I'm glad SM lets aespa sing live now, look at how they are slaying and flourishing, pure vocals, they defs deserve daesangs this year, drama after drama, just wow
The company won't wasting any their artist's talent without prices. That's why they were holding the girls voice during the covid era. Even if you notice their first promotion week, always gonna be not live for the AR because they knew the girls voice are worth high price. It's still business afterall. Now with many audiences around the stage, of course the girls would be showing their skills, i mean depends on the money deal as well. It's SM, of course quality are number one despite how crappy they dealing with their artist management
@@nana_forlifeNot live actually. They definitely are great singers but staying perfectly on pitch all the time while dancing is not humanly possible. It's unfortunate to read so many comments of people believing this is real. There are other performances (ex: KWORLD DREAM AWARDS uploaded by this same channel) where they have sung live though, they still sound amazing but not this perfect. From the first verse, a real live stage would sound a little bit shaky due to the movement, this doesn't at all.
SM QUALITY Although it is the company with the most haters, it is undoubtedly the best with vocals, raps, music and visuals, there is a reason they are #1 of the Big4 And the creator of Kpop
Not really live, I suggest you watch other mr removed videos. Voices are supposed to be affected by movement, but their voices sound 100% stable hear...
0% live lol. If you watch the original performance they are clearly lip syncing. Nothing wrong with that, every idol does that for their first stage of a song, pretty much. It's just weird that they did "MR removed" for that.
The def improved in stage presence and facial expression tho I remember they looked like robot in black mamba and next level era Now they look more enjoyable and having fun at stage ❤
Is it bad I like both of them? Cuz I don’t see why I would hate either aside from the shady owners and higher ups. The artists themselves seem like pretty decent people regardless of an image that might need to be kept. Regardless of that, idk I feel like I just enjoy music to the point where if the performance made me have fun and enjoy then it’s good in my books. Maybe different for you, not trying to offend just giving my thoughts. Have a good day.
@@Cinnamoroll842I like HYBE and SM groups, but to be very honest the way you just brought it up would start a whole argument in another comment section. I’d rather we all just enjoy the music that we are able to see and listen to without the extra BS yk? That’s just my thoughts though, not trying to offend. Hope you have a good day.
Love how they're finally delivering on both live vocals and performance energy. It took them a while to get the balance right, but now they'll be unstoppable, especially with this amazing new music. This is what I always wanted to see from aespa. Happy to say I'm a fan at last after years of hoping they could be enabled to deliver on their potential, both in talent and group concept. These new songs remind me of Ashnikko's new direction, I love the combination of a futuristic cyber concept with this ancient-witchcraft-ritual energy.
Not live actually. They definitely are great singers but staying perfectly on pitch all the time while dancing is not humanly possible. It's unfortunate to read so many comments of people believing this is real. There are other performances (ex: KWORLD DREAM AWARDS uploaded by this same channel) where they have sung live though, they still sound amazing but not this perfect. From the first verse, a real live stage would sound a little bit shaky due to the movement, this doesn't at all.
like with AR! You can check out some of their performances at Korean universities to see 100% live. They do much better even there. They are seriously the best.
![[CLEAN MR Removed] aespa - Supernova | Mnet Mcountdown 240516 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-q1gnrgKsTw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] aespa - Supernova | Mnet Mcountdown 240516 MR제거](/img/tr.png)
![[R(ae)cord] aespa 에스파 ‘Armageddon’ Recording Behind The Scenes](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TDeVyISAt6Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] BABYMONSTER (베이비몬스터) SHEESH | Mnet Mcountdown 240411 MR제거](/img/n.gif)
I'm glad SM lets aespa sing live now, look at how they are slaying and flourishing, pure vocals, they defs deserve daesangs this year, drama after drama, just wow
The company won't wasting any their artist's talent without prices. That's why they were holding the girls voice during the covid era. Even if you notice their first promotion week, always gonna be not live for the AR because they knew the girls voice are worth high price. It's still business afterall. Now with many audiences around the stage, of course the girls would be showing their skills, i mean depends on the money deal as well.
It's SM, of course quality are number one despite how crappy they dealing with their artist management
this is pretty obviously autotuned tho
@@ebreshea1337 they released bts of recording tho it was live but with backtrack
@@nana_forlifeNot live actually. They definitely are great singers but staying perfectly on pitch all the time while dancing is not humanly possible. It's unfortunate to read so many comments of people believing this is real. There are other performances (ex: KWORLD DREAM AWARDS uploaded by this same channel) where they have sung live though, they still sound amazing but not this perfect. From the first verse, a real live stage would sound a little bit shaky due to the movement, this doesn't at all.
@@Kenneth_MJ yes I realized it was prerecorded.
SM QUALITY
Although it is the company with the most haters, it is undoubtedly the best with vocals, raps, music and visuals, there is a reason they are #1 of the Big4
And the creator of Kpop
No matter what other said, like it or not, SM is the blue print that's the fact not just my imagination or smthing
@@Cinnamoroll842 if you're into Kpop since 2007 or before, you'll understand. Hybe hasn't exist back then
@@Cinnamoroll842the management in SM is def more hated than in HYBE, but the groups in HYBE are hated more than SM
this performance was lip synced lol
@@ebreshea1337 Yeah it was, but it doesn't change the fact that the song is extremely hard to perform, right?
90% LIVE!!!!
how about the rest 10%?
@@daotackk backtrack. but the girls are killing it anw SOTY! ❤️🔥
Not really live, I suggest you watch other mr removed videos. Voices are supposed to be affected by movement, but their voices sound 100% stable hear...
0% live lol. If you watch the original performance they are clearly lip syncing. Nothing wrong with that, every idol does that for their first stage of a song, pretty much. It's just weird that they did "MR removed" for that.
2:37 Just Winter proving that they're singing live
Say it louder
Paling enak dgr mr removed nya aespa emg😭🫶🏻
Rill bangettt
@@verennanda8104 Udah ada Auto tune suaranya mereka,,,
Aku pikir lipsync sumpah aku mikir mgkin mereka cape udh brpa minggu promosi kan eh taunya masih live 😭🫶🏻
Ini pre recorded. Bukan live
@@onnikg pre-record itu live
What I've noticed is Karina always sings live no matter what💙
They killed it
ningning’s note at 2:43 took me straight to heaven holy shit
와..카리나 음색 뭐냐
그냥 음원 그 자체인데
이햐 던~~~~~~을 다 소리로 내버리네.. 대박.. 다른 그룹들이었으면 던! 하고 끊었을듯. 에스파 실력은 진짜 수수수수수퍼노바❤
winter's and ningning's voices sound like honey in the end
the song is so addictive, nice to see them enjoying the stage and singing live
그냥 음원 아닌가요 ? 대박
Really I never worried about their live vocals!
*NO one is Stepping on Godspa!!🔥🔥 And what do you mean they improved? They always this good since the beginning😍*
The def improved in stage presence and facial expression tho
I remember they looked like robot in black mamba and next level era
Now they look more enjoyable and having fun at stage ❤
Omg winter's run in the second verse ❤
Yasss 🎉
apa yang harus di ragukan dari aespa, selalu terbaik
Ningning❤
그냥 음원인데...???? 소화하기 힘든 노래까지 제대로 소화하네
@@sung8695 비유를 모르나?
sound like pre record. no hate, just an opinion
Look for their performances at universities. Maybe you'll think twice before saying they don't sing live.
@@Rahmaaa_zizahit is live , but the back track is loud
@@joykendi09 MR removed is supposed to remove the backtrack. This was lip synced. You can tell if you watch the original performance.
I love Winter's 'We never play nice'. It sounds sooooo good!
에스파도 대단하고 응원하는 팬들도 목소리 진짜 크다👍👍👍
100% live
REAL singers!
진짜 너무 잘해……. 걍 음원
perfection
kerenn bgt, gabisa disepelehkan
Sampe lupa kalo ini mr removed 😂
Bener kan yaa..
Mankanya banyak bgt yg blg mereka lipsync mulu 😂 gara2 mirip bgt suara nya kayak rekaman nya
닝닝 목소리에 기절할 것 같다
Its live!
Ningning serving all those adlibs 😌😌
Ningning 🔥🔥
OMG GISELLE AND NINNING’S VOCALS😮😮😮😮
Aespa 🤝🏻 MYs sangat menyatu 😆👍🏻
Even the main rapper is so good at singing😭 this group is full of all rounders
SM quality is better than Hybe quality. Facts
Of course, you can't step on OG
Is it bad I like both of them? Cuz I don’t see why I would hate either aside from the shady owners and higher ups. The artists themselves seem like pretty decent people regardless of an image that might need to be kept. Regardless of that, idk I feel like I just enjoy music to the point where if the performance made me have fun and enjoy then it’s good in my books. Maybe different for you, not trying to offend just giving my thoughts. Have a good day.
Haven't you seen enhypen and Seventeen MR before?? Don't generalize please!
@@Maram.mz.seventeen is OG PLEDIS LOL
TRUE
GOKIL KEREN BGT! INI BARU IDOL!!
Not hybe trying to step on them with their 🐐 sounding idols 😂😂😂
Dont bring le sserafim into this pls.
@@Cinnamoroll842 I didn't even said le seerafim, guess what, you're bringing them here 😂😂
@@Wony1zone U say hybe sounds like goat ur of course bringing them up 🤣🫵 haha
Stop it 😅😅
@@Cinnamoroll842I like HYBE and SM groups, but to be very honest the way you just brought it up would start a whole argument in another comment section. I’d rather we all just enjoy the music that we are able to see and listen to without the extra BS yk? That’s just my thoughts though, not trying to offend. Hope you have a good day.
1:30 와 미쳤네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 차원이 다른 라이브 ㅋㅋ
aespa slayyy!!! Do IWALY MCD stage by top 6 iland2 please😭😭😭
순간 진짜 ar인줄...
이게 에스파다💗💗
이걸 라이브라고 믿네.....
Love how they're finally delivering on both live vocals and performance energy. It took them a while to get the balance right, but now they'll be unstoppable, especially with this amazing new music. This is what I always wanted to see from aespa. Happy to say I'm a fan at last after years of hoping they could be enabled to deliver on their potential, both in talent and group concept. These new songs remind me of Ashnikko's new direction, I love the combination of a futuristic cyber concept with this ancient-witchcraft-ritual energy.
와,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 이 격한 안무속에서도 이 어려운 노래를,,,,, 미쳤다 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,bbb
real singers 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Best release so far this year
まさに口から音源♡♡♡さすが女王！！
와 녹음실인인줄.. 이정도 퀄리티로 라이브가 가능하다니👍😲
OMG!!! THEY'RE LIVE VOCAL SO DAMNN GOOODDDDD!!!
They're even sing the backsound:") SO PROUD
This is the best version ever
The voice so stable all
와 미쳤다
Not live actually. They definitely are great singers but staying perfectly on pitch all the time while dancing is not humanly possible. It's unfortunate to read so many comments of people believing this is real. There are other performances (ex: KWORLD DREAM AWARDS uploaded by this same channel) where they have sung live though, they still sound amazing but not this perfect. From the first verse, a real live stage would sound a little bit shaky due to the movement, this doesn't at all.
winter's tone is so beautiful
GISELLE🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Aespaไม่ต้องห่วงแสดงสด เพราะทำถึงทุกสเตจทั้งร้องสดทั้งเต้น ไว้ใจได้เลย คุณภาพ😊
daebak!!!
진짜 잘한다
아일릿 르세라핌 보다 넘어왔는데 진심 넘사네....
this is what happens when you debut singers
Some dude: Aespa, today you will be lip syncing
Aespa: what’s that
이럴때 코첼라 가줬어야 했는데!!!!!
2:00 is how we know it’s live winters voice cracked a bit
Goose bumps…
ALL THE COMEBACK STAGE ARE PRERECORDED…
lol
AESPA 🎉🎉🎉🎉 so impressive they sang the whole song fr each member is so stable😍😍 LOVE YOU GIRLS🩷🩷✨️✨️
Just BabyMonster and aespa are live sound clearly😭😭😭
Nmixx mamamoo>>>
Ar 아닌가요?? 너무 완벽한디
ningning's stable vocals???
Can you do the special performance fatal trouble of enhypen please ?
Best ❤❤❤❤❤
ITS A RECORDING
Ini mah jelas suara asli dari awal smpe akhir..
편안😊
❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
진심으로 라이브 ar 아님...?
mr제거 다른 영상 봤는데 이거 ar맞는듯
Can you do iland 2 perform IWALY ?
Xg듣다 넘어왔는데 확실히 잘 들리는대?😅
gini mau di aduin sama amagedon 😭🫵🏻
Why are you removing MR from a lip synced performance?
대단한데?
It is❤
뭐여 녹음실이여
❤
ENHYPEN PLS!!!❤
P.S. aespa the best ❤
팬들 응원하는 목소리도 아티한테 다 들리는 건가요?
잘 안들릴걸요 인이어껴서
aespa crushed this 😽😽 newjeans and mhj sit back down with the zionist advertisements
is it pre recorded?
dont think so as there are alot of variations in their voices.. maybe live with AR
Yes
sadly yes
like with AR! You can check out some of their performances at Korean universities to see 100% live. They do much better even there. They are seriously the best.
Yes what are you serious??? Guys you're too sick just accept that their vocals untouchable and chat up @@rinakyun
The only part they don't sing is owayo
와 라이브 ar일줄 알았는데 ㅈㄴ 라이브네
카리나 음색 왜이럼?????????????????????
you’re just playing the back track
이건 립싱크용으로 사전 녹음 한거네 가지가지 한다 에스파
Ningning ❤
❤❤