Classical Musicians React: VIXX 'Eternity' vs 'Error'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 พ.ค. 2017
- For the 56th video of this series, classical music majors react to VIXX’s ‘Eternity’ MV vs ‘Error’ MV!
We have already filmed reactions to Beautiful Liar & Chained Up (will post 6/26) and the trilogy (will post it on 7/31,8/2,8/4). Milky Way & Shangri La is also on the list along with a few non-title track songs!
FOLLOW MY TWITTER FOR UPDATES & SNEAK PEEKS OF FUTURE REACTIONS: @_emcha_
Full Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
THE FULL LIST OF MVs TO-BE REACTED TO: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
TH-cam (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: / kpop-instrumental-covers
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(Assistant editor & channel manager) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
(Assist. filmer) Ash:
Instagram: @ashhfong
Snapchat: @ashleyfong457
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Yunyi:
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Facebook: / classicjennycomics
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
TH-cam: nerdymusicks
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Ben:
Instagram: @ben.j.l.kronk
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![MEYOU - กอดหมอน [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RAG4Ee8FPxA/mqdefault.jpg)
"What the hell is he wearing"
*literally every single person who first watches Error* 😂
IWIofficial tO BE HONEST SKLSSKLS
IWIofficial TRUE
SO TRUE. I'VE SEEN THIS MV SO MANY TIMES AND STILL "WHY IS RAVI WEARING THAT TIN MAN HAT"
it was an error
that was my question for 4 freaking years
"Love is like a fart, if you force it, it's probably shit" LOL W H A T
same
Lazy Potaito not even going to lie this is my new favorite phrase
Lazy Potaito i need that on a shirt
Lazy Potaito: I knew someone was gonna mention this it took me a long time looking for u fam
Lazy Potaito hahahahahaha your comment is the best
Every reactions from error mv
*'What is he wearing on top of his head?'*
*'Why are you wearing trash can on your head'*
*'Oh my god that low note'*
*'STOP KISSING GO SAVE YOURSELVES'*
the 600th like :))
look at chabooty, love your name
if you noticed in the "eternity" video (after the rap part), the clock stops at 6: 20. since the numbers of the clock are in roman numerals...
6 = VI
20 = XX
6: 20 = VI:XX
when i first read that post in the official video, i was blown away like wow.
And then 20 is XX OMGGGGG OoO
YOU BLEW MY MIND OMFG
OH MY GOD! I NEVER NOTICED!!!
Arin's Fanboy Omg 😱
Arin's Fanboy i
"She's dead but I'm still so pumped" I died
9:15 Hongbin is a baritone. Poor little baritone in the ocean of tenors :D
Arthur Aren't Ravi, N and Hyuk baritones too tho ?
Ravi seems to have a baritone voice but he's a rapper, it isn't unusual that his voice is lower. N and Hyuk are tenors imo. I don't listen to them much to identify their passaggi but I think they are both tenors
MeiQuiche Lorraine Just Hongbin is a baritone. You can hear Ravi goes high when he sings not rapping.
Arthur Idk but they always sounded like baritones to me...
One Class I checked Ravi's singing moments video and you might be right. His singing voice isn't as deep as Hongbin's but it's really difficult to say cuz he isn't a vocalist
MeiQuiche Lorraine Listen to Hongbin's cover of 'Falling Slowly' and listen to any live solo performances of N and Hyuk. Hongbin's voice is deeper and lower. Even when he sings in a higher range or when he sings in falsetto you can say his voice differs from the other vocalists' voices in VIXX
"she's dead but I'm still so pumped"
Hugo: "Wtf you have on your head? why do you have a trash can on your head?!"
HUGO I FEEL YO BRO
"im done with things that aren't reaaalll!!!!! son of a bbbbbbttttccchhh" LOL
Jonah Elise "peyton, we don't even know if we're real" lmao
Jonah Elise I LAUGH SO HARD AT THAT PART XD
Ive been into kpop since 2012 and ive never noticed how common "the girls disappearing in mvs " till this reaction series 😂
I feel you girl 😂
"Love is like fart, if you need to force it it's probably shit"
#Preach 😂
omgomgomg 11:48 its soooo funnyyy
"That's so sad. Why you crying with your shirt unbuttoned?" LOL that got me laughing reason being cause he was crying with his shirt unbutton lol :'D (hope people get what i mean)
same XD
Error is one of my favorite VIXX songs
CreatureSoul446 same especially error
CreatureSoul446 Same, and even more one of my favorite kpop song 😍
same, but then who doesn't
same tbh especially when it's live
so do I
"woah what is that voice? I like it" That would be the evil maknae's beautiful voice #hyuk #maknaeontop
Am I the only one who thinks Hyuk sounds like SHINee's Onew?
sometimes I also feel that..
***** hahaha I knew it!
Just wanted to clear things up about the end of "Error" they actually don't kill each other, both of their bodies are made into "one". A.k.a the heart :)
Fluffy Fairy No problem! I'm glad I was of help to a fellow Starlight 😊
Oohhhhhhh thanks!
"I am done with things thAT ARENT REAL.. Son of a biiiiiiiiii"
I DONT THINK I'VE EVER RELATED TO A STATEMENT MORE LMFAO
"stop kissing and get out of there" i feel yah girl, i feel yah HAHAHAHAH
jaz mrt thats true!! and I'm Like ARRRGGGHHH GET OUT!!!
OMG FINALLY ERROR THE SONG THAT GOT ME INTO VIXX
same, because of Error I became a Starlight
unicorn's wife watch exo wolf same af
Error is one of the best songs EVER
unicorn's wife watch exo wolf same here. Now they are my favorite group.
same!
"I'm so into their bone structure" *ME*
"Why are you crying with your shirt unbuttonned" 😂😂
They're appreciating Hongbin's voice!!!!! And Ravi's hat in Error keeps attracting everyone's attention as usual Lolllll
"Love is like a fart if you have to force it it's probably shit" - Henry 2017, Pearls of Wisdom
I think we need this on a tshirt tbh
ReacttotheK start a store I'd buy this kind of quality merchandise 😁😂
ForTaxReasons me too lmao 😂 it made my day XD
henry ???
i understood after i finished watching the video 😂😂😂
Hugo's reaction/analysis of Leo & Ken's high notes in Eternity is amazing. Thank you for that :D
It's not the idea of you should commit suicide if you can't be in a relationship. He didn't want just any relationship. He wanted her and only her, so I feel like that comment was demeaning to the story. What I always got from Error was the desperation of losing a one true love to the point of committing the crime of creating a cyborg with human consciousness from a dead person. If you've seen Fullmetal Alchemist, it's the futuristic equivalent to human transmutation. It's the total despair of trying absolutely anything to bring that person back. The plot was Romeo and Juliet-esque, but never will it be this well executed. Error will always be my number one song and music video. It's what made me a Starlight, so I may feel a bit more strongly towards it. But I really do believe Error is one the best, if not the best, executed song/music video combo.
I really like your explanation and the comparison to fullmetal alchemist is amazing
YES
"its not a vixx video with out body horror" 💀💀💀💀 and pain and angst lmaoo
VIXX really changed me. I'm slower than a turtle before but now... Oh well, it's VIXX. 😂😂
EDIT: Omo! She noticed Hyuk's voice! My UB, my life, my baby, my everything! I'M CRYING 😭😭
LOL, you know, I had the same thing when I heard Eternity for the first time. That was for me the first time, that I really paid attention to the voice of Hyuk. His voice somehow just jumped out.
Also with 'Eternity' I was kinda taken by how the 2 vocalists were really paying attention to the vocal range of both Leo and Ken. Thanks for making this reaction, and thanks for the reactors to put time into this!
Eternity and Hyuk's voice was what stood out to me
nsomia cha The love for Hyuk's and Hongbin's voices are so good
ForTaxReasons yes indeed, Hongbin's deep voice came really through in Error. I still remember one reaction video saying something like: "Whoah, voice sounding five hundred octaves deeper"
TBH, I'm not surprised that sometimes they say he's the sub-rapper of the group. O well. .. just enjoying it.
nsomia cha HYUK IS MY UB TOO
did anyone else notice umu freak out a bit when jaron figured out part of the mv plot before it even really began to develop?
Hyuk - a shock to the senses, I mean... same lol! Error is also one of my absolute faves!
"what the fck do you have on your head?" lmao I've been waiting for any of them commenting this tbh xD
can't wait till they see chained up and shangri-la
Yunki Min oh my god yessss
Yunki Min Yesssss ❤❤❤❤
Yunki Min yes
Yesss, Them reacting to Fantasy would also be great
VIXX ARE BEST GROUP EVER
i repeated around 10 times the part where the girl said she likes sanghyuk's voice GIRL YOU ARE MY FAVOURITE HUMAN RIGHT NOW
who else was reacting like Umu when Jarrod literally described the entire story 😂😂😂
Francesca Milsom I was like this boy has been theorising too damn much
and Peyton just sat there like "why is he in my life"
Where my fellow Starlights at??
MissOblivion22 YOHOO☝❤
MissOblivion22 hey theeeeere
yooooooo
MissOblivion22 HEEEEEEYYYYYYY
i miss their spoopy themed songs
Eternity was the first song that made me search for other songs of VIXX & error made me starlight
YUNYI IS THE CUTEST AND I'M SO SAD THAT SHE'S GRADUATING SO WE WON'T SEE HER ANYMORE SOON
Hana 하나 is she? She is my fav :(
Oki Santi Yeah, she is ;___;
Hana 하나 :OOOOOO NOOOOO
She's graduating
Whatt???? Noooooo she is my fav😫
I swear, VIXX are the concept kings of kpop
Peyton's "Not real!? Son of a beee-aah!!", Davis's "She's dead, but I'm still so pumped." and Kevin's "It ain't VIXX without body horror." lololooool XD
"Yeah I.. I am so into their bone structure" THIS IS MY FAVORITE QUOTE
THAT INFINITE CAMEO THO YASSSSSSSS
Flower Myungsoo I KNOW RIGHT!!!!!!!!
Flower Myungsoo IT MADE MY DAY
Ikr. It made my day. :D
Flower Myungsoo INFINITE IS EVERYWHEREEEEE 💕
i dont see any of them? when is it
"maybe they went back in time before they exist"
hit him up with sungkyu - 60 seconds
oh yeeeesss
Nicholas Joestar YESSSS
YES OMFG WHAT A SONG
FT ISLAND'S SEVERELY
kev and yunyi humming the intro is on point 😂
YUNYI'S DANCING TO ERROR BACK AND FICTION IS GOLD
'love is like a fart, if you got to force it; it's probably shit'
LMAO
I'm always so worried that you won't do a lot of VIXX reactions because they aren't the most popular group, so these videos won't get as many views as compared to the other groups. But I'm very thankful that you decided to react to VIXX:) Thank you so much!
Dorothy: I'm pretty indifferent towards VIXX, but I'm glad that Umu stays true to her favorites groups. Also, for me, the reactors are the most valuable component of the videos so even if I can't totally appreciate the artists I can like the video and learn more about music and Kpop,
Dorothy yeah.. i agree.. pls make some another react from vixx.. fantasy and shangri la? Can?
Hugo's reactions to the high notes are the best
"Love is like a fart, if you have to force it it's probably shiiiiiiiiit" 😩😂😂💀 lmfao I freaking love him, he kills me in every video.
if they say error is epic I can't wait for them to see fantasy
I was in middle of watching Vixx play Overwatch and then clicked so fast because I needed this video in my life to relieve the tension but soon I'll go back to watching Hongbin wipe the the floor with poor I.M. Kihyun and Minhyuk
"The robo popo are here to take your love away"
This video has some truly quotable quotes honestly but this one is my favorite
A+ CHOICE IN YOUR FAVORITE KPOP SONG UMU ERROR IS SERIOUSLY AMAZEBALLS OMG
I love Error so much, and their acoustic performance was amazing
when Hugo went "why do you have a trash can on your head" I died this was just too funny
My brother cried his eyes out when I showed him Error, because he loves love so much. He's 20 btw.
I've been waiting for this because they really seem to get into the VIXX songs. VIXX really doesn't get enough credit for how unique and talented they are.
Yunyi's pun-game is strong in this one.
Am i the only one who always gets goosebumbs whenever i hear Hongbin's deep voice
And now I reeealy want them to react to Shangri-La) Just to see if it would sound unique for them or not ^^
TacseraEpSekahs yeah... i agre.. i hope they react the shangri la and fantasy
TacseraEpSekahs shangri la and fantasy r my fav title songs from vixx
yes.. i hope they do reaction for VIXX's new songs..
"Ah, there she goes"
'Why are you crying with your shirt unbottoned.' 😂
12:30 "Stop kissing and get out of there" Me watching any dystopian future film
I didn't see NELL on the list, so I'd like to request that you guys eventually listen to their son The Day Before. It's a slow ballad but I think it'll be interesting to see how everyone reacts to the music video in accompaniment!
ko haru oh yes! I second that! The mv makes me cry everytime. And it's such a great song.
omg error, back and fiction are like my favorite kpop songs. mind blown.
i started stanning VIXX after Error, was just a casual listener before. i had so much goosebumps from the music and video when i first watched this that i cried ;_;
and im having goosebumps while listening as it played here ㅠㅠ
Finally someone recognize Vixx-Eternity.
I'm loving the appreciation for Hyuk and Hongbin's voices (and the concepts because that's their whole thing).
loved this omg these 2 are my favorite vixx songs and i know umu loves vixx cant wait for them to react to shang rila and more vixx ALSO im a big fan of dean and I see that you guys are reacting to half moon and and july but haven't filmed yet. I suggest changing and july (because it's not his own song and he didnt really produce it and it isnt his sound) to come over(넘어와) a newer song from him with baek yerin. im obviously excited about it so i hope u read this. i also suggest put my hands on you ft anderson paak vs love ft syd from the internet
((((also i just realized dean produced eternity for vixx))))
Been waiting this for an eternity no joke
Jasmine Loh BA DUM TSS
YAAASH FINALLY MORE VIXX REACTION! and noticed Hyuk voice omg thank u so much😭❤
you guys should react to VIXX's Fantasy. For me, Fantasy's music is just crazy, good crazy. 😁
It's coming in August but first they are going to have Beautiful Liar and Chained Up this upcoming monday the 26th
whoa.. That's awesome! I'm looking forward to it.. Thank you..
the liked hongbin's and hyuk's voicees YOHOOO!I'm so proudddd of them,they improved so much!👌
I just can't WAIT for the next VIXX reaction !!!!
Same! I'm also hoping they'll react to Shangrila ^_^
FrozenRoxas Oh yea they will!! I can't wait for that reaction
The instrumental for the song is amAZING
Oh yess in the next like 2 months there will be so many good songs/videos that they'll react to, I'M SO EXCITED and Umu I want to thank you for all the editing and effort you put into these
PLEASE react to So hyang -Arirang !!! the live instruments her VOCALS OMG are to die for
x blossom sohyang singing arirang gives me chills, so damn good.
Up
Yaaaas finally. I've been waiting for the rest of my life 😂 these 2 song are my fav vixx's song ever. Thankyou, Umu. You made my day ❤
I loved the way gwen and Hugo described the previous MVs lol
2:16 I have always thought that! Srsly, since I listened to the song for the first time. Hyuk killed this part so much. It takes you off guard and it's very nice to hear him sing
I'm so excited, I've been waiting for this!!! >___
Will wait for LR - beautiful liar.
Where's Shimon? I miss him so much :'((
He was at a kendo tournament for 1 recording session which caused him to be absent for 4+ reaction videos
ReacttotheK I was waiting for this for a long time because Error is my ultimate favorite Kpop MV. A little disappointed with the reactions. I wonder how they would have reacted if they watched it alone and felt the emotional heaviness of it all through the song, the instrumentations, the VOICES (gods!), and the MV. They've probably become too "saturated" at this point. They need to react to other stuff, I think, like reality shows, just to get a fresh perspective on new music videos. Just a thought, Umu.
BLESS im so excited to watch this right now I LOVE THESE SONGS
I HAVE BEEN WAITING SO LONG FOR THIS YOU HAVE NO IDEA
I've been waiting forever!!!
CreatureSoul446 me too. I honestly checked and rechecked the date and time so many times its unreal. 😂😂 now to wait for chained up and beautiful liar 😁😁
Me to.. i'm always rechecking the dates for VIXX lol
Francesca Milsom Same...nkw we gotta wait again 😩😩
This Shangri-la comeback has me dead
I'm waiting for the Fanstasy reaction to come out this August. It's the most anticipated reaction for me.
Yay more VIXX reactions!
Two of my favourite songs from VIXX YASSSSS I've been waiting for this ❤❤❤❤❤
I love this so much thank you for this!! These are the 2 songs that I first fell for when I got into VIXX!! I love these songs so much Idk they are just so epic for me and Fantasy just followed this and Ughhh I just can't!! Anyways, thank you!!💕💕🤗🤗
PLEEEEEASE REACT TO NU'EST Good Bye Bye and FACE...PLEASE PLEASE. I'm from Brazil, and really like your videos
Yoontae Popper YES!!! I love Nu'est so much
Yoontae Popper YES Please!! Overcome or Love Paint too!
React to NU'EST Love Paint too!!!
Quero tmb
Love Paint is definetly on the list, and I saw something else too :D
Hello, i'm one of the subscriber in this program-in Korea. for me this program is so interestimg. Get to the point. Nothing but, I just recommend th music of k-music.
The name is 'AKMU-re bye' ,'IU - palette' , ' Aliee-첫눈처럼 너에게 가겠다(I will go to youlike the first snow)' . The song of Aliee's are so wonderful.
김호석: She has Ailee recorded and on the schedule several times, including on the Vocalists list way on the bottom. AKMU Re-bye is one of several Akmu songs also recorded/on the schedule. If you haven't seen it, here is the schedule found under the description/"Show More" docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/preview
So agreee with your selection.. Ailee!! first snow!!
I just want to know if they don't know the drama & lyrics can they feel the sadness also in thhis song.. because, I'm still weeping every time I hear the song!! f***k
i can't wait for the trilogy reaction T.T they gonna react to fantasy yassss
I'm incredibly proud of vixx so when I see these guys give fab critiques, not only of their voices but song set up too makes me beam! 😁
I anticipate their reaction to Fantasy so much
Ellara__ SAME
Early cause. VIXX is ❤️❤️
Omg thank you so much for comparing Error and Back at the end! That explains why these two songs give me such similar feelings.
I love it every time you do a VIXX reaction. The eyes get so big when Leo hits those high notes and holds them. It's wonderful.
" ooh that was sexual"
oh my fuckin God I could spit coffee in my art assignment. I like how casually she said it too😂
lesson learned : don't drink or eat while watching a reaction
Please react to
VIXX-Shangri-La
Taemin-Drip Drop
SHINee-View
f(x)-4walls
Full Reaction Schedule: docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
Samantha Mosely I can't seem to open the link
Ameera Irdena click the one in the bio
OMG I love these songs!! These are the songs that got me into VIXX.👏🏻😁
Im totally waiting for this reaction 😍😍
"Love is like a fart, if you have to force it it's probably shit" -Henry May 29, 2017
LMFAO
"WHY do you have a trash can on your head" AKA THE question every St☆rlight asked the first time they noticed Kim Won Shik in this mv.
Their vixx reactions are always my favorite 💫💫
the 5th is so close yet so far away. i can't wait to watch ur reactions to their teasers!