I think the closest dupe for the upper shade in the Patrick Ta duo Do You Know Who I Am is the gold shade from the PMG Moonlit Seduction palette. Of course, they’re only similar in terms of shade, not formula. I’m sorry I haven’t been commenting much lately-life has been very busy. But I always watch every one of your videos! ❤️ You are my favorite person on beauty TH-cam!
Oh I’m glad you’re back 😘 Yeah, I totally understand! I don’t own Moonlit Seduction so I can’t compare. But I’m glad that these duos add something in my baked gelée collection 😘
I'm glad you are happy with these duos, as I mentioned on your previous videos I got the same 2 duos and I'm obsessed. My favorite way to wear the gold ones is to use the Lisa Eldridge liquid silk in Phoebe as a base and then use the mapplely gold shade on top with a few flakes of the more yellowy gold shade and looks stunning.
The gold in DR1 might be more neutral in tone and similar to the first duo shade you mentioned. It is a smooth texture though but I am sure with some layering from the DR2 shade you might get a similar effect. I usually achieve the effect of the second duo shade by layering the rosy brown from Body Heat with Platinum Bronze from Pat.
I absolutely love these Patrick Ta duos. I have the brown Still in the Club, and the silver and gold We Need Better Lighting. I’m getting the gold duo you have from Santa. I think they are unique and -even better- they do not give me any fallout during the day. Like zero fallout. I find that amazing. I’m reaching for them all the time!
Amanda Z swatched the top shade of Still At The Club next to the Charlotte Tilbury single in Smoky Quartz, and they seem incredibly similar. Also, Sephora’s single in Shock Choc looks similar to the bottom shade. Keep in mind, though, that neither the CT or the Sephora shadows are baked gelée, it’s just a similarity in color and look, not formula. I’m torn because I really like Still At The Club, but I own the CT and Sephora products and I don’t use them enough, so I can’t justify getting the Patrick Ta one.
@ Thank you so much for confirming that they are too similar to justify the buy! As for the other shade in the duo, do you happen to know of any dupes, maybe in your collection? That’s the shade that keeps me interested in the duo and I’m not certain that Shock Choc is fully a dupe.
The bottom shade in patrick ta brown duo is dupe for the satin brown in mothership 3, they both have pinkiness to them have similar soft metalic satin finish
Yeah, I sticked to the baked gelée formula in these comparisons. Color wise it’s easy to find dupes in different formulas, they are not original colors for sure
These do look pretty especially the taupe one but I’m going to wait. I swear PT names his makeup after text messages. I’m good for the winter months. Saving up for the spring so I can see what Byredo is going to do or maybe someone else with a beautiful palate. Always something new around the corner. Thank you.
I underestimated my duo in 'still at the club' bc i compared it to Victoria Beckham in Mink and they're darn close so i thought i overshopped but this is actually a bit prettier, more convenient to use vs the glass jar and comes with that beautiful (luminous) matte brown for more variety.
I do like the versatility to have in my compact able stash that I can carry for any occasions to add that bit of a magic whisper of a special moment. , however it’s not a knock- out kiss of sparkle glitz of sophistication I was hoping for. Glad I got them on sale with a gift of purchase for that love me gift to myself. Purchased (3) still at the club, better lighting, and talk to the team. Keeping my fingers crossed they don’t fall - out of the embossing component ( like previously holiday palette ) or 👩🏼✈️better yet No mold. Nice addition t my arsenal as I’m a professional in the travel industry that lives out of my bag. 👜✨
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! They can’t compare to his previous releases (different manufacturer) so I don’t think they will be affected by the same problems (mold etc) 😘
Thanks BoB!! Yay - I'm so excited to see some new sparkly baked gelee shadows on offer - and I'm glad they were a worthwhile purchase for you. I'm going to buy Still At The Club and will be interested to compare the bottom shade to Blitz Brown from the PMG Interstellar Icon quad. Btw, my conspiracy theory that the lab that makes the baked shades is Intercos Europe is getting stronger - they make for Chantecaille, PMG, and Tom Ford's parent company, Estee Lauder. Couldn't find any info about Patrick Ta, though. Here's hoping Patrick Ta bring out more colours in this formula :)
I bought the same shades and returned both of them. I couldn’t make a look with the lighter duo no matter how hard I tried and the darker duo wouldn’t blend out.
Mhh. don't think people are missing anything. Glad I didn't buy any duos. Subtle differences you see on your arm when you put shades right next to each other searching for the difference don't show up or matter on the eye at all. Which is the end purpose? Nor does slight differences in intensity of shimmer stay that different throughout the day either w wear. At least on my eyes the particles that add extra sparkle dull or plain disappear over the hours so that for most parts these shadows will end up looking the same. The difference I see in the first hour or so but what is that worth?
Mothership X will have the best gold tones based on what you like. I don’t love the matte shades for me so I bring in a Viseart or other good matte in shades I prefer and get beautiful not too yellow not orange at all looks.
@ Smoother and very lightweight on my lids. I’m older than you so I can’t use formulas that create texture or are heavy. For example I have to be very careful with Pat’s Italian quint formula and use it very lightly. I now like it but at first I was not getting good results because it is heavy and creamy. If you like the Clionadh smooth formulas, you might like it, but you should swatch it in store if you can.
I think the closest dupe for the upper shade in the Patrick Ta duo Do You Know Who I Am is the gold shade from the PMG Moonlit Seduction palette. Of course, they’re only similar in terms of shade, not formula. I’m sorry I haven’t been commenting much lately-life has been very busy. But I always watch every one of your videos! ❤️ You are my favorite person on beauty TH-cam!
Oh I’m glad you’re back 😘 Yeah, I totally understand! I don’t own Moonlit Seduction so I can’t compare. But I’m glad that these duos add something in my baked gelée collection 😘
I'm glad you are happy with these duos, as I mentioned on your previous videos I got the same 2 duos and I'm obsessed. My favorite way to wear the gold ones is to use the Lisa Eldridge liquid silk in Phoebe as a base and then use the mapplely gold shade on top with a few flakes of the more yellowy gold shade and looks stunning.
I’ve tried them with Suqqu liquid eyeshadows and they’re stunning
That sounds like an amazing look!
I use them like this. Usually I mix the 2 golds together, but I might try it just a few flakes.
I’ve been waiting for your analysis on these. Just love hearing your breakdowns. So happy you are enjoying them ❤
Thanks dear. They’re definitely a valid product. I’ve heard that more shades are coming. Let’s see… 😘
@ Oh I’d love some with a slight shift 🤩
Thank you for the video! Glad that you are enjoying the Patrick Ta eyeshadows!
😘
The gold in DR1 might be more neutral in tone and similar to the first duo shade you mentioned. It is a smooth texture though but I am sure with some layering from the DR2 shade you might get a similar effect.
I usually achieve the effect of the second duo shade by layering the rosy brown from Body Heat with Platinum Bronze from Pat.
Oh yes, I didn’t think of DR1! Thanks!
I absolutely love these Patrick Ta duos. I have the brown Still in the Club, and the silver and gold We Need Better Lighting. I’m getting the gold duo you have from Santa. I think they are unique and -even better- they do not give me any fallout during the day. Like zero fallout. I find that amazing. I’m reaching for them all the time!
The gold duo gave me a bit of fallout. Maybe because the particles are a bit coarser. But it’s shiny like a golden diamond so I don’t complain
Amanda Z swatched the top shade of Still At The Club next to the Charlotte Tilbury single in Smoky Quartz, and they seem incredibly similar. Also, Sephora’s single in Shock Choc looks similar to the bottom shade. Keep in mind, though, that neither the CT or the Sephora shadows are baked gelée, it’s just a similarity in color and look, not formula. I’m torn because I really like Still At The Club, but I own the CT and Sephora products and I don’t use them enough, so I can’t justify getting the Patrick Ta one.
I have the CT and the PT that you mencioned, and yes, they are incredibly similar. If you have one, it would be enouph.
@ Thank you so much for confirming that they are too similar to justify the buy! As for the other shade in the duo, do you happen to know of any dupes, maybe in your collection? That’s the shade that keeps me interested in the duo and I’m not certain that Shock Choc is fully a dupe.
These PT duo's are lovely. I'm very happy with my purchase. Have 4 of them except the pink duo.
Exactly all the duos I originally wanted. Which are your favorites?
@@bobmindset Still At The Club is my favourite.
Omg settling in now to watch!! So excited for this :)
Great video!! Thanks for the info BoB!!! 🫶💕⭐️
Thank you ❤️
The bottom shade in patrick ta brown duo is dupe for the satin brown in mothership 3, they both have pinkiness to them have similar soft metalic satin finish
Yeah, I sticked to the baked gelée formula in these comparisons. Color wise it’s easy to find dupes in different formulas, they are not original colors for sure
These do look pretty especially the taupe one but I’m going to wait. I swear PT names his makeup after text messages. I’m good for the winter months. Saving up for the spring so I can see what Byredo is going to do or maybe someone else with a beautiful palate. Always something new around the corner. Thank you.
Sure, with all the new things that constantly come out, there’s no point to buy something we’re not convinced about 😘
I underestimated my duo in 'still at the club' bc i compared it to Victoria Beckham in Mink and they're darn close so i thought i overshopped but this is actually a bit prettier, more convenient to use vs the glass jar and comes with that beautiful (luminous) matte brown for more variety.
I decluttered my Mink but I will keep this one. I love it
Great analysis, love these videos BoB. Chanel has come out with another over sized palette full of orange.
Yeah, I know! Too orange! 🍊
Oh god let me go and look. Lol
Yes Tracy, check Lexi Jong
I do like the versatility to have in my compact able stash that I can carry for any occasions to add that bit of a magic whisper of a special moment. , however it’s not a knock- out kiss of sparkle glitz of sophistication I was hoping for. Glad I got them on sale with a gift of purchase for that love me gift to myself. Purchased (3) still at the club, better lighting, and talk to the team. Keeping my fingers crossed they don’t fall - out of the embossing component ( like previously holiday palette ) or 👩🏼✈️better yet No mold.
Nice addition t my arsenal as I’m a professional in the travel industry that lives out of my bag. 👜✨
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! They can’t compare to his previous releases (different manufacturer) so I don’t think they will be affected by the same problems (mold etc) 😘
@ Oh great! Ty for that little tid bit of information. Your channel is very enlighten 🫶.
Thanks BoB!! Yay - I'm so excited to see some new sparkly baked gelee shadows on offer - and I'm glad they were a worthwhile purchase for you. I'm going to buy Still At The Club and will be interested to compare the bottom shade to Blitz Brown from the PMG Interstellar Icon quad.
Btw, my conspiracy theory that the lab that makes the baked shades is Intercos Europe is getting stronger - they make for Chantecaille, PMG, and Tom Ford's parent company, Estee Lauder. Couldn't find any info about Patrick Ta, though.
Here's hoping Patrick Ta bring out more colours in this formula :)
Hi dear I don’t own that PMG quad. If you buy the PT duo, let me know how they compare 😘
Hiya I think the gold is similar to the ones in moonlight seduction.
Yes, but I don’t have it
I bought the same shades and returned both of them. I couldn’t make a look with the lighter duo no matter how hard I tried and the darker duo wouldn’t blend out.
Oh that’s bad! ☹️
Mhh. don't think people are missing anything. Glad I didn't buy any duos. Subtle differences you see on your arm when you put shades right next to each other searching for the difference don't show up or matter on the eye at all. Which is the end purpose? Nor does slight differences in intensity of shimmer stay that different throughout the day either w wear. At least on my eyes the particles that add extra sparkle dull or plain disappear over the hours so that for most parts these shadows will end up looking the same. The difference I see in the first hour or so but what is that worth?
Yeah, I agree it’s not a must have. But they’re pretty
Mothership X will have the best gold tones based on what you like. I don’t love the matte shades for me so I bring in a Viseart or other good matte in shades I prefer and get beautiful not too yellow not orange at all looks.
Yeah, but I don’t like the formula of Mothership X so it’s a strong no for me (I only used Pat baked gelée). I’m fine with my golds 🤣
@@bobmindset I have come to really enjoy the Mothership X formula. It’s miles above Pat’s other non-baked formulas.
What is the difference?
@ Smoother and very lightweight on my lids. I’m older than you so I can’t use formulas that create texture or are heavy. For example I have to be very careful with Pat’s Italian quint formula and use it very lightly. I now like it but at first I was not getting good results because it is heavy and creamy. If you like the Clionadh smooth formulas, you might like it, but you should swatch it in store if you can.
And the brown I think is similar to Natasha Denona I need a nude
I decluttered it. I explain why in my video