
Aespa vocal is on other level ❤❤❤❤
닝닝 목소리 공간감 미쳤다ㅏ
Haters will say shit but aespa will slay as usual
Karina ur so unique
Ningning😘 aespa❤
Omg Ningning vocals🔥🔥
Nobody talking about Aeri? Hello her voice is heavenly
Winter so stable 😭
SM has the best vocal teachers I swear! From 1st to 5th gen. They never fail
Ningning!!!!!!!!
VOCAL QUEENS
Man, they are so fucking stable. It is almsot the same as the studio ver.
though it is prerecorded, they’re solid and remain the best vocal group this gen (to me)
I saw them live earlier this year and let me tell you their vocals are out of this world amazing.
@@hellfire4youespecially ningning and winter😭
OMG❤ VOCAL QUEENS!!!
이번에 네명 다 비주얼 리즈 찍었던데
라이브도 미쳤다 정말..
At first i thought it was pre recorded but you can actually hear them breathing and pronouncing some words different
Even for their prerecorded stages they're still superior cause they can actually SING, i mean it's still them singing and doing all those high notes and everything
They prerecorded it especially for "live stages" so it seems that way.
I think they sing over prerecorded tracks, which is much smarter than using studio tracks or using prerecorded alone.
its crazy how ning ning voice is THAT SMOOTH
와…. 다시들어도 개소름끼쳐서 온몸에전율이😢😢😢 에스파가 단연코 4세대 실력원탑이다….라이브이렇게할수있는 걸그룹 누가있는데..
엔믹스랑 공동 1등..
아이들
This is pre record
Nmixx
이거 라이브 아니야... 라이브ar..
닝닝 1, 2 부터 윈터 받아서 끌어올리는것 까지 소름이다 진짜
Best 4th gen gg vocal wise imo🥰😍
Even though I'm the YG stand, I'm more prepared AESPA for Coachella than that girl group
Sm vocals never disappoint.
Fr
@@Shanaznctzenpfft this pre record
@@meandyou7492the point still stands listen to any of their encores
1:49 from ningie's "I'm a stunnaaa" to rina's part is sooo satisfying! 🔥
They are not lipsync😮
And the vocal is very stable
SM talents are always stable :) but this is really AWESOME!
Winter tetep stabil n enak bnget 😍👏👍🥰
aespa its so talented fr
vocals ATE
for the comments saying its pre recorded, listen to 1:40 of ningning singing, theres a brief moment of cut off, for sure pre recorded wont have that
also on winter 2:12
I´m not a fan but i would say this is quite impressive, i coudn´t believe it but now i´m convinced.
omg so stable i love them
Aespa don't need back vocals. Thanks God there's still hope for live vocals in kpop
와…ㄹㅇ 네명 다 개돌았네.. 윈터 성량은 걍 ㄹㅈㄷ
근까 …. ㄹㅇ 네명 다 엄청 잘해..
AR인데…
뭐래 라이브 인증 됬는데 ;
Ningning 🔥🔥
No wonder they were so mad SM made them lipsync like wtf these are so good
ningning～ ❤❤❤
와 이거 라이브였음?😮😮 립싱크인 줄 알았는데 소름😨😨 역시 믿고 보는 스엠😊😊
나도 AR 인줄 알았는데 라이브라니..
숨소리와 중간중간 성량 차이가 나는 걸 보고, 이 그룹의 라이브는 진짜 최고!
Wow they def super stable they need to sing live always ❤
에스파는 4명 다 노력하는거 보여서 좋다
They sound way better than I thought they would. I didn’t think they ever sang live.
They sing live in their concerts all the time...
They can sing . Doesnt matter its pre recorded. All of them can sing.
Yeppo winter so stable🤍
Is this real their vocal when live? This is Unreal stable and perfect...😭
No, These girls always use pre-recorded voices, they rarely sung live like in coachella and you can notice the difference, they don't have much physical resistance
@@meeehbi3530why you're lying lmao ? coachella was live and their spicy come back they ssang live most of the stages + during the festivals they do too
All of did great but winter wow
Todas estaban cantando en vivo omg QUEENS 👑
Hatter gak percaya bett klo gue bilang ini live . Soalnya gue sempet denger nafas Gisel . Bener aja kan mereka live😂 . Saking sempurna nya live performance mereka Ampe hatter gak bisa bedain mana live mana lipsing 😂😂
Yups bnerr... Gw jg dgr nafas mreka
gue liat bbrp video lain dn ini bener' murni mr removed tanpa edit, dan gila siii sejauh yang gue tonton suara aespa sama babymonster pling stabil berasa lipsing
@ashaarazhelia wey aespa sama baemon pre recorded
OMG KARINAA
Karina fighting!
So stabil they voice Aespa, Winter,Karina,Gisele,Ningning 🔥❤️
All four them are amazing! ❤❤❤❤
경지에 오른거 아니냐;; 앉아서 부르는거같애 투어한번 돌면 실력 향상이 압도적이긴 하네
Seharusnya yg pernah audisi sama trainne di SM gausah bingung "kenapa sih mereka mau nyari yang gimana?" Lah nyari yang kaya begini 😊
stan Aespa for better life.
OMG NINGNING 😮😮😮😮😮
얼굴도 넷다 최고리즌데 넷다 라이브실력까지미쳤다.. 에스파는 진짜 깔게없다.. 대체 못하는게뭐냐 이미친소녀들아….
근데도 까는 애들 있음 안티들 ;
역시 aespa!!!너무 멋있고 안정된 목소리!!다른 그룹과 레벨이 다르네요!
OMG IS SO PERFECT😭
god bless SM's dedication to picking vocal talent 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲
Ae girls are so stable that haters thought they are lip syncing. Because their faves cannot sing stable to save their lives.
Embarrassing, not even live.
@@WinniePooh33it is live, their voice sounded better than recording. Sorry to break the fact to you, you must be surprised, but this is SM
These girls rock !!!
No me sorprende lo buenas q son porq siempre lo supe ❤❤❤ talentooo
They’re so perfect, that I thought it was lipsync
I’m sorry 🥹❤️
I love it..❤❤❤❤
사전녹화 맞는거 같은데 라이브 잘하는건 아는데 이건 숨소리도 안 들리잖아
지랄
부분사전일수도
카리나 i bring i bring 할때 살짝 바람소리들리는데 이건뭐에요??
it's not the same plzz =))))))))
@@효준-x2iㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 미안한데 저런 춤추면서 이렇게 보컬만 깔끔하게 나올수가 절대 없음 에스파 4세대 보컬로 두손가락 안에 들어가는거 완전 맞음 다만 이 mr제거는 확실히 라이브 아님 그 바람 소리는 그냥 사전녹음 할 때 b 발음을 좀 더 세게해서 그런거임
Winter amd Ningning's vocals are just 🔛🔝🛐
Pre record means they go to record few rehearse stage first. Like all . They hv to rehearsal few time .. its not that they pre record the song they nv sing. .
AESPA I LOVE YOU. YOU WILL NEVER DISAPPOINT ME AND I WON’T BE ASHAMED THAT MY FAVES CANNOT SING.
Kenapa gak mereka yang ke Coachella
they inherited the stunning vocals from mother of kpop live AESPA AND RV FOREVERRRR
Winter💟💟
I thought this was a pre-recorded stage!!
it is.
It obviously is.
it is
Its is but they sing it live
They don't need backing vocals if they sing so perfect. JUST WOW!
Vocal queen
I’m a stunnaa~~
WINTER
OMG 🤩💯 And the whole team is perfect
This is why I'm so proud of aespa despite all the negative comments about them ❤ They still shine ✨
at some point i even forgot this was mr removed 😭
It blows my mind that people can't tell that this isn't live vocals
THANK YOU I NEEDED THIS COMMENT TO REDEEM HUMANITY
NO WONDER THEY ARE SO SUCCESSFUL ! they truly deserve everything and more
This is pre-recorded. They’re barely breathing hard or at all really. There are a lot of moves where you would at least hear some disturbance in the singing. Not saying they should be struggling but there’s an almost impossible chance that they’re doing the choreo and it sounds like they’re standing still. Even at the end, they sound as though they just started.
Ps. This isn’t out of hate, I really like Aespa and each of the members individually. I just see a lot of incorrect comments. Also I’m very much aware of their talent, like come on. They’re talented as hell but two things can be true at once: they’re talented and this is prerecorded.
Its prerecord but they still sing it live!
What does this mean? So they sing live or not?
@@flynnryder21No
진짜 개잘한다
if its prerecorded or live, its fine. at least its not straight from the studio recording 😅😅
but still, aespa is SM. and SM vocalists are top-tier, so i wouldnt be surprised if this was live. but tbh, with those kind of bouncy movements? i rlly think they'd sound a bit shaky...
buut if proven wrong then this means aespa's a vocal powerhouse.
What? Amazing
Wow that’s amazing so stable
I´m not part of the fandom but I think their voices are amazing