It's funny how some people are pissed in the comments, when this is just one guys opinions. Everybody can have them. For example smt > persona. I don't want any of this strawberry slice of life stuff on my edgy game. Should have been demi fiend not joker in smash.
great video my friend! You made me think more about how ann is objectified more than the other characters and when you pointed out the idea of her coming out of an arc based on sexual assault, it does seem very distasteful and poorly written to make her a gag character for all comedic sexual relief jokes.
I do disagree with you a fair bit with this list (for example I love Tartarus personally, and I much prefer EP’s cast to IS’s), but overall I give this one big Based.
I agree, and i get that nobody asked, but my ranking would be 5:persona 1 4:persona 3 3:persona 2 2:persona 5 1:persona 4 Hate it all you want you ARE The one who pressed read more
my ranking would probably be: 1. Persona 2 2. Persona 3 3. Persona 5 4. Persona 4 5. Persona 1 they're all great games btw, it's just that i love P2's writing the most and P3's gameplay is alot better than 4's while P5 had an interesting theme (and 3rd semester's writing is onpar with P2 for me) while P1 on the other hand is good with it's themes and message but the presentation didn't really do it well for me (doesn't mean it's bad tho!! the PSX OST and the cast are great)
Im sorry but this is the wrost list i have ever seen ngl. The reasons especialy for persona 5 are really wrong and even tho it depends on taste saying that the story takes a nose dive after kamoshidas palace when you have saes palace,shidou and not liking the 3rd semester which includes one of the best antagonists and the best girl on the seriesreally dont agree with.
I dont get the appeal for these kinda videos. The opinions presented are really flat and without substation or argumentation. Its just "this is how I feel" and then moving on, its not interesting. Also clasic misunderstanding of what they were trying to do with Ann. You can still not like it, but they were going for a story about her taking back her sexuality and using it for herself instead of being used by other people. Thats why her phantom thief outfit is a domanatrix, a pretty straight forward idea of sexual control. The scene you show from Shido's palace is a culmination of her trying to be a femm fatale and actually succeeding. Its not just a joke, theres more going on. Like in the nude painting scene, she never actually shows anything. Maintaining control over her body by her standards. Also how are Iseabu and Makoto similar? That could have been an interesting exploration on how you feel. Im guessing because they both deal with the idea of finding ones own moral compas? I wish you actually delved into that.
I honestly don't know how someone could love Isabeau but hate Makoto. In fact, and I say this as someone who does like Isabeau, there's arguably more to Makoto than there is Isabeau.
i mean is he wrong? Makoto is literally so poorly written in P5. hell i'd say that the spinoffs give her more justice (no pun intended) with her character even if it isn't as much. Makoto's confidant is probnably the worst in the entire series (aside from Nozomi from P3)
Don't get me wrong i love Makoto, i only romanced her in my First playtrough and never once Took her out of the party, but her writing is really just terrible. Admiting this didn't make me suddenly not like the character anymore, a random person saying that something i enjoy is bad means nothing to me. But you don't need to convince everyone your favorite character or game or gameplay or whatever is absolutely perfect Just to have It as your favorite, it's not healthy, especially when you're calling everyone you disagree with a retard. The flaws of something should only matter to you if they take away from what made the thing good in the first place. I love p5 and p3, even after admiting that they're both "bad", and you can too
Yeah I go crazy when I think which game is my favorite. They all mean so much to me for different reasons
ISABEAU BEST SMT 4 GIRL
Persona is my 2nd Favorite Series of All Time with Persona 5 Royal and Persona 4 Golden are both are in my Top 5 VideoGames of All Time
It's funny how some people are pissed in the comments, when this is just one guys opinions. Everybody can have them.
For example smt > persona. I don't want any of this strawberry slice of life stuff on my edgy game. Should have been demi fiend not joker in smash.
I’m shocked anyone played Persona 1 and 2.
Very good vid. (Minus what you said about p3)
P2 is first so it's an amazing list
persona 3 in number 4 is criminal
great video my friend! You made me think more about how ann is objectified more than the other characters and when you pointed out the idea of her coming out of an arc based on sexual assault, it does seem very distasteful and poorly written to make her a gag character for all comedic sexual relief jokes.
i feel like i am the only person who likes persona 5
i jork to your vids
I do disagree with you a fair bit with this list (for example I love Tartarus personally, and I much prefer EP’s cast to IS’s), but overall I give this one big Based.
Based
I agree, and i get that nobody asked, but my ranking would be
5:persona 1
4:persona 3
3:persona 2
2:persona 5
1:persona 4
Hate it all you want you ARE The one who pressed read more
my ranking would probably be:
1. Persona 2
2. Persona 3
3. Persona 5
4. Persona 4
5. Persona 1
they're all great games btw, it's just that i love P2's writing the most and P3's gameplay is alot better than 4's while P5 had an interesting theme (and 3rd semester's writing is onpar with P2 for me) while P1 on the other hand is good with it's themes and message but the presentation didn't really do it well for me (doesn't mean it's bad tho!! the PSX OST and the cast are great)
@@Windermed cool, nice, poggers even.
bad persona 5 take
Im sorry but this is the wrost list i have ever seen ngl. The reasons especialy for persona 5 are really wrong and even tho it depends on taste saying that the story takes a nose dive after kamoshidas palace when you have saes palace,shidou and not liking the 3rd semester which includes one of the best antagonists and the best girl on the seriesreally dont agree with.
I dont get the appeal for these kinda videos. The opinions presented are really flat and without substation or argumentation. Its just "this is how I feel" and then moving on, its not interesting. Also clasic misunderstanding of what they were trying to do with Ann. You can still not like it, but they were going for a story about her taking back her sexuality and using it for herself instead of being used by other people. Thats why her phantom thief outfit is a domanatrix, a pretty straight forward idea of sexual control. The scene you show from Shido's palace is a culmination of her trying to be a femm fatale and actually succeeding. Its not just a joke, theres more going on. Like in the nude painting scene, she never actually shows anything. Maintaining control over her body by her standards.
Also how are Iseabu and Makoto similar? That could have been an interesting exploration on how you feel. Im guessing because they both deal with the idea of finding ones own moral compas? I wish you actually delved into that.
I honestly don't know how someone could love Isabeau but hate Makoto. In fact, and I say this as someone who does like Isabeau, there's arguably more to Makoto than there is Isabeau.
"also makoto is just isabeau but not as well done"
yeah im not listenning to this rtard lmao
i mean is he wrong? Makoto is literally so poorly written in P5. hell i'd say that the spinoffs give her more justice (no pun intended) with her character even if it isn't as much.
Makoto's confidant is probnably the worst in the entire series (aside from Nozomi from P3)
@@Windermed excuse me??? devil arcana???? if you mean the plot then yeah but their (makoto x isabeau) character arcs arent even comparable...
Don't get me wrong i love Makoto, i only romanced her in my First playtrough and never once Took her out of the party, but her writing is really just terrible.
Admiting this didn't make me suddenly not like the character anymore, a random person saying that something i enjoy is bad means nothing to me. But you don't need to convince everyone your favorite character or game or gameplay or whatever is absolutely perfect Just to have It as your favorite, it's not healthy, especially when you're calling everyone you disagree with a retard.
The flaws of something should only matter to you if they take away from what made the thing good in the first place. I love p5 and p3, even after admiting that they're both "bad", and you can too
@@cachorrodekatana117 i never said its good. i said the character arcs aren't comparable. they have nothing to do with each other