John walking into Saint Denis like a boss with a 10% discount and max honor thanks to Arthur doing side quests. I left the Charlotte's mission for John and Hamish's too, to max his honor and get stuff for nothing before the ending
that's Molly O'Shea's design when she was gonna be in the saint denis mayor garden party (forgot the mission name) but Mary Beth still looked so gorg in that mission with her og design
What do you mean, "should have"? Do you know who owns Rockstar? The name is Take Two Interactive, and they're... Horrible. They fund everything that Rockstar has and does, and when they take longer than 10 years, too bad! No more money for them, and they have to release with 50% less content and 6 years earlier than planned! Rockstar would have. But blame Take Two Interactive for everything that's wrong with Rockstar and their games - like Online or cut content. Proof to support my theory: Take Two Interactive is only mentioned when talking about legal rights and stuff, saying that they own everything. Meanwhile Rockstar is the point of attention... Perhaps Take Two Interactive wants to put the blame to them! Also Take Two Interactive CEO said that they "won't do any simple ports" (like making Red Dead Redemption 1 available to all modern consoles and computers) and still, RDR1 came out and only on consoles (with a big price at first).
Meeting Rains Fall was the last big thing I did on my save, and it was first thing I did after clearing the final mission, placing the squirrel statue down in Beecher's Hope and getting 100%
One detail I liked was that the homeless vet (not mickey, the other one in Rhodes) was surprised that Arthur saved John but the people who knew him when he had TB weren’t surprised because they knew he changed
I thought he has Arthur mod or some trainer tricks when saw that. A I've read they changed John's model after first release to look more like Arthur for some reason. There's even a mod that changes John's model
Not innocent, but compared to the rest, an angel. She should've been with Arthur in the end. She probably would've been if Arthur had shown any interest back
this changed my outlook on if the fate of the Van der linde gang. Charles, Sadie, Tilly, Mary Beth and Pearson for all we know lived a happy life yea it's sad what happended to Arthur, John, Dutch etc but at least some people got out and lived
I know it’s supposed to be tragic that Jack ends up a gunslinger like his dad, but I like to think that after the epilogue of RDR1 he got it all out of his system and became an author like he wanted
@@cozybones4644 i like to believe he went on the WW1,met his share of horror grief and action then came back got out alive,become a writer.and thinking of him in games like L.A noire.
@@cozybones4644couldn't warn it as spoiler? Nobody cares that the game is old, that doesn't justify ruining other people's fun! I'm praying every single day to forget all that!
@@TheMastermind7259bro I got spoiled multiple times for multiple games but it's partly my fault since I decided to go to the comments. Just don't go to comments of games you haven't played yet
if you follow through all the additional missions with hamish as arthur, he actually dies while you're going boar hunting with him and he tells you in his dying breathe to take his horse.
@@Ozi_121blame that to Take Two Interactive, they're behind everything. They even made Rockstar the point of attention so that they get blamed by people that don't think enough about it like you. Take Two Interactive has all the power over Rockstat, and they fund all they have as well. So, when Rockstar takes more than 10 years to make a game, too bad! They don't get paid anymore and are forced to release way earlier than planned, like 6 years earlier and with 40% less content than planned.
It's just sad to think that Mickey actually thought more about Arthur than other characters. You can visit him back in Valentine after the TB diagnosis, and you'd actually have him say he's sad for Arthur.
Seeing that most of the members from the gang get a happy ending like Pearson,Tilly,Mary Beth and even Charles and Sadie near the end getting a new beginning really just makes me happy that rockstar took that extra step to write that in.
Cause he never was.his whole life revolved in violence and crime but he never regret it,he did what he could and thought for the people that were near him.
Charlotte Balfour was my favorite character to interact with when I played Arthur. I, in a way, wanted them to be together, but I understood why that wouldn't happen.
My heart genuinely dropped when he said they are in Canada. They moved from one hell just to get to another. (Search residential schools if you don’t know what I mean)
Had the honor of playing this game without knowing a thing about it until after I beat it, I remember seeing Rain Falls call at me and in real life I was like “Ahh shoot what’s up man! How you been?!” Glad I gave this game a chance 🤝🔥
I am platinuming RDR2 now. Finished 100% walk through, did MVP trophy and currently finishing off the gold rush trophy. Got 61/70 gold medals, need 9 more to do. 38/52. Hopefully should be done by next month maybe.
7:17 and this is why I always wonder if players are a certain way in real life, when there's no reason for doing any of it, they get the idea to do it.
I almost had a stroke when I saw the honor I got from rain falls now in my new save I am doing the 90 chalenges I left him so when I finish I get sum of the honor I lost
It’s hard to say when Karen left the gang, some reckon it was after the oil field raid but not sure. Tilly’s letter to John (found at his dinner table at Beechers Hope post end credits or sometimes you can get it spawn before hand but can be tricky) explains she feels Karen’s probably dead due to alcoholism although Tilly said she’s not sure.
@@Auth0R_M0RGaN ah gotcha! Thank you for the info! I never even knew you could get a letter from Tilly at the end. Guess this calls for another playthrough! ☺️
They actually ruined John in the epilogue he looked so much better before the epilogue I actually can’t use him without a beard cuz he looks awful they did him so dirty
What do you mean? Do you know who owns Rockstar? The name is Take Two Interactive, and they're... Horrible. They fund everything that Rockstar has and does, and when they take longer than 10 years, too bad! No more money for them, and they have to release with 50% less content and 6 years earlier than planned! Rockstar would have. But blame Take Two Interactive with everything that's wrong with Rockstar and their games - like Online or cut content. Proof to support my theory: Take Two Interactive is only mentioned when talking about legal rights and stuff, saying that they own everything. Meanwhile Rockstar is the point of attention... Perhaps Take Two Interactive wants to put the blame to them! Also Take Two Interactive CEO said that they "won't do any simple ports" (like making Red Dead Redemption 1 available to all modern consoles and computers) and still, RDR1 came out and only on consoles (with a big price at first).
Different endings ? Because Sinclair died in my playthrough on my other account and I kept his horse in honor to him .... Then if coarse I died in the end of lucimia and from micha
I honestly wish people still had this way of communicating. What I mean is people today are so uninterested (not all) in having a conversation with strangers they go out of their way to avoid it. Now I’m sure in 1899 just randomly talking to strangers was nerve wracking, but for the most part it would seem people enjoyed conversations with strangers then.
maybe cuz Arthur was not planned while Rockstar made RDR, it was not until after Arthur was introduced. That's why RDR needs a remake for the lore to make actual sense taking RDR2 as a starting point.
@@notjhuz9589no, a post on Quora made a good point - John just feels so bad about Arthur that he's keeping him a secret. There's a conversation between Jack and Abigail, where Jack mentions the potential Arthur, and Abigail tells him not to talk about the man in front of John. For John, Arthur was his brother. And stuff like that actually happen in real life!
Anyway, here is a very sad fact: Do you know who owns Rockstar? The name is Take Two Interactive, and they're... Horrible. They fund everything that Rockstar has and does, and when they take longer than 10 years, too bad! No more money for them, and they have to release with 50% less content and 6 years earlier than planned! Rockstar would have. But blame Take Two Interactive with everything that's wrong with Rockstar and their games - like Online or cut content. Proof to support my theory: Take Two Interactive is only mentioned when talking about legal rights and stuff, saying that they own everything. Meanwhile Rockstar is the point of attention... Perhaps Take Two Interactive wants to put the blame to them! Also Take Two Interactive CEO said that they "won't do any simple ports" (like making Red Dead Redemption 1 available to all modern consoles and computers) and still, RDR1 came out and only on consoles (with a big price at first).
I almost had a heart attack when I saw how much honor I got for just accidentally meeting rains fall
Same lol
John walking into Saint Denis like a boss with a 10% discount and max honor thanks to Arthur doing side quests.
I left the Charlotte's mission for John and Hamish's too, to max his honor and get stuff for nothing before the ending
How much honour do u get?
@@Lunalovegood406 i don't know, It goes form the middle of the bar to two levels away from max
Which means that you were a rat right before that 😂son of a gun
0:10 Rains Falls speaking while rain is falling just fits so perfectly
It's almost poetic
God damn did Mary Beth look fucking gorgeous dude, I’m so happy she got out and managed to live a happy life like some of the others that got out.
that's Molly O'Shea's design when she was gonna be in the saint denis mayor garden party (forgot the mission name) but Mary Beth still looked so gorg in that mission with her og design
John: Arthur saved my life....
Others: Yelp! This my train gotta go bye
😂
so underrated 🤣🤣🤣
I almost wonder if Rains Falls has dementia... it would make sense because he went back to America for a reason he can't remember.
Probably to stay with his son
He was probably visiting his sons grave
@@POdreams44 Yeah, he was, but he seemed confused.
It's a kind of attachment in fact. It's because he misses his son.
His son dying probaly made his life go downhill real fast, poor bloke
They should've added Captain Monroe and Brother Dorkins
Captain Monroe was a fugitive I doubt he would have stayed in the USA and that is also the advice Arthur gave him
Monroe might've actually gone to Tahiti.
@@XiasIV MONROE IS AN OFICAIL TAHITIAN
@@XiasIVHe had a plan
What do you mean, "should have"? Do you know who owns Rockstar? The name is Take Two Interactive, and they're... Horrible. They fund everything that Rockstar has and does, and when they take longer than 10 years, too bad! No more money for them, and they have to release with 50% less content and 6 years earlier than planned!
Rockstar would have. But blame Take Two Interactive for everything that's wrong with Rockstar and their games - like Online or cut content. Proof to support my theory: Take Two Interactive is only mentioned when talking about legal rights and stuff, saying that they own everything. Meanwhile Rockstar is the point of attention... Perhaps Take Two Interactive wants to put the blame to them! Also Take Two Interactive CEO said that they "won't do any simple ports" (like making Red Dead Redemption 1 available to all modern consoles and computers) and still, RDR1 came out and only on consoles (with a big price at first).
Meeting Rains Fall was the last big thing I did on my save, and it was first thing I did after clearing the final mission, placing the squirrel statue down in Beecher's Hope and getting 100%
What’s this squirrel statue thing I’ve heard about it before but I don’t think I’ve had it before
@@maxbaker6220You gotta do all hunting requests then put a squirrel in ur house after epilogue
@@zRazor oh yh I ain’t ever done them so that’s why I had no idea what they were on about
One detail I liked was that the homeless vet (not mickey, the other one in Rhodes) was surprised that Arthur saved John but the people who knew him when he had TB weren’t surprised because they knew he changed
You see a man who changed. I see a man who turned out to the man who he always was.
@@TheMastermind7259 I guess your right
0:20 Arthur Marston at its best, jesus John looks horrible without a beard
Nah you got it reversed
That is NOT John dude what the hell
Johnthur Margston
@@FlyingLineit is 💀
I thought he has Arthur mod or some trainer tricks when saw that. A I've read they changed John's model after first release to look more like Arthur for some reason. There's even a mod that changes John's model
I'm glad mary beth had a peaceful life.The others were affiliayed with a gang more or less.But mary beth was the only one that was still innocent.
She tips you off about a robery in valentine
She is not innocent lol. None of them are.
Not innocent, but compared to the rest, an angel. She should've been with Arthur in the end. She probably would've been if Arthur had shown any interest back
Lmao she was a master of pickpocket 😂😂😂
@@uptGuapo Pickpocketing ain't on the same level as murder, which most everyone else in the gang did on a regular basis.
this changed my outlook on if the fate of the Van der linde gang. Charles, Sadie, Tilly, Mary Beth and Pearson for all we know lived a happy life yea it's sad what happended to Arthur, John, Dutch etc but at least some people got out and lived
I know it’s supposed to be tragic that Jack ends up a gunslinger like his dad, but I like to think that after the epilogue of RDR1 he got it all out of his system and became an author like he wanted
@@cozybones4644 Pretty sure he will have to defend the others that got out from trouble
@@cozybones4644 i like to believe he went on the WW1,met his share of horror grief and action then came back got out alive,become a writer.and thinking of him in games like L.A noire.
@@cozybones4644couldn't warn it as spoiler? Nobody cares that the game is old, that doesn't justify ruining other people's fun! I'm praying every single day to forget all that!
@@TheMastermind7259bro I got spoiled multiple times for multiple games but it's partly my fault since I decided to go to the comments. Just don't go to comments of games you haven't played yet
7:17 was personal 💀
Yes
i dont remember john being so big
John Marston, more like John Cena lmao
Mods
Man got his rdr1 height, lmao.
i saw somewhere in a while back that they used arthur morgan's body for the epilogue
@@thatgirlstephanie6023 yeah but they used Arthur’s tuberculosis model for John, even here this model is bulked up from Arthur’s, this is a mod
"I dont really know..."
“For my son I suppose”
''Just you left is it?''
John in Arthur’s “summer gunslinger” outfit looks SO wrong
if you follow through all the additional missions with hamish as arthur, he actually dies while you're going boar hunting with him and he tells you in his dying breathe to take his horse.
I wonder if you do that last mission with Hamish if he gives Buell to John instead?
@@zjdarrah he does
@@zjdarrah no hablaremos el mismo idioma pero Hamish morirá de todas maneras y dirá que te lleves su caballo a si sea con Arthur o John
Now I'm tempted to start a new game just to help Charlotte hunt so I won't find her dead after the game and/or epilogue
If you don’t help her she does?
@@KayGee-iv1gdno, she dies by starvation.
@@TheMastermind7259 only if you don’t help her
She gives Arthur a kiss 😘 Arthur rizz
Mary Beth was not in pajamas for me
Mary-Beth looks so good in that dress dude!!
good times never last john, a guy in a chicken mask told me that.
A guy with a helmet told me that I forget a thousand things everyday
A man wearing a turtle shell told me I got this, but he kept calling me Goku or something.
😂
Hotline miami ahh reference
A old priest with a shotgun said to not be afraid
I accidentally killed Charlotte by doing the first mission as Arthur but then leaving the rest. When I came back I found her corpse so....
Oh...
Did you reload your save?
Or I'm you did that and I don't get it
John: ARTHUR SAVED MY LIFE MORE THAN ONCE
Micah: ArThUrs bEeN dEaD a LoNg tImE
Dutch: *Blank Stare*
Mickey's dialogue makes me so sad
meeting rains fall when the rain falls is so strange tbh
1:43 why does John look so buff
Thats for Abigail
Rockstar was lazy af, sooooo... They used Arthur's model for john... He literally looks like arthur but with scars and different hair colour
@@Ozi_121blame that to Take Two Interactive, they're behind everything. They even made Rockstar the point of attention so that they get blamed by people that don't think enough about it like you.
Take Two Interactive has all the power over Rockstat, and they fund all they have as well. So, when Rockstar takes more than 10 years to make a game, too bad! They don't get paid anymore and are forced to release way earlier than planned, like 6 years earlier and with 40% less content than planned.
@@TheMastermind7259 the game was still good
How come no one wants to meet Albert Mason? 😢
A change to Albert's eagle mission where he takes a last photo with arthur
7 years later he shows john the photo
It's just sad to think that Mickey actually thought more about Arthur than other characters. You can visit him back in Valentine after the TB diagnosis, and you'd actually have him say he's sad for Arthur.
7:16 Aughhhhhhh
Besides John, Arthur and Jack, Hamish is my favorite Rdr character.
Besides Arthur John Hosea and Lenny, Charles is my fav in my opinion
I like how Tilly says "we Live in a House" she's the best part of RDR
7:17 💀
I miss Arthur Morgan
Seeing that most of the members from the gang get a happy ending like Pearson,Tilly,Mary Beth and even Charles and Sadie near the end getting a new beginning really just makes me happy that rockstar took that extra step to write that in.
I wish Pearson had a cutscene though
He does, he’s a gunsmith and u can meet him
@@SomeDudeLol530what one
@@Kuteandkrazy1234 food store in Rhodes
@@SomeDudeLol530*General Store Owner
@@TrevorPhilipsEnterpriseCEO oh yeah sorry thank you
I can’t believe he said Arthur was not a good man
Cause he never was.his whole life revolved in violence and crime but he never regret it,he did what he could and thought for the people that were near him.
Low honor✨✨✨
Really like all the modding you’ve done, looks amazing.
Thx🥰
Bro absolutely PUMPED THIS FULL OF MODS, GOLLLLYYYY BROOO
Charlotte Balfour was my favorite character to interact with when I played Arthur. I, in a way, wanted them to be together, but I understood why that wouldn't happen.
My heart genuinely dropped when he said they are in Canada. They moved from one hell just to get to another. (Search residential schools if you don’t know what I mean)
This video is good but I am seeing more arthur morgan than John Marston. Glad I reverted back to 1.00
I met Mickey in Rhodes outside Pearson’s shop
No way... How?
@@gator_mk idk it was in the epilogue part 2 and I just met Pearson for the first time
You sure it wasn't a veteran who lost his leg? He's a different person than Mickey.
@ ohhhh
@@IGPriX no it was Mickey I just replayed the game and it says mickey
Had the honor of playing this game without knowing a thing about it until after I beat it, I remember seeing Rain Falls call at me and in real life I was like “Ahh shoot what’s up man! How you been?!” Glad I gave this game a chance 🤝🔥
I must say, Mary-Beth looks really fine in that green dress. Plus these gloves. 👌
7:24 *Pearson minding his own Business then somebody breaks down his door
Wow Mary-Beth looks even more beautiful in that dress mod, let's face it, the most of us fell for her and misses Adler
I am platinuming RDR2 now. Finished 100% walk through, did MVP trophy and currently finishing off the gold rush trophy. Got 61/70 gold medals, need 9 more to do. 38/52. Hopefully should be done by next month maybe.
7:17 and this is why I always wonder if players are a certain way in real life, when there's no reason for doing any of it, they get the idea to do it.
Sheesh Mary-Beth is such a beauty
Under four hours gang
(Just comment)
I almost had a stroke when I saw the honor I got from rain falls now in my new save I am doing the 90 chalenges I left him so when I finish I get sum of the honor I lost
Does anyone know what happened to Karen? I feel like I missed something with her, because she was just gone towards the end of the game! lol
It’s hard to say when Karen left the gang, some reckon it was after the oil field raid but not sure. Tilly’s letter to John (found at his dinner table at Beechers Hope post end credits or sometimes you can get it spawn before hand but can be tricky) explains she feels Karen’s probably dead due to alcoholism although Tilly said she’s not sure.
@@Auth0R_M0RGaN ah gotcha! Thank you for the info! I never even knew you could get a letter from Tilly at the end. Guess this calls for another playthrough! ☺️
As a curiosity: if you kill Mary Beth your honor will be greatly reduced.
Mary Beth is bad Sadie too for a southern girl on a 🎮 game
Ij the hamish one does that happen when you dont complete the last mission ajd then you go back with john
wow I thought hamish was dead after that boar attack
*Breaks door* John marston, I don't believe it!
They actually ruined John in the epilogue he looked so much better before the epilogue I actually can’t use him without a beard cuz he looks awful they did him so dirty
What do you mean? Do you know who owns Rockstar? The name is Take Two Interactive, and they're... Horrible. They fund everything that Rockstar has and does, and when they take longer than 10 years, too bad! No more money for them, and they have to release with 50% less content and 6 years earlier than planned!
Rockstar would have. But blame Take Two Interactive with everything that's wrong with Rockstar and their games - like Online or cut content. Proof to support my theory: Take Two Interactive is only mentioned when talking about legal rights and stuff, saying that they own everything. Meanwhile Rockstar is the point of attention... Perhaps Take Two Interactive wants to put the blame to them! Also Take Two Interactive CEO said that they "won't do any simple ports" (like making Red Dead Redemption 1 available to all modern consoles and computers) and still, RDR1 came out and only on consoles (with a big price at first).
Different endings ? Because Sinclair died in my playthrough on my other account and I kept his horse in honor to him .... Then if coarse I died in the end of lucimia and from micha
The trick is not to do the final mission with sinclair, then you’ll do the mission of saving his horse as John
John Morgan
Where’d you get that jacket that John was wearing in the first clip?
Mrs.chalote i just meet her after Epilogue now her doesn't know who is Arthur Morgan 😂
John should not be this buff what is happening?
Arthur gave him a pack of steroid powder
I honestly wish people still had this way of communicating. What I mean is people today are so uninterested (not all) in having a conversation with strangers they go out of their way to avoid it. Now I’m sure in 1899 just randomly talking to strangers was nerve wracking, but for the most part it would seem people enjoyed conversations with strangers then.
we should go back to having that mindset
I don't understand what Tilly says about Arthur
gracis
Everyone we meet as Arthur mentions him here while in rdr1 Arthur seems to not exist
maybe cuz Arthur was not planned while Rockstar made RDR, it was not until after Arthur was introduced. That's why RDR needs a remake for the lore to make actual sense taking RDR2 as a starting point.
Because no one knew arthur in rdr1 except sister and the gang members(but it’s been 12 years so they probably won’t care as much, besides Dutch)
@@notjhuz9589no, a post on Quora made a good point - John just feels so bad about Arthur that he's keeping him a secret. There's a conversation between Jack and Abigail, where Jack mentions the potential Arthur, and Abigail tells him not to talk about the man in front of John. For John, Arthur was his brother. And stuff like that actually happen in real life!
@@TheMastermind7259 cool
8:49 the vet dies and that’s when you get bull so did he survive or what
Why did you barge into Pearson’s store like that? 😂😂😂
Dang, is this a mod or something ?
How did John get so swole ?
01:50 How can you save her? I did her side quest with Arthur, finished the game and when I came back with John, she was dead inside the house
You didn’t finish her quest line obviously 😂
There are like 3 missions with her make sure you finished them All
Does anyone know what coat is used in the cutscene with rains fall and if its available on console?
It's mod
@@gator_mk thanks, I was looking to use it for a revolver ocelot costume.
7:20 i would do the same thing tbh 😂😂
😂
What did you do to John
7:17 so unnecessary 😂😂😂
When can I meet rains fall?
In annesbieg at the train station I think
Anyway, here is a very sad fact: Do you know who owns Rockstar? The name is Take Two Interactive, and they're... Horrible. They fund everything that Rockstar has and does, and when they take longer than 10 years, too bad! No more money for them, and they have to release with 50% less content and 6 years earlier than planned!
Rockstar would have. But blame Take Two Interactive with everything that's wrong with Rockstar and their games - like Online or cut content. Proof to support my theory: Take Two Interactive is only mentioned when talking about legal rights and stuff, saying that they own everything. Meanwhile Rockstar is the point of attention... Perhaps Take Two Interactive wants to put the blame to them! Also Take Two Interactive CEO said that they "won't do any simple ports" (like making Red Dead Redemption 1 available to all modern consoles and computers) and still, RDR1 came out and only on consoles (with a big price at first).